Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am not on a quest to prove the PGF shows a bigfoot. I am just a geomaticist that sees potential in measuring the film.

I'm just curious, Gigantofootecus, as to what kind of potential you see if not ruling out or making a human extremely unlikely?

BTW, I think we have the same hometown. Have you ever joined or plan to join any of the BFRO Vancouver Island expeditions?
 
Bill,

I can’t find the standard 16mm film showing the different gate size so I will concede that. What I was trying to find would have been standard 16 cameras where one had double sprocket (maybe single sprocket double claw) and double perf film and the other would have been a standard 16 single sprocket single perf. I believe the standard across the board for 16s allows for a 2% deviation in gate width, far more common in the supers and ultras but occasionally showing up in some standards. I do concede to failure without proof.

I believe someone has the book for the Cine K-100 would you please be so kind as to check and see if that camera uses a registration pin or a pressure plate?


Sweaty,

What can I say, I’m speechless, you got me.


m
 
Nope, not going that route.

:)

Bill

On the route you are going, Bill, and the coming revelations you predicted:

I predict that in 2009, this coming year, facts about the filming will be revealed which are so unexpected but significant and scientifically reliable that the vast majority of what you are debating here will cease to be in dispute and will simply be retired to the archives of the forum.

I predict that all discussion of Bob Heironimus will be relegated to the trivia discussions. I predict that all your imaginative "suspicious backstory" will amount to nothing more than just the fact that people's lives aren't perfect. And I predict that the new information revealed will be as unbiased and factually impartial as any logical person could want.

It seems apparent that you speak of presenting revelations that would seem to, if not rule out a human (but most definitely ruling out Heironimus), make a human in a suit extremely unlikely. Yet how can this be when we can see that Patty's proportions are quite human?
 
Mangler:


"I believe someone has the book for the Cine K-100 would you please be so kind as to check and see if that camera uses a registration pin or a pressure plate?"

I've been curious about this as well. Don't know but I'll look into it.

Kitakaze:

"It seems apparent that you speak of presenting revelations that would seem to, if not rule out a human (but most definitely ruling out Heironimus), make a human in a suit extremely unlikely. Yet how can this be when we can see that Patty's proportions are quite human?"

Haven't finished my research yet, but just a thought, allometric scaling, as applied to biological entities, shows that for any given body shape, increases or decreases in size cause proportional changes in the body. Part of it is that weight increases by the cube while area cross sections increase on the square, so for example, if a body is twice as big as another, it's weight increased by a factor of 8 (the cube of 2) while the area cross section of it's ankle increased by a factor of 4 (the square of 2) and so that ankle carries twice as much pressure in pounds per square inch. So as size increases, proportions change (and ankles usually get proportionally bigger in area cross section, to carry the extra load). Just one example.

Any given anatomical proportions have a range of effective functionality over a certain size. exceeding the size range requires a change of proportion.

A determination of height, if it can be accomplished (and I acknowledge here many forum contributors have gone on record saying it cannot, so this is a hypothetical remark, emphasis on the "IF"), must then look at proportions of humans of similar size to consider if Patty's proportions are "normal" for a human of that size.

That's the theory. How it applies to to the PG film is under consideration. Might be relevent, maybe not. More work to be done.

:)

Bill
 
Bill, I'm going to ask you help walk me through this for me and any others that might not not follow.

Haven't finished my research yet, but just a thought, allometric scaling, as applied to biological entities, shows that for any given body shape, increases or decreases in size cause proportional changes in the body.

Biological entities, proportional changes in body, I'm with you. I remember seeing something on allometry and how it applies to a polar bear. I'll give some links for those who would like to know more:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allometry

http://weber.ucsd.edu/~jmoore/courses/allometry/allometry.html

Part of it is that weight increases by the cube while area cross sections increase on the square, so for example, if a body is twice as big as another, it's weight increased by a factor of 8 (the cube of 2) while the area cross section of it's ankle increased by a factor of 4 (the square of 2) and so that ankle carries twice as much pressure in pounds per square inch. So as size increases, proportions change (and ankles usually get proportionally bigger in area cross section, to carry the extra load). Just one example.

OK, now we're talking about ankles. Are we talking about human body equations or something less specific? Just want make sure I'm following.

Any given anatomical proportions have a range of effective functionality over a certain size. exceeding the size range requires a change of proportion.

So if I follow correctly, where you are going so far is that Patty may exceed a size range typical of normal human like Heironimus and that the proportions fit well in the range for effective functionality of that size. If the size is scaled back to normal human range ie BH, then the effective functionailty is eliminated or greatly impaired?

A determination of height, if it can be accomplished (and I acknowledge here many forum contributors have gone on record saying it cannot, so this is a hypothetical remark, emphasis on the "IF"), must then look at proportions of humans of similar size to consider if Patty's proportions are "normal" for a human of that size.

If I follow this correctly, it is reiterating what I just deduced from the prior statement. So then it must follow by this that you are looking to establish a significant height for Patty in order to realize your predictions. Like something 7 ft or above?

How am I doing so far? Please correct me if I have misunderstood.
 
I think Chris Murphy favors a height exceeding 7 feet ..

I need to see how they work around the established 14 inch foot length, when scaled against the height of the subject in the film..
 
Last edited:
Kitakaze:

"OK, now we're talking about ankles. Are we talking about human body equations or something less specific? Just want make sure I'm following."

I just used the ankles as an example of the concept, because it's a relatively easy one for most people to grasp. It's also the example I learned allometric scaling with, from a great book on nature called "The Grand Design"

I'm not looking at Patty's ankles, in case you are wondering.


My Quote:
"Any given anatomical proportions have a range of effective functionality over a certain size. exceeding the size range requires a change of proportion."

"So if I follow correctly, where you are going so far is that Patty may exceed a size range typical of normal human like Heironimus and that the proportions fit well in the range for effective functionality of that size. If the size is scaled back to normal human range ie BH, then the effective functionailty is eliminated or greatly impaired?"

If you look at people (and this is a generalization, as an example) the average human man is I believe about 5' 9" or so. A shorter man may have shorter legs in proportion to his torso, and a much taller man might have much longer legs in proportion to his torso. My earlier study of anatomical proportions found an unusually short lower leg, a curious trait. I would expect to see that on a short man, but not a tall man.

In this case, there's no argument that functionality is impaired, but there is consideration for the likelyhood a human of a given height might have short lower legs.

So there would be a probability of what percentage of the human population has a specified height, and then what percentage of that group has the short lower legs. As you add conditions, the probability of how many people fit the description diminishes.

An obvious line of criticism would be that A) The height is wrong, and B) the short lower leg proportion is wrong, or C) the statistical data on percentages of population with the specification is incorrect.

Any argument for percentages of people who "fit" must address these anticipated criticisms.



My Quote:
"A determination of height, if it can be accomplished (and I acknowledge here many forum contributors have gone on record saying it cannot, so this is a hypothetical remark, emphasis on the "IF"), must then look at proportions of humans of similar size to consider if Patty's proportions are "normal" for a human of that size."

"If I follow this correctly, it is reiterating what I just deduced from the prior statement. So then it must follow by this that you are looking to establish a significant height for Patty in order to realize your predictions. Like something 7 ft or above?"

I am looking to establish her height, yes. I have doubts that she's 4' 3" and so, as Longtabber noted earlier in this thread, there must be something wrong with one of three numbers (the size of patty in the frame, the distance she is from camera, or the lens focal length). That optical formula has no agenda and it isn't biased. You just plug in three numbers and get a fourth (in this case, the subject's height). If I can determine with some confidence what the three numbers are, I'll let the formula determine the height.

"How am I doing so far? Please correct me if I have misunderstood."

You seem to be doing okay so far.

Bill
 
I just used the ankles as an example of the concept, because it's a relatively easy one for most people to grasp. It's also the example I learned allometric scaling with, from a great book on nature called "The Grand Design"

I'm not looking at Patty's ankles, in case you are wondering.

I didn't think you were looking at Patty's ankles. I was thinking something with limbs but not the forearms as you pointed out to Dfoot.

If you look at people (and this is a generalization, as an example) the average human man is I believe about 5' 9" or so. A shorter man may have shorter legs in proportion to his torso, and a much taller man might have much longer legs in proportion to his torso. My earlier study of anatomical proportions found an unusually short lower leg, a curious trait. I would expect to see that on a short man, but not a tall man.

In this case, there's no argument that functionality is impaired, but there is consideration for the likelyhood a human of a given height might have short lower legs.

So there would be a probability of what percentage of the human population has a specified height, and then what percentage of that group has the short lower legs. As you add conditions, the probability of how many people fit the description diminishes.

An obvious line of criticism would be that A) The height is wrong, and B) the short lower leg proportion is wrong, or C) the statistical data on percentages of population with the specification is incorrect.

Any argument for percentages of people who "fit" must address these anticipated criticisms.

So I was right in that you are trying to establish significant height. So this is your revelation. You need the height to rule out BH and your research on proportions to reduce the likelihood of Patterson being able to find an actor to be in the suit of that height and irregular proportion. Now I see.

I am looking to establish her height, yes. I have doubts that she's 4' 3" and so, as Longtabber noted earlier in this thread, there must be something wrong with one of three numbers (the size of patty in the frame, the distance she is from camera, or the lens focal length). That optical formula has no agenda and it isn't biased. You just plug in three numbers and get a fourth (in this case, the subject's height). If I can determine with some confidence what the three numbers are, I'll let the formula determine the height.

"Her," yes. Seems like you're confident of that. The 4' 3" estimate is ridiculous, I agree.

Here's the thing. I'm confident of the following:

1) Patty's not really tall. Not significantly over 6ft, to be sure.

2) Patty's proportions are quite normal. No oddly short legs and nothing that doesn't nicely fit with BH.

Here is why I feel confident of that:

Patty/Heironimus proportion match demonstration courtesy mangler:



GooGooGaaGaa2.jpg




Patty height measurement of 6ft courtesy Astrophotographer:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3571927&postcount=13474

Patty proportion measurements courtesy Astrophotographer:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3844448&postcount=14692
 
Kitakaze:

""Her," yes. Seems like you're confident of that."

A. the outward appearance has always been described as female, so it's simply a presumption based on the outward appearance.

B. Have you ruled out a woman in a suit? Or can only men wear them in Hollywood type costumes? When I did "The beastmaster", almost half the "Birdwarrior" characters were tall women in suits. Paula Crist was the suit mime for a baby dinosaur in "Baby". Gotta keep an open mind to all alternatives. Good skeptical practice.

Bill
 
Well of course it can't look exactly like Patty you fool but the photos I've posted speak for themselves. Do they or do they not show primtaes with lighter feet/hands than face? However your Africa foot photo shows to excellent effect a Negro's much paler sole and transiton tissue. Patty's skin where lighter appears gray like a primate's. You should seek medical attention for that wound having just shot yourself through the foot. No pun intended.

Yes'm, boss. Looksa like ol' Miss Daisy gone done her britches up real tight. Yessir'.

First of all, yes, the images you posted of gorilla and chimp do show lighter colouration on hands and feet. Those images and the image of the Ugandan kid's foot I posted are nothing like what we see on Patty.

Here's the kid's feet again:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/eddiemackle/1458621009/

And another Ugandan kid:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/eddiemackle/1459493510/in/photostream/

BTW, log, unless you want me to keep up with the Miss Daisy, please understand that while you may find "Negro" to be fine, many people find it at least archaic if not an outright slur. I'm sure you don't mean it that way.

This not even beginning to address the ridiculousness of the Patty's slipper feet.





90dc13cc.jpg
cef4b073.jpg
 
A. the outward appearance has always been described as female, so it's simply a presumption based on the outward appearance.

A presumption that to the reader indicates an acceptance of the outward appearance. Minor issue.

B. Have you ruled out a woman in a suit? Or can only men wear them in Hollywood type costumes? When I did "The beastmaster", almost half the "Birdwarrior" characters were tall women in suits. Paula Crist was the suit mime for a baby dinosaur in "Baby". Gotta keep an open mind to all alternatives. Good skeptical practice.

Bill

Have I ruled out a woman? No. A woman in a suit is far more likely than a real Bigfoot. I really doubt based on the strength and uniqueness of Heironimus' claim and the known associations of Patterson. Ivan Sanderson used his wife for a Bigfoot hoax, though. None of Patty's outward appearance makes a woman more likely. Certainly not the pair of rug shells.

What's interesting to me is that you chose one minor aspect of the post to respond to, saying nothing of the most important part and saying nothing about mangler's demo and Astro's measurements.
 
Kitakaze:

"What's interesting to me is that you chose one minor aspect of the post to respond to, saying nothing of the most important part and saying nothing about mangler's demo and Astro's measurements."

I'm not relying on any of them, so why should I remark about them. I'm not trying to disprove or challenge somebody elses work. I'm trying to start with a fresh slate. Look at the film, what do I see, what image data is there, how can it be analysed, what tools might analyse it, and so on. If my results do disprove or challenge someone elses work, we can take that up if it happens, not before.

Consider also that I can really only talk to you either in generalities about my work (the broad concept), or general theory and foundation material which applies to other studies as much as to my own (like the allometric stuff above, a generalized concept which may or may not apply to the PG film). I will not disclose any actual findings of my work until the results have been reviewed, challenged and documented as best I can. So there are many things I choose not to talk about now for that reason. I know I'll be talking about them when the time comes to release the results of my work, with a package of supporting documentation.

Bill
 
http://www.cryptomundo.com/cryptozoo-news/skeptic-bf/#comment-44554

Well, now that you mention it, there really is nothing incredible about an animal that big with flat padded feet walking like that. Right? Right. I don’t know ANYONE who can say, authoritatively, how you “should” walk if you weigh x. I want to know: what’s that on the film? I’m not concerned what diet she’s on. I just want to know: how do you get a human in a suit proportioned like that? No, SHOW me. (Bill Munns, BTW, while we’re on science, has shown us. To wit: can’t be done.)

I didn't know Munns had already done that...
 
LTC:

"I didn't know Munns had already done that... "

Neither do I. I can't even figure out exactly what the poster on Cryptomundo seems to think I have proved. ??

Bill
 
Yes'm, boss. Looksa like ol' Miss Daisy gone done her britches up real tight. Yessir'.

First of all, yes, the images you posted of gorilla and chimp do show lighter colouration on hands and feet. Those images and the image of the Ugandan kid's foot I posted are nothing like what we see on Patty.

Here's the kid's feet again:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/eddiemackle/1458621009/

And another Ugandan kid:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/eddiemackle/1459493510/in/photostream/

BTW, log, unless you want me to keep up with the Miss Daisy, please understand that while you may find "Negro" to be fine, many people find it at least archaic if not an outright slur. I'm sure you don't mean it that way.

This not even beginning to address the ridiculousness of the Patty's slipper feet.



[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_187554942a5b130577.jpg[/qimg][qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_187554942d5c1c3f95.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/90dc13cc.jpg[/qimg][qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/cef4b073.jpg[/qimg]

You're shrinking! Would you prefer Negroid? But please keep it up with the Miss Daisy. It suites you.
 
Last edited:
I'm not relying on any of them, so why should I remark about them.

That doesn't make any sense. You make your bold predictions, say you are trying to establish Patty's height. I give you reliable measurments based on pixels and Patty's foot from Astrophotographer. And clear evidence that Patty's legs are not oddly short. Nobody asked you to disprove it, it's right there for anyone to see with the work all laid out, nice and neat.

I'm trying to start with a fresh slate. Look at the film, what do I see, what image data is there, how can it be analysed, what tools might analyse it, and so on.

I think it's been made blatantly clear you've decided Patty's real and are going backward from there. It's in everything you do, everything you say. It's in your predictions and what you will and will not address.

Consider also that I can really only talk to you either in generalities about my work (the broad concept), or general theory and foundation material which applies to other studies as much as to my own (like the allometric stuff above, a generalized concept which may or may not apply to the PG film). I will not disclose any actual findings of my work until the results have been reviewed, challenged and documented as best I can. So there are many things I choose not to talk about now for that reason. I know I'll be talking about them when the time comes to release the results of my work, with a package of supporting documentation.

Bill

Thanks, Bill, As far as I'm concerned, the rabbit has been pulled out of the hat.

I've got so many good reasons to think Patty's a hoax. I've got solid measurements and proportion matches fitting Patty with BH. I've got the opinions of oscar winning master fx artists telling me it's a bad hoax. I have the mountain of pain for Patty here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4073133#post4073133

What do Patty fans have to make a Bigfoot a better candidate? What do you have? I see wishful thinking and nothing else.
 
Last edited:
You're shrinking! Would you prefer Negroid? But please keep it up with the Miss Daisy. It suites you.

It has nothing to do with what I prefer. I'm not black and I wouldn't expect you to care anyway. I can safely say that black people do not feel fond of being referred to as Negro. If I called my best friend a Negro, he'd laugh his ass off, from a stranger, I doubt it. Negroid is not a major improvement. I'm not the PC police, just telling the fact. I'm pretty sure you're an older white lady, nobody's going to flip here because you're out of touch. Consider it advice for the real world.
 
LTC:

"I didn't know Munns had already done that... "

Neither do I. I can't even figure out exactly what the poster on Cryptomundo seems to think I have proved. ??

Bill

Yeah!:rolleyes: Here you can see, Bill:

I just want to know: how do you get a human in a suit proportioned like that? No, SHOW me. (Bill Munns, BTW, while we’re on science, has shown us. To wit: can’t be done

It's quite clear that that particular Bigfoot enthusiast is one of the many that are,, with scarce protest, being given the impression that you've disproven hoax for the PGF. It's a trend.
 
Kitakaze:

Here we go again:

"That doesn't make any sense. You make your bold predictions, say you are trying to establish Patty's height. I give you reliable measurments based on pixels and Patty's foot from Astrophotographer. And clear evidence that Patty's legs are not oddly short. Nobody asked you to disprove it, it's right there for anyone to see with the work all laid out, nice and neat."

You don't have all the data and it's nowhere as clear as you think. What part of " I'm trying to start with a fresh slate. Look at the film, what do I see, what image data is there, how can it be analysed, what tools might analyse it, and so on." don't you understand?


"I think it's been made blatantly clear you've decided Patty's real and are going backward from there. It's in everything you do, everything you say. It's in your predictions and what you will and will not address."

Yes you think that of me. That is clear. I have no expectation you understand me or will judge me fairly. You are far more biased that you accuse me of being.


My Quote:
Consider also that I can really only talk to you either in generalities about my work (the broad concept), or general theory and foundation material which applies to other studies as much as to my own (like the allometric stuff above, a generalized concept which may or may not apply to the PG film). I will not disclose any actual findings of my work until the results have been reviewed, challenged and documented as best I can. So there are many things I choose not to talk about now for that reason. I know I'll be talking about them when the time comes to release the results of my work, with a package of supporting documentation.

Bill

"Thanks, Bill, As far as I'm concerned, the rabbit has been pulled out of the hat."

I've got so many good reasons to think Patty's a hoax. I've got solid measurements and proportion matches fitting Patty with BH. I've got the opinions of oscar winning master fx artists telling me it's a bad hoax. I have the mountain of pain for Patty here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...33#post4073133

What do Patty fans have to make a Bigfoot a better candidate? What do you have? I see wishful thinking and nothing else.


Fine. That's what you see. Enjoy the view, while it lasts.

Bill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom