LAL said:
That was only when Peter was trying to track them.
Ah, I see... no wonder he never ever saw one even after all those years.
They sign pretty well. Have you read Fouts' book - Next of Kin?
No, but I have read a lot of info concerning 'talking' apes. I've seen no evidence they're actually engaging in language as we know it.
An elk sat on its hoofprints?
Your claim, not mine. (Ok, Rick Noll's claim)
One looks clear enough for me in the photo in the field notes.
Looks can be deceiving. According to the field notes, no clear footprints were ever found during the expedition.
And Noll found some in the area prior to the expedition, didn't he? That's why they went to Skookum Meadow.
From recent postings on the BFRO website, it would appear the BFRO are not only aware of the specific areas bigfoot resides, they only lack the proper equipment to capture them on film. (If you're not aware of these claims/appeals, I can direct you to the applicable topic on the BFF)
The heat marks could have been bear or even porcupine. There was no way to determine just what they were, but they weren't from a hooved animal.
Exactly my point.
Calls, according to the story you posted.
What use are calls when no animal is observed making the calls? As I said,
absolutely no other evidence collected (or recorded) during this expedition that points to squatch as the culprit.
"While the DNA tests have not been completed, the hair samples have been determined by an independent lab to belong to an "unknown primate," Noll said.
Have these lab results been posted? If so, where?
Both the hairs and the castings have been shown to experts who are convinced that they didn't come from an elk, deer or bear."
Very few 'experts' have even examined the cast. After the initial hype, the Skookum cast seems to have faded away, no better than a cast of a footprint at this point.
It's all well and good to quote internet websites and newspaper reports, but where are the entries in the scientific journals regarding the Skookum cast?
Remember what Dr. Meldrum stated:
“While not definitively proving the existence of a species of North American ape, the cast constitutes significant and compelling new evidence that will hopefully stimulate further serious research and investigation into the presence of these primates in the Northwest mountains and elsewhere.â€
Only a handful of scientists have actually examined the Skookum cast however.
He probably was [a hair analysis expert] before he took an interest in bigfootdom.
I've not seen any evidence he was.
Such as this?
""There's where the cheeks are," he says. "And that's a heel mark and the Achilles tendon. We figure this is where its arm rested, as it turned on its side." Mr. Noll points out the fine ridges left by matted hair in the thigh -- and then points delicately to a double print between the cheeks, where the, uh, impressions were left that show this Sasquatch was male."
And:
"It's an elk!" hoots Cliff Crook, founder of Bigfoot Central, who has been tracking Sasquatches since 1956.
Everyone's entitled to an opinion. Noll can claim tiny impressions belong to tiny testicles, and Crook can claim elk kneeprints. Without a body comparison, neither claim can be proven.
Mr. Crook, however, who lives not far away in Bothell, Washington, has not bothered to see the cast for himself. "He's just jealous," says Mr. Noll, "because he's never found anything like this himself."
There are only two people Mr. Noll has
not allowed to examine the cast, Mr. Crook(who he seems to be feuding with) and Benjamin Radford(who writes for the
Skeptical Inquirer. That comes from Mr. Noll himself.
http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=2516&st=0&#entry54191
"I have turned down only two people in coming to see the cast... Cliff Crook and Benjamin Radford."
Didn't you say other statements ring true?
Yes, and they agree with my own opinion.
Who besides Crook thinks it's a elk? Anyone who's actually seen it other than Marc Hume, who seems to be a reporter, not an expert in anatomy or primatology? I notice he didn't mention the elk hoofprints were old.
How many 'experts' do you think have actually examined the cast? Very few, from what I've been told.
The heel prints look nothing like elk knees to me.
I can't say I've examined elk knees up close, but what criteria was used to eliminate elk as a possible suspect?
Sure, once they had been convinced it was a squatch buttprint.
Not in the middle of the knee print.
Does it matter? According to the BFRO,
"Old tracks in mud include elk..."
Sure, but being skeptical usually means making a decison based on evidence not speculation.
So Drs. Sarmiento and Swindler can't tell an elk imprint from a primate imprint? They're specialists, f'r Pete's sake. And Swindler was a sceptic with thirty years experience at saying "Bosh."
Which doesn't negate the fact they both might be mistaken. I wasn't there, so I can't comment on
how they came to their conclusion, though it make for interesting reading.
RayG