Bigfoot - serious, not follies

LTC8K6 said:
Remember, at ~3 am there was no impression. Then at ~9 am the impression is there.

They were just 6 hours at most behind the bigfoot, and probably a lot less than that.

Just 6 hours and the cast and wallow are full of all sorts of hair and tracks.

Just six hours......

The ground was frozen too at some point.

Just six hours, and they left.

The next day, after putting out more bait.

The imprint was drying and cracking. Casting it had priority. The animal could have been miles away by the time they got up. They weren't out to hunt it. They were out for more evidence and they got it.
 
To LAL:

You'd think that with even one person, let alone many people, devoting an entire life to finding and proving these things, SOME universally agreeable proof would emerge over the course of decades. This isn't a microbe, it's a creature larger than a human. Why only weak video clips and "unidentifiable" prints and hairs?

A suggestion: just get as many people as you can, armed with GPS devices and tranquilizer guns, to surround the woods where one MUST live based on previous evidence, and with pure numbers go from the outside of the forest towards the middle point where everyone must converges. Spot him, tranq him, tag and document him, and get the credibility you seek.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Exactly what the hoaxee would say if he had been fooled by a hoax. Since he has been fooled, he is naturally unaware that he has been hoaxed.

Oh, good grief.

Fahrenbach knew the hair in question was synthetic. He wasn't fooled by it at all. He did not believe it was an attempted hoax, just a case of Freeman not knowing what it was.

What hoaxer, having faked evidence good enough to fool experts, would then mess it up with a synthetic hair? That's stupid.
 
SmooveK said:
To LAL:

You'd think that with even one person, let alone many people, devoting an entire life to finding and proving these things, SOME universally agreeable proof would emerge over the course of decades. This isn't a microbe, it's a creature larger than a human. Why only weak video clips and "unidentifiable" prints and hairs?

A suggestion: just get as many people as you can, armed with GPS devices and tranquilizer guns, to surround the woods where one MUST live based on previous evidence, and with pure numbers go from the outside of the forest towards the middle point where everyone must converges. Spot him, tranq him, tag and document him, and get the credibility you seek.

Please forward your suggestion to the BFRO. I'm not a member.

You haven't been in the mountains of the PNW, have you?
 
Fahrenbach knew the hair in question was synthetic.

Who cares? You missed my point entirely.

What hoaxer, having faked evidence good enough to fool experts, would then mess it up with a synthetic hair? That's stupid.

Actually, putting an obvious clue into a hoax is pretty common. It is to give the believers a fair chance to realize that they are looking at a hoax. It also prevents them from continuing to claim the hoax is real after the the truth is revealed.

To those who are fooled, the synthetic hair would be proof that they have lost their objectivity, since the synthetic hair should have been obvious.

Except for Dynel, of course. :D
 
LTC8K6 said:

So the elk prints were not old, as is always claimed. Here is the claim from the BFRO expedition report:



And here's the section from the field notes. The age is not mentioned.

"On their way out, Randles, Noll, and Fish decided to stop and check the roadside mud pool that Randles and Dr. Fish had placed fruit at the night before. Some of the fruit, but not all, had been taken. Three of the original six apples were missing. Some of the melons showed evidence of having been pecked at by birds. They noted elk, deer, coyote and bear tracks in the mud pool. The three noticed a large impression at the eastern edge of the mud pool. It took several minutes of studying the impression before they finally deduced that it was possibly made by a sasquatch sitting down at the edge of the pool, and leaning over to grasp the fruit in the center. The three immediately returned to camp to inform the others."

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/pnw_newsletter003/dayseven.htm
 
LTC8K6 said:
They up and leave. Inexcusable. Unexplainable. Incredible.

Sure is puzzling.

If they aren't really interested in bigfoot, why should I be interested. Why should science?

It DOES seem like odd behavior for a group calling itself -- "The only scientific research organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"

RayG
 
LAL said:
As Dahinden once said, "My God, what do you have to show them before they'll take it seriously?"

Evidence. Evidence that can stand on its own.

I wonder, given the opportunity to pursue/track/search for a live bigfoot, or, stand around pouring casting material, which do you think Dahinden would have chosen? And Dahinden weren't no scientist.

RayG
 
LTC8K6 said:
Who cares? You missed my point entirely.



Was there one?

Actually, putting an obvious clue into a hoax is pretty common. It is to give the believers a fair chance to realize that they are looking at a hoax. It also prevents them from continuing to claim the hoax is real after the the truth is revealed.

To those who are fooled, the synthetic hair would be proof that they have lost their objectivity, since the synthetic hair should have been obvious.

Except for Dynel, of course. :D

The hair was one of many that were brought in, and Fahrenbach was not part of investigating the site where the hair was found. He noted others had brought in synthetic hairs as well, just because they didn't know what they were.
There's no evidence Freeman was a hoaxer (a prankster, maybe), and the synthetic hair was just something he brought in for identification.

If you're referring to the PGF, Dynel is the worst.
 
Like I quoted:

"But by the mid-1990s only Krantz and a select few academic supporters could maintain belief in Freeman's discoveries."

I guess Dr. Meldrum is one of those supporters.

LAL said:
Doesn't the fact that Dennett regards him as one send up a red flag?

Not at all. Beckjord gets published, Beckjord gets interviewed. How many times have YOU been on Letterman discussing bigfoot? There's no bigfoot certification exam, no degree to be earned, no outward proof that one 'expert' has more validity than another.

I'd double check anything Dennett says, if I were you.

I could say the same for Noll or Fahrenbach.

According to Noll, Wes Summerlin nearly gave him a knuckle sandwich when Dennett showed up at the airport in a suit.

Some people think with their fists, others with their brains.

What problems?

His inability to differentiate between human and sasquatch hair, yet he claims to have positively identified hair as belonging to sasquatch. I've still not seen any evidence that he's an expert in hair analysis to begin with, and the previous links I have provided about microscopic hair analysis being 'junk science' anyway.

The hairs are close to human. That's not to say they are human.

Not to say they aren't either. They can't be distinguished from human hair.

Don't read this, then:

"Contrary to popular belief, I have not encountered any deliberate effort to produce a hoax with hair samples, even in the much decried case of the fiber sample gathered by Paul Freeman. The same man-made fibers have been found elsewhere in the mountains by others and may be an environmental contaminant. People like Paul Freeman submit these samples for analysis precisely because they are not sure what they are at the time of collection.

Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach

I'll repeat: As far as I'm concerned, Fahrenbach's past problems with hair identification render any further hair claims worthless.

http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/articles/skeptical.htm
Lonnie Somer, a Washington State University graduate student, made a presentation on Bigfoot hair samples to the annual meeting of the International Society of Cryptozoology. The gathering was hosted by the Department of Anthropology at WSU in June 1989. Somer obtained several hair samples said to be from a Sasquatch, all from the Blue Mountains, of which the Mill Creek watershed is a part. He reported that he made microscopic observations of the cross-sections and shapes of the hairs. He conducted tests of the pattern of the burn and of the smell. In these instances the Sasquatch "hair" differed from human and animal samples. He discovered that no hair follicles or scales were present on his Bigfoot samples, although human and animal hairs showed both follicles and scales. Somer compared the alleged Bigfoot hair with synthetic wig fibers. He found the synthetic fibers varied from the human and animal samples in the same way as the alleged Bigfoot hair. His conclusion was that the Sasquatch hair samples were meant, Somer replied that he believed someone was "perpetrating a [Bigfoot] hoax!"(3)

Krantz mentions Somer's presentation in his book and agrees that it indicates hoax activity in the Blue Mountains.

http://www.csicop.org/si/2002-03/bigfoot.html
Originally quoted from the Grover Krantz book Bigfootprints:

"A large amount of what looks like hair has been recovered from several places in the Blue Mountains since 1987. Samples of this were examined by many supposed experts ranging from the FBI to barbers. Most of these called it human, the Redkin Company found significant differences from human hair, but the Japan Hair Medical Science Lab declared it a synthetic fiber. A scientist at [Washington State] University first called it synthetic, then looked more closely and decided it was real hair of an unknown type. . . . Final confirmation came when E.B. Winn, a pharmaceutical businessman from Switzerland, had a sample tested in Europe. The fiber was positively identified as artificial and its exact composition was determined: it is a product known commercially as Dynel, which is often used as imitation hair."

RayG
 
RayG said:
Evidence. Evidence that can stand on its own.

I wonder, given the opportunity to pursue/track/search for a live bigfoot, or, stand around pouring casting material, which do you think Dahinden would have chosen? And Dahinden weren't no scientist.

RayG

He'd have gone after the hairy sonuvabitch while the others preserved the imprint. And he wouldn't have found it, either.

He had a chance to collect some urine and didn't do it. He weren't no scientist, as you said. (Shouldn't that be "warn't"?)

He wanted to be "the one" and seemed to have an obvious resentment against anyone who was bringing in more evidence than he was. Noll says he was behind the plot to fool Krantz with the Indiana cast. Seems he didn't like no scientists, either.
 
LAL said:
Oh, good grief.

Fahrenbach knew the hair in question was synthetic.

He did? I've not read anywhere that he even examined the hair in the early stages.

He wasn't fooled by it at all.

Certainly not after it was confirmed synthetic.

He did not believe it was an attempted hoax, just a case of Freeman not knowing what it was.

Even though Freeman had submitted identical hairs on more than one occasion?

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/proponent.html
"Freeman then produced at least two more sets of "hair" which he gave to Professor Krantz."

What hoaxer, having faked evidence good enough to fool experts, would then mess it up with a synthetic hair? That's stupid.

Nothing stupid about it, the 'hair' DID fool experts, initially.

RayG
 
The hair was one of many that were brought in, and Fahrenbach was not part of investigating the site where the hair was found. He noted others had brought in synthetic hairs as well, just because they didn't know what they were.

Who cares? I referred only to your thought that it would be stupid to "mess up" a hoax with a synthetic hair, not to any specific case or scientist.

So the BFRO either didn't note the age of the other animal tracks at all, or they incorrectly claimed they were old?

Is that supposed to make the BFRO look good?

Is it now my fault that the stories differ, or what?

This is a scientific organization?
 
LAL said:
The next day, after putting out more bait.

The imprint was drying and cracking. Casting it had priority. The animal could have been miles away by the time they got up. They weren't out to hunt it. They were out for more evidence and they got it.

I have used tracking dogs to find a bear that was in the area three days before. Maybe it's time serious bigfoot hunters invested in some good tracking dogs.
 
Nope. Dogs will track everything but bigfoot, apparently. :D

Lion, tigers, and bears, oh my, but not bigfoot. :D

They will even work in heavy combat, sniffing out explosives and enemy soldiers, but they refuse to follow bigfoot. :D
 
LTC8K6 said:

They will even work in heavy combat, sniffing out explosives and enemy soldiers, but they refuse to follow bigfoot. :D

...and they can find an illegal species of shellfish even when it's wrapped in other fish and sealed in plastic.

Bigfoot must be VERY odor-free! Could he be a robot?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom