Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm all for optimism but I'm also a realist.

If the goal was to go back there and look for something physical ( such as the alleged dead Bigfoots from the MK massacre) with new ground penetrating radar and cadaver dogs- yeah because that technology might find them.
First, any claim of legitimate measurements that would meet any scientific or even legal ( the lower standard) criteria is stillborn because the baseline is NOT the factual ORIGINAL ( or a certified true copy) but lets assume it miraculously appears.

This effort is after a "measurement" ( an intangible) because thats what PG is based on. ( measurements and math) So these measurements MUST ( not should) be accurate and reliable or they are hold no weight whatsoever in regards to accuracy or legitimacy.

In order to get that accuracy, one will literally have to determine where his feet were in relation to a referenced frame and object in frame. Thats how it works. Thats the ONLY way it works. ( Imagine building a house to print when the carpenters cut all the boards to "around" a measurement)

I could say there would be a slim chance IF there was a second camera showing where RP was but thats the problem. Placing Patterson.

I am surprised you think that way. You have just invalidated all of forensic photogrammetry. But why would we need physical measurements to determine the IM index? And why would attainable relative measurements be meaningless unless you can convert them into inches/inches?
 
O,

I think a camera distance at 352 of somewhere between 85-90 feet is probably closer to fact. Titmus stated 81 feet at frame 264 (Green 88’), Patterson moved forward and to the right after 264 finally settling down around 320ish. There is a ballpark -18.1% difference in object/clutter/tree/stump size (middle 3rd of image) between 264ish and 320ish, that is, 320ish has to be reduced ballpark 18.1% for the images to begin to line up correctly. The headache is just beginning, do we use Titmus at 81 feet or Green at 88, do we know for certain the gait distance during those frames, do we know the absolute fps, how can we accurately measure the distance from the film to subject as it moves through the plane? One thing is for certain we do not know the subjects relative height and without an accurate measure of distance that will remain a mystery.

I have no problem with trying different SWAG methods but when someone mentions scientific I have to chuckle a bit. The very first project in a scientific analysis would be a 4k scan (if 4k is even justified) followed by a grain analysis to verify the integrity of the film aka crop specs, enlargement numbers if any, method of process, optical vs. wet gate/contact dupe and possibly film generation. Unfortunately, none of that will ever give you the subject’s height or accurately measure the distance from the film to the subject.

The window is closed; the time for data collection was Oct. of 1967. There is one absolute though, they did a horrible job collecting data.

I must admit I’m pretty much with LT across the board on this one. It doesn't mean it wont be fun to look at.


m

That is an important consideration that you have tracked RPs motion during that sequence. If you also note Patty's change of scale you can subtract it from the background changes and track her relative recession from the camera. This has nothing to do with absolute distances and everything to do with relative motion from the camera. If you are seriously attempting to recreate the scene then It sounds like you are on your way. Why so pessimistic? Have you determined that it can not be done?
 
I am surprised you think that way. You have just invalidated all of forensic photogrammetry. But why would we need physical measurements to determine the IM index? And why would attainable relative measurements be meaningless unless you can convert them into inches/inches?

Dude, puhleeze ( this aint the BFF)

>>>You have just invalidated all of forensic photogrammetry.

I have done nothing of the sort

>>>But why would we need physical measurements to determine the IM index?

Technically, you need a physical bone

>>>And why would attainable relative measurements be meaningless unless you can convert them into inches/inches

I doubt even you understand what you were trying to say there.
 
and it's...um..."interesting." Although the attempt at a mask recreation is interesting (and supposedly only cost $3 to make), his other, paredolia-tastic claims cast doubt about the veracity of his claims about the shooting location and how certain stills supposedly don't match the footage (which could be due to the footage he's using to compare being from a later generation print).

Oh, and I think I found MK Davis' Youtube channel.

I dont know which needs the more work- his imagination or my eyesight but this does raise the point of justifying why an analysis of the PGF will never be considered legitimate without the actual original.

It wouldnt matter if it was the PGF, Nessie or your cookout last July 4th. There are questions about this film specifically. Allegations that frames were flipped, hats, horses, people, gunshots, blood, stills not from the video, seams, selective editing and one of those trees looks like a sniper I used to know.

Heres the thing, the PGF is "known" ( in other words the film is out there in many formats for the world to see- stills, clips and versions) so I cant see any reason for the "original" to have such an air of "secrecy" attached to it.

Film analysis is basically 2 parts- the "images" the film captured and the film itself.

The "images" are out there for everyone to see but they all have ( allegedly) been modified in multiple ways for reasons aplenty and all the back engineering cannot account for all them.

So, why is the "in the camera" original such a problem to find or see?

My investigative mind keeps coming back to me that the only reason that makes sense is that theres something on that original that will show to the world that the film is a hoax. I have no proof of that, I'm not stating it as any kind of fact- thats just my gut feeling. ( one would think that if it didnt- why not have it available to verify the accuracy of all next gen copies? Its not like we dont already know what the film is supposed to be. My mind keeps defaulting back to occam and the only answer that makes sense is that theres something on the original someone does NOT want seen)

I've done too many investigations in my life and when theres an "air of mystery" surrounding a key piece of evidence- theres usually an adverse reason attached to it.

Even if nothing else was learned from the original- it would answer the question were any frames removed/altered and it would establish the visual record from the start to the end of the actual roll and that would at least be something.

Anyone have an idea why the "original" is so MIA?
 
Anyone have an idea why the "original" is so MIA?


From a BFF thread that you posted in.


colobus (Owen Caddy) said:
The original film's exact location is known to a handful of people.

To the best of my understanding this is the current situation.

A number of attempts have been made by the copyright holder (and others) to reacquire the original from the current holder. When ANE went bankrupt the original was at the ANE business offices because it was to be incorporated into another documentary. I am unclear if ANE bought it, or was loaned it. I believe Mrs Patterson states that it was on loan. Then the company went bankrupt, and its assets were frozen by the court. The film was collected, along with every other thing in the offices, and those "assets" were sold at action in lots.

When some of the principals in the story realized what had happened, the deed was either already done, or unstoppable. At some point the purchaser learned about the film. ANE had a lot of exposed reels of film, and this PG film was apparently mixed in.

At some point negotiations for the reacquisition of the film were looking good, but apparently Rene Dahinden got involved (as someone who had been sold limited copyright to some portions of the film in Canada) and, again - according to those in the know - Mr. Dahinden's contentious manner sunk the whole deal, and pissed off the new holder of the original film greatly, so that now whenever the matter is broached the holder quotes an unreasonably high price for reacquisition.

The individuals who know where the film is do not want others to again sour the milk, and so they keep the identity of the business holding it to themselves; but it is apparently in Florida.

So that's the stated situation. I've heard that story from a number of people involved. Others may know more. There was that gentleman who was putting together a book with Mrs. Patterson's cooperation, and he supposedly had more info, but that project seems to have fallen off the radar.

If you knew, or know anything about Mr. Dahinden, the story is quite easily believable.

Anyway... for whatever it's worth. Just passing on information.
 
For the "original" to be incriminating it would have to possess one or more of the following:

Clarity that shows evidence of a costume.
Evidence of editing (cut & splice) which reveals that it is not the true original.
Additional (incriminating) scenes (frames) not found in 1st Generation copies.
Processing date stamp that does not coincide with the testimony of P&G.

Anything else?
 
My mind keeps defaulting back to occam and the only answer that makes sense is that theres something on the original someone does NOT want seen)
This is a point I have brought up more than once; here and at BFF ..

Here is a topic I posted over there .

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=21681&hl=

One person was even arguing that removing 75% of the 100 foot reel was not editing ..


As far as we know, all they saw in DeAtley's basement the day after the footage was shot, is the ~ 60 seconds we are seeing now ..

Any number of people insist there is no reason do doubt that Patterson ran out of film, exactly where we see it today .. I contend there is at least one very good reason to doubt it.. That being - The missing film ..


People jokingly ask - " Well, what do you expect to see? BH taking off the head piece ? "

And my reply would be - " Why not ? "

One of the most glaring discrepancies between what we see on the film and the story being told, is that Patty was moving away before he started filming; when it is obvious Patty is taking a first step from a standing position when the footage begins .
 
Can you prove that Sweaty got his working photos from JREF? Since when is the JREF the only source for photos of the Paterson Gimlin film and its related characters? Virtually everything concerning the PGF is availanble from sources outside the JREF. For instance I've obtained photos relating to the the PGF via private sources I've met on various forums and websites.

Yet there are frames we do associate with regular posters. One that comes to mind is the finger flex frames that Sweaty often posts. Its even been commented that hes prone to posting it.

I also asked Mangler if he had any copywrights on his work to which there was no reply. Maybe Sweaty shouldn't ream Mangler concerning the use of public domain/available photos. However he certainly could ream him for having posted that miscaled dribble with the #7 poser.


AGAIN there is anyway exception for academic purpose and research in copyright law. Ever heard of fair use ? A case is when one need to use the document to comment on it. And in this case, adding the human skeleton is as far as I can tell such a case.
 
Last edited:

I remember that thread and I never got a satisfactory answer.

Where are these alleged contracts identifying who has what right? ( if they ever did exist)

Also, if the bankruptcy legend is true and the film was discharged to anyone for debt ( or whatever) then ALL prior rights/agreements/licenses are null and void. ( if they didnt appeal and get a modification to the bankruptcy order) so whoever "owns' it from the bankruptcy discharge ( if that legend is true) owns it lock,stock, barrel, body, soul, copyright and film can.

Then theres this BS "secrecy". Who would care who knows who owns it? ( its not like this film is stolen nuclear secrets from Los Alamos)

Theres no doubt in my mind the owner could sell rights to examine it ( and there would be plenty of offers) and get royalties off of the published results. ( even if the Dahinden "PO" version is accurate- there are thousands of others who would pay and their money is just as green)

Why not?

I'm sorry WP but I keep going back to the mindset that theres "something" on that original film that will kill its credibility.

Its obvious that if this was part of debt settlement then accepting a film lot as compensation is directly related to money and profit. ( otherwise why accept it in a bankruptcy settlement?) and if thats the case, here is probably the single most valuable roll of film in the lot and the owner isnt cashing in? ( since a liquidation settlement never gets back all the losses- he is still in the red)
 
Negro? Where would you like to be driven, Mrs. Daisy?

Here is an image of a black person's feet:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/eddiemackle/1458621009/

My best friend is black so I get to see his hands all the time. The problem with your reference to black people or those images you posted is that the difference is nothing like what we see with Patty. Fudge face, fudge boobs, white-out hands and feet.

Well of course it can't look exactly like Patty you fool but the photos I've posted speak for themselves. Do they or do they not show primtaes with lighter feet/hands than face? However your Africa foot photo shows to excellent effect a Negro's much paler sole and transiton tissue. Patty's skin where lighter appears gray like a primate's. You should seek medical attention for that wound having just shot yourself through the foot. No pun intended.
 
Last edited:
...here is probably the single most valuable roll of film in the lot and the owner isnt cashing in?

There might be an unfortunate surprise. This "original" may essentially be no different than what P. Patterson, Green & Dahinden already have. It may only be of slightly better quality because it is the master from which they were copied.

I can't imagine Patterson allowing glaringly incriminating scenes (such as a glove falling off, etc.) to be seen by anybody. If something really horrible occured on film, he would probably have removed it and destroyed it.

Anyway, I'd want to examine the "original" before buying it or using it for analysis.
 
Last edited:
WP,

In the Paul Vella account (is he the "madman across the water" BTW?) he does not tell how he knew, for double darn sure certain, that he was at the actual site of the PGF. Is there any account, anywhere, that gives GPS coordiants for the film site and if so what's the proof it's the actual site? Unless there is a unique feature at the site it would be hard for BG to know for sure if he was at the right place or not after 40 years. It will take more than a couple of large trees that "seem" to be in the right place to convince me that any claimed site is the place where the filming actually took place.
 
WP:
I can't imagine Patterson allowing glaringly incriminating scenes (such as a glove falling off, etc.) to be seen by anybody. If something really horrible occured on film, he would probably have removed it and destroyed it.

Then this suggests the original 100 foot piece of film, or an intact copy, no longer exists.. Otherwise it seems likely, someone would have produced it by now..
 
Last edited:
WP,

In the Paul Vella account (is he the "madman across the water" BTW?) he does not tell how he knew, for double darn sure certain, that he was at the actual site of the PGF. Is there any account, anywhere, that gives GPS coordiants for the film site and if so what's the proof it's the actual site? Unless there is a unique feature at the site it would be hard for BG to know for sure if he was at the right place or not after 40 years. It will take more than a couple of large trees that "seem" to be in the right place to convince me that any claimed site is the place where the filming actually took place.

There are Google Earth coordiants and photos of the site.
 
There might be an unfortunate surprise. This "original" may essentially be no different than what P. Patterson, Green & Dahinden already have. It may only be of slightly better quality because it is the master from which they were copied.

I can't imagine Patterson allowing glaringly incriminating scenes (such as a glove falling off, etc.) to be seen by anybody. If something really horrible occured on film, he would probably have removed it and destroyed it.

Anyway, I'd want to examine the "original" before buying it or using it for analysis.

And thats as realistic as any other scenario. Now to this

>>>I can't imagine Patterson allowing glaringly incriminating scenes (such as a glove falling off, etc.) to be seen by anybody. If something really horrible occured on film, he would probably have removed it and destroyed it.

I agree but lets look at it from a different angle

RP "wanted' a BF movie, he had several rolls of film, the camera was late in being returned, the development story has questions of its own and so forth.

Who is to say the PGF ( that we see) isnt/wasnt a compilation of several takes, has a scene of the suit in a trunk, Patty drinking from a straw or whatever? I'm not saying it is but conversely I cant just rule out the possibility based on "nothing".

I'm not trying to make a mystery out of a molehill but there are a lot of legitimate questions and suspicions surrounding what we know about the PGF that would be forever put to bed with 1 professional,quality, unbiased look at the original. ( if it in fact still exists)
 
WP,

In the Paul Vella account (is he the "madman across the water" BTW?) he does not tell how he knew, for double darn sure certain, that he was at the actual site of the PGF. Is there any account, anywhere, that gives GPS coordiants for the film site and if so what's the proof it's the actual site? Unless there is a unique feature at the site it would be hard for BG to know for sure if he was at the right place or not after 40 years. It will take more than a couple of large trees that "seem" to be in the right place to convince me that any claimed site is the place where the filming actually took place.

Vella is the first I called MATW, mainly because of what he said in a lecture about the "story" of the PGF. Lyndon/Carcharodon is the second guy I called MATW. I think he has fewer marbles than Vella.

People have said they found the exact site. I'm not sure why we don't see any specific photos of this on the web.

Unless this is one...


"Bluff Creek today"
Bluff+Creek.jpg
 
Then theres this BS "secrecy". Who would care who knows who owns it? ( its not like this film is stolen nuclear secrets from Los Alamos)

BS indeed. You have a better chance of doing a scientific examination of the Shroud of Turin than of the original PGF film. An alleged artifact of Bigfoot is more preciously guarded than an alleged artifact of the Christ? Please.
 
OK, playing devil's advocate here. From the backgrounds in the film, how can it be reconciled with certainty that this is the literally "exact" area and the "exact" walk path be determined?

Is there any "thing" that is unique and distinguishable today that can be directly linked to the PGF?

If the answer is yes- what is it?

If the answer is no then how can any valid scene recreation be accomplished?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom