Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
AMM:

"I remembered. That's why I noted it was a bonus and used it in a response to Dfoot (seeing as how he's been discussing those types of costumes as of late). I didn't intend it as a rebuttal to you."

I didn't take it as one, so we're cool.

Suits vary tremendously in design and practical usage. Studying the various alternatives gives one a better perspective on what's done and why.

:)

Bill
 
Always happy to be a thorn in your side. But I think Sir WIlliam is capable of defending himself. Or is he?
Occasional cause of mild amusement? Yes. Thorn in my side? Not so much.

I guess there would have to be something to defend against before I made the choice to defend WP or not. You have presented no such choice so I haven't had to think about it.

All that I have done is point out the irony of you accusing someone else of ducking out of a conversation and try to help you not butcher INXS.
 
Occasional cause of mild amusement? Yes. Thorn in my side? Not so much.

I guess there would have to be something to defend against before I made the choice to defend WP or not. You have presented no such choice so I haven't had to think about it.

All that I have done is point out the irony of you accusing someone else of ducking out of a conversation and try to help you not butcher INXS.

What conversation? Do you actually think that you have conversations with a veiw that's not toeing/towing your line?
About the song lyrics...damn you're anal!
 
Here is a segment from the Discovery Channel ‘ Best Evidence ‘, where Anthropologist Dr. Begin debunks the
MTB .. ( Warning ! large ..WMV file – Download it if you want to save it – I will be deleting it in the near future -.. )

http://www.gatzstuff.com/Video/MidTarsal.wmv

He points out that the human like, forward pointing, big toe and an MTB are ambiguous, and
physiologically incompatible. The human arch became rigid as the big toe aligned itself with the
other toes .. ( evolutionarily speaking )


As LTC8K6 would say, “ It’s a mid tarsal crock ..
Don't forget, the first time you read about it, it was right here, at JREF. With the quoting of an answer from Meldrum.
 
What conversation? Do you actually think that you have conversations with a veiw that's not toeing/towing your line?

Absolutely. Being a bigfoot proponent in no way means I'm going to be unable to carry on a normal conversation. Such things don't get me in a huff. It doesn't get any more complicated with each time I say it. You believe bigfoot is real, just that they aren't around anymore. You believe that this disappearance occurred in the early twentieth century. You also claim yourself to be a skeptic, that your opinion is not belief based. As a matter of course, people here such as myself will naturally want to know on what you base this position. All I have ever gotten from you in trying to seek that understanding are contrite attempts to duck the matter.

You know my opinion, my position. It is the one that is the most logical. I don't believe the creature described variously as bigfoot ever existed. This is based on an utter vacuum of reliable evidence. Very clearly when I look at bigfootery I can see the maintenance of social construct and a subculture. A self-perpetuating cult-like group. I have no status quo to maintain. If any member of this forum says something on the subject of the bigfootery phenomenom that I disagree with, I will voice that opinion regardless of whether it's you or RayG or whoever. I don't think there is an absence of evidence because Diogenes or tube said there is. I have concluded that after years and years of examining the claimed evidence myself. This is bigfootery. Every trail, every strand, every whiff of evidence turns to smoke. Pursue any line of inquiry into any claim of evidence and in every case, every time it comes to nothing in terms of reliability. You must agree with much of that considering for some odd reason you believe bigfoot is extinct.

I wonder about a person like you, log. Not a lot. Not to distraction. But when I read your posts I often wonder. I wonder what makes this person think bigfoot existed and went extinct. I wonder why this person consistently can't spell 'sasquatch'. It's not an insult, just a valid question. I wonder why would someone choose for themselves an Aesop-like handle yet get really flustered all the time when asked to substantiate their views. I wonder why a person would label themselves a skeptic and say that bigfoot doesn't exist but do very little to convey that position when playing Woods and Wildmen at a Bigfoot enthusiast website. That's just me, though.

I might have to review some exchanges you've had with Correa but so far from what I've gathered, you believe bigfoot to be some form or descendant of Homo erectus as opposed to the more favoured bigfoot enthusiast view regarding Gigantopithecus. I really would like to try and understand your thoughts on the matter but I have no hopes for you to be of any assistance. I'm only left with the impression that the nature of the position you hold on bigfoot is not as you describe.

About the song lyrics...damn you're anal!
That's fine but I don't think of it as being anal. If I thought a certain quote was worthy enough to used as a signature, I'd certainly want to make sure I got it right. I'd feel pretty silly if I didn't. I mean, "Words are weapons, sharpen the knives!" What does that even mean? Words are weapons and one should increase their potency? If I thought that way, if I had that sort of mentality, then I'm pretty sure that I would consider consistently atrocious spelling to be blunting my edge. I'd probably want to make judicious use of a spell-checker. Again, that's just me. I mean, it's Thunderdome, afterall.;)
 
Such an upward bending motion serves no grasping purpose. Other than the extended range of flexibility, as our own feet do (to a lesser degree). Now try mimicing that motion with your hands. Unless your a circus freak, you can't .. Reason: no advantage for the hands or feet to "hinge" this way. Down yes, Up, no. Patty's feet look to me like they are flat soled booties, unlike any feet I've ever seen...

I can imagine this BF MTB hinged as Meldrum speculates, to be of some advantage when walking up a steep incline. It could allow most of the foot (forward of the ankle) to remain in contact with the substrate while the body of the creature is perfectly upright. We accomplish something like this by using the ankle joint to bend the foot "upwards". It has limitations on how far (acutely) you can bend your ankle joint. If you are not conditioned for walking up a steep incline you can feel some stress or even pain in your Achille's tendon. It's probably no accident that some athletes will use running uphill as an easy form of training to strengthen the calf and foot muscles.

But that uphill walking advantage of the MTB may be mostly lost when the Bigfoot goes downhill. I'm just speculating and I certainly am not knowlegeable about foot mechanics. I also don't know if Meldrum thinks the MTB locks in a "horizontal" position - or if it is free to hinge downwards as well as upwards.

Because of their scientific qualifications, I think it would be informative and interesting to witness a live debate between Dr. Meldrum and Dr. Begun. Though both are featured in the DC Pie Grande program, they are not truly debating each other in any real sense. This is because of the DC production format, not because such a thing could or would not be possible.

Right now we are exploring and discussing the theory and design of this MTB like never before in this forum.
 
And when Gus took them fishing they wouldn't use the poles. They'd just stick their heads in the water and come up with a fish in their mouths. Gus burned himself up real good. Aunt Bunny would fall down the stairs screamin' "Oh Jesus, Lord! Help me, oh Jesus Lord!"

Hmmmm.....I was thinking that old Gus shaved a bigfoot and got it talk (according to Eddie's dad). That would have been sometime in the late 60s? Maybe...just maybe....we should stop calling the subject of the PGF "Patty" and start calling it "Bunny". After all, isn't the subject in the PGF female? Just a crazy thought.
 
Do Iowa, New Jersey, etc., bigfoots have limp little femme MTB's? You know, like the lack of some real rugged mountain terrain makes them kind of lame. Maybe they can't motor around enough bigfoot-style, diversify that gene pool so they get all three-toed, inbred, white, midgety, and freaky.

Mystery solved? It's gold, guys. Work with me. Use it on your websites, don't tell them where you got it.
 
Last edited:
Absolutely. Being a bigfoot proponent in no way means I'm going to be unable to carry on a normal conversation. Such things don't get me in a huff. It doesn't get any more complicated with each time I say it. You believe bigfoot is real, just that they aren't around anymore. You believe that this disappearance occurred in the early twentieth century. You also claim yourself to be a skeptic, that your opinion is not belief based. As a matter of course, people here such as myself will naturally want to know on what you base this position. All I have ever gotten from you in trying to seek that understanding are contrite attempts to duck the matter.

You know my opinion, my position. It is the one that is the most logical. I don't believe the creature described variously as bigfoot ever existed. This is based on an utter vacuum of reliable evidence. Very clearly when I look at bigfootery I can see the maintenance of social construct and a subculture. A self-perpetuating cult-like group. I have no status quo to maintain. If any member of this forum says something on the subject of the bigfootery phenomenom that I disagree with, I will voice that opinion regardless of whether it's you or RayG or whoever. I don't think there is an absence of evidence because Diogenes or tube said there is. I have concluded that after years and years of examining the claimed evidence myself. This is bigfootery. Every trail, every strand, every whiff of evidence turns to smoke. Pursue any line of inquiry into any claim of evidence and in every case, every time it comes to nothing in terms of reliability. You must agree with much of that considering for some odd reason you believe bigfoot is extinct.

I wonder about a person like you, log. Not a lot. Not to distraction. But when I read your posts I often wonder. I wonder what makes this person think bigfoot existed and went extinct. I wonder why this person consistently can't spell 'sasquatch'. It's not an insult, just a valid question. I wonder why would someone choose for themselves an Aesop-like handle yet get really flustered all the time when asked to substantiate their views. I wonder why a person would label themselves a skeptic and say that bigfoot doesn't exist but do very little to convey that position when playing Woods and Wildmen at a Bigfoot enthusiast website. That's just me, though.

I might have to review some exchanges you've had with Correa but so far from what I've gathered, you believe bigfoot to be some form or descendant of Homo erectus as opposed to the more favoured bigfoot enthusiast view regarding Gigantopithecus. I really would like to try and understand your thoughts on the matter but I have no hopes for you to be of any assistance. I'm only left with the impression that the nature of the position you hold on bigfoot is not as you describe.

That's fine but I don't think of it as being anal. If I thought a certain quote was worthy enough to used as a signature, I'd certainly want to make sure I got it right. I'd feel pretty silly if I didn't. I mean, "Words are weapons, sharpen the knives!" What does that even mean? Words are weapons and one should increase their potency? If I thought that way, if I had that sort of mentality, then I'm pretty sure that I would consider consistently atrocious spelling to be blunting my edge. I'd probably want to make judicious use of a spell-checker. Again, that's just me. I mean, it's Thunderdome, afterall.;)

It is more important the you undersdand your own thoughts about what gets discussed on this forum than troubling yourself trying to understand the thoughts of others. At this point in time I wouldn't be posting at all had Mr. Parcher not taken it upon himself to dictate how I should post on another forum. My views are not your views and as such will never be subject to anything except the standard boilerplate arguments and verbosity that this forum and you operate from.

"Words are weapons sharpen the knives." Clearly you don't understand the poetry and metaphor here. "Words are weapons", that is to say words have power and can do great harm and damage to one's opponents. "Sharpen the knives." which is to say hone your words, choose those that will penatrate and pierce to the heart of the matter, to the heart of the opponent, to the heart of the battle. Perhaps you've never heard of having a sharp tongue, or words that cut like a knife.
 
William P - I ran across a mention of the NEW YORK PARTY DeAtley and Patterson attended with the wigged Gimlin and publicity agent.

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/pursuit68.htm

Ivan Sanderson's June1968 article mentions Patterson calling him from New York while there with an agent and DeAtley.

Sanderson said the agent flew in from Hollywood to meet Roger and Al in New York. He then talks about how he made some phone calls and set up the BBC documentary with BBC producer Ronald Webster.

Chicago Films Inc. was hired to film Roger at his Bigfoot HQ for the BBC and that gave Roger and Al a documentary ready-made with their footage and interviews with scientists included. All they had to do was expand it with a tiny bit of extra DeAtley footage and other things to fill it out to a longer running time.

It would be great if someone could contact anyone previously connected with this film company and try to get hold of a copy of this.

It's interesting that Sanderson says Roger and DeAtley flew to Hollywood first to try to negotiate a deal for the film and the filming of a documentary of Roger on expedition. He says they spent seven weeks in Hollywood together working on this. I wonder if this was when they took Gimlin to Walter Hurst's office in Beverly Hills?

Hmmm Hopefully he didn't have to wear a wig in Los Angeles.
 
Last edited:
At this point in time I wouldn't be posting at all had Mr. Parcher not taken it upon himself to dictate how I should post on another forum. My views are not your views and as such will never be subject to anything except the standard boilerplate arguments and verbosity that this forum and you operate from.

The whiny victim role doesn't wear well on you. Don't characterize it as dictating how you post on BFF, think of it as a dare. I am daring you to go to BFF and broadcast your belief that Bigfoot went extinct. Tell them it happened during the 20th century. Answer them when they ask what decade or even quarter that this happened. Was it before 1958? 1967? Be prepared for a reversal of the burden of proof. Offer proof or good evidence that Bigfoot is now extinct. I dare you.

"Words are weapons sharpen the knives." Clearly you don't understand the poetry and metaphor here. "Words are weapons", that is to say words have power and can do great harm and damage to one's opponents. "Sharpen the knives." which is to say hone your words, choose those that will penatrate and pierce to the heart of the matter, to the heart of the opponent, to the heart of the battle. Perhaps you've never heard of having a sharp tongue, or words that cut like a knife.

Sounds like Thunderdome. I didn't know you were into that sort of thing.
 
The whiny victim role doesn't wear well on you. Don't characterize it as dictating how you post on BFF, think of it as a dare. I am daring you to go to BFF and broadcast your belief that Bigfoot went extinct. Tell them it happened during the 20th century. Answer them when they ask what decade or even quarter that this happened. Was it before 1958? 1967? Be prepared for a reversal of the burden of proof. Offer proof or good evidence that Bigfoot is now extinct. I dare you.



Sounds like Thunderdome. I didn't know you were into that sort of thing.

I have a better idea why don't you go to the BFF and state your position. Or why don't you go over to the BFF and state my position. As far as I'm concernd the debate for me is over. The only thing I'm interested in is getting to the bottom of the PGF and how it was actually accomplished.
 
I have a better idea why don't you go to the BFF and state your position. Or why don't you go over to the BFF and state my position. As far as I'm concernd the debate for me is over. The only thing I'm interested in is getting to the bottom of the PGF and how it was actually accomplished.

For those of you who don't know, whiney fits crow like a glove. Go read his posting history on BFF and see how he/she/it handles differing opinions. He once based his "evidence" on a few odd weekends he spent ----alledgedly---- in an rea over twenty five years ago. He has no basis for his claims inho.
 
The only thing I'm interested in is getting to the bottom of the PGF and how it was actually accomplished.

Trouble is, we can think whatever we want about any topic, but it does nothing to change reality. Do you have some actual arguments to support your assertion [bigfoot went extinct]?

You're starting to sound like the Monty Python Cheese Shop Sketch. Modified only slightly, it would go something like this:

(Everyone else walks in the door)

Everyone else: Good Morning.

Crowlogic: Good morning. Welcome to my Cheese Shop!

Everyone else: Ah, thank you, my good man.

Crowlogic: What can we do for you?

Everyone else: I want to buy some cheese.

Crowlogic: (lustily) Certainly. What would you like?

Everyone else: Well, eh, how about a slab of Gouda?

Crowlogic: I believe bigfoot went extinct prior to the turn of the century.

Everyone else: Pardon?

Crowlogic: I believe bigfoot went extinct prior to the turn of the century.

Everyone else: Ah, that's what I thought you said. Upon what do you base that belief?

Crowlogic: I thought you came into my shop to buy some cheese?

Everyone else: Ah yes, this IS a cheese shop, but you presented a very curious belief. We just wondered what it was based upon.

Crowlogic: Well, I believe bigfoot went extinct prior to the turn of the century.

Everyone else: Yes, we've heard that part, what evidence do you have to support that assertion?

Crowlogic: I have a huge variety of cheese here at my shop.

Everyone else: Right, but what about your belief that bigfoot went extinct?

Crowlogic: Look, did you come into my shop to buy some cheese or not?

Everyone else: Why yes, eventually we'll buy some, but you raised an interesting, but so far unsupported, assertion about bigfoot. Since we have an interest in bigfoot, we were hoping you'd discuss your assertion further. You know, satisfy our curiosity, so to speak.

Crowlogic: Look, this is a cheese shop, all I want to do is sell some cheese.

Everyone else: Yes, but YOU brought up your belief that bigfoot went extinct.

Crowlogic: That's because it's my belief bigfoot went extinct prior to the turn of the century.

Everyone else: Yes, we heard that. Repeatedly. You contintually refuse to elaborate on that statement.

Crowlogic: Look, are you going to buy some cheese or not?

Everyone else: Ummm, of course, that's why we stopped in. Now, what do you have for Gouda?

Crowlogic: I don't see what bigfoot has to do with buying cheese anyway.

Everyone else: Maybe you shouldn't have mentioned it then.

Crowlogic: Well, I do believe bigfoot went extinct prior to the turn of the century you know.

Everyone else: You certainly seem reluctant to explain why.

Crowlogic: (leans over the counter) You haven't asked me nicely.

Everyone else: Would it be worth it?

Crowlogic: Could be....

Everyone else: (smiling, and without a hint of anger or sarcasm) Please sir, have you got any evidence that bigfoot went extinct prior to the turn of the century?

Crowlogic: I thought we were discussing cheese.

Everyone else: Figures. Predictable, really I suppose. It was an act of purest optimism to have posed the question in the first place. Tell me:

Crowlogic: Yessir?

Everyone else: (deliberately) Have you in fact got any intention of supporting your assertion with some valid arguments?

Crowlogic: Yes.

Everyone else: Really?

(pause)

Crowlogic: No. Not really. I was deliberately wasting your time.

Everyone else: Really?

Crowlogic: No, I've got some wonderful cheese, here, have a look.

Repeat as necessary...

RayG
 
I must submit an apology for the above 'Cheese Shop' post. While it may seem like Crowlogic has not provided reasonable arguments in favor of bigfoot extinction, she has at least listed her reasons why she feels they have gone extinct.

Had I searched for information [aligned my ducks if you will], prior to posting, I would have found her listing. I truly do not remember her posting that, nor any responses I may have made to it.

Crow, I apologize for ridiculing your perceived lack of explanation on your position, when you had already done so. I don't agree with that position, but I had no business ridiculing it.

RayG
 
For those of you who don't know, whiney fits crow like a glove. Go read his posting history on BFF and see how he/she/it handles differing opinions. He once based his "evidence" on a few odd weekends he spent ----alledgedly---- in an rea over twenty five years ago. He has no basis for his claims inho.

Those "few odd" weekends were two years worth of not odd weekends but weeks at a time in the field collecting environmental data. Specifically rain and standing water Ph. I've detailed this in other posts. But Mikeyx as Buggs would say "what a maroon" you don't know what you're talking about. But I see the "gang" has circled the wagons.
 
I must submit an apology for the above 'Cheese Shop' post. While it may seem like Crowlogic has not provided reasonable arguments in favor of bigfoot extinction, she has at least listed her reasons why she feels they have gone extinct.

Had I searched for information [aligned my ducks if you will], prior to posting, I would have found her listing. I truly do not remember her posting that, nor any responses I may have made to it.

Crow, I apologize for ridiculing your perceived lack of explanation on your position, when you had already done so. I don't agree with that position, but I had no business ridiculing it.

RayG

Ray apology accepted. Sorry you had to go to the trouble of making the cheese shop post. But it was pretty good!
 
Last edited:
To be proven extinct shouldn't they have been proven to have existed in the first place??

I mean one could go nuts with that logic and list all sorts of mythical creatures than claim they went extinct...unicorns,minotaurs,orcs...the kraken.

Godzilla once existed but sadly he and his kind went extinct before we could prove he even existed.

Seems to me even Bigfoot Nation would call shenanigans on that line of thinking....so keeping it hush hush while posting over at the old Bigfeet Think Tank is probably the best course of action really.
 
Post 376 in this BFF thread makes some interesting comments regarding special effects and the P/G film. Here's a quote from it that I finds especially interesting:

(Dmitri Bayanov @ email to many Bigfooters, May 22, 2004)
How can you … ignore Janos Prohaska, the Disney Studios stunt man and maker of ape suits, who told John Green, back in 1969, that “it could not be a padded suit like his gorilla suits, it would have to be skin tight to show muscle movement as it did.” (SASQUATCH, 1978, p. 129)

At the bottom on this thread (it should be on page 4), it's claimed that Bob H. got the "Patty gait" as the result of getting hit by a car in 1968.

In this Cryptomundo update, we get a discussion of Patterson, artwork, and female Sasquatches. For some odd reason, Loren Coleman seems to imply that Kunsler copied someone else's artwork.

Coleman said:
"The above drawing of the William Roe encounter’s Sasquatch was used to illustrate Ivan T. Sanderson’s men’s magazine article detailing Roe’s sighting. From the initials of the artist in the right hand corner, they do not appear to match Morton Kunstler’s."

Gosh, what could the initials "R.P." stand for? "Roger Patterson?" Funny how Sanderson credits Kunsler for the illustration for what appears to be his article on the Roe encounter here. Oh, and it seems that Sports Afield used Kunsler artwork for another one of their Bigfoot-related articles.

Getting back to the Sanderson commentary, his claim that that the accusations of the Kunsler drawing not looking "exactly like" Patty not standing up can be considered technically correct. It doesn't look exactly what I'd imagine a drawing of Patty to look like. Then again, it's not like I've ever seen any Patterson artwork depicting what he filmed and it's silly for me to expect artwork to look exactly the way I'd imagine something to look. I will say that it shares several similarities to Patty, though. It certainly shows that Patterson was familiar with features seen on Patty and could've designed a costume with those features in mind. Also, it's not like concept art for movie monsters always matches up with what's seen onscreen, either.

Gosh, and why show a copy of Patterson's Bigfoot statue when a picture of the real deal has been linked to on Cryptomundo in the past...

By the way, some contact information for a Chicago Films, Inc. is given at these sites. I don't know if that company is the same one that Dfoot was talking about, though.

Speaking of film companies, it seems that this company made some fake Bigfoot films that've fooled some people. The hair seems like Patty's, length-wise, so studying it could be handy in discussions of the P/G film.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom