LAL said:
There are misinterpretations (snags are common), but when you have multiple witnesses, physical evidence and the thing moves, it's a pretty good guess it's not a snag.
So now I'm supposed to believe witnesses are misidentifying hoaxers?
You know, you should not really
believein anything, specially if you are trying to use scientidic methodology. Here´s a trap where most -if not all- "investigators" fall. One must
conclude, after evaluating the evidence. Note that you admitted that most sightings happen at night and last less than 20s. Very nice conditions for the proposed explanation.
You should, however, consider the following possibilities:
(a)Pareidolia and similar phenomena ("daydreaming", etc.)- Witnesses confused either ordinary animals - or no animal at all jut shadows and lightining playing games with the mind;
(b)Witnesses were fooled by hoaxer(s)
(c)The sighting itself is a lie, a hoax.
LAL said:
Since fossils are so common and easy to find, according to you, there should be Gigantopithecus femurs and pelvic bones all over Asia.
So, can you tell me why there are no remains -
fossil or not- of a creature that is supposed to live across a large part of Asia and North America? Uh... Eh... Because its not real?
However, my point was that before using Gigantopithecus as an evidence for bigfoot, first you have to:
(a)Prove big foot exists;
(b)Prove that the species are related.
So, how´s the work going?
LAL said:
Krantz, on the A&E show (which I just received) says 2000 and makes it clear he's guessing (I recall 15,000 from the book, but I could be wrong). Let's go back to 2000-6000.
There's no evidence their population has shrunk. It could have grown. A small population could have spread over the Bering Strait, and started speading out of the PNW in more recent times. The PNW has the largest population and more Indian legends that seem to be unmistakably about them than Eastern tribes do.
So be it, 4000, the average. He based on what to achieve this figure?
Anyway, lets suppose bigfeet are real, and dwell in forests. So, Europeans colonize North America, forests have their area decreased, thus bigfeet´s habitat area also decresed, right? Not to mention the introduction of chemicals such as pesticides in the environment. And you say its possible the number of specimens actually may have increased? Weird...
Other than that, the usual
may and
could excuses for the lack of evidences.
Correa Neto said:
Sure, few areas on Earth will be left outside as places where remains (fossil or not) should have been found.[/B]
LAL said:
I'm not sure I follow that.
Just if you don´t want to. If large primate live (or lived in historical times) in Europe and tropical Asia, then its even more unlikely that such animals would still be unknown.
LAL said:
Heuvelmans, Sanderson and Coleman have written of the mapinguary as a form of primate. David Oren thinks the natives are seeing a medium-sized Giant Sloth. (See Cryptozology A to Z by Loren Coleman and Jerome Clark, pg. 151.) I don't know what evidence there is for them.
There seems to be more evidence for Sasquatches just from the State of Washington than there is for any of the other cryptic hominids worldwide, maybe all put together.............Just my impression.
I will write again, since it seems you ignored it when I wrote before, the mapinguar
i legend is about a creature whose mouth is so big that is located at it´s belly, has just one eye, whose skin is like that of an alligator and whose back has a turtle-like shell. Got the picture? Its the way the people an the Amazon forest desribe it, taken personally and directly from them. If you don´t want to take my word, try checking:
http://www.amazonia.com.br/folclore/lenda_mapinguari.asp
Its in Portuguese, but has an "artistic concept"...
Now, if Heuvelmans, Sanderson and Coleman think its a primate, and David Oren thinks of it as a "medium-sized Giant Sloth", I say they either reinterpretated and distorted the original myth in a way to suit their needs or have very poor anatomy and biology knoweledge. In both cases, its lousy data handling, at best.
So, what about considering the possibility that sasquatch is a myth from Native North-Americans
LAL said:
And plenty of these people have seen them. Don't forget residents. They see them too, sometimes.
Any biologist saw them? Anyone working there managed to get nice pictures?
LAL said:
Did I miss the post where you showed me fossilized forest-dwelling animals of the Pacific Northwest?
Yes, and refused to understand what I wrote about using Pacific Northwest as standard. Does the remains -fossil or not- have to come from PNW? I guess not. Your opinions are heavilly biased towads´s PNW´s "special conditions". What cause the whole argument to be flawed.
LAL said:
In your opinion. I don't think it's shared by many who have actually seen them.
Same words said by those who belive in UFOs...
LAL said:
Then there should be many fossils of the common forest-dwellers of the PNW, shouldn't there? Where are they?
...snip...
Where are the fossil Chickarees? Flickers? Cougars? Bear?
You are kidding? You wrote this before thinking, haven´t you? Are you now claiming that there are no fossils of bears? And if you are just referring to PNW, well, again, its pretty useless. You know, bigfeet are not supposed to live just there, remains should heve been found somewhere else, for a species with such a large territory...
LAL said:
Why not? That's where the largest number of sightings are. It's also the area I'm most familiar with.
Correa Neto said:
You should understand that such argument is completely useless, unless the creature not only is endemic to this area but also evolved there, maybe from a squirrel...
LAL said:
That's a joke, right?
No one's saying they evolved there or anywhere in North America.
No, its not a joke. See, if they evolved outside North America, then chances are remains of related species could have been found...
Not to mention that, taking in to account the evidence that is avaliable today, if the creature exist, it may have evolved after a squirrel...
It really does not atter if its the area you are most familiar with. Its not the only place where these creatures are supposed to live!! Therefore, it will only result in biased conclusions. As I have wrote before.
LAL said:
Yep. There are nine permanent glaciers on Mt. Hood and eleven on Rainier, as I recall. You don't see dredges on the Columbia. I was near the French Broad today, which is brown and near flood. The Columbia is clear by comparison (it reportedly was before Eastern Washington was irrigated). There is little siltation in the Cascades. Shores tend to be rocky.
What part of "volcanic" didn't you understand?
If the area has glaciers, and if there are lakes (and indeed there are plenty of them at the Cascades), water coming from glacier melting does brings silt. And, since the area is volcanic, and since the volcanoes are of explosive nature, there are plenty of tuff deposits. Tuffs are composed by clay and silt- sized grains. One of the major products of its erosion is... Guess what? SILT. Even at volcanic areas, sedimentation happens. Sediments are created by weathering and erosion of volcanic rocks. Transported say, by rivers, and deposited at lakes, riverbeds, floodplains, etc.
Oh, on last thing, what do you think that gave that gray color and molasse-consistency to the flood waters that runned through the river valleys after mount Sait Helen´s eruption? Yep, sediment, created by the rosion of volcanic rocks, tuff included, by the waters generated by melted glaciers. Gainsize? Variable, but clay and silt where dominant. And the lahar (that´s the phenomena name) generatedwhat type of deposit? A sedimentary one.
So, see that this claim of yours is also unfunded?
LAL said:
I was referring to the Bering Strait and Alaska, not human remains anywhere else. If fossilization is such a sure thing there should be fossils representing all the human waves of migration, which may have begun 40,000 years ago.
...snip...
Also, there's evidence of worked bone in Alaska that dates to 40,000 years ago.
Footprints and film of a Sasquatch from last April don't work for you do they?
So, you accept that your claim that there were no humans remains in the area is flawed?
And no, footprints and film of a Sasquatch from last April . Sighting reports, footage of blurry fuzzy things and tracks (both subject to hoaxes and misinterpretations) don´t work for me. Actually you should be asking yourselve why so few specialists consider this sort of evidence unreliable. Have you ever considered that they may be right?
LAL said:
There are no Jaguars or Grizzlies in the PNW (except for eastern Washington), nor the Ohio Valley, but there could be some overlap with Grizzlies in the Southern Rockies. Jaguars?
...snip...
So you choose to ignore the evidence that points to the largest population being in the Northwest (that's a huge area, from Northern California into Canada) and prefer to hypothesize they live with Grizzlies and Jaguars so you can claim there should be fossils?
Your points are not well taken.
And you choose to ignore that its not the only area where these creatures are supposed to live. Actually its a
small part of it. Thus the habitat´s areas overlaped in historic and prehistoric times. And that there are plenty of sites where remain -fossil and recent- must have been found.
LAL said:
There was a drought this year:
...snip...
They may use caves......I don't know, but there's no need for them to die there.......or be preserved there. And who would know?
They seem to prefer wet forests. I've never said they're confined to the PNW. Evidently there's some evidence for them elsewhere. I've been extremely sceptical of eastern reports. Now I'm not so sure.
So you admit your claim that there are no dry seasons is flawed. And that the way the remains of these and other animals could be preserved within caves is reasonable. Even if they never use caves as shelter.
LAL said:
Are you trying to tell me water would carry a body uphill into a lava tube?
That another claim you can´t defend. Do you really thing the only way inside a lava tupe is by its end? Have you never noticed that a certain places there are parts of their ceilings that have collapsed, creating entrances, and that water may enter through it, flowing downhill? So, you´ll now write that Ape Cave has no such openings? Then I´ll write that Hawaii´s lava tubes have such openings. And material do get washed inside these caves by water. And that similar but smaller caves in Galapagos and other oceanic islands do have fossil content. What will you write next? That PNW´s lava tubes don´t have such feature? And I´ll then write that your opinion is based just in what you know about PNW, thus is biased and therefore of little use.
Not to mention that, as I wrote before, why should anyone bother with the lava tubes, if there are plenty of other places (caves, sedimentary deposits, roads, etc.) within bigfeet´s habitat where remains -fossil and recent- could have been found, if it existed?
LAL said:
There are limestone caves in the Pacific Northwest. I know of none in the Cascades, however.
Who cares? I´ll write again, since you seem to be having problems understanding the argument. These animals are not restricted to the Pacific Northwest of USA. Its not the only place these animals are supposed to exist. Its remains -past and recent- shoud have been found somewhere else.
LAL said:
There are reports from other parts of the country but Washington and California have the most by far. Oregon and Ohio are next with about half the documented reports (BFRO figures).
LAL said:
What does size have to do with it? An elusive animal is an elusive animal.
It must be hard to be a 3m-high elusive ape...
Try to imagine a small deer hiding. Now try to imagine a bigfoot hiding. See now what size has to do with being elusive?
LAL said:
The deer's skull, was found, not the deer.
Oh my... So, if i ever find a bigfoot´s skull I will not have find bigfoot...
LAL said:
The video of the Ivory Bill is three seconds long. The PGF is 24' of film.
You don't see a double standard or anything there, do you?
Of course I see. From the people that use it as an argument favorable to the existence of a large ape in North America. A short resume of the rediscovery of the ivory-billed woodpecker:
Gallagher read a post from a canooer who reported to have seen a strange woodpecker. Less than two weeks later, they went to the place and guess what? They found it. And there´s no shadow of hoaxes over the footage, neither they were the only ones who saw them. And any researcher who wants to study or see them, just has to go to the site.
Here are the differences between the rediscover of this species and the non-discovery of bigfeet.
Oh, and one question:
There were speciments of the ivory-billed woodpecker in museums, killed before it was considered extinct, weren´t they? After all, to describe a species, one must have anumber of specimens (type specimen, holotype, paratype, etc.).
Its very different situation.
LAL said:
Creationists would say the Devil put them there to deceive us.
>snipped for brevity and because I'm beginning to get irritated - there really are gaps in the fossil record, you know<
Getting irritated will not change the facts that:
(a)Your argument was completely pointless, you are lowering yourself to the creationist´s level by using the "fossil gap" argument;
(b)no solid evidence supports bigfoot´s existence.
Getting irritated is futile.
Maybe the devil is hiding bigfoot...
LAL said:
So, the National Park Service is unreliable. Noted.
Yes, the information they provided -if it was really provided by them- is unreliable. Unless PNS can prove that the Appalachian orogeny is very older than 350ma (after all, some concurrents are 2.7 Gy -G stands for billion- and are not the oldest ones). Are you willing to keep this absurd claim?
LAL said:
DNA testing has been inconclusive. I think it's a safe assumption Dynel won't yield DNA. Inconclusive or not, it is real hair.
And why should anyone think its from a bigfoot? Inconclusive evidence is very far from being solid evidence.
LAL said:
You know, it just struck me that a lot of the above applies to George Bush.
Sure, GWB always appear in footage as a blurry fuzzy object...