Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've yet to see any suit that was even the least bit ambiguous....when it's seen in full view.

You seem to miss the point that the individual/creature in the PGF is not seen in full view at close range. This is not a valid comparison of the PGF. To be an accurate comparison, the suit has to be filmed under the same conditions with the same equipment. Anything else just demonstrates a very biased point of view.
 
Sweaty's argument vs the skeptics argument concerning proof is a valid one. Because the issue of the PGF is inconclusive from both sides of the argument it is equally extraordinary to claim its a man in a suit as it is to claim its a real animal.

You're kidding right? This is seriously one of the dumbest things Ive ever heard.

Ive heard of "appeal to authority", but never "appeal to retarded cousin".
 
Well kids I think both sides need to produce something. That something is from the skeptic side a suit shown in a period style film that recreates the PGF to such a quality that even the dimmest of the dim will look at it and say shucks its just like the PGF. The proponents on the believer side need to produce a Sasquatch, dead or alive. The skeptics have IMO the easier of the two tasks.

Recently scientists were debating whether or not an ancient feathered dinosaur could fly or not. One group believed that yes it could fly and the other believed it didn't. Simply detailed studyof the bones it seemed was inconclusive. So a model of the dinosaur was built and wind tunnel tested. The wind tunnel test proved whether the little dinosaur could fly.
 
Last edited:
Well kids I think both sides need to produce something. That something is from the skeptic side a suit shown in a period style film that recreates the PGF to such a quality that even the dimmest of the dim will look at it and say shucks its just like the PGF. .

The problem with the "produce the suit" demand is that is a subjective test and not a quantitative result. Again, it is not a matter of a suit but filming a person in a suit under the same or very similar conditions to that of PGF. This means the same equipment, lighting, location, etc. Such a test might be done but it will resolve nothing. No matter how good the suit, proponents will state that it does not look as good as PGF. Therefore, they can claim that Patty is bigfoot. This is the problem with your "test" of the bigfoot suit.

The more likely option continues to be a man in a suit until somebody produces a bigfoot or undisputable evidence of a bigfoot thus swinging the possibility towards a potential bigfoot actually being filmed. I suggest that the proponents step up their act because after 40 years, the most significant piece of evidence for bigfoot appears to be this film. To me, that says a lot and just improves the probability of the PGF being a hoax.
 
That something is from the skeptic side a suit shown in a period style film that recreates the PGF to such a quality that even the dimmest of the dim will look at it and say shucks its just like the PGF.

No, skeptics don't need to produce such a suit for any reason whatsoever, nor should they. The burden is entirely on the believers, no matter how many attempts to shift it.

If such a suit were produced by skeptics, the claim would simply be that the skeptics spent a lot of money and copied Patty, so of course the suit looks like Patty.

Making a Patty suit would be a total waste of time and money, as we have already seen with other suits and fake feet and much skeptic work done to explain things such as "dermal ridges" and "sasquatch body prints".
 
The problem is believers aren't going to make a suit that works. And skeptics aren't going to tramp around the woods looking for Sasquatch. When Randi set out to disprove Uri Geller he produced the bi metal spoons. The way to disprove the PGF is to recreate the PGF.

I'll offer another scenerio where myths were disproved by recreating the object of the myth. Case in point is the Gee Bee racer of the 1930's (Gee Bees were racing planes of outlandish design). Myth said that the aircraft were only margionally flyable and a number of pilots died in them. But one pilot set out to make an accurate reproduction of a Gee Bee and over the course of several years of flying it at airshows proved that not only is the Gee Bee flyable and controlable but excells in some flight modes. But without a flying example the myths would have never been tempered. That's why we need a new PGF. It'll be expensive but have you priced a gallon of gas lately? Everything is expensive. It was expensive for Roger Patterson too.
 
The problem is believers aren't going to make a suit that works. And skeptics aren't going to tramp around the woods looking for Sasquatch.

You consider that a problem? I call it normal.

None of those examples is relevant, imo.

It was expensive for Roger Patterson too.

It's cheap if you forget to pay for things or forget to return them, and if you have an Al DeAtley.
 
A perfect Patty suit and film made by a skeptic is easily and totally trumped by a small chunk of a bigfoot from a believer.

No contest at all.

The believer has the easiest task and the most powerful evidence available to him. Living bigfoots.
 
A perfect Patty suit and film made by a skeptic is easily and totally trumped by a small chunk of a bigfoot from a believer.

No contest at all.

The believer has the easiest task and the most powerful evidence available to him. Living bigfoots.

But there has been up to now a serious lack of Bigfoot flesh. If given a budget of say 10 million dollars and 24 months time a new recreation of the PGF could be produced as well as a documentary analyzing and confirming the details that get bantered about here and elsewhere. What would the odds be that in 24 months time a real Bigfoot would be brought in? I'm going with a good reproduction of the PGF subject and filming will appear long before somebody brings in a Sasquatch burger.
 
There are very few details visible in the PGF due to the resolution of the film used. Most of the details that are discussed are imaginary. Many of the stills and clips have been enhanced to reduce motion blur and correct colors. This further reduces usable detail.

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/biology/fahrenbach.htm

This is for a good clear film too, which the PGF is not.
 
What a surprise. Sweaty can't handle the arguments and questions put to him so his only response is to ignore them and repeat his same flawed and dismantled arguments. Well, since they are so flawed and simple it is little effort to show it. And again:
Patty's actual identity (man or beast) is still, after all these years, ambiguous. Even skeptics on this board admit to that being the case.
The fact that her identity is ambiguous, and not obvious, makes her "extraordinary".

Sweaty likes to use the word 'ambiguous' in a way that gives the impression that it is basically equally possible as to whether Patty is a man in a suit or a living bigfoot. It is not. Given the established facts that Sweaty is ignoring, it is far, far more likely that Patty is a man in a suit. The fact that we don't have the suit in question or detailed admissions by the party involved is not extraordinary nor does it make the film extraordinary. Neither is the length footers are willing to go to impart faith that the subject is real.

All the Bigfoot/gorilla suits that I've seen are instantly recognizable as suits.
This statement is subjective and without any merit. Stop the evasion and explain why the Hoffman video is easily identifiable, instantly recognizable as a suit. Sweaty will not do this, he will run from it and just repeat himself.


And this, more elaborate suit, complete with body contour...is easily recognizable as a "chump-in-a-suit"....(though this one may take upwards of 15 seconds to decide whether or not it's a real beast)...;)...

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Gorilla%20Suits/Gsuit4a.jpg[/qimg].
If that had been the suit used in the PGF what would the results be? Features of Patty make her look ridiculous also.
 
Forgot to add:
This one...(excuse me while I laugh) takes less then a tenth of a second to figure out....

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/gorilla55a.jpg[/qimg]
That's very weird, why are you laughing? I don't understand your derision. Was this suit made with the intention of convincing people it was a real gorilla? More importantly was the suit made, ever used, or intended to convince people it was a living bigfoot? Why post this picture if that is not the case? Seems like a very intellectually dishonest thing to do. Nobody thinks this is real or ever did. Nobody is supposed to. What's the matter with you, Sweaty? Oh, I remember - A heavy case of bigfoot enthusiasm and denial.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom