Correa Neto said:
The films, the photograms, all that´s been shown at TV and internet. There´s no need for an "army of" hoaxers. A few of them, acting indenpendently could do a lot of things.
LAL said:
Such as fake footprints in 1958, and three times in two countries in April, 2005? With a whole lotta hoaxing in between? In remote areas where all this handiwork wasn't likely to be found?
Ever considered the possibilty of all these “evidences†being a product of hoaxes AND misinterpretations?
Correa Neto said:
IF its a relative to bigfoot. And that´s all that it is. And if its a relative to orang-utang, then it does hurt.
LAL said:
Depends on whether it was bipedal or not, doesn't it?
Nope. You have to (1) prove that big foot exists; (2) prove that Gigantopithecus was biped and (3) prove that the two animals were related. A bit of work remains to be done, don´t you think?
LAL said:
Homo erectus lived from 1.8 million years to 300,000 ago and was very widespread, yet remains of only about 40 individuals from two or three locations (according to the Smithsonian's rather out-of-date website) have been found. The population must have numbered in the millions, yet only one boy managed to die in such a way that his nearly complete skeleton could be found at Lake Turkana.
Note that they left their remains, so we managed to have a good idea on their constitution and geographic span. Note also that their geographic span is comparable to that of bigfoot and relatives. And even if the millions of individuals figures is correct (could not find refferences), what was bigfoot population before humans begun to mess with the environment? Quite possibly above the current 14000 individuals estimates
within USA. So, nothing you wrote serves as an explanation for absence of bigfoot remains (fossil or not).
Correa Neto said:
Note that, on purpose, I am not considering its "tropical equivalents" in Southern Asia, the hairy wildmen (woodwoose) from mediaeval Great Britain (and its European equivalents) and the (sadly distorted) mapinguari legend from Brazil.
LAL said:
Sure, few areas on Earth will be left outside as places where remains (fossil or not) should have been found.
Now, after what I wrote about the mapinguari, do you still consider the legend as a reliable indication of the presence of a giant sloth or a giant primate in the Amazon forest? And, don´t you think similar distortions could have happened to the other legends (amas, yeti, sasquatch, etc.) cited as "evidence" for the existence of these animals?
Correa Neto said:
That´s really hard, since the type of evidence currently avaliable for Nessie and bigfoot are quite similar. That´s why I asked you where and how you draw the line between a plausibe crypto (bigfoot) and an unlikely one (Nessie)? What are the criteria for unlumping them together?
LAL said:
Loch Ness was scanned, wasn't it? No Nessie. Last I heard it was thought a school of Dolphins could account for sightings in the loch. I don't know how the photo of the flipper is explained............
Sturgeons and otters are the most likely candidates to be misinterpreted nessie sightings (same is valid for ogopogo). Check a picture of a sturgeon´s lateral fin and you´ll see a pretty good candidate fot the “flipper photoâ€.
Now, plenty of people are currently working and worked at the areas where bigfeet are supposed to live. In a way, you can say it was (and is being) scanned.
Correa Neto said:
OK, then you understand the animals must have not only crossed but lived in open-field environments.
LAL said:
No, I don't. If they followed the coast, in search of fish, perhaps, and the forests were more northerly and the Strait not all grassland and tundra and the climate milder they need not have been in the open much at all.
Ifs,
maybes and
mays. Do you know that many places that were used for the habitat expansion are still above sea level? And that actually they are well above it? When icecaps retreat, isostasy happens. Since the weight of the glaciers is no longer present, the ground slowly is uplifted. This is called isostasy. Not to mention that the migration routes did not followed the shoreline all along. They followed gaps in the glaciers, many of these gaps were well within the continent.
Correa Neto said:
Thus it is not far-fetched to suppose their fossils could be found with fossils from animals that lived all their lives in open-field environments. Not to mention the transitional environments.
LAL said:
Except that there's no evidence they live anywhere but in forests.
Actually there´s no evidence that they live anywhere. And forest animals are fossilized also. I´ve already explained that.
Correa Neto said:
Again if Bryne is correct. Note that a basic requisite for it is that the animal must exist. What is far from being proved.
LAL said:
It's far from being proved that it doesn't.
I say the odds are, given what we know, that its does not exists. It
may exist, but it is quite unlikely.
Correa Neto said:
What, once again, would favor preservation of remains.
LAL said:
Rapid burial, for one thing.
That was not a question. That was a statement. Rapid burial is one way of enhancing fossilization chances. A quiet, oxigen-deprived lake with slow silt or mud deposition are very nice environments for fossilization. I´ll write again: Taking in to account the whole area these creatures are supposed to live nowdays (or have lived in the past)there´s a large number of possible fossilization sites, and by different processes.
LAL said:
It's hard to confuse a giant hominid track with anything else. I have copies of the Bossburg casts (they're not as large as Closner's cast, but they're still impressive). The deformity is consistent with metatarsus adductus. It's difficult to imagine a hoaxer, in 1969, being able to lay down 1089 tracks overnight with such a deformity. Tracks like that were seen 30 years earlier, incidently.
Is this one or two of the same few hoaxers? Why did they only do this in '69? Why not repeat the stunt rather than waste a perfectly good pair of fake feet that were good enough to fool a professor of anatomy. Why not just use the feet from Bluff Creek........one set, anyway?
It´s already being discussed by other posters here. And yes, it seems the hoaxers can fool a lot of people, actually it seems that a lot of people get confused even without the hoaxer´s help.... Why the hoaxers made his stunt just in 1969? You should ask to the hoaxers, not to me.
LAL said:
You're not saying everything that drowns in a flood becomes a fossil are you? That would only be a first step. Siltation is pretty light in areas like the PNW.
Of course not. Anyone can see that. What I am saying is that animals die in floods, including those that live in forests, what increases the chances of having their remains preserved.
And once again you use PNW as a comparsion. You should understand that such argument is completely useless, unless the creature not only is endemic to this area but also evolved there, maybe from a squirrel...
Its another OT digression, but I´ll take that by "siltation" you are reffering to deposition of silt, the granulometric fraction between fine sand and clay. If this is so, can ou really say there´s little silt deposition across the whole area composed by the PNW? I say that if there are any lakes nearby glaciers, or are fed by creeks or rivers that are born in glaciers, your claim is flawed.
LAL said:
There may be evidence of humans 40,000 years ago. Where are all the human remains from that period?
In Africa, Europe and Asia. There´s no reliable evidence of humans in the Americas 40Ky ago. Where are the evidences for bigfoot for ANY time period ANYWHERE?
LAL said:
Jaguars live in both forest and savannahs. Their diet is unlike that of Sasquatches and they're not related, are they?
No Grizzlies in the forests of the PNW. They may be in the North Cascades, I've been told, but that's pretty far inland and much drier.
It appears Sasquatches don't overlap with Grizzlies and Jaguars. Your point?
If jaguars and bigfoot are related? Well, since bigfoot is immaginary, it can be even related to terrapins...
You wrote on the previous post about fossils of jaguars and grizzlies. And stated that these animals did not lived in forests, thus they would not be found associated with bigfoot. As you can see, they do live in forests. And the supposed geographic span of bigfoot do overlaps with that of the grizzly bear.
And again, since PNW is not the only place where bigfeet are suposed to live or to have lived, using it as a standard is useless.
These are my points.
Correa Neto said:
Why do you think the fossil record of caves is so nice? All the animals whose fossils were found in caves spent much time hanging out there?
What happens is that caves are natural water and humidity sources. Animals are attracted to them during dry periods.
LAL said:
Western Washington doesn't have dry periods.
Another claim that you can´t really defend. You are saying that its such a blessed area that never has dry periods? Years or months when there´s exceptionally small precipitation? It never happened? The climate never changed there?
And I´ll write again: Even if PNW is such an unlikely place that never has dry periods (add this to PNW´s list of oddities), as an argument, it was useless, since the creature is not supposed to be endemic to this area, today or in the past...
LAL said:
Those casts are pretty solid.
Yep. Plaster do solidifies after drying.
Correa Neto said:
Weakened, victims of a fall, or just lost in the darkness, they commonly die there. Some just fall inside sinkholes hidden by vegetation. Also, some cave entrances act as "natural sinks". During strong rains, water running over the surface carries a lot of loose material to the cave, sediments, dead leaves, twigs, loose bones and carcasses.
If I recall correctly, that´s one of the possible reasons for hominid fossils in caves in Africa. The events chain would have been something like this: leopard kills hominid, carries body to the top of a tree, remains fall to the ground, are washed away by rain to a cave, humans find, hundreds of Ky later, the skull -with leopard´s teeth marks included.
So animal species don´t even need to have as part of its habits to take temporary shelter at a cave to become fossilized inside one.
Why I have insisted on the limestone cave? Not only because they are much more common than lava tubes or quartzite caves, but because the constant precipitation of carbonate inside them helps a lot the fossilization.
LAL said:
To my knowlege, the limestone caves in the PNW are nowhere near the mountains. The area's volcanic. No limestone caves.
The PNW seems to have the largest Sasquatch population, based on reports.
Correa Neto said:
So, see now why it is not far-fetched to suppose bigfoot remains could be found inside a cave? Even if they don´t spend much time there?
Do we agree on that?
LAL said:
Not until you can show me a limestone cave on Mt. St. Helens.
Apes Caves on Mt. St. Helens are lava tubes....not too good for preservation. Bears would tend to exploit caves in the area and bears scavenge. If the nocturnal behavior has to do with avoiding bears, they may avoid places where bears hang out (or hibernate) such as caves.
...snip...
However, I'm having difficulty imagining an African leopard in the PNW dropping a Sasquatch into a sinkhole, which seem to occur in the Southeast, not in the NW.
...snip... I don't see that it's a problem given the habitat and the lack of leopards and limestone caves. Cougars feed on the ground, I believe.
Are you kidding? I can´t belive you really have not understood my point. No predator needs to kill a bigfoot for its remains (those from the bigfoot, not the predator)be preserved in a cave. It just has to die near the cave. Water flowing over the ground may carry the bones to the cave. It does not even need to have ever entered the cave when alive!
Oh, please, don´t use "there´s no limestone caves in PNW" as an argument...
PNW is not the only place these animals were supposed to live or to have lived.
LAL[/i]
[B]What about the new mammals found in Viet Nam? Is there a fossil record for them?[/B][/QUOTE]
You can not compare the discovery of a mammal in Vietnam with bigfoot´s non-discovery. Take a look on the differences between the sizes of the animals (a small deer X a 2 to 3 m high ape) and the logistics (Vietnam X USA). So said:
Sure. But that doesn't mean thousands of track events are all cases of mistaken identity. Or that all the sightings are, or that the films are of bipedal bears.
Of course all the tracks are not mistaken identities. What about the hoaxes?
Correa Neto said:
There are evidence for human migration. Campsites, remains, at several places along the path, from Asia to North America, extending towards South America!
LAL said:
Such as where the mammoths were plentiful?
Mammoths in South America? South America´s early human pouplation was adapted to small game. Your point was?
Correa Neto said:
Ah, so we agree that the species must have spreaded rather than migrated. Progressively expanding its habitat to include Russia, Asias´s eastern coast, Alaska, Canada and USA. What leaves us with a lot of places to find fossil evidence...
LAL said:
Except for the in the forests.
Already discussed. Forest animals do get preserved. It just depends on where in the forest the animal dies.
Correa Neto said:
...snip...
So, we do have evidence on the human habitat expansion. Not only of the younger one, that brought the people that nowdays compose amerindians, but also of a previous wave.
LAL said:
That's interesting.
But no human remains on the Bering Strait?
Check Paleoarctic tradition. And would you allow me to remind you that bigfeet´s supposed habitats were not restricted to the Bering land bridge and PNW?
Correa Neto said:
All of them? Every single individual since the species appeared? At all the places where it lives(ed)?
LAL said:
Why not? It seems to have happened with Gorillas and Chimps and a couple of million years worth of "seed" apes.
Correa Neto said:
But it was found! Any bigfeet molar avaliable?
LAL said:
If it were, the scofftics would say it was planted and belonged to a elk.
I doubt. Every single biologist or paleontologist would love to have such a finding in his/hers hands.
LAL said:
There's a problem of how Yowies, if they exist, got to Australia.
If Sasquatches are closely related to the Russian Kaptar, it seems more likely they took the northern route, especially since they don't seem to have a talent for raft-building.
Any evidence of this? Maybe they came flying, mounting on mothmen´s or big birds´ backs...
LAL said:
And we may have fossil evidence of a species related to Sasquatches as well.
May. See the begining pf this post.
LAL said:
Punc Ec.
Didn't I mention I spent a couple of years debating Creationists........and posting lists of transitional fossils?
Then you know your argument was really worthless.
LAL said:
There's a better chance of a live one being brought in.
Stil, I will not be holding my breath...
LAL said:
That's "Appalachians". They're the oldest on the continent and among the oldest in the world. If they're not the oldest, the NPS is wrong. I've found several sites that say they're among the oldest in the world.
You know, there´s realiable and unreliable information. If you read - and understood- what I wrote you´ll see it´s just plain wrong. Compare the age of the Appalachian Orogeny 350 to 300 Ma (million years) 600 My and 2.1 Gy orogenesis. And these are not even the oldest ones, they just happen to be among the better known.
LAL said:
Then you have read Krantz? What, specifically, did you find wrong with his methodology and/or conclusions? I would not consider listing your sources "bragging about it".
My critic is to the
dataused. This critic applies to every single text I´ve read defending the existence of bigfoot. The data used for all speculation is unreliable.
The data is composed by:
(i) Reports of sightings. There´s very little controll on this, specially the oldest cases. Memories change with times, sometimes "filling up" the voids, in some cases people can´t even differentiate between dreams and reality after a long time. Not to mention pure lies and hoaxes.
(ii) Interpretation of myths. I´ve already been through this. Its not reliable.
(iii) Pictures and footage. They have poor quality, and one can not dismiss them as misinterpreatations, pareidolia and hoaxes.
(iv) Alleged tracks. This is being discussed by the other posters. Unreliable, since a combination of misinterpretation and hoaxes can do the trick.
(v) Hair samples. Again already being discussed by other posters. No reliable evidence provided at best. And with the shadow of hoaxes floating around.
So, with this foundation, the whole building is very frail.
edited to fix some really messed up cut-and-paste