LAL said:
That we know of.........the two species of Gigantopithecus have left us four lower mandibles altogether. Where are the rest of the remains of this wide ranging and successful species (and subspecies) that endured for half a million years?
Where are the remains of these highly sucessful species of bigfeet, whose habitats span Asia and North America? Gigantopithecus left traces. We know it existed.
LAL said:
It's not known if they're the same species or not.
What's all this "should". The US isn't the Karoo.
So what? there are no areas in the whole North America that do not had conditions for fossil preservation at the time bigfeet or their relatives lived?
LAL said:
That has been found and identified so far.
Who's been looking?
How long did the Leaky's labor before they found a single hominid fossil at Olduvai? Did no hominid fossils exist or were they just not discovered?
One does not need to be looking for bigfoot fossils to find them. Cartelle, for example, was not looking for ape fossils when he found the Caipora. If I recall correctly, part of his team was looking for bats... A huge ammount of findings is due to chance. Paleontologists looking for cave bear fossils, for example, could find a bigfoot jaw. And don´t underestimate the skills of these people when it comes to identify bones. I doubt one of them would not recognize a primate jaw or femur.
LAL said:
I have no idea. That wasn't why I posted it.
I saw an article in Archaeology, I think, about a search for living Giant Sloths in South America. Can't think of the scientist's name, but he got his funding.
But it showed how frail is the evidence used to back the claim of giant sloths and mammoths are still living, or lived untill the last century or so.
The guy is/was looking after the mapinguari. He managed to convince NGC to make a documentary on his research. As always, nothing was found. Just a few reports ("My grandmother saw one"), the guy standing in the woods making what was supposed to be the mapinguari call. Rather frustrating I would say. He got some attention after the new mammal findings in Vietnam.
LAL said:
Haven't I already mentioned bones of anything are rare in the wet part of the PNW? Ten or twenty times?
Yep. No fossils of much of anything in these parts either, but there have been sightings in WNC and Tennessee near the border with NC.
I don't know of any fossil beds in the PNW where forest-dwelling Pleistocene (or even more modern) animals are preserved. It's just not fossil country.
Haven´t I mentioned that bigfoot fossils as well as recent remains should have been found OUTSIDE PNW some ten or twenty times?
LAL said:
????????? Maybe I'm thinking of the Legend of Boggy Creek. Sorry. I really have little interest in other "cryptos".
But they share the same viability problems that bigfeet have. What makes you consider one more likely than the other?
LAL said:
Yep.
"Life
By life I mean that the life strategy of the organism, which will have a profound impact into its fossilization potential (FP - the likelihood of being found as a fossil). For an organism even to begin considering a career as a fossil it must be buried, any life strategy which enhances the likelihood of burial will increase its FP. Consequently, organisms which live on land have a much lower FP than organisms which live in shallow, near-shore marine environments. For example, the FP of your average marine Lesser Spotted Leaping Clam has a higher FP than your average Lesser Spotted Leaping Mountain Goat, due to the periodic, rapid sedimentation events experienced in near-shore environments. Also, organisms which do not possess hard parts or whose hard parts are fragile will have a low FP since they are unlikely to survive the burial process intact.
...snipped to avoid a large quote that could hamper text´s reading...
The fossil record we have reflects these influences on fossilization. The vast majority of fossils are of organisms with hard parts which lived in environments conducive to rapid burial, i.e., in basins that were below sea level and were sinking. In other words the vast (up to 90%) majority of all fossils are of near-shore marine organisms with hard parts. Organisms which lived on land represent a tiny fraction of the fossils record............"
http://home.tiac.net/~cri/1998/taphonomy.html
Again you show misunderstanding of the fossil record. Ever considered that in the statistics, plankton is considered? As well as endemic species? Ever considered that Pleistocene sediments are usually the shallower ones? Those most likely to be exposed, say in roadcuts and river banks, for example? To probe it´s true fossilization chances, you should take in to account only terrestrial animals.
Now, lets play with bigfoot´s fossilization chances.
Question 1- Has the species a broad spatial distribution, spanning different ecosystems?
Answer 1- According to you, yes, since it live (ed) in Asia and North America, in several types of forests and open-field environments.
Conclusion 1- Then, chances are it´ll have, according to this criteria, elevated chances of perservation.
Question 2- Does the animal has hard parts?
Answer 2- Well, its a vertebrate, and a big one...
Conclusion 2- So, according to this criteria, the species has elevated chances of perservation.
Question 3- The species live in areas that have geologic conditions favorable to preservation of bones?
Answer 3- Yes, since it has a vast and diversified habitat. Let me expand this a bit further to cover some aspects the articles you pointed have not touched. Slow burial rates can be very effective for fossil preservation. The corpse of an animal in a lake has great chances of preservation, for example. Despite the small burial rate, the deposited sediment is compose by fine-grained material, that allows exceptional preservation. Now, imagine an animal that lives in a forest - or why not, a grassy plain, since you stated they can live there. River systems cross the forest - or the grassy plain. There are a lot of chances that eventually a number of them would die -note that we are talking in terms of geological time, in this case all the time the species live in that environment- in sites were preservation would be possible. Drowned by floods, when trying to cross a water body, or specimens weakened by disease who came near drinking sites and died there, their bodies later being carried by currents. At river beds, oxbow lakes and even in the river´s flood plains preservation would be possible. Oh, don´t even try to argue that rivers in PNW would not have these conditions, since we are talking of an area that is much bigger abd diversified than this. In such a vast area, there are other sites that favor preservation, such as caves. Looking for water or seeking for shelter, animals get trapped in caves, places with exceptional preservation conditions.Again, don´t argue that there are no caves in PNW capable of preserving bones, since we are talking of an area that is much bigger and diversified than this. Heck, I would expect even a frozen bigfoot carcass as a possible find!
Conclusion 3- High chances of fossil preservation, again.
Question 4- The species has a great number of individuals?
Anwer 4- At a first glace, unknown. But, let´s think a bit more on the issue. We are talking about past bigfoot population, not just before the arrival of European colonization, but also quite possibly before the arrival of humans. If, as you stated, todays' bigfeet population is estimated at 14000, at a time where humans are decreasing its habitat at an allarming rate, one can suppose that without humans to create them problems, their numbers must have been quite larger!And don´t forget the time frame. There´s at least 11Ky for the event to happen. Even if the chance is small, the dice were rolled several times for a long time...
Conclusion 4- There are chances that they had a high fossilization chances in the past. However it is uncertain.
So, it passes in 3 or 4 conditions. And in th fourth one, you get a question mark at best.
LAL said:
Or all the hominid and ape species that must have lived during those several million years?
Haven't we been over this before?
But their fossils were found, weren´t they? And after the "big gap" where are the fossils?
LAL said:
The Bering Strait was evidently open until 10,500, 11,000 years ago. Where are all the fossil people, horses and rock rabbits that must have come down the coast..............?
"The research went back in time far beyond the final submergence of the land bridge. Elias says that fossil samples fell into three age classes--more than 40,000 years old, 20,000-14,000 years old, and 14,000-11,000 years old. Generally, the oldest period represented an environment of birch-heath-grass tundra with a few shrubs, while the middle period was tundra with fewer heaths. The latest period again was dominated by birch-heath-grass tundra--moderately moist--and there were small ponds choked with aquatic plants. By 12,000 years B.P. summer temperatures were as warm as they are now and by 11,000 B.P. summers were warmer than Alaska's north slope now experiences.
Elias and paleobotanist Susan K. Short (INSTARR) and Hilary H. Birks (University of Bergen Norway) found no evidence for steppe-tundra vegetation at any period. R. Dale Guthrie of the University of Alaska's Institute of Arctic Biology has hypothesized that Beringia was a vast steppe covered with grasses and sagebrush. Dr. Guthrie, an authority on large Pleistocene mammals, argues that Alaska's plentiful fossil record means that Beringia must have offered highly productive grazing to have allowed bison, mammoths, and other grazers to reach such giant size. Elias and his colleagues, however, have not found evidence of extensive expanses of that steppe habitat, nor had earlier work by palynologists. Is Guthrie wrong?
"I think that we could easily both be right," said Elias. "The land bridge may have been a narrow waist of mesic tundra surrounded by steppe-tundra landscapes on either side." He notes that the land bridge probably could not have sustained many big grass eaters. "I don't think that there was much for megafaunal mammals to graze on out there on the land bridge, but they may have migrated across the narrowest part of the Bering Strait region in just a few days."
"Based on our evidence, grazing animals and their human hunters probably spent little time on the land bridge. Shrub tundra offers too few food resources for the animals." "
http://www.cabrillo.edu/~crsmith/bering.html
So, steppes, no forests, as I´ve told you... Bigfeet are grazing animals? Populations of bigfeet can live in open fields for a long time?
Note that there´s refference to "Alaska's plentiful fossil record". Bigfeet must have expanded its habitat to Alaska. And why there are no bigfeet fosils there?
And regarding the statement "land bridge probably could not have sustained many big grass eaters", who said it needed to? Not to mention that the term "many" is a bit vague. Think on how animals expand their habitats. Lets take mammoths as a case. They lived across Asia and Europe, didn´t they? Now, as the bridge was being formed, oviously some groups started to gradually use the new land, expanding their territory. As population expanded, new genartions, the new groups formed moved towards new grazing fields, eventually stabilishing new populations in North America, without the need of a large permanent population in the land bridge. And Alaska and Canada would offer ample space for this species expand their numbers, thus leaving fossils...
LAL said:
He had driven through the fogbank. I don't know if there were other patches. I hit one en route to Washougal on the same highway that was so dense I couldn't see the end of the hood ( I had to open the door and shine a flashlight on the road to see the center line), but once I was through it it was totally clear.
The animal was on the south side of the road ahead of him. It crossed the highway and leapt up a bank. The only light was from his headlights. He was heading toward Hamilton Island to go fishing. He hadn't been driving all night. He stopped at Jerry's all-night café (no longer there) in North Bonneville, where the Sheriff's Office was phoned. Smeared toe marks were found 8' up the bank and a full print by the river. There was crushed fern and a small tree at the top, according to Deputy Rod Bevins. Rod said it was about a half mile east of Beacon Rock.
The snow pack was the heaviest in 85 years; many animals were coming down from higher elevations in search of food.
There's a full recounting of the incident in Hunter/Dahinden's Sasquatch/Bigfoot and a report on the BFRO website. I saw the story on the front page of the Vancouver Columbian in March, 1969, and talked with some of the people involved about a year or two later. My land was only a few miles from Beacon Rock.
So, he only saw a glimpse of the animal crossing the road, illuminated by his car´s headlights, there was fog neraby, and it was very late at night. All conditions needed to create a lot of illusions. Add to this the possibility of misinterpretation of tracks, and now you have zero reliable evidence.
LAL said:
There have been sightings in drier areas, such as in eastern Oregon, Colorado, New Mexico........ While forest seems to be the preferred habitat, they may be able to range outside it. See excerpt on the Bering Strait above.
They must have been able not to range outside it, but to actually live in steppes and tundra for a long time, at least enough time to expand their habitats from Asia to North America.
Note that you are now talking about an animal able to live in several different environments (several types of temperate forests, grassy plains, tundra, etc.), with a broad spatial distribution range. Couple this with the fact that no body or related fossil has ever been found and you turn bigfoot even more unlikely.
LAL said:
Black Bear prefer forest too. How did they get here? (Note, both are omnivores.)
And are you sure all mammals that live or lived in North America came through the Bhering land bridge at the last Ice Age? And there are fossils of several species of bear, with sevar age spans, in the Americas and in Asia. Where are the fossils of bigfeet-related species?
LAL said:
If a close relative of Homo habilis lived in Russia, why couldn't a species of robust Australopithecine (or something on that order) have made it that far as well? The Russian's have their "crypto" hominids and one report from Russia regarding the hand position (the thumb was practically unopposed) while one fed on "rock rabbits" (aka Pikas, also found in the Northwest) is virtually identical to what Glen Thomas saw on Mt. Hood.
If there's a living Asian relative, who needs fossils?
If, and that´s a major if. Is there anything else other than reports? There are reports of ghosts also, almost everywhere.
LAL said:
It's clay and it's all over. It's not rock and it doesn't look much like the rock in the area.
What does not mean it has not been formed by weathering. It may have been formed by weathering of any type of rock that exists in your surroundings. If you live in an area composed by igneous or metamorphic rocks, then these will be the rocks that will generate the soil, after weathering. Thus, no fossils. And bigfeet are/were restricted to this area?
LAL said:
I'm in the Appalachians. They're the oldest chain in the world.
Who told you this has not a clue about geology. There are several other mountain chains all around the world that are older, in terms both of morphology age and rock formation age. And the age of the rock has little to do with weathering intensity. It has to do with the time it´s been exposed to the weathering agents (a function of uplift rate, that is controlled by a number of factors), rock composition and the climate (that will controll temperature, precipitation, etc. and ultimately decide the weathering agents). But thats OT digression.
LAL said:
Clay soils in the Piedmont yield skeletons of reptiles dating back more than 200 million years, but I'm not in the Piedmont. There are coastal fossil beds, but I know of none in the mountains in this area.
That´s because the rocks (from wich the soils were created by the proccess of weathering) are 200My old. BTW, that´s completely irrelevant to the present discussion, since as I am (as well as other posters) once again repeating that, in other areas, fossils and remains of the creature could -and would- have been found, if it were a real creature