Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
I really want to know about a reputation broken on the PGF.

It's history now. You just didn't check the date.

I'm quite sure that when you fire up the old P4 you'll be logging into a bigfoot forum.

Reputations broken because of the PGF? Every public proponent of the film whose views are brought to task on this forum. Let's say as a specific Jeff Meldrum. Do you consider him a level headed reputable scientist? Does the membership of this forum consider him in any kind of positive high regard? Bob Gimlin do you or the members of this forum consider him a man that can be counted on to tell the truth concerning the PGF? That is unless you consider a liar to be of good reputation. Maybe you do.

Yes Sweetie the Studiodrome film is history. But you know as well as I do that I meant it in the sense that its staying power will be short lived.

And as for where anyone will be upon logging into cyber space just as sure as following a slimy trail along a sidewalk will lead to finding a slug I know I'll find you here.
 
Last edited:
Gravy any word on Bigfoot? There are umteem million words on Bigfoot all over this forum. Positive words, negative words, misspelled words, fancy words, plain words, smart words, dumb words, big words, little words, words beyond words. Damn I think I made the 14,000 post too. Shucks I hate this place as much as I do even numbers!
 
Reputations broken because of the PGF? Every public proponent of the film whose views are brought to task on this forum. Let's say as a specific Jeff Meldrum. Do you consider him a level headed reputable scientist? Does the membership of this forum consider him in any kind of positive high regard? Bob Gimlin do you or the members of this forum consider him a man that can be counted on to tell the truth concerning the PGF? That is unless you consider a liar to be of good reputation. Maybe you do.
..snip...
Crow, it was not, I guess, directed to me, however I would like to say something about this. I'm pretty sure chances are that you as well as other people will not like what I wrote below. Yes, there's a risk that this may be confused with "poisoning the well". And maybe it is, indeed.

Untill some months ago, I thought Meldrum probably just had a weak spot for bigfoot. He, I thought, probably was a "reputable scientist" (to use your own words) but his attachment to bigfoot somehow made him loose his objectivity and impartiality.

But after being aware of at least one text where he tries to defend the veracity of the Book of Mormon (http://www.fairlds.org/FAIR_Conferences/2003_Children_of_Lehi_DNA_and_the_Book_of_Mormon.html), I was left with little option than to conclude that he allows his beliefs to introduce heavy bias in his works. When his beliefs are at stake, he does not seems to be, I think, level-headed.

Sorry folks, but it all smells too much like creationism to me... Remember, for Mormons (at least the official doctrine), the Book of Mormon and the Bible are true, literally true. Adam, Eve, Flood, 6Ky-old Earth, etc. I can no longer think of him as objective and impartial, at least for now.

As for Gimlim, I consider him a hoaxer - just like Hieronimus, Patterson, Marx, etc. If they can be trusted in other aspects, I don't know. I can think of a couple reasons for Gimlim never tell the truth about PGF. Am I correct? I think so, but I actually can't prove.

All I know is that human beings are complex and quite often sweeping generalizations don't work.
 
Crow, it was not, I guess, directed to me, however I would like to say something about this. I'm pretty sure chances are that you as well as other people will not like what I wrote below. Yes, there's a risk that this may be confused with "poisoning the well". And maybe it is, indeed.

Untill some months ago, I thought Meldrum probably just had a weak spot for bigfoot. He, I thought, probably was a "reputable scientist" (to use your own words) but his attachment to bigfoot somehow made him loose his objectivity and impartiality.

But after being aware of at least one text where he tries to defend the veracity of the Book of Mormon (http://www.fairlds.org/FAIR_Conferences/2003_Children_of_Lehi_DNA_and_the_Book_of_Mormon.html), I was left with little option than to conclude that he allows his beliefs to introduce heavy bias in his works. When his beliefs are at stake, he does not seems to be, I think, level-headed.

Sorry folks, but it all smells too much like creationism to me... Remember, for Mormons (at least the official doctrine), the Book of Mormon and the Bible are true, literally true. Adam, Eve, Flood, 6Ky-old Earth, etc. I can no longer think of him as objective and impartial, at least for now.

As for Gimlim, I consider him a hoaxer - just like Hieronimus, Patterson, Marx, etc. If they can be trusted in other aspects, I don't know. I can think of a couple reasons for Gimlim never tell the truth about PGF. Am I correct? I think so, but I actually can't prove.

All I know is that human beings are complex and quite often sweeping generalizations don't work.

I have absoloutely no problem with anything you've written. But reputations are a curious thing. For instance when I first encountered the MK Davis stabilization I thought it was a rather interesting piece of work done by someone with a great deal of skill within thier craft. However his observations and later conclusions have lead me to believe that in spite of his prowless with photography he somehow managed to be sucked into the object of his handiwork to begin postulating what many including myself consider off the wall ideas about what's on that film strip.

It is generally assumed that Roger Patterson was a con man, is it not? Its been said hundreds of times on this thread. Is there any other general opinion of his reputation that I'm not aware of here? It is generally assumed that Bob Titmus was a lously researcher? It is generally assumed that proponents of the PGF and Sasquatach are misguided fools and dimwits. Is there any other way anyone here chooses to describe or treat them?
 
It is generally assumed that proponents of the PGF and Sasquatach are misguided fools and dimwits. Is there any other way anyone here chooses to describe or treat them?
Forgivable dreamers. Passionate without all the facts. Subscriptionary to a romantic concept of which there are many worse. As in the end with all woo, lost to all the real mysteries in search of a mysterious world to call home.

Cuttlefish and Conformal anomalies be damned, the Boss of the Woods calls to me.
 
Last edited:
I have absoloutely no problem with anything you've written.
OK, now I'm surprised.

But reputations are a curious thing. For instance when I first encountered the MK Davis stabilization I thought it was a rather interesting piece of work done by someone with a great deal of skill within thier craft. However his observations and later conclusions have lead me to believe that in spite of his prowless with photography he somehow managed to be sucked into the object of his handiwork to begin postulating what many including myself consider off the wall ideas about what's on that film strip.
Well, an individual can be extremely gifted on one aspect and make some pretty bad moves on others. Especially when bias seep in. The way I see it, many proponents start with an assumption such as "bigfoot exists". From this point, evidence is somehow forced to fit within the assumption. Again, we fall in my common question regarding methodology....

It is generally assumed that Roger Patterson was a con man, is it not? Its been said hundreds of times on this thread. Is there any other general opinion of his reputation that I'm not aware of here?
Don't know. Since we are just discussing woith his bigfoot-related activities, I'm not sure if other aspects were touched and people generated an opinion.

It is generally assumed that Bob Titmus was a lously researcher?
Well, given the fact that we know about at least one blunder (horsedung being confused with bigfootdung) and one or two... Pitoresque tales, I really don't put too much weight on his claims regarding tracking Patty (there are other reasons which are not related to his skills). Same is valid for his claimed sighting.

It is generally assumed that proponents of the PGF and Sasquatach are misguided fools and dimwits. Is there any other way anyone here chooses to describe or treat them?
I would try to avoid sweeping generalizations.
Again, people are complex, individually and in group. I would reserve terms such as "fools" and "dimwits" for a number of individuals with whom I interacted due to their online behavior. Personally, who knows, they migth even be nice prople to have a beer or two. I think most footers probably are cool. They just have a certain weak spot. Just like I probably also have. Humans.
 
Drew:

"Bill-

Do you think that Bigfoot is a creature exclusive to the PNW (CA, OR, WA, ID, BC), or do you think it could exist in other areas of the country, i.e. Florida, Michigan, Connecticut, Upstate NY?"


All I can say is I have heard or read of sightings all around the country.

"Have you ever heard of Piltdown Man?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piltdown_Man"


Yes. I studied the case quite extensively. A very fine reference book on the subject is Roger Levin's fine book, "Bones of Contention" about controversies of paleoanthropology, and it has a fine discussion about Piltdown Man.

Bill
 
Kitakaze:

"Bill, why is that all you can say? We're all aware of claims of sightings all around the country. What do you think of them?"

I haven't investigated them sufficiently to make any conclusion yet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom