Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Condensed Version


Bill,

I guess I’ll start at the beginning. The formula seems to be in proper order M = F/f when M= blah, blah, blah.

How do we know that 15% is accurate, is that standing height or walking height, which walking height because it seems to vary, was the measurement taken from hardcopy or the film (Pixels or LPI), what generation etc.? The subject is behind debris in 352; we can’t see the substrate contour, what’s the elevation of the camera relative to the subject? Are we certain that the lens was a Kodak Cine Ektar?

How do you arrive at .292”? Image area is defined by aperture opening/angle/pitch (7.605 mm long pitch, 7.6mm short pitch, guesstimated) you will need the numbers from the specific model, but, that’s not the problem. The problem is we are not working with the master (ya, ya, I know, quit whining about the master) all we have are dupes so now we have to wonder about the specific optical printer (were any prints contact printed?) and it’s aperture opening, was it printed using an 1R or 2R optical, what about a second generation and the optical printer specs for that one? See what I’m getting at here, if we don’t have accurate information how can we come to an accurate conclusion? Do I even need to go into changing aspect ratios using an optical printer and how it could have been changed from one generation to the next without anyone really being the wiser, or, how frames could have been pulled without splicing?

To answer your question, yes I have run numbers, my conclusion, I don’t run numbers anymore.


O,

Tracking is do-able both manually as well as with BouJou. In Boujou I’ve found that keeping the reference points to a minimum helps considerably with the tracking, otherwise the tracker tends to interpret the spatial shifting incorrectly. I prefer doing it manually using old school/traditional point tracking, it takes a hell of a lot longer but I seem to understand/grasp what was actually happening in real time much better.

I haven’t absolutely/factually determined anything, nor do I intend to. It’s just a personal exercise in futility. BTW, like LT, I’m simply a realist.

My original sole intentions were to see (1. If an IM index within average human range could possibly fit into the subject (say around 72 +change). (2. To see if the subject could walk without some wild-ass gait. Everything else is byproduct and irrelevant to me, least of all the subjects actual height. I don’t really have an opinion as to whether the subject is human or some frickin freak of nature and I have a gut belief that regardless of the “scientific” analysis this film will never provide the answer to that question. My scientific method of analysis is, and always will be SWAG, actually SWAGS little brother SRWAG (Some Really Wild Ass Guessing).

Final conclusion, horrible data. All they (the "professional" bigfoot researchers) needed to do was provide detailed information for ten strides, length, impression, trail width etc. Provide detailed information on nine points from any good frame (three for each horizontal 3rd of the image) tree diameter, rock info, stump size etc.


Previous Map Guesstimate

I narrowed the location down to 3 possibilities. If anyone was paying attention when I posted the map I created (not sure if I had to pull it because of space requirements) I went with the 3rd possibility on that, the Titmus map actually lines up pretty good with it. The red line NW of the creek is an old trail/road that I found on a map from the 30’s, it goes to the site and beyond. There were actually structures there at one point in time and it was called Ferris Camp (FC is now a historical landmark). Note that the coordinates on the maps are decimal.








As far as I’m concerned that’s pretty much it. I’ve probably left important things out. I’m probably wrong about other things. Honestly, I don’t really care.


Later


m
 
kitakaze wrote:
When you mean scaling to the same size, are you talking about height? Why would I scale an image of a figure hunched forward to the same as someone standing up straight?

These look fine to me:


All is fine, kitty...:boggled:...except for a big discrepancy.
If the skeleton on the left straightened out it's upper legbone, would the top of it's pelvic bone (marked by the lower black line) rise up as high as the top of the pelvic bone of the other skeleton (marked by the upper black line)?...


WTF1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Mangler:

"How do you arrive at .292”?"

American Society of Cinematographers' Manual, second edition 1967, page 199, specs on a 16mm camera and 25mm lens, where it states "Field of view is based on Full frame 16mm apature: 0.402' x 0.292"

Bill
 
Bill,

Isn't SIGGRAPH the computer graphics event? What would that have to do with a creature suit from 1967? Just because someone plays with CGI in 2008 doesn't mean they would know anything about what anyone could or would have done with a creature suit back then. The two subjects are not related.

No creature suit fx expert would ever make the claim that slightly longer forearms or anything like that means something isn't a suit. That would be silly. So I"m sure you are not going to go that route (I hope).

The CG character in SAS MEETS SCIENCE was so bad that it doesn't even match up to the suit. The foot sticks out of poor Bob's shinbone. It actually shows the opposite of what is being claimed.

You can make anything with computer graphics, however, but that would not have anything to do with reality.


This was just a quick cannibalized suit thrown together when I had already hired a 5'8" stuntman before I found out the suit they planned on using was for a 6'6" guy. So we just took one of the old rubber suits from another episode and stuck the longer arms on it - plus a little facial make-up and hair - and he was done. The "giant monster" became the "regular sized monster with long arms."

That is why I can't understand all this measuring of the suit as if the wearer had to have the same dimensions. Your chest can be as wide as you are tall. Your arms can scrape the floor. Your shoulders can be higher or lower. Your legs can be made longer or shorter. I'm sure you must know this and surely would have explained that to the Bigfooters who think Patty is real.

Arguments for Bigfoot's possible existence I can understand. Doing math on rubber I cannot get behind.:boggled:

btw - We did give the guy above a penis that was the same size as an alleged male Sas penis. (As has been reported in sightings of the Bigfoot penis)
 
Last edited:
Assume Roger filmed a real live Bigfoot.. the film was developed, and the original and a couple of copies are put away for safe keeping..

What seems like the logical next step:

A. Start marketing the film.

B. Get back in the woods ( with more film and find that critter .. ( and the rest of the family that made all them prints )

However, if you know you didn't really film Bigfoot, why bother with B ?

Even Patterson's trusted Indian tracker friend, knows for sure they really saw a Bigfoot that day, but he hasn't bothered to go looking again either..
 
Last edited:
Dfoot:

Thanks for your reply.

I guess it's up to the SIGGRAPH people to decide if what I present in my application has anything to do with their event. We'll see.

"No creature suit fx expert would ever make the claim that slightly longer forearms or anything like that means something isn't a suit. That would be silly. So I"m sure you are not going to go that route (I hope)."

Nope, not going that route.

:)

Bill
 
help me out here (flying from memory to HS Photography club)

I thought FOV was in degrees and inverse to the length of the focal length and a std 16mm aperture was .404x.295 or are we talking super 16 or one of those other types? ( or do I just need another beer?)
 
LT:

"I thought FOV was in degrees and inverse to the length of the focal length and a std 16mm aperture was .404x.295 or are we talking super 16 or one of those other types? ( or do I just need another beer?)"

I was just quoting the ASC Manual. Figured they might be somewhat reliable.

FOV is usually stated as an angle, yes, but it's the angle for a conical (circular) view, and the apature is a rectangle inside that circle, so true lens working FOV is a slightly different angle than apature width and height angles of view.

So the ASC manual also states, for example, that for a 25mm lens on a 16mm full frame apature camera, at a distance of 50 feet, the true working field of view (what the camera actually captures on film) is 18' 9" wide and 14' 2" high.

At 100 feet, that would be 28' 4" high. If Patty is 100 feet away, and 15% of that frame height, she's 4' 3" tall.

Guess it's not Bob Heironimus in the suit. It's Billy Barty.

Bill
 
Last edited:
Even Patterson's trusted Indian tracker friend, knows for sure they really saw a Bigfoot that day, but he hasn't bothered to go looking again either..

He didn't even bother to watch the film after it was developed...

Let's remember that Titmus had trouble finding the site...
 
From Bill

>>>So the ASC manual also states, for example, that for a 25mm lens on a 16mm full frame apature camera, at a distance of 50 feet, the true working field of view (what the camera actually captures on film) is 18' 9" wide and 14' 2" high.

At 100 feet, that would be 28' 4" high. If Patty is 100 feet away, and 15% of that frame height, she's 4' 3" tall.


Well, quoting from industry std publications is about as reliable as it gets and ASC would certainly qualify.

So, assuming the formula is essentially correct as well.

The film subject certainly isnt 4'3" so one or more of the variables simply must be inaccurate somewhere.
 
sweaty,

It’s the same skeleton, joints are bent, camera altitude needs to be different to compensate for the individual images, how one perceives front, back, high, low, different angles, it’s all relative. You have to get beyond the color crayons.

Do really think I’d try to pull off what you and crow are implying, on this forum? Get real dude, you have to go deeper than the surface. Read up on camera altitude and it’s effects on images.




LT,

Your right, but, see, there’s always a but. My guess would be those numbers are from a single sprocket and in all reality we don’t know for a fact that the Master wasn’t shot on single sprocket. That would play hell with the implied aspect ratio.

Edited to add, "What, the number are goofy" go figure!

Sorry, I take back that camera aperture and fold. I don't know where my head was. Must start drinking.


m
 
Last edited:
ugh, its been so long

what about the uncropped area around the sprockets? ( or was that just 8mm?)

what was that called?
 
Mangler:

"Your right, but, see, there’s always a but. My guess would be those numbers are from a single sprocket and in all reality we don’t know for a fact that the Master wasn’t shot on single sprocket. That would play hell with the implied aspect ratio."

In the ASC Manual, second edition, page 287, it has specs on both single perf and double perf, and they have the same apature size. The lack of perfs on one side simplty allows for a magnetic stripe on camera stock (for recording sound while filming, with a camera like an Auricon, or allows an optical stripe for audio tracks to be added in a release print.

Super 16 has a differennt apature, but I think it's well documented Roger's camera was standard 16mm, not Super 16mm.

Bill
 
Bill,

Yes, Yes, Yes you are right. In my experience not all 16s produce the exact same image size, I'll try to dig-up some examples in the near future if it's not too much hassel. I don't believe the documentation for the camera used is beyond reproach. I don't believe that there much about any of this that is beyond reproach.

This is cutting into shots of Te-kill-ya.

BTW, it's real simple to modify a 16. Very little knowledge is required, and if I was into conspiracy theories, well I'll tell you what...

Till later.


m
 
Last edited:
mangler wrote:
sweaty,

It’s the same skeleton, joints are bent, camera altitude needs to be different to compensate for the individual images, how one perceives front, back, high, low, different angles, it’s all relative. You have to get beyond the color crayons.

Do really think I’d try to pull off what you and crow are implying, on this forum? Get real dude, you have to go deeper than the surface. Read up on camera altitude and it’s effects on images.



Why doesn't Patty's head bob up-and-down as much as this skeleton's head does, in the two images of it on the left???

In those 2 stills, the skeleton's head has moved up by about 3/4 the height of the head itself....while Patty's head only moves up and down by a few inches.

Pattywalk55A.gif




Tonight or tomorrow I'll post a still of Patty with her leg straight, and compare her with the skeleton.
 
Last edited:
Dude, puhleeze ( this aint the BFF)

>>>You have just invalidated all of forensic photogrammetry.

I have done nothing of the sort

>>>But why would we need physical measurements to determine the IM index?

Technically, you need a physical bone

>>>And why would attainable relative measurements be meaningless unless you can convert them into inches/inches

You seem to be the one bringing over some residual BFF attitude regarding this topic. Paranoid perhaps? I am not on a quest to prove the PGF shows a bigfoot. I am just a geomaticist that sees potential in measuring the film. I never trust anyone's claims that something is impossible without backing it up. All attitude no mas.

I doubt even you understand what you were trying to say there.
Let me explain in layman's terms. Relative measurements do not require a physical ruler and are not by default meaningless. Comprende?

RayG said:
Originally Posted by Óðinn
But why would we need physical measurements to determine the IM index?
Depends on whether or not you want accurate measurements. For an accurate IM index you need to measure the actual bones, not guesstimate where the joints might be.

RayG
Not true. The actual bones are not necessarily required for accuracy. We know the bones are in there articulating over many frames. The objective is to resolve the articulation points which is part of building the model. This is not revolutionary or voodoo science. The accuracy of this process can easily be verified (and has been) using humans with known dimensions. The joint positions of humans can be determined accurately from external markers and enough examples of articulation. Whether this can be applied for a person inside a BF suit remains to be seen.

I suspect the results will not convince anyone either way. But what are you guys afraid of? Are you worried that some people might be wasting their time? How considerate.
 
Last edited:
help me out here (flying from memory to HS Photography club)

I thought FOV was in degrees and inverse to the length of the focal length and a std 16mm aperture was .404x.295 or are we talking super 16 or one of those other types? ( or do I just need another beer?)

The FOV is a function of the frame dimensions (image area) and the focal length, expressed in horizontal and vertical angles (radians). For example, Glickman quoted the image width for the PGF is 10.29 mm. The equation for the horizontal FOV is then:

F(hz) = 2(90-(arctan(focal length/(frame width/2))))

where:

90 deg = PI / 2 radians
focal length = 25 mm
frame width = 10.29 mm

FOV (hz) = 23.3 degrees.

Doing the same for the FOV (vertical) = 17.6 degrees.
 
Last edited:
mangler wrote:



Why doesn't Patty's head bob up-and-down as much as this skeleton's head does, in the two images of it on the left???

In those 2 stills, the skeleton's head has moved up by about 3/4 the height of the head itself....while Patty's head only moves up and down by a few inches.

*groan* Because Patty doesn't stand near fully erect in the PGF as BH does in the Corvette shot. It's just meant to show the proportions match. Jeez, Sweaty, come ooon!

Tonight or tomorrow I'll post a still of Patty with her leg straight, and compare her with the skeleton.

Yeah? Standing on straight leg and upper body fully erect? You know, otherwise you're wasting your time, right?
 
You seem to be the one bringing over some residual BFF attitude regarding this topic. Paranoid perhaps? I am not on a quest to prove the PGF shows a bigfoot. I am just a geomaticist that sees potential in measuring the film. I never trust anyone's opinions who claims something is impossible without backing it up. All attitude no mas.

Let me explain in layman's terms. Relative measurements do not require a physical ruler and are not by default meaningless. Comprende?


Not true. The actual bones are not necessarily required for accuracy. We know the bones are in there articulating over many frames. The objective is to resolve the articulation points which is part of building the model. This is not revolutionary or voodoo science. The accuracy of this process can easily be verified (and has been) using humans with known dimensions. The joint positions of humans can be determined accurately from external markers and enough examples of articulation. Whether this can be applied for a person inside a BF suit remains to be seen.

I suspect the results will not convince anyone either way. But what are you guys afraid of? Are you worried that some people might be wasting their time? How considerate.

>>>You seem to be the one bringing over some residual BFF attitude regarding this topic. Paranoid perhaps?

Nope, its the same message- I just dont have to deal with the same level of crap, threats and the ganging on, the obfuscations et al. It was correct then as it is now

>>>I am just a geomaticist that sees potential in measuring the film. I never trust anyone's opinions who claims something is impossible without backing it up. All attitude no mas.

Its not attitude, its called confidence and knowing what you are talking about. Thats also why I'm a PE and not a technician. And for the umpteenth time- I said it can not be done with any degree of ACCURACY. ( and it cant because the necessary information IS NOT THERE and all the kings horses and all the kings men will never change that) Sure, theres "potential" because nothings "impossible" but then theres a probability problem. Its like having a round room and telling someone to sit in a corner. Lets define 'corner' in terms of arc seconds, mils. What is a "corner"? and so forth to try to find something that they can pass off as a corner

>>>Let me explain in layman's terms. Relative measurements do not require a physical ruler and are not by default meaningless. Comprende?

I comprende and habla just fine. "relative measurements" defined in BF "science" equal "scientific proof"- NOT anywhere else in the universe. You have "relative" measurements now and they are meaningless. What do you believe that more guestimated measurements are going to accomplish? Try cutting an object in halves with each subsequent piece as well. Let me know when you get to the final part.

>>>Whether this can be applied for a person inside a BF suit remains to be seen.

when you wish upon a star.....................

>>>I suspect the results will not convince anyone either way. But what are you guys afraid of? Are you worried that some people might be wasting their time? How considerate.

Speaking for me, its time invested by the people who want to do it and i think its a great idea. Its not about fear its a "check and balance' when many of the masses will possibly hail it as "scientific evidence" that the PGF is legitimate.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom