Bigfoot - serious, not follies

LAL said:
With Lonnie Somers.

When was this? Link/source?

Didn't the Arizona expedition find some tracks?

If you're talking about the October 2002 one, no squatch tracks were found.

http://www.bfro.net/avevid/nelson/Chuska.asp
"Up into the little valley a ways, just ahead of us we spotted some very interesting looking tracks in the loose soil of one of the tire tracks. Reid stopped the truck and we jumped out. Bear!...With one bear track find we fell well short of the effort required to find a sasquatch track."


No, it was only an analogy. There are many such analogies:

"The only teaching organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery" because someone's high school teacher tags along/is a member.

"The only law enforcement organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery" because a retired detective tags along/is a member.

"The only religious organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery" because a Catholic tags along/is a member.

etc. etc.

That sounds better.

I don't think so. (see the above analogies for my reasoning)

Naïve of them, wasn't it?

Highly unscientific if you ask me.

I can't imagine why.

Neither can I. He's quick to take his ball and go home if people don't agree with him.

RayG
 
LAL said:
Do the testicle prints help? (Tries to imagine testicles on an elk's chest................)

They got his dingle-berries too? How'd they get a match for that?

I'm not finding the thread in 79 pages of your posts yet, but I'm enjoying your NW Coast Indian lore and thoughts on the PGF.

Hope you're also finding that I'm not an unreasonable skeptic. :D

RayG
 
LAL said:
Chris Stringer is a Merit Researcher on hominids in the Department of Palaeontology at the Natural History Museum, London, and he's written a recent book (where he no doubt states the consensus is that bipedalism came first and k-w was a later adaptation in the Great Apes ;) ):

http://www.newscientist.com/channel/being-human/mg18625042.300

Waters doesn't seem to be well-known in this country, but he posted some interesting stuff. Did you read more of his posts on the newsgroup?

I have no trouble finding info on Stringer, just can't find the article where he speculates that bipedalism predates knucle-walking.

As for Waters, I can't find ANY info on him other than he authored the book Helpless as a Baby, though I can find no record of it on amazon.com.

RayG
 
Well, this seems to be a good enough explanation on the tracks:

"The "easiest" explanation for a Sasquatch to have made the Skookum imprint and not leave any footprints was for it to have approached the muddy area from the dry side, straight out of the woods, walk a little ways into the mud (which may have been more solid in the very cold weather that morning), sit on it's own foot tracks (if there were any), do whatever it did, roll away from the mud and get up to walk back the way it came, across that dry, hard rocky soil. Not thinking a damn thing about weather or not it was making tracks, a body impression or that it just got mud on itself. I don't know why it would of rolled to the dry side of things, that's just the way it looks."

He was there and we weren't.
 
RayG said:
I have no trouble finding info on Stringer, just can't find the article where he speculates that bipedalism predates knucle-walking.

I can't either. I'm thinking the article may have been regarding "Kadabba"or Orrorin or even "Toumai", but I'm not sure. It's been too long since I used it. He only stated what I said he stated about the consensus. He didn't speculate and he didn't write it. He was quoted.

The fossil record seems to be bearing this out, in any event. David Kreger e-mailed me that not all agreed with Richmond and Strait's conclusions. I know I found the article quoting Stringer after that and it surprised me. So, if I can remember when instead of what, I may still be able to find it. The articles are saved in the order I found them in general catagories. It's not like I have the sense to save them alphabetically or retitle them, or anything.

Still looking.

As for Waters, I can't find ANY info on him other than he authored the book Helpless as a Baby, though I can find no record of it on amazon.com.

RayG

And the link doesn't work.
The aquisitions librarian at the local library is British. So far she's filled every request of mine as long as it's from England.
 
LAL said:
Well, this seems to be a good enough explanation on the tracks:

That's the problem, there weren't any.

"The "easiest" explanation for a Sasquatch to have made the Skookum imprint and not leave any footprints was for it to have approached the muddy area from the dry side, straight out of the woods, walk a little ways into the mud (which may have been more solid in the very cold weather that morning), sit on it's own foot tracks (if there were any), do whatever it did, roll away from the mud and get up to walk back the way it came, across that dry, hard rocky soil. Not thinking a damn thing about weather or not it was making tracks, a body impression or that it just got mud on itself. I don't know why it would of rolled to the dry side of things, that's just the way it looks."

The scenario suggests the squatch must have given a great deal of thought to not leaving tracks. To my knowledge the speculated behavior has never been witnessed before, nor since. All other times it seems to have little regard for leaving footprints, why the sudden change?

RayG
 
LAL said:
What makes you think all the films are "fuzzy blotches" ? Which ones have you seen? Do you think they're all of "guys in suits" and that there really is an army of hoaxers out there faking all this stuff?

The films, the photograms, all that´s been shown at TV and WWW. There´s no need for an "army of" hoaxers. A few of them, acting indenpendently could do a lot of things.

LAL said:
If Giganto is a relative, there are fossils of a close relative.
It doesn't hurt it. There's not much to say they're closely related to Orangutans, either.

IF its a relative to bigfoot. And that´s all that it is. And if its a relative to orang-utang, then it does hurt.

LAL said:
Why are you dragging "Bigfoot" into Olduvai? The point was that even knowing they were in a likely spot for hominid fossils, it still took a long time for any to be found.

It's possible Sasquatches evolved from an Australopith, but even those were few and far between in the area.

You dragged it to Africa, since you are using the temporal distribution of hominids there as an excuse for the absence of bigfoot fossils. I am pointing out that the area where its fossils could be found is much bigger, due to the species' geographic distributions.

Note that, on purpose, I am not considering its "tropical equivalents" in Southern Asia, the hairy wildmen (woodwoose) from mediaeval Great Britain (and its European equivalents) and the (sadly distorted) mapinguari legend from Brazil.

LAL said:
...snip...
There's evidence from Canada, but, again the environment is wet with acid soils. I'm not finding anything about fossils of forest animals of any kind from these areas. Help me out, here.

See discussions below.
LAL said:
Can we please leave Loch Ness and UFO's out of this? I'm really tired of them being lumped together.

That´s really hard, since the type of evidence currently avaliable for Nessie and bigfoot are quite similar. That´s why I asked you where and how you draw the line between a plausibe crypto (bigfoot) and an unlikely one (Nessie)? What are the criteria for unlumping them together?

LAL said:
I know how that works.

It was a thousand miles wide.
...snip...
"The distance across the Bering Strait from Siberia to Alaska's Seward Peninsula is approximately 55 miles, and for several periods during the Pleistocene Ice Ages the trip could be made entirely on land instead of water."

OK, then you understand the animals must have not only crossed but lived in open-field environments. Thus it is not far-fetched to suppose their fossils could be found with fossils from animals that lived all their lives in open-field environments. Not to mention the transitional environments.

LAL said:
If Bryne is correct that they can cover twenty-five miles in a night, they'd only need to a couple of nights to cross.

Forests, or at least stands of Spruce, Poplar, etc., grew much farther north than they do now and the climate was much milder.

The Powder Mountain tracks go from stand to stand of Balsam. The animal was after berries.

Again if Bryne is correct[/i]. Note that a basic requisite for it is that tha animal must exist. What is far from being proved.

What, once again, would favor preservation of remains.

If the tracks were correctly interpreted...

LAL said:
Fossils of new species are found just about daily, aren't they, especially in China. Of course, I wouldn't expect many mammalian fossils in strata that yeild dinosaurs, would you?

Many, of course not, but some, yes. China´s Sinodelphys szalayi is 125M old.

But you seem to have missed my point. What I am arguing is that the same type of phenomena that allowed the preservation of those -and many other- animals would as well alow the preservation of bigfoot remains. What you see happening today is what happened 1, 1ky, 1My or 1Gy ago. So, all those events, such as flash or slower-paced floods, are potentially events that may start the fossilization proccess.
Turkana boy,as you cited, was one among many specimens of countless species that died near a lake or a marsh, possibly due to disease, and was preserved.
Common scene: river level increases seadly due to rainy season. Animals trapped at higer sites try to cross the flooded area to reach a safer -or with more food- place, drown and become fossils. Like this, there are many other possible scenarios, and they happen in forests, open fields and intermediate environments.

LAL said:
I didn't say they were. If these conditions, found in many places in the world, past and present, are so good at preserving fossils, why are there still so few? A. afarensis may be the best represented ancient hominid with fragmentary remains of over 300 individuals, but there's only one 40% complete skelton. The species was unknown prior to 1974.

...snip...

First, define "few". Even with just a 40% complete skeleton, I would not say 300 individuals is a small number. Not to mention that the remains are scattered over Africa. This provides you a good example of why I, and a lot of other people, would expect such a species to have left traces. Somewhere in North America and Asia specimens should have surfaced, even with a small population density, for the reasons we have already discussed..

LAL said:
Good question. Not found yet? Might there not be some evidence submerged along with evidence for humans crossing the Bering Strait?

Why just there? And all the other places? And have you forgot what I told you about the evidence found in sediment dragged from the (nowdays submerged) areas in Alaska and the land bridge?

LAL said:
Yep. The PNW isn't known for it's limestone caves. I'm not stupid.

Who said you are stupid?

LAL said:
I don't.

I'm saying fossil remains of forest dwelling animals are rare at best. I lived in the PNW and know it better than these other areas. Some of the best evidence comes from there.

What, again, does not mean the fossil evidence must come just from there. So, can we say we agree at least with this?

LAL said:
Caves in Skamania County are lava tubes. No limestone caves in that area.

Which limestone caves would be most likely to have Sasquatch fossils? Oregon Caves (no fossils found there until 1995-Jaguar and Grizzly aren't forest-dwellers, are they?)? Mammoth? Luray? Shenendoah? Carlsbad?

Jaguars live in forests, don´t they? I´ve seen some of them - beautifull creatures- in forests. To hear their screams, calls, growls, whatever, at night is quite an experience.

Grizzly bears also do live in forests and mixed open-field forest pacthes environments.
http://www.canadianrockies.net/Grizzly/habitat.html
http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hre/topics/grizzly.htm
http://greennature.com/article137.html

Do we agree on the above statements?
Now, with this settled, let´s move to your next question:

LAL said:
What makes you think Sasquatches spend much time hanging out in caves?

Nothing. I´ll then ask you:

Why do you think the fossil record of caves is so nice? All the animals whose fossils were found in caves spent much time hanging out there?

What happens is that caves are natural water and humidity sources. Animals are attracted to them during dry periods. Weakened, victims of a fall, or just lost in the darkness, they commonly die there. Some just fall inside sinkholes hidden by vegetation. Also, some cave entrances act as "natural sinks". During strong rains, water running over the surface carries a lot of loose material to the cave, sediments, dead leaves, twigs, loose bones and carcasses.

If I recall correctly, that´s one of the possible reasons for hominid fossils in caves in Africa. The events chain would have been something like this: leopard kills hominid, carries body to the top of a tree, remains fall to the ground, are washed away by rain to a cave, humans find, hundreds of Ky later, the skull -with leopard´s teeth marks included.

So animal species don´t even need to have as part of its habits to take temporary shelter at a cave to become fossilized inside one.

Why I have insisted on the limestone cave? Not only because they are much more common than lava tubes or quartzite caves, but because the constant precipitation of carbonate inside them helps a lot the fossilization.

So, see now why it is not far-fetched to suppose bigfoot remains could be found inside a cave? Even if they don´t spend much time there?

Do we agree on that?

*Wishes that LAL will not say the conditions are appliable only to Africa*

LAL said:
Wrong habitat, again. I don't think you'll find much overlap with horses and caribou. Wapiti, maybe.

See above notes...

W
LAL said:
e don't really know what they're related to, do we, or when they may have migrated?

No, specially because there´s no solid evidence they exist. But, assuming they exist... It really does not matter if they are related to some hominid, if they are great apes that evolved to bipedalism or squirrels that evolved to look as giant hominids. Neither if they migrated at the first or last intervall when the land bridge was exposed.

What matters is the absence of fossil specimens that can be related to it within its present and past geographic span.

Do we agree its an issue?

Correa Neto[/i] [B]Oh... The footprints. Other people are already discussing this issue. Yes said:
'Bout time.

Got you!

LAL said:
...snip...
When a hard-headed deputy like Rod Bevins says that was no bear, you can bet that was no bear.

I´m hard-headed (no, I´m no deputy) and I can be mistaken. Every single human being can be mistaken.

Do we agree on that?

LAL said:
Illusions don't leave tracks.

...snip....

But tracks can be misinterpretated, can´t they?
Do we agree on that?

LAL said:
There's hardly a trace of humans doing the same, but we know they did. No non-stop required, just a small population of a cold-adapted species spreading east from Russia over the land bridge sometime between ice ages.

There are evidence for human migration. Campsites, remains, at several places along the path, from Asia to North America, extending towards South America!

Ah, so we agree that the species must have spreaded rather than migrated. Progressively expanding its habitat to include Russia, Asias´s eastern coast, Alaska, Canada and USA. What leaves us with a lot of places to find fossil evidence...

Correa Neto said:
Well, there are several remains of humans in Africa and Asia recording the habitat expansion, whose ages fit well. Note that population estimates for this time generally are of the magnitue order of 100K individuals. And, have you read the news on the recent find in Mexico? Ever read about Luzia?

LAL said:
No. Fill me in.

Quick summary:

The skull of a woman (nicknamed Luzia) was found at Lagoa Santa cave, Soutehrn Brazil. It dates between 8.8Ky to 10.7Ky. Facial reconstructions indicate she may have been linked with modern Australians and Africans. Dating matches with Monte Verde site at Chile, as well as the Baja skull, for example.
http://www.utexas.edu/courses/stross/ant322m_files/1stpersons.htm
http://www.ngnews.com/news/2003/09/0903_030903_bajaskull.html
http://www1.folha.uol.com.br/folha/ciencia/ult306u13144.shtml (in portuguese)

And 30ky-old human footprints were found at tuff layers deposited nearby a lake (funny coincidence, eh?) in Mexico.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/4650307.stm

So, we do have evidence on the human habitat expansion. Not only of the younger one, that brought the people that nowdays compose amerindians, but also of a previous wave.

Correa Neto said:
And where are bigfeet´s remains?

LAL said:
Out in the forest somewhere being scavenged as we speak.

All of them? Every single individual since the species appeared? At all the places where it lives(ed)?

Correa Neto said:
Well, that primate was a bit different from a bigfoot, wasn´t it?


LAL said:
Without question. And only one molar found? There must have been more.

But it was found! Any bigfeet molar avaliable?

LAL said:
Are there any other primate finds from North America? Monkeys got to South America somehow. Where are all the monkey fossils between New York and Puerto Rico?

Who said they had to pass through North America?

LAL said:
Or the migrated through what is now the arctic from Europe or Asia circa 20 mya.

I've seen the rafting idea for the Yowie, not for Bigfoot.

Maybe bigfeet evolved from yowies...

LAL said:
.....like Gorillas and Chimpanzees seems to have no fossil record that we know of at this time.

But we have fossil remains of species that are related to them.

LAL said:
The record of whales and horses are the most complete, but not every single species is known. Feathers may have evolved from scutes. Didn't I mention I have about 300 saved sites on human evolution alone? I actually managed to learn something during two years of debates on evolution, though I'm not totally clear on the new terminology and may have used the term "hominoid" (as opposed to "hominid") incorrectly at times.

Then you know that the creationist´s arguments on "where are the intermediate forms" is bogus. And that any versions of it can not be used to support the idea that bigfeet (and bigfeet-related species) fossil remains are not known just due to the nature of fossil record. Even if in a sarcastic way.

Sure, there´s a chance that someday the fossil of a big anthropoid will be found in North America, but I will not hold my breath.

LAL said:
In fact, I found that out Googling on biodiversity preserves (there's one in the Great Smokies) before I ever left Washington State.

"Perhaps of more interest to visitors today is the other half of the mountain-building story, their gradual destruction. The slow, steady forces of wind, water, and chemical decomposition have reduced the Blue Ridge from Sierra-like proportions to the low profile of the world's oldest mountain range."

http://www.nps.gov/blri/geology.htm

That's on the official National Park Service, Department of the Interior, site.

http://www.nps.gov/

Tourist info.

]Just how are we measuring "oldest"? Oldest rocks? Longest time above sea level?

In both cases, Appalaches will not be among the oldest of the world.

To sum things up, you could say the age of a mountain chain is determined by the age its formation started. The rocks that compose the chain, can be older of of the same age of the chain. New rocks are formed during orogenesis (mountain formation process by collisional tectonics, when two or more plates collide- the case of Appalaches) by igneous activity and metamorphism.

Time above sea level is not a good index by two reasons:

(a) Some orogenic mountain chains have parts of it below the sea level;

(b) Orogenetic areas suffer a lot of uplift (during and after the orogenesis), so weathering and erosion act, denudating the mountains and gradually exposing the mountain belt´s lowemost level. So, rocks that once were very below sea level (tens of thousands of meters) may now be thousands of meter above it.

So, you have to reffer to the starting age of mountain formation.

And in this case, the Appalaches are quite young. Note that we are talking of a 4.5Gy-old story of geologic events. Here´s the ages of some major orogenetic events: 550Ma, 1.1 Gy, 1.7 Gy, 2.1Gy, 2.7Gy. Ages do have a span, that change according to the place in the world the events happened.

But that´s OT digression. Shall we move on?

LAL said:
Imaginary creatures don't leave tracks and sign. Hm. Maybe I should put that in my sig line so I don't have to keep typing it out.
Sorry you're so bored. You might find this more interesting if you'd do a little research. There are some good books on the subject.

Maybe it would also be a good idea to add that tracks can be misidentified.

Would you please avoid accusing me of not knowing what I´m talking about? I once did though bigfoot was a possibility. Then I started to realize, as I learned more about nature, how unlikely it is. I have done my homework and will not even bother bragging about it. I have not read anything that would bring me back to my initial position.

LAL said:
And hominids. It may be the last common ancestor or something very near to it.
They're related to humans, other hominids and Great Apes too, so there are your relatives. Thanks for pointing that out.

And left remains. And bigfeet? Where are the remains that could point to the possibility of a large primate in North America?
 
RayG said:
That's the problem, there weren't any.



The scenario suggests the squatch must have given a great deal of thought to not leaving tracks. To my knowledge the speculated behavior has never been witnessed before, nor since. All other times it seems to have little regard for leaving footprints, why the sudden change?

RayG

Did you see the photo showing the road?
Noll has photos of Gorillas doing the same sort of lean.

Bryne thought they might conceal tracks and he told me that at least three years before the cast was taken.

Chimpanzees have been observed purposely leaving tracks for the troop to follow. Maybe there is some behavior associated with tracks in the Great Apes (such as not leaving tracks when they don't want to be followed).

I don't see that any thought was required if it came up the road and then stepped on the fine gravel. Could have just happened that way.
 
LAL said:
Did you see the photo showing the road?

Not sure I see a connection.

Noll has photos of Gorillas doing the same sort of lean.

Gorilla ain't no squatch.

Bryne thought they might conceal tracks and he told me that at least three years before the cast was taken.

Sounds like Bryne might have been speculating.

Chimpanzees have been observed purposely leaving tracks for the troop to follow. Maybe there is some behavior associated with tracks in the Great Apes (such as not leaving tracks when they don't want to be followed).

And maybe there isn't. Chimps ain't no squatch.

I don't see that any thought was required if it came up the road and then stepped on the fine gravel. Could have just happened that way.

I'm talking about the purposeful care at not leaving any footprints in any area of the mud, the 'several heel strikes' as it positioned itself closer to the fruit without leaving any clear evidence. If the squatch engaged in crawling behavior it was obviously concerned about leaving footprints behind, or the depth of the mud, or both. It was presented with a problem (fruit in the middle of the mudhole) and had to formulate a plan to obtain the fruit while minimizing its presence.

Is it possible? Sure, but I'm not convinced that elk have been eliminated as the source of the 'heel' print. In fact, there wasn't a single additional scrap of evidence that supports the squatch hypothesis.

RayG
 
Correa Neto said:
The films, the photograms, all that´s been shown at TV and WWW. There´s no need for an "army of" hoaxers. A few of them, acting indenpendently could do a lot of things.


Such as fake footprints in 1958, and three times in two countries in April, 2005? With a whole lotta hoaxing in between? In remote areas where all this handiwork wasn't likely to be found?

IF its a relative to bigfoot. And that´s all that it is. And if its a relative to orang-utang, then it does hurt.


Depends on whether it was bipedal or not, doesn't it?

You dragged it to Africa, since you are using the temporal distribution of hominids there as an excuse for the absence of bigfoot fossils. I am pointing out that the area where its fossils could be found is much bigger, due to the species' geographic distributions.


Homo erectus lived from 1.8 million years to 300,000 ago and was very widespread, yet remains of only about 40 individuals from two or three locations (according to the Smithsonian's rather out-of-date website) have been found. The population must have numbered in the millions, yet only one boy managed to die in such a way that his nearly complete skeleton could be found at Lake Turkana.

Note that, on purpose, I am not considering its "tropical equivalents" in Southern Asia, the hairy wildmen (woodwoose) from mediaeval Great Britain (and its European equivalents) and the (sadly distorted) mapinguari legend from Brazil.


Good idea.

See discussions below.


Thanks.

That´s really hard, since the type of evidence currently avaliable for Nessie and bigfoot are quite similar. That´s why I asked you where and how you draw the line between a plausibe crypto (bigfoot) and an unlikely one (Nessie)? What are the criteria for unlumping them together?


Loch Ness was scanned, wasn't it? No Nessie. Last I heard it was thought a school of Dolphins could account for sightings in the loch. I don't know how the photo of the flipper is explained............

OK, then you understand the animals must have not only crossed but lived in open-field environments.


No, I don't. If they followed the coast, in search of fish, perhaps, and the forests were more northerly and the Strait not all grassland and tundra and the climate milder they need not have been in the open much at all.

Thus it is not far-fetched to suppose their fossils could be found with fossils from animals that lived all their lives in open-field environments. Not to mention the transitional environments.


Except that there's no evidence they live anywhere but in forests.

Again if Bryne is correct. Note that a basic requisite for it is that tha animal must exist. What is far from being proved.


It's far from being proved that it doesn't. :D
You can probably figure out from the stride how many miles a day they could cover.

What, once again, would favor preservation of remains.


Rapid burial, for one thing.

If the tracks were correctly interpreted...


It's hard to confuse a giant hominid track with anything else. I have copies of the Bossburg casts (they're not as large as Closner's cast, but they're still impressive). The deformity is consistent with metatarsus adductus. It's difficult to imagine a hoaxer, in 1969, being able to lay down 1089 tracks overnight with such a deformity. Tracks like that were seen 30 years earlier, incidently.

Is this one or two of the same few hoaxers? Why did they only do this in '69? Why not repeat the stunt rather than waste a perfectly good pair of fake feet that were good enough to fool a professor of anatomy. Why not just use the feet from Bluff Creek........one set, anyway?

Many, of course not, but some, yes. China´s Sinodelphys szalayi is 125M old.

But you seem to have missed my point. What I am arguing is that the same type of phenomena that allowed the preservation of those -and many other- animals would as well alow the preservation of bigfoot remains. What you see happening today is what happened 1, 1ky, 1My or 1Gy ago. So, all those events, such as flash or slower-paced floods, are potentially events that may start the fossilization proccess.
Turkana boy,as you cited, was one among many specimens of countless species that died near a lake or a marsh, possibly due to disease, and was preserved.
Common scene: river level increases seadly due to rainy season. Animals trapped at higer sites try to cross the flooded area to reach a safer -or with more food- place, drown and become fossils. Like this, there are many other possible scenarios, and they happen in forests, open fields and intermediate environments.


You're not saying everything that drowns in a flood becomes a fossil are you? That would only be a first step. Siltation is pretty light in areas like the PNW.

First, define "few". Even with just a 40% complete skeleton, I would not say 300 individuals is a small number. Not to mention that the remains are scattered over Africa.


???????????? Afarensis remains have been found along East Africa's Northern Rift Valley at Hadar and Koobi Flora with the trackway at Laetoli.
The fossils are mostly fragments.
http://www.msu.edu/~heslipst/contents/ANP440/afarensis.htm

This provides you a good example of why I, and a lot of other people, would expect such a species to have left traces. Somewhere in North America and Asia specimens should have surfaced, even with a small population density, for the reasons we have already discussed.


A lack of fossils does not mean the species does not exist. It only means no fossils have been found so far. It could be there are none, but Sasquatches are certainly not the only living animals lacking a fossil record.

Why just there? And all the other places? And have you forgot what I told you about the evidence found in sediment dragged from the (nowdays submerged) areas in Alaska and the land bridge?


There may be evidence of humans 40,000 years ago. Where are all the human remains from that period?

What, again, does not mean the fossil evidence must come just from there. So, can we say we agree at least with this?

Jaguars live in forests, don´t they? I´ve seen some of them - beautifull creatures- in forests. To hear their screams, calls, growls, whatever, at night is quite an experience.

Grizzly bears also do live in forests and mixed open-field forest pacthes environments.
http://www.canadianrockies.net/Grizzly/habitat.html
http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hre/topics/grizzly.htm
http://greennature.com/article137.html

Do we agree on the above statements?


Jaguars live in both forest and savannahs. Their diet is unlike that of Sasquatches and they're not related, are they?
No Grizzlies in the forests of the PNW. They may be in the North Cascades, I've been told, but that's pretty far inland and much drier.
It appears Sasquatches don't overlap with Grizzlies and Jaguars. Your point?

Why do you think the fossil record of caves is so nice? All the animals whose fossils were found in caves spent much time hanging out there?

What happens is that caves are natural water and humidity sources. Animals are attracted to them during dry periods.


Western Washington doesn't have dry periods.

Weakened, victims of a fall, or just lost in the darkness, they commonly die there. Some just fall inside sinkholes hidden by vegetation. Also, some cave entrances act as "natural sinks". During strong rains, water running over the surface carries a lot of loose material to the cave, sediments, dead leaves, twigs, loose bones and carcasses.

If I recall correctly, that´s one of the possible reasons for hominid fossils in caves in Africa. The events chain would have been something like this: leopard kills hominid, carries body to the top of a tree, remains fall to the ground, are washed away by rain to a cave, humans find, hundreds of Ky later, the skull -with leopard´s teeth marks included.

So animal species don´t even need to have as part of its habits to take temporary shelter at a cave to become fossilized inside one.

Why I have insisted on the limestone cave? Not only because they are much more common than lava tubes or quartzite caves, but because the constant precipitation of carbonate inside them helps a lot the fossilization.


To my knowlege, the limestone caves in the PNW are nowhere near the mountains. The area's volcanic. No limestone caves.
The PNW seems to have the largest Sasquatch population, based on reports.

So, see now why it is not far-fetched to suppose bigfoot remains could be found inside a cave? Even if they don´t spend much time there?

Do we agree on that?


Not until you can show me a limestone cave on Mt. St. Helens.

Apes Caves on Mt. St. Helens are lava tubes....not too good for preservation. Bears would tend to exploit caves in the area and bears scavenge. If the nocturnal behavior has to do with avoiding bears, they may avoid places where bears hang out (or hibernate) such as caves.

*Wishes that LAL will not say the conditions are appliable only to Africa*


The thought would never occur to me. However, I'm having difficulty imagining an African leopard in the PNW dropping a Sasquatch into a sinkhole, which seem to occur in the Southeast, not in the NW.

No, specially because there´s no solid evidence they exist.


Those casts are pretty solid.

But, assuming they exist... It really does not matter if they are related to some hominid, if they are great apes that evolved to bipedalism or squirrels that evolved to look as giant hominids. Neither if they migrated at the first or last intervall when the land bridge was exposed.

What matters is the absence of fossil specimens that can be related to it within its present and past geographic span.

Do we agree its an issue?


If we agreed we wouldn't be having this debate. I don't see that it's a problem given the habitat and the lack of leopards and limestone caves. Cougars feed on the ground, I believe.
What about the new mammals found in Viet Nam? Is there a fossil record for them?


:D)

I´m hard-headed (no, I´m no deputy) and I can be mistaken. Every single human being can be mistaken.

Do we agree on that?



Sure. But that doesn't mean thousands of track events are all cases of mistaken identity. Or that all the sightings are, or that the films are of bipedal bears.

But tracks can be misinterpretated, can´t they?
Do we agree on that?


That's one of the first things looked for, i.e. could they be overlaid bear tracks? No claw marks, for one thing.

There are evidence for human migration. Campsites, remains, at several places along the path, from Asia to North America, extending towards South America!


Such as where the mammoths were plentiful?

Ah, so we agree that the species must have spreaded rather than migrated. Progressively expanding its habitat to include Russia, Asias´s eastern coast, Alaska, Canada and USA. What leaves us with a lot of places to find fossil evidence...


Except for the in the forests.

Quick summary:

The skull of a woman (nicknamed Luzia) was found at Lagoa Santa cave, Soutehrn Brazil. It dates between 8.8Ky to 10.7Ky. Facial reconstructions indicate she may have been linked with modern Australians and Africans. Dating matches with Monte Verde site at Chile, as well as the Baja skull, for example.
http://www.utexas.edu/courses/stross/ant322m_files/1stpersons.htm
http://www.ngnews.com/news/2003/09/0903_030903_bajaskull.html
http://www1.folha.uol.com.br/folha/ciencia/ult306u13144.shtml (in portuguese)

And 30ky-old human footprints were found at tuff layers deposited nearby a lake (funny coincidence, eh?) in Mexico.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/4650307.stm

So, we do have evidence on the human habitat expansion. Not only of the younger one, that brought the people that nowdays compose amerindians, but also of a previous wave.


That's interesting.

But no human remains on the Bering Strait?

There's a human print in a lava flow somewhere in Washington. I hate to think what happened to the foot.
I don't know of any Sasquatch reports from Mexico.

All of them? Every single individual since the species appeared? At all the places where it lives(ed)?

Why not? It seems to have happened with Gorillas and Chimps and a couple of million years worth of "seed" apes.

But it was found! Any bigfeet molar avaliable?


If it were, the scofftics would say it was planted and belonged to a elk.

Who said they had to pass through North America?

Maybe bigfeet evolved from yowies...


There's a problem of how Yowies, if they exist, got to Australia.
If Sasquatches are closely related to the Russian Kaptar, it seems more likely they took the northern route, especially since they don't seem to have a talent for raft-building. ;)

But we have fossil remains of species that are related to them.


And we may have fossil evidence of a species related to Sasquatches as well.

Then you know that the creationist´s arguments on "where are the intermediate forms" is bogus. And that any versions of it can not be used to support the idea that bigfeet (and bigfeet-related species) fossil remains are not known just due to the nature of fossil record. Even if in a sarcastic way.



Punc Ec.
Didn't I mention I spent a couple of years debating Creationists........and posting lists of transitional fossils?

Sure, there´s a chance that someday the fossil of a big anthropoid will be found in North America, but I will not hold my breath.


There's a better chance of a live one being brought in.

In both cases, Appalaches will not be among the oldest of the world.


That's "Appalachians". They're the oldest on the continent and among the oldest in the world. If they're not the oldest, the NPS is wrong. I've found several sites that say they're among the oldest in the world.

To sum things up, you could say the age of a mountain chain is determined by the age its formation started. The rocks that compose the chain, can be older of of the same age of the chain. New rocks are formed during orogenesis (mountain formation process by collisional tectonics, when two or more plates collide- the case of Appalaches) by igneous activity and metamorphism.

Time above sea level is not a good index by two reasons:

(a) Some orogenic mountain chains have parts of it below the sea level;

(b) Orogenetic areas suffer a lot of uplift (during and after the orogenesis), so weathering and erosion act, denudating the mountains and gradually exposing the mountain belt´s lowemost level. So, rocks that once were very below sea level (tens of thousands of meters) may now be thousands of meter above it.

So, you have to reffer to the starting age of mountain formation.

And in this case, the Appalaches are quite young. Note that we are talking of a 4.5Gy-old story of geologic events. Here´s the ages of some major orogenetic events: 550Ma, 1.1 Gy, 1.7 Gy, 2.1Gy, 2.7Gy. Ages do have a span, that change according to the place in the world the events happened.

But that´s OT digression. Shall we move on?



Sure.

Maybe it would also be a good idea to add that tracks can be misidentified.


I've already covered that.

Would you please avoid accusing me of not knowing what I´m talking about? I once did though bigfoot was a possibility. Then I started to realize, as I learned more about nature, how unlikely it is. I have done my homework and will not even bother bragging about it. I have not read anything that would bring me back to my initial position.


Then you have read Krantz? What, specifically, did you find wrong with his methodology and/or conclusions? I would not consider listing your sources "bragging about it".

Funny, as I learned more about nature I realized how likely they are, especially after moving into a forest near the Gifford Pinchot.

And left remains. And bigfeet? Where are the remains that could point to the possibility of a large primate in North America?
None found yet, but that doesn't negate the evidence that they're alive and well and living in North America.
 
RayG said:
Not sure I see a connection.
Gorilla ain't no squatch.


True, but sitting and leaning to reach food doesn't seem to be unusual behavior for apes.

Sounds like Bryne might have been speculating.


He spent years trying to track them and thought they might possibly be smart enough to hide "the one thing that could lead us to them".

And maybe there isn't. Chimps ain't no squatch.


No, but if a Chimp is aware of its tracks, might not other apes be too?

I'm talking about the purposeful care at not leaving any footprints in any area of the mud, the 'several heel strikes' as it positioned itself closer to the fruit without leaving any clear evidence. If the squatch engaged in crawling behavior it was obviously concerned about leaving footprints behind, or the depth of the mud, or both. It was presented with a problem (fruit in the middle of the mudhole) and had to formulate a plan to obtain the fruit while minimizing its presence.


It might just have been wary about aproaching the fruit (other bait had been taken, but it's not known what took it) and was completely unmindful of tracks. Maybe they don't enjoy sinking in mud. And, as Noll suggested, it may have obliterated tracks just by sitting on them.

Is it possible? Sure, but I'm not convinced that elk have been eliminated as the source of the 'heel' print. In fact, there wasn't a single additional scrap of evidence that supports the squatch hypothesis.


Except for tracks found earlier in the area, heat prints that couldn't have been from a hooved animal, a history of sightings in the county, hair of an "unknown primate" in the imprint, a forearm mark with long hair print clearly visible (remember the MD footage?).

Are the heel strikes supposed to be from elk knees too?

How would an elk get up without leaving clear hoofprints in the middle of the imprint?

And don't you think the expedition members were smart enough to figure all this out before hauling about 350 lbs. of cast back to civilization?
 
LAL said:

True, but sitting and leaning to reach food doesn't seem to be unusual behavior for apes. [/B]

Not surprising at all if you have very short legs and are used to sitting on your haunches.

Gorilla%20medium.jpg


He spent years trying to track them and thought they might possibly be smart enough to hide "the one thing that could lead us to them".

If thousands of tracks have been found they don't appear to be very successful at hiding them.

No, but if a Chimp is aware of its tracks, might not other apes be too?

Careful, next thing ya know chimps will be 'thinking' and gorillas will be 'talking' (Koko, Washoe, etc. etc.)

It might just have been wary about aproaching the fruit (other bait had been taken, but it's not known what took it) and was completely unmindful of tracks. Maybe they don't enjoy sinking in mud. And, as Noll suggested, it may have obliterated tracks just by sitting on them.

Or it might not be a squatch to begin with.

Except for tracks found earlier in the area,

Not during the expedition. I've never seen any evidence that a clear footprint was ever found.

heat prints that couldn't have been from a hooved animal,

Don't forget an original statement from the BFRO: "Old tracks in mud include elk, deer, bear, coyote..."

Bears don't have hooves, nor do cougars, wolves, coyotes..etc. etc.

a history of sightings in the county,

No sighting of a squatch during this expedition, absolutely no other evidence collected during this expedition that points to squatch as the culprit.

hair of an "unknown primate" in the imprint,

Got a source for that? From what I read they have a single hair that they couldn't distinguish from human. I don't see where the BFRO is claiming to have found an "unknown primate" hair, but I might be looking in the wrong place.

http://www.bfro.net/news/bodycast/ISU_press_rel_cast.asp
"Hair samples collected at the scene and from the cast itself and examined by Dr. Henner Fahrenbach, a biomedical research scientist from Beaverton, Ore., were primarily of deer, elk, coyote, and bear, as was expected since tracks in the wallow were mostly of those animals. However, based on characteristics matching those of otherwise indeterminate primate hairs collected in association with other Sasquatch sightings, he identified a single distinctly primate hair as “Sasquatch.”"

All the other hair that Dr. Fahrenbach has identified as 'Sasquatch' are undistinguishable from human hair, and I've already pointed out problems with hair analysis in earlier posts. (I'm still interested in finding out whether Dr. Fahrenbach is accepted as a hair analysis expert outside the field of bigfootdom.)

Elk hair has also been confirmed according to this:

http://www.100megsfree4.com/farshores/bfoot29.htm
"And then there was all the hair the research team picked up. A few strands are in a lab in Vancouver awaiting DNA analysis. Several others already tested have been identified -- as elk hair."

Further statements on that same website seem to ring quite true:

"In the cast are the clear hoof tracks of an elk. There are imprints left that would match perfectly with an elk's legs. The hair collected in the mud has been matched to an elk. It would seem that Mr. Noll has, if anything, a cast of the impression left by the hindquarters of an elk. But Mr. Noll and his entire research team see only one thing -- undeniable scientific proof of a Sasquatch.

a forearm mark with long hair print clearly visible.

Hair or fur?

Are the heel strikes supposed to be from elk knees too?

Why not?

How would an elk get up without leaving clear hoofprints in the middle of the imprint?

Why would the elk leave a hoofprint in the middle of the kneeprint? If I kneel down and then stand up, I see no requirement for me to leave my footprint in the middle of the kneeprint. If however, I leave my HEEL print, I find it difficult to stand without leaving either a foot or handprint.

And don't you think the expedition members were smart enough to figure all this out before hauling about 350 lbs. of cast back to civilization?

Enthusiasm can sometimes cloud our better judgement. Noll had to convince other expedition members that it even WAS a buttprint of a squatch, that's how ambiguous it was. If there had been a clear handprint or footprint in the mud to go along with the buttprint, I doubt we'd be having this discussion.

RayG
 

If thousands of tracks have been found they don't appear to be very successful at hiding them.

That was only when Peter was trying to track them. ;)

Careful, next thing ya know chimps will be 'thinking' and gorillas will be 'talking' (Koko, Washoe, etc. etc.)

They sign pretty well. Have you read Fouts' book - Next of Kin?
Or it might not be a squatch to begin with.
An elk sat on its hoofprints?
Not during the expedition. I've never seen any evidence that a clear footprint was ever found.

One looks clear enough for me in the photo in the field notes. And Noll found some in the area prior to the expedition, didn't he? That's why they went to Skookum Meadow.
Don't forget an original statement from the BFRO: "Old tracks in mud include elk, deer, bear, coyote..."

Bears don't have hooves, nor do cougars, wolves, coyotes..etc. etc.

The heat marks could have been bear or even porcupine. There was no way to determine just what they were, but they weren't from a hooved animal. Wolves are thought to be extinct in the Southern Cascades (though I had a friend who claimed he saw them).
No sighting of a squatch during this expedition, absolutely no other evidence collected during this expedition that points to squatch as the culprit.

Calls, according to the story you posted.

Got a source for that? From what I read they have a single hair that they couldn't distinguish from human. I don't see where the BFRO is claiming to have found an "unknown primate" hair, but I might be looking in the wrong place.

"While the DNA tests have not been completed, the hair samples have been determined by an independent lab to belong to an "unknown primate," Noll said.

"It didn't match humans," he said. "And they were tapered at the ends, meaning they had never been cut."

Both the hairs and the castings have been shown to experts who are convinced that they didn't come from an elk, deer or bear."

http://www.heraldnet.com/bigfoot/story13353257.cfm

All the other hair that Dr. Fahrenbach has identified as 'Sasquatch' are undistinguishable from human hair, and I've already pointed out problems with hair analysis in earlier posts. (I'm still interested in finding out whether Dr. Fahrenbach is accepted as a hair analysis expert outside the field of bigfootdom.)

He probably was before he took an interest in bigfootdom.
Elk hair has also been confirmed according to this:

http://www.100megsfree4.com/farshores/bfoot29.htm
"And then there was all the hair the research team picked up. A few strands are in a lab in Vancouver awaiting DNA analysis. Several others already tested have been identified -- as elk hair."

Further statements on that same website seem to ring quite true:
Such as this?

""There's where the cheeks are," he says. "And that's a heel mark and the Achilles tendon. We figure this is where its arm rested, as it turned on its side." Mr. Noll points out the fine ridges left by matted hair in the thigh -- and then points delicately to a double print between the cheeks, where the, uh, impressions were left that show this Sasquatch was male."


And:

"It's an elk!" hoots Cliff Crook, founder of Bigfoot Central, who has been tracking Sasquatches since 1956.

Mr. Crook, however, who lives not far away in Bothell, Washington, has not bothered to see the cast for himself. "He's just jealous," says Mr. Noll, "because he's never found anything like this himself." "[/B][/QUOTE]

Fancy meeting Crook here.
Didn't you say other statements ring true? :)

Who besides Crook thinks it's a elk? Anyone who's actually seen it other than Marc Hume, who seems to be a reporter, not an expert in anatomy or primatology? I notice he didn't mention the elk hoofprints were old.

The heel prints look nothing like elk knees to me.

Sarmiento notes the other animals that had been there on LMS.

"From that experience, and several much longer expeditions where he spent up to three months in the bush, Mr. Noll concluded that a new approach was needed. Instead of trying to track down the fleet-footed Sasquatch, he reasoned, they'd have to bring the animals to them.

So when they went to work under the shadow of the volcano they were armed with a new weapon: the call blaster.

As they sat around their camp surrounded by the seemingly endless wilderness, the Sasquatch team broadcast a recording of a Sasquatch that was made last year in California. Owl and wolf researchers do the same thing to get population estimates, sending out recorded calls, then counting howls and hoots they get in reply.

Mr. Noll's team took a huge sound system to reach out as far as they could across the gullies and ridges of Mt. St. Helens.

"When we call blast a scream," he explained, "we pump it out at 150 watts on this great, big battleship horn, and we wait for a response. Then the next day we look in those areas for tracks where we hear Sasquatch screaming back."

And they did hear them answering. "It sounded sort of like a high- pitch scream by a woman, trailing off to a gurgle," he said."

And:

"The base camp is alerted. Everyone comes to see the impression. All conclude the animal was lying on its side at the edge of the mud, reaching out over the soft mud to grab the fruit. The group discusses the possible reasons why the animal might have done this, instead of just walking into the wet mud to grab the fruit, as the other animals did ... One possible explanation is immediately apparent -- the animal did not want to leave tracks.""

They did concur.
Hair or fur?
Hair. From the other story you posted.

"After the cast was cleaned, extensive impressions of hair on the buttock and thigh surfaces and a fringe of longer hair along the forearm were evident. Meldrum identified what appear to be skin ridge patterns on the heel, comparable to fingerprints, that are characteristic of primates."


Why would the elk leave a hoofprint in the middle of the kneeprint? If I kneel down and then stand up, I see no requirement for me to leave my footprint in the middle of the kneeprint. If however, I leave my HEEL print, I find it difficult to stand without leaving either a foot or handprint.

Not in the middle of the knee print. Ever see one get up? It's quite a production.

Try rolling. I can do it, and I've never seen Noll rolling around on the garage floor.
Enthusiasm can sometimes cloud our better judgement.
So can scepticism.
Noll had to convince other expedition members that it even WAS a buttprint of a squatch, that's how ambiguous it was. If there had been a clear handprint or footprint in the mud to go along with the buttprint, I doubt we'd be having this discussion.

If you've seen the photo of the imprint, it's easy to see why it took awhile to figure it out.
So Drs. Sarmiento and Swindler can't tell an elk imprint from a primate imprint? They're specialists, f'r Pete's sake. And Swindler was a sceptic with thirty years experience at saying "Bosh."
 
There's also one of a young ape standing on branches to check out something on the ground.
 
LAL said:
I found where you said you're 90% sure they exist. I haven't seen statements like that from you here. ;)

When in Rome..............?

I've always said I think it's possible that they exist. You'll also probably notice I'm considered a 'nit-picker' over there, that I don't play favorites, I ain't out to stroke egos, and regardless of what I report I read, it all comes down to the evidence.

I have freely stated my concerns about the Skookum cast both here and there. Do I read skeptical books and articles? Sure. Do I read bigfoot books and articles? Sure. Does that make me an outcast? Don't know, don't care.


Krantz and others were relying on 'evidence' brought or reported to them by Paul Freeman.

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/dennett03.htm

The examination by a wildlife biologist and a border patrol tracker concluded the tracks [submitted by Freeman] were a hoax, but...word was suppressed and those who believed the tracks genuine were never told of the evidence against their authenticity.

...Freeman underestimated long-time Bigfoot researcher René Dahinden. When both were in the Blue Mountains, Freeman told Dahinden he'd found yet another set of Sasquatch tracks. Suspicious of "evidence" so readily at hand, Dahinden made plaster casts and photographs of the footprints, and upon examination discovered they consisted of an uninterrupted sequence of left, right, left and left, a most unlikely gait for a bipedal creature.

...Freeman began to come across Bigfoot hair samples...Evidence against Freeman's "Sasquatch hair" came from a most unexpected quarter: one of Krantz's own graduate students, Lonnie Sumer. Sumer presented a paper on the last day of the conference examining alleged Bigfoot hair samples (he admitted to me privately they were from Freeman) and concluded the samples were synthetic fibers.

... Not since the days of Ivan Marx (a notorious Bigfoot hoaxer) had someone so consistently been associated with bogus evidence as Paul Freeman...Eventually Freeman would go on to find additional Bigfoot footprints, encounter the creature on a second, third, and fourth occasion, photographing and filming it twice. According to the late Bob Titrnus, once he told Freeman that to mark a territory an individual Sasquatch would sometimes break off the tops of young fir trees, Freeman then began discovering damaged vegetation, in one case locating a tree with damage well above the reach and strength of any human. Freeman claimed to find a series of Indian cave paintings depicting Bigfoot scratch marks, feces, and a ~section of an elk hide with huge teeth marks embedded in it." He even managed to tape record the screech of the monster. But by the mid-1990s only Krantz and a select few academic supporters could maintain belief in Freeman's discoveries.

...I'm sure that at least some among the older Bigfoot buffs still have a copy of the Good Morning America program. Should they decide to play the tape again they will see and hear ABC'S Steve Fox ask, "You tried to make fake footprints?" with Freeman answering, "Yes, I did." Fox then asks, "To create prints?" and Freeman again says, "Yes, I did." Fox is bent on being absolutely clear and so he asks, "You admit those were fake foot prints," and Freeman is seen nodding in agreement.

I find anything associated with Freeman less than compelling.

RayG
 
LAL said:
There's also one of a young ape standing on branches to check out something on the ground.

Pictures of apes sitting on the ground, or on their haunches, don't surprise me one bit. Suggesting that a longer legged possible relative engages in exactly the same behavior is a stretch.

RayG
 
RayG said:

Krantz and others were relying on 'evidence' brought or reported to them by Paul Freeman.

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/dennett03.htm
I find anything associated with Freeman less than compelling.

See my brilliant ;) defense of Freeman on BFF (I don't want to go through all that again right now) and note your article is by the ever-popular Michael Dennett who misquoted Dahinden, called Erik Beckjord a "researcher", mispelled Somer and failed to mention Freeman played a joke on the neighbors in Camas with carved feet prior to his sighting in 1984 (that was the faking of prints). Fahrenbach stated the synthetic hair was probably a natural contaminant and not an attempt at a hoax.

Meldrum said this in his review of Daegling's book:

"Attention is next turned to Paul Freeman and events occurring in the Blue Mountains of southeastern Washington State. Daegling indicates this locale is “well removed from the mountainous coastal habitat that is usually associated with Sasquatch activity.” What is apparently lost on Daegling is the fact that the northern end of the Blue Mountain range is extremely wet with up to 90 cm of precipitation annually and rich habitat resources amply sufficient to support a large omnivore, not to mention one of the nation’s largest elk herds.
Accounts of Bigfoot had emerged from the region long before Freeman arrived on the scene and continue after his departure. Daegling’s entire assessment of the incidents involving Paul Freeman appears to be largely filtered through the smoked lens of Michael Dennett. The numerous problems alluded to by Daegling lie not with the tracks but with the decidedly skewed interpretations of the tracks. With all due respect to the reputed
tracking prowess of Joel Hardin, his mind was made up prior to the event; he interpreted the tracks as if they were man tracks. In most points of his objection the apparent contradictions are precisely what should have been expected based on the distinctive style of walking surmised for the sasquatch, based on other tracks and eyewitness accounts. Krantz deals with Hardin’s points head-on in his book and I discussed them at length
indirectly with Hardin. Dennett is again cited as a source for Dahinden’s claim that tracks were left a nonsequential series, with two left feet in succession – an apparently damning situation, if true. Dahinden corrected this bit of misrepresentation when I questioned him on it. His sarcastic comment, indiscriminately reported by Dennett, that one couldn’t tell a right foot from a left, and there appeared to be “two left feet” was
baseless. Further distortions by Dennett include the often repeated claim that Freeman admitted to faking footprints. In reality Freeman stated that he had experimented in his backyard to determine what would be required, if it was even possible, to fake a convincing Bigfoot track. In that case, I guess I am guilty of hoaxing Bigfoot tracks, as well as any other serious-minded researcher who has done his homework. As for the rumor
that Freeman worked at an orthopedic shoe company -- as best I can determine there is no substance to it; let Dennett reveal his “anonymous sources.”"

Dahinden really had it in for Freeman, and having read Hunter's book, I now know the source for Scott's arguments on BFF. They take up about a paragraph on pg. 192. :D
 
RayG said:
Pictures of apes sitting on the ground, or on their haunches, don't surprise me one bit. Suggesting that a longer legged possible relative engages in exactly the same behavior is a stretch.

RayG

Yep. That was a pun wasn't it?
 
The long skinny thing is a tendon.

Nope, it's a leg.

From the BFRO:

Hair samples collected at the scene and from the cast itself and examined by Dr. Henner Fahrenbach, a biomedical research scientist from Beaverton, Ore., were primarily of deer, elk, coyote, and bear, as was expected since tracks in the wallow were mostly of those animals. However, based on characteristics matching those of otherwise indeterminate primate hairs collected in association with other Sasquatch sightings, he identified a single distinctly primate hair as “Sasquatch.”

Elk hair and elk tracks in the cast and in the wallow.

This is clearly from an elk, and the BFRO has known it all along.

A single indeterminate hair is conveniently called a sasquatch hair. Pure irresponsible speculation to fluff up their cause.

I rest my case. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom