Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm hesitant to agree that he locates the hinge there. His "X-ray" skeletal view shows a nearly identical BF and human bones. All bones are more robust with BF, but besides that the only apparent difference is the location of the forward hinge (our ball). That hinge is located a bit farther back as compared to humans.

Is there an animated depiction of the MTB in action on LMS (or any program)?
 
These feet seem to be acting the same...

84236e5d.jpg
9e1264aa.jpg
 
This is somewhat exaggerated to illustrate... but is this what a double-hinged foot could do? Red dots are the hinges. Does this drawing show both an "activated" MTB and a ball hinge?

37f995a6.jpg
 
Last edited:
WP, I would have to agree that Meldrum's illustration has the hinge in the ball of the sasquatch foot. He has the foot bending in the same places the human foot bends. At the toe joints, and at the first foot joint.

I see no upward bend of the middle of the foot, and no way for the illustrated foot to make the Laverty print.
 
Crow, you don't seem very vocal about that when you post on BFF. Sweaty is the only actively posting BF believer on this forum. I was counting you as one also, but you now seem to want to clarify that you are significantly skeptical of a modern living Bigfoot. Maybe you could turn some heads if you bring that argument to BFF. Give 'em a big dose of crow logic.

Let me get this straight. You're dictating how I should be conducting myself on another forum? Well who do you think you are? You gotta damn gall!
 
Last edited:
WP, I would have to agree that Meldrum's illustration has the hinge in the ball of the sasquatch foot. He has the foot bending in the same places the human foot bends. At the toe joints, and at the first foot joint.

When Meldrum illustrates the BF foot bones he assumes that they are basically the same as a human. The only significant difference is that he locates the tarsal joint further back (away from the toes) on the BF as compared to the human. He does not illustrate that other joint (just in front of the ankle) doing any flexing. If that other joint is really the location of the so-called "mid-tarsal break", then he certainly hasn't shown its peculiar and significant action by way of graphic illustration.

Is the Bigfoot MTB the reason why there is a big and obvious sand ridge in the middle of the famous (Laverty pic) Patty footprint? Well, I think many Bigfooters and BF skeptics think so. Almost everyone is at a point where they call that mound of sand in the print "the mid-tarsal break". Any other BF print that has such a mound is also referred to as a MTB print. How did we get to that point?

What is so special about a Bigfoot foot that causes that big ridge to form in the footprint? Why doesn't it always show up, or at least show up often in purported BF tracks? Why can a bare human foot walking in moist sand produce the same ridge when we have no MTB? What the hell is going on here?

It seems that the underlying biological theory of BF's MTB is that it is a special evolutionary adaptation for a primate biped walking around in rugged terrain. OK. So what exactly is this MTB, and how does BF make it work for himself? I can walk barefoot on rugged and inclined terrain pretty decently. If I had thick sole callouses I could do much better. But Bigfoot has this MTB, which is supposed to make traversing that same situation a more straightforward and economical approach. Apparently, the MTB is key, but I can't figure it out.

Is a Bigfoot foot supposed to grip the earthly substrate in the same evolutionarily adaptive sense as a chimpanzee foot grips a tree branch? Is that what Meldrum is trying to say?

I see no upward bend of the middle of the foot, and no way for the illustrated foot to make the Laverty print.

Upward bend? Dude, I have always been thinking that the MTB allowed the foot to bend downwards. Bigfoot grabs the substrate with its foot. That's what I thought is proposed to be going on.
 
Let me get this straight. You're dictating how I should be conducting myself on another forum? Well who do you think you are? You gotta damn gall!

LOL. Remember where you are. This is Thunderdome. Maybe you could find a skeptic here to take you under their wing and help you get to the weapons. Try to use the logic that crows have.
 
I'm hesitant to agree that he locates the hinge there. His "X-ray" skeletal view shows a nearly identical BF and human bones. All bones are more robust with BF, but besides that the only apparent difference is the location of the forward hinge (our ball). That hinge is located a bit farther back as compared to humans.

Is there an animated depiction of the MTB in action on LMS (or any program)?

There is the Discovery Channel episode of ' Best Evidence ' with Meldrum in person, holding that cast, and talking about that depression being the mid tarsal break .

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcYK2_1pSL0&feature=related

This is the Spanish version.. Couldn't find the English one..

Look at 2/6 for Meldrum and the MTB ..
 
Last edited:
LOL. Remember where you are. This is Thunderdome. Maybe you could find a skeptic here to take you under their wing and help you get to the weapons. Try to use the logic that crows have.


You can take your silly Thunderdome and stick it where the sun doesn’t shine. That’s nothing but an adolescent construct aimed at absolving you from the pretense of any actual intelligent and mature behavior. Grow up!
 
Anyway, here's a link if that doesn't work -
http://youtube.com/watch?v=AQlPAFV6yaI

No time to make a diagram of how Patty worked right now. But watching the little video should give anyone with half a chimp's brain a fair idea about it. I'll do a detailed thing at a later date.

I have some suggestions for your reponse to the Georgia bigfoot team. You might want to mention tube's website, as I've noted that some people on Youtube don't have any knowledge of his experiments with casting artifacts. I also see that the "team" is arguing that the so-called dermals in the track can't be dessication ridges since they're made in soil. You might weant to point out that using a plaster cast with dessication ridges (or more ideally, a mold made from the cast using a more durable material) pressed into soil could create a track with "dermal ridges." Then again, a big rubber costume foot with "dermals" on it could have the same effect.

Also, there's a non-dessication explanation for the "dermals" in the Skookum cast. Than again, desertyeti also said that one could get dermals in dried mud...

How about Gimlin and Patterson's cowboy buddies? They just sat around and joked about it. How could they keep such a huge secret all these years?

Could you go into more detail on this? I know that Bob H. obviously joked around about the film, but I also know that a friend of Patterson's named Buddy Knox bought the film hook, line, and sinker.

LAST NIGHT I was working with a well known actor when one of the stunt guys brought in a Marvel comic. They had used stills of the actor's face to draw their superhero character. The actor wanted to call his lawyer. I told him that would be useless and only cost him money.

They don't say it's him. It's slightly changed. But the whole crew identified him right away in the pics. It was his face from another movie. He called his lawyer from the set. His lawyer told him to forget it. He would get nowhere with a suit. Good advice.

The guy behind the comic book art is Greg Land, who is pretty infamous for tracing pictures of celebrities (and porn). You can read more about him here. Also, the whole Greg Land issue reminds me of this.

If I was that actor, I'd tip off the Karloff estate that Land has been tracing pictures of Boris Karloff in mummy makeup as one of his villains and let them take care of that sleazeball. I've heard they're pretty tenacious when it comes to lawsuits. Even if they couldn't win, the sheer hassle might make Marvel crack down on Land.

As for the question someone raised about Wah not wanting to give his mask to "competition" like Chambers or anyone else --- That is just wrong.

I could be wrong, but I took his original comment as meaning that whoever bought the suit could compete with Janos Prohaska as another performer with his own costume, not that Wah would've feared that Chambers would compete with him.

As a bonus of sorts, here's a page from a 1971 issue of TV Guide showing the construction of a two piece "wetsuit" type monster costume for "Night Gallery." Here's where I found it.
 
Last edited:
Is the Bigfoot MTB the reason why there is a big and obvious sand ridge in the middle of the famous (Laverty pic) Patty footprint?

According to someone at the BFF, the old explanation was that Patty had stepped on a branch.

Almost everyone is at a point where they call that mound of sand in the print "the mid-tarsal break". Any other BF print that has such a mound is also referred to as a MTB print. How did we get to that point?

I suspect that it's done to provide a common reference/ground, similar to how some skeptics use the term "Patty" to refer to the subject of the P/G film(although I do partly because I know that Hollywood monster costumes sometimes have nicknames).

Some out there might be tempted to think that since nobody had claimed Bigfoot had midtarsal breaks around the time of the P/G film, then a hoaxer would not think to fake such a thing. While not technically true (a hoaxer who knew about ape feet could be inspired to apply that to footprints of the infamous ape-man that is Bigfoot), I'd be more inclined to argue that such a feature could've been unintentionally faked. Here are all the skeptical explanations that I can remember for "mid tarsal breaks":

-Flawed attempt at faking a heel lift-off.

-The result of using a semirigid fake foot. (Go here for more on the subject).

-The result of a hinged foot.

-The imprint of the arch of a human foot in the middle of a large rubber foot.

-A result of a hoaxer trying to do an exaggerated stride.

-Accidentally created due to how the rigid fake foot was applied to the soil.

-Issue with the substrate when stepped on.

-Created by overlaid animal tracks (This obviously doesn't apply to the Laverty photos.)

I should note that I only provided the links that I had handy when I was typing this, so my apologies to anyone who feels left out because I didn't link to their theory.

Also, this provides some excellent questions about the validity of the midtarsal break explanation.

What is so special about a Bigfoot foot that causes that big ridge to form in the footprint? Why doesn't it always show up, or at least show up often in purported BF tracks? Why can a bare human foot walking in moist sand produce the same ridge when we have no MTB?

Aside from the track seen in the Laverty photo, the examples of "bigfoot" tracks showing signs of a midtarsal break have me leaning towards "overlaid animal (most likely bear) tracks"

As for the barefoot human issue, I know of at least one person who'd argue that they aren't the same as the supposed midtarsal breaks.

Is a Bigfoot foot supposed to grip the earthly substrate in the same evolutionarily adaptive sense as a chimpanzee foot grips a tree branch? Is that what Meldrum is trying to say?

I seem to vaguely remember LAL saying that it'd be handy for young Sasquatches while they climb trees.
 
Last edited:
WP, I see a human -type foot moving like one in the PGF. I have no idea why Meldrum felt the need to invent the MTB.

The beginning of Patty3.mov is illustrative.

I cannot reconcile Meldrum's ideas and illustrations with the prints and what I see.

There is no way the Laverty print was made the way Meldrum explains, imo.

Human foot, imo:

 
Upward bend? Dude, I have always been thinking that the MTB allowed the foot to bend downwards. Bigfoot grabs the substrate with its foot. That's what I thought is proposed to be going on.

I always thought he could "grab" a tree branch, ie, the middle of the foot can bend upwards. That is, partially wrap the foot around the branch by bending the foot in the middle. Sort of like our arch, except it's a flexible arch.
 
AMM:

"I could be wrong, but I took his original comment as meaning that whoever bought the suit could compete with Janos Prohaska as another performer with his own costume, not that Wah would've feared that Chambers would compete with him."

You are correct. That was what I was suggesting.


"As a bonus of sorts, here's a page from a 1971 issue of TV Guide showing the construction of a two piece "wetsuit" type monster costume for "Night Gallery." Here's where I found it."


I remember reading that article when it first came out. And the two piece thing, I had mentioned in several notes that I used the two piece design for both Swamp Thing and the Arcane Monster he fights with. The two piece design works real well for suits which have a logical break at the pelvis or waist (like reptilian shingled scales)

Bill
 
I have some suggestions for your reponse to the Georgia bigfoot team. You might want to mention tube's website, as I've noted that some people on Youtube don't have any knowledge of his experiments with casting artifacts. I also see that the "team" is arguing that the so-called dermals in the track can't be dessication ridges since they're made in soil. You might weant to point out that using a plaster cast with dessication ridges (or more ideally, a mold made from the cast using a more durable material) pressed into soil could create a track with "dermal ridges." Then again, a big rubber costume foot with "dermals" on it could have the same effect.

The video that DFoot is responding to is this one:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-_9g8c6YKTg&feature=related

I admit, the thing had me going for a while, but I'm pretty sure this is a parody. This makes Dfoot a big meanie-head for debunking a parody!
 
tube -- That team is from my home state and they are as serious as Tom Biscardi when it comes to their Bigfoot activities. They want you to believe them, but I have a hard time making their "Patty" image match up with the actual photo. Seems someone has overlayed an image there to make things more interesting. That's my take on it. Hey... Tom couldn't have done it better.:p

ATOMIC MM -- Here's a quick video of Janos and his son Robert wearing bear suit rubber feet that bend much like the Patty feet. Same color too. Their bear feet were custom made to fit their own little feet, unlike the over-sized clownish feet of Patty's meant to fit anyone.

http://s295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/?action=view&current=RUBBERJANOSFEET.flv

It's so mind-numbingly simple. I just cannot get over this whole "dermal ridge" mess. Seems like every decade someone comes up with something new based on an accident with the suit, or a track making goof, or even film grain. Astounding to watch it happen and watch the emotions that flare up when anyone points out the absurdity of it.

Bill Munns -- You're welcome. I do know that Janos was mad at a certain young man who had DON POST make a gorilla suit for him. Janos felt that those jobs should be for real stuntmen like himself. He didn't like it when the kid got a job over him because he was taller.

But as for Wah and Chambers, they hired Janos and each other. They had no problems working together for years. Wah was more into his props, stop-motion and camera fx than make-up, but he did suits too. Chambers was, of course, the make-up master. Janos was a decent maker of goofy suits and had some good bear suits for the time too. No jealousy among them at all.

TO ANY BIGFOOTER: Just try on a pair of rubber feet like those I show in the above video. You should be able to duplicate Heironimus'... I mean "Patty's" bend in the foot easily. Unless you plan on pulling a Green and going into denial mode you should figure this one out.

I think I'll just keep posting little irritating videos as time goes by and turn that YOUTUBE channel I opened up into a Patty-bashing site.:cool: At least it'll give people another side of the story.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom