Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
WP

"The thing is Bill, you won't know what mistakes you made (if any) until somebody else finds them. A few trusted reviewers may not find the mistakes either. It always works that way. When you say "trusted people", do you mean folks you have befriended and regard as trustworthy?"

I would go to people who have sufficient expertise in the science and math to be qualified to check the numbers and formulas, ideally people who have no resaon to determine anything other that the accuracy of the material.

I can't imagine how the NASI thing slipped by. I am mindful of their error and determined not to repeat it with one of my own. Best I can say at this time.

That's one reason I hope to get my paper accepted at SIGGRAPH. Nobody there is a "friend" who will cut me any slack. They will all be strangers with expertise in the kind of work I present, and more concerned about the intregity of SIGGRAPH than they will care about me, the film, Footers, skeptics, BFF, JREF or any other element of the film debate. I have confidence they will evaluate my submission impartially, and will have the expertise to find any errors if I make any in the paper.

Bill
 
I can't imagine how the NASI thing slipped by. I am mindful of their error and determined not to repeat it with one of my own. Best I can say at this time.

Do you understand the nature of their error? If so, could you explain it?
 
WP:

"Do you understand the nature of their error? If so, could you explain it?"

They apparently used the wrong algorythm or had a flawed chest circumference estimate.

I would just look at a human with similar "stocky" build, take the human's height and weight, and then if a height is estimated for Patty, find the percentage of height increase from the comparative human to Patty, and cube it, and take that resulting number and multiply the human's weight by the same number to get Patty's weight.

Let's just say, as a random example, I', 6'2 and 285 pounds (gotta lose some of it before I go hiking into Bluff Creek). And let's say Patty is 7'4", a hypothetical example, then her height would be 1.189 times taller than me. Her weight would be 1.189 cubed, meaning 1.189 x 1.189 x 1.189, which is 1.68 times heavier. So if I weigh 285, a Patty 7'4" tall with the same proportions as me would weigh 478.8 pounds (285 x 1.68).

If she were taller, or huskier than me, then the weight might go up to 500, 525 maybe.

Bill
 
Who's talking about the film?

I'm talking about footprint casts..
Smooth as a baby's bottom, rubber foot, or whatever the case may be...


My oversight, or undersight. Isn't it Legend Meets Science where they're making large human casts from swollen latex? Should have lots of flexatation lines. I'm going to watch it and see. Of course no flexation lines in Wallace wooden foot casts lol. But excellent observation and argument. However we've all seen human footprints on beaches that while crisp looking in damp soil do not exibit flexation creases. But if dermal ridges are claimed flexation lines should be more prominent sice the run deeper.
 
The thing is Bill, you won't know what
NASI used a calculation to come up with the weight...

They probably ran that equation more than once to make sure it was right.
Glickman's error was how he determined the chest circumference. He erroneously overscaled Patty's dimensions. A photogrammetric error. I also believe the allometric eqn was wrong. Estimating Patty's weight was doomed from the start.
 
I predict that the complaints are starting already! Question to WP. William I've read NASI report and am aware of the weight miscalculation. Is that its only major flaw or rather fatal flaw. Yet is there trustworthy of other aspects in it?
 
I predict that in 2009, this coming year, facts about the filming will be revealed which are so unexpected but significant and scientifically reliable that the vast majority of what you are debating here will cease to be in dispute and will simply be retired to the archives of the forum.

I predict that all discussion of Bob Heironimus will be relegated to the trivia discussions. I predict that all your imaginative "suspicious backstory" will amount to nothing more than just the fact that people's lives aren't perfect. And I predict that the new information revealed will be as unbiased and factually impartial as any logical person could want.

I predict some of you will still complain about it even if it really is factually impartial and unbiased.

Bill

The only way that will happen is if, at the Yakima conference, you declare Patty to be a bloke in a suit, and that declaration is supported by the Bobs.

Even you can't be arrogant enough to think that you declaring Patty to be a bigfoot would instantly silence the members of this board site.

Here is my prediction;
Since Yakima is a one-time event and Munns is trying to play some transparent build-the-suspense game, we will finally learn the truth most of us already know, that the PGF is a hoax.

I sure hope they don't serve Kool-Aid at the party!
 
Question to WP.

Questions to log:

Log, I was hoping that you might have found some rationalization as to why Sweaty has grounds to ream out mangler for using an image for demonstration that Sweaty first obtained at the JREF.

Nothing? No?

Thought so.

BTW, any thoughts on why simply standing mangler's Patty skeleton image into BH's corvette pose works perfectly?
 
Do tell ..

Why would anyone else' calculations carry any more weight?
They wouldn't necessarily. Providing they do not repeat the error. Glickman used a photo of someone with a known height taken at the film site. He scaled it to the background of a frame in the PGF and used the person as a ruler. Problem is that they would have to be at the same distance from the camera for that trick to work. They were not. End of story.
 
Bill Munns wrote:
I predict that all discussion of Bob Heironimus will be relegated to the trivia discussions.


I'll second that! :)

Bob's boat is well on it's way to the bottom of the deep blue sea. It's gonna be fun watching his crewmates treading water, trying to stay afloat.
 
Questions to log:

The flaw in Mangler's presentation occurs in the tibia. He's arrived at the tibia being the same length, actual as shown, and not relative in both Patty and Bob H. When the smaller illustration (being Patty) gets scaled up to being the same size as Bob leaning against his Corvette the tibias no longer match up while the rest of the bones (skull etc) become fairly well proportioned to scale against each other. Please note that Patty's right tibia is in a verticle position and should be perfectically scalable to Bob's verticle tibias. In other words Mangler had to scale down Patty to get the #7 poser skeleton to work with Bob H and have at least something measure up. If you don't see it or don't want to see it. Fine but Mangler made no case there.
 
I predict that the complaints are starting already! Question to WP. William I've read NASI report and am aware of the weight miscalculation. Is that its only major flaw or rather fatal flaw. Yet is there trustworthy of other aspects in it?

I read it over a year ago. I just went and grabbed the weight chapter as an example of error. There could be more errors. I'm not qualified to review the measurement sections of the report. If Odinn is right about Glickman using a faulty 'ruler' (known subject at unknown distance from camera), then all sorts of other measurements could be wrong. They estimated the height at just over 7'3".

NASI concluded that Patty could not be a man in a costume. I guess it's a case of garbage in - garbage out. I think I read that someone paid $70,000 for that report. If so, it was a bigger $$ mistake than buying Parcherfoot. Maybe there are things of value in the report. I'll probably read it again pretty soon.
 
WP:

"Maybe there are things of value in the report. I'll probably read it again pretty soon."

In looking at any report or study, you need to arrange the facts and conclusions in a logic tree, and see what conclusions are branched off of what other conclusions. If a branch conclusion is flawed, that does not mean the foundation conclusions were, but if a foundation conclusion is flawed, everything that branches off of it is also flawed.

So the flaw of the weight estimate doesn't necessarily negate the whole report. But if, for example, somebody was taking footprint depth analysis based on the estimated weight and a pounds per square inch pressure analysis, that data would be junk, because it branches off of the flawed weight determination.

But Oainn is correct in that the failure to know exactly where Roger's camera was (exact position), and all the related camera data, the inconsistancies between Roger's camera and the camera photographing the guy with the measure bar basically blew that part of the analysis out the window.

Part of my work is locating Roger's true camera position in relation to the site physical elements. That's what the Matchmove software does.

Bill
 
I'll second that! :)

Bob's boat is well on it's way to the bottom of the deep blue sea. It's gonna be fun watching his crewmates treading water, trying to stay afloat.


You're missing the bigger picture, mate. Biggus Footus' boat sank years ago, probably about the time that people first started claiming this awful fake film is the real deal, and the fun has always been watching his "crewmates" flailing and floundering about, not even managing to tread water.

Please don't stop.
 
Diogenes:

"How would that distance be determined today ?"

A photogrammetry reconstruction of the site only creates a 3D model in digital space, which has no inherent real world dimensions. Real world dimensions must be introduced into the digital model by some actual measurements, like for example, those taken by Rene Dahinden in 1971, or a visit to the actual site today, and if those measurements can reliably be assigned to elements of the digital model, a "real world" scale can then be set into the digital model, and then any point in the model can be measured against any other point, in real world numbers.

So Roger's camera, if located for any given frame of the film, could be measured to any other point in the 3D model as determined by the photogrammetry analysis. Patty, being a moving object, is not automatically determined by the photogrammetry solution. Additional analysis is needed to try and locate her. One such locator is objects she walks in front of or behind, which narrows the path corridor. Other path analysis methods may apply as well.

A "margin of error" analysis of this scaling must also be done, to test the reliability of measurements. Generally, the larger the real measurement, the smaller the margin of error. Any analysis using this method will be subjected to considerable skeptical scrutinyto determine if the real world measurements were properly applied.

"How would we determine the lens Patterson was using ?"

Current Matchmove CGI software solves camera position (X,Y,Z coordinates in the digital space, object X.Y.Z rotational orientation to a fixed digital horizon or groundplane, and lens focal length for every frame (in case a zoom lens was used) or the fixed focal length throughout the sequence, if the lens was a prime lens.

As an example, Boujou 4.1 Matchmove software does all the above very well.

Bill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom