Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Remember, at ~3 am there was no impression. Then at ~9 am the impression is there.

They were just 6 hours at most behind the bigfoot, and probably a lot less than that.

Just 6 hours and the cast and wallow are full of all sorts of hair and tracks.

Just six hours......

The ground was frozen too at some point.

Just six hours, and they left.
 
LAL said:
That was only when Peter was trying to track them. ;)

Ah, I see... no wonder he never ever saw one even after all those years.

They sign pretty well. Have you read Fouts' book - Next of Kin?

No, but I have read a lot of info concerning 'talking' apes. I've seen no evidence they're actually engaging in language as we know it.

An elk sat on its hoofprints?

Your claim, not mine. (Ok, Rick Noll's claim)

One looks clear enough for me in the photo in the field notes.

Looks can be deceiving. According to the field notes, no clear footprints were ever found during the expedition.

And Noll found some in the area prior to the expedition, didn't he? That's why they went to Skookum Meadow.

From recent postings on the BFRO website, it would appear the BFRO are not only aware of the specific areas bigfoot resides, they only lack the proper equipment to capture them on film. (If you're not aware of these claims/appeals, I can direct you to the applicable topic on the BFF)

The heat marks could have been bear or even porcupine. There was no way to determine just what they were, but they weren't from a hooved animal.

Exactly my point.

Calls, according to the story you posted.

What use are calls when no animal is observed making the calls? As I said, absolutely no other evidence collected (or recorded) during this expedition that points to squatch as the culprit.

"While the DNA tests have not been completed, the hair samples have been determined by an independent lab to belong to an "unknown primate," Noll said.

Have these lab results been posted? If so, where?

Both the hairs and the castings have been shown to experts who are convinced that they didn't come from an elk, deer or bear."

Very few 'experts' have even examined the cast. After the initial hype, the Skookum cast seems to have faded away, no better than a cast of a footprint at this point.

It's all well and good to quote internet websites and newspaper reports, but where are the entries in the scientific journals regarding the Skookum cast?

Remember what Dr. Meldrum stated: “While not definitively proving the existence of a species of North American ape, the cast constitutes significant and compelling new evidence that will hopefully stimulate further serious research and investigation into the presence of these primates in the Northwest mountains and elsewhere.”

Only a handful of scientists have actually examined the Skookum cast however.

He probably was [a hair analysis expert] before he took an interest in bigfootdom.

I've not seen any evidence he was.

Such as this?

""There's where the cheeks are," he says. "And that's a heel mark and the Achilles tendon. We figure this is where its arm rested, as it turned on its side." Mr. Noll points out the fine ridges left by matted hair in the thigh -- and then points delicately to a double print between the cheeks, where the, uh, impressions were left that show this Sasquatch was male."


And:

"It's an elk!" hoots Cliff Crook, founder of Bigfoot Central, who has been tracking Sasquatches since 1956.

Everyone's entitled to an opinion. Noll can claim tiny impressions belong to tiny testicles, and Crook can claim elk kneeprints. Without a body comparison, neither claim can be proven.

Mr. Crook, however, who lives not far away in Bothell, Washington, has not bothered to see the cast for himself. "He's just jealous," says Mr. Noll, "because he's never found anything like this himself."

There are only two people Mr. Noll has not allowed to examine the cast, Mr. Crook(who he seems to be feuding with) and Benjamin Radford(who writes for the Skeptical Inquirer. That comes from Mr. Noll himself.

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=2516&st=0&#entry54191
"I have turned down only two people in coming to see the cast... Cliff Crook and Benjamin Radford."

Didn't you say other statements ring true? :)

Yes, and they agree with my own opinion.

Who besides Crook thinks it's a elk? Anyone who's actually seen it other than Marc Hume, who seems to be a reporter, not an expert in anatomy or primatology? I notice he didn't mention the elk hoofprints were old.

How many 'experts' do you think have actually examined the cast? Very few, from what I've been told.

The heel prints look nothing like elk knees to me.

I can't say I've examined elk knees up close, but what criteria was used to eliminate elk as a possible suspect?

They did concur.

Sure, once they had been convinced it was a squatch buttprint.

Not in the middle of the knee print.

Does it matter? According to the BFRO, "Old tracks in mud include elk..."

So can scepticism.

Sure, but being skeptical usually means making a decison based on evidence not speculation.

So Drs. Sarmiento and Swindler can't tell an elk imprint from a primate imprint? They're specialists, f'r Pete's sake. And Swindler was a sceptic with thirty years experience at saying "Bosh."

Which doesn't negate the fact they both might be mistaken. I wasn't there, so I can't comment on how they came to their conclusion, though it make for interesting reading.

RayG
 
Sarmiento & Swindler already knew it was a sasquatch butt imprint, didn't they?

By that, I mean they had been told what it was beforehand, and went in to the examination with knowledge of what they were supposed to see.

Did they examine the cast blind, in other words?
 
LAL said:
See my brilliant ;) defense of Freeman on BFF (I don't want to go through all that again right now) and note your article is by the ever-popular Michael Dennett who misquoted Dahinden, called Erik Beckjord a "researcher", mispelled Somer and failed to mention Freeman played a joke on the neighbors in Camas with carved feet prior to his sighting in 1984 (that was the faking of prints). Fahrenbach stated the synthetic hair was probably a natural contaminant and not an attempt at a hoax.

As was pointed out in the article I quoted:

"But by the mid-1990s only Krantz and a select few academic supporters could maintain belief in Freeman's discoveries."

Eliminating the misquote of Dahinden, doesn't eliminate the rest of the reported problems. Speaking of Dahinden, how's this quote:

http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/articles/skeptical.htm
"Look, any village idiot can see [the Mill Creek] tracks are fake, one-hundred-percent fake!"

I never mentioned anything to do with Beckjord, and I certainly don't consider him a 'researcher' either. I don't know of many bigfoot enthusiasts that DO consider him a 'researcher'. He does claim to be a bigfoot 'researcher', however.

As far as I'm concerned, Fahrenbach's past problems with hair identification render any further hair claims worthless.

RayG
 
The wallow was muddy that night. They specifically left fruit in the middle of it in order to get tracks. We know that Fish left a shoe heel print in that mud which is also in the cast. The time period that they were behind the sasquatch is probably more like 4 hours rather than 6. Note the size of the muddy hole and the fact that they put the fruit in the middle.

Note what Randles said in an Oct. 2000 Earthfiles interview:

PUTTING FRUIT OUT TO SEE ...
To see if something would walk in and leave tracks so we could get an idea of how many animals were there, if any animals were there. We already knew there was something out there because of the return vocalizations. So at about 3:30 AM September 22, I said we should put some fruit right in the middle of the wallow since it was right from where we heard the return vocalization. My friend, Leroy Fish, and I put some apples in the middle of the wallow - a muddy hole that's probably 15 feet across, a low spot so when it rains it gets full and the animals seemed to congregate there. Then we returned back to camp. We were freezing to death and went to bed.
We got up about 7:30 still on September 22 and went to check the wallow accompanied by Richard Knowle who also left fruit out. We noticed that some of the apples were gone and some of the nectarines. And then all three of us noticed at the same moment an impression where an animal had laid down. It looked like a giant human thigh. Actually, left buttock, thigh, knee area, lower leg and four heel imprints."

Meldrum in the same interview:

There were elk and deer that had walked across this puddle and mud subsequent to the impressions, so it wasn't a smooth pristine surface to begin with, before and subsequent. There are clearly footprints over the top of the impression, the body impression. In fact, there is a little trail of coyote footprints that walked right up across the back side of the impression and left their prints.

Fresh elk and deer prints on top of the sasquatch print. Not old. Subsequent to the sasquatch impressions. After the sasquatch impressions. Like an elk kneeling down to eat apples and then getting back up and leaving his hoofprints on top of his body print.

Meldrum again:

SO IT'S HAIR THAT DOESN'T QUITE MATCH PRIMATES SUCH AS GORILLA OR PRIMATES SUCH AS HUMANS?
Right. It has the greatest similarity to human hair. And at first glance, one can easily mistake it for a human hair. But there are subtle differences in the diameter of the shaft structure, the architecture and the cuticle structure that distinguish it.

They couldn't really distinguish it from human hair at all.

http://www.bfro.net/GDB/show_article.asp?id=18
 
LTC8K6 said:
Nope, it's a leg.

From the BFRO:



Elk hair and elk tracks in the cast and in the wallow.

This is clearly from an elk, and the BFRO has known it all along.

A single indeterminate hair is conveniently called a sasquatch hair. Pure irresponsible speculation to fluff up their cause.

I rest my case. :D

Don't you think you should draw some pictures first to show how an elk could fit into this?
 
LTC8K6 said:
Sarmiento & Swindler already knew it was a sasquatch butt imprint, didn't they?

By that, I mean they had been told what it was beforehand, and went in to the examination with knowledge of what they were supposed to see.

Did they examine the cast blind, in other words?

They were asked to examine it and did. I doubt either would jeopardize their reputations by making a stupid mistake like not being able to tell an elk print from an "unknown primate" print on camera.
 
No, I don't think it's from an elk alone. The "heel and tendon" is an elk's knee and leg.

It is improper to draw pictures like that anyway. It taints the audience. It makes them see what you have drawn, rather than coming to their own conclusions independently.
 
That Earthfiles interview shortly after the imprint was discovered is proof that the elk prints were not old, as has been previously claimed. They were fresh. They were made contemporaneously with the "sasquatch" imprint.

Now we know for sure that an elk was there at the time the imprint was made.

We know that the wallow was muddy that night, so there should have been bigfoot tracks.

We know that Fish left a shoe heel print in that mud as well.

Even if we accept the idea that sasquatch made the imprint, then we have the unbelievable actions of the team.

They reported return calls from a sasquatch from the area of the imprint just a day before. They have a fresh sasquatch imprint that is only hours old.

They up and leave. Inexcusable. Unexplainable. Incredible.

If they aren't really interested in bigfoot, why should I be interested. Why should science?
 
LTC8K6 said:
The wallow was muddy that night. They specifically left fruit in the middle of it in order to get tracks. We know that Fish left a shoe heel print in that mud which is also in the cast. The time period that they were behind the sasquatch is probably more like 4 hours rather than 6. Note the size of the muddy hole and the fact that they put the fruit in the middle.

Fish put fruit in. Why wouldn't he leave a heel print. Earlier you were trying to make that seem suspicious as though he was out there perpetrating a hoax with an "artificial chewing machine". But it was an elk. Oh.

Fresh elk and deer prints on top of the sasquatch print. Not old. Subsequent to the sasquatch impressions. After the sasquatch impressions. Like an elk kneeling down to eat apples and then getting back up and leaving his hoofprints on top of his body print.
No, like they walked across it.
They couldn't really distinguish it from human hair at all.
"But there are subtle differences in the diameter of the shaft structure, the architecture and the cuticle structure that distinguish it."

http://www.bfro.net/GDB/show_article.asp?id=18
 
LTC8K6 said:
That Earthfiles interview shortly after the imprint was discovered is proof that the elk prints were not old, as has been previously claimed. They were fresh. They were made contemporaneously with the "sasquatch" imprint.

One of the reporters got the day wrong. I'll have to read those again, but young or old, the elk prints were walking, not from an elk getting up.
Now we know for sure that an elk was there at the time the imprint was made.

Before or after, not at the time.
And the coyote was after.
We know that the wallow was muddy that night, so there should have been bigfoot tracks.

We know that Fish left a shoe heel print in that mud as well.
Already been addressed. Any tracks may have been obliterated when it sat down. The ground on the approach was hard, fine gravel. By a road.
Even if we accept the idea that sasquatch made the imprint, then we have the unbelievable actions of the team.

They reported return calls from a sasquatch from the area of the imprint just a day before. They have a fresh sasquatch imprint that is only hours old.

They up and leave. Inexcusable. Unexplainable. Incredible.

They weren't equipped for a capture, were they? The experience of Noll himself, as well as others, has shown attempts to track them are futile. He devised a method of luring one in and it worked.
If they aren't really interested in bigfoot, why should I be interested. Why should science?

As Dahinden once said, "My God, what do you have to show them before they'll take it seriously?"

One guy, who's never seen the cast, who's an expert at nothing, not even hoaxing, says it's an elk and you take his opinion over that of the man who wrote the standard text on primate anatomy.

Whatever.
 
Earlier you were trying to make that seem suspicious as though he was out there perpetrating a hoax with an "artificial chewing machine".

Liar. You made up the artificial chewing machine. It was entirely a construct of your mind.

No, like they walked across it.

So the elk prints were not old, as is always claimed. Here is the claim from the BFRO expedition report:

Old tracks in mud include elk, deer, bear, coyote.

Old tracks, not fresh as we now know to be the truth.


"But there are subtle differences in the diameter of the shaft structure, the architecture and the cuticle structure that distinguish it."

That is already quoted in my post. Why repeat it? It shows that they could not really distinguish it from human hair, imo.



Note that out of this (picture below) they are claiming to have come to the conclusion that a sasquatch was here. It's utterly ridiculous, imo.

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/pnw_newsletter003/images/SkookumImpressionBig.jpg
 
LTC8K6 said:
Were they told beforehand what they were looking at?

I don't know, but with Swindler's record of scepticism, it shouldn't have made any difference if they were.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Liar. You made up the artificial chewing machine. It was entirely a construct of your mind.


Excuse me? Should I look up the posts?

So the elk prints were not old, as is always claimed. Here is the claim from the BFRO expedition report:

Old tracks, not fresh as we now know to be the truth.


Do I detect a contradiction there?

That is already quoted in my post. Why repeat it? It shows that they could not really distinguish it from human hair, imo.


Because you seem to have missed it any only read what you wanted to read.

Note that out of this (picture below) they are claiming to have come to the conclusion that a sasquatch was here. It's utterly ridiculous, imo.

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/pnw_newsletter003/images/SkookumImpressionBig.jpg

Would that be your expert opinion?

I was just about to post that, but from the notes. Thanks for saving me the trouble. So you can se an elk getting up from the impression, or does it just look like a jumble to you?
 
Do I detect a contradiction there.

Yep. The BFRO's report says the elk, and other tracks were old, and Meldrum says they are fresh.

The BFRO has decided to call the elk tracks old to try to eliminate an elk as having made the marks and eaten the fruit.

Meldrum's recollection from the time reveals the truth. An elk could be what made the imprint and ate the fruit.

I am more concerned that I can't reconcile the depth shown in the cast with the depth visible in the photo. There appears to be a lot more depth in the cast than there is in the mud.
 
Btw, I am just as highly qualified an expert on bigfoot as anyone you would care to name.

Since there aren't any bigfoot experts, we are all equally qualified to pontificate on the beast.
 
RayG said:
As was pointed out in the article I quoted:

"But by the mid-1990s only Krantz and a select few academic supporters could maintain belief in Freeman's discoveries."

Well, that's not true either. Meldrum found him credible, at least mostly, and bought his cast collection for a reported $2000 (Freeman spent about $50,000 on the quest). One of those was one of the ones Chilcutt found compelling.

"Dr. Meldrum: I have secured the bulk of Freeman's collection from the Blue Mtns of Washington and Oregon. I also have the bulk of Dr. Grover Krantz's collection. In addition, many individuals have been very generous in sharing their discoveries with me and permitting me to duplicate their casts or photographs, for which I am considerably indebted. They have contributed greatly to the picture of the sasquatch foot that has emerged. Each additional specimen has the potential to add another piece to the puzzle."

http://www.oregonbigfoot.com/newsletter/01_05.php

"One of those big gaps is the lack of information about the many years of work done by the late Paul Freeman in providing a lot of what we know about the creature in question. But, Freeman is not only left out of the book, his work is utterly cast aside as being fabrications, according to Murphy. The author observes (in what he terms “a specific irreconcilable situation) the following:

“Many researchers do not give any credibility to findings by both Ivan Marx and Paul Freeman. In other words, the researchers consider such findings hoaxed or fabricated. Without doubt, Ivan Marx was a notorious practical joker and Freeman’s ‘luck’ in finding sasquatch footprints and handprints goes far beyond reason.”

In a section of his book devoted to John Green, Murphy says he has found Green “exceedingly critical and accepts absolutely nothing at face value. John is very careful where doubt is involved with people and sasquatch related evidence. He is highly uncomfortable with all findings by Ivan Marx and Paul Freeman. It is only through my insistence that some material provided by these individuals is included in this work.”

Murphy does not list these “researchers” but does have sketches of several in his otherwise fine book. There are many notables who are missing, however, and to my mind that of Paul Freeman is the most glaring. I’d like to offer some defense of the man and his many contributions to the sasquatch/bigfoot matter, a defense mostly offered by researchers. And, most of them Murphy could just as well have interviewed for his book, since he was attempting to make of it a tome which would “tell the full story of what we know about the creature…”

I’d like to refer back a few lines to where Murphy commented on the “luck” of Paul Freeman in finding so many footprints.

In one of the more definitive bigfoot books, “The Big Footprints,” the late Grover Krantz, longtime anthropology professor at Washington State University, has this revealing paragraph in a discussion of tracks found and cast by Freeman in 1984 in the mountains near Walla Walla. The tracks were unusual in that they had dermal ridges (same as fingerprints in one’s hands) a feature he felt unlikely to be there if tracks were made by a hoaxer. Here’s what Krantz had to say:

“Anyone who might have faked these tracks faced the usual problems of getting to the sites unobserved, with the equipment that not only made the footprints but also impressed them so deeply (in most cases), made each of the prints unique and showing flexible foot movements, and left no evidence of his own presence. That faker also was an expert at dermatoglyphics who was able to include the appropriate amount of absolutely accurate friction-skin detail on a reasonable number of footprints. In spite of all this, some skeptics still think that Paul Freeman was able to accomplish this feat. I think not, and raise just one more point. We might ask a simple question, if he has somehow been faking these tracks, why has never again matched the quality of the specimens that appeared in 1982?”

Several qualified researchers of the sasquatch came forward in my book, “The Walla Walla Bigfoot,” to offer further defense that Paul Freeman was not the major hoaxer some were saying, according to Murphy’s book. One of those was Henner Fahrenbach, primate reasearch biologist of Beaverton. He closes his remarks in the book with this:

“Some of the castings collected by Paul contain anatomical details that only an anatomist can appreciate after study, but not one that a layman would conjure up and convincingly introduce into fabrications. Paul may slide a bit in his recounting of specific events but that happens to everybody and that constitutes no grounds for according him the universal disdain he has been receiving. Frequency of sightings indicates that you are hanging out in the right area, which he did for years.”

Fahrenbach also came to further defense of Paul Freeman in an address at this year’s Bigfoot Symposium, held in Willow Creek, California.

Dr. Jeffrey Meldrum, a professor of anthropology at Idaho State University, who now wears the mantle of Grover Krantz in the bigfoot research in the eyes of many, had some cogent words about the matter in my book. I cite the following:

“The body of evidence (emerging from investigations of reputable researchers) includes repeat appearances of identifiable individuals over successive years.

“Examples of footprints that appear to preserve fine dermatographic details have been regarded very seriously by a number of professional fingerprint examiners.”

In this accounting of Paul Freeman and his bigfoot contributions, it should be mentioned two incidents which his detractors are pretty likely to bring up. Long before he came to Walla Walla to work for the Forest Service, Paul was living in Camas, Washington. Here, he whittled out two big feet and stomped around the neighborhood to confound the neighbors. It was a prank he acknowledged in the years following his 1982 sighting of a bigfoot in the Blue Mountains. There is also the story that he was involved in a man in a monkey suit, an incident I could easily put down as another prank or the work of a man “fed up “ with detractors."

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/record_shows.htm

[D]
Eliminating the misquote of Dahinden, doesn't eliminate the rest of the reported problems. Speaking of Dahinden, how's this quote:

http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/articles/skeptical.htm
"Look, any village idiot can see [the Mill Creek] tracks are fake, one-hundred-percent fake!"
[/D]


Pretty mild for Dahinden, I'd say. I wonder what he said that didn't make it to print. If you read the account, however, his reasons for thinking the tracks were faked seem pretty flimsy.

[D]
I never mentioned anything to do with Beckjord, and I certainly don't consider him a 'researcher' either. I don't know of many bigfoot enthusiasts that DO consider him a 'researcher'. He does claim to be a bigfoot 'researcher', however.
[/D]

Doesn't the fact that Dennett regards him as one send up a red flag? I'd double check anything Dennett says, if I were you.
According to Noll, Wes Summerlin nearly gave him a knuckle sandwich when Dennett showed up at the airport in a suit.
[D]
As far as I'm concerned, Fahrenbach's past problems with hair identification render any further hair claims worthless.
[/D]

What problems? The hairs are close to human. That's not to say they are human.

Don't read this, then:

"Contrary to popular belief, I have not encountered any deliberate effort to produce a hoax with hair samples, even in the much decried case of the fiber sample gathered by Paul Freeman. The same man-made fibers have been found elsewhere in the mountains by others and may be an environmental contaminant. People like Paul Freeman submit these samples for analysis precisely because they are not sure what they are at the time of collection.

Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach

http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/WHF/dnatests.htm
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom