Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
By 'human', I wasn't refering to Patty being a real wild creature, but some form of human....as MK Davis has stated he thinks she is.

That's why you shouldn't have substituted "human" for "man in a suit" for me.

Of course, "some form of human" would include newfound bipedal hairy primates and human men in suits, I guess.
 
SweatyYeti wrote:
By 'human', I wasn't refering to Patty being a real wild creature, but some form of human....as MK Davis has stated he thinks she is.

That's why you shouldn't have substituted "human" for "man in a suit" for me.

Of course, "some form of human" would include newfound bipedal hairy primates and human men in suits, I guess.


I think you misunderstood what I was saying in that quote of mine, above. I didn't word it very clearly.

By "human" I meant "a man in a suit".....that's all.


Can you respond to this earlier post of mine....and answer the questions I asked you in it....

In response to my post:
Quote:
So, "Patty is a human, until proven otherwise" does not mean it has been proven, and it's not a definite, right?

Is that what you mean?

LTC wrote:
Not exactly...



Can you answer the first question, LTC... directly, with a 'yes' or a 'no'....and explain your answer?

Also, what do you mean by... "Not exactly"?
 
Last edited:
LTC wrote:
SweatyYeti wrote:
Quote:
Can you respond to this earlier post of mine....and answer the questions I asked you in it....




Not surprising. Another skeptic bites the dust! :D

It happens over and over again....when it gets down to the point where the skeptic's argument is about to be exposed for what it truly is....garbage....the skeptic runs away. :)

kitakaze ran away on Melissa's board....and LTC just ran, here.

This happened several times over on the BFF, in debates I had with skeptics such as RayG, scotto, wolftrax...and others. They debated to a certain point...and then they refused to answer ANY more questions.

It says a lot when someone refuses to continue a debate, while on a discussion board. They're afraid.


To highlight LTC's statements....first he says...

"Patty IS a "man-in-a-suit"...until proven otherwise".

But when asked if that means Patty is definitely "a man-in-a-suit"...he says....

"Not exactly". :boggled:

Oh, I see! :)
 
Last edited:
LTC wrote:



Not surprising. Another skeptic bites the dust! :D

It happens over and over again....when it gets down to the point where the skeptic's argument is about to be exposed for what it truly is....garbage....the skeptic runs away. :)

kitakaze ran away on Melissa's board....and LTC just ran, here.

This happened several times over on the BFF, in debates I had with skeptics such as RayG, scotto, wolftrax...and others. They debated to a certain point...and then they refused to answer ANY more questions.

It says a lot when someone refuses to continue a debate, while on a discussion board. They're afraid.


To highlight LTC's statements....first he says...

"Patty IS a "man-in-a-suit"...until proven otherwise".

But when asked if that means Patty is definitely "a man-in-a-suit"...he says....

"Not exactly". :boggled:

Oh, I see! :)

It's a man in a suit.

I know this because I have seen men in suits.

They all look just like that.

Put on that suit and run around with a bunch of cowboys with guns and a logging crew around. Good Luck.
 
The wisdom of Diogenes....
So far, I am not aware of any evidence which indicates with any degree of likeliness, however small, that Bigfoot creatures exist....anywhere in the world.

I'm sure everyone would get a chuckle out of that at MABRC or the BFRO , but here, it is really a compliment ..


Don't you guys forget .... I am very wise ... :D
 
LTC wrote:
This happened several times over on the BFF, in debates I had with skeptics such as RayG, scotto, wolftrax...and others. They debated to a certain point...and then they refused to answer ANY more questions.

It says a lot when someone refuses to continue a debate, while on a discussion board. They're afraid.
That's a lie. What happened was you couldn't discuss anything civilly, you would pepper your remarks with ad homs and that eventually got you banned. That's what ended the discussions with you. You never won any argument with me or any of the people you mentioned.

Your method of arguing involves circular reasoning, evasiveness and answering questions with questions. You're doing the same thing here and everyone knows it. When was the last time you answered any question that involved any thinking?
Your favorite line is, "I don't have time right now but I'll get to it soon." Then you never do "get to it".

You want to go back to debating the MDV? We can't do it BFF but you are registered at BFD. Come on over Sweaty, don't be skeered.
Baby on the back, floppy breasts...ROTFLMFAO
 
To highlight LTC's statements....first he says...

"Patty IS a "man-in-a-suit"...until proven otherwise".

But when asked if that means Patty is definitely "a man-in-a-suit"...he says....

"Not exactly".

Sweaty is lying, of course. I never said that patty was a man in a suit. I stated that as the position of the scientific community, not as my personal position. Thus my reply of "Not exactly" when Sweaty asked me what I meant.

That's why I said I couldn't answer the questions, of course.

I knew you were just baiting me, Sweaty.

Just another pathetic Sweaty attempt to twist someone's words...
 
Not only that, but Sweaty already tried this trick once of trying to claim that I said that patty is a man in a suit. I didn't say it before and I still haven't said that patty is a man in a suit.
 
The National Geographic program "Is It Real? Bigfoot" is quite good. I had not ever seen it on television, and I had been working with YouTube segments dubbed in Spanish called "Pie Grande". Thanks to LTC, I now have a chance to see the full production as it was broadcast. This program has a 2006 copyright, and this may have been the year it was first shown as well. I have found no evidence that this program is available for sale on DVD or VHS.

The program does very little to support Bigfoot as a real animal. This is in spite of numerous Bigfooters and their evidences being presented. From my perspective, it does a decent job (for mass media entertainment) of showing that Bigfootery is not about an animal, and is instead about people and their interest in participating in a modern myth.

All Bigfooters voluntarily decide to become a part of this belief group. There does not seem to be anything in particular (survival necessities or social requirements, etc.) that forces a person to become a Bigfooter. Members of this group sometimes say that an eyewitness encounter is often a singular event which compels a person to enter the community of Bigfooters. This is still a voluntary act nonetheless. Those claiming eyewitness encounters have the option of remaining anonymous (by various means), but again this is still a voluntary move to offer an encounter report while remaining anonymous. In this case, the presented encounter story itself is not anonymous, but instead the person behind it is.

National Geographic has a long-standing history of being a generally excellent organization that brings the real world to almost any armchair. For more than a century, their magazine has allowed folks to see and learn about the world without leaving their own home. But NG has also always been packaged and marketed to its consumers. Their modern television productions reflect modern consumer appetites. They give us all what we want. You get the good with the bad. Sensationalism must rule because it’s what pays the bills. The share- and stake-holders become increasingly hungry as the mass media market expands exponentially.

The NG Bigfoot program was narrated by Will Lyman. He is also the voice of “Frontline”, and may be one of the most recognizable and powerful documentary narrators in the modern American age. Nonetheless, NG got punked by the Bigfooters.

The program features two notable Bigfoot skeptics. These are David Daegling and Benjamin Radford. There should be little doubt that the production of this NG program was like many others. The NG producers, production staff and contractors should not be expected to lurk among the Internet pro-Bigfoot forums, nor those that are skeptical. They have a ‘day job’ called ‘Creating National Geographic Documentary Programs’ for mass appeal and modern relevance. Now enters the punking of National Geographic by Bigfootery. Daegling and Radford can only comment on what is put before, and asked of, them. They are not likely to be presented with what the Bigfooters have also contributed to the NG production team. NG cannot act as a mediator between rival factions – and so it only just presents both sides as it receives them. NG acts in good faith and allows both sides to present their position and argument. The end product (the actual program) will be seen by both sides, and each may imagine that it could have been done better (more supportive for their own side) if only that had been given the chance to influence NG after seeing what the other side presented.

These are only two examples of the punking of NG by the Bigfooters:

1) NG narrator first asks the open question (about the PGF): “What about the guy in the suit?” Then adds the following “fact”, which is the punking: “Several people have come forward over the years to claim that particular honor.” The truth is that only Bob Heironimus has come forward with this confession.

2) A full-frame version of the PGF is shown numerous times. It contains a repeated scene showing the driftwood. This is not the only difference we see when comparing this film copy version to other versions. Did nobody notice this? Nobody? Nobody at all?

Has the whole world reached a point of jaded post-modernity that neither skeptics, nor believers, really even care what is real anymore? Has anything really changed about humanity? Just what is the modern age? If Peter Jackson can bring King Kong to life by using high-tech software, does he actually bring an enormous gorilla to the real world? Should everyone look over their shoulder and listen for smashing trees when walking on remote and foggy islands?
 
Whether the evidence is the PGF, mid-tarsal prints, Skookum butts, eyewitness accounts, whisps of hair, or clumps of unidentified DNA, Dennett hit the nail on the head with these remarks:

"The argument for Bigfoot rests on the promoters' ability to interpret the evidence and judge it authentic. The public and the scientific community remain unimpressed because obviously such evaluations are highly subjective." -- Michael Dennett, Skeptical Inquirer, Summer 1987, page 411.

RayG
 
Hello, William. I do not think that is anything M.K. did. According to what M.K. told me, he examined that clip frame by frame, and at the end he said he saw writing on it that said "American Bigfoot." He speculated that it may have been the original movie film because American National Enterprises (ANE) had possession of the original film, and someone from the National Geographic may have gone to ANE while they still had the film in their possession and made a 1-inch tape copy of it, the entire film. You can tell that it is from NG because the NG logo is on the bottom right-hand corner, so it is safe to assume that this copy of the film that I got from YouTube is from the National Geographic special that was done a few years ago which somebody probably extracted from the DVD copy (yes, there is a DVD of this production, I have it). The Bigfoot program was put together on a promotional DVD with two other National Geographic Programs, one on Tattoos and the other on Hurricanes.


Hope this clears things up for you, William.

Thank you, Henry. I have more questions because some things are not clear. You seem to be in a position to possibly provide some answers.

Your Bigfoot website features this NG clip of the PGF that we are talking about. Is your clip simply a link to another YouTube clip posting? IOW, I am asking you if this NG PGF clip is actually the product of some other YouTube member. If so, could you please provide the actual hyperlink to the original YouTube PGF video that you are featuring on your site?

You have talked to MK Davis about this clip, and you say he has examined it "frame by frame". In general, I think that that is a good thing. Did MK mention anything to you about seeing strange repeated scenes? Did he mention seeing the repeating driftwood scene, and pose any kind of outspoken mystery concerning this?

Did he mention the writing on the film? When I watch the NG program, I only see the writing after the Patty walk. Yet, the clip featured on your site shows writing before, and after the Patty walk. Did MK talk to you about this apparent mystery? Can you yourself solve this issue by watching the NG DVD that you have? Does that DVD show the writing before and after the Patty walk? Can anyone go and buy this NG Bigfoot DVD that you have now?

You mention that MK speculates that NG got their hands on the "original movie film" from ANE. Does he believe that this "original movie film" does indeed contain the repeated driftwood scene?

What about this reference to "1-inch tape copy"? Does MK have any information on this? Did he talk to NG and learn that their material on hand (showing the ANE original movie film) is in the form of 1-inch digital tape?

Henry, are you interested in trying to know these things just like I am? Can I possibly infect you with the same intrigue into the PGF that I hold? Many in the Bigfooter community say that the "original PGF" is lost (missing), or is really being held in some vault (Florida?).

I wonder if this NG PGF clip (from ANE) is actually a copy of what everyone is calling the "original PGF". Do you wonder this too?

I hope that I haven't asked too many questions of you. I think you can provide at least some of the answers. Maybe that is because you are friends with MK Davis, and he had a sort of connection to National Geographic during the 2006 production of Is It Real? Bigfoot.
 
Whether the evidence is the PGF, mid-tarsal prints, Skookum butts, eyewitness accounts, whisps of hair, or clumps of unidentified DNA, Dennett hit the nail on the head with these remarks:

"The argument for Bigfoot rests on the promoters' ability to interpret the evidence and judge it authentic. The public and the scientific community remain unimpressed because obviously such evaluations are highly subjective." -- Michael Dennett, Skeptical Inquirer, Summer 1987, page 411.

Dennett wastes no time in arguing with Bigfoot believers and researchers. Dawkins wastes no time in arguing with Creationism believers and researchers. Do you think that they know something we don't? Or, do they just fear the SweatyYetis of the world? Hmmmm.....
 
Of course, Gimlin wastes no time arguing with PGF skeptics either.

These folks are either onto something, or they are terribly closed-minded. Now what?
 
Question:
If someone says "Patty is a man in a suit, until proven otherwise"....why should that mean anything to me...or to anyone else?

OK fine..... saying that every possible position is equally *invalid* is just as wrong.

Why should it mean anything to you? Because it is based in *current reality*. Once again, we have solid evidence man exists. We have solid evidence monkey suits exist. We have no solid evidence that BF exists, in any form. Therefore, the default position must be that patty is a guy in a suit.

Claiming that it is just as invalid as "patty is 2 tonne of horse excrement" is the height of intellectual dishonesty.

Patty is a guy in a suit until proven otherwise. You're just sore because there *is no proof*. This is akin to the people who rant about the MDC - they only have a problem with the challenge because they cannot actually do what they claim they can. With Patty, if you had *any* evidence of Patty being real whatsoever, you wouldnt care at all about default positions.

So, once again - provide solid evidence of BF's existence and we can start rethinking the default position.
 
Quote from JERF "The US Government is not doing its job if it ignores Bigfoot and does not fund Bigfoot research."

Uncle Sam hasn't ignored the Bigfoot issue! Hence the Men In Brown! My neighbors collage roomate's brother had a close encounter with a Bigfoot in 1996 and even got in a few good photos on 35mm film. He dropped of the film for processing and when he went back to collect it he was told that the film had been picked up and paid for in cash by a man claiming to be my neighbors collage roomate's brother. The photo clerk described the person who picked up the developed film as being tall in brown attire and dark sunglasses. The man in brown after picking up the photos was met in the parking lot by another man in brown and the two men studied the photos for a few moments before getting into a brown Grumman step van with government plates. The clerk was emphatic that these men were not UPS drivers because it was in mid August and the men in brown were wearing long pants and long sleeve shirts and everyone knows that in August UPS drivers are in Shorts. Even in the somewhat northerly area of Billings MT where the incident took place.
 
Last edited:
I couldn't help it. Make certain the clerk gets a copy of this.

The MIB wear brown suits with brown shirts. Their clothes seem to be brand new and fit perfectly, as if tailor-made

MIB have dark complexions and have an almost Oriental or 'foreign' appearance

MIB have 'expressionless' facial features

They speak formally, using stiff phrases that sound like they come from a Hollywood 'B' movie script

They travel in groups of three

When travelling in groups, the Men In brown look almost identical and walk in 'formation'

MIB use large brown old-fashioned cars, usually brown vans in the United States and
Rolls Royce or Jaguars in England.

These cars appear to be brand new and sometimes sport 'strange' insignia or logos

MIB have smooth featureless skin and a distinct lack of facial hair ( it has been suggested that they look like they dont need to shave)

They have shiny brown hair which is always impeccably groomed

Men In Brown seem to know things about the Bf, not told anyone before

Men In Brown have 'unusually' broad shoulders and narrow waists

They also walk upright with a 'stiff ' gait, similiar to Patty

MIB seem capable of doing 'impossible' things, like making themselves
appear or disappear without trace
 
Quote from JERF "The US Government is not doing its job if it ignores Bigfoot and does not fund Bigfoot research."

Uncle Sam hasn't ignored the Bigfoot issue! Hence the Men In Brown! My neighbors collage roomate's brother had a close encounter with a Bigfoot in 1996 and even got in a few good photos on 35mm film. He dropped of the film for processing and when he went back to collect it he was told that the film had been picked up and paid for in cash by a man claiming to be my neighbors collage roomate's brother. The photo clerk described the person who picked up the developed film as being tall in brown attire and dark sunglasses. The man in brown after picking up the photos was met in the parking lot by another man in brown and the two men studied the photos for a few moments before getting into a brown Grumman step van with government plates. The clerk was emphatic that these men were not UPS drivers because it was in mid August and the men in brown were wearing long pants and long sleeve shirts and everyone knows that in August UPS drivers are in Shorts. Even in the somewhat northerly area of Billings MT where the incident took place.

I posted this earlier today on the BFF while lamenting the lack of tangible evidence for large hairy critters, but I see it works equally well on either forum.

RayG said:
From the movie Forrest Bigfoot's Day Off:

Economics Teacher: "Bigfoot?... Bigfoot?... Bigfoot?"

Simone: Um, he's sick. My best friend's sister's boyfriend's brother's girlfriend heard from this guy who knows this kid who's going with the girl who saw Forrest pass out at 31 Flavors last night. I guess it's pretty serious.

Sounds like Simone is describing the origin of your bigfoot story.

Did you actually speak with your neighbors college roomate's brother? The clerk? Do you have one single shred of evidence that the story is more than a tall tale?

RayG
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom