Bigfoot - serious, not follies

LTC8K6 said:
Well, the "scientific" consensus is that dogs are afraid to follow a sasquatch. :D

Not afraid to chase down and tree a bear, though.

Not afraid to chase a car, either. :D

Science: I tried to get my dog to follow a sasquatch and it never did. This must mean that it is afraid to follow a sasquatch. An alternate hypothesis, such as that there are no sasquatch to follow, is not conceivable.
 
aggle-rithm said:
If Bigfoot can get around, then people shouldn't have any problem.

I don't think all the members of the BFRO would be sufficient to ring even a small part of Skamania County. In most areas they wouldn't be able to see each other, let alone the quarry.
 
FFed said:
I have used tracking dogs to find a bear that was in the area three days before. Maybe it's time serious bigfoot hunters invested in some good tracking dogs.

Been done I believe. There are dogs that will react to the smell. There's a thread on BFF on what is needed for a good team, and such dogs are listed.
 
aggle-rithm said:
...and they can find an illegal species of shellfish even when it's wrapped in other fish and sealed in plastic.

Bigfoot must be VERY odor-free! Could he be a robot?

Ah, but remember - Sasquatch is not an animal, but a being of energy, apparently. And we all know energy has no scent.

:rolleyes:
 
LTC8K6 said:
Who cares? I referred only to your thought that it would be stupid to "mess up" a hoax with a synthetic hair, not to any specific case or scientist.

So the BFRO either didn't note the age of the other animal tracks at all, or they incorrectly claimed they were old?

Is that supposed to make the BFRO look good?

Is it now my fault that the stories differ, or what?

This is a scientific organization?

Or it's a reporting error?

Failure to dot an "i" doesn't mean the oranization is incompetant or that the imprint is of an elk. Have you figured out how three "knee prints" in a row show an elk getting up (or down?)
 
zaayrdragon said:
Ah, but remember - Sasquatch is not an animal, but a being of energy, apparently. And we all know energy has no scent.

:rolleyes:

That's nonsense. They're an animal. They leave tracks, scat, hair, urine, and may make nests.
 
LAL said:
That's nonsense. They're an animal. They leave tracks, scat, hair, urine, and may make nests.

*aside to self - someone hasn't been reading the thread, or checking out EB's site, and apparently lacks a sense of sarcasm*

OK, I agree that an animal source is more likely true. So let's see the tracks, scat, hair, urine, and possible nests analyses by prominent and respectable laboratories, showing that they are clearly and without doubt not the product of other animals.
 
RayG said:
Like I quoted:

"But by the mid-1990s only Krantz and a select few academic supporters could maintain belief in Freeman's discoveries."

I guess Dr. Meldrum is one of those supporters.


As is Vance Orchard as recently as 2004, so, once again, Dennett is wrong.


Not at all. Beckjord gets published, Beckjord gets interviewed. How many times have YOU been on Letterman discussing bigfoot? There's no bigfoot certification exam, no degree to be earned, no outward proof that one 'expert' has more validity than another.


I barely watch Letterman and I would have no desire to be on the show with all those underdressed women and Billy Crystal. I never even saw it before Politically Incorrect was cancelled.

How did Letterman fail to notice as we did, when Beckjord invaded this forum, that the man is stark raving mad. How did Dennett? Have you seen his website?

I could say the same for Noll or Fahrenbach.

Some people think with their fists, others with their brains.

His inability to differentiate between human and sasquatch hair, yet he claims to have positively identified hair as belonging to sasquatch. I've still not seen any evidence that he's an expert in hair analysis to begin with, and the previous links I have provided about microscopic hair analysis being 'junk science' anyway.

There are differences, visible under the microscope, which he has noted. The DNA testing was inconclusive and the samples may have been contaminated during collection by humans.

Not to say they aren't either. They can't be distinguished from human hair.


Not true.

I'll repeat: As far as I'm concerned, Fahrenbach's past problems with hair identification render any further hair claims worthless.


As you wish. I see it's easy for you to dismiss any expert opinions that don't agree with yours.


Did you see the photo in the article from Cliff Crook? That's one of the ones he was discredited for. Appling the same standard to him that you do to Freeman, you should dismiss everything he found or has said, shouldn't you?

Bigfootprints was published several years before Fahrenbach gave his opinion wasn't it? There was a tuft on a branch displayed at a symposium, which turned out to be synthetic. Someone called it "scientific sabotage" and Freeman's reputation went down in flames.

But there's no evidence Freeman or anyone else planted those hairs. Contamination happens.

Freeman spent a good part of his like trying to prove he wasn't a "kook". Now that he's dead he's still labled a fraud. Poor guy.

http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/articles/wallawalla.htm

Note the article cites Rant Mullens in their claim "Bigfoot print hoaxing is a time-honored cottage industry".

Geez.

SI needs to apply some of their scepticism to their own articles on this topic.
 
Well, let's put it this way:

if a researcher is fooled by someone deliberately setting out to fool them, or through 'contamination', they deserve to be discredited on the grounds that their research was not thorough enough - unless they go back, openly admit their error, and are able to demonstrate that they have some competency after all. After all, how can we trust the opinions of someone who couldn't tell a fake photo from a genuine photo, when others could? Clearly, someone who is fooled by false evidence is less trustworthy than someone who catches said fakery.

If, on the other hand, the researcher faked a bit himself - then he can't be trusted, no matter what.

And if we don't know who was responsible for the fakery, we certainly can't invest trust in the researcher, his associates, colleagues, etc.
 
LAL said:
Been done I believe. There are dogs that will react to the smell. There's a thread on BFF on what is needed for a good team, and such dogs are listed.

Not done enough then. Instead of using all the fancy night vision, trail cameras and such, they should stick to the tried and true hunting methods. Cougar hunters are very successful using dogs, and if I was serious about catching bigfoot dogs would be the first item on my list.
 
Have you figured out how three "knee prints" in a row show an elk getting up (or down?)

Why would anyone need to figure that out?

You already know how that could happen with an elk, so why did you ask?

This obtuseness seems to me to be intentional on your part, Lu.

Why?

You can't seem to think of any way anything could happen except BIGFOOT.
 
LAL said:
As is Vance Orchard as recently as 2004, so, once again, Dennett is wrong.

Coming up with two names certainly qualifies as -- "a select few academic supporters".

How did Letterman fail to notice as we did, when Beckjord invaded this forum, that the man is stark raving mad. How did Dennett? Have you seen his website?

I've not only seen it, I once created a parody of it, along with a secondary website to refute his paranormal claims. Do you remember any of the websites I created? If not, that suggests you're fairly new to the internet bigfoot community.

There are differences, visible under the microscope, which he has noted. The DNA testing was inconclusive and the samples may have been contaminated during collection by humans.

You can ignore what Dr. Fahrenbach himself wrote if you wish, but his own admission is quite telling:

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair...

I am concentrating now on blood or tissue, as the hair holds no promise." -- Dr. W. H. Fahrenbach, November 3, 1999


Not true.

Really? Fahrenbach himself calls the hairs indistinguishable (impossible to differentiate or tell apart) from human hair. (In other words, he can't tell the difference).

As you wish. I see it's easy for you to dismiss any expert opinions that don't agree with yours.

You've yet to provide ANY evidence that Fahrenbach is an 'expert' at microscopic hair analysis.

Did you see the photo in the article from Cliff Crook? That's one of the ones he was discredited for. Appling the same standard to him that you do to Freeman, you should dismiss everything he found or has said, shouldn't you?

Nope. Opinions are not evidence. I already indicated I wouldn't accept any evidence from Cliff Crook without a great deal of suspicion.

Bigfootprints was published several years before Fahrenbach gave his opinion wasn't it?

Which seems to agree with what I said, that Fahrenbach never actually examined the 'hair' in the early stages. (Actually, I've seen no evidence he EVER examined the Freeman 'hair'.)

But there's no evidence Freeman or anyone else planted those hairs.

But as I pointed out, Freeman twice brought Krantz MORE 'hair', which, if I read correctly, also turned out to be synthetic.

Contamination happens.

So does fraud.

Freeman spent a good part of his like trying to prove he wasn't a "kook". Now that he's dead he's still labled a fraud. Poor guy.

Appeal to pity.

SI needs to apply some of their scepticism to their own articles on this topic.

It would be helpful if someone were to provide some actual evidence. (A body perhaps?)

RayG
 
Definitive Proof!

"I don't think that nine people that seen it could tell the same story. They wouldn't be able to tell the same story if it wasn't true."

Sasquatch knocks on houses in one of Canada's Territories

The creature left behind some evidence, the men said: a footprint about twice the size of a human's, and a small patch of hair found in the area that has been sent to a conservation officer in Whitehorse.

btw this websiteHunting Outfitters does not advertise trophy hunting of sasquatch. Could it be because the Canadian government offers no liscenses to hunt sasquath? Everything else is on the "menu".
 
RayG said:
Coming up with two names certainly qualifies as -- "a select few academic supporters".



Dennett's still wrong.

I've not only seen it, I once created a parody of it, along with a secondary website to refute his paranormal claims. Do you remember any of the websites I created? If not, that suggests you're fairly new to the internet bigfoot community.


If joining BFF makes me a member of the "Bigfoot Community", yes, I'm fairly new (though my interest goes back to '68), and I haven't had time to find every post on the forum. Got links?

You can ignore what Dr. Fahrenbach himself wrote if you wish, but his own admission is quite telling:

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair...

I am concentrating now on blood or tissue, as the hair holds no promise." -- Dr. W. H. Fahrenbach, November 3, 1999




Really? Fahrenbach himself calls the hairs indistinguishable (impossible to differentiate or tell apart) from human hair. (In other words, he can't tell the difference).


We've posted that, what? Half a dozen times? He noted differences in a caption on a micrograph, but the caption's been removed. I'll try to find something else on it.

http://www.visualsunlimited.com/browse/vu851/vu85166.html


You've yet to provide ANY evidence that Fahrenbach is an 'expert' at microscopic hair analysis.



http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=3058888&dopt=Abstract

http://www.aecom.yu.edu/wormem/DrDavidHallv1/referenc.htm

Nope. Opinions are not evidence. I already indicated I wouldn't accept any evidence from Cliff Crook without a great deal of suspicion.


Shouldn't SI do the same?

Which seems to agree with what I said, that Fahrenbach never actually examined the 'hair' in the early stages. (Actually, I've seen no evidence he EVER examined the Freeman 'hair'.)


"He talked to Paul Freeman, who has spent much of the last several years looking for Bigfoot, and Bill Laughery, an ex-game warden. The three of them decided to drive up and have a look the next morning. They hiked in off the main road and started climbing into the highlands. Then, Sumerlin said, he got "a whiff of something." "Smelled like somebody skinning muskrats. And then I thought, 'Hell, there ain't nobody skinning muskrats up here.' " Freeman had gone on ahead, but Sumerlin called Laughery back. "I stood there just a second or two, and all of a sudden I smelled it: a real pungent, heavy odor like an animal that's in rut. Like you can smell a bull elk or a buck deer," Laughery said. The two men were interviewed separately but gave identical accounts.

Sumerlin and Laughery said they moved together into a clearing, where they found a number of small trees twisted and broken, so fresh they were still dripping sap. There were large clumps of long hair, some black, some dark brown, caught on the trees where they were broken. Laughery started to walk on when Sumerlin said he saw something moving in the trees. "It's like you can't see it, but you can see the daylight breaking behind it," he said. "Bill was there — he packs those sneaky little spy glasses around — and he said, 'Wes, I see something, but I can't put a head on it.' ... I got down by him and he was talking about it while I was walking toward it, and then he said, 'Hell, it's gone.' I was looking at the back of the critter, I was just seeing part of it. But he was looking on the other side, and he was getting a good look at it. But basically we saw the same thing. It was a big, hairy critter, about 7 foot tall, I'd say, covered with hair." "It was 7 to 8 foot tall, buckskin brown, I could see it well enough to see fringe about 1 inch high, a little, on the top of the head," Laughery said. "We were 87 feet away and we stood and watched that for four or five minutes, and it didn't move at all. I looked it up and down. I couldn't see its face. ... I got a quarter-view. And then the minute I turned to Wes to say something, it took off."

Laughery and Sumerlin said they thought that there were actually two creatures, one that moved off down the canyon, another that headed down a small trail. They both saw the big one jump the trail, 15 feet in one leap, and they got a better look at it. They followed it down 60 to 70 yards through ferns and low bushes.

At about that time, they said, Freeman came running up and kept moving toward the car. "Paul said, 'Let's get the hell out of here'," Sumerlin said. But the three of them sat down, quietly. "We sat down three or four minutes and started hearing that brush snapping ," Sumerlin said. "We heard a snip, and then we heard another snip, and every time we heard a snip, we'd point. We didn't say nothing. And pretty soon we got up and went over there and we could hear it breathing. Just a real heavy breathing." From far down in the canyon, they said, there was a whistle. And then a grunt, and a crash of bushes, and whatever it was was gone.

Their story has been discounted by some Bigfoot investigators because it involves Freeman, who is believed to have faked some Bigfoot evidence in the past. But Sumerlin and Laughery said they know all the stories about Freeman and he could not have faked what they saw. Sumerlin has a good reputation in the Blue Mountains, even among skeptics. Hair samples the trio collected finally will tell the tale, Sumerlin and others believe.

Paul Fuerst, associate professor of molecular genetics at Ohio State University, said technical problems have delayed completion of the tests until at least the end of this month. Fuerst said the tests, if they can be completed, "will either show that it was something we know, a bear or a squirrel, or they will show whether it is in fact an unknown species."

Originally published Monday, January 22, 1996 in the Section: MAIN NEWS
Page: 1A By Kim Murphy writer for the Los Angeles Times/Washington Post Service"

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/fact.htm


But as I pointed out, Freeman twice brought Krantz MORE 'hair', which, if I read correctly, also turned out to be synthetic.


I read Big Footprints years ago, but I don't remember this part. I tried to order the new edition from Amazon.com, but they were sold out. Back to the library.


So does fraud.


But not necessarily by Freeman.

Appeal to pity.



My opinion. I think he's getting a bum rap.

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/forslund.htm

It would be helpful if someone were to provide some actual evidence. (A body perhaps?)
Perhaps the guy with the gun on the NG show will get lucky.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Why would anyone need to figure that out?

You already know how that could happen with an elk, so why did you ask?


No, I don't. Watch an elk, then draw me a picture.

This obtuseness seems to me to be intentional on your part, Lu.

Why?


Inasmuch as I'm not obtuse, I don't think I can answer that.

You can't seem to think of any way anything could happen except BIGFOOT.

You've said youself you can't see anything on the imprint unless it's pointed out to you.
You take the opinion of a, hm, colorful character over that of five PhDs with specialties in anatomy who actually examined it. The PhD in zoology who saw the imprint you accused (in so many words) of artificially chewing the fruit.

But I'm obtuse? And a liar?

I'll buy my own coffee, thanks.
 
LAL said:
Dennett's still wrong.

How so? Because you disagree with his findings?

If joining BFF makes me a member of the "Bigfoot Community", yes, I'm fairly new (though my interest goes back to '68), and I haven't had time to find every post on the forum. Got links?

No, my bigfoot websites were online long before the BFF ever existed. So long ago in fact, that though links still exist, the websites do not. Have you heard of the IVBC? It was a bigfoot email list created by Henry Franzoni back in the mid 90's that I belonged to.

We've posted that, what? Half a dozen times?

Seems to be worth repeating.

He noted differences in a caption on a micrograph, but the caption's been removed. I'll try to find something else on it.

I keep pointing it out but you keep sidestepping the issue: Dr. Fahrenbach could not distinguish a human hair from that of a purported sasquatch.

One more time...
http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/WHF/dnatests.htm
The hair was sent to Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach (Beaverton, Oregon), who determined microscopically that the hair appeared to have come from two individuals of the same species, that it differed in color, length and hair growth cycle between the two sets, had not been not cut, and was indistinguishable from human hair by any criterion.

He [Dr. Fahrenbach] says the same thing a second time on the same website:

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair..."


Those two links did nothing to show Dr. Fahrenbach is an expert in microscopic hair analysis.

Originally posted by RayG
Opinions are not evidence. I already indicated I wouldn't accept any evidence from Cliff Crook without a great deal of suspicion.

Originally posted by LAL
Shouldn't SI do the same?

I have twice pointed out that Crook provided an opinion NOT evidence to SI. Big difference.

Paul Fuerst, associate professor of molecular genetics at Ohio State University, said technical problems have delayed completion of the tests until at least the end of this month. Fuerst said the tests, if they can be completed, "will either show that it was something we know, a bear or a squirrel, or they will show whether it is in fact an unknown species."

Originally published Monday, January 22, 1996...

What's the purpose of submitting that? I've already given more recent quotes from both Dr. Fahrenbach and Fuerst concerning those hairs. They couldn't distinguish them from human.
http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/WHF/dnatests.htm

I read Big Footprints years ago, but I don't remember this part.

And you won't find it in there, because to my knowledge it's not in the book. The original quote I gave for that:
http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/proponent.html

Krantz did seem somewhat suspicious of hairs from the Blue Mountains when he said:

"Clearly someone was planting samples of Dynel fiber in many places in the Blue Mountains." (Big Footprints page 127)

But not necessarily by Freeman.

Not necessary, but certainly possible. It's also possible someone was trying to dupe Freeman, but not necessarily. It seems rather strange that he kept bringing in fake hair samples.

RayG
 
No, I don't. Watch an elk, then draw me a picture.

I already gave you 2 pictures, dear. That was you who responded to them, wasn't it?

You really couldn't think up:

There was more than one elk eating the fruit..

The elk kneeled more than once to get some of the fruit.

The elk stepped in it's own track.

The elk or another animal obliterated one of the elk tracks.

In light of the fact that there were two piles of chewed apple in the muddy wallow, I find it frightening that you couldn't come up with the 2 elk idea at least.

Even I, with only 2 bigfeets, can make odd numbers of tracks around a spot. All by myself I can make 3 foot prints. Amazing!

You've said youself you can't see anything on the imprint unless it's pointed out to you.

Fortunately, someone pointed out a few things to me. I think it was the BFRO. :p

An elk knee/leg imprint, for example. :D

Fresh elk, deer, and coyote prints, for example. :D

No sasquatch imprints though. :D

The PhD in zoology who saw the imprint you accused (in so many words) of artificially chewing the fruit

I accused him of making fake chewed fruit and putting it in the muddy wallow. I also accused Fish and Randles of faking the imprint and biasing subsequent observers. :D

Who went out there by themselves at 3:00AM? Who discovered the butt print?

I didn't say anything about a chewing machine though, other than that I wouldn't need one. :D

It's amazing that your mind can come up with an "artificial chewing machine" to make fruit look like it had been chewed, but it can't figure out how to fake tracks, or how an elk might make three tracks in some mud.

I'll buy my own coffee, thanks.

You're welcome. It would have been tea for me, though.
 
Re: Definitive Proof!

PygmyPlaidGiraffe said:
Sasquatch knocks on houses in one of Canada's Territories

The creature left behind some evidence, the men said: a footprint about twice the size of a human's, and a small patch of hair found in the area that has been sent to a conservation officer in Whitehorse.

Anyone heard any follow-up on this? This took place about a week ago, so I figured we would have heard more by now (supposing there is anything to hear :p).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom