Bigfoot - serious, not follies

It's difficult to imagine a hoaxer, in 1969, being able to lay down 1089 tracks overnight with such a deformity. Tracks like that were seen 30 years earlier, incidently.
It's a lot harder to imagine that all these Bigfoots are not laying down many more tracks themselves, much less one individual leaving only two sets of tracks over 30 years..
 
LAL said:
Because it's still been shown what it's not.

How do you know which hairs it's being compared to? Have the people testing the hairs compared the 'purported' squatch hair to hair samples from ALL North American mammals in that area? The admission that they "plan to expand our own hair reference collection..." suggests they might not have.

Why are samples still being submitted if the hair holds no promise...

Because of the hope and possibility of obtaining a sample of DNA from the hair core.

...and why does he state he has over a dozen he's willing to identify as Sasquatch?

I know he's said this: "I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair..."

That's a direct quote.

I'm hardly "infatuated". The hair is just a small part of the evidence. It's interesting even if not compelling.

It was only interesting up to a point. I've seen no recent information on hair analysis that is either interesting OR compelling.

I read all that. But our continual harping on Fahrenbach may be giving the impression no one but him has examined hairs.

If the hair analysis is inconclusive does it matter?

Dr. Fahrenbach was at Oregon Primate Research Center and sent the hairs to Dr. Fuerst at OSU, so whether he's considered an expert on hair analysis or not, he didn't rely on his own expertise.

Back in 1998 both Fahrenbach and Fuerst agreed the hair analysis did not provide definitive proof.

But sixteen samples identified as "unknown" or "unknown primate" (according to Roger Knights, and I don't know his sources, but I'm sure he's got 'em) is pretty suggestive. Presumably human hair was ruled out as well.

Suggestive sources should be quoted. ;) Some say Fahrenbach's results are suggestive. From what I've read, that's not the case. If presuming human hair was ruled out equates to 'indistinguishable FROM human hair', have they really been ruled out? (I'm not certain what sources/analysis you're referring to, so I'm playing devil's advocate here.)

Prior to 1980, anyway.

More recent hair analysis results have proven nothing.

I've told you where to find more recent findings (still inconclusive, of course). I'm not a very good DVD salesperson, am I?

You aren't allowed to quote small portions of the hair analysis results?

Not even evidence they migrated over the Bering Strait from China? Gosh, I'm crushed.

As well you should be. :D You've offered no proof that bigfoot migrated over the Bering Strait.

RayG
 
zaayrdragon said:
So how many have you seen, LAL?


Meaning compelling scofftic arguments? So far, none. Some good questions, but not an iota of evidence that all this can be explained by hoaxes, misidentification and some sort of primordial need to see big, hairy "boogeymen". Why don't desert-dwellers have this need?


Ignoring the hair, the footprint casts - which have been very inconsistant -,


Be specific. If you're referring to the three-toed tracks in Dennett's article they could be due to a congenital deformity, or there may be another unknown species.


Some tracks found at Bluff Creek seven years prior to the PGF turned out to be from the same individual.


the exceptionally poor photographic and videographic evidence,

Seeing them on TV doesn't really give a good idea of the quality. Being that most encounters last about 20 seconds and are usually at night, it seems amazing to me there are films and videos at all.

the questionable scat samples,


Questionable? The sheer volume of some rule out just about anything but horses, and the difference there can be detected easily, as evidenced by Dahinden's famous comment on the finding of some of that.


the unreliable eyewitness reports,


What makes you think they're all unreliable? Sasquatches have been seen by everyone from school kids to professional people, one a psychologist. A PhD photographed tracks in California this last April.

and you still have to face the lack of fossil records and remains,

Okapi's don't have a fossil record either, nor do Chimpanzees and Gorillas. It was 67 years between the "discovery" of the Giant Panda and a live capture, despite expeditions trying to obtain them for zoos.

the lack of blood or skin samples,

Just how would you go about getting those without risking getting your head removed?


the lack of habitation evidence,


You need to do your homework. A "feeding lot" was found after the Nelson Creek sighting/video this year. There seem to be some territorial marking and occasional nests. They seem to range singly or in small family groups. They don't leave much sign, nor are there many people out looking for it.


the lack of sightings by qualified biologists,


Of course one did discover a trackway. There haven't been many biologists out looking for them, have there?

the improbable nature of a creature being able to hide in the woods for hundreds of years unobserved,


Make that plural. They're nocturnal and inhabit rough terrain in the PNW that's not only uninhabited, it's seldom visited by humans, especially at night. Dozens of planes have vanished without a trace in those forests since WWII.

They may also inhabit deep forests in other parts of the country (and Canada).

They are observed, just not by scientists yet.

the lack of appearance of adolescent or female members of the species,

What? The figure in the MD footage appears to be an adolescent female and may have a baby with her. The second figure in the 1994 Freeman footage may be a female hoisting an infant. The PGF is clearly of a female. There are many reports of females and the Ostman incident involved a family group with a female and two adolescents. "Jacko" may have been an adolescent male.

and the several times when hoaxers have been fully able to fool so-called 'experts'.

Name 'em and give the details.

All-in-all, things look pretty bad for the pathetic morons who still push 'Bigfoot' on folks.


Ad hominem attacks on people who take this seriously do nothing to further your case.

As far as your friends' friends and relatives being insulted - Well, too bad. But I've seen it plenty of times before. I'm a Pagan priest; I see lots of people every single day deluding themselves into believing all manner of tripe and nonsense.


And you make money encouraging this? Or do you do it for free. Either way, you ought to be ashamed of yourself. :p


I've even seen people who, after being shown solid evidence of what they actually saw, swear that they know what they saw, be it faeries, bogies, ghosts, or any other supernatural stuff.

Resperdol can be useful.

But your acquaintances shouldn't feel too insulted - most people are gullible morons.


Two of those aquaintances followed a double trackway for seven miles with the film crew from the Vancouver (Wa.) Columbian. Another was a deputy in on a sighting investigation, and the Sherriff kept a cast on his desk for years. The pharmacist had a sighting after I moved (his uncle did too, years earlier). A friend of the head librarian saw one by the railroad tracks near the Columbia. The manager of the auto parts store had cousins who saw one as children (he was sceptical himself) - they mentioned whistling, and I doubt they'd read any reports of that.

These were leading citizens, not "gullible morons".

It's just that people like you, who continue to feed the morons this nonsense, are responsible for the problem, really.

You, a Pagan priest, who feeds nonsense to morons, are telling me this?

The scofftical POV has done much to prevent serious scientific investigation. Dr. Krantz' carreer was hurt by the attitude of his colleagues. He felt it was relevant to his field and that he would have been remiss to not pursue it. Primatologists at Yerkes pronounced the PGF authentic, but as soon as someone at the Smithsonian said there was "something wrong with it" (he didn't say what), it was dismissed as a hoax (except by Napier). Where was the objective investigation that should have followed?


Now - how about some solid evidence, and not more of this pathetic stuff?

How about getting informed on it? Your appalling ignorance on the subject is showing.
 
Diogenes said:
It's a lot harder to imagine that all these Bigfoots are not laying down many more tracks themselves, much less one individual leaving only two sets of tracks over 30 years..

There were tracks near the garbage dump before Dahinden was called in. More tracks were found across the river after Dahinden counted the tracks. They were in snow or they might not have been seen at all. This individual may have been near the end of its life and was driven from more remote areas by a need for food.

It's hard to find tracks of anything in forest. Try looking sometime.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Alleged sasquatch hair and feces were also tested at the University of Tennessee by John Placyk.

Got more on this? I'm not finding anything.

It wouldn't have to do with Mary Green, would it?
 
BronzeDog said:
Shifting burden of proof: We aren't here to prove they are hoaxes. Hoaxing just happens to be one explanation that covers a number of sightings pretty well.




And you're willing to accept someone is hoaxing in the Yukon without any evidence this is the case.

The burden of proof is on those making the "extrodinary" claims, and to some, the "hoax hypothesis" is extraordinary and the reality of these creatures the parsimonious explanation. So, why not some proof from the sceptical side? The little there's been (Wallace, e.g.) falls apart pretty quickly.
 
Re: Hair samples ?

casebro said:
You know, when I bump my head bad enough to leave a clump of hair worth inspecting, the hair is usually atached to some skin. If I pluck a single hair it often has the follicle attached. I would think that out of all those 'bigfoot' hair samples, just one would have some cellular material big enough to do a MTDNA analysis. The cops did OJ Simpson's from a blood droplet. OJ's was a 1 in 50,000,000 match. (stupid jurors). So, one bigfoot follicle could prove his matrilinear genetics- human , ape, orangutan, chimp?

And to defend my copy-cat hoax hypothisis: Without even putting on my furry suit, I'm between 6 feet and 8 feet tall, depending on which convienience store I'm coming out of at the time....and I just remembered that I have a hair-on horse hide in a packing barrel somewhere....borrow a sewing machine...."No, those aren't seams, those are tendons? ...or scars?.....make it reversible to use as a Reptoid tooo.....Next trip to the Mini-Mart, I'l have to buy Micky's Big Mouth Malt Liqour to get in the spirit? I see the Headlines now " Big Foot spotted leaving Del Mar Convienence Store- Security Camera film at 11:00"....awe , nuts... that won't work, the clerk will check my ID to make sure I'm 21...

Do people in the Yukon do this as a matter of course?
 
LAL said:
Seeing them on TV doesn't really give a good idea of the quality. Being that most encounters last about 20 seconds and are usually at night, it seems amazing to me there are films and videos at all.

How about seeing them firsthand? Every single one I've seen has been of rotten quality.

Questionable? The sheer volume of some rule out just about anything but horses, and the difference there can be detected easily, as evidenced by Dahinden's famous comment on the finding of some of that.

Sheer volume of animal droppings in a forest? The forest is full of creatures - why would the sheer volume count out anything but horses?

You do realize how stupid a statemnet that actually is...

What makes you think they're all unreliable? Sasquatches have been seen by everyone from school kids to professional people, one a psychologist. A PhD photographed tracks in California this last April.

I knew a psychologist once who kept garlic under his bed because he was convinced his neighbor was a vampire. I've known Ph.D.s in many fields who believed in ghosts, homeopathy, and alien abductions. Being a professional doesn't make you credible; having a degree doesn't prevent you from being gullible.

Okapi's don't have a fossil record either, nor do Chimpanzees and Gorillas. It was 67 years between the "discovery" of the Giant Panda and a live capture, despite expeditions trying to obtain them for zoos.

Actually, Giraffe-like ancestors do appear in the fossile records, so you're wrong there. Likewise, prehistoric primates also exist in fossil records, so you're wrong there too.

And the Chinese knew about the Giant Panda long before white man every did - it only shows your racist POV that you think the 'discovery' and subsequent capture was something new.

Where are the natives familiar with BigFoot? Other than a few scant legends. Chinese historians and artists had Giant Pandas down pat for centuries.

Just how would you go about getting those without risking getting your head removed?

Well, I wasn't talking about trying to get a fresh sample... :D

But given the terrible nature of human beings, I expect people would have hunted these creatures in numerous ways... Traps, shotguns, rifles, etc. etc. might all get skin and blood samples or - heck - Sasquatch bodies. Even a dead BigFoot would at least be proof. Not that I approve of such methods, but there are some who do - which makes the lack of evidence even more curious.

You need to do your homework. A "feeding lot" was found after the Nelson Creek sighting/video this year. There seem to be some territorial marking and occasional nests. They seem to range singly or in small family groups. They don't leave much sign, nor are there many people out looking for it.

Hmmm... the only Nelson Creek sighting I can find is listed as unconfirmed/unreviewed. Perhaps too new to be discussed... And no information whatsoever about feeding lots.

I'll have to see it when it turns up publicly.

Of course one did discover a trackway. There haven't been many biologists out looking for them, have there?

After all - why look for something that doesn't exist?

Make that plural. They're nocturnal and inhabit rough terrain in the PNW that's not only uninhabited, it's seldom visited by humans, especially at night. Dozens of planes have vanished without a trace in those forests since WWII.

Granted - but since, as you rightly say, it should be plural, that only makes matters worse, not better.

They may also inhabit deep forests in other parts of the country (and Canada).

They are observed, just not by scientists yet.

Nor by reliable witnesses, apparently, or scientists would be looking harder.

What? The figure in the MD footage appears to be an adolescent female and may have a baby with her. The second figure in the 1994 Freeman footage may be a female hoisting an infant. The PGF is clearly of a female. There are many reports of females and the Ostman incident involved a family group with a female and two adolescents. "Jacko" may have been an adolescent male.

'appears to be', 'may be'... Not very sure, are you?

But to be fair, I was unaware that any of these creatures looked female. The 1994 footage definitely didn't look at all female. And the PGF does not look like a female - though I've never seen the original, and find it highly suspicious that such a key piece of evidence is only available for purchase, not openly available for research. This is not the way of science, but of marketting, and is just more suggestion that BigFoot is a big money-making scheme.

Name 'em and give the details.

"In one case, Krantz claimed as one of the gold standards of Bigfoot tracks a print that "passed all my criteria, published and private, that distinguishes sasquatch tracks from human tracks and from fakes" (Krantz 1992). He further agreed that it had all the signs of a living foot, and that no human foot could have made the imprint. Michael R. Dennett, investigating for the Skeptical Inquirer, tracked down the anonymous construction worker who supplied the Bigfoot print. The man admitted faking the tracks himself to see if Krantz could really detect a fake (Dennett 1994). "

"Krantz certainly isn't alone in his mistaken identifications. One of the biggest names in cryptozoology, Ivan Sanderson, was badly fooled by tracks he confidently proclaimed would be impossible to fake. In 1948 (and for a decade afterward), giant three-toed footprints were found along the beach in Clearwater, Florida. Sanderson, described as a man who "was extremely knowledgeable on many subjects, and had done more fieldwork than most zoologists do today" (Greenwell 1988), spent two weeks at the site of the tracks investigating, analyzing the tracks, and consulting other experts. He concluded that the tracks were made by a fifteen-foot-tall penguin. "

www.csicop.org/si/2002-03/bigfoot.html

But of course, you won't accept that, since it comes from evil CSICOP...

Oh well.

Ad hominem attacks on people who take this seriously do nothing to further your case.

It ain't ad-hom if it's true. :)

And you make money encouraging this? Or do you do it for free. Either way, you ought to be ashamed of yourself. :p

Nope, I don't encourage anything. I'm a Pagan priest, but I act in a somewhat different capacity than most. And I make no money for my work - I just help people find their way, wherever that way may lead.

But at least I don't tell people things are true in spite of all evidence against it... :p

Resperdol can be useful.

You should try it sometime.

Two of those aquaintances followed a double trackway for seven miles with the film crew from the Vancouver (Wa.) Columbian. Another was a deputy in on a sighting investigation, and the Sherriff kept a cast on his desk for years. The pharmacist had a sighting after I moved (his uncle did too, years earlier). A friend of the head librarian saw one by the railroad tracks near the Columbia. The manager of the auto parts store had cousins who saw one as children (he was sceptical himself) - they mentioned whistling, and I doubt they'd read any reports of that.

These were leading citizens, not "gullible morons".

Are you trying to say that 'leading citizens' can't be gullible? That they can't be morons?

The Royal Family of England would certainly count as 'leading citizens' in London, right? But they believe in homeopathy.

Argument by authority doesn't work here either, LAL. Sherriffs, deputies, pharmacists, etc. are just as gullible and just as stupid as everyone else. Ignorance and foolishness exist in every single profession on earth. The President of the United States thinks that his branch of Christianity are the only ones going to heaven, and that everyone else deserves to suffer.

So I stand by what I say: at least 70% of everyone who thinks they've seen Bigfoot evidence are gullible morons; the rest are ignorant of what they've actually seen, or have perhaps actually seen Bigfoot evidence. But the probabilities and the observations so far support the idea that Bigfoot is a nice moneymaking scheme like UFOlogy and Nessie.

You, a Pagan priest, who feeds nonsense to morons, are telling me this?

I feed nothing. I preach nothing. Since you don't know me, and don't know what I do, only what I am, your strawman attacks are meaningless.

Ask around. I'm not your usual 'Witch Boy'. I'm fully accredited as Clergy in accordance with state laws, and fully accredited by an incorporated Church, recognized by Federal and State government; so I am a 'Pagan Priest'. This doesn't mean I go around telling people to leave whiskey out to keep the faeries happy, carry bloodstones to absorb evil energies, or consult tarot cards to glimpse their futures. In fact, I generally tell people the opposite - that they have to understand the world around them first before they go off seeking the magical and mysterious. And I definitely don't feed them shoddy evidence, anecdotes, and scams and expect them to believe. Like you do.

The scofftical POV has done much to prevent serious scientific investigation. Dr. Krantz' carreer was hurt by the attitude of his colleagues. He felt it was relevant to his field and that he would have been remiss to not pursue it. Primatologists at Yerkes pronounced the PGF authentic, but as soon as someone at the Smithsonian said there was "something wrong with it" (he didn't say what), it was dismissed as a hoax (except by Napier). Where was the objective investigation that should have followed?

"Scofftical"? You feel a need for ad-hominem now yourself, obviously.

There's no doubt the PGF debate will rage on; but that is largely because it is such a shoddy film clip. Is that a bell-shaped fastener, or matted feces? Is the creature male, or female? Is its chest too large to be human, or within normal tolerance? Did Chambers make a costume for a hoax, or not?

The problem, LAL, is that it is impossible - especially today - to have 'objective investigations' precisely because we have all formed our opinions already about Bigfoot. Either you believe in them - in which case, your investigations will confirm Bigfoot - or you don't, in which case your investigations will deny Bigfoot.

How about getting informed on it? Your appalling ignorance on the subject is showing.

As is your appalling gullibility and ignorance, or perhaps you're just invested in your scam?

What would you do (serious question, here) if a team of the most respected Bigfoot researchers were to come forward tomorrow and declare the whole thing to be a hoax? Would you drop Bigfoot research and do something useful, or would you decide that they had been poisoned by the 'Scofftics' and continue your quest for the Hairy Grail?
 
LAL said:
There were tracks near the garbage dump before Dahinden was called in. More tracks were found across the river after Dahinden counted the tracks. They were in snow or they might not have been seen at all. This individual may have been near the end of its life and was driven from more remote areas by a need for food.

It's hard to find tracks of anything in forest. Try looking sometime.

It's not that hard. In fact, if you know what to look for, forests aren't hard to track in at all. Tracks in snow are easier to follow.
 
LAL said:



And you're willing to accept someone is hoaxing in the Yukon without any evidence this is the case.

The burden of proof is on those making the "extrodinary" claims, and to some, the "hoax hypothesis" is extraordinary and the reality of these creatures the parsimonious explanation. So, why not some proof from the sceptical side? The little there's been (Wallace, e.g.) falls apart pretty quickly. [/B]

Nope, sorry.

The extraordinary claim is that there is a species of eight foot tall Primate hiding in the Northern Forests, and in spite of thousands of sightings, no one can actually get good evidence of one of them.

The hoax hypothesis alone is insufficient to explain what has been observed; but combined with an acceptible level of erroneous interpretation of findings, pretty much covers the 'parsimonious explanation'.
 
An interesting opinion on Dr. Fahrenbach and hair analysis over on the BFF:
http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=5210&st=0&#entry103272

Originally posted by colobus May 22 2004, 04:59 PM]

"If I read these conflicting examination accounts correctly, then this brings up some very troubling issues regarding Henner's ability to non-subjectively examine hair samples. There have been warning flags in the past regarding Henner and hair analysis, but this seems more serious.

In the past hair samples loaned to Henner have been retained by him against the wishes of the collectors (not myself). He has also refused to publish on the subject, has given over the years somewhat different "gold standards," and refused any peer review of his collection or conclusions.

I'm not trying to bash Henner here, but one needs to remember that he is a retired parasitologist, not a hair expert. He has, via his interest in sasquatch, gained an extensive lay-knowledge of hair analysis. But it is not formal education in the subject.

His letter to Green states that the subject hair's do not match those of any known North American animal, and they appear to those of a primate (or a pig - if you favor the analysis in John's letter). Assuming this is true (i.e. is a primate & not N. American mammal) that does NOT equal undescribed primate.

It's not terribly hard to get the hair of any one of a hundred types of primates to send in to be analized. All will come back as primate, and NOT of North American origin. I have myself hair from a dozen african primates unlikely to be represented in most hair analizers collection of representative samples. There are only a couple labs in the world that have samples of hair from all known mammals. I can tell you that Henner's home is not one of them.

Henner has fully embraced multiple habituation stories in the past, and now appears to be changing hair analysis results to favor one. One has to wonder how objective and rigorous are his methods. How about some peer review. Most serious reserchers try hard to get peer review, yet Henner actively avoids it."

Apparently I'm not the only one that finds Dr. Fahrenbach's findings less than convincing.

RayG
 
hodgy said:
Correa Netto: Superb - you took the (albeit dodgy) pro-bigfoot argument to tiny pieces. I've been watching this thread awhile and yours was the most conclusive refutation (there's others 99% as good but apologies - Correa's was superlative).

I suppose we should be grateful to believers for keeping us supplied with interesting threads :o)

Correa has done a good job of showing there are no fossils, but we already knew that.

As far as there "should" be fossils I'm waiting for evidence there are fossils of even the common forest-dwellers of the PNW. Deer? Chickarees? A subspecies of the Cascades Sapsucker even?
 
As Professor Farnsworth said (and I'm paraphrasing here):

"BALDERDASH!! Show me some Bigfoot droppings or SHUT THE HELL UP!!"
 
Correa Neto said:
Ever considered the possibilty of all these “evidences” being a product of hoaxes AND misinterpretations?


There are misinterpretations (snags are common), but when you have multiple witnesses, physical evidence and the thing moves, it's a pretty good guess it's not a snag.

So now I'm supposed to believe witnesses are misidentifying hoaxers?


Nope. You have to (1) prove that big foot exists; (2) prove that Gigantopithecus was biped and (3) prove that the two animals were related. A bit of work remains to be done, don´t you think?


Since fossils are so common and easy to find, according to you, there should be Gigantopithecus femurs and pelvic bones all over Asia.

Note that they left their remains, so we managed to have a good idea on their constitution and geographic span. Note also that their geographic span is comparable to that of bigfoot and relatives. And even if the millions of individuals figures is correct (could not find refferences), what was bigfoot population before humans begun to mess with the environment? Quite possibly above the current 14000 individuals estimates within USA. So, nothing you wrote serves as an explanation for absence of bigfoot remains (fossil or not).


Krantz, on the A&E show (which I just received) says 2000 and makes it clear he's guessing (I recall 15,000 from the book, but I could be wrong). Let's go back to 2000-6000.

There's no evidence their population has shrunk. It could have grown. A small population could have spread over the Bering Strait, and started speading out of the PNW in more recent times. The PNW has the largest population and more Indian legends that seem to be unmistakably about them than Eastern tribes do.

Sure, few areas on Earth will be left outside as places where remains (fossil or not) should have been found.


I'm not sure I follow that.

Now, after what I wrote about the mapinguari, do you still consider the legend as a reliable indication of the presence of a giant sloth or a giant primate in the Amazon forest? And, don´t you think similar distortions could have happened to the other legends (amas, yeti, sasquatch, etc.) cited as "evidence" for the existence of these animals?


Heuvelmans, Sanderson and Coleman have written of the mapinguary as a form of primate. David Oren thinks the natives are seeing a medium-sized Giant Sloth. (See Cryptozology A to Z by Loren Coleman and Jerome Clark, pg. 151.) I don't know what evidence there is for them.

There seems to be more evidence for Sasquatches just from the State of Washington than there is for any of the other cryptic hominids worldwide, maybe all put together.............Just my impression.

Sturgeons and otters are the most likely candidates to be misinterpreted nessie sightings (same is valid for ogopogo). Check a picture of a sturgeon´s lateral fin and you´ll see a pretty good candidate fot the “flipper photo”.


Sounds reasonable. Thanks.

Now, plenty of people are currently working and worked at the areas where bigfeet are supposed to live. In a way, you can say it was (and is being) scanned.


And plenty of these people have seen them. Don't forget residents. They see them too, sometimes.

Ifs, maybes and mays. Do you know that many places that were used for the habitat expansion are still above sea level? And that actually they are well above it? When icecaps retreat, isostasy happens. Since the weight of the glaciers is no longer present, the ground slowly is uplifted. This is called isostasy. Not to mention that the migration routes did not followed the shoreline all along. They followed gaps in the glaciers, many of these gaps were well within the continent.

Actually there´s no evidence that they live anywhere. And forest animals are fossilized also. I´ve already explained that.


Did I miss the post where you showed me fossilized forest-dwelling animals of the Pacific Northwest?

I say the odds are, given what we know, that its does not exists. It may exist, but it is quite unlikely.


In your opinion. I don't think it's shared by many who have actually seen them.

That was not a question. That was a statement. Rapid burial is one way of enhancing fossilization chances. A quiet, oxigen-deprived lake with slow silt or mud deposition are very nice environments for fossilization. I´ll write again: Taking in to account the whole area these creatures are supposed to live nowdays (or have lived in the past)there´s a large number of possible fossilization sites, and by different processes.


Then there should be many fossils of the common forest-dwellers of the PNW, shouldn't there? Where are they?

It´s already being discussed by other posters here. And yes, it seems the hoaxers can fool a lot of people, actually it seems that a lot of people get confused even without the hoaxer´s help.... Why the hoaxers made his stunt just in 1969? You should ask to the hoaxers, not to me.


I would if there were any, other than Ray Pickens, who didn't even claim he'd made tracks near Bossburg, let alone Carson. As usual, the carved feet didn't match anything. The hoaxes have been few and far between and quickly exposed. They're the work of amateurs with no knowlege of anatomy, biomechanics, primate locomotion..............

Of course not. Anyone can see that. What I am saying is that animals die in floods, including those that live in forests, what increases the chances of having their remains preserved.


Where are the fossil Chickarees? Flickers? Cougars? Bear?

And once again you use PNW as a comparsion.


Why not? That's where the largest number of sightings are. It's also the area I'm most familiar with.

You should understand that such argument is completely useless, unless the creature not only is endemic to this area but also evolved there, maybe from a squirrel...


That's a joke, right?

No one's saying they evolved there or anywhere in North America.

Its another OT digression, but I´ll take that by "siltation" you are reffering to deposition of silt, the granulometric fraction between fine sand and clay. If this is so, can ou really say there´s little silt deposition across the whole area composed by the PNW? I say that if there are any lakes nearby glaciers, or are fed by creeks or rivers that are born in glaciers, your claim is flawed.


Yep. There are nine permanent glaciers on Mt. Hood and eleven on Rainier, as I recall. You don't see dredges on the Columbia. I was near the French Broad today, which is brown and near flood. The Columbia is clear by comparison (it reportedly was before Eastern Washington was irrigated). There is little siltation in the Cascades. Shores tend to be rocky.

What part of "volcanic" didn't you understand?

In Africa, Europe and Asia.


I was referring to the Bering Strait and Alaska, not human remains anywhere else. If fossilization is such a sure thing there should be fossils representing all the human waves of migration, which may have begun 40,000 years ago.

There´s no reliable evidence of humans in the Americas 40Ky ago. Where are the evidences for bigfoot for ANY time period ANYWHERE?


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/4650307.stm

Also, there's evidence of worked bone in Alaska that dates to 40,000 years ago.

Footprints and film of a Sasquatch from last April don't work for you do they?


If jaguars and bigfoot are related? Well, since bigfoot is immaginary, it can be even related to terrapins...


I find that statement sort of silly.

You wrote on the previous post about fossils of jaguars and grizzlies. And stated that these animals did not lived in forests, thus they would not be found associated with bigfoot. As you can see, they do live in forests. And the supposed geographic span of bigfoot do overlaps with that of the grizzly bear.


There are no Jaguars or Grizzlies in the PNW (except for eastern Washington), nor the Ohio Valley, but there could be some overlap with Grizzlies in the Southern Rockies. Jaguars?

"Jaguars have not been found in Florida since Prehistoric times. When Spaniards first discovered Florida, the northern limit of the jaguars range extended into Texas, New Mexico and Arizona. Further south, the jaguar was found throughout Mexico, Central and South America, all the way to northern Argentina. By the 1980s, the jaguars range was reduced by two-thirds in North and Central America and, within 75% of its present range, the jaguar has been reduced or greatly reduced in numbers. Although the jaguar has been virtually eliminated from the United States, photographs of a jaguar in Arizona were documented during 2002."

http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/UW176

"Home Range: Grizzly bears can be found in the Canadian provinces of British Columbia, Alberta, Yukon, and the Northwest Territories; and the US states of Alaska, Idaho, Wyoming, Washington, and Montana. In general their home range is between 10 and 380 square miles. A grizzly bear’s home range is basically inland – away from major bodies of water. In most cases, a grizzly bear’s home range includes an area of forested land or shrub cover, which is used mostly for escape (Jonkel 1984, p 21)."

http://www.bear.org/Grizzly/Grizzly_Brown_Bear_Facts.html


And again, since PNW is not the only place where bigfeet are suposed to live or to have lived, using it as a standard is useless.
These are my points.


So you choose to ignore the evidence that points to the largest population being in the Northwest (that's a huge area, from Northern California into Canada) and prefer to hypothesize they live with Grizzlies and Jaguars so you can claim there should be fossils?

Your points are not well taken.

Another claim that you can´t really defend. You are saying that its such a blessed area that never has dry periods? Years or months when there´s exceptionally small precipitation? It never happened? The climate never changed there?


There was a drought this year:
http://www.livescience.com/forcesofnature/050321_crazy_weather.html
But there was still a snowpack.
Lewis and Clark experienced a month of rain on the Coast. Their tents rotted. I remember a month that had one clear day. I assured my kids before a camping trip that it never rains in August. It poured.

They may use caves......I don't know, but there's no need for them to die there.......or be preserved there. And who would know?

And I´ll write again: Even if PNW is such an unlikely place that never has dry periods (add this to PNW´s list of oddities), as an argument, it was useless, since the creature is not supposed to be endemic to this area, today or in the past...


They seem to prefer wet forests. I've never said they're confined to the PNW. Evidently there's some evidence for them elsewhere. I've been extremely sceptical of eastern reports. Now I'm not so sure.

Yep. Plaster do solidifies after drying.


Precisely.

Are you kidding? I can´t belive you really have not understood my point. No predator needs to kill a bigfoot for its remains (those from the bigfoot, not the predator)be preserved in a cave. It just has to die near the cave. Water flowing over the ground may carry the bones to the cave. It does not even need to have ever entered the cave when alive!


Are you trying to tell me water would carry a body uphill into a lava tube?

Oh, please, don´t use "there´s no limestone caves in PNW" as an argument...


There are limestone caves in the Pacific Northwest. I know of none in the Cascades, however.

PNW is not the only place these animals were supposed to live or to have lived.


There are reports from other parts of the country but Washington and California have the most by far. Oregon and Ohio are next with about half the documented reports (BFRO figures).

You can not compare the discovery of a mammal in Vietnam with bigfoot´s non-discovery. Take a look on the differences between the sizes of the animals (a small deer X a 2 to 3 m high ape) and the logistics (Vietnam X USA). So, people can discover a small deer in a remote jungle in Vietnam but not a 3m-high ape in USA...
Neither the discovery of a new parrot species in the Amazon jungle with bigfoot´s non-discovery, for the same reasons. So, people can discover a small parrot within the Amazon jungle in Brazil but not a 3m-high ape in USA...
Neither the (re)discovery of a woodpecker species in USA with bigfoot´s non-discovery serves as an argument. Heck, birds are even smaller and usually don´t leave tracks, since they spend most of their time flying. So, people can rediscover a woodpecker but not a 3m-high ape...


What does size have to do with it? An elusive animal is an elusive animal.

The deer's skull, was found, not the deer.

The video of the Ivory Bill is three seconds long. The PGF is 24' of film.

You don't see a double standard or anything there, do you?

Of course all the tracks are not mistaken identities. What about the hoaxes?


They're amateurish. The most sophisticated was the Snow Walker hoax, but even that was exposed.

Mammoths in South America? South America´s early human pouplation was adapted to small game. Your point was?


I was referring to the encampments in Alaska where the people were hunting Mammoths. I said nothing about South America with or without Mammoths. Other than dinosaurs, the only fossils in Alaska seem to be from animals that lived in the grasslands.

Already discussed. Forest animals do get preserved. It just depends on where in the forest the animal dies.


Then why are there no fossils of Chimpanzees and Gorillas? Or two million years worth of seed apes?

Check Paleoarctic tradition. And would you allow me to remind you that bigfeet´s supposed habitats were not restricted to the Bering land bridge and PNW?


I've never said they were.

I doubt. Every single biologist or paleontologist would love to have such a finding in his/hers hands.


Creationists would say the Devil put them there to deceive us.

>snipped for brevity and because I'm beginning to get irritated - there really are gaps in the fossil record, you know<

You know, there´s realiable and unreliable information. If you read - and understood- what I wrote you´ll see it´s just plain wrong. Compare the age of the Appalachian Orogeny 350 to 300 Ma (million years) 600 My and 2.1 Gy orogenesis. And these are not even the oldest ones, they just happen to be among the better known.


So, the National Park Service is unreliable. Noted.

My critic is to the dataused. This critic applies to every single text I´ve read defending the existence of bigfoot. The data used for all speculation is unreliable.

The data is composed by:
(i) Reports of sightings. There´s very little controll on this, specially the oldest cases. Memories change with times, sometimes "filling up" the voids, in some cases people can´t even differentiate between dreams and reality after a long time. Not to mention pure lies and hoaxes.


Many, if not most, sightings have been investigated soon after the incident. Many are backed up by physical evidence and some with film.

(ii) Interpretation of myths. I´ve already been through this. Its not reliable.


Ask the Indians.

(iii) Pictures and footage. They have poor quality, and one can not dismiss them as misinterpreatations, pareidolia and hoaxes.


Not? Heh, heh. That's what I say.

(iv) Alleged tracks. This is being discussed by the other posters. Unreliable, since a combination of misinterpretation and hoaxes can do the trick.


Nonsense. Have you seen any of the casts? Studied the photos? Read about the circumstances under which the tracks were found? Meldrum's collection is open for inspection at Idaho State.

(v) Hair samples. Again already being discussed by other posters. No reliable evidence provided at best. And with the shadow of hoaxes floating around.


DNA testing has been inconclusive. I think it's a safe assumption Dynel won't yield DNA. Inconclusive or not, it is real hair.
So, with this foundation, the whole building is very frail.

edited to fix some really messed up cut-and-paste

You know, it just struck me that a lot of the above applies to George Bush.
 
RayG said:
An interesting opinion on Dr. Fahrenbach and hair analysis over on the BFF:
http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=5210&st=0&#entry103272


Apparently I'm not the only one that finds Dr. Fahrenbach's findings less than convincing.

RayG

Well, we're coming up with some other names. I need to get one off the Ancient Mysteries show. Have at 'em.

There are critics on BFF. Who'd a thunk it? We've both been attacked too, haven't we?
 

I know he's said this: "I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair..."

That's a direct quote.
And here's the rest:

"..........of the particular structure (great variability is available among the latter). DNA extracted from both hair shaft or roots (hair demonstrably fresh) was too fragmented to permit gene sequencing. That characteristic is also sometimes found in human hair that lacks the medulla (as does sasquatch hair - at least what I am willing to identify as such). "


"The hair underwent lengthy and concerted analytical study by Dr. Fuerst and a graduate student, J. A. Poe, both with extensive experience in hair DNA analysis."

That is too.

You aren't allowed to quote small portions of the hair analysis results?

I'd have to watch it again and I'm busy. (Just answering one of CN's posts is taking hours.)

As well you should be. :D You've offered no proof that bigfoot migrated over the Bering Strait.

RayG

Might be a logical way to go, though, if they're descended from an African or Asian species. Beats Mothman.
 
More concerning Dr. Fahrenbach and/or hair analysis:

You really need to read this thread:
http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=5119

More from the BFF:

Originally posted by colobus @ Jan 14 2005, 01:13 AM
As has been pointed out before, Henner is a retired parsitologist, nothing more, nothing less. He's not a field primatologist, and not a hair expert.

Originally posted by Wildman @ Jan 26 2005, 01:27 PM
...Fahrenbach's testimony on hair samples is irrelevent, mainly because that isn't his field of specialty.

Originall posted by AnotherPullTab @ Jun 6 2005, 01:02 PM
"I took some heat a while back because I called Fahrenbach on one of his "Sasquatch hair" claims. I was attacking a pillar of the BF community and several folks took issue with it. I simply stated that he shouldnt be calling it Sasquatch hair because he had no actual sample of sasquatch hair to compare it to. Its an improper scientific conclusion."

From: http://www.bigfootencounters.com/biology/hair.htm

"There is no absolutely identified sasquatch hair. I have 12 samples from 4 states, all collected under suggestive or excellent circumstances. They measure from 3 to 15 inches in length, are all under 90 microns in diameter, all have a reddish tinge under the microscope, and all are lacking a medulla. You can find human hair like that...--Dr. W. H. Fahrenbach, 1997"

"Unfortunately for these earlier studies, the science of hair analysis is rather inexact and the competence of the investigator varies greatly...As one expert put it, the only way to positively identify a sasquatch hair is to match it with a known sample."-- Grover Krantz (originally from Big Footprints, pages 125-126)

RayG
 
zaayrdragon said:
How about seeing them firsthand? Every single one I've seen has been of rotten quality.


Try DVD.

Sheer volume of animal droppings in a forest? The forest is full of creatures - why would the sheer volume count out anything but horses?

You do realize how stupid a statemnet that actually is...


Evidently no more than you realize how stupid the question was.

I knew a psychologist once who kept garlic under his bed because he was convinced his neighbor was a vampire. I've known Ph.D.s in many fields who believed in ghosts, homeopathy, and alien abductions. Being a professional doesn't make you credible; having a degree doesn't prevent you from being gullible.



I'll have to tell my brother to shred his. Am I to lose all respect for PhDs because a few are kooks?

Actually, Giraffe-like ancestors do appear in the fossile records, so you're wrong there.


But not Okapis. They're not the same.

Likewise, prehistoric primates also exist in fossil records, so you're wrong there too.


Nope. I said Gorillas and Chimpanzees, not primates. If you've been following the thread you should know I've brought up several fossil primates.

And the Chinese knew about the Giant Panda long before white man every did - it only shows your racist POV that you think the 'discovery' and subsequent capture was something new.


Africans knew about Gorillas while whites thought they were myths. Native Americans knew about Sasquatches long before the coming of the whites. It's not a "discovery" until western science says so. And don't even think about calling me a racist.

Where are the natives familiar with BigFoot?


Do you want Hoopa, Salish, Kwakiutl, Kubu, Cree..........?

Other than a few scant legends.


"The term sasquatch, for the North American primate under consideration in this website, is an anglicized derivative of the word "Sésquac", meaning "wild man". The original word, in the Stó:lõ dialect of the Halkomelem language, is used by the Coast Salish Indians of the Fraser Valley and parts of Vancouver Island, British Columbia. Indian tribes across North America have a total of more than sixty different terms for the sasquatch."

Chinese historians and artists had Giant Pandas down pat for centuries.


They're in a very restricted area and it still took 67 years for a capture.
Sasquatches are represented in a few Native cultures.

Well, I wasn't talking about trying to get a fresh sample... :D

But given the terrible nature of human beings, I expect people would have hunted these creatures in numerous ways... Traps, shotguns, rifles, etc. etc. might all get skin and blood samples or - heck - Sasquatch bodies. Even a dead BigFoot would at least be proof. Not that I approve of such methods, but there are some who do - which makes the lack of evidence even more curious.


Green has reports of five kills.

Hmmm... the only Nelson Creek sighting I can find is listed as unconfirmed/unreviewed. Perhaps too new to be discussed... And no information whatsoever about feeding lots.

I'll have to see it when it turns up publicly.


It already has. The newspaper stories are unfortunately archived, but I've posted reprints on another thread.

http://wriversasquatchassoc.net/index50norwayhouse.html


After all - why look for something that doesn't exist?


They do exist. I find it hard to believe there's any doubt.

Granted - but since, as you rightly say, it should be plural, that only makes matters worse, not better.


And why is that?

Nor by reliable witnesses, apparently, or scientists would be looking harder.


Dr. Krantz spent as much time in the field as he could. Dr. Meldrum has too. There's no grant money for this or you might see a team.

'appears to be', 'may be'... Not very sure, are you?


I got in the habit of using the cautious language of science while debating Creationism vs. Evolution. You just used a Creationist argument.
I've been criticized on another thread for using "absolutist" statements.

But to be fair, I was unaware that any of these creatures looked female. The 1994 footage definitely didn't look at all female.


The second figure may be, just because it seems to be lifting an infant. Only the back is visible.

And the PGF does not look like a female -


What about the breasts?

though I've never seen the original, and find it highly suspicious that such a key piece of evidence is only available for purchase, not openly available for research. This is not the way of science, but of marketting, and is just more suggestion that BigFoot is a big money-making scheme.


The copyright is held by Patricia Patterson, Roger's widow. She has a right to charge. He didn't leave her much; he spent the last of the money he made touring with the film on a wild goose chase after a Yeti that was supposed to have been held in a Tibetan monastary. The film was shown to primatologists at Yerkes, the Smithsonian..........Dahinden took it to Russia to be seen by biomechanics experts.

Dahinden bought Gimlin's rights (for a reported $26) and spent a lot of money trying to straighten out the rights (Roger kind of oversold them). The film was tied up for years. Dahinden made a living collecting spent shot so he could have time to follow leads. He died broke. DeAtley made some money on the PGF, but he and Roger cut Gimlin out. Gimlin defends the film to this day.

You might want to check out some of the history before you make any more mistakes like that.


"In one case, Krantz claimed as one of the gold standards of Bigfoot tracks a print that "passed all my criteria, published and private, that distinguishes sasquatch tracks from human tracks and from fakes" (Krantz 1992). He further agreed that it had all the signs of a living foot, and that no human foot could have made the imprint. Michael R. Dennett, investigating for the Skeptical Inquirer, tracked down the anonymous construction worker who supplied the Bigfoot print. The man admitted faking the tracks himself to see if Krantz could really detect a fake (Dennett 1994). "


According to Rick Noll, who talked to him about it, Dahinden, who had examined tracks in situ put Parker up to it. In Rick's words, René could be mean. He didn't like Dr. Krantz, or PhDs in general. Krantz could be arrogant at times, and René evidently decided to get him. Krantz made it clear he didn't think much of reports from the east until he saw hat cast. It's unfortunate the mistake made it into the book (because sceptics seize on that and ignore the rest of the work), but there's a track from Elkins Creek, Georgia, Jimmy Chilcutt (forensic fingerprint expert) found compelling.

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/elkins.html

"Krantz certainly isn't alone in his mistaken identifications. One of the biggest names in cryptozoology, Ivan Sanderson, was badly fooled by tracks he confidently proclaimed would be impossible to fake. In 1948 (and for a decade afterward), giant three-toed footprints were found along the beach in Clearwater, Florida. Sanderson, described as a man who "was extremely knowledgeable on many subjects, and had done more fieldwork than most zoologists do today" (Greenwell 1988), spent two weeks at the site of the tracks investigating, analyzing the tracks, and consulting other experts. He concluded that the tracks were made by a fifteen-foot-tall penguin. "

www.csicop.org/si/2002-03/bigfoot.html

But of course, you won't accept that, since it comes from evil CSICOP..."

Oh well.


I would certainly like to see some verification of the Sanderson story. I've read a lot of Sanderson's work, and that just doesn't seem to fit at all. Dennett's much better at making mistatements than he is at correcting them.

I happen to be a CSICOP fan, but I think they're way off base with their articles by Dennett, Daegling and Korff and Kocis.

It ain't ad-hom if it's true. :)


It isn't true.

Nope, I don't encourage anything. I'm a Pagan priest, but I act in a somewhat different capacity than most. And I make no money for my work - I just help people find their way, wherever that way may lead.


Then you might want to try respecting differences.

But at least I don't tell people things are true in spite of all evidence against it... :p


There's no evidence against Sasquatches and a huge amount for them.

You should try it sometime.


I'm not delusional.

Are you trying to say that 'leading citizens' can't be gullible? That they can't be morons?


Did you catch the part where I mentioned the camera crew? The tracks were filmed.
What gives you the right to call people you don't know "gullible morons"?

The Royal Family of England would certainly count as 'leading citizens' in London, right? But they believe in homeopathy.


I hate to call them "twits", but...........well, one of my best friends does too.

Argument by authority doesn't work here either, LAL. Sherriffs, deputies, pharmacists, etc. are just as gullible and just as stupid as everyone else. Ignorance and foolishness exist in every single profession on earth. The President of the United States thinks that his branch of Christianity are the only ones going to heaven, and that everyone else deserves to suffer.


It is not an appeal to authority to mention the occupations of those involved in those investigations. Since law enforcement was called, law enforcement showed up. The pharmacist might not have wanted his name mentioned, so I just mentioned his profession. Same with the head librarian. You wouldn't know them from the town drunk if I just "dropped names". The two who followed the tracks were the publisher of the paper and the photographer, later owner of the paper and county commissioner.

So I stand by what I say: at least 70% of everyone who thinks they've seen Bigfoot evidence are gullible morons; the rest are ignorant of what they've actually seen, or have perhaps actually seen Bigfoot evidence. But the probabilities and the observations so far support the idea that Bigfoot is a nice moneymaking scheme like UFOlogy and Nessie.


You really don't know what you're talking about.

I feed nothing. I preach nothing. Since you don't know me, and don't know what I do, only what I am, your strawman attacks are meaningless.


Ah, haven't you done that to me? You assume; you don't ask. My opinion of religion of any kind would probably get me a five-day suspension, so I'll ignore what you do.

>snip<
And I definitely don't feed them shoddy evidence, anecdotes, and scams and expect them to believe. Like you do.


I'm presenting what evidence there is and I don't think it's shoddy. If I can't convince, I can at least educate.

"Scofftical"? You feel a need for ad-hominem now yourself, obviously.


Nope. It's a term I picked up on another board. I use it to distinquish the people who dismiss this out of hand and who don't know enough about it to have an opinion from the people who know something about it and ask good questions.

There's no doubt the PGF debate will rage on; but that is largely because it is such a shoddy film clip. Is that a bell-shaped fastener, or matted feces? Is the creature male, or female? Is its chest too large to be human, or within normal tolerance? Did Chambers make a costume for a hoax, or not?


Chambers denied it; he wished he could have been that good. Landis started the rumor. There's no "bell-shaped object at all. It's probably a highlight.

See it on DVD. There's nothing shoddy about the PGF.


The problem, LAL, is that it is impossible - especially today - to have 'objective investigations' precisely because we have all formed our opinions already about Bigfoot. Either you believe in them - in which case, your investigations will confirm Bigfoot - or you don't, in which case your investigations will deny Bigfoot.


The evidence can be evaluated objectively. There's no reason it can't.

As is your appalling gullibility and ignorance, or perhaps you're just invested in your scam?


There's no scam. I'm neither gullible nor ignorant and your continuing insults are about to earn you the honor of being the first person I've filtered on this board.

What would you do (serious question, here) if a team of the most respected Bigfoot researchers were to come forward tomorrow and declare the whole thing to be a hoax?


In the nearly forty years I've been interested in this, it's never happened. I did have the pleasure of meeting one, though.

Would you drop Bigfoot research and do something useful, or would you decide that they had been poisoned by the 'Scofftics' and continue your quest for the Hairy Grail?

I'm not involved in Bigfoot research. Even when I lived in an area that had the highest number of sightings in the country I never went out looking for one (kept my eyes open at night, though).

Would you like to drop the attitude and join in the discussion? Or would you prefer to continue the rude tirades and be ignored?
 
LAL said:
I'm presenting what evidence there is and I don't think it's shoddy. If I can't convince, I can at least educate.

I hope yer not including the 'hair analysis' evidence. That ship sunk a long time ago. :D

I did have the pleasure of meeting one, though.

You too? I met with John Green back in 82 when I went on a military course in Victoria, BC. It was a one-on-one meeting, lasted a couple hours, and I ended up with an autographed Apes Among Us. (He also gave me copies of his earlier stuff). Thing is, I don't think we're really any closer to proving bigfoot exists now than we were back then. I see lots of the same tired old arguments being tossed out as 'evidence', but we're still left with mostly anecdotal accounts, indistinguishable hairs, scat that ain't worth crap, and the occasional footprint. The deeper I look into it, the less I'm convinced.

I'm not involved in Bigfoot research.

I'm not a 'field researcher', but I have been interested in bigfoot sightings for about 30 years now.

RayG
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom