Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dfoot:

A small favor to ask, if I may.

Given I readily concede what I see in the PG film mystifies me, and you assure me and all here in the forum that you know with certainty the facts of the suit, could you please just answer me a few questions, so satisfy my knawing curiosity?

1. How many people were there at the filming to assist the person in the suit, as far as help dressing and grooming the suit?

2. Where exactly does the head mask split from the body suit? Could you diagram it on a frame of Patty for all of us to see? And explaining how the closure was secured (to hold the mask edge secure to the body suit part)would be more than wonderful, if you can answer that as well.

Thanks,

Bill

What is, "knawing curiosity"?
 
GT:

"What is, "knawing curiosity"?"

bad spelling.

Bill

(intended meaning) "to chew on incessently or continually"

:)

Bill
 
Last edited:
Dfoot:

about the jokster thing, I do know a bit about it. For a movie called "Savage Harvest" (made in 1980) Tom Skerritt stars and in one scene he's on the porch of an estate, fighting off an attack by a mature male lion. Somewhere in a vault, there may still exist the original footage, whereby the lion (me, in a lion mane and paws for arms, back to camera) is violently trying to maul Tom, and then the director calls "cut", the camera keeps rolling, and Tom and I start dancing a waltz on the patio, like "Dancing with the Stars". A joke, for fun, and had the whole crew laughing till they nearly wet themselves. Yeah, there's fun stuff out there, always has been.

Now here's my concerns, in all seriousness and due respect to you and your research.

1. Jokesters and "funsters" tend to play their jokes or have fun doing two things. One is to do silly things and not admit it. The other is to claim to have done things they actually did not do. For each person who may have tried to create faked Bigfoot event, there may be people who falsely claim they were involved with an event even when they were not. Those who claim to do something they actually did not do wait for some eager and suseptable person wanting to hear "the true story" and they then fabricate a story to satisfy the eager listener. Common Funster behavior.

Since the people you say were involved with this suit were "funsters", how do you know they simply aren't having fun with you, making up stories you are eager to hear?

2. If this was done by "funsters", would there be any contractual "confidentiality" agreements, any obligation to keep the secret? Seems contracts, NDA's and the like are serious stuff. So if it's "all in good fun", why the mafia like secrecy, the fear of anyone involved simply saying publicly, Yeah, I did part of it, and this is how." Given that even "Deep Throat" from the Watergate Scandal eventually spoke publicly and identified himself, what's keeping the participants so quiet? And why are they talking to you so freely, while denying to speak for themselves?

3. Do the people who are telling you the "real story" know you are posting "the real story" here on the forum, and why do they feel comfortable letting you tell the truth of their participation while denying their identities? Seems they want the real story out. So don't they know the real story is stronger and more credible if they go on the record themselves?

Curious minds wish to know.

Bill
 
Bill Munns wrote:
Do the people who are telling you the "real story" know you are posting "the real story" here on the forum, and why do they feel comfortable letting you tell the truth of their participation while denying their identities? Seems they want the real story out. So don't they know the real story is stronger and more credible if they go on the record themselves?

Curious minds wish to know.


I've been wondering the same thing myself, Bill....everytime I read Dfoot's posts with all that "behind-the-scenes' info in them.

But I just think of it this way....:)...


ROLL UP...ROLL UP for the Magical Mystery Tour, step right this way!
Roll up, roll up for the mystery tour.
Roll up, roll up for the mystery tour.
Roll up......THAT'S AN INVITATION,
Roll up......TO MAKE A RESERVATION...
The magical mystery tour is waiting to take you away...

Waiting to take you away.....take you today...



MMT1.jpg



Why ask why......Just kick back and enjoy the ride!
 
Nice try, Astro....but when I used "T-Rex sightings" in my post, I was refering to a T-Rex, the BIG and scary kind...as in.....

Length - 40 feet (12.4 m) long
Height - 15 to 20 feet (4.6 to 6 m) tall
Weight - 5 to 7 tons



This is from an article about your supposed "T-Rex in Utah"...:boggled:...



Link to article:

http://web.ksl.com/dump/news/cc/local/leapin_lizards.php


Again....the "plausibility" of any cryptid animal's existence depends on a mulitude of factors. Physical size is one of those factors.

Are there people claiming to have seen 20-foot tall, 40-foot long dinosaurs stomping around the Pacific Northwest, or any other part of North America??
If so....how many are claiming this?


If you're not interested in intelligently discussing how a sighting claim can be judged to be "far-fetched" or not, that's fine. Just don't pretend to be, Astro.
Oh, but look, T rexes had 75 million years to evolve and adapt, reaching a smaller body size! Gigantopithecus needed only a few hundreds of thousands of years to move from Southern Asia and become Patty.

Not to mention that the smaller number of dinosaur sightings may be due to:
- a smaller number of specimens;
- populations are in areas more distant from civilization;
- 75 million years of evolution towards a stealthy species able to live in a world dominated by mammals;
- they are at the brink of extinction or were extincted a few decades ago;
- they may be "invisiable" interdimensional paranormal dinosaurs or pets from the reptilian aliens.

Open your eyes, oh denialist-close-minded living dinosaur skeptic!They may be there!
 
Last edited:
The opinions here carry no weight except within the online community of JREF. JREF is not exactly a household word with regards to shaping world opinion. So the opinions expressed here are of limited value except within the confines of JREF.
My original comment was
Crow, do you realy think that an opinion (or a speculation) built over reliable evidence has the same value of one based in nothing?

I don't think so.

Do you agree or not with the above?

In my personal life and profession my opinions and decisions carry weight with regards to my own well being and the well being of those who are connected to my decisions professional/personal. If you are of the opinion that your contributions here are somehow effecting the course of humanity fine but I've encountered enough "small ponds" and the "big fish" who populate them to know how "big fish" in "small ponds" opinionate about the importance of thier small pond opinions.
Crow, I honestly fail to see the point as well as any basis regarding the comment above. FYI, I usually don't care how far what we discuss here can go. I don't think they can change the world; I think, however, that they may help a few people to make their own minds, and that's all.

I try to build my opinions over reliable evidence, I try to build them using critical thinking, using the scientific method as best as I can. I think opinions built over unreliable evidence as well as baseless suppositions (such as those used to back bigfoot, UFOs, alien civilizations in Mars, Atlantis, god, life after death, lake monsters, conspiracy theories, etc.) to be weaker, to have much less weight. These types of opinions are better labelled as beliefs instead of conclusions reached through critical thinking.

I stand by to every single word I wrote - as long as no new (and better) evidence is provided.

Some people (actually most of humanity, depending on the chosen subject) disagree with me. So far, none of their arguments managed to impress me enough to reconsider my position.

Now with regards the family picnic where a relic realitive of H. Erectus might inadvertantly encounter a few humans lets set the stage as follows

Year -1872
Place- 20 miles SE of Rosenberg Oregon
Environment- Edge of Alpine meadow elevation 3,200ft

Humans
Male age 41 Father, Railroad worker
Female age 36 Mother
Children 2 males ages 12 & 13

Circumstance of sighting. At 1:30 on bright sunlight afternoon in early June family wittnesses an adult male human sized animal which appeared from the forest and stood on two legs and watched the family for a period of a minute. The animal then turned and strode back into the forest. The father estimated that the distance between the family and the creature was the distance of the lenght of a Pullman Coach. They later reported the sighting to the Rosenberg Gazette. All four family members described the animal as looking like a large monkey with dark greyish brown fur that walked upright.

There you have a circumstance. Be advised its not a real report but you did request.
I hope you agree with me that some sources, like newspapers from that time, are not exactly reliable. Sometimes they needed material to "fill the gaps", "spice the story" or just have something to publish when interesting news are not available. And quite often they created what they needed.

That's the main reason why I would not trust this fictional report, its the reason why I do not trust the monster tales from those times that every now and then pop out at Cryptomundo. Its the main reason why I don't trust old bigfoot tales.
 
Woha big fella slow down! Nobody in Hollywood is going to agree to that deal. Unless perhaps they'd just arrived in town after having fallen off the back of a pumpkin turck. Its hard enough getting paid from legitmate customers for services let along a hick cowboy even if his brotherinlaw has a few dead presidents in his wallet.
Are you sure you are not underestimating people's gullibility? Specially when confronted with an interesting proposal made by a convincing person? Or when the person who receives the proposal needs money?

And what about the cases when they have other motivations to accept the proposal ("OK, let's have a laugh with them", "Let me see how many people I can fool with my work", etc.). Or when the person who receives the proposal is also a "smart" person?

Take a look at the stock markets... You'll find plenty of examples of "smart" people being fooled. Even the top people. Google for Bre-x for an example that I am familiar with. I'm sure there are many others and probably you are already familiar with some of them.

In Hollywood's case, think some movies would never be made if there were not errors in the evaluation of the presented project. "Waterworld" is the first to come to my mind... I bet there are many more.

*Note: I have no idea on who built the Patty suit.
 
Bill Munns -- The weekend is here and my wife is off from work so I'm going to spend time with her, but by Tuesday I'll have some time to myself and I'll sit down and answer all your questions as well as edit some sort of video for you to watch.

I understand that you had no experience with the two-sectioned gorilla or bear suits of the 60's. I do have experience with them and so do many, many others. I'll do my best to spell everything out as carefully as possible and point out each pad, where it sits, how things attached, etc...

What you are saying about contracts simply did not apply in 1967 to these guys. Wah didn't "steal" the head he made for OUTER LIMITS and take it with him when he and Robert Justman began STAR TREK. It belonged to him. Neither did Chambers "steal" studio property when he gave Ape masks away from POTA. The studios in those days considered all that "junk" to be thrown away or else the creature designer could reuse it as much as he wanted. That is just what happened to the Taurean head.

Ask Rick Baker about his raiding the dumpsters to get stuff that had been thrown away. Nobody realized then that this would have much value. Wah actually went to the dumpsters and retrieved more items that he'd tossed out when his auction had gone over so well. He was shocked at the fan base out there and interest in these things.

After STAR WARS all that became important. But in the 60's few cared. Today I even had a contract written up for the Fox lawyers to sign off on declaring that my home video from BUFFY was my own property and they could only use it in one behind-the-scenes special that I appeared in. They did fail to return my tapes (although I knew enough not to give them the originals) and I'm sure some of my footage will show up somewhere one day. This back and forth is common now, but it really had no bearing on what Chambers and Wah did with their creations.

You have to be careful as some things you've said that are often totally inaccurate have already been latched onto by desperate Bigfooters. That is how pseudo-science like the "length-wise dermals" got started. One expert makes an error, refuses to see his error, and then he's a goofball to the real experts and a hero to some cult fanatics. He's also wrong and in the long run hurts real investigations. Saying it was just your opinion later after a guy has hung up the phone doesn't erase that fact. To him an expert has spoken and he now knows Patty must be real. Thus, he becomes an idiot to most people based on erroneous info.

RICK BAKER'S "Harry and the Hendersons" foot has nice realistic dermal ridges. No one is allowed by contract to re-create and reuse the "Harry" image, but if I wanted to make a Bigfoot I could just use those for feet. My "Bigfoot" would not be "Harry" and not subject to any contract. Wah owned his Taurean mask and could toss it if he wanted or give it away to be used for a "Bigfoot". No problem.

I'll be back next week and answer all of those questions. The real question is - will you be able to hear the answers?

To answer one question: Look at the tee-shirt with foam pads I wore and observe the neckline. The Taurean head fits INSIDE the neck area and was worn the way I"m wearing Janos' gorilla head below. I"ll show you how Patty opened and closed at the neckline when I get back.




Hi Sweaty... just waving at you again.:)

 
Correa Neato wrote "Crow, do you realy ( really) think that an opinion (or a speculation) built over reliable evidence has the same value of one based in nothing?"

Define based on nothing. With regards to the evolution of human and primates there is a great deal of speculation as well as a great deal of credible knowledge that’s been learned from the fossil record. Correct me if I’m wrong here but the fossil record and observations of living humans and primates supports the following credible assumptions that supports both human and primate biology and potential.

1. Primates can and have existed as very small and light weight creatures as well as very large and heavy weight creatures
2. Primates can and have existed as both arboreal and terra based creatures.
3. Primates can and have existed in a wide range of habitat from temporal to tropical.
4. Primates can and have existed as both bipeds and quadrupeds.
5. Primates can and have existed within a great range of hair/fur types textures and colors.
6. Primates can and have existed as herbivores and omnivores .
7. Primates can and have existed as nocturnal and diurnal creatures.

This list I’m sure is not complete but you get the picture. My opinion, based on what is known about primate biology potential, is that there is no biological reason why such a creature as reported in Sasquatch/Bigfoot lore could not have existed and existed long enough to have made it into the funa lore of the 19th century and early 20th century. If you know of any biological or genetic reasons why such a creature should be excluded from that possibility by all means extrapolate. To say that the fossil record does not support it is an incorrect assumption. To say that there is nothing in the fossil record that’s been found to date to support it is the correct assumption. But not every human/primate/ hominid fossil has been yet. How different do you think the final fossil record is going to look once the last tooth or skull has been unearthed? Do you expect it to be more richer and more complex then the one at present? But does the animal in question exist right now? My speculation is that no it does not and for many of the same reasons that Mountain Gorillas would no longer exist if not for the extreme effort to protect the small localized population that does still exist in the wild. My speculation on the Mountain Gorilla is that it to will go extinct in the wild before the end of this century.

With regards to the quality of press/news reporting during the 19th century I’m of the opinion that it was no less reliable than today. However language was used more effectively than it is now.
 
Last edited:
Dfoot:

Thank you for the preliminary response. Tuesday is fine for more.

regarding one point,

"What you are saying about contracts simply did not apply in 1967 to these guys. "

Work for hire traditionally recognizes that the hiring party (the studio) owns everything the "hired" person makes. If th owner (the studio) doesn't want it, or doesn't want to enforce their right, they may, and as you say, the studios may have been laxed back then in not caring about enforcing their right.

I've worked for people who made me box up and inventory every single piece, which they kept, and others who simply ignored the existance of what I made after the job was done, and left it to my discretion to keep it, throw it out, or sell it off.

My point was that the studio or employer is the rightful owner in basic legal principle, for work for hire things made. How they use or neglect or waive that right is, of course, subject to a lot of variation.

Hope this clears it up.

Bill
 
Correa Neato wrote "Crow, do you realy ( really) think that an opinion (or a speculation) built over reliable evidence has the same value of one based in nothing?"

Define based on nothing. With regards to the evolution of human and primates there is a great deal of speculation as well as a great deal of credible knowledge that’s been learned from the fossil record. Correct me if I’m wrong here but the fossil record and observations of living humans and primates supports the following credible assumptions that supports both human and primate biology and potential.

1. Primates can and have existed as very small and light weight creatures as well as very large and heavy weight creatures
2. Primates can and have existed as both arboreal and terra based creatures.
3. Primates can and have existed in a wide range of habitat from temporal to tropical.
4. Primates can and have existed as both bipeds and quadrupeds.
5. Primates can and have existed within a great range of hair/fur types textures and colors.
6. Primates can and have existed as herbivores and omnivores .
7. Primates can and have existed as nocturnal and diurnal creatures.

This list I’m sure is not complete but you get the picture. My opinion, based on what is known about primate biology potential, is that there is no biological reason why such a creature as reported in Sasquatch/Bigfoot lore could not have existed and existed long enough to have made it into the funa lore of the 19th century and early 20th century. If you know of any biological or genetic reasons why such a creature should be excluded from that possibility by all means extrapolate. To say that the fossil record does not support it is an incorrect assumption. To say that there is nothing in the fossil record that’s been found to date to support it is the correct assumption. But not every human/primate/ hominid fossil has been yet. How different do you think the final fossil record is going to look once the last tooth or skull has been unearthed? Do you expect it to be more richer and more complex then the one at present? But does the animal in question exist right now? My speculation is that no it does not and for many of the same reasons that Mountain Gorillas would no longer exist if not for the extreme effort to protect the small localized population that does still exist in the wild. My speculation on the Mountain Gorilla is that it to will go extinct in the wild before the end of this century.
Lets sepatare the parts and work with them individually, as the ripper would say...

You will have a hard time trying to find a quote of mine (as well as anyone else around here) saying bigfeet-like animals are impossible. Actually you can find some posts of mine where I examined some bigfoot template flesh-and-bones candidates Gigantopithecus, Australopithecines, Meganthropus and, (why not?) H. sapiens. So far, we all agree. Its possible. But its is a speculation and we must find something to support it.

Now, the hard part; its the part where some proponents get mad with skeptics. What do we have when it comes to reliable evidence that these creatures exist or existed in North America? Do we have a specimen, some bones, ancient or not? No. The remains of the closest candidates (except H. sapiens) were found in Asia. So, what do we have to support the speculation? Old sighting reports which are highly questionable and myth interpretations, which quite often are actually myth twisting and cherry-picking. In other words, there's nothing. No reliable evidence. Its a speculation, its possible, but there's actually nothing to back it. I hope you can understand my position, even if you do not agree with it.

When it comes to these animals existing right now, its even worse. Do we have pictures or footage that are not suspected of being a hoax? No. Can we rely on sighting reports? No. Are the footprints, body prints and buttprint casts reliable pieces of evidence? No. Once again, no reliable evidence. And in this case, given the recent advances in technology and land development...

With regards to the quality of press/news reporting during the 19th century I’m of the opinion that it was no less reliable than today. However language was used more effectively than it is now.
I disagree. But again, lets go by parts.

I have the impression that the press back in the XIX century was much more eager to accept and even build amazing tales to sell newspaper than nowadays. This was part one.

Now, for part two, even nowadays its not uncommon to find crappy stuff at the press, even at the top news agencies. And need I to remind you that bigfoot tales (as well as UFO, ghosts, other cryptids, etc.) are usually easier to find at National Enquirer's pages instead of National Geographic's?
 
Lets sepatare the parts and work with them individually, as the ripper would say...

You will have a hard time trying to find a quote of mine (as well as anyone else around here) saying bigfeet-like animals are impossible. Actually you can find some posts of mine where I examined some bigfoot template flesh-and-bones candidates Gigantopithecus, Australopithecines, Meganthropus and, (why not?) H. sapiens. So far, we all agree. Its possible. But its is a speculation and we must find something to support it.

Now, the hard part; its the part where some proponents get mad with skeptics. What do we have when it comes to reliable evidence that these creatures exist or existed in North America? Do we have a specimen, some bones, ancient or not? No. The remains of the closest candidates (except H. sapiens) were found in Asia. So, what do we have to support the speculation? Old sighting reports which are highly questionable and myth interpretations, which quite often are actually myth twisting and cherry-picking. In other words, there's nothing. No reliable evidence. Its a speculation, its possible, but there's actually nothing to back it. I hope you can understand my position, even if you do not agree with it.

When it comes to these animals existing right now, its even worse. Do we have pictures or footage that are not suspected of being a hoax? No. Can we rely on sighting reports? No. Are the footprints, body prints and buttprint casts reliable pieces of evidence? No. Once again, no reliable evidence. And in this case, given the recent advances in technology and land development...


I disagree. But again, lets go by parts.

I have the impression that the press back in the XIX century was much more eager to accept and even build amazing tales to sell newspaper than nowadays. This was part one.

Now, for part two, even nowadays its not uncommon to find crappy stuff at the press, even at the top news agencies. And need I to remind you that bigfoot tales (as well as UFO, ghosts, other cryptids, etc.) are usually easier to find at National Enquirer's pages instead of National Geographic's?


Some skeptics will agree that Sas/BF could have existed and some adamantly will deny such a possibility. It comes down to an opoinion. New World primates exist which confirms that the Old World does not have an exclusive claim to primate evoloution. The fossil record of New World Primates is very sparce but primates were here as early as 14 million years ago. As I'm not certain as to how long it takes a fossil to form I don't know if what we find in the way of human bones dating back 15- 20 thousand years whether these are still bone or whether they are in some state of fossilization. However ancient human remains are somewhat easier to find due to the fact that humans leave traces of where they've inhabited, fire pits, rubbish, tools. And most importantly we've been burrying our dead since almost the beginning which increases the the odds of preservation and later exumation immensely. How many mammal sleletons do you suppose still exist on the PNW forest floor from a death that occured 150 years ago? When I was growing up in a rural area I frequently encountered dead animals. Left to the elements these remains decayed very rapidly. I could if required locate some exact places where as a child I found dead animals. I can guarantee that those places would come up tracless of the remains I encountered in my youth. Sasquatach was an animal or at best a minimal human and as such when it died its remains faced the same fate of any other forest dweller. So much for the New World.

Since the Old World contains a far greater fossil record than the New World, and virtually all of the known ancient hominids its just a matter of time before a fossil is found that will bridge the gap between smallish biped subhumans and larger and heavier biped sub humans.

As for North American reports of Sasquatach/Bigfoot creatures occuring in the 19th Century one either concludes that everyone with such a report ,then as now, is a liar or portrayer of cavalier tales or that some are accurate reportages and recorders of such. Since in the previous two centuries people were much more connected to the land and spent a great deal more time actually on it who's report are you going to trust? That of a hunter, trapper, farmer, or Native living during a period where the wholesale rape of nature had not yet occured? Or that of a modern hunk of consumer society flab that's never actually known wilderness or the potentials contained within?
 
Last edited:
Some skeptics will agree that Sas/BF could have existed and some adamantly will deny such a possibility. It comes down to an opoinion. New World primates exist which confirms that the Old World does not have an exclusive claim to primate evoloution. The fossil record of New World Primates is very sparce but primates were here as early as 14 million years ago. As I'm not certain as to how long it takes a fossil to form I don't know if what we find in the way of human bones dating back 15- 20 thousand years whether these are still bone or whether they are in some state of fossilization. However ancient human remains are somewhat easier to find due to the fact that humans leave traces of where they've inhabited, fire pits, rubbish, tools. And most importantly we've been burrying our dead since almost the beginning which increases the the odds of preservation and later exumation immensely. How many mammal sleletons do you suppose still exist on the PNW forest floor from a death that occured 150 years ago? When I was growing up in a rural area I frequently encountered dead animals. Left to the elements these remains decayed very rapidly. I could if required locate some exact places where as a child I found dead animals. I can guarantee that those places would come up tracless of the remains I encountered in my youth. Sasquatach was an animal or at best a minimal human and as such when it died its remains faced the same fate of any other forest dweller. So much for the New World.

Since the Old World contains a far greater fossil record than the New World, and virtually all of the known ancient hominids its just a matter of time before a fossil is found that will bridge the gap between smallish biped subhumans and larger and heavier biped sub humans.

As for North American reports of Sasquatach/Bigfoot creatures occuring in the 19th Century one either concludes that everyone with such a report ,then as now, is a liar or portrayer of cavalier tales or that some are accurate reportages and recorders of such. Since in the previous two centuries people were much more connected to the land and spent a great deal more time actually on it who's report are you going to trust? That of a hunter, trapper, farmer, or Native living during a period where the wholesale rape of nature had not yet occured? Or that of a modern hunk of consumer society flab that's never actually known wilderness or the potentials contained within?

Is belief in bigfoot a metaphor of longing for your lost innocence?
 
Yup its all a hoax everything past present and future everyhere. Oz and unknown primate especially. You need technology to get to ancient OZ and humans had that technology. Our primate buddies did not unless they came as pets. Yet if one was to rely on the mind as a parachute some mindsets are going to result in a harder landing due to the inability of certain minds to open broadly.
 
Is belief in bigfoot a metaphor of longing for your lost innocence?

Why don't you mind you own business. This post has nothing to do with you. Worry about your Bigfoot issues whatever they may be not anyone elses.
 
Some skeptics will agree that Sas/BF could have existed and some adamantly will deny such a possibility. It comes down to an opoinion.
You are making an oversimplification. First of all, define the type of bigfoot creature we're talking about. All of us skeptics(*) will deny the possibility of Beckjord's and Historian's bigfeet being real. I guess the same is valid for talking bigfeet living with some family at a farm...

I think you will have a hard time finding quotes from skeptics here saying bigfeet-like creatures (past and present) are impossible. What you will find are quotes saying there's no reliable evidence that such creatures are alive nowadays somewhere in the world or existed in North America. Of course, it also depends on how you approach the bigfoot phenomena. This is related to one of the core questionings we make- the (lack of) criteria used by bigfoot investigators. If you accept all the aspects of the phenomena, we'll say "no way". If you accept a few of them, we'll ask you why, and so far the answers were found to lack consistency and substance.

Once again, Crow, do you realy think that an opinion (or a speculation) built over reliable evidence has the same value of one based in nothing substantial?

New World primates exist which confirms that the Old World does not have an exclusive claim to primate evoloution. The fossil record of New World Primates is very sparce but primates were here as early as 14 million years ago.
Any of them looked vaguely like bigfoot?
Not that I'm aware of.

The closest things are two large fossil monkeys (Caipora bambuirorum and another one I can't remember the name right now) found at caves in South America. The search function will be helpfull if you want to find more info on this aspect, right at this sub-forum.

As I'm not certain as to how long it takes a fossil to form I don't know if what we find in the way of human bones dating back 15- 20 thousand years whether these are still bone or whether they are in some state of fossilization.
How long it takes for fossilization? Depends on the fossilization process. In limestone caves, for example, it may be just a few years. For our present discussion, it really doesn't matter if a bone was completely substituted by minerals or not. What matters is that there are no evidences for a bigfoot-like creature in North America's past (and present) times.

However ancient human remains are somewhat easier to find due to the fact that humans leave traces of where they've inhabited, fire pits, rubbish, tools. And most importantly we've been burrying our dead since almost the beginning which increases the the odds of preservation and later exumation immensely. How many mammal sleletons do you suppose still exist on the PNW forest floor from a death that occured 150 years ago? When I was growing up in a rural area I frequently encountered dead animals. Left to the elements these remains decayed very rapidly. I could if required locate some exact places where as a child I found dead animals. I can guarantee that those places would come up tracless of the remains I encountered in my youth. Sasquatach was an animal or at best a minimal human and as such when it died its remains faced the same fate of any other forest dweller. So much for the New World.
Crow, these lines (fossils, remains, scavenging activities, etc.) have been followed here several times before. I and other posters already pointed many of the flaws on such reasonings. Its again the "bigfoot of the gaps". And the gaps seem to be too small to hide a bigfoot.

Of course, maybe as you read this, someone is finding a bone of a big bipedal ape which will change the current knoweledge status. But so far, I am not aware of a single piece of reliable evidence that can back bigfeet, extinct or not. Even tought this does not "prove" they are not here right now or were here, the sum of what we know leaves little room for their existence.

If you say bigfeet-like creatures lived in Africa or Asia, I'll say OK, you're right. If you say similar animals may have lived in North America, I'll say OK, you are correct. If you say bigfeet-like animals lived in the Americas, I'll say, they may have lived, but we have no evidence of it. So, my position is there were none, untill some bone is found and proves me wrong.

Since the Old World contains a far greater fossil record than the New World, and virtually all of the known ancient hominids its just a matter of time before a fossil is found that will bridge the gap between smallish biped subhumans and larger and heavier biped sub humans.
And these "larger biped subhumans" would be exactly which species? Or you are just supposing there is or was a large bigfoot-like species in the Americas? Once again, please note that there are no reliable evidences to to back this supposition. If I am wrong, please show me the evidences. There may have been, but we have no evidences.

As for North American reports of Sasquatach/Bigfoot creatures occuring in the 19th Century one either concludes that everyone with such a report ,then as now, is a liar or portrayer of cavalier tales or that some are accurate reportages and recorders of such.
A detailed tale without anything of material, substantial to back it is not reliable. And please try to avoid the "skeptics say eyewitnesses are liars" fallacy.

There are other options- mistaken identifications, intentional or not distortions of the original fact (by the witness and/or by those who tell the tale), etc. We've discussed countless times the problems with the accuracy of eyewitnesses' reports. You can find these discussions by the search function.

Since in the previous two centuries people were much more connected to the land and spent a great deal more time actually on it who's report are you going to trust? That of a hunter, trapper, farmer, or Native living during a period where the wholesale rape of nature had not yet occured? Or that of a modern hunk of consumer society flab that's never actually known wilderness or the potentials contained within?
Seems quite a romantic question for me, with some points in common with the "bon sauvage" idea...
Reports, be them ancient or recent, be them from a hunter, a trapper, a redneck, an urbanoid, or a Native American, I think none of them fullfill a minimum standard for evidence quality.

(*) Think of "skeptic" as a person who uses critical thinking. A skeptical is not an unbeliever. A skeptic is someone who requires evidence and critical thinking to form an opinion, and this opinion will change as soon as evidence is available. We usually set the bar for evidence quality above the level most people set and quite often take a more conservative approach. A skeptic may, for some people, be taken as "unimaginative", "boring" or "shy" because we do not have the habit of making (OK, we do make them, we just avoid telling people about them) and defending some bold or wild speculations.
 
Correa

Then you know all there is to know about the subject. Publish a paper. This discussion is a waste of electrons.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom