Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Re: Re: Definitive Proof!

Winterfrost said:
Anyone heard any follow-up on this? This took place about a week ago, so I figured we would have heard more by now (supposing there is anything to hear :p).

I saw a few news casts on it the other day. One was an interview with a couple of the guys who saw the critter. They said something like, "We were in the shed there, drinking a few beers...."

I was doing something else while another news cast was on but I believe the Conservation Officer who was examining the hair said something to the effect that he was pretty sure it was bison hair.
 
LTC8K6 said:

from there:
"It was something big, about eight feet tall. It's black, hairy, muscular. It was huge," he said. "He was, like, teasing us, making noises in the bush, coming back and forth."

Sounds exactly the way I would do a hoax. First, make sure the victims have no guns, then put on a suit made from local hides, and 'tease' them 'til I know they must have seen me.

Possibly a copy-cat hoax? after hearing about the other sighting in the neighborhood?
 
RayG said:
How so? Because you disagree with his findings?



No, because he's wrong.


No, my bigfoot websites were online long before the BFF ever existed. So long ago in fact, that though links still exist, the websites do not. Have you heard of the IVBC? It was a bigfoot email list created by Henry Franzoni back in the mid 90's that I belonged to.


No. I was living in the forest in Skamania County in the mid-nineties with only cell-phone service and couldn't get online.

Seems to be worth repeating.


Yes. Maybe you'll notice the part about them never having been cut.

I keep pointing it out but you keep sidestepping the issue: Dr. Fahrenbach could not distinguish a human hair from that of a purported sasquatch.

One more time...
http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/WHF/dnatests.htm
The hair was sent to Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach (Beaverton, Oregon), who determined microscopically that the hair appeared to have come from two individuals of the same species, that it differed in color, length and hair growth cycle between the two sets, had not been not cut, and was indistinguishable from human hair by any criterion.

He [Dr. Fahrenbach] says the same thing a second time on the same website:

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair..."


He notes the lack of a medulla, too. He doesn't reach the conclusion they are human hair.

Those two links did nothing to show Dr. Fahrenbach is an expert in microscopic hair analysis.

I said he was an expert in microscopy. He's no lightweight if he was published in PubMed.

I have twice pointed out that Crook provided an opinion NOT evidence to SI. Big difference.


And they take it at face value while ignoring the opinions of people who have examined the cast?

What's the purpose of submitting that? I've already given more recent quotes from both Dr. Fahrenbach and Fuerst concerning those hairs. They couldn't distinguish them from human.
http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/WHF/dnatests.htm


I thought you said you didn't think he'd examined hairs from Freeman. Weren't those the ones examined at OSU?

And you won't find it in there, because to my knowledge it's not in the book. The original quote I gave for that:
http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/proponent.html


Ah yes, Dennett's "smoked lens".

Krantz did seem somewhat suspicious of hairs from the Blue Mountains when he said:

"Clearly someone was planting samples of Dynel fiber in many places in the Blue Mountains." (Big Footprints page 127)


Couldn't have come from parkas, could it?

Not necessary, but certainly possible. It's also possible someone was trying to dupe Freeman, but not necessarily. It seems rather strange that he kept bringing in fake hair samples.

RayG
I was under the impression the tuft on the branch that turned out to be synthetic was all there was from Freeman.
 
RayG said:
http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/proponent.html
"Freeman then produced at least two more sets of "hair" which he gave to Professor Krantz."



Nothing stupid about it, the 'hair' DID fool experts, initially.

RayG


It would be stupid to submit synthetic hair and risk exposure.

Do you have any sources other than Dennett? He didn't uncover the real perpetrator on the Bloomington track, didn't retract on Dahinden's statement, though he did sort of retract on the shoe statement:

"In that article I quoted Dahinden as comparing the Hitler diaries scare to the Mill Creek tracks. In quoting him I wrote: "It turns out that the ink was not invented until 1954." In fact, it was a discrepancy in the paper, not the ink that proved the diaries fake. This was my error, not Dahinden's. I also reported I had been told that Freeman had once worked for an orthopedic-shoe company. At the 1989 International Society of Cryptozoology (ISC) meeting Freeman told me he had never worked in the shoe industry. Later when I asked him to release a government employment file, which could have substantiated his denial, he declined. In fairness I should add that despite considerable effort, I was never able to verify this employment with any custom shoe firm."

http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/articles/skeptical.htm

There is some confirmation of a non-opposed thumb from sightings.
 
casebro said:
from there:
"It was something big, about eight feet tall. It's black, hairy, muscular. It was huge," he said. "He was, like, teasing us, making noises in the bush, coming back and forth."

Sounds exactly the way I would do a hoax. First, make sure the victims have no guns, then put on a suit made from local hides, and 'tease' them 'til I know they must have seen me.

Possibly a copy-cat hoax? after hearing about the other sighting in the neighborhood?

Yeah, sure.

Let's see some evidence someone put on a suit and appeared to be 8' tall.
 
LAL said:
Yeah, sure.

Let's see some evidence someone put on a suit and appeared to be 8' tall.

chewy_resting.jpg


Yeah, I know. That's not what you meant, but I couldn't resist an opening like that. :D
 
LAL said:
Yeah, sure.

Let's see some evidence someone put on a suit and appeared to be 8' tall.
Shifting burden of proof: We aren't here to prove they are hoaxes. Hoaxing just happens to be one explanation that covers a number of sightings pretty well.

If you want to prove that Bigfoot exists, get some evidence so good, hoaxing looks less likely than the existence of Bigfoot. DNA and specimens come to mind.

And yes, as LTC8K6 said, eyewitnesses are notoriously unreliable.

One example I remember was quoted by Brian Brushwood, if anyone knows him: Had thousands of people at an airshow when an accident happens, leading to a plane crash. Everything's on camera. Just in case the cameras missed something, police decided to get statements from everyone. Out of the thousands of statements, only 8 matched the events as caught on camera, and only one of those eight provided any useful information.

Anyone know more about that example?
 
LAL said:
No, because he's wrong.

In your opinion.

Yes. Maybe you'll notice the part about them never having been cut.

Oh I noticed it, but I also noticed that they couldn't tell the difference between the hair they were examining and human hair.

He notes the lack of a medulla, too. He doesn't reach the conclusion they are human hair.

Nope, he just points out that he can't distinguish them from human hair.

I said he was an expert in microscopy. He's no lightweight if he was published in PubMed.

That doesn't make him an expert at hair analysis though.

And they take it at face value while ignoring the opinions of people who have examined the cast?

You mean like journalist John Green? Why have so few scientists actually examined the cast, and where are the articles published in scientific journals (about the Skookum cast I mean).

I thought you said you didn't think he'd examined hairs from Freeman. Weren't those the ones examined at OSU?

Yes, I stand corrected. I don't believe Krantz specifically mentions Fahrenbach examining them, I'll have to re-read that portion of the book.

Ah yes, Dennett's "smoked lens".

In your opinion.

Couldn't have come from parkas, could it?

Maybe, though I've never heard any explanation other than imitation hair.

I was under the impression the tuft on the branch that turned out to be synthetic was all there was from Freeman.

Have you confirmed that? Though Krantz doesn't mention specifically who brought in all the hair samples from the Blue Mountains, he twice indicates they were from "several places".

RayG
 
Hair samples ?

You know, when I bump my head bad enough to leave a clump of hair worth inspecting, the hair is usually atached to some skin. If I pluck a single hair it often has the follicle attached. I would think that out of all those 'bigfoot' hair samples, just one would have some cellular material big enough to do a MTDNA analysis. The cops did OJ Simpson's from a blood droplet. OJ's was a 1 in 50,000,000 match. (stupid jurors). So, one bigfoot follicle could prove his matrilinear genetics- human , ape, orangutan, chimp?

And to defend my copy-cat hoax hypothisis: Without even putting on my furry suit, I'm between 6 feet and 8 feet tall, depending on which convienience store I'm coming out of at the time....and I just remembered that I have a hair-on horse hide in a packing barrel somewhere....borrow a sewing machine...."No, those aren't seams, those are tendons? ...or scars?.....make it reversible to use as a Reptoid tooo.....Next trip to the Mini-Mart, I'l have to buy Micky's Big Mouth Malt Liqour to get in the spirit? I see the Headlines now " Big Foot spotted leaving Del Mar Convienence Store- Security Camera film at 11:00"....awe , nuts... that won't work, the clerk will check my ID to make sure I'm 21...
 
LAL said:
It would be stupid to submit synthetic hair and risk exposure.

Humans sometimes do stupid things.

Do you have any sources other than Dennett?

In Bigfootprints Krantz indicates hair was submitted from "several places"(page 126) and again from "many places" (page 127) in the Blue Mountains. That certainly indicates more than a single clump of hair, though as I said, Krantz doesn't specifically indicate it was Freeman that brought them in.

RayG
 
LAL said:
Yeah, sure.

Let's see some evidence someone put on a suit and appeared to be 8' tall.

Happens often enough in the movies.

It's really not that hard to fool someone into believing the size difference. Especially with as distant as most sightings have been, and the non-optimal conditions under which they occured.

You've got to do better than this.
 
One would think, that as this creature ( 8' tall, 800 + lbs ) goes tearing through the PNW, virtualy impenetrable by dog and man , it would leave hair ( with follicles ) all over the place .. ???
 
RayG said:
You mean like journalist John Green? Why have so few scientists actually examined the cast, and where are the articles published in scientific journals (about the Skookum cast I mean).



I mean like Drs. Krantz, Swindler, Sarmiento and Meldrum.

I don't know why it's not published. Alton Higgins has mentioned bias, but not necessarily regarding the cast, just on articles by Meldrum and Bindernagle.

And I don't know how many scientists have examined it. There's a standing invitation to them.

>snip<

Have you confirmed that? Though Krantz doesn't mention specifically who brought in all the hair samples from the Blue Mountains, he twice indicates they were from "several places".

RayG

Not really. It was in Meldrum's review of Daegling's book (he didn't mention others) which has been pulled from the website at Meldrum's request, hopefully because he's going to include it in his book.
 
zaayrdragon said:
Happens often enough in the movies.

It's really not that hard to fool someone into believing the size difference. Especially with as distant as most sightings have been, and the non-optimal conditions under which they occured.

You've got to do better than this.

Try reading some of the books or seeing the video you've all been pointed to or perusing some of the over 8000 reported sightings before you decide what conditions they were under or the range.

It's been possible to measure on trees, e.g., and 8' is pretty consistant for a full grown male.
 
Diogenes said:
One would think, that as this creature ( 8' tall, 800 + lbs ) goes tearing through the PNW, virtualy impenetrable by dog and man , it would leave hair ( with follicles ) all over the place .. ???

There's a population, not an individual, and who says they "tear"? There may be hair that's just not been seen. Some has.

I don't remember Chickaree and deer hair all over my place in Washington. The rain tends to wash anything caught on trees into the detrius anyway. Chances of finding it would be slim, which may account for the scarcity.
 

In Bigfootprints Krantz indicates hair was submitted from "several places"(page 126) and again from "many places" (page 127) in the Blue Mountains. That certainly indicates more than a single clump of hair, though as I said, Krantz doesn't specifically indicate it was Freeman that brought them in.

And Fahrenbach mentioned others, but didn't say who.
 
Analysis of Feces and Hair Suspected to Be of Sasquatch Origin

Vaughn M. Bryant, Jr. and Burleigh Trevor-Deutsch

The authors have examined five specimens of preserved feces and three specimens of animal hair suspected to be of Sasquatch or Bigfoot origin. They find that two of the fecal and two of the hair specimens are definitely attributable to known animals, but the remaining samples are not. Recognizing the limited sample studied, they call for further such analyses to ascertain the origin of the unidentified specimens.

>snip<

"Our laboratory has thus far examined a number of suspected Sasquatch hairs. However, we were not the first to search for suspected Sasquatch hair specimens. John Green reported that in 1968 Wayne Twitchell found six hairs on a bush near Riggins, Idaho, near a reported sighting of two Sasquatch l5. The hair specimens were sent for analysis to Ray Pinker, an instructor of police science at California State College in Los Angeles. His study revealed that the hairs did not match specimens from any known animal species and that they had some characteristics common to both humans and non-humans. In his final report, Pinker stated that he could not identify the hairs until he had had an opportunity to examine some authentic Sasquatch hair specimens.

Other people have collected and, in some cases, have sent suspected Sasquatch hair specimens to various laboratories for analysis. As reported by Green and John Napier 16 some of the hair samples have been identified as being from known animals, yet others cannot be attributed to any known animal species.

>snip<

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/bryant.html

Fahrenbach's not the only one who's looked into this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom