Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
The extraordinary element to be explained by the skeptics is the nature of the extraordinary suit. That is to say present a model of how it was made. Dosen't have to be actual suit just a good explaination. For the believer provide proof its not a suit. But the PGF and not the Bigfoot question in general is the topic of this thread so that is the item demanding extraordinary proof. Dfoot so far has provided the best skeptic evidence to date.
This is a bigfoot enthusiast attempt to mask and present again the 'realism' angle. Nothing about the suit is extraordinary. Everything that has been claimed as such has been shown as ordinary. A more appropriate description is 'ridiculous'. As in the hairy missiles in the middle of the she-thing's torso and the diaper butt are ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
One very good copy was used for Worlds Greatest Hoaxes, according to Bob Kiviat it is a copy from the master whichever one that is but you can see it is good quality...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IKZP4A2Si-Y

Outstanding! That is probably the highest quality version of the PGF that I have seen yet. Rich color and focused detail. It's no wonder that the Dahinden Cibrachromes look so good.

Here is another National Geographic clip with the film..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dr4dTXGSsSs

Thanks. We recently reviewed that one. Davis claims to see mid-tarsal break Patty tracks as well as Patterson bootprints.
 
It's got some interesting elements. There are obviously flipped scenes. The Roger riding at Bluff Creek scene, plaster pour scene and panned view of the footprints are all excellent quality. They also mix in some Dahinden Cibachromes, and you could be fooled into thinking these are still frames from the PGF copy they are using.
 
Just glanced at this discussion for the first time in a while. Astonished to see the same arguments still rolling around.

It's all really quite funny. Consider:

  • The suit in the PGF isn't extraordinary. That point has been demonstrated time and again.
  • Reputable, award-winning FX artists and individuals in the motion picture industry have pointed out in detail why the film is a hoax.
  • Major details about the film (date and time of photography, processing time, clear indications of edits) either remain questionable or point to tampering.
  • The character of the "lucky" cameraman doesn't stand up to close scrutiny, and lends itself towards the hoax hypothesis.

There's more, but the point is this: Even one of those points above should immediately raise a red flag about the authenticity of the Patterson-Gimlin Film of 1967. That these points are either justified with astonishing leaps of logic, or ignored outright does more to discredit the PGF than any skeptic has done in the past forty-one years.

Proponents have had forty-one years to produce a similar film, or the animal itself. Neither has occurred.

By contrast, non-proponent investigations have produced a series of questions that damage claims to its authenticity.

At this point, the rational response to the PGF is to dismiss it as a hoax. If a tenth of the energy that has been wasted on analyzing the blurry blobs on screen had been turned into, I don't know, actual field investigations, there might actually be more evidence of such an animal to discuss. (Or not, as is more likely.)

(Somehow, though, I have a feeling that certain individuals in the Bigfoot world are well aware of that fact...)

I'd love to be wrong about this topic. I'd be ecstatic if someone trotted out the big monkey -- complete with diaper butt and nose-cone boobs -- and said "Ain't this is one weird looking primate?" I'd eat crow with glee. Unfortunately, the evidence as it exists today clearly points to this being a man in a not-particularly-convincing suit.

To date, I have yet to see a PGF proponent offer up something close to that kind of admission. They defend this film as an article of faith, logic and evidence be damned.

So...where is the Big Monkey again?
 
Last edited:
Sweaty's argument vs the skeptics argument concerning proof is a valid one. Because the issue of the PGF is inconclusive from both sides of the argument it is equally extraordinary to claim its a man in a suit as it is to claim its a real animal.

I completely disagree because you can not put a man and a suit (which can and do exist) on the same level as an object that has not been proven to exist. You might as well say that the argument that it is an alien or fairy has equal footing as well.
I notice you also state the suit is "extraordinary". What is "extraordinary" about it? I have seen nothing to suggest that an "extraordinary" suit is required to create this illusion.
 
Now comes the part of the loop where the bigfoot enthusiast, realizing themselves unable to meaningfully define the 'realism' they speak of, looks for any kind of out and breaks for the appeal to authority with something along the lines of "Well, Meldrum thinks it's real."

That's where you pass them Meldrum's creduloid hat with a quote of his saying that he can see bouncing breasts in the Memorial Day Footage.
 
What's going on in the lower right hand corner? Some sort of odd impression in the soil. This is the first time I have gotten this good a look at these frames.

hoaxesBF_2008-02-27_13_53_00_359.jpg


hoaxesBF_2008-02-27_13_51_45_187.jpg


hoaxesBF_2008-02-27_13_53_56_687.jpg
 
Weird, do you have any more shots of the ground like that?

What is that thing in the lower right? what is that V shaped thing?
 
Yeah looks like a stick.

I'd like to see block foot, side by side with that footprint.
That doesn't even look close to being from a foot like perfect foot or block foot
 
So this description of mine is wrong. The left end of the log is buried, that's why it disappears and that whole area on the left is just flat land.



This is also incorrect. The creek is not going where I thought it was and those are not it's banks.



That whole edge is the right bank of the creek and it is flowing as WP earlier noted, either towards or away from the camera.
 
Last edited:
Crowlogic wrote:
Sweaty's argument vs the skeptics argument concerning proof is a valid one.
Because the issue of the PGF is inconclusive from both sides of the argument it is equally extraordinary to claim its a man in a suit as it is to claim its a real animal.


Well said, CL. :)

Patty's actual identity (man or beast) is still, after all these years, ambiguous. Even skeptics on this board admit to that being the case.
The fact that her identity is ambiguous, and not obvious, makes her "extraordinary".
All the Bigfoot/gorilla suits that I've seen are instantly recognizable as suits.

This one...(excuse me while I laugh) takes less then a tenth of a second to figure out....

gorilla55a.jpg




And this, more elaborate suit, complete with body contour...is easily recognizable as a "chump-in-a-suit"....(though this one may take upwards of 15 seconds to decide whether or not it's a real beast)...;)...

Gsuit4a.jpg



I've yet to see any suit that was even the least bit ambiguous....when it's seen in full view.
 
Last edited:
That's right, Devnull...nobody here has to do anything.





You're right...they do!




Sure it is.....since, after 40 years, no monkey-suit-in-motion has ever come close to replicating the realism of Patty.

Like I said in my post last night...can you direct me to a video of one? :)

I did it yesterday in my back yard. But the dog ate the homework.
 
And this, more elaborate suit, complete with body contour...is easily recognizable as a "chump-in-a-suit"....(though this one may take upwards of 15 seconds to decide whether or not it's a real beast)...;)...


Now film that suit from 100' away, shakey, out of focus, and over-exposed, with a camera from the 60s.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom