LTC8K6
Penultimate Amazing
How well does photogrammetry work with an enlargement of unknown percentage and/or scale?
I understand ( as has been pointed out by others ) that soles of feet can have light pigmentation, but just walking around is going to make your feet dirty ..
Greg, I was thinking about our discussion on Patty's feet yesterday and a few things occurred to me. I was wrong. There's no way we're just looking at clay on the feet here:
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/90dc13cc.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/cef4b073.jpg[/qimg]
First of all, regardless of chimps with light skin, the scenario doesn't fit with Patty. Patty's hands and feet are light but not her face or breasts. If she's a real ape, she should have light skin showing in those areas. Also the light area on her feet is huge. It looks consistent with a suit that has been modified at the head and breasts but the modifications don't match the original hands and feet. I think you were right to question it, regardless of the issue of light footed animals.


By working backwards. If you knew the distance from the camera you could use photogrammetry to estimate Patty's height. But if you can determine Patty's height (by whatever means) then the distance from the camera can be calculated using the film frame height and the focal length of the lens. Even if you do not determine the exact height you can still obtain relative distances from the camera for each frame. Also we can count the steps and estimate the body orientation to construct one side of a triangle. The other two sides would be the distances from the camera for the first and last step which can be solved geometrically. All these methods can be used in combination to develop a model of the scene and fine tune the estimates.How would that distance be determined today ?
The camera used had a stock 25mm lens. Given the approximate distances involved a 25mm lens would give us the view we see in the film. From all accounts I do not think that the turret mount was used.How would we determine the lens Patterson was using ?
Greg, I was thinking about our discussion on Patty's feet yesterday and a few things occurred to me. I was wrong. There's no way we're just looking at clay on the feet here:
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/90dc13cc.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/cef4b073.jpg[/qimg]
First of all, regardless of chimps with light skin, the scenario doesn't fit with Patty. Patty's hands and feet are light but not her face or breasts. If she's a real ape, she should have light skin showing in those areas. Also the light area on her feet is huge. It looks consistent with a suit that has been modified at the head and breasts but the modifications don't match the original hands and feet. I think you were right to question it, regardless of the issue of light footed animals.

Given the approximate distances involved a 25mm lens would give us the view we see in the film.
Again? Do you have an issue with relative measurements? I am referring to using photo units and photogrammetry to build a model of the scene. All positions are "relative" to the camera. Georeferencing the scene would supply the physical units. That is not what I was referring to. Any CGI rendering of the PGF will be "relative" (photo units) as for the film itself. Building a CGI model attempts to restore the third dimension relative to the camera but not georeference it. How else do you think the IM index is determined? It is unitless.Ah, the old "relative" measurements again.
Looks like "A" to me.Too bad no one can give the actual distances to us.
http://www.mediafire.com/imgbnc.php/f8b3aa6eca156f5c682ec4a6e81362096g.jpg
Looks like "A" to me.
Questions to log:
Again? Do you have an issue with relative measurements? I am referring to using photo units and photogrammetry to build a model of the scene. All positions are "relative" to the camera. Georeferencing the scene would supply the physical units. That is not what I was referring to. Any CGI rendering of the PGF will be "relative" (photo units) as for the film itself. Building a CGI model attempts to restore the third dimension relative to the camera but not georeference it. How else do you think the IM index is determined? It is unitless.
Georeferencing the film requires a known physical scale of reference such as a body part or the distance from the camera. If you have a known ruler you can derive physical distances from the film by converting photo units (relative) to real world coordinates.
How do you know?
If wishes were horses.......
we have been thru this before so I'll refresh your memory.
There isnt detail in the PGF to get the accurate measurements ( thus "relative") so any meaningful "study" will carry the same scientifically useless merit of Fahrenbachs "foot,size" histograms and papers.
Thats why anyone can bring any PG type software they want but the minute they plug junk data into it, call it pseudo science.
Then attempting to use "questionable" field measurements and attempt to locate points in a natural area exposed to 40 years of weathering with nothing but an old film to reference it from? ( thats assuming the film was actually shot there in the first place- theres certainly no independant proof it was shot there and no proof the "trackway" was actually the one left by the film subject)
such things wouldnt pass muster in any legitimate science.
Its called GIGO and all the $10 words, wishful thinking and tapdancing wont change that.
If you say so.
I say so
Then attempting to use "questionable" field measurements and attempt to locate points in a natural area exposed to 40 years of weathering with nothing but an old film to reference it from? ( thats assuming the film was actually shot there in the first place- theres certainly no independant proof it was shot there and no proof the "trackway" was actually the one left by the film subject).
The actual filmsite had been visited a number of times in the first years following the event. Others in more recent times have gone there and have located some of the visual cues we see in the film. If nothing else the actual site is a know quantity of location. It has been photographed and visitors have noted that it is very changed. If I were to film a working model of the event to test resolution etc I'd choose a spot that looked as close to that location as that location did in 1967. Lots of things will need to be the same. Things like soil albedo and overall lay of the land.