Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Would this be one?:

LOL, no

Our discussions were limited only to the "mechanics" of suit construction, techniques etc.

I personally have a difficult time accepting a premise of a "hypothetical" creature such as BF with no Type A specimen to use as a baseline being speculated upon as belonging to another specimen where the fossil record is incomplete and the majority of their recreation is part art.
 
I understand ( as has been pointed out by others ) that soles of feet can have light pigmentation, but just walking around is going to make your feet dirty ..

Unless you're walking in light coloured sediment and get your picture around that time.

I make myself want to vomit in tinfoil and eat it.

(Monster House)
 
LOL, no

Our discussions were limited only to the "mechanics" of suit construction, techniques etc.

I personally have a difficult time accepting a premise of a "hypothetical" creature such as BF with no Type A specimen to use as a baseline being speculated upon as belonging to another specimen where the fossil record is incomplete and the majority of their recreation is part art.

I suspect I can't ask you if you find Bill Munns playing Bigfoot authority or paleoanthropologist for cryptomumble as amusing, can I?
 
Lot of non-bipeds, kit ..



Why no flexion creases ?

Well Greg you ought to know the answer to that question by now. But just in case I'll deliver an argument you've used dozens of times. The resolution of the film is not good enough to allow for those kinds of details.
 
Tear you apart with those arms!


[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/98dff1a0.jpg[/qimg]


A hug of tough love! How verticle do you suppose. could that that mime and suit get the arms? Works well as the organic gorilla I posted.
 
I suspect I can't ask you if you find Bill Munns playing Bigfoot authority or paleoanthropologist for cryptomumble as amusing, can I?

I dont know if I see it that way and we never broached the subject.

I will say this tho- one thing we discussed somewhat in depth is his extreme taxidermy skills. ( I do mounts to a degree but mine are far from show quality, Bill is truly an expert on it)

So, I have no problem with his recreations because I'm confident they are the best he can do and they look good. ( whether they are factually accurate- nobody knows) Many others have extrapolated on how some extinct species looked and were later wrong when other bones were discovered.

That entire method ( just like forensic reconstructs from human bones in LE) is part science, part SWAG and part art. ( I've seen some that were way off and some that were dead ringers) I just take it for what it is. A good effort.

At the end of the day, I dont have the knowledge in those fields to say whats good,bad, right,wrong or indifferent so I dont comment too far.
 
A hug of tough love! How verticle do you suppose. could that that mime and suit get the arms? Works well as the organic gorilla I posted.

Log, I was hoping that you might have found some rationalization as to why Sweaty has grounds to ream out mangler for using an image for demonstration that Sweaty first obtained at the JREF.

Nothing? No?

Thought so.

BTW, any thoughts on why simply standing mangler's Patty skeleton image into BH's corvette pose works perfectly?
 
Unless log would like to argue piloerection.:rolleyes:


A few fine little flexation lines on the soles of dirty feet are a far cry from the visible impact of tens of thousands hairs . Now then I've already posted photos concerning piloerection as a possible reason why Pattys arm has the abrupt widening above the wrist. Much like the gorilla photo I posted with it that is exibiting piloerection. I've made and posted my observation. What more do you want blood?
 
Well Greg you ought to know the answer to that question by now. But just in case I'll deliver an argument you've used dozens of times. The resolution of the film is not good enough to allow for those kinds of details.
Who's talking about the film?

I'm talking about footprint casts..
Smooth as a baby's bottom, rubber foot, or whatever the case may be...
 
We can see from the casting stills of Roger, which we are told are from that day, that Patty walked through mud.

The tracks in the mud can also be seen in the film clip of Patty's tracks, and in the LeClerc montage.
 
Busy night.

LT:

Thank you, my friend, for your comments. I know when I present a finding, you will be my most severe critic, but in the most responsible sense of simply expecting scientific responsibility from me.

Drew:

I don't have a clue what I'll find on the site, or even if we can find the site, so how can I saynow what landscape elements might still exist and be reliably identified. I simply stated a goal, what I aspire to do. What will actually be found, if anything, we will not know until it's attempted in the spring.

WP:

The copy Chris gave me was a DVD of a NTSC video the museum made. That's all I know of it's origin. It will not be used in my final research, assuming I can get something true full frame and higher resolution.

Diogenes:

I'm assuming the whitish color on Patty's feet is the ground substrate on the foot, not any natural pigment or intrinsic color of a fake foot. Either one could pick up an earth/clay residue walking over moist ground (of which there usually is in streambed areas). So if both a real foot and a fake foot could pick up the clay residue and appear whitened, then the color does not seem to me to argue for one over the other.


To All:

In the spirit of the impending New Year, I'm going to make some predictions for the future of this thread, and the whole PG Film debate. Now obviously one cannot prove a prediction. All we can do is wait and see if it comes to pass. If it comes to pass, it was right. If it doesn't, it was wrong. So I will thank you all in advance to resist the temptation of asking me to "prove it" now, because only time will prove these true or not. Patience is a virtue and I'm sure all of you are virtuous in that matter. With patience, we will all see if these predictions are right or wrong.

I predict that in 2009, this coming year, facts about the filming will be revealed which are so unexpected but significant and scientifically reliable that the vast majority of what you are debating here will cease to be in dispute and will simply be retired to the archives of the forum.

I predict that all discussion of Bob Heironimus will be relegated to the trivia discussions. I predict that all your imaginative "suspicious backstory" will amount to nothing more than just the fact that people's lives aren't perfect. And I predict that the new information revealed will be as unbiased and factually impartial as any logical person could want.

I predict some of you will still complain about it even if it really is factually impartial and unbiased.

Bill
 
Why are you going to Bluff Creek, if, regardless of conditions and what you find there, you can make this prediction?

Bill Munns said:
I predict that in 2009, this coming year, facts about the filming will be revealed which are so unexpected but significant and scientifically reliable that the vast majority of what you are debating here will cease to be in dispute and will simply be retired to the archives of the forum.

This :
Bill Munns said:
I don't have a clue what I'll find on the site, or even if we can find the site, so how can I saynow what landscape elements might still exist and be reliably identified. I simply stated a goal, what I aspire to do. What will actually be found, if anything, we will not know until it's attempted in the spring.

Tells me, that the trip to Bluff Creek has no bearing on your promised revelations. So what could be the reason for your trip?
 
Drew:

"Tells me, that the trip to Bluff Creek has no bearing on your promised revelations. So what could be the reason for your trip?"

I'm sure Longtabber would back me up on this, but a good scientific proof is strengthened by multiple verifications of facts. It's like sending a specimen to two or three different labs for analysis, to see if all three arrive at the same determination. Reduces the margin or potential of error to have multiple verifications of facts.

Of course the trip is part of my current research project. The trip is to try and get an additional verification of information I already have, to strengthen the proof by having multiple verifications of the reliability of data. That's called good science, and that's why it takes time to accomplish.

Bill
 
I predict some of you will still complain about it even if it really is factually impartial and unbiased.

The concern is accuracy of results.

What do you think happened to cause the screw-up with the NASI report? That was a scientific analysis of the PGF which resulted in the subject's (Patty) weight estimate of 1,957 lbs. That is outrageous unless her flesh is a heavy metal. Did bias or partiality cause that error, or was it simply a mistake in the application of 'science'?

Complaints about results can come because they are wrong, not because there was any bias behind them.
 
I predict some of you will still complain about it even if it really is factually impartial and unbiased.

Bill
I predict you have decided which side you are on, before you have actually examined the evidence that is available ....

I predict you will determine the subject in the PGF cannot be a man in a suit ...

The problem remains: if their is no North American non-human primate, the subject in the PGF must be a person in a suit; personal incredulity notwithstanding...
 
WP:

"The concern is accuracy of results."

I agree the NASI report's erronious weight measurement was a big mistake. They should have caught it before they published.

I plan to check my numbers over and over again, and submit them to a few trusted people to doublecheck.

Diogenes:

"I predict you have decided which side you are on, before you have actually examined the evidence that is available ...."

we'll all know in 2009.

Bill
 
WP:

"The concern is accuracy of results."

I agree the NASI report's erronious weight measurement was a big mistake. They should have caught it before they published.

I plan to check my numbers over and over again, and submit them to a few trusted people to doublecheck.


The thing is Bill, you won't know what mistakes you made (if any) until somebody else finds them. A few trusted reviewers may not find the mistakes either. It always works that way. When you say "trusted people", do you mean folks you have befriended and regard as trustworthy?

NASI used a calculation to come up with the weight...


Estimated Mass

The mass of all primates has been shown to be allometrically related to chest size [McMahon 1983*]. Whether this equation is applicable to the subject of the Patterson-Gimlin film is open to debate. It is nonetheless interesting to note the mass estimated by this equation.

The allometric relationship that relates chest circumference in centimeters to mass in kilograms is:

eq7.gif
(Eq. 7)

Substituting the chest circumference in centimeters, the estimated mass of the subject in the Patterson-Gimlin film is 887 kg or 1,957 lbs. An error analysis has not yet been undertaken.

*McMahon, Thomas A. and Bonner, John Tyler, On Size and Life, Scientific American Books, Inc., 1983.


They probably ran that equation more than once to make sure it was right.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom