Bill Munns
Banned
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2008
- Messages
- 449
WP
"The thing is Bill, you won't know what mistakes you made (if any) until somebody else finds them. A few trusted reviewers may not find the mistakes either. It always works that way. When you say "trusted people", do you mean folks you have befriended and regard as trustworthy?"
I would go to people who have sufficient expertise in the science and math to be qualified to check the numbers and formulas, ideally people who have no resaon to determine anything other that the accuracy of the material.
I can't imagine how the NASI thing slipped by. I am mindful of their error and determined not to repeat it with one of my own. Best I can say at this time.
That's one reason I hope to get my paper accepted at SIGGRAPH. Nobody there is a "friend" who will cut me any slack. They will all be strangers with expertise in the kind of work I present, and more concerned about the intregity of SIGGRAPH than they will care about me, the film, Footers, skeptics, BFF, JREF or any other element of the film debate. I have confidence they will evaluate my submission impartially, and will have the expertise to find any errors if I make any in the paper.
Bill
"The thing is Bill, you won't know what mistakes you made (if any) until somebody else finds them. A few trusted reviewers may not find the mistakes either. It always works that way. When you say "trusted people", do you mean folks you have befriended and regard as trustworthy?"
I would go to people who have sufficient expertise in the science and math to be qualified to check the numbers and formulas, ideally people who have no resaon to determine anything other that the accuracy of the material.
I can't imagine how the NASI thing slipped by. I am mindful of their error and determined not to repeat it with one of my own. Best I can say at this time.
That's one reason I hope to get my paper accepted at SIGGRAPH. Nobody there is a "friend" who will cut me any slack. They will all be strangers with expertise in the kind of work I present, and more concerned about the intregity of SIGGRAPH than they will care about me, the film, Footers, skeptics, BFF, JREF or any other element of the film debate. I have confidence they will evaluate my submission impartially, and will have the expertise to find any errors if I make any in the paper.
Bill