Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Diogenes said:
Gorillagator,

Think you could figure out how to un-bold your comments within the quotes, so we can distinguish your comments from the others?








You're so right, and we actually have a specimen..


Are we going to have to wait 70 million years for a specimen of bigfoot ?

P.S.

Uhh, how did we know Coelacanth was extinct ? ( before we discovered it )




*As for your first question about differentiating my words from others; I hope to figure out this forum soon. It is rather strange compared to others I write on and i'm no comouter whiz. I certainly do not expect that it will take as long{70 million years} to discover bigfoot, if it exists Recently I read claims that only 50 of the giants still live.If this is the case they could{and have been} hard to find
As for your last question the answer, as it is with all purported extinctions is simply speculation ; one assumes. If no living chimps or gorillas existed one would conclude that they'd been extinct for lack of any historical fossil records.How does one prove a negative, in the sense of when the last individual of a species dies out. It was simple with the passenger pigeon and dodo, but far more difficult with invertebrates and other species.The ivory-billed woodpecker was thought to be extinct except in Cuba, but now, after fifty years of no sightings, some have been seen and heard in the U.S.A.. *
 
LAL said:
Not off the top of my head. Does it have to be paleontologists? Or living?




There are two new primate species that have been identified from photos only. No remains there that I know of.

The common ancestor was all theory until recently.




THERE IS ONE CRITTER WHICH I HAVE LEARNED IS BEING SEARCHED FOR WHILE THOUGHT TO BE EXTINCR FOR 8500 YEARS; THE AMAZONIAN JUNGLE SLOTH SOME BIOLOGISTS CONSIDER IT PROBABLE THAT THIS CREATURE , OFTEN CALLED MAPINGUARY STILL LIVES. nATIVES DESCRIBE IT AS HAVING THE BODY OF A BEAR, THE FACE OF A MONKEY AND A "DISABLING STENCH" WITH A "TERRIFYING" ROAR.tHIS SLOTH IS 6 FEET TO 6 AND 1/2 FEET TALL
 
Gorillagator said:
THERE IS ONE CRITTER WHICH I HAVE LEARNED IS BEING SEARCHED FOR WHILE THOUGHT TO BE EXTINCR FOR 8500 YEARS; THE AMAZONIAN JUNGLE SLOTH SOME BIOLOGISTS CONSIDER IT PROBABLE THAT THIS CREATURE , OFTEN CALLED MAPINGUARY STILL LIVES. nATIVES DESCRIBE IT AS HAVING THE BODY OF A BEAR, THE FACE OF A MONKEY AND A "DISABLING STENCH" WITH A "TERRIFYING" ROAR.tHIS SLOTH IS 6 FEET TO 6 AND 1/2 FEET TALL


"Or Mapinguari. Also known as Isnashi. Brazil's Bigfoot, described as a tall black-furred hominid usually seen in the jungles along the 'Rio Araguaia', a large river in Brazil's state of Mato Grosso do Sul.

Ape-like creatures have been reported in many areas of Brazil for over two hundred years, but it seems that this central area of this immense and diversified country is the 'hotspot' for them.

In March and April of 1937 one of these creatures supposedly went on a three week rampage at Barra das Gar硳, a small farming town 300 miles southeast of the city of Cuiabá¬_capital of the central state of Mato Grosso do Sul. A large number of heads of cattle were slaughtered by somebody or something with super-human strength, enough to torn out their huge tongues. Reports included unconfirmed sightings, humanoid-like tracks as long as 18 inches, and horrible roaring from the woods. All together, over one hundred heads of yellow cattle of old Spanish origin were killed, all the way to Ponta Branca, located 150 miles south of Barra das Gar硳. This Mapinguary rampage made the major newspapers in Rio de Janeiro and Sã¯_Paulo. "

http://www.crystalinks.com/bigfoot.html

Hm. The "other version" seems to be a Giant Sloth. Could they have more than one thing going on?

I've read about a large hairy hominid being shot in SA.
 
Gorillagator said:




*As for your first question about differentiating my words from others; I hope to figure out this forum soon.

Gorillagator, this forum seems to use tags similar to HTML tags, except instead of the "greater than" and "less than" brackets, it uses square brackets. If you're interspersing your comments within a bold quoted section, begin your comment with "/B" enclosed with square brackets, to end the bold, and end your comment with "B" in brackets to restart it. The tags are not case sensitive.

It is rather strange compared to others etc. etc. snip. *
 
LAL said:
Gould estimated 99% of all species that have lived on earth are extinct, with most leaving no fossils.

Gorillas, Chimpanzees and Okapi, among many other living animals, have no fossil record. They "should", shouldn't they?

There may be fossils of large "unknown primates" somewhere in NA. They haven't been found...........yet.

Yes, these species include planktonic animals, endemic species, very short-lived species, etc.
Gorillas, etc. There are fossils of speies that are related to them. It also happens that these animasl are constantly photographed filmed (and not like fuzzy blotches), bodies are found, etc. But maybe that´s just because they are real animals.

Yes there could be undiscovered primate species, actually there are. But this is not an evidence for bigfoot. At the present point, fossil record points to its inexistence, since no species similar to it has ever been found along its alleged geographic span. And regarding Gigantopithecus, as far as I know, one can´t even say if its morphology fits with that of bigfoot. So, it really does not hepl bigfoot´s case.

LAL said:
As I recall, the Leakys dug in fossil-rich Olduvai for thirty years before a hominid turned up.

*sigh*
Olduvai is the only place in the world where fossils of bigfoot-related species could be found? Old Crow Basin is the type of place where bigfeet-related species fossiles could be found, for example..

LAL said:
Not sure it's the same. Fresh tracks were found, according to the article. I may still have the magazine around somewhere.

See my reply to Gorillagator - and you on the next post. Mapinguari´s description does not fit with a giant sloth or a primate. And if you accept the description as reliable or feasible, then the headless-mule-breathing-fire-by-the-nostrills is possibility...

LAL said:
No, but I think you said there "should" be roadkill at least that many times.

I'm having trouble finding Pleistocene fossil beds listed anywhere in the US besides the ones mentioned, and they seem to be the wrong habitat. http://www2.nature.nps.gov/geology/paleontology/paleo_7_2/parkpaleo_7_2_print.pdf

Strange... Your link points at California, where you wrote that "if it weren´t for La Brea tar pits, nothing would be known"... Try also cave fossil register. And don´t forget to extend you search beyond USA to completely encompass bigfoot´s geographical span.

LAL said:
To my knowlege they don't have thousands of sightings and trackways backing them up.

There are thousands of sightings of Nessie, as well as footage and even weird wake waves. If I recall correctly, even footprints were reported, since it may take a walk on the dry side on occasion, perhaps to drink some scotch at the local pubs.

LAL said:
I show misunderstanding by posting an excerpt from an article explaining it?

You show misunderstanding of the article´s content.
Will you stop that? I never said they can live in open field environments. They can cross them apparently, as evidenced by two track events that have been photographed (farmers fields, at that), but that doesn't mean they do anything but cross them.[/B][/QUOTE]

Oh, but they -or some related species- must have (or been) able to spend a considerable ammount of time in open terrain! See, they migrated from Asia, and even if it took "just a couple of days" for an animal to cross the land bridge, it was not like that.

A group of animal that live in forests would not not decide "lets keep walking untill we find another forest habitat beyond the land bridge". It would make small incursions between forest patches, nothing that would make the group vulnerable to predators or run out of food for a long time. And since open fields dominated not only the land bridge but the nearby areas in Asia and North America...

LAL said:
I said there have been sightings in drier areas. I never said they can live in grassy plains. There are nearby forests in these areas.

Define "nearby". A 1-day walk? There were forest patches close enough all along the migration path from Asia to North America? And these patches, had they enough size to sustain big feet populations?

LAL said:
A whole hersd of dinosaurs perished that way, but how many finds like that have there been?

Turkana Boy, e.g.

Krantz estimated 15,000; other estimates are much lower.

You've described conditions that are like parts of Africa, so why are there no fossils of Gorillas and Chimpanzees?

You are ascribing to a particular fossil deposit, that is not the only one of a group of animals (dinos or ammals) caught by flash flood. How many dinosaur fossils were found at laccustrine, eolic, riverine and lagoonal deposits? How many mammal, bird, reptile, etc have been found in these environments? And how many bigfeet fossils?

Sorry, but the described conditions are not found just at "parts of Africa". All river systems suffer periodic floods. Animals from forests all around the world die while crossing rivers, or nearby drinking spots (disease, old age, predation). You know, there are some orang-utang related fosils that were found in a lake bed... Where are bigfeet remains, past and present?

LAL said:

You know the differences betwee a limestone cave and a lava tube?

And again, why do you insist that bigfoot remains should be restricted to the Cascades? Its supposed distribution range is/was much larger, encompassing several limestone caves.

Porcupine Cave in Colorado provided at least fossil 127 species, Old Crow cave, in Northwestern Canada also provide mammal fossils. These - and many others- are within bigfoot´s supposed territorial range, past or present.

LAL said:
Paleoanthropologists are asking the same question even as they ask that their grants be renewed. Where are all those hominid fossils?

You are referring to a specific time span at an specific area. That do not fit with the ones we are discussing.

LAL said:
Did you read what kind of fossils are plentiful in Alaska?

Yes. And why there´s no bigfoot-related species there? They should have lived there.

LAL said:
There was fog behind him. He saw what he thought was a tree leaning , then it crossed and leapt a bank leaving physical sign. He got a good look and was extremely shaken. What does late at night have to do with it? He got up early to go fishing. One of the prints was cast and Sheriff Bill Closner kept the cast on his desk for years. He said he guessed he'd have to stop laughing.

There are many sightings from this area and across the Columbia on the Oregon side.

You know that waking up early does not avoid people to feel sleepy? Have you ever read about a phoenomenon where people have small dreams when they are awake but with some sleep (can´t remember the name now). Have you ever read about pareidolia?

Oh... The footprints. Other people are already discussing this issue. Yes, now I´m convinced.

Sure it could not have been a bear, moose or just an illusion, coupled with track misidentification. Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight. Is this the best bigfoot research can provide?

Correa Neto said:
They must have been able not to range outside it, but to actually live in steppes and tundra for a long time, at least enough time to expand their habitats from Asia to North America.

LAL said:
As did many other mammals.

Already discussed that. Where are the fossil evidences? Do you think they just walked non-stop from Asia to USA, thus not leaving a trace behind?

LAL said:
"The Bering land bridge, ...snip...

Where are the fossil pre-Indians? Among the oldest bones found in NA are those of Kennewick Man, yes? 9300 years old, but the land bridge was gone 10,500 years ago. Does this mean the Natives were created right here on Turtle Island, as some claim, and no people crossed the Bering Strait?

Well, there are several remains of humans in Africa and Asia recording the habitat expansion, whose ages fit well. Note that population estimates for this time generally are of the magnitue order of 100K individuals. And, have you read the news on the recent find in Mexico? Ever read about Luzia?
And where are bigfeet´s remains?

...snip... There were many waves of migration, apparently.

LAL said:
The primate tooth found at John Day was 20-22 mya, wasn't it? It's still rather unknown just how monkeys got to the New World.

Well, that primate was a bit different from a bigfoot, wasn´t it?
Monkeys got to new world, maybe in plant rafts when the continents were closer (try imagining a 3 m tall bigfoot doing this). However, there are fossil record of monkeys at several places, all around their present and past habitats. Now, bigfoot...

LAL said:
Where are all those transitional fossils the Creationists keep yammering for?

Try some googling on transitional forms of whales and you´ll find a lot of them. You can also check feather evolution, evolution of birds from dionaurs and ant last but not least, have you ever heard of primates called hominids? They are supposed to be intermediate species between Homo sapiens and some other primates...

LAL said:
I don't know that much about the physical evidence for Almas and Kaptars, but feel free to Google them.

*yawn*
Pictures of footprints, reports and interpretated myths...

LAL said:
I was talking about western North Carolina.

Start talking about the whole North America and a large part of Asia. Regardless of the peculair conditions you ascribe for PNW, the actual distribution range is much larger. So, the claims that the alleged peculiar conditions at some PNW places do not favor preservation of recent or old corpses is not valid.

LAL said:
Yeah, it's some more of that US Government National Park Service Blue Ridge Parkway hype. The Appallachians are at least the oldest in NA and among the oldest in the world. The tourist info has them the oldest chain.

Oh, yes, tourist info. What a great source. Canada and USA have older rocks and geomorphological features. Do some googling and you´ll see there are plenty of older rocks. And geomorphological features as well, all around the world. Roraima plateau, for example, leaves the Appalachians biting the dust. OT sidenote - it is the site of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle´s The Lost World, that among dinosaurs, features the curupuri, homids similar to large australopithecines, created by blending local myths such as the curupira, caipora and the mapinguari with evolution theories.

LAL said:
And I'm saying fossil beds are pretty rare in this country, let alone ones of the proper age representing habitat in which there might be a chance of finding a fossilized Sasquatch.

*yawn*
They are not. There are sites where the immaginary creature would have been found.

LAL said:
If Gorillas and Chimpanzees were real creatures their fossils would have been found by now.

Pierolapithecus as a possible ancestor of all today´s big apes. Its a species that is related to gorillas, chimpazees and oraguntangs.
Lufengpithecus chiangmuanensis is a relative to the orang-utangs - and were found in lake deposits.

So, there are fossils of species related to chimps, gorillas and orang-utangs. Where are the bigfeet-related fossils?
 
Gorillagator said:
Not necessarily. The fish known as Coelacanth left no fossils {which anybody discovered} for 70 million years and was thus thought to be extinct until a fisherman dredged one up a few decades ago. Since then it has been learned that their distibution is spread far and wide, yet for 70 million years of living and reproducing no proof of its continued existence was ever found that was later than 70 million years old.

But coelacanths were known by local fisherman for a long time as an ugly worthless fish. A woman once passed by a fish market, noticed a specimen and it was "discovered". Nowdays, there are even high-quality underwater footage avaliable, besides a nice number of specimens. I may be mistaken, but I recall reading that a Japanese sea aquarium even tried to keep a specimen alive, but was not successfull.

Now, compare this with bigfoot....

Gorillagator said:
THERE IS ONE CRITTER WHICH I HAVE LEARNED IS BEING SEARCHED FOR WHILE THOUGHT TO BE EXTINCR FOR 8500 YEARS; THE AMAZONIAN JUNGLE SLOTH SOME BIOLOGISTS CONSIDER IT PROBABLE THAT THIS CREATURE , OFTEN CALLED MAPINGUARY STILL LIVES. nATIVES DESCRIBE IT AS HAVING THE BODY OF A BEAR, THE FACE OF A MONKEY AND A "DISABLING STENCH" WITH A "TERRIFYING" ROAR.tHIS SLOTH IS 6 FEET TO 6 AND 1/2 FEET TALL

LAL said:
"Or Mapinguari. Also known as Isnashi. Brazil's Bigfoot, described as a tall black-furred hominid usually seen in the jungles along the 'Rio Araguaia', a large river in Brazil's state of Mato Grosso do Sul.

Ape-like creatures have been reported in many areas of Brazil for over two hundred years, but it seems that this central area of this immense and diversified country is the 'hotspot' for them.

In March and April of 1937 one of these creatures supposedly went on a three week rampage at Barra das Garças, a small farming town 300 miles southeast of the city of Cuiabá, capital of the central state of Mato Grosso do Sul. A large number of heads of cattle were slaughtered by somebody or something with super-human strength, enough to torn out their huge tongues. Reports included unconfirmed sightings, humanoid-like tracks as long as 18 inches, and horrible roaring from the woods. All together, over one hundred heads of yellow cattle of old Spanish origin were killed, all the way to Ponta Branca, located 150 miles south of Barra das Garças. This Mapinguary rampage made the major newspapers in Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo. "

http://www.crystalinks.com/bigfoot.html

Hm. The "other version" seems to be a Giant Sloth. Could they have more than one thing going on?

Ah, the mapinguari that I´ve mentioned before. Have I mentioned that it has a single eye, its mouth is so large that ends at its belly, its skin is either hairy or like that of an alligator and it has a tortoise-like shell at its back? That´s how it is described by local people. That´s the original description that you´ll find with Native Brazillians and river side population. Not second-hand accounts and/or interpretations. Wow! The description really fits with a giant sloth, eh? Or with a giant primate...

See? That´s what you get by attributing to myths and legends -actually distorted myths and legends- the status of evidence. Now, can´t the original tales of yetis, almas and sasquatch have been very different from the current version? Don´t you think there´s no chance that the original tales were interpretated and adapted by people with different cultural backgrounds to fit their views of the world? I saw this happen with a couple of Brazilian myths.

Oh, wait, there are Mediaeval tales of wild men in Asia with mouths at their bellies, as well as pictures of demons with such feature. So there must be a species like this. Just that it is so ellusive that no remains were ever found, recent or fossil... I´ll name it Buccastomachii hallucinogenicus...

LAL said:
I've read about a large hairy hominid being shot in SA.

Quoting my previous sig... "Show me the body".
 
LAL said:
I apologize for not being able to Google up an article I've used a couple of times in debates. It may have been moved or archived, but I haven't given up yet.

Don't forget about John Waters, who seems to have authored a book but little else. ;)

Am I out of line for asking for the name of even one expert who has examined the cast who disagrees? How about half a citation?

How many 'experts' have actually examined the cast? How many with skeptical opinions have been allowed access to it? Why is the scientific community showing such little interest in the cast? Could it be that a cast proves nothing?

Have you asked the BFRO about that?

I have pointed out my misgivings about the Skookum cast a few times on the BFF. Some of those instances have included dialogue with Richard Noll, the man who originally discovered and identified the Skookum cast. I have tried speaking to Dr. Meldrum about the Skookum cast, but that dialogue seemed to die a quick death after I asked about scientific journals, and compelling evidence, and such.

I tend to trust the opinions of five people (two prominent) with PhDs in fields related to primate anatomy and a couple of researchers with over thirty years experience more than I do the opinions of scofftics on message boards, I guess, and because I'm somewhat familiar with the area where it happened and know there have been numerous sightings and track events in the county over the years and because that's what it looks like.

Keep in mind these experts have only given opinions on the matter, to my knowledge there is no way to make a definitive identification with nothing more than the cast.

The Skookum cast isn't even as good as a well defined footprint cast. In either case, there's still no body, no hardcore, conclusive evidence.

What's your alternative explanation (for the third time ;) )?

For all I know the 'heel print' may have been caused by someone kneeling in the mud to place the fruit. With no other evidence of sasquatch being in the area, why should I believe the 'heel print' belongs to a squatch?

Keep in mind that during the whole expedition no clear footprints were ever found, no sighting ever took place, and no squatch was witnessed sitting in the mud. If you choose to believe they have a cast of a squatchbutt so be it, I'm not so easily convinced.

RayG
 
Did you know the Wall Street Journal once did a balanced story on them?

So what? That doesn't mean anything and you know it. Why even bother to post it?

They just live there.

Great opinion. Now bring out the evidence to support it.

It's compelling. Please show me how the methodology used by Drs. Sarmiento, Swindler, Meldrum and others was faulty and why their conclusions are in error.

I am under no obligation to disprove the skookum cast or any of the other bigfoot evidence. None whatsoever. The obligation rests entirely on those making the claims to support them. They have no proof whatsoever about the skookum cast or about any other bigfoot evidence. They are speculating.

What on earth are you talking about?

Are you confused? The BFRO/etc. left the area just hours after the ultimate prize sat down in the mud and ate their bait. Just hours after the greatest find in the world sat down right next to them. I am sure I have brought up this tendency, and this specific incident more than once.

I'm a life member and I don't care what you think.

What a lovely attitude.

I know about the state fossil, I'm just not finding any under SeaTac. When did this happen?

Why ask me? I haven't said anything about any mammoths under SeaTac.
 
Source: Audubon Society Associate & Bigfoot Central Investigators.

The 250 pound + plaster cast of the alleged Bigfoot's alleged butt and heel mark, labelled and billed by (bfro) and Rick Noll as "The Skookum Cast", and claimed by Rick Noll to eventually become a find "just as big or bigger than the Patterson film", may be solved. Case investigators of this hulking plaster moulage have found signs pointing to a more credible and rational theory about just what was collected within this big plaster cast. The Skookum Cast label now gives way to a new label that could fit this cast much more scientifically. Here is the other side of the story.

Investigators strongly suspect that the cast collected is nothing more than the impressions from a kneeling elk. The hulking plaster moulage which is partially dotted with hoof impressions from an elk appears to point to a kneeling elk as the prime suspect. An elk will often kneel to retrieve food from a pool of water, or in this case, apples in a rain puddle. This was where they had baited for a Bigfoot and poured the cast after the fruit had disappeared. The most probably imagined "Bigfoot Butt Print" may have been the chest or belly area of an elk and the solitary purported heel mark impression inside the giant cast, may in fact, be nothing more than the bend (knee) mark of the elk's leg as it knelt in it's natural way to retrieve the apples from the ground. That would rationally explain why another "heel mark" or an actual Bigfoot footprint was not found inside the cast and that no Bigfoot tracks were found anywhere around or inside the cast. Another case of Wild Imagination gone bonkers. An example of mistaken identity strikes again.
 
Imagine an elk doing this in mud. You'd get an impression of the ball of the knee, and a little bit of the leg. Just like what is in the Skookum cast, imo.

deer-kneeling-eat.jpg
 
LAL said:
I tend to trust the opinions of five people (two prominent) with PhDs in fields related to primate anatomy and a couple of researchers with over thirty years experience more than I do the opinions of scofftics on message boards...

Just to clarify, I don't trust opinions no matter who presents them. My boat floats or sinks based on the evidence.

In the case of the Skookum cast, that evidence is just not there.

RayG
 
Correa Neto said:
Yes, these species include planktonic animals, endemic species, very short-lived species, etc.
Gorillas, etc. There are fossils of speies that are related to them. It also happens that these animasl are constantly photographed filmed (and not like fuzzy blotches), bodies are found, etc. But maybe that´s just because they are real animals.


What makes you think all the films are "fuzzy blotches" ? Which ones have you seen? Do you think they're all of "guys in suits" and that there really is an army of hoaxers out there faking all this stuff?
If Giganto is a relative, there are fossils of a close relative.

Yes there could be undiscovered primate species, actually there are. But this is not an evidence for bigfoot. At the present point, fossil record points to its inexistence, since no species similar to it has ever been found along its alleged geographic span. And regarding Gigantopithecus, as far as I know, one can´t even say if its morphology fits with that of bigfoot. So, it really does not hepl bigfoot´s case.


It doesn't hurt it. There's not much to say they're closely related to Orangutans, either.

*sigh*
Olduvai is the only place in the world where fossils of bigfoot-related species could be found? Old Crow Basin is the type of place where bigfeet-related species fossiles could be found, for example..


Why are you dragging "Bigfoot" into Olduvai? The point was that even knowing they were in a likely spot for hominid fossils, it still took a long time for any to be found.

It's possible Sasquatches evolved from an Australopith, but even those were few and far between in the area.

Homo georgicus didn't leave a trail of fossil ancestors along the route they must have taken to get to Russia. They made it though.

"Fossil History
From Morison and Smith (1987)

More than 20,000 fossils have been collected from Old Crow by members of the Northern Yukon Research Programme, and the Paleobiology Division of the National Museum of Canada. Among the specimens are significant ones that have rarely or never been reported before from North America: the hyena (Adcrocuta), large camel (Camelini), giant moose (Alces latifrons), giant pica (Ochotona whartoni), and the muskoxen (Soergeliaand Praeovibos). Other taxa such as short-faced skunk (Brachyprotoma), the giant beaver (Castoroides ohioensis), and the ground sloth (Megalonyxcf. jeffersoni) are considered highly unusual for such a northerly location."

http://www.taiga.net/wetlands/oldcrow/oc_gen.html

Does it sound like these fossils are from a heavily forested area?

Got any beds in North America that are loaded with fossils of Pleistocene animals that preferred deep forest?

See my reply to Gorillagator - and you on the next post. Mapinguari´s description does not fit with a giant sloth or a primate. And if you accept the description as reliable or feasible, then the headless-mule-breathing-fire-by-the-nostrills is possibility...

Strange... Your link points at California, where you wrote that "if it weren´t for La Brea tar pits, nothing would be known"...


No, I asked what we would know of life in the Pleistocene in California without them. They give an awesome picture, but it's still far from complete. And you can't go a few miles away and find remains of all the species that didn't get trapped there.

Try also cave fossil register. And don´t forget to extend you search beyond USA to completely encompass bigfoot´s geographical span.


There's evidence from Canada, but, again the environment is wet with acid soils. I'm not finding anything about fossils of forest animals of any kind from these areas. Help me out, here.

There are thousands of sightings of Nessie, as well as footage and even weird wake waves. If I recall correctly, even footprints were reported, since it may take a walk on the dry side on occasion, perhaps to drink some scotch at the local pubs.


Can we please leave Loch Ness and UFO's out of this? I'm really tired of them being lumped together.
Will you stop that? I never said they can live in open field environments. They can cross them apparently, as evidenced by two track events that have been photographed (farmers fields, at that), but that doesn't mean they do anything but cross them.

Oh, but they -or some related species- must have (or been) able to spend a considerable ammount of time in open terrain! See, they migrated from Asia, and even if it took "just a couple of days" for an animal to cross the land bridge, it was not like that.

A group of animal that live in forests would not not decide "lets keep walking untill we find another forest habitat beyond the land bridge". It would make small incursions between forest patches, nothing that would make the group vulnerable to predators or run out of food for a long time. And since open fields dominated not only the land bridge but the nearby areas in Asia and North America...[/B][/QUOTE]

I know how that works.

It was a thousand miles wide.

"The distance across the Bering Strait from Siberia to Alaska's Seward Peninsula is approximately 55 miles, and for several periods during the Pleistocene Ice Ages the trip could be made entirely on land instead of water."

If Bryne is correct that they can cover twenty-five miles in a night, they'd only need to a couple of nights to cross.

Forests, or at least stands of Spruce, Poplar, etc., grew much farther north than they do now and the climate was much milder.

The Powder Mountain tracks go from stand to stand of Balsam. The animal was after berries.

Define "nearby". A 1-day walk? There were forest patches close enough all along the migration path from Asia to North America? And these patches, had they enough size to sustain big feet populations?

Evidently, especially if there were Pikas.
You are ascribing to a particular fossil deposit, that is not the only one of a group of animals (dinos or ammals) caught by flash flood. How many dinosaur fossils were found at laccustrine, eolic, riverine and lagoonal deposits? How many mammal, bird, reptile, etc have been found in these environments? And how many bigfeet fossils?

Fossils of new species are found just about daily, aren't they, especially in China. Of course, I wouldn't expect many mammalian fossils in strata that yeild dinosaurs, would you?
Sorry, but the described conditions are not found just at "parts of Africa".
I didn't say they were. If these conditions, found in many places in the world, past and present, are so good at preserving fossils, why are there still so few? A. afarensis may be the best represented ancient hominid with fragmentary remains of over 300 individuals, but there's only one 40% complete skelton. The species was unknown prior to 1974.

Remember "Lucy"?

"In effect, Lucy is one of the "missing links" anthropologists have been searching for since the turn of the 20th Century. She is essentially part ape, part human; the surprising thing about Lucy, however, is which part is which. Before Lucy's discovery, scientists reasoned that the main trait separating humans from the apes was intelligence, anatomically represented by the cranial capacity of the skull. The prevalent hypothesis held that intelligence was a precursor to, if not the impetus for, bipedalism, and anthropologists expected to one day find the remains of a sort of big-brained chimp. Upright, tiny-brained Lucy flew in the face of that line of reasoning. Below her neck, her locking knee-joint and short, narrow pelvis show she could walk upright, and her hands were human-like with slightly more curved fingers. Above her neck, her skull fragments, although not entirely conclusive, point to a cranial capacity of about 450cc (on par with that of a modern chimp) and her jaw and skull were ape-like as well. Lucy's discovery forced anthropologists to reexamine the evolutionary pressures that drove bipedalism."

http://www.pbs.org/saf/1103/features/meetlucy2.htm
All river systems suffer periodic floods. Animals from forests all around the world die while crossing rivers, or nearby drinking spots (disease, old age, predation). You know, there are some orang-utang related fosils that were found in a lake bed... Where are bigfeet remains, past and present?

Good question. Not found yet? Might there not be some evidence submerged along with evidence for humans crossing the Bering Strait?
You know the differences betwee a limestone cave and a lava tube?

Yep. The PNW isn't known for it's limestone caves. :bricks:
I'm not stupid.
And again, why do you insist that bigfoot remains should be restricted to the Cascades? Its supposed distribution range is/was much larger, encompassing several limestone caves.

I don't.

I'm saying fossil remains of forest dwelling animals are rare at best. I lived in the PNW and know it better than these other areas. Some of the best evidence comes from there.
Caves in Skamania County are lava tubes. No limestone caves in that area.

Which limestone caves would be most likely to have Sasquatch fossils? Oregon Caves (no fossils found there until 1995-Jaguar and Grizzly aren't forest-dwellers, are they?)? Mammoth? Luray? Shenendoah? Carlsbad? What makes you think Sasquatches spend much time hanging out in caves?

Porcupine Cave in Colorado provided at least fossil 127 species,


Maybe Dr. Mead will turn some up. There have been Irvingtonian Pikas found in Porcupine Cave.

There were alleged Sasquatch tracks found this spring fairly near Pike's Peak (according to a bow-hunters' website) and Pikas may be something Sasquatches eat.


Old Crow cave, in Northwestern Canada also provide mammal fossils. These - and many others- are within bigfoot´s supposed territorial range, past or present.



Wrong habitat, again. I don't think you'll find much overlap with horses and caribou. Wapiti, maybe.


You are referring to a specific time span at an specific area. That do not fit with the ones we are discussing.

Yes. And why there´s no bigfoot-related species there? They should have lived there.

We don't really know what they're related to, do we, or when they may have migrated?

You know that waking up early does not avoid people to feel sleepy? Have you ever read about a phoenomenon where people have small dreams when they are awake but with some sleep (can´t remember the name now). Have you ever read about pareidolia?

Oh... The footprints. Other people are already discussing this issue. Yes, now I´m convinced.


'Bout time.

Sure it could not have been a bear, moose or just an illusion, coupled with track misidentification. Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight. Is this the best bigfoot research can provide?


Since there are no Moose in Skamania County (haven't I mentioned that a couple of times?), I think we can safely rule them out.

When a hard-headed deputy like Rod Bevins says that was no bear, you can bet that was no bear.

Illusions don't leave tracks.

There's a photo of Sheriff Closner with his cast in Hunter/Dahinden's book. It is not an overlay, bear or imprint from a carved foot. It measured 22" in length, 7 1/2 inches across the ball and 4 1/2" at the heel.

Cox saw what he saw. I've mentioned that a sceptical friend who doubted his own uncle's sighting had a sighting of his own not far from there years later with his young daughter in the car.

There are thousands of such sightings, many of them backed up by physical evidence.

Already discussed that. Where are the fossil evidences? Do you think they just walked non-stop from Asia to USA, thus not leaving a trace behind?

There's hardly a trace of humans doing the same, but we know they did. No non-stop required, just a small population of a cold-adapted species spreading east from Russia over the land bridge sometime between ice ages.

Well, there are several remains of humans in Africa and Asia recording the habitat expansion, whose ages fit well. Note that population estimates for this time generally are of the magnitue order of 100K individuals. And, have you read the news on the recent find in Mexico? Ever read about Luzia?


No. Fill me in.

And where are bigfeet´s remains?


Out in the forest somewhere being scavenged as we speak.


...snip... There were many waves of migration, apparently.


Well, that primate was a bit different from a bigfoot, wasn´t it?


Without question. And only one molar found? There must have been more.

Are there any other primate finds from North America? Monkeys got to South America somehow. Where are all the monkey fossils between New York and Puerto Rico?


Monkeys got to new world, maybe in plant rafts when the continents were closer (try imagining a 3 m tall bigfoot doing this).


Or the migrated through what is now the arctic from Europe or Asia circa 20 mya.

I've seen the rafting idea for the Yowie, not for Bigfoot.

However, there are fossil record of monkeys at several places, all around their present and past habitats. Now, bigfoot...


.....like Gorillas and Chimpanzees seems to have no fossil record that we know of at this time.

Try some googling on transitional forms of whales and you´ll find a lot of them. You can also check feather evolution, evolution of birds from dionaurs and ant last but not least, have you ever heard of primates called hominids? They are supposed to be intermediate species between Homo sapiens and some other primates...


The record of whales and horses are the most complete, but not every single species is known. Feathers may have evolved from scutes. Didn't I mention I have about 300 saved sites on human evolution alone? I actually managed to learn something during two years of debates on evolution, though I'm not totally clear on the new terminology and may have used the term "hominoid" (as opposed to "hominid") incorrectly at times.

One of my cyber friends dubbed me the "Mistress of the Web" because of all the great information I came up with Googling. I've had to eliminate whole folders (twice on whales) because I kept bumping into my limit of 2500 saved sites.

I also check out books by the pound.

I may not know everything, but I try.

*yawn*
Pictures of footprints, reports and interpretated myths...

Over 100 casts available for inspection at Idaho State.
Myths don't leave footprints. Don't forget recorded calls analysed at Texas A&M and a few other clues there's enough (some would say more than enough) evidence to warrant a full-scale scientific investigation.

Start talking about the whole North America and a large part of Asia. Regardless of the peculair conditions you ascribe for PNW, the actual distribution range is much larger. So, the claims that the alleged peculiar conditions at some PNW places do not favor preservation of recent or old corpses is not valid.


There are reports from forested areas (hardwood, too) elsewhere in this country and I don't know of fossils for the other denezins of those areas either.

Oh, yes, tourist info. What a great source.


In fact, I found that out Googling on biodiversity preserves (there's one in the Great Smokies) before I ever left Washington State.

"Perhaps of more interest to visitors today is the other half of the mountain-building story, their gradual destruction. The slow, steady forces of wind, water, and chemical decomposition have reduced the Blue Ridge from Sierra-like proportions to the low profile of the world's oldest mountain range."

http://www.nps.gov/blri/geology.htm

That's on the official National Park Service, Department of the Interior, site.

http://www.nps.gov/

Tourist info.


Canada and USA have older rocks and geomorphological features. Do some googling and you´ll see there are plenty of older rocks. And geomorphological features as well, all around the world. Roraima plateau, for example, leaves the Appalachians biting the dust. OT sidenote - it is the site of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle´s The Lost World, that among dinosaurs, features the curupuri, homids similar to large australopithecines, created by blending local myths such as the curupira, caipora and the mapinguari with evolution theories.


Just how are we measuring "oldest"? Oldest rocks? Longest time above sea level?

*yawn*
They are not. There are sites where the immaginary creature would have been found.


Imaginary creatures don't leave tracks and sign. Hm. Maybe I should put that in my sig line so I don't have to keep typing it out.
Sorry you're so bored. You might find this more interesting if you'd do a little research. There are some good books on the subject.

Pierolapithecus as a possible ancestor of all today´s big apes. Its a species that is related to gorillas, chimpazees and oraguntangs.


And hominids. It may be the last common ancestor or something very near to it.

Lufengpithecus chiangmuanensis is a relative to the orang-utangs - and were found in lake deposits.

So, there are fossils of species related to chimps, gorillas and orang-utangs. Where are the bigfeet-related fossils?

They're related to humans, other hominids and Great Apes too, so there are your relatives. Thanks for pointing that out.
 
RayG said:
Don't forget about John Waters, who seems to have authored a book but little else. ;)



I assume the book is referenced. I'm going to see if I can get it through the library.


How many 'experts' have actually examined the cast? How many with skeptical opinions have been allowed access to it? Why is the scientific community showing such little interest in the cast? Could it be that a cast proves nothing?



Maybe they're taking up the BFRO's invitation anonymously so they won't get ridiculed out of tenure. ;)

I have pointed out my misgivings about the Skookum cast a few times on the BFF. Some of those instances have included dialogue with Richard Noll, the man who originally discovered and identified the Skookum cast. I have tried speaking to Dr. Meldrum about the Skookum cast, but that dialogue seemed to die a quick death after I asked about scientific journals, and compelling evidence, and such.


I'll do a search on your posts when I have time.

Keep in mind these experts have only given opinions on the matter, to my knowledge there is no way to make a definitive identification with nothing more than the cast.



Pretty strong opinions. Do see LMS, even if you have to buy it.


The Skookum cast isn't even as good as a well defined footprint cast. In either case, there's still no body, no hardcore, conclusive evidence.


No one's denying that.

For all I know the 'heel print' may have been caused by someone kneeling in the mud to place the fruit. With no other evidence of sasquatch being in the area, why should I believe the 'heel print' belongs to a squatch?


Is that what it looks like to you? There were several heel strikes, and a forearm print with long hair.

Keep in mind that during the whole expedition no clear footprints were ever found, no sighting ever took place, and no squatch was witnessed sitting in the mud.



No clear footprints of much of anything are found in Skamania County. Noll found footprints earlier, didn't he, which was why they decided to focus on the area?

Noll: I saw one sitting in the mud.
Sceptic: You were drunk and it was an elk.
If you choose to believe they have a cast of a squatchbutt so be it, I'm not so easily convinced.

RayG

I just wish this had happened before I moved. I'd have been roaming Skookum Meadows like an awe-struck groupie.
 
LTC8K6 said:
So what? That doesn't mean anything and you know it. Why even bother to post it?


Just trying to educate you. Life planned a seven page spread on the PGF, but died before it was published.

Great opinion. Now bring out the evidence to support it.


Been doing that.

I am under no obligation to disprove the skookum cast or any of the other bigfoot evidence. None whatsoever. The obligation rests entirely on those making the claims to support them. They have no proof whatsoever about the skookum cast or about any other bigfoot evidence. They are speculating.


When you claim other experts disagree, I expect you to back that up.




Are you confused?


Yep. I thought you were talking about the Texas expedition.

The BFRO/etc. left the area just hours after the ultimate prize sat down in the mud and ate their bait. Just hours after the greatest find in the world sat down right next to them. I am sure I have brought up this tendency, and this specific incident more than once.


They have a no-kill policy, don't they? What more could be gained? The BFRO expedition was only testing infra-red and hoping to get clear tracks in mud. I don't think convincing sceptics is one of their goals.
Alton Higgins (of the BFRO) warned me I'd never convince a sceptic. I'm sure learning a lot in the attempt, though.

What a lovely attitude.


Same to you, fella. Objective or not, the Sierra Club has done a lot to keep us from totally destroying our rather nice country in the name of progress. I think they deserve better than a ROFLMAO.

Why ask me? I haven't said anything about any mammoths under SeaTac.
I was Googling for mammoths in Washington and came up with ice cream. I thought it was funny.
The sloth skeleton was excavated at the north end of SeaTac airport in 1961, FYI.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Source: Audubon Society Associate & Bigfoot Central Investigators.

The 250 pound + plaster cast of the alleged Bigfoot's alleged butt and heel mark, labelled and billed by (bfro) and Rick Noll as "The Skookum Cast", and claimed by Rick Noll to eventually become a find "just as big or bigger than the Patterson film", may be solved. Case investigators of this hulking plaster moulage have found signs pointing to a more credible and rational theory about just what was collected within this big plaster cast. The Skookum Cast label now gives way to a new label that could fit this cast much more scientifically. Here is the other side of the story.

Investigators strongly suspect that the cast collected is nothing more than the impressions from a kneeling elk. The hulking plaster moulage which is partially dotted with hoof impressions from an elk appears to point to a kneeling elk as the prime suspect. An elk will often kneel to retrieve food from a pool of water, or in this case, apples in a rain puddle. This was where they had baited for a Bigfoot and poured the cast after the fruit had disappeared. The most probably imagined "Bigfoot Butt Print" may have been the chest or belly area of an elk and the solitary purported heel mark impression inside the giant cast, may in fact, be nothing more than the bend (knee) mark of the elk's leg as it knelt in it's natural way to retrieve the apples from the ground. That would rationally explain why another "heel mark" or an actual Bigfoot footprint was not found inside the cast and that no Bigfoot tracks were found anywhere around or inside the cast. Another case of Wild Imagination gone bonkers. An example of mistaken identity strikes again.

What? No names? Dr. Daegling cited Cliff Crook, at least. Crook has never seen the cast and is thoroughly discredited over the "bell-shaped object" and the phony photos.

Look who "Bigfoot Central" turns out to be (big surprise):

http://www.angelfire.com/biz/bigfootcentral/

Elk print was specifically ruled out as was the possibility of several animal prints combining to give an impression of one print.
Elk eat apples whole, BTW.
All this was thought of before the thing was even cast.
Hairs from the imprint were not elk.
Solitary heel print? Did the unnamed author of this snippet bother to look at the photos?
Did you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom