Correa Neto said:
Ever considered the possibilty of all these “evidences†being a product of hoaxes AND misinterpretations?
There are misinterpretations (snags are common), but when you have multiple witnesses, physical evidence and the thing moves, it's a pretty good guess it's not a snag.
So now I'm supposed to believe witnesses are misidentifying hoaxers?
Nope. You have to (1) prove that big foot exists; (2) prove that Gigantopithecus was biped and (3) prove that the two animals were related. A bit of work remains to be done, don´t you think?
Since fossils are so common and easy to find, according to you, there should be Gigantopithecus femurs and pelvic bones all over Asia.
Note that they left their remains, so we managed to have a good idea on their constitution and geographic span. Note also that their geographic span is comparable to that of bigfoot and relatives. And even if the millions of individuals figures is correct (could not find refferences), what was bigfoot population before humans begun to mess with the environment? Quite possibly above the current 14000 individuals estimates within USA. So, nothing you wrote serves as an explanation for absence of bigfoot remains (fossil or not).
Krantz, on the A&E show (which I just received) says 2000 and makes it clear he's guessing (I recall 15,000 from the book, but I could be wrong). Let's go back to 2000-6000.
There's no evidence their population has shrunk. It could have grown. A small population could have spread over the Bering Strait, and started speading out of the PNW in more recent times. The PNW has the largest population and more Indian legends that seem to be unmistakably about them than Eastern tribes do.
Sure, few areas on Earth will be left outside as places where remains (fossil or not) should have been found.
I'm not sure I follow that.
Now, after what I wrote about the mapinguari, do you still consider the legend as a reliable indication of the presence of a giant sloth or a giant primate in the Amazon forest? And, don´t you think similar distortions could have happened to the other legends (amas, yeti, sasquatch, etc.) cited as "evidence" for the existence of these animals?
Heuvelmans, Sanderson and Coleman have written of the mapinguary as a form of primate. David Oren thinks the natives are seeing a medium-sized Giant Sloth. (See Cryptozology A to Z by Loren Coleman and Jerome Clark, pg. 151.) I don't know what evidence there is for them.
There seems to be more evidence for Sasquatches just from the State of Washington than there is for any of the other cryptic hominids worldwide, maybe all put together.............Just my impression.
Sturgeons and otters are the most likely candidates to be misinterpreted nessie sightings (same is valid for ogopogo). Check a picture of a sturgeon´s lateral fin and you´ll see a pretty good candidate fot the “flipper photoâ€.
Sounds reasonable. Thanks.
Now, plenty of people are currently working and worked at the areas where bigfeet are supposed to live. In a way, you can say it was (and is being) scanned.
And plenty of these people have seen them. Don't forget residents. They see them too, sometimes.
Ifs, maybes and mays. Do you know that many places that were used for the habitat expansion are still above sea level? And that actually they are well above it? When icecaps retreat, isostasy happens. Since the weight of the glaciers is no longer present, the ground slowly is uplifted. This is called isostasy. Not to mention that the migration routes did not followed the shoreline all along. They followed gaps in the glaciers, many of these gaps were well within the continent.
Actually there´s no evidence that they live anywhere. And forest animals are fossilized also. I´ve already explained that.
Did I miss the post where you showed me fossilized forest-dwelling animals of the Pacific Northwest?
I say the odds are, given what we know, that its does not exists. It may exist, but it is quite unlikely.
In your opinion. I don't think it's shared by many who have actually seen them.
That was not a question. That was a statement. Rapid burial is one way of enhancing fossilization chances. A quiet, oxigen-deprived lake with slow silt or mud deposition are very nice environments for fossilization. I´ll write again: Taking in to account the whole area these creatures are supposed to live nowdays (or have lived in the past)there´s a large number of possible fossilization sites, and by different processes.
Then there should be many fossils of the common forest-dwellers of the PNW, shouldn't there? Where are they?
It´s already being discussed by other posters here. And yes, it seems the hoaxers can fool a lot of people, actually it seems that a lot of people get confused even without the hoaxer´s help.... Why the hoaxers made his stunt just in 1969? You should ask to the hoaxers, not to me.
I would if there were any, other than Ray Pickens, who didn't even claim he'd made tracks near Bossburg, let alone Carson. As usual, the carved feet didn't match anything. The hoaxes have been few and far between and quickly exposed. They're the work of amateurs with no knowlege of anatomy, biomechanics, primate locomotion..............
Of course not. Anyone can see that. What I am saying is that animals die in floods, including those that live in forests, what increases the chances of having their remains preserved.
Where are the fossil Chickarees? Flickers? Cougars? Bear?
And once again you use PNW as a comparsion.
Why not? That's where the largest number of sightings are. It's also the area I'm most familiar with.
You should understand that such argument is completely useless, unless the creature not only is endemic to this area but also evolved there, maybe from a squirrel...
That's a joke, right?
No one's saying they evolved there or anywhere in North America.
Its another OT digression, but I´ll take that by "siltation" you are reffering to deposition of silt, the granulometric fraction between fine sand and clay. If this is so, can ou really say there´s little silt deposition across the whole area composed by the PNW? I say that if there are any lakes nearby glaciers, or are fed by creeks or rivers that are born in glaciers, your claim is flawed.
Yep. There are nine permanent glaciers on Mt. Hood and eleven on Rainier, as I recall. You don't see dredges on the Columbia. I was near the French Broad today, which is brown and near flood. The Columbia is clear by comparison (it reportedly was before Eastern Washington was irrigated). There is little siltation in the Cascades. Shores tend to be rocky.
What part of "volcanic" didn't you understand?
In Africa, Europe and Asia.
I was referring to the Bering Strait and Alaska, not human remains anywhere else. If fossilization is such a sure thing there should be fossils representing all the human waves of migration, which may have begun 40,000 years ago.
There´s no reliable evidence of humans in the Americas 40Ky ago. Where are the evidences for bigfoot for ANY time period ANYWHERE?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/4650307.stm
Also, there's evidence of worked bone in Alaska that dates to 40,000 years ago.
Footprints and film of a Sasquatch from last April don't work for you do they?
If jaguars and bigfoot are related? Well, since bigfoot is immaginary, it can be even related to terrapins...
I find that statement sort of silly.
You wrote on the previous post about fossils of jaguars and grizzlies. And stated that these animals did not lived in forests, thus they would not be found associated with bigfoot. As you can see, they do live in forests. And the supposed geographic span of bigfoot do overlaps with that of the grizzly bear.
There are no Jaguars or Grizzlies in the PNW (except for eastern Washington), nor the Ohio Valley, but there could be some overlap with Grizzlies in the Southern Rockies. Jaguars?
"Jaguars have not been found in Florida since Prehistoric times. When Spaniards first discovered Florida, the northern limit of the jaguars range extended into Texas, New Mexico and Arizona. Further south, the jaguar was found throughout Mexico, Central and South America, all the way to northern Argentina. By the 1980s, the jaguars range was reduced by two-thirds in North and Central America and, within 75% of its present range, the jaguar has been reduced or greatly reduced in numbers. Although the jaguar has been virtually eliminated from the United States, photographs of a jaguar in Arizona were documented during 2002."
http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/UW176
"Home Range: Grizzly bears can be found in the Canadian provinces of British Columbia, Alberta, Yukon, and the Northwest Territories; and the US states of Alaska, Idaho, Wyoming, Washington, and Montana. In general their home range is between 10 and 380 square miles. A grizzly bear’s home range is basically inland – away from major bodies of water. In most cases, a grizzly bear’s home range includes an area of forested land or shrub cover, which is used mostly for escape (Jonkel 1984, p 21)."
http://www.bear.org/Grizzly/Grizzly_Brown_Bear_Facts.html
And again, since PNW is not the only place where bigfeet are suposed to live or to have lived, using it as a standard is useless.
These are my points.
So you choose to ignore the evidence that points to the largest population being in the Northwest (that's a huge area, from Northern California into Canada) and prefer to hypothesize they live with Grizzlies and Jaguars so you can claim there should be fossils?
Your points are not well taken.
Another claim that you can´t really defend. You are saying that its such a blessed area that never has dry periods? Years or months when there´s exceptionally small precipitation? It never happened? The climate never changed there?
There was a drought this year:
http://www.livescience.com/forcesofnature/050321_crazy_weather.html
But there was still a snowpack.
Lewis and Clark experienced a month of rain on the Coast. Their tents rotted. I remember a month that had one clear day. I assured my kids before a camping trip that it never rains in August. It poured.
They may use caves......I don't know, but there's no need for them to die there.......or be preserved there. And who would know?
And I´ll write again: Even if PNW is such an unlikely place that never has dry periods (add this to PNW´s list of oddities), as an argument, it was useless, since the creature is not supposed to be endemic to this area, today or in the past...
They seem to prefer wet forests. I've never said they're confined to the PNW. Evidently there's some evidence for them elsewhere. I've been extremely sceptical of eastern reports. Now I'm not so sure.
Yep. Plaster do solidifies after drying.
Precisely.
Are you kidding? I can´t belive you really have not understood my point. No predator needs to kill a bigfoot for its remains (those from the bigfoot, not the predator)be preserved in a cave. It just has to die near the cave. Water flowing over the ground may carry the bones to the cave. It does not even need to have ever entered the cave when alive!
Are you trying to tell me water would carry a body uphill into a lava tube?
Oh, please, don´t use "there´s no limestone caves in PNW" as an argument...
There are limestone caves in the Pacific Northwest. I know of none in the Cascades, however.
PNW is not the only place these animals were supposed to live or to have lived.
There are reports from other parts of the country but Washington and California have the most by far. Oregon and Ohio are next with about half the documented reports (BFRO figures).
You can not compare the discovery of a mammal in Vietnam with bigfoot´s non-discovery. Take a look on the differences between the sizes of the animals (a small deer X a 2 to 3 m high ape) and the logistics (Vietnam X USA). So, people can discover a small deer in a remote jungle in Vietnam but not a 3m-high ape in USA...
Neither the discovery of a new parrot species in the Amazon jungle with bigfoot´s non-discovery, for the same reasons. So, people can discover a small parrot within the Amazon jungle in Brazil but not a 3m-high ape in USA...
Neither the (re)discovery of a woodpecker species in USA with bigfoot´s non-discovery serves as an argument. Heck, birds are even smaller and usually don´t leave tracks, since they spend most of their time flying. So, people can rediscover a woodpecker but not a 3m-high ape...
What does size have to do with it? An elusive animal is an elusive animal.
The deer's skull, was found, not the deer.
The video of the Ivory Bill is three seconds long. The PGF is 24' of film.
You don't see a double standard or anything there, do you?
Of course all the tracks are not mistaken identities. What about the hoaxes?
They're amateurish. The most sophisticated was the Snow Walker hoax, but even that was exposed.
Mammoths in South America? South America´s early human pouplation was adapted to small game. Your point was?
I was referring to the encampments in Alaska where the people were hunting Mammoths. I said nothing about South America with or without Mammoths. Other than dinosaurs, the only fossils in Alaska seem to be from animals that lived in the grasslands.
Already discussed. Forest animals do get preserved. It just depends on where in the forest the animal dies.
Then why are there no fossils of Chimpanzees and Gorillas? Or two million years worth of seed apes?
Check Paleoarctic tradition. And would you allow me to remind you that bigfeet´s supposed habitats were not restricted to the Bering land bridge and PNW?
I've never said they were.
I doubt. Every single biologist or paleontologist would love to have such a finding in his/hers hands.
Creationists would say the Devil put them there to deceive us.
>snipped for brevity and because I'm beginning to get irritated - there really are gaps in the fossil record, you know<
You know, there´s realiable and unreliable information. If you read - and understood- what I wrote you´ll see it´s just plain wrong. Compare the age of the Appalachian Orogeny 350 to 300 Ma (million years) 600 My and 2.1 Gy orogenesis. And these are not even the oldest ones, they just happen to be among the better known.
So, the National Park Service is unreliable. Noted.
My critic is to the dataused. This critic applies to every single text I´ve read defending the existence of bigfoot. The data used for all speculation is unreliable.
The data is composed by:
(i) Reports of sightings. There´s very little controll on this, specially the oldest cases. Memories change with times, sometimes "filling up" the voids, in some cases people can´t even differentiate between dreams and reality after a long time. Not to mention pure lies and hoaxes.
Many, if not most, sightings have been investigated soon after the incident. Many are backed up by physical evidence and some with film.
(ii) Interpretation of myths. I´ve already been through this. Its not reliable.
Ask the Indians.
(iii) Pictures and footage. They have poor quality, and one can not dismiss them as misinterpreatations, pareidolia and hoaxes.
Not? Heh, heh. That's what
I say.
(iv) Alleged tracks. This is being discussed by the other posters. Unreliable, since a combination of misinterpretation and hoaxes can do the trick.
Nonsense. Have you seen any of the casts? Studied the photos? Read about the circumstances under which the tracks were found? Meldrum's collection is open for inspection at Idaho State.
(v) Hair samples. Again already being discussed by other posters. No reliable evidence provided at best. And with the shadow of hoaxes floating around.
DNA testing has been inconclusive. I think it's a safe assumption Dynel won't yield DNA. Inconclusive or not, it is real hair.
So, with this foundation, the whole building is very frail.
edited to fix some really messed up cut-and-paste
You know, it just struck me that a lot of the above applies to George Bush.