Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
The lines I was talking about are the famous "diaper butt" lines often described here as well as over there (BFF), plus the thigh line.

Ah, so we're on the same page. I've noticed that I get similar lines when I wear boxer briefs under a pair of long johns. Perhaps a similar type of clothing worn under a suit could produce the same effect? My only other guess at the moment is that something like hip waders (aka "hip boots") worn under a suit could produce the effect. I know there are many styles of hip waders, so I'll note that I think this kind would produce the best effect. However, I know that there are other styles of hip waders and I'm not sure what was available in the 60's.

The big question would be why such items would be worn under the suit. For the "boxer briefs" angle, perhaps it was done in an attempt to keep cool under the suit, to allow for easier movement, or because the mime was originally wearing pants that didn't look good under/didn't fit into the costume. From the hip waders angle, it could be an attempt to mimic muscle movement or an attempt at doing a less expensive version of the "wetsuit" type of undersuit that Dfoot was talking about.

Obviously it can be done, my observation from my experience was that it's uncommon or rarely done.

Ah, okay. I was under the impression from your comments during the show that you had never heard of anything like that before.

I don't personally endorse the Patty reconstructions that show a nose. Could be like that, but I don't get that impression from what I see in some of the more profile frames of Patty's face in the film.

I was talking about stills from the film, but I understand your point.

The reconstructions, however, were done without any consideration of resemblance to Patty. I just intrepreted the skull as I thought it might look, and the nose is the most guesswork for anybody's fossil species reconstruction, so don't get locked into anybody's nose on any prehistoric figure. The nose is always pure guess, nothing more.

No worries, I was just piggybacking off of Drewbot's comparing/contrasting Patty to the reconstructions. Personally, I don't think any of them look anything like the subject of the P/G film, so the idea that you were basing them off Patty hadn't crossed my mind. As for the noses, I remember your comments about cartilage from the podcast :) (I especially liked the "bonobo nose" comment). I had mistakenly thought that since you didn't make a similar comment about the lack of a "bald patch" on the reconstructions, we were acting as if the facial features were "set in stone" for the sake of discussion.

That link leads to some earlier Peking Man reconstructions done by scientific artists in the past. Same basic skull, slightly different artist intrepretations of how he's fleshed out.

Well, that photo collage only showed one Peking Man reconstruction (the bolack and white picture). The picture sandwiched between than and the Patty picture was of a Bigfoot sculpture done by Roger Patterson. Don't worry, I'm not trying to tear you from your focus of what's on the film/how it applies to costume effects of the time. It's just one of my usual asides of something that I think is interesting/somewhat related to an issue brought up here.
 
AMM:

Sometimes when I make a remark about what I've seen, of what I've experienced, it might help to know this about me.

There's a classic si-fi book, "Stranger in a Strage land" (highly recommended, by the way) but in it, there's a description of a person trained as a "Public Witness". The example for this person's training is that if you stand with this person on the sidewalk of a residentual neighborhood, and look at a house, and ask this "Public Witness" what color is the house, the witness will NOT say "the house is white". The witness might say "the sides of the house I see are white" (meaning the witness will not presume the sides of the house on the back sides are also white, even if that is common or expected by most people). The witness is trained to say exactly and specifically what he or she actually sees, knows, or can verify.

Well I tend to think that way, I try to answer people as much as I know things to be. I try to stay away from absolutes, but qualify my remarks with "rarely" (an opinion) or "as far as I know", or similar qualifiers.

The film industry is an incredibly diverse place, and I doubt if any one person even knows 1% of the people or what's going on. So all we can do is offer thoughts, opinions, or appraisals of what we know, from our perspective.

I say this in advance of the expectation Dfoot is preparing a lengthy explanation of why I'm so wrong about my industry comments of the last few days here, but the indusrtry really is a tremendously varied place with many practices and conflicting realities.

he sees things one way, from his perspective. I see things differently, from my perspective. Those perspectives do clash (apparently often), and you, who are trying to understand in good faith, are left to try and sort it all out, like "who's right and who's wrong?".

If i don't know things with a factual certainty, I try to explain what I know about presumptions of regularity, and I do try to qualify my opinions in more relative terms. But the world seems to have come to expect more absolute and unequivical answers with no ambiguity or relative flexbility. More "political" for lack of a better word.

All I can do is answer in good faith as I think the answer should be, and you are, of course welcome to seek out answers from others, or, ideally, do your own research and form your own conclusions from that totality of information you have gathered.

And if you want to tell me I'm wrong, I'll never be offended. I'll listen to why you think so, and try to respond thoughtfully and respectfully, as much as I can.

Bill
 
Yes, Sweaty seems to have the burden of proof bass ackwards.

RayG

Yeah I'll say he does. Of course this seems to be standard practice among the Bigfoot Nation rank-n-file....if memory serves Fuddster did the same thing like 200 pages ago or so....he defied me to prove that he DIDN'T see a set of feetprints....at least I think it was him...anyhoo...this switching the burden of proof is basically.... Intro to Bigfoot Fan 101.

What's peaking my interest is this Robo-Skeptic business that Sweaty keeps falling back on....now that's some good stuff...because skeptics demand more than grainy video and plaster feetprint casts...we're the robots??

Hahahahahahhaha...what a joke.
 
A "public witness" would have to be very vague indeed about the subject of the PGF.

Indeed,something along the lines of...

I see something that may or may not be a real creature walking across what appears to be a wooded area.
 
I'm no Robo-skeptic. I tell you there are fierce living Dinosaur superpredators. Prove it ain't so. Big hairy monkeys are lame-o. Thunderlizards are where the action is.
Forget Rear Admiral Koolaid and his Mylantasoreass Sux. Thunderlizards are for faeries. Punchy's gonna open up a can of Hawaian Punch.

The big money is on the Boss of the Woods/Extra-terrestrial 1-2 tag team tornado. You see, brothers, I'm out of the darkness. I've seen the light. Correction - lights. Lights in the sky with bigfoots coming out of them. I was skeptic, a deniar, a gainsayer of the knowledge of bigfoot from beyond. Beckjord could not show me the way. Burgstahler could not show me the way. No, brothers. Not even PIGI alien bigfoot guy could show me the way.

It was Sweaty who set me free and showed me I could not see the forest for the trees. He showed me I could not see the bigfoot in the forest for the trees that were in the forest where bigfoot was. Brothers, my mind was closed and Sweaty opened it wide to the stars. My mind is so open now, you could get lost in all the space in my mind which is open. He taught me how to leap and then to fly.

This is how it came to be, brothers. First I saw the bigfoot evidence. I saw PGF. I saw MDF. I heard the word of Joyce. Then I saw the Martian civilization images, straight from The Sweat. I knew the bigfoot/UFO reports but still I doubted. I knew the Beckjord, I knew the Burg, but still I doubted. Then I saw the Patty sculpture on Mars... MOVEMENT! We've got movement, people! Finally, Sweaty showed me the STS-48 Shuttle Mission truth and the deal was sealed.

But, wait. Sweaty taught me to leap, to fly, but could he fly with me? Could he connect the dots as I have? The evidence for bigfoot is there and it is strong. The evidence for UFOs is there and it is strong. The evidence for Martian civilization is there and it is strong. The Sweat showed these things to me. The Patty figure on Mars is there. The bigfoot/UFO reports are there. Is it really such a big leap? Don't fear to spread your wings, Sweaty. Fly with me!

http://www.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/story/0,22049,23100228-5012895,00.html
 
Correa Neto wrote:


This would be 'proof positive'.
It's not relevant to what would constitute "reliable evidence...short of proof".
Sweaty, we are discussing evidence reliability leves, actually. This


There have been reported samples of hair DNA.
You don't accept them as "reliable" evidence only because they don't rise to the level of "proof" of Bigfoot's existence.
Despite not being "proof"....they are evidence of such a creature.
Sweaty, lets go by parts.

First part: Could you please tell us how a DNA sample degradated to the point of providing only a "mammal" signature can be considered reliable evidence? Could you please tell us how a DNA sample degradated and suspected of being contaminated by human DNA ca be considered reliable evidence?
Lets assume bigfeet are from the gigantopithecus genus for the sake of our discussion. A reliable DNA sample assay result would be something like:
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Mammalia
Order: Primates
Family: Hominidae
Subfamily: Ponginae
Genus: UNKNOWN
Got some like this?
Not that I'm aware of.

Part two: Regarding the
You don't accept them as "reliable" evidence only because they don't rise to the level of "proof" of Bigfoot's existence.
line, sorry, it makes no sense. I do not accept them because they are too degraded and/or were contaminated, so they fail to provide a good result. There are quite a large number of species of mammals around, after all... One of them, which happens to collect and assay DNA samples is a primate, BTW.

There are already fossils of a "Bigfoot-like primate"...Ginganto.

If one VERY LARGE species of upright-walking primate existed in the past...then it's no big leap to think a 2nd species, or maybe even a descendant of it, existed, or exists today.
By parts, again, Sweaty.

Part one- I'll be bolder than you. There are several extinct species which would qualify as bigfoot template. They belong to the Homo, Gigantopithecus and Australopithecus genus. Happy? Now, time for the cold shower. There are no evidences that any of these species (except for H. sapiens) ever set a foot at the Americas. No bones, no ichnofossils, nothing. So, no reliable evidence for bigfeet here.

Part two- Given the lack of evidence poinint to the presence of these species, not only in North America but also somewhere near the land bridge, it is indeed a big leap to say they crossed the bridge and are still living at this side. Is sheer speculation, its a leap of faith.


As for any footage....it would only carry a lot of weight based on what is seen in the footage itself.....rather than carrying a lot of weight based on 'who took the footage'.
Nonsense. Reliability of the source is a key factor when it comes to evaluating evidence.

We have, at least, 2 potential Bigfoot videos in existence today....the PG film and the Memorial Day Video.
...snip...
Nope.
You have nothing. Both are suspected of being hoaxes (intentional or not in MDF). MDF shows nothing but a blob. None of them have relatively good quality, were obtained by individuals whose reputation would be ruined if caught somehow involved in a hoax. They were not obtained at the same place by unrelated teams.[/QUOTE]

It's the lack of ability of skeptics here to assign any weight (probability) to a piece of evidence that I'm refering to when I poke fun at them...calling them 'Robo-Skeptics' ;).
Sweaty, we do assign weights... Unfortunately for you, the "weight" the "relevance", in other words, the reliability of the evidence you presented is too close to zero.

Do I need to remind you of the footerbots?

You're all simply taking a "black and white" view ("proof" or "nothing") of the evidence...when, in actual fact...."evidence" requires a "gray" view (degrees of likelihood, or probability) to see, understand, and weigh it properly.
See above.
In my opinion, you are overestimating the value of your evidence and arguments. You try to show we are underestimating it all. But so far, you presented nothing substantial to back your position. Quite often it seems you are being backed by faith, by belief; its not critical thinking.
 
Kitikaze-
Does this mean you are going to bring the converted 'Footer-mobile' out of mothballs?

Also- Remembering back to Darkwing's encounter, in which the propane tanks were removed from the back of his truck by bigfoots, does this mean that Alien craft are fueled by LP?

Bill-
Just to clarify, you realize that the three photos in this progression, the middle one was created by Roger Patterson before the PGF footage was obtained? And he had never admitted to seeing one pre-PGF.

Also- Does the fact that shooting for POTA wrapped in August mean that Chambers would have more free time in the weeks before October to devote to costume building?
 
Last edited:
Kitikaze-
Does this mean you are going to bring the converted 'Footer-mobile' out of mothballs?

The Mobile Observatory for Hominids In Recluse (M.O.H.A.I.R.), or Susan, as I called her, shall ride again! I have decided to rechristen her. Susan will now be formally known as the Stealthy Hominid Ape Tracking and Navigational Equipped Ranger (S.H.A.T.N.E.R). Since Susan was sold I will have to convert my SUV (a WWII era military postal jeep that I bought from a military base here in Japan). I think we'll call her Majel.

For call blasting, instead of loud sobbing and verses by legendary Tang Dynasty poet Fenggan (AKA Big Stick), I think I shall employ Druidic chants of solstice such as were used in ancient times at Avebury, Silbury Hill, and Stonehenge and possibly some early works of Brian Eno and Mike Oldfield interspersed with the mating songs of humpback whales.

I think I shall equip Majel with some compact high-powered satellite dishes, EMP protection, triple-layered aluminum foil interior lining, and a Roland Juno-106 Synthesizer and large LCD display for impromptu communication.

It will be much better then that Magical Mystery Tour bus that I think Sweaty has.

Also- Remembering back to Darkwing's encounter, in which the propane tanks were removed from the back of his truck by bigfoots, does this mean that Alien craft are fueled by LP?
I believe that liquid propane for bigfoots may be not unlike Zima for us. You know, zomething different.
 
Last edited:
I thought this to be an appropriate counter to all of the experts that seem to be claiming Patty to be real as of late.

f) Dr. William Montagna, the director of the federal primate center at Beaverton, Oregon, writing in Primate News, September, 1976 says:

Along with some colleagues, I had the dubious distinction of being among the first to view this few-second-long bit of foolishness. As I sat watching the hazy outlines of a big, black, hairy man-ape taking long, deliberate human strides, I blushed for those scientists who spent unconscionable amounts of time analyzing the dynamics, and angulation of the gait and the shape of the animal, only to conclude (cautiously, mind you) that they could not decide what it was. For real or woe, I am neither modest about my scientific adroitness nor cautious about my convictions.

Stated simply, Patterson and friends perpetrated a hoax. As the gait, erect body, and swing of the arms attest, their Sasquatch was a large man in a poorly made monkey suit. Even a schoolchild would not be taken in. The crowning irony was Patterson's touch of glamor: making his monster into a female with large pendulous breasts. If Patterson had done his homework, he would have known that regardless of how hirsute an animal is, its mammary glands are always covered with such short hairs as to appear naked.

To believers who complain that we scientists are too opinionated to look at the evidence, I reply: Is a scientist to listen to every zealot who regales him with tales of a putrid stench, who shows him fake footprints, or makes films of a man wearing a badly tailored monkey suit? The scientist who is reviled because he won't listen to fantasy goes securely on his way, knowing that life is so full of real wonderment and mystery that he does not have to fantasize.

But perhaps I ought to add that man's need to fantasize is a vestigial remnant of his past. It created mythological characters, good and evil; visions of miraculous events, heaven, purgatory and hell. It created the oracles, the art of palmistry, phrenology, astrology and all sorts of other occult sciences. And finally, it peopled man's world with monsters.

Taken from this general bigfoot website
http://home.nycap.rr.com/wwilliams/... scientists get involved in Bigfoot research?
 
Nice post of Dr. Montagna Drewbot and is typical I have heard scientists say when confronted with paranormal claims. I recall hearing an astronomer state that if he thought UFOs were real alien craft, he would drop all his studies right away and pursue the pheonomena to it's logical conclusion. However, he felt the evidence was so poor that he doubted there was a signal lying in the noise and was not going to waste his time. One can say the same for Bigfoot. If there was a reasonable possibility that bigfoot did exist, it would have been found because all the anthropologists/zoologists/etc. would be tripping over each other trying to locate him. My guess is that there probably numerous grants and studies by NG in an attempt to find him. They certainly would not be hanging CDs/wind chimes from tree limbs in order to entice bigfoot to show up. Despite claims to the contrary, the evidence is not that good and not very compelling at all.
 
Despite claims to the contrary, the evidence is not that good and not very compelling at all.

This statement could be misleading because it can suggest that we actually have secondary evidence of Bigfoot but it just isn't high-quality. I'm willing to say something more. The secondary evidences we have are almost entirely intentional fakes. The only exceptions to that would be errors like plaster-casted bear oversteps, hair and DNA from known animals, photos and footage of known animals, etc. Those are not intentional hoaxes or fakes per se - but how they are presented or interpreted can sometimes become a hoax in itself.

The easiest intentional hoax to perpetrate and have accepted is a false encounter report. The most difficult would be video of a Bigfoot. This is why new reports are still taken and logged into databases while virtually all of the videos (YouTube, etc) are rejected.

Ironically, almost any of these modern videos would have been accepted as real or very persuasive back in the Classic Bigfoot Years (though they would have been celluloid film). Even more ironic is my strong belief that if the PGF were presented now (pretend it didn't exist before now) it would be rejected. The modern standards that Bigfootery uses to evaluate presented visual evidence would cause serious problems for the PGF. You have big problems with timeline, changing and unbelievable testimony, a general lack of footage before and after the encounter (intentionally edited film), and a primary witness (Gimlin) who will not face skeptical inquiry, etc.

This is exactly the kind of stuff that gets your evidence tossed out nowadays. What's that you say, Patterson? You won't present the before/after footage or it's all cut apart? You had this film developed in one day and several states away from the location? Get out of my forum. You are banned, you slimy hoaxer!
 
OK, confession time! I only pretend to be a skeptic! I do not think bigfeet are real. I KNOW they are real, for I have seen them twice, at close range, once. And it was very similar to Patty! I am not from Brazil, I live at Vancouver! I was just studying the tactics used by close-minded denialist skeptics. Its soo easy to fool them, they are so baseless, with their weak counter-arguments! They have no evidence that bigfeet are not real. The PGF and the MDF are real, too bad or you skeptics! They do not want them to be real, for it would shatter their narrow world view, a view that precludes the possibility, in their minds, of being wrong. Oh, but they are so wrong, isolated at their ivory towers surrounded by a wall of logic built by science. A wall which artificially detaches them from reality, from the mysteries and the poetry of nature. And it is so sad to be a skeptic, locked by their own minds in to a bleak unimaginative world. They lack boldness and curiosity, the very features which fuel human progress. Their closed minds block their progress, their evolution.

You can keep ignoring the fact that Native American myths describe them perfectly!
You can keep ignoring the fact that footprint casts and the Skookum casts can not be explained by anything other than bigfoot!
You can keep ignoring the eyewitnesses reports!
You can keep ignoring the tree-knocking and the rock-throwing!
You can keep ignoring the roars louder than jet engines!

But when you see one of them, you will no longer be able to ignore them.

They will continue to be, regardless of your ignorance.

The fact that today is April fool has nothing to do with this post…. Its true!
 
Drew:

"Bill-
Just to clarify, you realize that the three photos in this progression, the middle one was created by Roger Patterson before the PGF footage was obtained? And he had never admitted to seeing one pre-PGF."


I wasn't aware of who did the images you referenced. Your link to them was the first time I had seen them.

"Also- Does the fact that shooting for POTA wrapped in August mean that Chambers would have more free time in the weeks before October to devote to costume building?"

Exactly what John may have been doing or not doing from mid August to mid October, 1967, I suppose anyone can speculate upon. But people in the business usually build costumes for paid jobs, because it's a lot of work, materials, etc. I have no information that anybody hired him to make anything then.

Also, I tend to think John's own interview statements that he was not involved are the more reliable indicator of his status, because I knew him and he was a man of more intregity than the usual industry sort. So I simply choose to believe John was truthful when he said he was not involved with the PG Film.

Bill
 
Correa Neto wrote:
SweatyYeti wrote:
If one VERY LARGE species of upright-walking primate existed in the past...then it's no big leap to think a 2nd species, or maybe even a descendant of it, existed, or exists today.


By parts, again, Sweaty.

Part one- I'll be bolder than you. There are several extinct species which would qualify as bigfoot template. They belong to the Homo, Gigantopithecus and Australopithecus genus. Happy?
Now, time for the cold shower. There are no evidences that any of these species (except for H. sapiens) ever set foot at the Americas. No bones, no ichnofossils, nothing. So, no reliable evidence for bigfeet here.

Part two- Given the lack of evidence pointing to the presence of these species, not only in North America but also somewhere near the land bridge, it is indeed a big leap to say they crossed the bridge and are still living at this side.

Is sheer speculation, its a leap of faith.


So...according to you.....there is no evidence of Bigfoot's existence in North America. (You're sounding like one of them "Robo-Skeptics" again, Correa. :) )

What about all the sighting reports? Aren't they "evidence"...even if they are 'weak evidence'?

You said you do give the evidence some weight....

Sweaty, we do assign weights... Unfortunately for you, the "weight" the "relevance", in other words, the reliability of the evidence you presented is too close to zero.


So, do the sighting reports carry any weight, or not? If so....how did you determine that weight?

In general...'eyewitness testimonies' do carry weight if what the person is testifying to is not very outlandish.

In the case of Bigfoot...you readily admit that there was, in fact, a species or two already proven to exist in the past, which fit the basic description of Bigfoot.
Add to that the fact that they had access to a land-bridge...and many millions of acres of forested land in N.A. to live in.....what makes someone's claim to have seen a Bigfoot so outlandish?


Again...from the article I had linked to previously:

First, it is important to understand that the strength of a conclusion is a function both of the 'quality of the evidence' provided in its support and the 'a priori probability' of the claim being supported.


Here's a link to a skeptic's blog site...

http://skeptico.blogs.com/skeptico/2008/01/extraordinary-c.html

On the homepage, where they list examples of "extraordinary claims"....they failed to include "Bigfoot exists". ;)
 
Also, I tend to think John's own interview statements that he was not involved are the more reliable indicator of his status, because I knew him and he was a man of more intregity than the usual industry sort. So I simply choose to believe John was truthful when he said he was not involved with the PG Film.

Again, not that I think Chambers made a Patty suit, but...

If he had worked on the project, and he had promised to keep it a secret, and you know him as a man of integrity, then... wouldn't he say he didn't have anything to do with it?

Wouldn't he keep his promise?
 
LTC:

So your argument is a man of intregity promises to lie?

Isn't that a contridiction in terms?

Semantics aside, I knew the man. I believe he's telling the truth.

Bill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom