Bigfoot - serious, not follies

RayG said:
Without the actual leg for comparison purposes, how can anyone be certain?

RayG

Swindler was.

"Dr. Swindler has in the past appeared in TV documentaries on this subject as the mandatory skeptical scientist. He changed his opinion as a result of the discovery in a patch of drying mud, beside a road in a mountain forest in Washington, of the hairy imprints of a buttock, thigh, and forearm plus several heel prints, of an animal far larger than a human. A huge plaster cast was successfully made that shows all these elements with such detail that individual hairs can be counted. One heel print, a cast of which is on display, shows several inches of the Achilles tendon, and Dr. Swindler has gone on public record that it is the heel of a huge, unknown higher primate."

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/jgreen.html
 
LTC8K6 said:
Imagine an elk doing this in mud. You'd get an impression of the ball of the knee, and a little bit of the leg. Just like what is in the Skookum cast, imo.

deer-kneeling-eat.jpg

There was a herd of Roosevelt Elk ranging on land behind mine in Washington and I've seen the introduced herd at Cataloochie not far from where I live now. They get up and down rather like a horse does. Fresh hoof prints would have been obvious.
 
More on Crook:


"New Fake Bigfoot Photo by hoaxer Cliff Crook

An interesting looking 'bigfoot' photo allegedly obtained by a park ranger in the Wild Creek area near Mt. Rainier, Washingtion, and currently displayed on the Shadowlands Bigfoot page, is actually the latest creation of notorious, attention-hungry bigfoot hoaxer Cliff Crook of Bothell, Washington.

As more people have realized that this photo is a fake, Mr. Crook has tried to distance himself from it by suggesting that he may have been fooled by the unidentified person who allegedly sold him the photo. This is also not true. The photo itself and story of how Crook obtained it are both hoaxes by Mr. Crook himself.

Mr. Crook has been serving up and attempting to market fake bigfoot photos and other fabricated bigfoot evidence for several years now and is well known for doing so among veterans in the bigfoot research community. He claims to have been researching bigfoot for "longer than anyone". This is far from the truth, and typical of the mistruths continually pumped out by this individual.

Although it is not certain how this latest fake photo was produced, many conclude that is was produced the same way as many of his previous fake photos -- a sculpture model placed in an outdoor setting. Several of Crook's other fake bigfoot photos can be seen in the A&E video documentary "Bigfoot"."

http://www.bfro.net/REF/hoax.asp

And:

" Where's the Bell?
Searching for Murphy's "Bell-Shaped Object"

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

On January 10, 1999 the Associated Press carried a news story regarding the 1967 Patterson footage. A Pacific Northwest man named Cliff Crook called a press conference to announce the discovery of new "evidence," which he claims indicates the footage was a hoax. The evidence is a small fuzzy detail visible in some of the published reproductions of still frames of the 1967 footage. Buffs of the controversial footage immediately scoffed at this new "evidence," because the proffered detail had never before been identified by any of the formal scientific investigations directed at the footage over the past 30 years. Crook claims the new evidence shows an "artificial object" in the fur of the bigfoot figure. He asserts this object is part of a costume. At the press conference Cliff Crook exhibited a pretzel-like, clay model of this "artificial object" built by associate Chris Murphy, based on Murphy's interpretations of the fuzzy detail.

Murphy had previously issued a statement describing how he found this detail in an enlargement of a color plate from the book Manlike Monsters on Trial (Majorie Halpin). This color plate depicts the widely recognized "frame 352" of the Patterson footage. Murphy and Crook claim this "object" is visible in the waistline of the bigfoot figure when the color plate is magnified or closely examined. In his written statements Murphy claimed this object is, for some unexplained reason, not visible in all reproductions of the footage, but is visible in the Halpin book. Murphy also stated that anyone can see this "bell-shaped object" simply by enlarging the color plate of frame 352 in the Halpin book.

On January 11, 1999 the color plate of frame 352 was carefully examined by imaging specialists at a color technology laboratory in Ventura, California. State-of-the-art scanners were used to magnify the image down to the color-point level. Below you will find some of the unaltered, high-resolution scans of the book image which were obtained in the lab examination. The final image in the series shows the detail in question at approximately 1600% magnification. At this level of resolution the individual points of color are clearly visible. Murphy's "bell-shaped object" is not readily discernable at any level of resolution. To the naked eye the "object" appears to be a diffuse blotch of light reflecting off the fur. At increasingly higher magnification this detail still appears to be a diffuse blotch of light reflecting off the fur. Several other parts of the bigfoot figure show similar blotches of light reflecting off the fur. The detail in question has no clear edges, and has no visible "artifical" shape. The lab tests demonstrated that a clear magnification of the color plate does not reveal anything like the pretzel-like object displayed at Crook's press conference. The image analysts stated that Murphy seems to be relying on some "highly imaginative, Rorschach-like interpretations of fuzzy details in enlargements of the color plates."

Browse through the series of high-resolution scans below to view the area of detail that Murphy and Crook claim shows a "bell-shaped object."

Is it a "bell," or is it a diffuse blotch of reflected sunlight? You be the judge."

http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/bell.asp

Now, got any "experts"?
 
LAL said:
They have a no-kill policy, don't they? What more could be gained?

What more could be gained?? :jaw:

Are you serious? They were that close to solving an ancient mystery, to providing unparalleled evidence of the creature known as bigfoot, to setting the scientific establishment on its collective ear!!! Far better to say, "Move along, nothing to see here...we only want to test equipment...no sense bringing back real proof."

The BFRO expedition was only testing infra-red and hoping to get clear tracks in mud.

You'd think, as the "only scientific research organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery" they would have leaped at the opportunity to bring back absolute proof.

I don't think convincing sceptics is one of their goals.

How about convincing mainstream science?

Alton Higgins (of the BFRO) warned me I'd never convince a sceptic.

Not without evidence.

I'm sure learning a lot in the attempt, though.

No sarcasm intended, but I hope you're learning it requires real evidence to convince both skeptics and mainstream science. Opinions, speculations, wishful-thinking, and experts/enthusiasts passing judgements on films (which can be altered/faked), footprints (which can also be faked), or hairs (which remain indistinguishable from human) isn't going to pass peer review on the scientific level.

RayG
 
LAL said:
Elk print was specifically ruled out as was the possibility of several animal prints combining to give an impression of one print.

How was this accomplished? Did they actually bring in live elk to see if the imprint would fit?

Elk eat apples whole, BTW.

Always? Even if startled?

Hairs from the imprint were not elk.

You're certain? Who tested the hairs?

Solitary heel print?

Were these multiple heel prints all the same size? If not, why not? Why would there be multiple heel prints, but no footprints?

RayG
 
LAL said:
Swindler was.

"Dr. Swindler has in the past appeared in TV documentaries on this subject as the mandatory skeptical scientist. He changed his opinion as a result of the discovery in a patch of drying mud, beside a road in a mountain forest in Washington, of the hairy imprints of a buttock, thigh, and forearm plus several heel prints, of an animal far larger than a human. A huge plaster cast was successfully made that shows all these elements with such detail that individual hairs can be counted. One heel print, a cast of which is on display, shows several inches of the Achilles tendon, and Dr. Swindler has gone on public record that it is the heel of a huge, unknown higher primate."

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/jgreen.html

I'll repeat...Without the actual leg for comparison purposes, how can anyone be certain? Do you have Dr. Swindler's email address? I wouldn't mind asking him how he can be so certain by merely looking at a cast or an imprint in the ground. I find it quite incredible that someone can make an absolute pronouncement on something that isn't even there.

RayG
 
RayG said:
What more could be gained?? :jaw:

Are you serious? They were that close to solving an ancient mystery, to providing unparalleled evidence of the creature known as bigfoot, to setting the scientific establishment on its collective ear!!! Far better to say, "Move along, nothing to see here...we only want to test equipment...no sense bringing back real proof."


I have no idea what they said. "Gotta get back or the boss will fire me and I won't be able to afford any more cams?" Didn't you ask Noll?

They got more than they came for, by a long shot.

(I'm searching BFF. Got the name of the thread? Much as I love reading Richard's posts, I do have to get to bed sometime tonight.)

You'd think, as the "only scientific research organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery" they would have leaped at the opportunity to bring back absolute proof.


And how easy is that? Didn't Krantz go out armed every chance he got. Didn't Patterson and Gimlin think it would be easy to track the animal later and that scientists would swoop down on Bluff Creek? Didn't Dahinden spend most of his life trying to be the one to bring in the proof?

No sarcasm intended, but I hope you're learning it requires real evidence to convince both skeptics and mainstream science. Opinions, speculations, wishful-thinking, and experts/enthusiasts passing judgements on films (which can be altered/faked), footprints (which can also be faked), or hairs (which remain indistinguishable from human) isn't going to pass peer review on the scientific level.

RayG

I've known that for approximately 38 years. Actually, I have convinced a few sceptics, but only in real life. :p

I've at least inspired a few cyber friends to check it out on their own. I'm always amazed at the drubbing we get, even from people who seem to be reasonable and objective in other areas.

Why wasn't there a capture after the Cox sighting, or the PGF, or the Clarke filming, or the Bossburg incident or...........

Maybe tracking is a waste of time. That seems to have been shown many times. They were trying the luring method. Was anyone carrying if they had managed to lure it in again?

Re peer review, you may have just answered the earlier question. But there have been attempts to publish on some of the evidence; it's not like no one has tried.

From the notes it sounds like they were worn out and wanted to get the cast back safely:

"After the final coats were applied, the group finally had time to sit back and fully contemplate the significance of this discovery. Many high fives and pats on the back were passed around, amidst posing for several photos. For the first time since the discovery of the impression, some six hours previously, members took a chance to grab a bite to eat and get something to drink. Theories were passed around as to what circumstances had led to this event, and speculation as to what should be done with the cast was presented. Finally, Noll announced that the cast was ready to be removed from the impression.

Several members gathered around the cast and began scoring the edges of the cast adjacent to the frame so that the wood could be removed. After the frame was gone, members then began to dig out the dirt around the edges of the cast, scooping out underneath as far as possible, careful not to scrape the cast surface. When this was completed, Noll instructed a few people to carefully twist the cast back and forth, to help break the suction between the cast and the ground. When he was satisfied that this had been accomplished, he directed four members to carefully lift up on one side of the cast, until it was standing up on end. At this point, the 200 pounds of casting material and 20 gallons of water, plus the 2-3 inch thick layer of wet dirt stuck to the face of the cast, combined to bring the weight of the cast to close to 500 pounds. The group held the cast in an upright position while most of the dirt was brushed off of the cast, leaving only a thin layer of dirt on the cast face. This dropped the weight back down to well below 400 pounds.

The group then prepared Randles' truck for transporting the cast. Randles donated an air mattress to serve as cushioning underneath the cast, while other members contributed whatever spare padding was available. It took 6 men on the ground plus one in the bed of the truck to successfully and safely maneuver the cast into the truck bed. Padding was then placed around the cast to prevent it from sliding during transport. The area where the impression had been was then swept clean of all debris from the casting procedure. Powell departed immediately after the cast was secured, as he had obligations back in Portland. Terry left as well.

After returning to camp, Randles, Fish and Noll decided to head out for Hood River again to obtain a car battery for Noll. The rest of the group remained at camp, discussing the day's discovery. Randles, Fish and Noll returned at around 11 PM. Some more fruit and peanuts were placed at the mud wallow, in an attempt to obtain more track evidence. A combination of fatigue and high winds won out over the remaining researchers, and so everyone retired to their tents at a relatively early hour. No vocalizations or other disturbances were noted that night."

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/pnw_newsletter003/dayseven.htm
 
LAL said:
More on Crook:...(big snip)

Now, got any "experts"?

I certainly agree that any 'evidence' Crook presents should be viewed with a great deal of suspicion, but the article quoted echoes my own opinion, and nowhere in the article does he present anything with certainty.

I would have liked a link to the Audubon Society Associate, unless that's supposed to be Crook himself. But then I like links to anything or anyone used as evidence. Like John Waters or Chris Stringer for example. ;)

RayG
 
RayG said:
I'll repeat...Without the actual leg for comparison purposes, how can anyone be certain? Do you have Dr. Swindler's email address? I wouldn't mind asking him how he can be so certain by merely looking at a cast or an imprint in the ground. I find it quite incredible that someone can make an absolute pronouncement on something that isn't even there.

RayG

I have his washington.edu address, but I doubt it works since he's retired. I didn't get an answer on it, anyway, nor was my e-mail returned. He may be in poor health. He was unable to attend Willow Creek two years ago.

Should I PM it just in case?

What isn't even there? You mean like the casts of bodies after Pompeii? Just think of it as negative space.

Again, I urge you to see LMS. He's very clear about his reasons.
 
RayG said:
How was this accomplished? Did they actually bring in live elk to see if the imprint would fit?
I doubt it.

"An elk will gather their feet under them when they get up," he (Richard Noll) said. "But there are no elk hoofprints in the center of the cast."

Meldrum and Swindler concur there are only two logical explanations for the cast: Bigfoot and elk. And they have also ruled out elk."

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/news/bfbelievers.html
Always? Even if startled?

How else?
You're certain? Who tested the hairs??

I believe it was the lab in BC. I can get the name off the DVD. The news story just said "independent lab.

"The remaining apple pieces were collected and sent to a lab to test for saliva and other hints of DNA. They also gathered hair samples to test.

While the DNA tests have not been completed, the hair samples have been determined by an independent lab to belong to an "unknown primate," Noll said.

"It didn't match humans," he said. "And they were tapered at the ends, meaning they had never been cut."

Both the hairs and the castings have been shown to experts who are convinced that they didn't come from an elk, deer or bear."

http://www.heraldnet.com/bigfoot/story13353257.cfm
Were these multiple heel prints all the same size? If not, why not? Why would there be multiple heel prints, but no footprints?

They're heel strikes. They look to be about the same size.

I can roll up without putting my feet flat. Try it. There was hard ground where it approached.
 
LAL said:

I have no idea what they said. "Gotta get back or the boss will fire me and I won't be able to afford any more cams?" Didn't you ask Noll?[/B]

Yeah, I asked a bunch of questions, some of which were:
  • How much effort was spent trying to find supportive evidence in the area surrounding the Skookum cast?(I wasn't on the expedition, and the notes on the website don't really make it clear.)
  • Were any RELIABLE footprints found in that area, or in any area on the expedition?(Again, you had implied footprints were found when you said, "They were, before the expedition, during and after.")
  • If your vehicle was only 5 feet from the Skookum cast, why wouldn't you have at least attempted to follow any signs in the immediate area? (No indication on the website that anyone in the expedition did so, or even attempted to do so.)
  • How many independant/non-biased scientists have examined the cast, who were they, and what were their thoughts? (It's been 3 years.)

To which he replied: How many times must it be said that the impression site was at the side of a road?
I answered the second part above.


I tried to clarify: I didn't ask whether it was at the side of the road, I realized that a long time ago. What I asked was why were signs not followed. From what I've gathered, no further signs were found in the immediate area.

For further discussion on the Skookum cast, do a search for skookum using my user name RayG, 30 days or older, and have the results presented as posts.

They got more than they came for, by a long shot.

They seemed to have missed an opportunity of a lifetime.

And how easy is that? Didn't Krantz go out armed every chance he got.

I don't recall Krantz ever being so close to a squatch that he got its butt print.

Didn't Patterson and Gimlin think it would be easy to track the animal later and that scientists would swoop down on Bluff Creek?

So the BFRO decided to repeat history? For a self-designated "scientific research organization" they didn't seem very willing to pursue the object of the expedition.

Didn't Dahinden spend most of his life trying to be the one to bring in the proof?

I'll bet Dahinden would have tried to follow/pursue if he had been that close. You can bet he'd be using some colorful language had he been there and everyone packed it in after stumbling upon "the most significant find in the past two decades."

Why wasn't there a capture after the Cox sighting, or the PGF, or the Clarke filming, or the Bossburg incident or...........

Were any of them claiming to be "the only scientific research organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"? Doubtful.

Maybe tracking is a waste of time. That seems to have been shown many times.

Well the pack it in method isn't going to produce any evidence, that's been shown too.

They were trying the luring method. Was anyone carrying if they had managed to lure it in again?

Ah yes, they weren't really trying to prove the existence of an undiscovered species. Were they only pretending to be scientific in their research/pursuit? I find it hard to believe a scientific expedition engaged in the pursuit of proof for bigfoot wouldn't have a camera in camp. I thought part of the purpose was to lure AND FILM a sasquatch. What's the point in merely luring one into camp?

But there have been attempts to publish on some of the evidence; it's not like no one has tried.

Where and when? Be specific. (link 'em if you got 'em)

From the notes it sounds like they were worn out and wanted to get the cast back safely:

Having spent time in the bush on military exercises, I can assure you that the adrenaline kicks in when the excitement climbs. I'm pretty sure hunters of big game would say the same.

RayG
 
RayG said:
I certainly agree that any 'evidence' Crook presents should be viewed with a great deal of suspicion, but the article quoted echoes my own opinion, and nowhere in the article does he present anything with certainty.

I would have liked a link to the Audubon Society Associate, unless that's supposed to be Crook himself.

That's Crook.
I went to an Audubon Society meeting that featured a talk by Peter Bryne on his Bigfoot research. I guess that makes me an Audubon Society Associate too, or at least it would if I had paid my dues.
But then I like links to anything or anyone used as evidence. Like John Waters or Chris Stringer for example. ;)

Chris Stringer is a Merit Researcher on hominids in the Department of Palaeontology at the Natural History Museum, London, and he's written a recent book (where he no doubt states the consensus is that bipedalism came first and k-w was a later adaptation in the Great Apes ;) ):

http://www.newscientist.com/channel/being-human/mg18625042.300

Waters doesn't seem to be well-known in this country, but he posted some interesting stuff. Did you read more of his posts on the newsgroup?
 
LAL said:
I have his washington.edu address, but I doubt it works since he's retired. I didn't get an answer on it, anyway, nor was my e-mail returned. He may be in poor health. He was unable to attend Willow Creek two years ago.

Should I PM it just in case?

Well, since you didn't get a response, it's probably not worth it. Are you aware of any writings of Dr. Swindler on the Skookum cast? I'd certainly like to read what his thoughts, impressions (pun intended), and conclusions were.

What isn't even there? You mean like the casts of bodies after Pompeii? Just think of it as negative space.

There's really no comparison between the Skookum cast and those from Pompeii. For one thing, the human casts completely encased many of their human captives, and the bodies rotted from within. There is little doubt that the casts left behind were created by humans. The same can hardly be said for the Skookum cast. I'm talking about positively identifying an undiscovered species based on something that is no longer there -- a supposed heel and achilles tendon.

RayG
 
RayG said:
Yeah, I asked a bunch of questions, some of which were:
  • How much effort was spent trying to find supportive evidence in the area surrounding the Skookum cast?(I wasn't on the expedition, and the notes on the website don't really make it clear.)
  • Were any RELIABLE footprints found in that area, or in any area on the expedition?(Again, you had implied footprints were found when you said, "They were, before the expedition, during and after.")
  • If your vehicle was only 5 feet from the Skookum cast, why wouldn't you have at least attempted to follow any signs in the immediate area? (No indication on the website that anyone in the expedition did so, or even attempted to do so.)
  • How many independant/non-biased scientists have examined the cast, who were they, and what were their thoughts? (It's been 3 years.)

To which he replied: How many times must it be said that the impression site was at the side of a road?
I answered the second part above.


I tried to clarify: I didn't ask whether it was at the side of the road, I realized that a long time ago. What I asked was why were signs not followed. From what I've gathered, no further signs were found in the immediate area.

For further discussion on the Skookum cast, do a search for skookum using my user name RayG, 30 days or older, and have the results presented as posts.



They seemed to have missed an opportunity of a lifetime.

I don't recall Krantz ever being so close to a squatch that he got its butt print.


No, but he was in an area with plenty of activity and sign of three individuals.

So the BFRO decided to repeat history? For a self-designated "scientific research organization" they didn't seem very willing to pursue the object of the expedition.


They seem to think they can do it again, at least for photos. Did having a retired zoologist along qualify them as a "scientific research organization"?

I'll bet Dahinden would have tried to follow/pursue if he had been that close. You can bet he'd be using some colorful language had he been there and everyone packed it in after stumbling upon "the most significant find in the past two decades."


Such as "We're going to get that hairy sonuvabitch"?

Were any of them claiming to be "the only scientific research organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"? Doubtful.


At the time? I don't know. They've changed that, haven't they?

Well the pack it in method isn't going to produce any evidence, that's been shown too.


They probably thought they had evidence that would finally convince the scientific community.

Ah yes, they weren't really trying to prove the existence of an undiscovered species. Were they only pretending to be scientific in their research/pursuit? I find it hard to believe a scientific expedition engaged in the pursuit of proof for bigfoot wouldn't have a camera in camp. I thought part of the purpose was to lure AND FILM a sasquatch. What's the point in merely luring one into camp?


They had cameras on Ridgetop. I don't know about camp.
Did you debate MM before he left the board in a huff?

Where and when? Be specific. (link 'em if you got 'em)


"I have had two abstracts accepted there (the American Assn of Physical Anthropologists), with very good dialogue. Also the Northwest Anthropological Conference, the Idaho Academy of Science, and the American Association for the Advancement of Science (Pacific Division). I am working on manuscripts for publication as well. Just had a paper come out in the Journal of Scientific Exploration. - Jeff"

http://www.scientificexploration.org/jse/abstracts/v18n1a5.php

Also Bindernagle.

http://www.bigfootbiologist.org/page8.html

Having spent time in the bush on military exercises, I can assure you that the adrenaline kicks in when the excitement climbs. I'm pretty sure hunters of big game would say the same.

RayG

Good thing the adrenaline didn't kill Dr. Fish. He died of a heart attack less than two years later.
 
Skookum Meadows revisited.......

"YEAR: 2002

SEASON: Fall

MONTH: October

DATE: 20

STATE: Washington

COUNTY: Skamania County

LOCATION DETAILS: Skookum Meadows area, Big Creek

NEAREST TOWN: Carson

NEAREST ROAD: FR 32

OBSERVED: My original plans were for a trip to northern California to visit the famous Bluff Creek film site and drop off some casts and pictures to the Willow Creek Museum, arriving on this day, the 35th anniversary of it’s making, October 20th. I had talked with Joe Beelart about this trip, because he had just returned from the area with a party of 10, including Peter Byrne, Todd Neiss, film crew and our own Al Berry and Ron Morehead. Joe talked me out of going there by myself because of the terrain and for safety reasons, so I altered my plans. I decided to divide this trip up into three parts… doing some things and going some places I had been meaning to for a long time. Skookum Meadows revisit, Estacada and the Wynooche river drainage.

I usually make trips like this in search of areas to investigate for longer periods of time at later dates. I do these scouting trips mostly alone and try to cram as much as possible into them.

Oct 19 – Met with Jeff Lemley and his brother around 10:00PM in the Skookum Meadows area to do some late night call blasting. By the time I got there they had already tried a couple of sets. It was quite foggy, but the sound still carried well, with echoes lasting a few seconds after the source stopped. This is the best time to blast out these sounds, late evening, early morning in the fog since the air is quite dense at this time. Interestingly enough, the primates that do use long type calls for communications between members also choose this time of the day to do so.

Jeff and Alan Terry have built themselves quite an impressive sound blasting system. It is modular and has very good output. The sound was clear, I heard no distortion or feedback during the blasts he made. It ran off his car battery. I was quite tired and didn’t last too long sitting outside with Jeff and company in the cold, I crawled back into my truck around 11:30PM and quickly fell asleep. My day job work shift gets me out of bed at 2:30AM and I usually work 10 hour days. I was starting this out all wrong.

Jeff woke me around midnight and said that they were going back home and that they had heard nothing while I was sleeping. I thanked them for meeting with me and bringing the equipment. I watched them leave. I quickly went back to sleep.

Oct 20 – I woke at my usual time – 2:30AM (great!) and started to drive the back roads, visiting the Skookum Meadows Expedition base camp, hill top and ridge top sites as well as the cast site. I wanted to take some measurements, get another average GPS reading after the military eliminated the scramble signal at the cast site and just have a look at the general area during hunting season.

One deer and a lone coyote, evidenced by their tracks had visited the cast site. I collected a soil sample, documented the cast site with pictures, GPS and did some tape measurements.

I found some interesting things traveling around the area this trip:

A skid mark, looking very much like a human buttock on a road side bank, complete with what might have been hand prints and three impressions that hinted at being bare footprints – 16.5” long x 6” wide at the ball and with toes.

At the exact spot where, during the expedition, I had been filmed looking at some heat tracks on the road with the thermal imager and where I cut open a melon fruit, I found a bee hive, broken in two. It was a natural hive. I couldn't think of why a bear would carry a hive around like this only to suck on it out in the open on a dirt road. There were more large human shaped tracks leading down the road side embankment nearby.

Along the roads, on the side banks, I found 20’ – 25’ fir trees growing half way up. Large human shaped tracks led up to a spot behind these trees and then back down to the road. Some stomping around behind the trees was evident. This lead me to envision something treking up these small slopes, evading night time drivers, returning to the roadway only after passing.

Someone had been leaving fruit...

I photographed these findings and casted a track."

http://www.inthegorge.com/BFreports1.htm

"Peter Byrne as recently as 1993 was challenged to find a subspecies of an elephant in Napal called the King Elephant by natives. They had an elephant with unusually pronounced lobes on its forehead that pointed back to the mammoth and mastodon days. He not only found it, but a mate to it."

http://www.royalforum.com/article.php?id=46
 
RayG said:
Well, since you didn't get a response, it's probably not worth it. Are you aware of any writings of Dr. Swindler on the Skookum cast? I'd certainly like to read what his thoughts, impressions (pun intended), and conclusions were.


No. Can you beg, borrow or steal LMS?
He retired in 1991 (I didn't know it had been that long). I'm surprised the address was still up when I found it as well as his page at UW.

There's really no comparison between the Skookum cast and those from Pompeii.


I didn't understand the comment at first, and I didn't want to just say "Huh?"
For one thing, the human casts completely encased many of their human captives, and the bodies rotted from within. There is little doubt that the casts left behind were created by humans. The same can hardly be said for the Skookum cast. I'm talking about positively identifying an undiscovered species based on something that is no longer there -- a supposed heel and achilles tendon.

RayG

Do the testicle prints help? (Tries to imagine testicles on an elk's chest................)

I'm not finding the thread in 79 pages of your posts yet, but I'm enjoying your NW Coast Indian lore and thoughts on the PGF.
 
LAL said:

No, but he was in an area with plenty of activity and sign of three individuals.

He was?

They seem to think they can do it again, at least for photos.

Their subsequent expeditions haven't produced anything other than speculation, most of it from outside the organization.

Did having a retired zoologist along qualify them as a "scientific research organization"?

No, that's the equivalent of calling yourself "The only sports organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery" because Michael Jorden tagged along.

Such as "We're going to get that hairy sonuvabitch"?

Yeah, something like that. Dahinden was quite the character.

At the time? I don't know. They've changed that, haven't they?

Original BFRO statement:
"The only scientific organization probing the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"

Modified to:
"Professional and amateur scientific researchers exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"

Then changed back to:
"The only scientific research organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"

They probably thought they had evidence that would finally convince the scientific community.

Then they weren't thinking very scientifically.

Did you debate MM before he left the board in a huff?

No, never got the chance. He doesn't seem to think much of the BFF or its occupants. :D

Thanks for the links to Meldrum and Bindernagle info, though neither specifically address the Skookum cast. I'm surprised the Skookum cast has been relegated to the back burner considering Dr. Meldrum himself said:

“While not definitively proving the existence of a species of North American ape, the cast constitutes significant and compelling new evidence that will hopefully stimulate further serious research and investigation into the presence of these primates in the Northwest mountains and elsewhere.”

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/BODYCAST/ISU_press_rel_cast.asp

RayG
 
RayG said:



With Lonnie Somers.

Their subsequent expeditions haven't produced anything other than speculation, most of it from outside the organization.


On MM's integrity?
Didn't the Arizona expedition find some tracks?

No, that's the equivalent of calling yourself "The only sports organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery" because Michael Jorden tagged along.


He did? :D

Yeah, something like that. Dahinden was quite the character.


Have you read his account of Slick's PNW Expedition? It's hilarious.

Original BFRO statement:
"The only scientific organization probing the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"

Modified to:
"Professional and amateur scientific researchers exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"

Then changed back to:
"The only scientific research organization exploring the bigfoot / sasquatch mystery"


That sounds better.

Then they weren't thinking very scientifically.


Naïve of them, wasn't it?

No, never got the chance. He doesn't seem to think much of the BFF or its occupants. :D


I can't imagine why. Some still volunteer, though.

Thanks for the links to Meldrum and Bindernagle info, though neither specifically address the Skookum cast. I'm surprised the Skookum cast has been relegated to the back burner considering Dr. Meldrum himself said:

“While not definitively proving the existence of a species of North American ape, the cast constitutes significant and compelling new evidence that will hopefully stimulate further serious research and investigation into the presence of these primates in the Northwest mountains and elsewhere.”

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/BODYCAST/ISU_press_rel_cast.asp

RayG

He's been preparing some articles for publication, but I don't know what they're on.

I'll wait for the book. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom