Some skeptics will agree that Sas/BF could have existed and some adamantly will deny such a possibility. It comes down to an opoinion.
You are making an oversimplification. First of all, define the type of bigfoot creature we're talking about. All of us skeptics(*) will deny the possibility of Beckjord's and Historian's bigfeet being real. I guess the same is valid for talking bigfeet living with some family at a farm...
I think you will have a hard time finding quotes from skeptics here saying bigfeet-like creatures (past and present) are impossible. What you will find are quotes saying there's no reliable evidence that such creatures are alive nowadays somewhere in the world or existed in North America. Of course, it also depends on how you approach the bigfoot phenomena. This is related to one of the core questionings we make- the (lack of) criteria used by bigfoot investigators. If you accept all the aspects of the phenomena, we'll say "no way". If you accept a few of them, we'll ask you why, and so far the answers were found to lack consistency and substance.
Once again, Crow, do you realy think that an opinion (or a speculation) built over reliable evidence has the same value of one based in nothing substantial?
New World primates exist which confirms that the Old World does not have an exclusive claim to primate evoloution. The fossil record of New World Primates is very sparce but primates were here as early as 14 million years ago.
Any of them looked vaguely like bigfoot?
Not that I'm aware of.
The closest things are two large fossil monkeys (
Caipora bambuirorum and another one I can't remember the name right now) found at caves in South America. The search function will be helpfull if you want to find more info on this aspect, right at this sub-forum.
As I'm not certain as to how long it takes a fossil to form I don't know if what we find in the way of human bones dating back 15- 20 thousand years whether these are still bone or whether they are in some state of fossilization.
How long it takes for fossilization? Depends on the fossilization process. In limestone caves, for example, it may be just a few years. For our present discussion, it really doesn't matter if a bone was completely substituted by minerals or not. What matters is that there are no evidences for a bigfoot-like creature in North America's past (and present) times.
However ancient human remains are somewhat easier to find due to the fact that humans leave traces of where they've inhabited, fire pits, rubbish, tools. And most importantly we've been burrying our dead since almost the beginning which increases the the odds of preservation and later exumation immensely. How many mammal sleletons do you suppose still exist on the PNW forest floor from a death that occured 150 years ago? When I was growing up in a rural area I frequently encountered dead animals. Left to the elements these remains decayed very rapidly. I could if required locate some exact places where as a child I found dead animals. I can guarantee that those places would come up tracless of the remains I encountered in my youth. Sasquatach was an animal or at best a minimal human and as such when it died its remains faced the same fate of any other forest dweller. So much for the New World.
Crow, these lines (fossils, remains, scavenging activities, etc.) have been followed here several times before. I and other posters already pointed many of the flaws on such reasonings. Its again the "bigfoot of the gaps". And the gaps seem to be too small to hide a bigfoot.
Of course, maybe as you read this, someone is finding a bone of a big bipedal ape which will change the current knoweledge status. But so far, I am not aware of a single piece of reliable evidence that can back bigfeet, extinct or not. Even tought this does not "prove" they are not here right now or were here, the sum of what we know leaves little room for their existence.
If you say bigfeet-like creatures lived in Africa or Asia, I'll say OK, you're right. If you say similar animals may have lived in North America, I'll say OK, you are correct. If you say bigfeet-like animals lived in the Americas, I'll say, they may have lived, but we have no evidence of it. So, my position is there were none, untill some bone is found and proves me wrong.
Since the Old World contains a far greater fossil record than the New World, and virtually all of the known ancient hominids its just a matter of time before a fossil is found that will bridge the gap between smallish biped subhumans and larger and heavier biped sub humans.
And these "larger biped subhumans" would be exactly which species? Or you are just supposing there is or was a large bigfoot-like species in the Americas? Once again, please note that there are no reliable evidences to to back this supposition. If I am wrong, please show me the evidences. There may have been, but we have no evidences.
As for North American reports of Sasquatach/Bigfoot creatures occuring in the 19th Century one either concludes that everyone with such a report ,then as now, is a liar or portrayer of cavalier tales or that some are accurate reportages and recorders of such.
A detailed tale without anything of material, substantial to back it is not reliable. And please try to avoid the "skeptics say eyewitnesses are liars" fallacy.
There are other options- mistaken identifications, intentional or not distortions of the original fact (by the witness and/or by those who tell the tale), etc. We've discussed countless times the problems with the accuracy of eyewitnesses' reports. You can find these discussions by the search function.
Since in the previous two centuries people were much more connected to the land and spent a great deal more time actually on it who's report are you going to trust? That of a hunter, trapper, farmer, or Native living during a period where the wholesale rape of nature had not yet occured? Or that of a modern hunk of consumer society flab that's never actually known wilderness or the potentials contained within?
Seems quite a romantic question for me, with some points in common with the "bon sauvage" idea...
Reports, be them ancient or recent, be them from a hunter, a trapper, a redneck, an urbanoid, or a Native American, I think none of them fullfill a minimum standard for evidence quality.
(*) Think of "skeptic" as a person who uses critical thinking. A skeptical is not an unbeliever. A skeptic is someone who requires evidence and critical thinking to form an opinion, and this opinion will change as soon as evidence is available. We usually set the bar for evidence quality above the level most people set and quite often take a more conservative approach. A skeptic may, for some people, be taken as "unimaginative", "boring" or "shy" because we do not have the habit of making (OK, we do make them, we just avoid telling people about them) and defending some bold or wild speculations.