Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here is a segment from the Discovery Channel ‘ Best Evidence ‘, where Anthropologist Dr. Begin debunks the
MTB .. ( Warning ! large ..WMV file – Download it if you want to save it – I will be deleting it in the near future -.. )

http://www.gatzstuff.com/Video/MidTarsal.wmv

He points out that the human like, forward pointing, big toe and an MTB are ambiguous, and
physiologically incompatible. The human arch became rigid as the big toe aligned itself with the
other toes .. ( evolutionarily speaking )


As LTC8K6 would say, “ It’s a mid tarsal crock ..
 
There is the Discovery Channel episode of ' Best Evidence ' with Meldrum in person, holding that cast, and talking about that depression being the mid tarsal break .

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcYK2_1pSL0&feature=related

This is the Spanish version.. Couldn't find the English one..

Look at 2/6 for Meldrum and the MTB ..

I thought I remembered seeing some program showing this. I did watch the Spanish "Pie Grande" DC program months ago.

So it comes up at about 4:48. It's very brief, but there is an animation showing the MTB according to Meldrum. Indeed, it is that joint just in front of the ankle. My first assumption was correct. Meldrum has two active joints on the BF foot. The "mid-tarsal joint" (break) just in front of the ankle, and the forward joint just behind the actual toes (this is where our ball is). The toes themselves are jointed but we can leave that out of this discussion.

LTC said:
I always thought he could "grab" a tree branch, ie, the middle of the foot can bend upwards. That is, partially wrap the foot around the branch by bending the foot in the middle. Sort of like our arch, except it's a flexible arch.

I was always thinking this same thing. I used the term "downwards bend", and you used "upwards bend". But how can it grab something with the foot if it bends upwards? That's the wrong direction for grabbing substrate or branches, etc.

But guess what? The Pie Grande animation shows the MTB hinged to create an upwards bend! Meldrum's MTB hinge allows the whole foot (forward of the ankle) to bend upwards. The animation does not show it bending downwards ("into" the soil) at any time. This is actually the opposite direction from my original assumption. I wonder how many other people (Bigfooters and skeptics) were thinking like I was. Maybe I was the only one who was confused in such a way.

Now I want to know if Meldrum proposes that that MTB hinge locks in any position, or if it is free to create a downwards as well as an upwards bend.

Yeah, he's the Jeff to the Meld to the PhD. He's smarter than you. He's got a science degree! :D
 
Dr. David Begun (not Begin) may be the only genuine scientific peer that has publicly criticized Dr. Meldrum on this MTB. It doesn't make sense to him. He may privately understand that Bigfootery (including Meldrum) is a science fiction fantasy cult. First start by imagining a giant wild bipedal primate. Then use your imagination to fill in the "scientific" blanks about its feet.

Use the Laverty photo and the Patty casts as your launching point. Now reverse-engineer the actual feet but never allow that this could be produced by hoaxery. Do not talk about the potential for Patterson as a hoaxer, or at least only mention it as a remote possibility. Instead, focus on the results of your reverse engineering. We've got us a MTB Beast roaming the woods. The fantasy cult will eat that stuff up.

Krantz did the same thing with Cripplefoot. Well, hot diggety. We've got us an injured Bigfoot walking around. I'll just use my science degree to allow me to draw a bunch of broken (but healed) foot bones and fit those into the outline of the Cripplefoot track cast.

Krantz already knew exactly what a healthy Bigfoot foot should look like. It was a piece of cake for him to then illustrate the internal jumble of broken bones that comprised this major trauma resulting in the bizarre track. Whatever caused this foot bone blow-out, it must have hurt this poor Bigfoot. That is a major boo-boo (ow!). Bigfooters can imagine the pain, then healing, then the reasonable resumption of a relatively productive life. Cripplefoot was a survivor, and a testament to the noble fortitude and "git er done" attitude of The Boss of the Woods. Rock on, Bigfoot. We salute you.

Yeah, he's the Grove to the Krantz to the PhD. He's smarter than you. He's got a science degree!
 
I posed this question to Dr. Meldrum in a similar fashion. His answer follows my question below.

Drew's Question to Dr. Meldrum said:
Would your scientific study of sasquatch allow you to say that Sasquatch has a well-developed Achilles tendon, similar to humans?

If yes, then why would the foot require a mid-tarsal break similar to great apes, which do not have a well developed Achilles tendon?

If no, then wouldn't that preclude witness testimony saying that Sasquatch walked smoothly/gracefully, and/or was able to run down prey animals? (Lack of Achilles development would require that highly accelerated bipedal travel would be unlikely. (From the Bill Sellers study, detailed here- http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/6990319.stm )

Dr. Jeffrey Meldrum said:
I am on my way out the door this morning to catch a plane, so my answer will of necessity be brief (I suggest you read chapter 13 in my book if you have not already). Sasquatch certainly would be expected to have characteristics associated with bipedalism. If the P-G film can be accepted at face for the sake of discussion, the film subject shows a lengthened Achille's tendon cxompared to a gorilla or chimp, but one shorter than the average human. Retention of the flexible midfoot affords several advantages (enumerated in the book) and associated/correlated anatomies of the foot are evident in multiple independent examples. A flat flexible foot doesn't preclude efficient walking and bursts of speed -- observe a chimp. But ape, and sasquatch I suggest, lack the specializations of the human foot and gracile body form, and physiology, selected for endurance walking and more specifically -- endurance running.
 
WP..You are correct in your initial assumption. The purpose of a MTB as you guys refer to it, is an adaptation to enable the foot to grasp objects, to aid in climbing. Why it has been shown as bending upwards escapes me..Think of the foot as you would your own hand..The MTB corresponds to our knuckles..A Mid Carpal Break if you will.. This feature allows our hands to grip and grasp objects..Now whether an actual Bigfoot possess these MTB's is moot for now. Only when we have a body, complete with feet, to examine will this question be answered..
 
WP..You are correct in your initial assumption.

Not exactly. I was correct in my placement of the MTB, but not in the direction that this hinge bends. Go watch DC Pie Grande at 4:48. Meldrum shows the bend going in a direction that won't grip anything. Maybe Bigfoot hangs upside-down in trees and uses the MTB as a hook over the branches. You used to work in a zoo, and you probably know that fruit bats and sloths don't even use this technique.

Here is an exaggerated drawing of what Meldrum thinks the MTB does for Bigfoot. Red dot is the MTB joint...

e989dee6.jpg
 
Now reverse-engineer the actual feet but never allow that this could be produced by hoaxery. Do not talk about the potential for Patterson as a hoaxer, or at least only mention it as a remote possibility.

I have discovered over the years reading about UFOs, that many highly educated individuals think they can spot a hoax a mile away and can never be fooled. They underestimate hoaxers/con men. Part of the reason some people like to hoax things has nothing to do with money. They like to see if they can trick people into thinking something is real when it isn't. If they are smart (and many are), they may just let the hoax continue to see how many people are willing to believe it. Meanwhile, the smart guys with the degrees come up with all sorts of analysis on the hoax trying to prove the hoax was actually something real. The instant somebody feels they are too smart to be fooled by a hoax is the instant they open themselves up to be fooled by a hoax.

Krantz did the same thing with Cripplefoot. Well, hot diggety. We've got us an injured Bigfoot walking around. I'll just use my science degree to allow me to draw a bunch of broken (but healed) foot bones and fit those into the outline of the Cripplefoot track cast.

Daegling writes in his book "Bigfoot exposed" that it is next to impossible to figure bones out by a footprint. They are just producing wild guesses at best.
 
Such an upward bending motion serves no grasping purpose. Other than the extended
range of flexibility, as our own feet do (to a lesser degree). Now try mimicing that motion with your hands. Unless your a circus freak, you can't .. Reason: no advantage for the hands or feet to "hinge" this way. Down yes, Up, no. Patty's feet look to me like they are flat soled booties, unlike any feet I've ever seen...
 
I like Meldrum. I think he's neat. I think it'd be really fun to go camping with him. We'd have a hoot spooking the sillies out of each other. Oh jeez, We'd be saying "What's that??" and chucking pine cones at each other all night long. When it was time to sleep I'd ask him to tell me about sasquatch calcanial tendons. It'd be the best.

Meldrum says these wild zingers that I think I'll call 'Melders'. Like when he says of the MDF in his 'Sasquatch: Legend Meets Science' book...

The video depicts a dark figure with sure-footed stride, apparent breasts, and possibly an infant on its back, running for cover across a mountainside clearing.

Whoa! What a Melder! Are you Jeffin' me, cous'?

Here's some fun. Here's an article just full of Melders:

Author says evidence proves Bigfoot exists.

Personally, I'm quite sure Meldrum objected to the title of that article. Nevertheless, have a boo and pick your favourite Melder. Here's mine:

Meldrum said the earliest recorded story about Bigfoot is the "Epic of Gilgamsh." He said that story and "Beowulf" both have accounts of a hairy wild man, which he said could be early accounts of Bigfoot.
But this was really good, too:

"No history is without myth. No myth is without history," Meldrum said.
Goonie goo goo.
 
Last edited:
He related the idea of describing a giraffe to someone who didn't know about giraffe and how unbelievable that would seem.
.....Similarly, Bigfoot may seem far-fetched when all people hear are stories, he said.

He avoids the obvious fact, that we don't have to stop our speculation on the existence of giraffes with a description ..

What a Woo tactic ..
 
All this talk about an imaginary, large, hair biped is rather tiring, isn't it? Would the time be better spent painting or writing a novel?
 
All this talk about an imaginary, large, hair biped is rather tiring, isn't it? Would the time be better spent painting or writing a novel?

I'm already the postmodern Bigfoot skeptic. The question of Bigfoot is long since dead. It really had no life even when it was lively. Now the question I ask myself is: who do I make fun of, and how do I do it?
 
Last edited:
You can take your silly Thunderdome and stick it where the sun doesn’t shine. That’s nothing but an adolescent construct aimed at absolving you from the pretense of any actual intelligent and mature behavior. Grow up!
Is irony?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3565316#post3565316

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3565364#post3565364

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3568128#post3568128

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3570334#post3570334

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3571106#post3571106

BTW, I know it's just another of my nit-picks but in you signature you seem to be quoting INXS's 'Devil Inside', which I love. If that's the case, I think you should know Michael Hutchence and Andrew Farris did not write "Words are weapons, sharpen the knives!" It's "Words as weapons sharper than knives."

Here comes the woman
With the look in her eye
Raised on leather
With flesh on her mind
Words as weapons sharper than knives
Makes you wonder how the other half die
Other half die
I don't mean to be facetious, just it was kinda bugging me.

http://www.lyricsfreak.com/i/inxs/devil+inside_20067853.html
 
That's right. I forgot that one. All they have to do is find Gus and his family. He is married to a bigfoot and all his little ones are bigfeet. I used to have that on a recording somewhere.
And when Gus took them fishing they wouldn't use the poles. They'd just stick their heads in the water and come up with a fish in their mouths. Gus burned himself up real good. Aunt Bunny would fall down the stairs screamin' "Oh Jesus, Lord! Help me, oh Jesus Lord!"

:D:D:D
 
So, where is this Jeff to the Meld to the PhD stuff coming from? I got me a new meme.

It was only a matter of time before the evolution vs. creation war came to pop culture. I think Bigfooters are pretty much like the creationists. Hell, many of them are creationists.

Check it out. MC Dicky Dawkins.
 
Is irony?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3565316#post3565316

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3565364#post3565364

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3568128#post3568128

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3570334#post3570334

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3571106#post3571106

BTW, I know it's just another of my nit-picks but in you signature you seem to be quoting INXS's 'Devil Inside', which I love. If that's the case, I think you should know Michael Hutchence and Andrew Farris did not write "Words are weapons, sharpen the knives!" It's "Words as weapons sharper than knives."

I don't mean to be facetious, just it was kinda bugging me.

http://www.lyricsfreak.com/i/inxs/devil+inside_20067853.html

Always happy to be a thorn in your side. But I think Sir WIlliam is capable of defending himself. Or is he?
 
I remember reading that article when it first came out. And the two piece thing, I had mentioned in several notes that I used the two piece design for both Swamp Thing and the Arcane Monster he fights with. The two piece design works real well for suits which have a logical break at the pelvis or waist (like reptilian shingled scales)

I remembered. :) That's why I noted it was a bonus and used it in a response to Dfoot (seeing as how he's been discussing those types of costumes as of late). I didn't intend it as a rebuttal to you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom