Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Kitakaze:

"Bill, why is that all you can say? We're all aware of claims of sightings all around the country. What do you think of them?"

I haven't investigated them sufficiently to make any conclusion yet.
Any sightings in general or just those outside the PNW?

Here is one that member SweatyYeti is a staunch supporter of:

http://bfro.net/GDB/show_report.asp?id=5245

Sweaty spoke with the lady who submitted the report, Joyce. The alledged sighting supposedly happened in Valatie, Columbia NY.

Any thoughts?
 
Kitakaze:

"Here is one that member SweatyYeti is a staunch supporter of:

http://bfro.net/GDB/show_report.asp?id=5245

Sweaty spoke with the lady who submitted the report, Joyce. The alledged sighting supposedly happened in Valatie, Columbia NY.

Any thoughts?"


I did read the report, but since I don't know the woman, don't know her daughter, don't know that part of New York, and don't know the investigator who took the report, I really can't offer any opinion about it.

Bill
 
Last edited:
I did read the report, but since I don't know the woman, don't know her daughter, don't know that part of New York, and don't know the investigator who took the report, I really can't offer any opinion about it.

Bill
Fair enough. Any thoughts on the obvious similarities we can see between Patty and Heironimus' gait and movement in the youtube video I posted?
 
Kitakaze;

"Fair enough. Any thoughts on the obvious similarities we can see between Patty and Heironimus' gait and movement in the youtube video I posted?"

I haven't studied the gait itself because from my point of research, it's a non-issue (real creature could do it, human could do it, so nothing to prove)

but for Bob, a skeptic (of Bob's claim) would say he simply watched the film and practiced to copy it, while a believer of Bob would say he was just demonstrating what he actually did decades before.

Seems a no-win argument no matter how you slice it.

Bill
 
It would take me a long time to read all the posts in this thread so sorry if I'm being ignorant, I just want to say this:
They analyzed the film and found traces of moving lips and eyelids. And an athlete tried to imitate the gait of the bigfoot and failed.
(I found that out on MonsterQuest)
 
Last edited:
I haven't studied the gait itself because from my point of research, it's a non-issue (real creature could do it, human could do it, so nothing to prove)

but for Bob, a skeptic (of Bob's claim) would say he simply watched the film and practiced to copy it, while a believer of Bob would say he was just demonstrating what he actually did decades before.

Seems a no-win argument no matter how you slice it.

Bill
I find it surprising that you've not studied the gait. The similarities of their figures and movements is readily apparent but of course that's just my opinion. You're right that he could haver learned the walk. In this case I think it's helpful to look at the extenuating circumstances. BH lives in the same small community as Gimlin. The members of the community that you see appear with BH all mention that it has long been common knowledge of the truth of the PGF. National Geographic state that in BG would not speak to them. A guy with a walk, height, and figure being a dead ringer for Patty who lives in the same community with one of the two men involved in the filming who declines to speak...

I also thought it was interesting how Bob states matter-of-factly that had he been paid his $1000, he would have kept his mouth shut.

If I made an investigation and at every point I found no case where a suit is more likely than a living bigfoot, I'd be much more mindful of such things.
 
Last edited:
Kitakaze:

"I find it surprising that you've not studied the gait. "

No reason to study it. It proves nothing. Humans have a remarkable capacity for motions (gymnasts and dancers in particular) so a person can learn to walk a certain way. So the human capacity to do "the walk" doesn't prove a human "did the walk". It merely proves a human can replicate it.

Dead end issue.

The other stuff you mentioned are seperate issues, and all circumstantial. But again, I don't get into all that because it has no baring on my focused research of the image in the film.

Bill
 
It would take me a long time to read all the posts in this thread so sorry if I'm being ignorant, I just want to say this:
They analyzed the film and found traces of moving lips and eyelids. And an athlete tried to imitate the gait of the bigfoot and failed.
(I found that out on MonsterQuest)

1) You can not resolve details that small. Any effects seen have more to do with film grain and wishful thinking than actually seeing lips move and eyelids.

2) The gait has been duplicated. Read "Bigfoot exposed" by Dr. David Daegling. You also can see that on the NGEO special "is it real?".
 
It would take me a long time to read all the posts in this thread so sorry if I'm being ignorant, I just want to say this:
They analyzed the film and found traces of moving lips and eyelids. And an athlete tried to imitate the gait of the bigfoot and failed.
(I found that out on MonsterQuest)
CryptidFan, welcome to the JREF. Here in the BF threads we have a running joke about this place being Thunderdome in reference to the standards of presenting factual information. What athlete are you referring to? If you tell me which Monster Quest bigfoot show it was, I'll be able to find it very quickly myself. For the show 'Best Evidence' in front of Dr. Jeff Meldrum actor Bronston Delone duplicated the gait to which Meldrum admitted surprise at the level of similarity.

Here is a link:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3360560#post3360560

As for blinking and moving lips, you're being told this by crackpot MK Davis who also claims to see genitalia, clinging turds, shot gun blast scars, braided hair with bone ornament, and a great many other ludicrous things.
 
Bigfoot is the "real creature". The reason I think Bigfoot is real is because on MonsterQuest they analyzed a DNA sample and concluded that it came from an unknown animal more closely related to humans than chimpanzees. And they found out a carcass could decompose within a week.
 
Last edited:
I just refreshed my memory on the athlete from Monster Quest. It is at the end of part 1 and continuing into part 2 of the youtube recording of the original Monster Quest episode on Bigfoot. Dr. Jurgen Konczak professor and associate director of the Human Sensorimotor Control Laboratory at the University of Minnesota and paleoanthropologist Esteban Sarmiento from the American Museum of Natural History in New York conduct a experiment where they use an athlete to try see if he could get into the same seemingly awkward positions of the PGF subject.

That particular athlete could not match the eversion of the knees of Patty. Monster Quest, a show produced by bigfoot enthusiasts, represented the results as being outside human range. All it takes is a little critical thinking to realize it was outside that particular athlete's range. Did they only try one person? We already know Monster Quest is pretty slick with the facts.
 
Last edited:
Diogenes:

" (Quoting me) I haven't studied the gait itself because from my point of research, it's a non-issue (real creature could do it, human could do it, so nothing to prove)"

.....
(your quote)
Bill
What ' real creature ' are you referring to ?"


One option of Patty, of course.

In other words, the figure in the film has absolutely the capability of doing the walk, because the film show it doing so. So if the figure in the film is real, something real can do it.

Just curious, are you arguing that it's impossible for anything other than a homo sapian to do the walk?

Bill
 
I don't think there's anything wrong with monster quest. It's in the view of the cryptozoologists. And to prove that they aren't just idiots who WANT to believe that all cryptids are real, they debunked the skunk ape and were able to accept that the skunk apes aren't real.
 
Bigfoot is the "real creature". The reason I think Bigfoot is real is because on MonsterQuest they analyzed a DNA sample and concluded that it came from an unknown animal more closely related to humans than chimpanzees. And they found out a carcass could decompose within a week.

Cryptid please check out the "Meldrum finds DNA" thread. You may want to take a critical look at how the DNA sample was supposedly collected.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=98301&highlight=twister-like
 
Well, in any case, whether the DNA is real or not, many forensic experts are convinced Bigfoot is real. I've heard that even Jane Goodall thinks Bigfoot is real.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom