Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
I must submit an apology for the above 'Cheese Shop' post. While it may seem like Crowlogic has not provided reasonable arguments in favor of bigfoot extinction, she has at least listed her reasons why she feels they have gone extinct.

Had I searched for information [aligned my ducks if you will], prior to posting, I would have found her listing. I truly do not remember her posting that, nor any responses I may have made to it.

Crow, I apologize for ridiculing your perceived lack of explanation on your position, when you had already done so. I don't agree with that position, but I had no business ridiculing it.

RayG

Why apologise? She still hasnt produced a single shred of evidence to backup her assertions.

She might as well have claimed "I believe BF is extinct because the winter of 1893 was especially harsh". She is fully deserving of your ridicule and contempt.

BTW, ultra-funny post dude :D
 
Let's Give Them Their Due

Being that Roger Patterson is probably the most discussed and most responsible for shining the light on the Bigfoot Phenomenon, I was curious if Patty resembles what is described and depicted in his book "Do Abominable Snowmen of America Really Exist?"
I ordered the book recently at biblio and I'm anxious to be fully enlightened by his personal study.

Has Bob Gimlin authored any material concerning bigfoot? Surely even his angle would be worthy of a Hollywood remake. Maybe for modern entertainment's sake they could make the Patty creature super-aggressive or something. Like Patty just happened to be exhausted from dispatching some smart-alecky pranksters interfering with Roger and Bob's (goodguys) study. And add other encounters also, make it a real wildwoman.
 
Had I searched for information [aligned my ducks if you will], prior to posting, I would have found her listing. I truly do not remember her posting that, nor any responses I may have made to it.

Crow, I apologize for ridiculing your perceived lack of explanation on your position, when you had already done so. I don't agree with that position, but I had no business ridiculing it.

RayG
I have searched for but have yet to find any post in which log explains on what she bases the opinion that bigfoot existed. I can easily say bigfoot went extinct and justify the statement simply by saying that they're not here now. Nothing in the post you linked says anything about what leads her to think bigfoot did exist.
 
Those "few odd" weekends were two years worth of not odd weekends but weeks at a time in the field collecting environmental data. Specifically rain and standing water Ph. I've detailed this in other posts. But Mikeyx as Buggs would say "what a maroon" you don't know what you're talking about. But I see the "gang" has circled the wagons.

not at all, ph water levels have squat to do with squatching, and your data is a quarter of a century old. You've presented nothing worth a damn to back up your """theory"".
 
not at all, ph water levels have squat to do with squatching, and your data is a quarter of a century old. You've presented nothing worth a damn to back up your """theory"".

You are absolutely right that my environmental field work was not squatch related. Neither was it deer related, bear related, racoon related etc etc. Not drectly anyway. I was however trained to observe the wildlife and general conditions of the environment under survey. Now even though as I write this I realize that I'm casting pearls before swine perhaps this will give you a little something to naw on.

Since my field work involved water courses, ponds, lakes, streams and rivers I was able to catalogue the prints of just about every animal that frequented places were water is available. I encountered virtually all of the fauna that inhabits Upper New York State including human beings.

Whether you know it or not, and I assume you don't, there are places in New York State that are extremely wild bordering on pure wilderness. On one occasion a bear did enter my camp and made a fine effort to get into my stores. I was armed, almost always at night, and spent several tense minutes wondering if that bear was going to investigate my tent next. I hoped my 22 long rifle was going to be sufficient to disuade the animal if it came to that. But it didn't.

Overall my field time amounted to a little over 25 weeks over the course of two years of in field data collecting. Weeks were roughly 10 day stretches as traveling back from the more remote areas of the State were time consuming as I was living in New York City at the time.

So what does this have to do with Sasquatach? Well I spent hundreds of hours deep in the forest/woods and observed the catalogue of land and air animals of the region but while I came across human tracks frequently enough I found no evidence of any other bipedal animals. Not a print, not a sound, not a smell, not a bone, hair or artifact that even remotely suggested that Sasquatach was in the region. And while there are reports of old that claim Sasquatach was once there it sure as hell wasn't there in 1980. I suppose you could say that I reached the conclusion that Sasquatach was extinct in the Northeast US was by direct observation. Now that's a little bit of what I did to get me out into the wilderness and learn first hand of what's out there. What have you done?
 
Last edited:
So what does this have to do with Sasquatach? Well I spent hundreds of hours deep in the forest/woods and observed the catalogue of land and air animals of the region but while I came across human tracks frequently enough I found no evidence of any other bipedal animals. Not a print, not a sound, not a smell, not a bone, hair or artifact that even remotely suggested that Sasquatach was in the region. And while there are reports of old that claim Sasquatach was once there it sure as hell wasn't there in 1980. I suppose you could say that I reached the conclusion that Sasquatach was extinct in the Northeast US was by direct observation. Now that's a little bit of what I did to get me out into the wilderness and learn first hand of what's out there. What have you done?

Why are you so sure they did once exist in New York state?
 
I have searched for but have yet to find any post in which log explains on what she bases the opinion that bigfoot existed. I can easily say bigfoot went extinct and justify the statement simply by saying that they're not here now. Nothing in the post you linked says anything about what leads her to think bigfoot did exist.

Yes, but that's why in my apology I said, "While it may seem like Crowlogic has not provided reasonable arguments in favor of bigfoot extinction, she has at least listed her reasons why she feels they have gone extinct."

Never mind evidence to support any assertions, I was ridiculing her for not even listing those assertions. I agree said assertions have not been supported by evidence, but at least she listed them. That was all, and it was my mistake to erroneously ridicule something as being unstated, when it had in fact been stated.

I'd still love to see some evidence to support the assertions mind you.

RayG
 
You are absolutely right that my environmental field work was not squatch related. Neither was it deer related, bear related, racoon related etc etc. Not drectly anyway. I was however trained to observe the wildlife and general conditions of the environment under survey. Now even though as I write this I realize that I'm casting pearls before swine perhaps this will give you a little something to naw on.

Since my field work involved water courses, ponds, lakes, streams and rivers I was able to catalogue the prints of just about every animal that frequented places were water is available. I encountered virtually all of the fauna that inhabits Upper New York State including human beings.

Whether you know it or not, and I assume you don't, there are places in New York State that are extremely wild bordering on pure wilderness. On one occasion a bear did enter my camp and made a fine effort to get into my stores. I was armed, almost always at night, and spent several tense minutes wondering if that bear was going to investigate my tent next. I hoped my 22 long rifle was going to be sufficient to disuade the animal if it came to that. But it didn't.

Overall my field time amounted to a little over 25 weeks over the course of two years of in field data collecting. Weeks were roughly 10 day stretches as traveling back from the more remote areas of the State were time consuming as I was living in New York City at the time.

So what does this have to do with Sasquatach? Well I spent hundreds of hours deep in the forest/woods and observed the catalogue of land and air animals of the region but while I came across human tracks frequently enough I found no evidence of any other bipedal animals. Not a print, not a sound, not a smell, not a bone, hair or artifact that even remotely suggested that Sasquatach was in the region. And while there are reports of old that claim Sasquatach was once there it sure as hell wasn't there in 1980. I suppose you could say that I reached the conclusion that Sasquatach was extinct in the Northeast US was by direct observation. Now that's a little bit of what I did to get me out into the wilderness and learn first hand of what's out there. What have you done?

Didn't see hide nor hair of any Hairy Bipeds of Unusual size so they must be extinct.

I guess my only question would be....why wasn't never existed in the first place an option? Why go straight to extinct? And while you were at it...why not embellish a bit with...

Were killed off by the Loup Garou in the Great Crypto War of 1918.
 
Originally Posted by Crowlogic
So what does this have to do with Sasquatach? Well I spent hundreds of hours deep in the forest/woods and observed the catalogue of land and air animals of the region but while I came across human tracks frequently enough I found no evidence of any other bipedal animals. Not a print, not a sound, not a smell, not a bone, hair or artifact that even remotely suggested that Sasquatach was in the region. And while there are reports of old that claim Sasquatach was once there it sure as hell wasn't there in 1980. I suppose you could say that I reached the conclusion that Sasquatach was extinct in the Northeast US was by direct observation. Now that's a little bit of what I did to get me out into the wilderness and learn first hand of what's out there. What have you done?

Why are you so sure they did once exist in New York state?

She's accepting earlier reports of Bigfoot in the area, but her personal observations is it no longer exists.

Not the conclusion I would have reached, but to each their own.
 
Last edited:
She's accepting earlier reports of Bigfoot in the area, but her personal observations is it no longer exists.

Not the conclusion I would have reached, but to each their own.

Hitch, AMM started a new thread for discussions on Crowlogic's BF extinction beliefs. We can talk about his beliefs there.
 
You are absolutely right that my environmental field work was not squatch related. Neither was it deer related, bear related, racoon related etc etc. Not drectly anyway. I was however trained to observe the wildlife and general conditions of the environment under survey. Now even though as I write this I realize that I'm casting pearls before swine perhaps this will give you a little something to naw on.

Since my field work involved water courses, ponds, lakes, streams and rivers I was able to catalogue the prints of just about every animal that frequented places were water is available. I encountered virtually all of the fauna that inhabits Upper New York State including human beings.

Whether you know it or not, and I assume you don't, there are places in New York State that are extremely wild bordering on pure wilderness. On one occasion a bear did enter my camp and made a fine effort to get into my stores. I was armed, almost always at night, and spent several tense minutes wondering if that bear was going to investigate my tent next. I hoped my 22 long rifle was going to be sufficient to disuade the animal if it came to that. But it didn't.

Overall my field time amounted to a little over 25 weeks over the course of two years of in field data collecting. Weeks were roughly 10 day stretches as traveling back from the more remote areas of the State were time consuming as I was living in New York City at the time.

So what does this have to do with Sasquatach? Well I spent hundreds of hours deep in the forest/woods and observed the catalogue of land and air animals of the region but while I came across human tracks frequently enough I found no evidence of any other bipedal animals. Not a print, not a sound, not a smell, not a bone, hair or artifact that even remotely suggested that Sasquatach was in the region. And while there are reports of old that claim Sasquatach was once there it sure as hell wasn't there in 1980. I suppose you could say that I reached the conclusion that Sasquatach was extinct in the Northeast US was by direct observation. Now that's a little bit of what I did to get me out into the wilderness and learn first hand of what's out there. What have you done?

pointed out that your experiences are 25 years old and that is just a bit out of date.... we dont like folks disagreeing with us, do we crow?
 
So what does this have to do with Sasquatach? Well I spent hundreds of hours deep in the forest/woods and observed the catalogue of land and air animals of the region but while I came across human tracks frequently enough I found no evidence of any other bipedal animals. Not a print, not a sound, not a smell, not a bone, hair or artifact that even remotely suggested that Sasquatach was in the region.

Yes, but no self-respecting squatch would be caught dead in the state of New York. How much of your time was spent in the PNW?

And while there are reports of old that claim Sasquatach was once there it sure as hell wasn't there in 1980.
Isn't that what they said about the coelacanth?

I suppose you could say that I reached the conclusion that Sasquatach was extinct in the Northeast US was by direct observation.
Or more specifically, by non-observation. Just because you didn't see evidence of squatch, doesn't mean he wasn't there observing you! He's really good at hiding and sneaking. Like an 8ft ninja, you turn around and there he is, gone!

RayG
 
Yes, but no self-respecting squatch would be caught dead in the state of New York. How much of your time was spent in the PNW?

Isn't that what they said about the coelacanth?

Or more specifically, by non-observation. Just because you didn't see evidence of squatch, doesn't mean he wasn't there observing you! He's really good at hiding and sneaking. Like an 8ft ninja, you turn around and there he is, gone!

RayG

Sounds to me like you want Sasquatach to be there in NY State. Come on Ray please say it ain't so! Ain't no BOSS there any mo'
 
Last edited:
Anybody out there catch the Discovery Channel "Best Evidence" Bigfoot show last night?
Probably the most well presented arguments, both pro and con. Of course the PGF was featured and some scientists deemed it to be authentic, while others claim it as a hoax.
If you haven't seen it, I suggest you check it out...By the way, I spend alot of time in the field. Just because I don't see a particular species each and every time where they have previously been observed, doesn't mean they went extinct! There off doing other things, in other areas. FYI New York State still receives many BF sightings each year...
according to BFRO...
 
pointed out that your experiences are 25 years old and that is just a bit out of date.... we dont like folks disagreeing with us, do we crow?

Let me see if I have this right. You say that my expierences of 25 years ago are out of date and therefore have no value. Well for my expierences of 25 years ago to be out of date would mean that the region is more accommodating to the possibility of harboring Sasquatach in spite of the encroachment of people into wild areas and a substantial increase in development. This is like saying that it is easier now to find stands of old growth virgin forests in North America now than it was in 1700. I don't mind people disagreeing with me. I just don't have a lot of patience for methane belchers. You're a little slow I think.
 
You're a little slow I think.

That's that crow logic. The hawk is slow. You can fly above and dive bomb. The hawks started a new thread for your crow beliefs. But Mr. Attention Defecit Disorder won't play that. Always fly above, and never let hawks determine the aerial arena. The crow is in control. This is crow logic.
 
That's that crow logic. The hawk is slow. You can fly above and dive bomb. The hawks started a new thread for your crow beliefs. But Mr. Attention Defecit Disorder won't play that. Always fly above, and never let hawks determine the aerial arena. The crow is in control. This is crow logic.

The crow is not in control, he/she/it just gets to showcase their "logic" that little bit better. I've had some interesting experiences in these "areas" much more recently than 25 years ago. It's not proof of anything but, they were enough to make to me wonder. I suspect crow is troll, thats how they acted on bff.
 
The crow is not in control, he/she/it just gets to showcase their "logic" that little bit better. I've had some interesting experiences in these "areas" much more recently than 25 years ago. It's not proof of anything but, they were enough to make to me wonder. I suspect crow is troll, thats how they acted on bff.

This would be mikeyx explaining how the crow is not in control of the hawk: You see the crow...BAM...cannot ever provide...BAM...detailed arguments based on...BAM...established scientific, or even rational norms for...BAM...what constitutes an evaluation...BAM...of the natural world.

The BAMs are the sound of the crow smashing into the hawk's back while it explains that the crow is not in control. A compress will usually stop the bleeding.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom