Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
JohnWS:

"Originally Posted by Bill Munns
The absense of any paddding on the body, the absense of gloves gives the true hands more dexterity, the long wig which makes a logical disconnect between hair on head and hair on the neck/torso (which is impossible for the wearer to groom when the hair is intended to look continuous head to neck to torso).

All would be factors. Plus being both previously highly experienced as a mime with various suits, and being specifically trained by the people fabricating the suit/prosthetics. "


(John's Reply):
Granted, as I said - it's doesn't appear as bulky as the Patterson subject.

However as a person who feels that the necessity of an elaborate 'support crew' with relation to a brief hoax is perhaps a little OTT, sooner than appear to yell:

'I don't agree with your professional opinion, even though I'm not a professional myself'


- with nothing to back it up (an all too familiar scenario I've seem died-in-the-wool proponents/believers engage in ), I thought I would supply a factual case where the support crew was not part of the production, to at least show it has happened that way, even on professional production.

Certainly the two 'suits' don't match but without trying to be pedantic I believe (no need to list them at this point) there were many more factors to the support crew argument than the padding and grooming issue.

At the end of the day The Missing Link is an example of a professional creature suit filmed under less than ideal conditions sans support crew."



John, it is a fascinating example of what can be done by a performer without an elaborate support crew, and I thank you for bringing it to our attention.

It is also substantially different from a full suit. You may choose to see the similarities as more important, or see the differences as more important. This is a judgment each person makes to form their opinion. I respect your right to form your own opinion, as I have a right to form mine.

And my quote above you cited, it has no conclusion, just a list of factors to be considered or weighed by each person in making their own conclusion.

And your remark above "I believe (no need to list them at this point) there were many more factors "

I agree with you. There are more issues than my list, which was a basic outline of some factors than simply came to mind initially. There definitely are more factors, agreed.

Bill
 
Derail, maybe, but here it is. If I follow correct, Drew, you're of the mind that the way bigfoot came about was that yeti was well into mainstream culture and a captivating subject but having it here was more convenient so we invented it. It reminds me of how Dahinden explains that his bigfoot genesis came when after immigrating to Canada he expressed an interest in yeti to someone who then told him that we have such a beast in North America.

How the whole thing came about in North America is of particular interest to me. I think the CBC archives that WP shared with us offer important clues to the evolution of the modern myth. I think when we try to get to the root it gets very muddled. European colonialism seems to have produced a wealth of wild man traditions. We see it in NA, Australia, South Africa, and many other places besides. We know the wild man figure has long been of importance in western culture.

Forget for a moment the more recent media phenomenom that is 'Bigfoot'. The question of what the earliest picture of tracks in situ in North America is an important one. It goes without saying that if a real creature is at the source, it shouldn't take until the Fifties for people to find and photograph huge hominid footprints in the forests of NA. Forget photos of tracks, what kind of smack do footers want to pass of on rational thinking people when they tell us our continent is populated left to right, top to bottom with these beasts despite any meaningful evidence? It makes one want to adopt Penn and Teller's colourful language.

Where does that leave us? I guess then that the proponent will wish to direct our attention to newspaper items such as Tirademan at BFF compiles. This is hardly helpful I think for reasons we've touched on already. There's simply no reliability or consistency. America made bigfoot what it is but I think we see the germ in Canada with sasquatch. That leads into the discussion of why we made something of it there. That of course brings us to the indigenous traditions and I won't derail that much here when we have a thread for it. I've been somewhat absent from the board lately but I found some pretty funky stuff on the subject that I will soon post in the Native American thread.

Anyway, as WP asked, where is the first bigfoot track photo?
 
Last edited:
John, it is a fascinating example of what can be done by a performer without an elaborate support crew, and I thank you for bringing it to our attention.

It is also substantially different from a full suit.
I for just one, would love to hear your thoughts on the hard boiled bigfoot action video I posted, Bill.
 
Kitakaze"

"I for just one, would love to hear your thoughts on the hard boiled bigfoot action video I posted, Bill."

Your link took me to the Cryptomundo website, so I don't know what video you are referencing.

Bill
 
LOL, Bill you will see a YouTube template within that Cryptomundo blog topic link. Click on the arrow found there.
 
Kitakaze"

"I for just one, would love to hear your thoughts on the hard boiled bigfoot action video I posted, Bill."

Your link took me to the Cryptomundo website, so I don't know what video you are referencing.

Bill
I'm stunned, I guess. I don't know how you would follow the link and yet miss the two videos it features.

Kitakaze and WP:

Saw it.

Now what?

Bill
The "now what?" would be your thoughts on the Shoalin-like manuevers of the man in the suit with the gear inside. Studiodrome made some effort. What do you think of that effort and how it relates to comments regarding the PGF?
 
WP:

"Start 13 new threads on BFF to analyze this mystery."

I"m doing as much as I can now. Maybe you could?

Bill
 
WP:

"Start 13 new threads on BFF to analyze this mystery."

I"m doing as much as I can now. Maybe you could?

Bill
Bill, the heart of it is that we are left to wonder your rationality in ignoring information which is invaluable to determining the truth of the PGF. The video I posted features elements which are pertinent to statements you give in support of the PGF's veracity as that of a living sasquatch.
 
Studiodrome made some effort.

Studiodrome makes films (video) just like Patterson was doing before he filmed Patty. These are guys walking around with cameras just like Patterson. Roger got lucky and filmed a Bigfoot just like Studiodrome did.

Are these both hoaxes? Well, neither has confessed to hoaxing so we need to look at credibility. Roger was a con man before and after filming Patty. The dude got busted for not repaying a loan (Radford) and not returning the camera with rental payment. There were plenty of other scams going on. What about Studiodrome? Have they ever defrauded anyone?

Patterson's credibility was bankrupt from the start. He may have tried to pull off a hoax with Patty. On the other hand, Studiodrome may be a horse of a different color. What color? A real Bigfoot.
 
Kitakaze:

"The "now what?" would be your thoughts on the Shoalin-like manuevers of the man in the suit with the gear inside. Studiodrome made some effort. What do you think of that effort and how it relates to comments regarding the PGF? "

The hair appears to be longish, which simplifies a construction, and makes a suit easier for an amateur to make. The figure is certainly lively in his gestures.

The staging with the subject partially obscured by folliage is what I'd expect from a staged video, and the ape-like gestures are what I'd expect from a performance trying to be like an ape-like creature.

"Bill, the heart of it is that we are left to wonder your rationality in ignoring information which is invaluable to determining the truth of the PGF. The video I posted features elements which are pertinent to statements you give in support of the PGF's veracity as that of a living sasquatch."

So I haven't ignored your information. I've considered it and see far more differences than similarities of it as compared to the PG Film. If you want to list what elements you feel are pertanent to my statements, I'll be willing to address those elements.

Bill
 
The hair appears to be longish, which simplifies a construction, and makes a suit easier for an amateur to make. The figure is certainly lively in his gestures.

The staging with the subject partially obscured by folliage is what I'd expect from a staged video, and the ape-like gestures are what I'd expect from a performance trying to be like an ape-like creature.

Bill, you know, I'm not sure if I'd choose the word 'gestures' for the the physicality we see in that video. An MC accentuating their lyrical prose with hand and arm movements I might call 'gestures' but what is in that bigfoot video I might more appropriately call 'takin' it down to Chinatown'. Maybe 'kickin' *** and takin' names'. Generally, doing a very fine job of being 'The Boss of the Woods'. I know that person was in a suit. I know that suit had some internal gear in it as we see in the arms. I don't see any Hong Kong wire support crews.

Do you see where I'm going?

So I haven't ignored your information. I've considered it and see far more differences than similarities of it as compared to the PG Film. If you want to list what elements you feel are pertanent to my statements, I'll be willing to address those elements.

Bill
If I had to wear arm extensions and do $6,000,000 man in that video like we see, would longish hair be a significant factor?
 
Kitakaze:

"Bill, you know, I'm not sure if I'd choose the word 'gestures' for the the physicality we see in that video. An MC accentuating their lyrical prose with hand and arm movements I might call 'gestures' but what is in that bigfoot video I might more appropriately call 'takin' it down to Chinatown'. Maybe 'kickin' *** and takin' names'. Generally, doing a very fine job of being 'The Boss of the Woods'. I know that person was in a suit. I know that suit had some internal gear in it as we see in the arms. I don't see any Hong Kong wire support crews.

Do you see where I'm going?"


I can't determine if there's any "gear" in the suit by watching the video (excluding apparent arm extensions, as I acknowledged). If you can, fine.

"Gestures" is any physical activity, subtle or extravagent. The ones in the video are more extravagent or exhaggerated. I don't see any Hong Kong wirework either, and don't know why that's an issue. There certainly isn't any in the PG Film, so why bring it up?

I don't have a clue where you are going with this.


"If I had to wear arm extensions and do $6,000,000 man in that video like we see, would longish hair be a significant factor?"

Longish hair to simplify a suit construction is just a consideration somebody takes to build a suit. It's generally "the easy way", and often taken by both amateurs and professionals to simplify their job.

Now consider this in comparing the two film samples (the link you referenced and the PG Film):

In many professions, as well as in many sports, there is a concept of "degree of difficulty" whereby the level of skill needed to accomplish an action is appraised. Sports like gymnastics, diving, and figure skating, for example, have these "degree of difficulty" appraisals done for specific competitive moves or routines by a committee of experts and certified by some sanctioning body or organization. In makeup effects, we don't have any such sanctioning body, so every person in the field must make their own personal acessment of what is easy and what is harder for others to do.

So I look at the films and first try to determine how much data can be extracted from viewing or study, and then from that data, I try to assign some estimated "degree of difficulty" to accomplish what I see. Others can offer differing appraisals.

Comparing the two film sequences, I would say the data itself is poor in the newer video, and there is more data in the PG film. Then I would say the degree of difficulty for staging what I see in the recent video is low or easy, while the degree of difficulty for staging what I see in the PG Film is much higher or harder.

I have explained my analysis of what I feel is simple or hard, easy for amateurs as compared to what is hard even for professionals. And I have done so in considerable detail already, to the point that some here like to make fun of how much material is in those notes. Some people will understand the notes. Others won't. Life is like that.

Bill
 
Studiodrome production is almost as silly as the one with the little Bigfoot (no pun intended). The subject lacks the sense of mass associated with a large heavy animal. It's lithe crisp momements indicate lots of percieve size and bulk composed mostly of the air within the foam padding. Not to mention its the same subject in both films. Will ya look at that the worlds first Bigfoot camera ham.

On the other hand I give them credit for maintaining the tradition of having a fallen tree between the camera person and the subject as well as being old school with the use of 16 & 35mm film. See it can't be fake film is too expensive to play with! LOL! Stick a fork in this one its done!
 
Last edited:
Stick a fork in this one its done!

Bullcrap!

The subject lacks the sense of mass associated with a large heavy animal.

Many "credible" Bigfoot encounters describe a creature just like this one. Somewhat slender with long hair.

Do you not agree that descriptive sighting reports are the ultimate foundation for the entirety of Bigfoot belief? Your own belief that Bigfoot once existed must be based solely on historical reported sightings. Do I have that right?

This one might be more "authentic" than Patty. Why? Because this one is actively defending its territory instead of casually strolling away. Which one is the silly hoax? You can only pick one, not both. If you must insist that both are hoaxes... then which one is more "hoaxy"?
 
Bullcrap!



Many "credible" Bigfoot encounters describe a creature just like this one. Somewhat slender with long hair.

Do you not agree that descriptive sighting reports are the ultimate foundation for the entirety of Bigfoot belief? Your own belief that Bigfoot once existed must be based solely on historical reported sightings. Do I have that right?

This one might be more "authentic" than Patty. Why? Because this one is actively defending its territory instead of casually strolling away. Which one is the silly hoax? You can only pick one, not both. If you must insist that both are hoaxes... then which one is more "hoaxy"?

Wow you mean I have to actually decide which is more of a silly hoax? I'm glad I wasn't woken up out of a sound sleep to answer this. Otherwise I'd be kinda PO'd. There is no contest, the Studiodrome production is the silly hoax. There is nothing about the Patterson /Gimlin hoax that can be considered silly. After all carreers have been based on it, reputations made and broken because of it. Millions of words written, thousands of articles, miles of taped analysis. Nothing silly about it at all. In another couple of weeks the Studiodrome tripe will be history. I may head out for a bit of wilderness time this summer and not bring an internet technology with me. However I am 100% certain that when I return and fire up the old P4 that this thread and the PGF will be motoring along in fine fashion. That's true greatness!
 
Last edited:
Studiodrome production is almost as silly as the one with the little Bigfoot (no pun intended). The subject lacks the sense of mass associated with a large heavy animal. It's lithe crisp momements indicate lots of percieve size and bulk composed mostly of the air within the foam padding. Not to mention its the same subject in both films. Will ya look at that the worlds first Bigfoot camera ham.

On the other hand I give them credit for maintaining the tradition of having a fallen tree between the camera person and the subject as well as being old school with the use of 16 & 35mm film. See it can't be fake film is too expensive to play with! LOL! Stick a fork in this one its done!
That is some fantastic stuff! I'm just going to have to go into my BFRO archives and chuck out all the truthy skinny lithe shaggy bigfoot reports. MOFO's!
 
There is no contest, the Studiodrome production is the silly hoax.
You wouldn't even know what to call it if I didn't tell you.

There is nothing about the Patterson /Gimlin hoax that can be considered silly.
Over the bellybutton, under the chin - a world of silliness.

After all carreers have been based on it, reputations made and broken because of it.
I really want to know about a reputation broken on the PGF.

In another couple of weeks the Studiodrome tripe will be history.
It's history now. You just didn't check the date.

However I am 100% certain that when I return and fire up the old P4 that this thread and the PGF will be motoring along in fine fashion. That's true greatness!
I'm quite sure that when you fire up the old P4 you'll be logging into a bigfoot forum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom