Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
One can also think of a skeptic as a Robot, which simply repeats the same line, over and over again.....looking for proof of Bigfoot, while remaining unable to weigh the evidence, and determine the true likelihood of the animal's existence.


Gee...Did you miss my post and my request or are you "still working on it". Maybe I missed it. Anyway, I asked how you figured that Patty's arms are too long to be human. I demonstrated with the image data that the arms are not too long to be human. Maybe my math or the image data is wrong or maybe I an unable to see what you see. Feel free to enlighten me with how you figured Patty's arms are too long. The world wonders....

I also asked you to demonstrate how you carefully weighed the evidence and determined that it was probable that the PGF is of a "real" creature. So far, all I have seen is you continuously flash pictures of "supposedly wiggling fingers", "supposed muscle movement", etc. etc. To me that is not really analyzing the data/evidence.

You claim the skeptics are unable to analyze the data but that is not the case. Have you read "Bigfoot exposed?" Probably not because it deals with the evidence from a scientific point of view and critiques the bigfoot investigations to date. The skeptics have looked at the data/evidence. Unfortunately, the data is very poor and does not carry much weight. Footprints can be faked, people can lie, and the PGF may be (and probably is, based on the lack of any good evidence of bigfoot's existence) a guy in a suit.
 
Gee...Did you miss my post and my request or are you "still working on it". Maybe I missed it. Anyway, I asked how you figured that Patty's arms are too long to be human. I demonstrated with the image data that the arms are not too long to be human. Maybe my math or the image data is wrong or maybe I an unable to see what you see. Feel free to enlighten me with how you figured Patty's arms are too long. The world wonders....
Astro, I'm personally on pins and needles waiting for this. I'm guessing 'later'...
 
Originally Posted by Astrophotographer
Gee...Did you miss my post and my request or are you "still working on it". Maybe I missed it. Anyway, I asked how you figured that Patty's arms are too long to be human. I demonstrated with the image data that the arms are not too long to be human. Maybe my math or the image data is wrong or maybe I an unable to see what you see. Feel free to enlighten me with how you figured Patty's arms are too long. The world wonders....


Astro, I'm personally on pins and needles waiting for this. I'm guessing 'later'...


You got it, kitty! "Later" is the key word.

I'll work on responses to that post of yours, and Astro's...and post them either tonight, or tomorrow. :boxedin:
 
Robo-Skeptic #44 asks...."Where's the proof...got a body?" :rolleyes:

Sweatster why on earth is it so much to ask that after 40 years Bigfoot Fan either produce something real like DNA of some kind or failing that a film that can be considered more than ambiguous?

You and the rest of Bigfoot Nation are making the extraordinary claims...so how about you produce the extraordinary proof?

Oh and this just in Sweaty old boy...

Feetprints won't cut it

Blobsquatches won't cut it

Butt casts won't cut it

Stories about someone seeing a Bigfeetsus won't cut it

Unknown Mammal hair won't cut it

Tree knocking won't cut it

Recordings of something unseen howling in the deep dark night won't cut it

and most importantly...

Patty won't cut it


Robo-Skeptic #44 states that there is no proof of Bigfoot's existence.

No Sweaty you are wrong Robo Skeptic #44 states that there is no RELIABLE proof of Bigfeets existence....there is a huge difference there which you just love to overlook

One can also think of a skeptic as a Robot, which simply repeats the same line, over and over again.....looking for proof of Bigfoot, while remaining unable to weigh the evidence, and determine the true likelihood of the animal's existence.

Unable to weigh the evidence??? Sweaty why is this so difficult for you to understand....Skeptics have weighed the evidence and that evidence has been found wanting...ahh but of course this doesn't fit into your fanciful worldview where Hairy Bipeds frolic the world over undetected by science....so you tell the Skeptics that they are robots for not BLEEVING in Bigfeetsus.

Whatever makes you feel better there sweaty.

To this "Robotic" mind...one either has "proof"...or one has "nothing".
There is no gray-area in-between....such as "probabilities".

(For a wonderful, shining example of this...please feel free to read Greg's quote, in my signature line.)

This bizarre tactic of yours to try and turn blind adherence to a BLEEF around on people who can see that that's your ploy from a couple hundred miles away....you're kidding with that.....right??

I mean it's obvious that it's the other way around...to the TRU BLEEVER all proof regardless of quality and or provenance is good proof and fosters in them a misguided BLEEF that DNA is unnecessary....yet you still attempt to turn the tables....whatever floats your boat I guess.

You speak of Gray area...well you and the rest of Bigfoot Nation has had 40 years of gray area... it's time for black and white.

Stop farting around with the ambiguous Bigfeet footage already and get some DNA.
 
You got it, kitty! "Later" is the key word.

I'll work on responses to that post of yours, and Astro's...and post them either tonight, or tomorrow. :boxedin:
Really? Dare I hope? Doubts were beginning to creep. If I were you, I'd want to get my chompers on that post of Astro's or mine and show them how a real bigfoot proponent does it. It seems like such a better use of time than trying to get into round #87 of quibbling about what Greg said.

ETA: Here's a link to that post, Sweaty:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3557239#post3557239

BTW, is everybody having peanut butter posting problems?
 
Last edited:
Yes I am Kit...it never confirms my reply goes through so I hit the submit button a few more times....hence my quadruple post....D'oh!!!
 
Last edited:
Madness, I find the best thing to do when the board goes sludge and you staring at a post that is just infinitely loading, rather than hitting the submit button more than once (which is guaranteed to get you multiple posts), simply right copy your post for insurance and hit the link back to the GS&P main page. The post may not register on the post count but it should still come through. If that doesn't work, I recommend shouting profanities at your computer really loud. It won't do anything but it's a neat way to pass the time.
 
Quick note, on the odd chance anybody might be interested;

I was part of a 2 hour webcast interview yesterday, discussing both "If Patty's a suit" and "If Patty is real".

Link is:

http://www.txsasquatch.blogspot.com/

The linked site has download links and some photographs related to each part of the discussion, including (for the "If Patty's a suit") some never before published photos of suits and related creature effects processes.

Bill
 
...snip... I recommend shouting profanities at your computer really loud. It won't do anything but it's a neat way to pass the time.

Wait a minute, Mr. Skeptic. You just complained about Betty's shouting of profanities! Where's you consistency, Mr. Skeptic? Just because her screams are louder than a jet engine? Or you are feeling jealous?
 
Drew:

"Bill-
One facial feature of Patty isn't visible in the other three Ancient ape photos at the top of this page. It is the Rectanglar, bald, patch that Patty's eyes are in. Do you have any knowledge of ancient apes/humans that have a rectangular bald eyepatch such as this?"


The "bald patch" on Patty may just be highlights with contrast buildup from the image enhancing, and a shape simplified by the grainy resolution. Hard to say for sure. But the hiominids weren't photographed under direct sunlight. They were photographed in diffused interior lighting, and that does change the light/dark patterns on a face significantly.

Bill
 
Quick note, on the odd chance anybody might be interested;

I was part of a 2 hour webcast interview yesterday, discussing both "If Patty's a suit" and "If Patty is real".

Link is:

http://www.txsasquatch.blogspot.com/

The linked site has download links and some photographs related to each part of the discussion, including (for the "If Patty's a suit") some never before published photos of suits and related creature effects processes.

Interesting; thanks for the link! Would it be possible for you to post a picture of Patty with the three lines you were talking about towards the beginning of the webcast pointed out or highlighted? I think I might have a potential, suit-based explanation for them, but I want to make sure I'm thinking of the same lines you are before posting it.

As for the issue of suit grooming, I can point out an instance where a professional lent out a costume without going along to make sure it was groomed properly during filming. George Barrows did this for the 1961 movie Konga, which you can read a little bit about here.

Similarly, this notes that Steve Calvert was given lessons after buying his suit from Ray "Crash" Corrigan. However, I don't know if grooming was included in the lessons.

The "bald patch" on Patty may just be highlights with contrast buildup from the image enhancing, and a shape simplified by the grainy resolution. Hard to say for sure. But the hiominids weren't photographed under direct sunlight. They were photographed in diffused interior lighting, and that does change the light/dark patterns on a face significantly.

Would the same issue apply to the appearance of noses? Patty seems to have a prominent nose whereas the reconstructions in the image Drew linked to don't.

Oh, and those pictures of the Peking Man reconstruction reminded me of this.
 
There are already fossils of a "Bigfoot-like primate"...Ginganto.

If one VERY LARGE species of upright-walking primate existed in the past...then it's no big leap to think a 2nd species, or maybe even a descendant of it, existed, or exists today.


Why "leap"? Shouldn't have to jump anywhere. The walking, talking, Volkswagen and trailer wrestling Superapes are, apparently, literally swarming all over North America. They are everywhere, in almost every State. "Bigfoot Research" Groups are in numbers that rival Rotary Clubs, and Boy Scout Troops... and they all seem to have wild giant monkeys getting up to mischief. There should not be any "leaping" required. The bones should be turning up, like...

The living Theropod Superpredators that Dino-skeptics don't want to admit are roaming North America, and eating hapless people on outhouse toilets. No need to "leap" for them. They are here, dude. You just cannot wrap your head around the terrifying truth.


As for any footage....it would only carry a lot of weight based on what is seen in the footage itself.....rather than carrying a lot of weight based on 'who took the footage'.

We have, at least, 2 potential Bigfoot videos in existence today....the PG film and the Memorial Day Video.


MDF is a joke. Hardcore Cultist "Jesus in the burrito" stuff. PGF doesn't even count. No film. No cigar. It's a movie.


Despite the MD Video's very low resolution....it has a very odd feature related to the main subject....the lifted object.
While it's very easy to dismiss it as simply a "mask"...it's quite difficult to explain how it continues to lift up after the subject has let go of it.
Another problem for the "mask" theory is that a mask would be too small, and thin, to appear as large as the lifted object appears in the video.
At that low resolution level, a thin mask would barely show-up at all.
The apparant 'mass' of the lifted object is much more in line with an object the size of an infant animal.

Until someone can come up with an explanation which accounts for all the details contained in the video itself, and which also accounts for all the details of the eyewitness testimonies from the people there....a Bigfoot w/infant is a very real possibility....and a probability.

I'm not saying the MD Video qualifies as "reliable evidence"....but it does carry some weight as evidence for Bigfoot's existence, because of a lack of alternate explanations which fit ALL the details surrounding the video.


There are alternate explanations. Even if a monkey suit, is ruled out, which it hasn't, a hooded military-style groundsheet/poncho behaves exactly like the blob in the video, when worn by a running figure. If one is to start interpreting this mess, the lower edges of the cape can be seen flapping behind the figure. The "lifted baby-Bigfoot", is really a hood that is shifting and being moved. The lift is caused by wind, raising the hood as the figure moves forward. Blobsquatch, in any event. There are likely half a dozen other, more reasonable explanations, than just this one. Other than a jogging juvenile Superape, plus infant. Cute and heart-warming though it might be.

It's the lack of ability of skeptics here to assign any weight (probability) to a piece of evidence that I'm refering to when I poke fun at them...calling them 'Robo-Skeptics' ;).

You're all simply taking a "black and white" view ("proof" or "nothing") of the evidence...when, in actual fact...."evidence" requires a "gray" view (degrees of likelihood, or probability) to see, understand, and weigh it properly.


I'm no Robo-skeptic. I tell you there are fierce living Dinosaur superpredators. Prove it ain't so. Big hairy monkeys are lame-o. Thunderlizards are where the action is.
 
Last edited:
AMM:

"Interesting; thanks for the link! Would it be possible for you to post a picture of Patty with the three lines you were talking about towards the beginning of the webcast pointed out or highlighted? I think I might have a potential, suit-based explanation for them, but I want to make sure I'm thinking of the same lines you are before posting it."

The lines I was talking about are the famous "diaper butt" lines often described here as well as over there (BFF), plus the thigh line.

"As for the issue of suit grooming, I can point out an instance where a professional lent out a costume without going along to make sure it was groomed properly during filming."

Obviously it can be done, my observation from my experience was that it's uncommon or rarely done.

"Would the same issue apply to the appearance of noses? Patty seems to have a prominent nose whereas the reconstructions in the image Drew linked to don't."

I don't personally endorse the Patty reconstructions that show a nose. Could be like that, but I don't get that impression from what I see in some of the more profile frames of Patty's face in the film. The reconstructions, however, were done without any consideration of resemblance to Patty. I just intrepreted the skull as I thought it might look, and the nose is the most guesswork for anybody's fossil species reconstruction, so don't get locked into anybody's nose on any prehistoric figure. The nose is always pure guess, nothing more.

"Oh, and those pictures of the Peking Man reconstruction reminded me of this."

That link leads to some earlier Peking Man reconstructions done by scientific artists in the past. Same basic skull, slightly different artist intrepretations of how he's fleshed out.

Bill
 
Hey SweatyYeti

Sweaty,

Found this while rereading Big Footprints:

"The burden of proof rests with those who think that the animals are real." (p7)

"The skeptics rightly demand that a specimen be produced before it can be taken seriously." (p9)

Sweaty, that's from ole Grover hisself by golly. So why are you spending time on a skeptics forum devoted to the PGF? Why aren't you out with your trusty 30-06 trying to bag a type specimen? Why aren't you here in Ky hanging out at the "Ky Incident" waiting to bag one of those bigfeets billgreen keeps spotting? Why waste time at a keyboard when you can be out call blasting or hitting trees with sticks?
 
Yes, Sweaty seems to have the burden of proof bass ackwards.

"In science, the burden of proof falls upon the claimant; and the more extraordinary a claim, the heavier is the burden of proof demanded. The true skeptic takes an agnostic position, one that says the claim is not proved rather than disproved. He asserts that the claimant has not borne the burden of proof and that science must continue to build its cognitive map of reality without incorporating the extraordinary claim as a new "fact." Since the true skeptic does not assert a claim, he has no burden to prove anything. He just goes on using the established theories of "conventional science" as usual. But if a critic asserts that there is evidence for disproof, that he has a negative hypothesis --saying, for instance, that a seeming psi result was actually due to an artifact--he is making a claim and therefore also has to bear a burden of proof." -- Marcello Truzzi, Zetetic Scholar, #12-13, 1987.

"The skeptics are under no obligation to disprove all or, for that matter, any of the evidence. The burden of proof rests with those who think that the animals are real. The skeptics are not obligated even to look at the evidence." -- Grover Krantz, Big Footprints, page 7

In many situations, one side has the burden of proof resting on it. This side is obligated to provide evidence for its position. The claim of the other side, the one that does not bear the burden of proof, is assumed to be true unless proven otherwise. The difficulty in such cases is determining which side, if any, the burden of proof rests on. In many cases, settling this issue can be a matter of significant debate. In some cases the burden of proof is set by the situation. For example, in American law a person is assumed to be innocent until proven guilty (hence the burden of proof is on the prosecution). As another example, in debate the burden of proof is placed on the affirmative team. As a final example, in most cases the burden of proof rests on those who claim something exists (such as Bigfoot, psychic powers, universals, and sense data).

"The burden of proof must be on the believer. If the evidence is convincing enough, the skeptics will in time accept almost anything, even that the continents are drifting about the face of the earth. But until the evidence is there, the only sane course is to reject all claims that are unverified and inconsistent with current knowledge." -- Alan Cromer, Uncommon Sense: The Heretical Nature of Science, pg. 157-157

RayG
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom