Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Thing is, I don't think we're really any closer to proving bigfoot exists now than we were back then. I see lots of the same tired old arguments being tossed out as 'evidence', but we're still left with mostly anecdotal accounts, indistinguishable hairs, scat that ain't worth crap, and the occasional footprint. The deeper I look into it, the less I'm convinced.

Exactly!

And then you read that on more than one occasion, the BFRO claims to have been basically within hours of a live sasquatch, and they abandoned the chase almost immediately.

That practically makes my blood boil.
 
It's difficult to imagine a hoaxer, in 1969, being able to lay down 1089 tracks overnight with such a deformity. Tracks like that were seen 30 years earlier, incidently.

Clubfoot bigfoot tracks were seen 30 years apart?

Are you sure you don't have your tracks mixed up?

I think you do, but in case I am wrong, how common are clubfoots among sasquatch?

Are the odds better for a different bigfoot with a clubfoot, or the same bigfoot 30 years later?
 
RayG said:
I hope yer not including the 'hair analysis' evidence. That ship sunk a long time ago. :D


No, I'm reading Roger Knights' dissection of your argument. Is it legal to post that, or is that some kind of violation of board etiquette and standards?

He's lurked on this board, you know.

Hm. Maybe just a bit (I hope he doesn't mind):

"QUOTE (RayG @ May 14 2004, 05:10 AM)
There are some claims that microscopic hair analysis is nothing more than junk science.

QUOTE (http://www.truthinjustice.org/where-justice.htm)
The weakness of hair analysis is well established. For example, it is a known fact that hairs from the same head often do not match. A test of 240 crime labs found error rates in hair analysis of 50 percent, 54 percent, 68 percent and 56 percent.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Thanks for the links--I've printed them out.

But don't be misled by the identity of the name ("microscopic hair analysis") into thinking that crime-labs and Fahrenbach are doing the same thing. Fahrenbach is doing something quite different and much more reliable: differentiating and matching species, not individuals within a species, on the basis of gross (mostly) anatomical differences and similarities. EDIT: He's saying that no known N. Am. animals have hair from any part of their bodies that matches the combination of gross characteristics in Sas hair samples, and that these samples are pretty similar, especially in certain subtle ways, like the red tint."

>snip<

EDIT: So the assertion microscopic hair analysis is unreliable should be qualified by the term, intra-species.

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=5119&st=20

Oh, and thanks for pointing me to the thread.

You too? I met with John Green back in 82 when I went on a military course in Victoria, BC. It was a one-on-one meeting, lasted a couple hours, and I ended up with an autographed Apes Among Us. (He also gave me copies of his earlier stuff). Thing is, I don't think we're really any closer to proving bigfoot exists now than we were back then. I see lots of the same tired old arguments being tossed out as 'evidence', but we're still left with mostly anecdotal accounts, indistinguishable hairs, scat that ain't worth crap, and the occasional footprint. The deeper I look into it, the less I'm convinced.



Ah, but at least there's more of it than there was in '82. The scofftics seem to have even fewer new arguments. ;)

I met Peter Byrne. Green "had enough of him forty years ago", but I found him fascinating.

I wish I could meet Green. I envy you.

I could have probably found a way to meet Krantz, but I feel I know him from books and films. He's in my living room now along with Bryne and Leonard Nimoy.

I'm not a 'field researcher', but I have been interested in bigfoot sightings for about 30 years now.

RayG

Well, at least I have seniority on you. :)

Do we really want the mystery to end?

I wonder if, aside from the chances of tracking the animal that made the Skookum imprint being less than those of a snowball in hell, the team didn't really want to bring one in.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Clubfoot bigfoot tracks were seen 30 years apart?

Are you sure you don't have your tracks mixed up?

I think you do, but in case I am wrong, how common are clubfoots among sasquatch?

Are the odds better for a different bigfoot with a clubfoot, or the same bigfoot 30 years later?

It was evidently the same individual. It's the only case of a crippled foot known.

It's not clubfoot. An earlier diagnosis was skewfoot, but Meldrum, at Krantz' request, searched the literature and found the condition was consistant with metatarsus adductus as I've mentioned before.

I found it amusing A&E did a segment with Krantz on the Mill Creek tracks, but the shot was of the Bossburg casts. Sloppy. They must have thought the viewers wouldn't know the difference.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Exactly!

And then you read that on more than one occasion, the BFRO claims to have been basically within hours of a live sasquatch, and they abandoned the chase almost immediately.

That practically makes my blood boil.

Did you miss the reasons they were trying to lure in Skookum Meadows instead of track? Noll once spent three months in the field. Bryne tried tracking on and off for five years, just when he was funded for the research project in Oregon.

Pursuit would have been impossible.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Links to Jim Placyk's tests and the story of an alleged unknown large primate in TN in the fall of 2003.

http://www.wate.com/Global/story.asp?s= 1498430

http://www.bigfootlady.net/campbell001.html

Yup. Mary Green.

But thanks for the links.

Here's this:

"To the Curators:

The following situation has transpired. Some years ago, when Janice Coy (Carter) and Mary Green contacted me cautiously about the activities at the Coy farm, I suggested several modes of action to provide substantiation for the claims being made, one of them being collecting hair directly off a sasquatch, if close approaches in the context of feeding were possible. This has now occurred, in that Jan, when approached by the primary habituated sasquatch, named Fox, for a food item, reached out briefly, lightly grabbed hair on his forearm and pulled some out.

I have examined a good sampling of these hairs and they totally agree with my previous "gold standard", illustrated in the BFRO website under the FAQ "What is a bigfoot/sasquatch", albeit substantially more pigmented. The hairs are overall quite fine, measuring between 35 and 65 µm in diameter and at most an inch long. They have largely the same diameter over their entire length, as one would expect from primate hair, and the tips have either a split or worn, rounded end. Most of the hairs have no medulla at all, a few have a fragmentary minimal one. The hair has the seemingly universal reddish tint (phaeomelanin) found in all prior sasquatch hair collections, in addition to having rather coarsely streaked and very dense melanin (eumelanin) granules throughout. The sasquatch in question was described as having had a blue-black hair color when he was younger, a color which shifted with age to reddish black when viewed in the sun.

The morphology of this hair is clearly primate in character, all standard mammals of N. America are ruled out, and the remaining confounding variable - human hair - is not similar to this hair at all, in that the density of pigmentation far exceeds that of the blackest human hair.

These observations provide a legitimizing underpinning to the factual details reported by Jan Coy (Carter)(as co-author) in the book by Mary Green, deviant interpretations thereof notwithstanding.

Further collections will be attempted.

W. H. Fahrenbach, Ph.D."


There's a report shown on Ancient Mysteries. I'll have to get the name. I didn't write it down and now I don't remember it. It was on hair collected in Washington State, I think.
 
Green has reports of five kills.

This is the only line that matters in all the tripe, nonsense, and flat-out racist ad-hominem you've blathered about.

Where are the bodies?

Put up or shut up - either show us the bodies, or admit you're a gullible moron and/or an oppotunistic scam artist.

I'm more than happy to admit that unknown species of animals may live in the PNW and other remote regions. Even unknown species of primates. But not on the basis of slipshod evidence and apparent hoaxes, anecdotes from people who have too much time on their hands and not enough education, and internet wanna-bes like yourself who just parrot their favorite woo-sites and woo-books when they've never seen the creature for themselves.

I really don't care if you put me on ignore - it will just go to show how weak your arguments and 'evidence' really are. You're angry because we don't buy this garbage whole-cloth like you did. C'mon - you've claimed that this skewfoot is the same creature from 30 years ago - gee, it sure looks like the two casts came from the identical foot - meaning, in 30 years, old scars haven't changed and no new scars have formed? Very unusual for a creature who walks barefoot in the woods any length of time.

But anyway, like I said - the only important thing you posted is that Green claims there were five kills.

WHERE ARE THE BODIES?

If there were five kills, we'd have five examples to definitively PROVE to scientists that Bigfoot exists, and then all the gullible morons in the PNW would finally be vindicated.

But I'm guessing that amazing excuses exist to cover up all five bodies, huh, LAL? Not one of these five will ever see the light of day, will they?

.....

That's OK though - I took another look at the university's copy of the PGF, and I have it all figured out. It's not a man in a monkey suit at all!

Nope!!

The sagittal crest gave it away. It's a reptoid in a monkey suit.

:D

(To answer a question fairly to LAL: I did discount the possibility of the breasts in question being female solely on the grounds that female primates do not have hairy breasts - which, of course, is not a wise thing to assume about unknown species of primates. I therefore retract the statement that only males have been observed. However, it remains odd that the one observed and arguably recognized female of the species is equally as large as the observed males... Generally, among mammals, females are somewhat smaller. Of course, P&G were just lucky enough to film the Amazon Bigfoot - the female who was picked on for being so big to the point that she ran away from their normal breeding grounds and stumbled into Patterson, who cut her a deal... :D )

LAL - if all this upsets you so much, take a step back and breathe, will you? It's not that important. I'm not making any money on debunking Bigfoot, and you're not making any on proving him. Neither of us has reputations to worry about. Just friendly discussions, is all.

And I value people's differences. Willful ignorance is not a 'difference'; it is a disease.
 
zaayrdragon said:
This is the only line that matters in all the tripe, nonsense, and flat-out racist ad-hominem you've blathered about.

You are not worth responding to, but I will mention the Cripplefoot tracks were seen, not cast, thirty years earlier.

If you post anything coherent or even important, I'm sure someone will repost.

Bye.
 
LAL said:
Did you miss the reasons they were trying to lure in Skookum Meadows instead of track? Noll once spent three months in the field. Bryne tried tracking on and off for five years, just when he was funded for the research project in Oregon.

Pursuit would have been impossible.
Hardly impossible, just a choice someone made.

And simply incredible, considering the implications of aquiring some real evidence..
 
LAL said:
No, I'm reading Roger Knights' dissection of your argument.

I'd hardly call his response a 'dissection' per se. He's splitting hairs, so to speak. (nice pun eh?)

Is it legal to post that, or is that some kind of violation of board etiquette and standards?

If it's in the public forum, I don't see why it can't be used for discussion purposes.

He's lurked on this board, you know.

Maybe he should join in the discussion.

Originally posted on the BFF by RogerKni May 14 2004, 01:56 PM
But don't be misled by the identity of the name ("microscopic hair analysis") into thinking that crime-labs and Fahrenbach are doing the same thing. Fahrenbach is doing something quite different and much more reliable: differentiating and matching species, not individuals within a species, on the basis of gross (mostly) anatomical differences and similarities.

Roger says, "Fahrenbach is doing something quite different and much more reliable: differentiating and matching species..." It doesn't sound like Dr. Fahrenbach is having much success if he can't distinguish squatch from human hair. I already gave a link earlier in this thread about the FBI being able to tell human from animal hair. Either squatch hair is so close to being human that it IS human, or Dr. Fahrenbach isn't the expert you believe him to be.

EDIT: So the assertion microscopic hair analysis is unreliable should be qualified by the term, intra-species.

As I said in my original reply to Roger, " Yes, but Henner is proclaiming these hairs as belonging to sasquatch, [by] comparing them to other sasquatch hairs he's examined. [and proclaimed as belonging to squatch]"

What type of background does Roger have in hair analysis? I notice he provided no links to back up his 'dissection'.

Ah, but at least there's more of it than there was in '82.

Too bad quantity doesn't equate to quality.

The scofftics seem to have even fewer new arguments. ;)

Not too many 'scofftics' are going to equate anecdotes with evidence.

Well, at least I have seniority on you. :)

Keep in mind that's 30 years as an adult. I had heard of bigfoot about 10 years prior to that. :D

Do we really want the mystery to end?

Why not? I think the foreplay has gone on long enough.

I wonder if, aside from the chances of tracking the animal that made the Skookum imprint being less than those of a snowball in hell, the team didn't really want to bring one in.

That's one of the reasons I don't consider them a scientific organization. I'm guessing they're only using the term because they think it adds credibility and/or authority to their 'research'. If it don't walk like a duck, sound like a duck, or act like a duck...you can still call it a duck, but it ain't no duck.

RayG
 
LAL said:
Here's this:

"To the Curators:

The following situation has transpired. Some years ago, when Janice Coy (Carter) and Mary Green contacted me cautiously about the activities at the Coy farm, I suggested several modes of action to provide substantiation for the claims being made, one of them being collecting hair directly off a sasquatch, if close approaches in the context of feeding were possible. This has now occurred, in that Jan, when approached by the primary habituated sasquatch, named Fox, for a food item, reached out briefly, lightly grabbed hair on his forearm and pulled some out.

I have examined a good sampling of these hairs and they totally agree with my previous "gold standard", illustrated in the BFRO website under the FAQ "What is a bigfoot/sasquatch", albeit substantially more pigmented. The hairs are overall quite fine, measuring between 35 and 65 µm in diameter and at most an inch long. They have largely the same diameter over their entire length, as one would expect from primate hair, and the tips have either a split or worn, rounded end. Most of the hairs have no medulla at all, a few have a fragmentary minimal one. The hair has the seemingly universal reddish tint (phaeomelanin) found in all prior sasquatch hair collections, in addition to having rather coarsely streaked and very dense melanin (eumelanin) granules throughout. The sasquatch in question was described as having had a blue-black hair color when he was younger, a color which shifted with age to reddish black when viewed in the sun.

The morphology of this hair is clearly primate in character, all standard mammals of N. America are ruled out, and the remaining confounding variable - human hair - is not similar to this hair at all, in that the density of pigmentation far exceeds that of the blackest human hair.

These observations provide a legitimizing underpinning to the factual details reported by Jan Coy (Carter)(as co-author) in the book by Mary Green, deviant interpretations thereof notwithstanding.

Further collections will be attempted.

W. H. Fahrenbach, Ph.D."

That was picked apart ages ago.

Here's more on the hair from the Coy/Green camp:

From the BFF
http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=5210&st=0&#entry103272

Originally posted by Tsiatko May 21 2004, 11:51 PM
Over a year ago after hearing so much about the Book that 50 years with Bigfoot I thought I would see if Marry Green would send me some of the hair she and Jan Coy say thye had from the Carter farm. They claimed to have a lot of hair and I had heard that Dr. Fahrenbach said it matched his samples of Sasquatch hair. First I asked Henner if it was true. He said yes. So I e-mailed Mary Green and asked if I could get a sample. She was very nice and agreed to send me the samples. The reason I wanted the sample was for my own research and to better understand what to look for in Sasquatch hair. After getting the samples I gave them to Henner and asked him to take a look at them. I didn't tell him where they came from. just that they were given to me. Here is what he said about them.

Dear John,

I looked at the hair today and it does not immediately fill me with confidence as to its being of sasquatch origin. It has a diameter of about 50 µm (ok for BF) and is exceedingly heavily pigmented to the point of being totally opaque (not ok for BF). As for a medulla, it is not a standard cellular one, as in most mammals, but rather subdued in its organization to the degree that one can visualize it at all (sort of ok for BF). What makes me suspicious is that the hair has very coarse pigment and some large pigment clumps that I associate with bovine hair and sometimes with bear, though bear has a different medulla. I have no purported sasquatch hair that looks like this, so I rather err on the side of caution and call it probable bovine, unless you have very compelling reason to rule that out. The batches in both baggies were identical, if that's any help.

My best, Henner.

Read the whole thread, I'm not the only one not convinced by Dr. Fahrenbach's findings.

RayG
 
Coy farm...no pics?

You mean a woman supposedly had a bigfoot eating out of her hand and NOBODY GOT ANY PICTURES? Pictures that close could show teeth, feet, eyes, face, mammaries...surely enough to go a long ways towards categorizing the critter.....but no, no foot prints, no fingerprints, no photos, no videos,,,but a sample of cows hair...anybody else smell a hoax?
 
I see he's avoiding the topics of Green's 'five kills'.

Which is interesting, considering there is a general discussion across bigfoot territory about whether or not B.F. CAN be killed.

I urge those of you reading this to demand evidence of the five kills from LAL. At this point in time, it would be the only convincing evidence, short of a 'Squatch walking out of the Northern Woods right now and agreeing to a C.N.N. interview.
 
Diogenes said:
Uhhhhh, source please ?

Peter Bryne citing an FFA report in 1994. He says 73 from California to Alaska since WWII.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Lu, do you have any links supporting the claim that similar "clubfoot" prints were found 30 years apart?

I believe that was from one of the researchers on BFF. I'll check next time I'm over there.
 
Diogenes said:
Hardly impossible, just a choice someone made.

And simply incredible, considering the implications of aquiring some real evidence..

They weren't out to shoot one and weren't equipped for a capture. The imprint was real evidence. Green thought the cast would be sufficient to finally convince science. You'd think after all this time he'd know better. Never underestimate the power of denial.

Pursuit with the creature having less than an hour headstart was impossible in another part of Skamania County with similar terrain. These creatures are reported to move swiftly as a deer and they slip through the trees as easily. No one runs down deer in that country either.
 
They weren't out to shoot one and weren't equiped for a capture.

Shooting and capturing?

What about following and reporting?

What about having people see it?

What about getting pictures?

What about finding some really fresh tracks?

If they had found it's tracks, seen it, or got pictures of it, even poor ones, it would have strongly supported their opinion of the cast.

I know Byrne makes the 73 planes claim on a show on A & E, but i have never seen any support for it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom