Bill Munns
Banned
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2008
- Messages
- 449
JohnWS:
"Originally Posted by Bill Munns
The absense of any paddding on the body, the absense of gloves gives the true hands more dexterity, the long wig which makes a logical disconnect between hair on head and hair on the neck/torso (which is impossible for the wearer to groom when the hair is intended to look continuous head to neck to torso).
All would be factors. Plus being both previously highly experienced as a mime with various suits, and being specifically trained by the people fabricating the suit/prosthetics. "
(John's Reply):
Granted, as I said - it's doesn't appear as bulky as the Patterson subject.
However as a person who feels that the necessity of an elaborate 'support crew' with relation to a brief hoax is perhaps a little OTT, sooner than appear to yell:
'I don't agree with your professional opinion, even though I'm not a professional myself'
- with nothing to back it up (an all too familiar scenario I've seem died-in-the-wool proponents/believers engage in ), I thought I would supply a factual case where the support crew was not part of the production, to at least show it has happened that way, even on professional production.
Certainly the two 'suits' don't match but without trying to be pedantic I believe (no need to list them at this point) there were many more factors to the support crew argument than the padding and grooming issue.
At the end of the day The Missing Link is an example of a professional creature suit filmed under less than ideal conditions sans support crew."
John, it is a fascinating example of what can be done by a performer without an elaborate support crew, and I thank you for bringing it to our attention.
It is also substantially different from a full suit. You may choose to see the similarities as more important, or see the differences as more important. This is a judgment each person makes to form their opinion. I respect your right to form your own opinion, as I have a right to form mine.
And my quote above you cited, it has no conclusion, just a list of factors to be considered or weighed by each person in making their own conclusion.
And your remark above "I believe (no need to list them at this point) there were many more factors "
I agree with you. There are more issues than my list, which was a basic outline of some factors than simply came to mind initially. There definitely are more factors, agreed.
Bill
"Originally Posted by Bill Munns
The absense of any paddding on the body, the absense of gloves gives the true hands more dexterity, the long wig which makes a logical disconnect between hair on head and hair on the neck/torso (which is impossible for the wearer to groom when the hair is intended to look continuous head to neck to torso).
All would be factors. Plus being both previously highly experienced as a mime with various suits, and being specifically trained by the people fabricating the suit/prosthetics. "
(John's Reply):
Granted, as I said - it's doesn't appear as bulky as the Patterson subject.
However as a person who feels that the necessity of an elaborate 'support crew' with relation to a brief hoax is perhaps a little OTT, sooner than appear to yell:
'I don't agree with your professional opinion, even though I'm not a professional myself'
- with nothing to back it up (an all too familiar scenario I've seem died-in-the-wool proponents/believers engage in ), I thought I would supply a factual case where the support crew was not part of the production, to at least show it has happened that way, even on professional production.
Certainly the two 'suits' don't match but without trying to be pedantic I believe (no need to list them at this point) there were many more factors to the support crew argument than the padding and grooming issue.
At the end of the day The Missing Link is an example of a professional creature suit filmed under less than ideal conditions sans support crew."
John, it is a fascinating example of what can be done by a performer without an elaborate support crew, and I thank you for bringing it to our attention.
It is also substantially different from a full suit. You may choose to see the similarities as more important, or see the differences as more important. This is a judgment each person makes to form their opinion. I respect your right to form your own opinion, as I have a right to form mine.
And my quote above you cited, it has no conclusion, just a list of factors to be considered or weighed by each person in making their own conclusion.
And your remark above "I believe (no need to list them at this point) there were many more factors "
I agree with you. There are more issues than my list, which was a basic outline of some factors than simply came to mind initially. There definitely are more factors, agreed.
Bill