Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Crow, each day I'm more convinced that you don't understand skepticism and why it exists.


William you're in luck. Enlighten me on why skeptisim exists. I await your dissertation. But I warn you the powers that be would prefer that we stick to the PGF. Why not post a thread devoted to the meaning of skepticism where forum members can contribute the how they percieve the defination and purpose of skeptism.
 
There is no way I am going to do what you ask for. I have read your posts from Day One. I can't understand your logic and why you create your arguments for Bigfoot. Nothing about that changes when you say that you think BF has already gone extinct. Indeed, that would make you a skeptic of a modern existing Bigfoot. But IMO, the way you think and argue is not at all typical of a critical thinking skeptic. That could be a good thing - but in your case it is not. Surely you must be wondering why all these BF skeptics seem to pick on you. Something isn't right with that picture. Or is it?
 
AMM:

"We do know that (from a link in a previous post) Project Unlimited had an auction in 1966 and that the response was greater than they had expected. They had worked on sci-fi and monster-related projects before the auction and an ad for it (apparently) appeared in Famous Monsters of Filmland 1966 yearbook. As a result, it's not unreasonable to assume that the auction included some creature props, masks, etc. There was clearly a demand for monsters at the time (After all, the "Monster Boom" occurred in the 60's), so (in my mind) the idea of people stealing props in order to sell them during the 60's is quite possible.

Do I think that Patterson got anything from an auction or any stolen goods? I don't have a clue; I just feel that you're underestimating the demand for such items in the 1960's."


I wasn't aware of the auction, but if it was advertised in Famous Monsters, I'd expect some "creature" stuff to be included. I did read Famous Monsters then, but not every issue.

I really wasn't trying to guage the demand so much as simply say I wasn't aware of such enthusiasm, as compared to when the conventions started and the people did the costume dress=ups as Kirk or Darth Vader, etc. So it was a relative comparison, less interest before the conventions era, more after. And I saw more Trek interest after it went off the air than during its run.

That's really it. I really didn't pay a lot of attention to the memoribilia seekers then, so if you want to call that "underestimating", fine.

I'm aware of the Monster boom of the 50's (Creature from the Black Lagoon, Monster from the ID, etc) but as I recall, the 60's was big historical epics, Beach Party Movies with Annette Funicello, and then biker movies (Easy Rider, etc.) in the late 60's.

SiFi stuff kicked back in in the late 70's with Star Wars, and monsters kicked back in during the 80's (Howling, American Werewolf, etc.)

that's what I recall.

:)

Bill
 
William you're in luck. Enlighten me on why skeptisim exists. I await your dissertation. But I warn you the powers that be would prefer that we stick to the PGF. Why not post a thread devoted to the meaning of skepticism where forum members can contribute the how they percieve the defination and purpose of skeptism.

No essay, but here's a quote. You could read the book too.

“Scepticism is the chastity of the intellect, and it is shameful to surrender it too soon or to the first comer.”
—George Santayana, Scepticism and Animal Faith, Scribner's, 1923, p. 69
 
There is no way I am going to do what you ask for. I have read your posts from Day One. I can't understand your logic and why you create your arguments for Bigfoot. Nothing about that changes when you say that you think BF has already gone extinct. Indeed, that would make you a skeptic of a modern existing Bigfoot. But IMO, the way you think and argue is not at all typical of a critical thinking skeptic. That could be a good thing - but in your case it is not. Surely you must be wondering why all these BF skeptics seem to pick on you. Something isn't right with that picture. Or is it?

William I'm not surprised. Goodby
 
I really wasn't trying to guage the demand so much as simply say I wasn't aware of such enthusiasm, as compared to when the conventions started and the people did the costume dress=ups as Kirk or Darth Vader, etc. So it was a relative comparison, less interest before the conventions era, more after. And I saw more Trek interest after it went off the air than during its run.

Ah, I see.

I'm aware of the Monster boom of the 50's (Creature from the Black Lagoon, Monster from the ID, etc) but as I recall, the 60's was big historical epics, Beach Party Movies with Annette Funicello, and then biker movies (Easy Rider, etc.) in the late 60's.

From what I can tell, the "Monster Boom" was sparked in the late 50's (I think it might've been 1958) by Universal's "Shock Theater" movie package for television (no relation to the horror host series of the same name). This carried on into/through the 60's.

SiFi stuff kicked back in in the late 70's with Star Wars, and monsters kicked back in during the 80's (Howling, American Werewolf, etc.)

Now that I agree with. Monsters got overtaken by "slashers" in the 80's and eventually died down, only to get revived by Scream and other "ironic slasher" movies. Then that died down and eventually, remakes (of both American and Asian horror movies) took over.
 
AMM:

"From what I can tell, the "Monster Boom" was sparked in the late 50's (I think it might've been 1958) by Universal's "Shock Theater" movie package for television (no relation to the horror host series of the same name). This carried on into/through the 60's."

Boy, truckin' down memory lane here.

:)

As I recall, the monster stuff sort of died out in movies (probably one or two, Time Machine, 7 Faces of Dr. Lao, but not a lot) but Si-Fi and fantesy stuff blossemed on TV with Twilight Zone and Outer limits. Those were the classic monsters and makeups of the 60's as I recall.

Eye of the beholder (The beautiful Donna Douglas as the "ugly" girl and the people with the twisted piglike faces), To Serve Man (the big brained Richard kiel as the alien), The Sixth Finger (David McCallum as the alien big brain guy), those were the iconic makeups of the 60's I remember.

Bill
 
William you're in luck. Enlighten me on why skeptisim exists. I await your dissertation. But I warn you the powers that be would prefer that we stick to the PGF. Why not post a thread devoted to the meaning of skepticism where forum members can contribute the how they percieve the defination and purpose of skeptism.

The biggest part of skepticism that has yet to be hammered into your tattered pipe cleaner of a brain stem is that contrary to what you and the rest of Bigfoot Nation would believe skeptics do NOT want Bigfeetsus to NOT exist....that is just ridiculous on it's very surface.

Short of getting to point and gawk at Bigfoot Fan...what on earth would be in it for Skeptic to have Hairy Bipeds of Unusual Size NOT exist? I'll answer that for ya Crow old boy....

NOTHING!!!

Nothing at all.

Both Skeptic and Bigfoot Fan alike would love Bigfeetsus to be really for really real creatures. The unfortunate probability of it all though is that given what evidence we Skeptics have seen thus far.....that fact is highly unlikely....and therefore we are able to see the phenomenon for what it really is....

A nice campfire story...and not much else.

There is no Church at this end of Bigfoot Street Crow....and we have no vested interest at all in seeing Bigfoot go the way of Santa Clause,The Easter Bunny or Leprechauns....we just have accepted the fact that in all probability...

It has.
 
The biggest part of skepticism that has yet to be hammered into your tattered pipe cleaner of a brain stem is that contrary to what you and the rest of Bigfoot Nation would believe skeptics do NOT want Bigfeetsus to NOT exist....that is just ridiculous on it's very surface.

Short of getting to point and gawk at Bigfoot Fan...what on earth would be in it for Skeptic to have Hairy Bipeds of Unusual Size NOT exist? I'll answer that for ya Crow old boy....

NOTHING!!!

Nothing at all.

Both Skeptic and Bigfoot Fan alike would love Bigfeetsus to be really for really real creatures. The unfortunate probability of it all though is that given what evidence we Skeptics have seen thus far.....that fact is highly unlikely....and therefore we are able to see the phenomenon for what it really is....

A nice campfire story...and not much else.

There is no Church at this end of Bigfoot Street Crow....and we have no vested interest at all in seeing Bigfoot go the way of Santa Clause,The Easter Bunny or Leprechauns....we just have accepted the fact that in all probability...

It has.

"Really" is a very weak word. I am wondering though how much stock can be put into the words of anyone touting themselves as a loose cannon. Have you pulled the trigger yet on the figurative gun your avitar seems to imply. And for all of the "accepted the fact that in all probability" it hasn't done alot for this broods banter in raising it much above junior high school. I have no vested interest in Bigfoot either or you.
 
No your mind is quite open. The wind is circulating freely throughout it.

Reliable evidences to back your positions, got some?

As I quite often tell some proponents, insults can not substitute reliable evidences and sound reasonings. They can not mask their absence.
 
Reliable evidences to back your positions, got some?

As I quite often tell some proponents, insults can not substitute reliable evidences and sound reasonings. They can not mask their absence.

If I was going to insult you I would call you a NeoCon, which I haven't.
 
Reliable evidences to back your positions, got some?


Robo-Skeptic #44 asks...."Where's the proof...got a body?" :rolleyes:


What you will find are quotes saying there's no reliable evidence that such creatures are alive nowadays somewhere in the world or existed in North America.


Robo-Skeptic #44 states that there is no proof of Bigfoot's existence.


Think of "skeptic" as a person who uses critical thinking.


One can also think of a skeptic as a Robot, which simply repeats the same line, over and over again.....looking for proof of Bigfoot, while remaining unable to weigh the evidence, and determine the true likelihood of the animal's existence.

To this "Robotic" mind...one either has "proof"...or one has "nothing".
There is no gray-area in-between....such as "probabilities".

(For a wonderful, shining example of this...please feel free to read Greg's quote, in my signature line.)


A skeptical is not an unbeliever. A skeptic is someone who requires evidence (#44 actually means "proof") and critical thinking to form an opinion, and this opinion will change as soon as evidence (proof ;) ) is available.
We usually set the bar for evidence quality ("proof positive"...to be precise) above the level most people set and quite often take a more conservative approach.
A skeptic may, for some people, be taken as "unimaginative", "boring" (Robotic :) ) or "shy" because we do not have the habit of making (OK, we do make them, we just avoid telling people about them) and defending some bold or wild speculations.
 
Last edited:
Sweaty, it seems you have failed to notice what I, as well as many posters here have considered as reliable evidence for bigfeet. Let me refresh your mind. From the best one (reaching the status of "proof") at the top towards those with less "weight" at the bottom:
1-A specimen, alive or not;
2-Good DNA data (No, sorry, "unknown mammal DNA" or "too close to human" are below the bar);
3-A fossil specimen of a bigfoot-like animal in North America or close to the land bridge;
4-Footage or stills of relatively good quality obtained by individualss whose reputation would be ruined if caught somehow involved in a hoax; ideally the images gathered at the same place by unrelated teams.

As you can see, you are, once again, mistaken. We don't demand a body; a body is not the only and single piece of evidence that can change our opinion. I think one could expect that a creature with the alleged distribution, size, population numbers and habits bigfeet are claimed to have would have by now produced at least one of the above pieces of evidence.

So, Sweaty, instead your standard empty rethorical arguments, insults and mischaracterizations, I suggest you to start considering why such pieces of evidences are not available right now. I suggest you to consider the many problems present at the answers proposed by footers to explain this absence. I suggest you to consider how to fix the many mistakes and errors we pointed in your reasonings.

After all, once again, mischaracterizations, empty rethoric arguments and insults can not substitute reliable evidences and sound reasonings. They can not mask their absence.
 
...snip... Or at least it was until Correa had to creep it all out having loud sex in his tent and screaming obscenities in Portuguese. He was the only one in there, for Randi's sake! Well, I took back the Bob Heironimus drawing I gave him to let him know just what I thought about that...snip...
How can you be such a liar, Kitakaze?

I was not alone. I was with Betty, my bigfoot mistress. You could not see her because she can slide through dimensions whenever she wants. She was screaming louder than a jet engine. She can get pretty wild, you know, specially when I whisper in her ears "Patty does it better..." YEEEEHAAA! There we go baby! Rough ride!
 
Correa Neto wrote:
1-A specimen, alive or not;

This would be 'proof positive'.
It's not relevant to what would constitute "reliable evidence...short of proof".

2-Good DNA data (No, sorry, "unknown mammal DNA" or "too close to human" are below the bar);

There have been reported samples of hair DNA.
You don't accept them as "reliable" evidence only because they don't rise to the level of "proof" of Bigfoot's existence.
Despite not being "proof"....they are evidence of such a creature.

3-A fossil specimen of a bigfoot-like animal in North America or close to the land bridge;

There are already fossils of a "Bigfoot-like primate"...Ginganto.

If one VERY LARGE species of upright-walking primate existed in the past...then it's no big leap to think a 2nd species, or maybe even a descendant of it, existed, or exists today.

4-Footage or stills of relatively good quality obtained by individuals whose reputation would be ruined if caught somehow involved in a hoax; ideally the images gathered at the same place by unrelated teams.


As for any footage....it would only carry a lot of weight based on what is seen in the footage itself.....rather than carrying a lot of weight based on 'who took the footage'.

We have, at least, 2 potential Bigfoot videos in existence today....the PG film and the Memorial Day Video.

Despite the MD Video's very low resolution....it has a very odd feature related to the main subject....the lifted object.
While it's very easy to dismiss it as simply a "mask"...it's quite difficult to explain how it continues to lift up after the subject has let go of it.
Another problem for the "mask" theory is that a mask would be too small, and thin, to appear as large as the lifted object appears in the video.
At that low resolution level, a thin mask would barely show-up at all.
The apparant 'mass' of the lifted object is much more in line with an object the size of an infant animal.

Until someone can come up with an explanation which accounts for all the details contained in the video itself, and which also accounts for all the details of the eyewitness testimonies from the people there....a Bigfoot w/infant is a very real possibility....and a probability.

I'm not saying the MD Video qualifies as "reliable evidence"....but it does carry some weight as evidence for Bigfoot's existence, because of a lack of alternate explanations which fit ALL the details surrounding the video.


It's the lack of ability of skeptics here to assign any weight (probability) to a piece of evidence that I'm refering to when I poke fun at them...calling them 'Robo-Skeptics' ;).

You're all simply taking a "black and white" view ("proof" or "nothing") of the evidence...when, in actual fact...."evidence" requires a "gray" view (degrees of likelihood, or probability) to see, understand, and weigh it properly.
 
Last edited:
How can you be such a liar, Kitakaze?

I was not alone. I was with Betty, my bigfoot mistress. You could not see her because she can slide through dimensions whenever she wants. She was screaming louder than a jet engine. She can get pretty wild, you know, specially when I whisper in her ears "Patty does it better..." YEEEEHAAA! There we go baby! Rough ride!
Is puke.:gasp:
 
BFF's "Remember November" is really quite hapless. Big zinger this morning.

RN said:
Not precise but pretty damn close.

Yeah, the plaster overpour matches quite nicely with Perfectfoot. Doh! :D

pattysfoot.jpg
pattysfootcast.jpg
red.jpg
 
Last edited:
There have been reported samples of hair DNA.
You don't accept them as "reliable" evidence only because they don't rise to the level of "proof" of Bigfoot's existence.
Despite not being "proof"....they are evidence of such a creature.

Separate purported bigfoot DNA samples matching. Possibility of contamination or tampering reasonably ruled out. I think this could qualify as reliable evidence and not proof under the right circumstances.



There are already fossils of a "Bigfoot-like primate"...Ginganto.

If one VERY LARGE species of upright-walking primate existed in the past...then it's no big leap to think a 2nd species, or maybe even a descendant of it, existed, or exists today.
Call back when you have one very large upright-walking primate species. Until then you don't have a bigfoot-like primate.

Get fossil evidence of Giganto being bipedal and you're getting started. Get it in North America and you're really making waves.

BTW, could Giganto talk? Bigfoot apparently is a bit of a talker.

As for any footage....it would only carry a lot of weight based on what is seen in the footage itself.....rather than carrying a lot of weight based on 'who took the footage'.
Yes. If Jane Goodall came back from a camping trip in Oregon with an ambiguous video of what may be a man in a suit or a bigfoot, I would sooner conclude that some of her bigfoot fans were pulling a hoax. IOW, not reliable evidence.

If we had a reasonably good looking video but the source was suspect (ex. SFX connections) then we do not have reliable evidence.

If we had a video that was obtained under known circumstances, showing something very difficult to hoax (bigfoot defecating and throwing it at you. Bigfoot eating a marmit.), where the pedigree is known and the likihood of intentional deception is very low, then I think you have what could qualify as reliable evidence. That's my opinion.

We have, at least, 2 potential Bigfoot videos in existence today....the PG film and the Memorial Day Video.
Not reliable. Best move on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom