Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
A reminder of words of wisdon from Dfoot (on the BFF):

CJW Thread on Page 9 or later

Dfoot (Dec. 4, 2004 - CJW Thread #49)

"Chris,

I've directed people in creature suits for a couple of decades now. I saw exactly the same thing you mentioned. Between what appeared to be seams and the way certain areas bunched up I thought I had found something....

Then I began to compare all of the suits available in '67 that I could find and real animals. I was surprised at what I saw.

Real mountain gorillas also show this same type of "seam" that is seen in the Patterson film. I could not find the same thing on any of the creature suits. Even on recent suits by Rick Baker there seems to be nothing like this. Only real life gorillas seem to have it and that surprised me quite a bit.

Someone certainly could create that look if they wanted. I've just never seen it done on purpose. Probably because someone would see it and think they were seeing a seam or a zipper.

If you watch enough clear film footage of gorillas in motion you'll see this effect sooner or later.

I don't know for sure if this is a suit or not. But the more I look at it and compare it to nature the more I am impressed. There are so many things that Roger Patterson would have to have done to make all of this happen. I don't see him as being able to do it.

- Dfoot


And in Post #162

If you ever watch a DVD of that little chimp walking that I posted earlier, compare the apparent "stitches" and muscle movement in the back to that seen on the LMS dvd. Though this is just a little chimpanzee the attachments are the same.

Today we have the ability to create suits of muscle like those seen below. In 1967 no one had these materials. And that is why so many creature suits from those sci-fi films look as stiff as they did.



The bottom line is that no one around Patterson could have made alterations to any of the ape suits of the 60's that matched what was filmed. The techniques and materials needed had yet to be invented.

Posting a still photo doesn't do it either. A frozen image is not the PG film. The "suit" from '67 will need to match the movements seen so clearly on the dvd.

- Dfoot


And in Post #184

In 1967 they did some great suit fx for the time. Yet we never got the kind of movement in the upper pec, buttocks, etc that we see in the PG film. All the "Bigfoot" creatures that followed the film never looked like Patty either.

It would be a lot less effort today. But we are supposed to think that Roger Patterson from Yakima who couldn't pay his phone bill pays to have the best suit made to his exact specifications from an old pre-1961 gorilla suit?

Did someone at Paramount top everything that they ever did on shows like STAR TREK just to play a prank for a cowboy and never showed the same skill on one of their televison episodes?

That just does not seem very likely at all.

There may be an answer other than the one Patterson-Gimlin gives - but that's really not it.

- Dfoot





D, you made all the above comments when you were an industry expert, didn't you?

:)

Bill
 
A reminder of words of wisdon from Dfoot (on the BFF):

...


D, you made all the above comments when you were an industry expert, didn't you?

:)

Bill
Munns, that's pretty low. LAL tried the same thing, pulling out old posts of Dfoot's when he was leaning towards the creature being real. You do allow for the fact that...

a) ...he made those posts before much of his experimentation that changed his opinion?

b) ...his opinion changed from believing the creature real to being a hoax as the result of his experimentations without any influence from BF skeptics?
 
Kitakaze:

"Munns, that's pretty low. LAL tried the same thing, pulling out old posts of Dfoot's when he was leaning towards the creature being real. You do allow for the fact that...

a) ...he made those posts before much of his experimentation that changed his opinion?

b) ...his opinion changed from believing the creature real to being a hoax as the result of his experimentations without any influence from BF skeptics?"


Why is it low to hold a person to their word? Isn't that what intregity is all about?

I'll grant you people can grow and their opinion may change because of that growth, but a 180 turn is pretty rare, and that's what he's done. Were his earlier statements and evaluations a rash and reckless display of ignorance? They seemed fairly lucid and reasoned to me.

And isn't this Thunderdome? No rules? Looking for discrepencies in a person's statements and remarks to challenge the credibility of that person?

Seems to be the standard operating procedure on this forum. So I'm just "fitting in".

:)

Bill

Just wanted to add:


How would any experiment Dfoot performed change any of the following statements?

"Even on recent suits by Rick Baker there seems to be nothing like this. "

No experiment Dfoot did changes what Rick Baker did.

"There are so many things that Roger Patterson would have to have done to make all of this happen. I don't see him as being able to do it. "

What experiment by Dfoot changed Patterson's capability, given Patterson died long before the experiments were done?

"In 1967 no one had these materials."

How does an experiment in 2005 or later change this fact?

"The bottom line is that no one around Patterson could have made alterations to any of the ape suits of the 60's that matched what was filmed. The techniques and materials needed had yet to be invented."

Again, How does an experiment in 2005 or later change this fact?

Fact is, Dfoot was right the first time, in 2004. His appraisals then were correct. He has chosen for some personal motive to get "skeptical religion", and he's aiming for the preisthood.

My opinion. Call 'um like I see 'um.

Sorry for being blunt, D, but you invited it with your silly post above.

Bill
 
Last edited:
A reminder of words of wisdon from Dfoot (on the BFF):



D, you made all the above comments when you were an industry expert, didn't you?

:)

Bill

Actually Bill you've got it entirely wrong and you are doing exactly what I'd hoped to spare you from doing.

Here's what went on at the BFF:

I stopped by because of the silly photo I'd seen regarding Optic Nerve and the "Notice the Arms" thing. When I told them I'd worked with Vulich I was asked about the PG film.

I told them that from the version I'd seen it looked good to me but I had no idea if it was real or not - only that the creature fx guys used to tell me it had obvious "earmarks" of a suit. I didn't know what they were talking about as I'd never paid attention to how suits were made. (I'd not seen a clear version of the PG film at this point yet either)

Since I said it looked good I was asked to write an article for the Bigfoot Information Project about how Hollywood couldn't have made the Patterson suit. I told them that I wasn't working in 1966-67 and I'd have to do some research first to find out what was available and who made what.

So I promised I'd do this...
I told them I'd take these positions and argue each one to see what panned out as the facts came in. The positions were:

1) The PG film shows a real Bigfoot and here is why.
2) Roger Patterson could have made the suit on his own and here's why.
3) A Hollywood connection was responsible for the suit and here's why.

You are taking items from 1) and ignoring the rest. That's how Bigfootery works y' know? But it's not how science works.

Science asks all the questions and takes all the positions. Whichever is true and can be demonstrated as such wins out. There is no "side" or emotion involved in it. It's an honest search for results. That's how it's done IF you really want to get at the truth.

When I finally got to the conclusion and the facts had been presented it was not what the BFF members wanted to hear. This caused much gnashing of teeth and I quickly went from being the latest Bill Munns to being a terrible "skoftic." But what can I do? I gave it the best argument that I could and those damn facts kept getting in the way. The truth turns out that it's Bob Heironimus in a suit.

I was amazed when I got hold of clearer images AND reviewed the suits being made back then. I even tracked down some of the suits the group of guys responsible had made (that I had even used myself previously) and found the same stitch pattern I'd found on Patty was used on them too. So far no one has presented a Bigfoot with such pads and stitches on them, nor one that used Wah's head or Janos' glue method as Patty does. It turns out nature had not created such a creature before as none could be found, but Wah and the boys had.

The things I had been told about Heironimus by Bigfooters turned out to be twisted into something untrue as well. The facts showed that Gimlin was the one lying. Patterson did indeed have access to the money and made quite a haul from the film. All of this was the opposite of what I'd been told when I arrived at the forum.

I quickly realized this thing existed this long because people were made to "join a side" and stick to it. Very few did honest research and looked at all sides. It was more like a club or a religion. I wanted to get to the bottom of the mystery - and that's just what has happened.

The same thing happened to my friend who really liked OJ Simpson during his trial. He and I went to the crime scene and then drove to OJ's house because my friend thought it was impossible to accomplish in the time the prosecution said. Turns out we did it in half that time without even trying. He was shocked, but he admitted that what Johnny Cochran was selling the jury was bunk. However, they were willing buyers of bunk and not willing to look at the real evidence. They had a conclusion they wanted to somehow reach. This is how the PG film investigations have gone in the past.

Don't be a willing buyer of bunk. Don't stick to something because the "group" will tease you if you suddenly notice a man behind the curtain. Because there is a reason for seeing that. It's because there's really a man behind the curtain. The Bigfoot world demands you only see the Wizard, however, the guys who made those shoes sticking out from beneath the curtain may have something else to say about that (if they trust you enough to say it). You need to be able to hear it.

One day you might find yourself in my position too. I even went down to a dank garage and put on some of the old items just to see for myself. And see I did. There's no doubt about it. Patty used the same techniques found among their old suits.

What's being sold to the Bigfoot community is hokum. Plain and simple. Some people blame Wallace or Patterson, but I'd say Green and Sanderson are pretty much responsible too. They did come across facts along the way that showed fakery on the part of Patterson and Wallace and they chose to ignore it or twist it into something else just to keep from admitting they were wrong about what they'd written. Meldrum is doing it right now.

I never want to be as weak and easily led as those people. And I don't want you to be either. Snap out of it Bill. They're turning you into Dr. Meldrum junior. (That's not a good thing btw) ;)
 
Dfoot:

"I never want to be as weak and easily led as those people. And I don't want you to be either. Snap out of it Bill. They're turning you into Dr. Meldrum junior. "

Thank you for your explanation. I agree with you most emphatically that the scientific method should prevail, and we should follow the facts, as best we can determine them, to their most rational and impartial opinion.

The funny thing you just don't get is nobody is leading me anywhere. Nobody has a clue what my notes will say till I post them, nobody suggests what aspects of the issue I should address, and nobody censors or modifies my notes. Nobody is leading me anywhere. I'm going where I choose to go, simply because of my curious scientific mind is intrigued by these issues.

Anybody from the Makeup FX industry (who makes suits for a living) can speak up and refute any aspect of my notes, the actual explanations of material and process. I'm still waiting.

I exclude your notes from the above because you and I clearly cannot establish a mutual foundation of what is relevant. Others may read your postings and mine, and they are free to choose one as the more scientific and well reasoned.

I reread some of my notes earlier today, and I see no reason to retract anything I said.

And if I may offer this observation of you, with all due respect and no sarcasm or criticism implied, you seem dedicated to your theory, and determined in your research. But as long as you continue to publish your notes under a screen name, you will never have the credibility you seek, because you are hiding behind the curtain.

If you want to be believed, start publishing under your real name, so the industry and the world can read your remarks and know the actual person who made those remarks. As long as you use the screen name, you are just a ghost of the internet, and ghosts don't have the same credibility as real people.

food for thought.

:)

Bill

Just an afterthought, rereading your post above:

"Don't be a willing buyer of bunk."

Just curious, what "bunk" am I buying from them?

Almost everything I've been posting is based on my experience and my knowledge, and I've stayed as far as I can away from most of their peripheral issues.

This is what I mean when I say we can't seem to establish an agreed basis of relevance. So I repeat, what "bunk" an i buying from them?

Bill
 
Last edited:
Why is it low to hold a person to their word? Isn't that what intregity is all about?

I'll grant you people can grow and their opinion may change because of that growth, but a 180 turn is pretty rare, and that's what he's done.

People can grow but a 180 is rare? Is there some way to qualify that statement? I think I can easily substantiate the opposite. No, Munns, it is not rare. It is not rare at all. This forum is full of people who believed all sorts of things and after having found or been shown evidence to the contrary, to have shifted their position completely opposite. At one time in my life I was sure the PGF was real. Now after having examined all the available evidence and detaching myself from what I knew was a desire to believe, I'm of the opinion it was a hoax. That would be a 180.

Were his earlier statements and evaluations a rash and reckless display of ignorance? They seemed fairly lucid and reasoned to me.

Dfoot can answer that for himself and I see he has.

And isn't this Thunderdome? No rules? Looking for discrepencies in a person's statements and remarks to challenge the credibility of that person?

Seems to be the standard operating procedure on this forum. So I'm just "fitting in".

:)

Bill

...

My opinion. Call 'um like I see 'um.

Sorry for being blunt, D, but you invited it with your silly post above.

Bill
Keep your insults and false apologies. Your lame attempt is without any of the integrity that you speak of. Standard operating procedure of this forum is to see that a person's arguments bare scrutiny based on facts and not false premises or assumptions. Regardless, you have much to learn about communicating on forums of any kind. I made my reasons for my opinion clear. If you want to call my post 'silly' that is means nothing to me, but the word 'hypocrite' does come to mind.
 
Anybody from the Makeup FX industry (who makes suits for a living) can speak up and refute any aspect of my notes, the actual explanations of material and process. I'm still waiting.
That's a strange thing to say, "I'm still waiting." That would give the impression that FX industry people should have seen your musings and commented by now. That is very strange statement indeed, given that instead of to a community of your peers, you chose to present your intial musings to a crowd of bigfoot enthusiasts and once the inevitable flood of admiration came you greatly expanded them. That doesn't speak to me of a strong effort to remain impartial. I would remind you that the same could be said if you chose this place to share your musings. Accept that we would and already have suggested presenting them to your peers.
 
Dfoot:


If you want to be believed, start publishing under your real name, so the industry and the world can read your remarks and know the actual person who made those remarks. As long as you use the screen name, you are just a ghost of the internet, and ghosts don't have the same credibility as real people.

food for thought.

:)

Bill

Bill: People already know my real name and I've never tried to hide it. I've even shown photos of myself both at work and playing Bigfoot.

What happens is that I'm asked about myself and my experience by Bigfooters. I tell them. If they think I'm positive about the PG film then I'm praised. If they think I'm negative then I'm told I'm bragging. This is just how it is.

Be careful about quoting me from BFF because some of the words are not actually my own. I complained when I noticed that my words were being re-written to say something I never said. I was told that they had the right to change what they thought needed to be changed and that I was not allowed to "talk back" to a moderator by daring to even mention they'd changed what I wrote. Now THAT'S a cult. Who knows what's taken out of context or changed around there? But if you have a question then ask me. You know I'll tell you what I think. No need to go to Jonestown.

Paul demanded that I never mention the word "Scientology" or "cult behavior" again in a post. So I didn't. Then he emailed me and ASKED me about the Scientology references. I gave him my opinion on what I saw going on and a link regarding Scientology and some of Hubbards' "dead-agenting" tactics.

He then went on the BFF to say how insulted he was by an email he'd received and banned me. He also looked up our names on IMDB (you too)and talked about our resumes then posted a completely false story written by some crazed fan about me and one of my shows. None of that had anything to do with researching Bigfoot or the PG film. It does have everything to do with controlling people's thoughts.

What I've learned since I started all this is not to take what I'm told at face value. I was told NOT to buy Long's book as they had the facts posted there and didn't want a liar to profit. They told me Heironimus was just some nutcase who latched onto the PG film trying to make money and was one of a long line of would-be suit wearers coming out of the woodwork. I believed them and posted accordingly.

As I went along I did my own research and found out NONE of that was true. Were these people hoaxers or just hoaxing themselves? This was something I wanted to know. So I stuck around and continued playing the Bigfoot game. It was very enlightening. There's a whole psychology behind this and how it has gone on for so long. As I've said many times that is just as fascinating to me as the question of whether Bigfoot ever existed or not.

What I say is that you will be used. Already incorrect info you innocently stated during the interview has been used to foster false beliefs. You should correct this tomorrow. The truth is that Chris Walas was absolutely right about the two section ape suits being the norm. When you say you've "never seen a hair suit in two sections" that gets repeated. Bigfooters take that to mean that no one used such suits when the opposite is true. ALL the pros, in fact, did use this type of suit. Twisting what people say is an important part of the game of keeping Patty "real" and you and I have now both been victims of it. (Though you may not yet know it)

Next month I will take the time to edit a little video for YOUTUBE. It won't change a Bigfooter's mind, I'm sure, and I fully expect all the usual verbal swipes to come my way.

What I would like to see happen is for those not wrapped up in this thing to stand back and observe how smart people can get caught up in a belief that so entrances them they'll willingly discount evidence and common sense. So much so that anyone who opposes that belief will become an enemy that must be somehow stopped.

As for the PG film itself: Don't you see that you are now doing what I did in phase 1? I used the knowledge from my own experiences with suits. Naturally that is what I originally had to go on. But by phase 3 I'd gone looking for who REALLY did what in 1967 and tried to see if anything on Patty matched that. When it did I sought these folks out and that's when I found certain items and testimony that could not be denied.

None of these people want a thing to do with Bigfoot or taking credit for anything. They don't have the same sort of respect for the "awesomeness of Patty" that the Bigfooters do. It's just a bad joke to them that went too far and it will stay that way.

You've done phase 1 now. I can tell you from my look at phase 2 (Patterson doing it alone) that I was surprised at how artistic the man was. By the end of that I found out it wouldn't have been impossible for him. He wasn't the goof ball I was told he was by certain Bigfooters when I first began. Once again the info I was being fed was wrong.

But the head of Patty and the techniques used in the suit were those used by a certain group of guys and that's where Patty came from. Phase 3 is the correct answer. Patterson wanted to make a movie and sell it. That's just what he did.

Your pal,

Jeff Pruitt :p
 
And if I may offer this observation of you, with all due respect and no sarcasm or criticism implied, you seem dedicated to your theory, and determined in your research. But as long as you continue to publish your notes under a screen name, you will never have the credibility you seek, because you are hiding behind the curtain.

If you want to be believed, start publishing under your real name, so the industry and the world can read your remarks and know the actual person who made those remarks. As long as you use the screen name, you are just a ghost of the internet, and ghosts don't have the same credibility as real people.

food for thought.

:)

Bill
Keep your food, Munns. You didn't think about it very much.

a) We all know who aka Jeff Pruitt AKA Dfoot is. He's this guy:


That's me in the gray shirt. The creature was made by Vulich and Optic Nerve. I'd hired a skinny stuntman so that two guys could fall into the same slim hole in our cave set before I knew that Optic Nerve already had a suit made for a huge-sized performer. They compromised by altering the suit for me so that my little guy could wear it. Do you really think they don't know how to make arms as long or longer than Patty's? Really?
Dfoot has had no problem making his identity known. Again you have the facts wrong before you start sharing your musings.

b) Neither your nor Dfoot's ideas concerning the PGF are published. They are posted on internet forums by each of you. If your musings on the PGF were published, I'm quite sure that the scrutiny that you say you've been waiting for from your peers would be abundantly forthcoming.
 
Munns, that's pretty low. LAL tried the same thing, pulling out old posts of Dfoot's when he was leaning towards the creature being real. You do allow for the fact that...

a) ...he made those posts before much of his experimentation that changed his opinion?

b) ...his opinion changed from believing the creature real to being a hoax as the result of his experimentations without any influence from BF skeptics?

Members of this forum pull up old posts from both this forum and BFF all the time. Its been done to me its been done to you it'll be done again.
 
Jeff:

Thank you for your more detailed description of your experience with the other board.

I am well aware that there are people in this whole sphere of the internet with all varied intentions, some good, others definitely not. It is simply a price we pay to participate, risking that others may misunderstand us or treat us in a manner we may feel was unwarranted.

But we do what we feel we have to do, and live the lives we choose, or try to determine for ourselves.

And then Fate decides.

So you and I have made our choices, and we shall see what fate decides for us each.

Bill
 
Andy Siren putting finishing touches on model of Sasquatch, Calgary, Alberta. Published in The Albertan August 24, 1961. The 2800 pound model left Calgary by truck destined for Oliver, British Columbia where it will be a tourist attraction.


2e1384c7.jpg
 
Bill,
How is the experimenting progressing?
Have you come to any conclusions yet?
Is there anything about the PGF that allows you to make a conclusion at this time?

I will say this, If I was doing an experiment to look at human ancestry, to determine if we descended from apes, or if we were created by an all-powerful being, If I wanted to maintain any form of credibility wrt the study, I wouldn't post my findings, plans, and theories on the Christian Broadcasting Network.
 
Members of this forum pull up old posts from both this forum and BFF all the time. Its been done to me its been done to you it'll be done again.

just like folks trying to use completely unrelated situations to deflect the readers of this away from their own logical quagmire.
 
Members of this forum pull up old posts from both this forum and BFF all the time. Its been done to me its been done to you it'll be done again.
We reference posts from bigfooters forums all the time. What we do not do is take posts several years old showing a person's opinion at the outset of their involvement with bigfootery contrary to the one they currently hold as an attempt to undermine that position. That is intellectually dishonest and denies a person their credit for advancing their understanding of a subject.

You will have of course seen the posts in your bigfoot extinction thread where I show first a recent post of yours that doesn't seem to be in line with the skepticism you claim but soon after that show posts from last year where you are very specific about your skepticism. That's certainly not an attempt to misrepresent your opinions but rather an attempt to clarify them. Such effort would not be necessary if you had the forthrightness enough to articulate why your position is that bigfoot once existed and how it is not based on imparted belief.
 
I will say this, If I was doing an experiment to look at human ancestry, to determine if we descended from apes, or if we were created by an all-powerful being, If I wanted to maintain any form of credibility wrt the study, I wouldn't post my findings, plans, and theories on the Christian Broadcasting Network.
Yahtzee!
 
Jeff:

I'm going to make a good faith attempt to see if you and I can reach some understanding here.

I've been a teacher for many years of my life, and I embrace a person's ongoing education throughout their life, so if you say that you started out a few years ago with one outlook on the BF issues and then with a more extensive research effort, you came to a different conclusion, a conclusion you now feel is more correct and factual, then fine. I have no more issue with that, and applaud your efforts to continue to research and learn. If you want to discuss this more, we can, or if you feel enough has been said, and the issue is closed, I'm fine with that too.

Now, in my most recent post of notes, I began as follows:

"Between the comments by Chris Walas in this forum a few years back, and some research information posted here and on other forums by a participant using the screen name "Dfoot', much has been discussed about fur suits commonly used in the film industry where they were designed in a two body piece configuration. I personally commented on several prior occasions that I would never design a fur suit in such a manner, and didn't see the merit of the design, but my opinions aside, there has been sufficient research into the matter to say that such suit designs do exist, did exist back in the 60's and before, and so such a design was a plausable explanation of the PG Film figure known as "Patty".

So in this analysis, I've chosen to address this question with the assumption that such two piece fur suits are common and that if "Patty" is indeed a suit, she may be of a two piece design. "

Do you see any problem with these remarks? Have I disrespected you in any way? Have I stated anything false? Have I mislead anybody? I've read your posts where you stated you are trying to get me to change my statements about two piece fur suits. Is there anything in the above you feel I must change, and if so, what is it, and why should I change it?

Next, I invite you to consider an issue of your own action, which you may not altogether perceive how your action may appear to others. You may, of course, disagree with me in this perceived action, and we can discuss it.

Above, in your post #13697, You started by saying:

"Well... he has an interview tomorrow on TalkShoe "Let's talk Bigfoot" with some of the BFF members. I've asked him to correct the mistake he made regarding the two-sectioned ape suits. I hope he does. "


Now, as I understand, there are several webcast interview programs mentioned on the other forum, and they announce guests every week. But in the six weeks I;ve been following this forum, I don't recall much mention by members giving notice of who those guests were. So when you post your notice of my interview, there appears to be an implied suggestion that I am somehow noteworthy, or more important than the interview guests you do not remind others here of. So, in effect, you are making an impresion that I'm important, since you feel it's worth your time to bring this news to the attention of the forum here. Similarly, Diogenes in the post above yours made note of my starting anew thread over there, as if this is news too. I'm sure others start threads there and nobody here feels it is signifigant to mention, so mentioning my new thread here implies mine has some importance of note.

What you (and Diogenes) appear to be doing is taking an action which confers or implies importance to me, and then you seem to be concerned that others who may misunderstand my notes are mislead. Maybe if you both ignored me more, and didn't feel the need to report over here my actions away from this forum, others wouldn't think I'm important and then my opinions would have less weight or influence or impact. If I'm wrong here, feel free to share with me your view on this issue.

Then you say "That is a serious problem. It means he has zero experience with what he's preaching about. "

Do you really want to get into a resume and photo display "who knows what" sort of rivalry, because I assure you I have an abundance of experience to validate what I write about, and if you are fair, you know I do. I laughed off that remark, because it was frankly so untrue I didn't even feel offended. I've made more suits that you have, fact. I've made fur suits, fact. And I write from the fact of that experience, which is beyond any contention and can be documented abundantly.

Your own credibility is determined as much by what you say of others as what you say about yourself and your research. In the above remark, I think all you succeeded in doing was damaging your own credibiltiy. I know you didn't damage mine.

Next, every criticism you speak of about proponents of BF, and the other forum, I see here in this forum as much if not more. And you say, " It's a strange form of denial that really does touch much more on religious belief than pure scientific evaluation of a subject."

Do you really want to get into a debate of scientific method and our respective science backgrounds? It is one of the sad cliches that in any argument that it is easy to say those who disagree or oppose your view are bound by religious dogma while you are the shimmering light of impartial scientific reason. Do you want to just throw that cliche back and forth as others in the forum seem to enjoy engaging, as if they were playing volleyball, or would you like to actually start with a set of foundation stipulations and fundamental understandings of process, method, and reasoning, and see if we can work toward some mutual understanding?

I'm prefer to do it the methodical and reasoned way.

Finally, I invite you to consider this, as one other way to procede. You and I ignore each other, and simply go about our research and forum activity as if the other did not exist, never commenting about the other's notes or ideas, never giving any concern to the other's opinions, and simply having confidence that our own ideas have enough merit to prevail as reasoned and reliable presentations.

Let others choose to evaluate what you say or present, and similarly evaluate what I say or present, and they can make up their minds whether they choose to believe you, me, neither of us, or simply themselves. I will not try to dissuade anyone who finds your ideas persuasive, and neither will you concern yourself with anyone who finds my ideas persuasive.

You see, I can live with that just fine. I even put a note on this forum a few weeks ago, saying "If you promise to ignore me, I promise to go away". I was hoping somebody here had enough of a sense of humor to just copy that quote and write below it "Deal", but it seems humor is in short supply here.

So, there it is, my calm and polite request for you to consider.

Bill
 
Next, every criticism you speak of about proponents of BF, and the other forum, I see here in this forum as much if not more. And you say, " It's a strange form of denial that really does touch much more on religious belief than pure scientific evaluation of a subject."

Scientific evaluation of the subject could only lead one to say that it is not an Unclassified, Hairy, Bipedal, Mid-Tarsal Break Having, Non-splaying toe having, Plover-Broken-Wing Acting, Beast, walking around the Northern California woods, only to be filmed by an amateur showman, riding along an open stretch a creek that morning in No-Cal.
 
Jeff:

I'm going to make a good faith attempt to see if you and I can reach some understanding here.

I've been a teacher for many years of my life, and I embrace a person's ongoing education throughout their life, so if you say that you started out a few years ago with one outlook on the BF issues and then with a more extensive research effort, you came to a different conclusion, a conclusion you now feel is more correct and factual, then fine. I have no more issue with that, and applaud your efforts to continue to research and learn. If you want to discuss this more, we can, or if you feel enough has been said, and the issue is closed, I'm fine with that too.

Now, in my most recent post of notes, I began as follows:

"Between the comments by Chris Walas in this forum a few years back, and some research information posted here and on other forums by a participant using the screen name "Dfoot', much has been discussed about fur suits commonly used in the film industry where they were designed in a two body piece configuration. I personally commented on several prior occasions that I would never design a fur suit in such a manner, and didn't see the merit of the design, but my opinions aside, there has been sufficient research into the matter to say that such suit designs do exist, did exist back in the 60's and before, and so such a design was a plausable explanation of the PG Film figure known as "Patty".

So in this analysis, I've chosen to address this question with the assumption that such two piece fur suits are common and that if "Patty" is indeed a suit, she may be of a two piece design. "

Do you see any problem with these remarks? Have I disrespected you in any way? Have I stated anything false? Have I mislead anybody? I've read your posts where you stated you are trying to get me to change my statements about two piece fur suits. Is there anything in the above you feel I must change, and if so, what is it, and why should I change it?

Next, I invite you to consider an issue of your own action, which you may not altogether perceive how your action may appear to others. You may, of course, disagree with me in this perceived action, and we can discuss it.

Above, in your post #13697, You started by saying:

"Well... he has an interview tomorrow on TalkShoe "Let's talk Bigfoot" with some of the BFF members. I've asked him to correct the mistake he made regarding the two-sectioned ape suits. I hope he does. "


Now, as I understand, there are several webcast interview programs mentioned on the other forum, and they announce guests every week. But in the six weeks I;ve been following this forum, I don't recall much mention by members giving notice of who those guests were. So when you post your notice of my interview, there appears to be an implied suggestion that I am somehow noteworthy, or more important than the interview guests you do not remind others here of. So, in effect, you are making an impresion that I'm important, since you feel it's worth your time to bring this news to the attention of the forum here. Similarly, Diogenes in the post above yours made note of my starting anew thread over there, as if this is news too. I'm sure others start threads there and nobody here feels it is signifigant to mention, so mentioning my new thread here implies mine has some importance of note.

What you (and Diogenes) appear to be doing is taking an action which confers or implies importance to me, and then you seem to be concerned that others who may misunderstand my notes are mislead. Maybe if you both ignored me more, and didn't feel the need to report over here my actions away from this forum, others wouldn't think I'm important and then my opinions would have less weight or influence or impact. If I'm wrong here, feel free to share with me your view on this issue.

Then you say "That is a serious problem. It means he has zero experience with what he's preaching about. "

Do you really want to get into a resume and photo display "who knows what" sort of rivalry, because I assure you I have an abundance of experience to validate what I write about, and if you are fair, you know I do. I laughed off that remark, because it was frankly so untrue I didn't even feel offended. I've made more suits that you have, fact. I've made fur suits, fact. And I write from the fact of that experience, which is beyond any contention and can be documented abundantly.

Your own credibility is determined as much by what you say of others as what you say about yourself and your research. In the above remark, I think all you succeeded in doing was damaging your own credibiltiy. I know you didn't damage mine.

Next, every criticism you speak of about proponents of BF, and the other forum, I see here in this forum as much if not more. And you say, " It's a strange form of denial that really does touch much more on religious belief than pure scientific evaluation of a subject."

Do you really want to get into a debate of scientific method and our respective science backgrounds? It is one of the sad cliches that in any argument that it is easy to say those who disagree or oppose your view are bound by religious dogma while you are the shimmering light of impartial scientific reason. Do you want to just throw that cliche back and forth as others in the forum seem to enjoy engaging, as if they were playing volleyball, or would you like to actually start with a set of foundation stipulations and fundamental understandings of process, method, and reasoning, and see if we can work toward some mutual understanding?

I'm prefer to do it the methodical and reasoned way.

Finally, I invite you to consider this, as one other way to procede. You and I ignore each other, and simply go about our research and forum activity as if the other did not exist, never commenting about the other's notes or ideas, never giving any concern to the other's opinions, and simply having confidence that our own ideas have enough merit to prevail as reasoned and reliable presentations.

Let others choose to evaluate what you say or present, and similarly evaluate what I say or present, and they can make up their minds whether they choose to believe you, me, neither of us, or simply themselves. I will not try to dissuade anyone who finds your ideas persuasive, and neither will you concern yourself with anyone who finds my ideas persuasive.

You see, I can live with that just fine. I even put a note on this forum a few weeks ago, saying "If you promise to ignore me, I promise to go away". I was hoping somebody here had enough of a sense of humor to just copy that quote and write below it "Deal", but it seems humor is in short supply here.

So, there it is, my calm and polite request for you to consider.

Bill

Whew! Okay.

Anyway... what I was trying to do was help you avoid the Bigfoot trap. Remember I told you that I didn't want to see your words turned around and used? Well... last night a "Bigfooter" did use this Bigfootery tactic on me. That Bigfooter was you.

Really investigating something means learning bit by bit as you go along. When new info comes in the idea is to correct and change whatever you've said that was off base before. As you progress you get to the facts and finally a resolution. This is what I have been trying to do.

With the exception of a very few (like Tube) Bigfooters seem to cling to dogma they like as if it were a religious belief instead of an investigation into something unusual. Eventually they begin turning Elk prints into Bigfoot evidence and grab hold of anything that helps support their belief system - no matter how ridiculous it turns out to be after further investigation.

The final stage is the attack mode. This is when after years of finding nothing they begin to blast each other. Comments made years earlier are dredged up and taken out of context. There is little else to do as all attempts to find Bigfoot have failed totally.

When I said some of the things you've quoted I was going off what the Bigfooters told me regarding what they had learned after years of supposedly investigating the suit angle. I made the mistake of assuming that they had really done honest work. I learned they were not capable of this. So I went back to square one and found out (as Tube did with the tracks) that much of what I was being told wasn't factual at all.

Here's your interview:
http://www.talkshoe.com/tc/30301
About half-way through we finally start talking about the Patterson film and this is when you relayed your shock over Chris Walas saying the suit was in two sections. You said you completely disagreed with him as you'd never seen such a thing used.

A biologist calls in and says he was starting to listen to this guy called "Dfoot" until you came along and clarified things for him. After that he understood that Patty couldn't be a man in a suit.

That is why I'm going to make a video next month to carefully spell out what is seen in the film and what my findings have been thus far. People like this biologist fellow might find it helpful to their sanity. Or at least it might spare them future embarrassment among their colleagues.

So far I've seen lots and lots of words, but no action from you. This is very much in line with the usual Bigfootologist way. I've seen the statue of Giganto you made:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/MUNNS-comp.jpg
I like it very much. No one knows if Giganto stood erect or was bald or much else as we only have a few teeth and bits to go off of, but I think that's a fine bit of work there and could well be what they looked like.

Yet on the actual creature suit side of things I've only seen your Swamp Thing suit:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/SWAMP-1.jpg
I'm guessing that's not your best work, but it's the only suit of yours I've seen.

What I'd like to see is some actual work related to investigating the Patterson film. Like what I did that weekend with the foam. Look at the film, see what Wah and the guys were doing with suits, then see if you can duplicate certain things clearly seen on Patty. This would be more useful than just typing or talking in a professorial tone. That's something any Bigfooter with a grasp of the English language can do. You have certain skills developed over the years and I think you should use them as part of a real investigation into this.

http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/151.jpg
That's me holding Rick Baker's "Harry" foot. Nice dermals it has. Janos made similar dermal ridges on his ape feet and so did a lot of other folks. They even made them in the pattern Meldrum touts for Bigfoot on some of the Alien feet. Really.

But Patty doesn't seem to have this. Patty has feet made the way Janos made his bear feet seen below:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/1.jpg
Soft, pliable booties.

But with toes like his front paws from the same suit:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/2.jpg

And here's the foot I made in minutes right next to a photo of Patty's foot:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/Patterson_Dfoot-first.jpg

My foot makes the same "mid-tarsal breaking footprint" as Patty was supposed to have made. So we know these feet are real. We know who made such feet in the 60's. We can duplicate and demonstrate such feet working. Patty? (*insert crickets chirping*) Even Patterson never bothered looking for Patty at Bluff Creek again. Perhaps, just perhaps, the reason is that he knew Patty's feet were not the feet of a real Bigfoot at all.

The most significant thing I've learned is this:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/youtube-avatar.jpg
That is Patty with the Wah mask overlayed on it. Each attribute fits perfectly. Same nose. Same cheeks. Same lips. Same philtrum. Same jawline. Same forehead. Same eyes. Same pointy head. Same everything.

The reason for that is simple. This is the head they used when they made Patty. The techniques I've been learning are those that were used on Patty. Nobody does it like this anymore and that's why I had to go backwards in time to find out what they were doing. It's different from what we'd do today or even in the 80's. But it fits Patty. Nature doesn't.

http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/D-backoveray-web.gif

Would it make a difference if you learned the old school methods of Wah Chang and applied them to an imitation suit? You have the chops to do it. But the answer is no. Even if you perfectly demonstrated how Patty was made and got one of the guys to talk on camera about it AND got the guy who was friends with Patterson and wore the suit to speak out (as he already has) it STILL wouldn't stop the onslaught of denials. People have built lives and careers around this thing. That's the truth of it.

Yet... there will be some who step back and say, "Hey, that Dfoot guy, or whatever his name is, has a point there. Wait a second... that IS a guy in a suit! Why didn't I see it before?"

When TUBE looks at the old pics from John Green today he's amazed that he ever spent a moment thinking they came from a real animal. But he did. And he's a brilliant guy. That testimony from him should make us all stop and think when it comes to the Patterson film. Can we see what is right in front of us or is there something in our heads that prevents us from seeing clearly?

http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/John2BGreen2B2.jpg

I don't know if there is a Bigfoot. I only know that I've thoroughly investigated the Patterson film and what is on it isn't one. It's a hoax. Mrs. Patterson has never once in all these years come out and said it's even real. She's only said one thing; "Just make sure you don't interfere with my money. Other than that you can do what you want." That pretty much spells it out for you right there.

http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/leg-1.jpg

The reason you see an edge at the top of my thigh in that photo is because there is a thigh pad under that fur. Same reason you see such an edge on Patty. How much clearer can it be? What exactly would be enough to get Bigfooters to realize this is a hoax film? You tell me and I'll try to add that to the video next month.

Think about it. Even the very guys who worked with Wallace making the faked tracks demonstrating how they did it with Wallace's wife explaining it all didn't seem to phase hardcore Bigfooters. Green said they were all liars and he was still right. Bigfoot made those tracks and they were just glory seekers. Bigfooters went with the Green story. Now that is an amazing tale. Maybe even unbelievable...
 
Last edited:
Andy Siren putting finishing touches on model of Sasquatch, Calgary, Alberta. Published in The Albertan August 24, 1961. The 2800 pound model left Calgary by truck destined for Oliver, British Columbia where it will be a tourist attraction.


[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/2e1384c7.jpg[/qimg]

That statue shows to excellent effect the preposterous idea of a 10 ft or 12 ft tall Hominid/Primate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom