Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Also, back on page 222, there was discussion about the scene showing RP making the casts and whether it was flipped. For what it's worth, in the World's Greatest Hoaxes clip, the scene is indeed the other way round, and he is using his left hand to do the work.

 
Last edited:
Astrophotographer wrote:
No matter how good the suit, proponents will state that it does not look as good as PGF. Therefore, they can claim that Patty is bigfoot. This is the problem with your "test" of the bigfoot suit.


People on BOTH sides of the fence should do their analysis for the sake of the analysis itself.....regardless of what they think the "other side" is going to say about it.

Your so-called "reason", Astro, is nothing but a lame excuse.
 
Crowlogic smartly wrote:
Well kids I think both sides need to produce something. That something is from the skeptic side a suit shown in a period style film that recreates the PGF to such a quality that even the dimmest of the dim will look at it and say shucks its just like the PGF. The proponents on the believer side need to produce a Sasquatch, dead or alive. The skeptics have IMO the easier of the two tasks.


I said exactly the same thing myself, Crowlogic...some time ago. :)

The advantage the skeptics have is that suits don't get-up off the shelf, run away and hide in the woods.

Anytime a skeptic wants to, all they need to do is grab a suit, stuff some padding in it, and go for a walk. ;)
They can laugh-off the PG "suit" as an obvious fake....but can't seem to reproduce it. Very strange.
 
Last edited:
Your so-called "reason", Astro, is nothing but a lame excuse.
As I'm sure you realize by now, Astrophotographer, familiar or not, skeptic or not, Sweaty has trouble maintaining civil debate with anyone. Blackdog has some insight:

That's a lie. What happened was you couldn't discuss anything civilly, you would pepper your remarks with ad homs and that eventually got you banned. That's what ended the discussions with you. You never won any argument with me or any of the people you mentioned.

Your method of arguing involves circular reasoning, evasiveness and answering questions with questions. You're doing the same thing here and everyone knows it. When was the last time you answered any question that involved any thinking?
Your favorite line is, "I don't have time right now but I'll get to it soon." Then you never do "get to it".

You want to go back to debating the MDV? We can't do it BFF but you are registered at BFD. Come on over Sweaty, don't be skeered.
Baby on the back, floppy breasts...ROTFLMFAO
As you can see, Sweaty's games are well known. He is petrified to debate me because he knows his bigfoot games can not stand up to reason and logic. A typical Sweaty fallacy:



I said exactly the same thing myself, Crowlogic...some time ago. :)

The advantage the skeptics have is that suits don't get-up off the shelf, run away and hide in the woods.

Anytime a skeptic wants to, all they need to do is grab a suit, stuff some padding in it, and go for a walk. ;)
They can laugh-off the PG "suit" as an obvious fake....but can't seem to reproduce it. Very strange.
Skeptics don't have to but twitch once, lift a single finger, momentarily consider making a single effort towards offering bigfoot enthusiasts anything in the way of a recreation of anything.

Sweaty is a typical footer trying the burden of proof switcheroo. You guys say bigfoot is most likely real and that this goofy film of the hair cans, diaper butt, she-thing shows that. Provide one single that shows a living bigfoot over a man in a suit. Don't waste a single minute trying to duck out of the responsibility of backing your claims. The facts that show the PGF is most likely are a hoax are firmly established. We don't need to recreate squat. There is absolutely zero burden of proof on us.

Sweaty, can you give even one valid reason why there should be any burden on those who dismiss the PGF as reliable evidence? Yet another question to the growing list of those you evade and can't handle.
 
Also, back on page 222, there was discussion about the scene showing RP making the casts and whether it was flipped. For what it's worth, in the World's Greatest Hoaxes clip, the scene is indeed the other way round, and he is using his left hand to do the work.

Thanks, Worm. WGH actually shows the plaster pour scene with both orientations. At 7:11 it is shown the way we have seen it before. If we could only see Roger's shirt buttons, we could know the correct orientation. WGH also shows a Patty walking scene in correct and flipped orientation.
 
People on BOTH sides of the fence should do their analysis for the sake of the analysis itself.....regardless of what they think the "other side" is going to say about it.

However, the bias involved in such analysis is the problem. Proponents of bigfoot will point out the "realism" angle and the skeptics will point out areas that make it appear to be a hoax. It accomplishes very little in resolving the point. The ONLY item that will resolve the PGF is for the proponents to produce indisputable evidence that bigfoot exists. Anything else is not going to resolve anything. Reproductions of the film would be scrutinized by proponents as not being real enough, too much money involved, etc. Where one person sees a body part others will see parts of a suit.

It is not a lame excuse. What is a lame excuse is people who claim bigfoot exists but have little to show to back up the claim. Instead we are treated to a 40-year old film, some tapes of noises, some plaster casts, and blurry indistinct pictures. You would think the proponents, with the great advance in technology over the years could come up with something better than that.

Until better evidence is provided, the best solution to the PGF is that it is a man in a suit.
 
Until better evidence is provided, the best solution to the PGF is that it is a man in a suit.
Astro, I would just like to comment that while it is clear we are on the same/similar train of thought on this matter and I obviously agree with your above post, I just wanted to point out that I find the last sentence to be a simple and elegant summation of the situation. I would like your permission to use it as a signature.
 
The advantage the skeptics have is that suits don't get-up off the shelf, run away and hide in the woods.

Anytime a skeptic wants to, all they need to do is grab a suit, stuff some padding in it, and go for a walk. ;)
They can laugh-off the PG "suit" as an obvious fake....but can't seem to reproduce it. Very strange.

Don't kid yourself. If skeptics did produce an accurate reproduction of the PGF by filming a man in a suit from a good distance away using archaic film equipment, you would claim that it was too easy to stage or does not look real enough. Your bias towards being a bigfoot believer would prevent you from accepting the possibility that the PGF, which you have supported for many years, could be a fake. As a result, skeptics know it would not be worth the effort to get a suit, find a film camera of the type used, go out to the area at the same time of year/day, and shoot the reproduction knowing before hand that proponents would not accept it no matter how "realistic" it appeared.
As for worried about bigfoot running off into the woods, this is also a lame excuse. In forty years, the best proponents can produce for evidence revolves around a short piece of film that is suspected to be a man in a suit. Science marches on but bigfoot research stays firmly planted in 1967. Hmmm...
 
The toes appear to show some sliding. Is this the correct orientation of the toes relative to the rest of the foot? How can this be?

e122956d.jpg

acb96e8a.jpg
 
The toes appear to show some sliding. Is this the correct orientation of the toes relative to the rest of the foot? How can this be?

[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/e122956d.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/acb96e8a.jpg[/qimg]

These photos may have touchup! There seems to be some airbrush effect (digital or actual) near the print. Its noticable right above the little Y shaped twig as a textureless tan fuzzy splotch. Very clean footprints can be flet in soil especailly if the soil has a thin crust where its slightly dried on the surface.
 
These photos may have touchup! There seems to be some airbrush effect (digital or actual) near the print. Its noticable right above the little Y shaped twig as a textureless tan fuzzy splotch.
I think not. What would be the purpose of the airbrush above the twig and the other places that appear smooth? To remove signs of a hoax?
 
Shown with Titmus cast from Patty trackway (flipped and rotated for comparison purposes). Did Titmus pour plaster into this particular print?

22dfee10.jpg

71e7b30f.jpg
 
Believers claim thousands to 100,000 population.

Should be no problem finding one.

100,000!!!! OMG! If there were that many we'd have them as pets by now. The brighter ones would be working at Wal Mart! But on one TV show in the 70's the population was estimated at around 200 and in a fairly localized region. I'm of the opinion they've all bitten the dust.:jaw-dropp
 
My apologies for my doggedness to others but I'm just going to keep score in-thread of my posts that address Sweaty's arguments that I believe he's evading (for the purpose of easy future reference or quoting):

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3464064#post3464064

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3466952#post3466952

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3472481#post3472481

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3476578#post3476578

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3476662#post3476662

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3479210#post3479210

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3479236#post3479236

Also a note that this list is not supposed to be a list of every recent post I made addressing Sweaty that wasn't responded to. I'm not interested in badgering Sweaty, only directly and thoroughly addressing erroneous arguments he makes regarding bigfoot. Thus it is only meant to be a list of recent posts that make detailed and thorough rebuttals to Sweaty's arguments which I believe to be erroneous and Sweaty has continued to post without responding to.

Also, I will be the first to acknowledge that no member is under any obligation to post to any other. This is just an internet forum, after all. It is simply the fact that Sweaty will try to accuse other members of evading him, like going into a Gollum dance when LTC indicates he will not play Sweaty's games, and yet continue to avoid sincere critical debate that motivates me. Finally, I don't pretend that my interactions with Sweaty are sugar-coated but I am confident that I have made no personal attacks in the list of posts above.

As I have said many times, Sweaty, if your interest in critical debate is sincere, if you believe your arguments are valid and sound, then you should have no problem addressing the above posts. At the very least the Hoffman question. You will want to make an excuse about time to post, I'm sure. To that I will point out the ludicrousness of you taking time to write multiple paragraphs of excuses about why you haven't responded to my question why the Hoffman video is easily indetifiable as a man in a suit. What I think we really have here is a thorough demonstration on how your are only here to try and score points on skeptics.
 
Thanks, Worm. WGH actually shows the plaster pour scene with both orientations. At 7:11 it is shown the way we have seen it before. If we could only see Roger's shirt buttons, we could know the correct orientation. WGH also shows a Patty walking scene in correct and flipped orientation.

That'll teach me not to watch the whole clip ;)
 
100,000!!!! OMG! If there were that many we'd have them as pets by now. The brighter ones would be working at Wal Mart! But on one TV show in the 70's the population was estimated at around 200 and in a fairly localized region. I'm of the opinion they've all bitten the dust.:jaw-dropp
Witness with amazement the sheer number and range of places you can pay a meer $300 to have a high chance of being among our hairy brethren:

http://bfro.net/news/roundup/exped_next.asp

Read with wonder the accounts of those happy customers who've been among them:

http://s2.excoboard.com/exco/forum.php?forumid=150505

Ponder with curiosity the wisdom on the numbers of our magnificent bosses of the woods:

http://bfro.net/gdb/show_FAQ.asp?id=415

One problem with any population estimate, even if it is only a theoretical parameter, is that it causes many people to visualize one big herd in one valley representing the entire population. Not everyone can conceive of a four-digit population scattered across a big continent, and thus being so widely scattered that they might never live in groups of more than three or four individuals. One must have a mathematical sense to understand that a few thousand elusive, nocturnal, nomadic individuals that are spread out among millions of square miles would make for a very rare species indeed.

That scenario raises the question of whether a population figure close to the minimal breeding population threshold is too low to explain the number of sighting reports across the continent.
Bigfoot / sasquatch sightings and track finds started being documented more or less from the early 1960's onward. Since that time there have been roughly 3500 documented sightings and track finds that are thought to be credible. The documented sightings and track finds are thought to represent only a fraction of the actual observations by humans in North America during the same time frame. The reports come from basically everywhere across continent where there are coniferous forests. It is likely that many observations and track finds over the years involved the same individuals. But it is also likely that many bigfoots have never been observed by any humans.

In the past when all the objective and subjective considerations have been juggled to come up with upper and lower parameters for a population size, those parameters have usually fallen in the neighborhood of 2000 - 6000.

The higher figures are favored by those who suggest that there would be two to three times as many documented sightings, if Canada and southern Alaska had anywhere near the same human population density as the lower forty-eight states. Humans have to be present for an observation to occur. Where there are no humans, there are no sightings, but there might be just as many bigfoots.

A figure of 2000-6000 would not exceed the reasonableness threshold, but it is well above the minimum breeding population figure.
 
Last edited:
Upstairs in his office, Perez plays the Patterson-Gimlin film on his computer again and again.

He thinks as many as 100,000 Bigfoots could be roaming North America, but he knows he may never find one.

"A lot of early researchers thought we would solve the mystery in a few years, but we haven't," he said. "I can't prove Bigfoot exists, but either someone has been fabricating tracks for over a hundred years or there is a real animal out there."

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2008/01/04/BAFDU8QON.DTL
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom