Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Diogenes said:
I see that I need to be more precise.. ( I realized right after I posted this, but I decided to let it ride and see what you would come up with. )

My question was in the context of the search for Sasquatch.

Do you have any examples of living animals that Paleontologists ( besides Sasquatch officiandos ) believe exist today, for which they have found NO fossils, remains or living specimens ?

Not off the top of my head. Does it have to be paleontologists? Or living?

There are two new primate species that have been identified from photos only. No remains there that I know of.

The common ancestor was all theory until recently.
 
bruto said:
I still maintain that there is no real connection between the fact that very FEW gigantopithecus have been found in one place and that NONE have been found in another. It does not disprove the surmise that there might have been gigantopithecus in places they haven't yet been found, but it constitutes absolutely zero evidence in favor of the hypothesis. It is simply irrelevant as an argument for either side.

Isn't it interesting that it's used by both sides?
 
LAL said:
Einstein thought the Milky Way Galaxy was the entire Universe. We now know it's one of about 150 billion.
Where did you get that incorrect idea from?

The Quantum and The Cosmos:
In 1929 the American astronomer Edwin Hubble discovered evidence that distant galaxies of stars are moving away from our galaxy, and away from each other, as if the entire universe were expanding. The original Einstein equations might give an exact description of our universe after all. Quickly convinced by Hubble's evidence, Einstein felt that his notion of a "cosmological term" was a mistake.
Einstein was fully aware of other galaxies.

Maybe you are incorrect about other things too.
 
Galaxies were recognised as distinct objects in the late 19th century:

Some information about galaxies

So Einstein knew all about galaxies well before his interaction with Hubble.

It sounds like you are getting confused as to what Hubble's discovery actually was. He demonstrated how distant galaxies were moving away from the earth.
More information

But it is totally incorrect to say Einstein thought the Milky Way was the entire universe.
 
Diogenes said:
You must have missed your own post...

You said:
Where did you say anything about deep forests ( in California ) in Pleistocene times ?

I didn't, but is it likely we're going to find fossils of animals from the deep forests of the Pleistocene near fossils of animals that inhabited grasslands?

My point, if I had one, is that there are relatively few fossil beds at all and the ones there are don't give a complete picture.

I'm not finding anything on SeaTac and mammoths except in regard to desserts and hotels. Got a source? That's interesting and I hadn't heard that.
 
Ashles said:
Where did you get that incorrect idea from?

The Quantum and The Cosmos:

Einstein was fully aware of other galaxies.

Not at first. I ran across this information while looking up Georges
Lemaître.

I'd cited NASA's website, was jumped on by a physicist regarding chronology, as I recall, and found out the website was in error.
Maybe you are incorrect about other things too.

Incomplete, perhaps, not incorrect. I should have added a qualifier before the barracudas got me.

"Lu makes typos" and "Lu is capable of making a mistake, therefore Sasquatches don't exist", are not valid arguments against the existance of unidentified hominid primates in North America, anyway, IMO.

Where does your source above say anything about Einstein being aware there were other galaxies?

Einstein visited Mount Wilson in 1931 to thank Hubble for correcting his error in thinking the Universe was static. Ironically, Lemaître based his ideas on Einstein's work and came up with the idea of the Big Bang, independently of Friedman.
 
LAL said:
Where does your source above say anything about Einstein being aware there were other galaxies?
Well they were discovered at least 20 years before he wrote his General Theory of Relativity, so you'd think he'd have heard about them.

And you're the one who claimed he was unaware of galaxies or the size of the universe in order to make a point about incorrect assumptions.
 
Ashles said:
Well they were discovered at least 20 years before he wrote his General Theory of Relativity, so you'd think he'd have heard about them.

And you're the one who claimed he was unaware of galaxies or the size of the universe in order to make a point about incorrect assumptions.

Oh, good grief.

I said he thought the Milky Way was the Universe (still looking for where I read that). I said nothing about other galaxies.

Was it known what galaxies are or that they were outside the Milky Way? Or that they were like the Milky Way? Or that they weren't just weird spirally things within the Milky Way?

He accepted Hubble's findings that they are moving away from each other and apologized for his "biggest blunder".

"Einstein's General Relativity requires a finite spherical universe (it cannot be infinite because of Mach's Principle, with which Einstein strongly agreed, that the mass of a body is finite, is determined by all other matter in the universe, thus all other matter in universe must be finite).
Two problems;
a) What surrounds this finite spherical universe? (Einstein used his spherical ellipsoidal geometry of General Relativity to propose curved space - if you travel in any one direction you will curve around and eventually return to your starting point - subtle, clever, weird, wrong).
b) What stops finite spherical universe gravitationally collapsing (thus Einstein's Cosmological / Antigravity Constant).

2. Two discoveries, one theoretical, one empirical sent Cosmology down the path of the Big Bang Theory for the creation of our universe.
a) Friedman used Einstein's equations to show that an expanding universe was possible by the equations, and solved the problem of the collapsing universe and thus removed the need for Einstein's Cosmological constant. Einstein was reluctant - believing in a static (non-expanding universe).
b) Then Hubble famously showed the relationship between distance and redshift. If Doppler shift caused this redshift then it meant stars / galaxies were moving apart.
Einstein, swayed by this argument, changed his mind - thus his comment 'My biggest blunder' referring to the Cosmological Constant."

http://www.spaceandmotion.com/cosmology-albert-einstein-universe-astrophysics.htm

If it will make you feel better, I will happily retract, at least until I can find the source (which could even be incorrect.)
 
LAL said:
If it will make you feel better, I will happily retract, at least until I can find the source (which could even be incorrect.)
Okey dokey.

It wasn't really the comment itself that I had issue with.

Einstein's General Theory of Relativity is actually surprisingly vague about the structure of the universe with regard to galaxies.

From General Theroy of Relativity: Part III: Considerations on the Universe as a Whole
If we ponder over the question as to how the universe, considered as a whole, is to be regarded, the first answer that suggests itself to us is surely this: As regards space (and time) the universe is infinite. There are stars everywhere, so that the density of matter, although very variable in detail, is nevertheless on the average everywhere the same. In other words: However far we might travel through space, we should find everywhere an attenuated swarm of fixed stars of approximately the same kind and density.
But this isn't meant to be a specific description of the existence of galaxies, or no galaxies, but more a way of emphasising the difference between his theory and a Newtonian model:
This view is not in harmony with the theory of Newton. The latter theory rather requires that the universe should have a kind of centre in which the density of the stars is a maximum, and that as we proceed outwards from this centre the group-density of the stars should diminish, until finally, at great distances, it is succeeded by an infinite region of emptiness. The stellar universe ought to be a finite island in the infinite ocean of space.

My main issues your post were:

A) That Einstein constantly gets misquoted in order to back up the most bizarre and varied of claims. I'm almost thinking of setting up a thread to post the highlights.

B) When illustrating a point about incorrect assumptions I feel it is particularly important to get the example exactly correct. Otherwise it rather undermines the point
 
Diogenes said:
I enjoyed the clip..

Thanks. I hadn't seen that interview.
I found the clip from the Patterson film interesting. I thought the walking looked very human-like..

"If the film was taken at 24 frames per second, then Dr. Grieve found that the stride was similar to that of a human, although the bending at the knee in one position and the angle of the thigh at another were not similar to a typical stride in humans. At 16 or 18 feet per second, the gait would resemble a humans even less.

Igor Bourtsev, in Moscow, did find an ingenious way of determining the film speed. By analysing the number of strides per second from the jitter in the camera, he ruled out the 24 frames per second film speed since Roger's pace would have been higher than a sprinter. Although that seems like a reasonable approach the matter is by no means closed.

After viewing the Patterson film one is usually left somewhat confused. One would rather not believe in "monsters" or beings from children's fairy tales, but one is presented with a rather large amount of fairly circumstantial evidence. Dr. Grieve makes an interesting observation:

My subjective impressions have oscillated between total acceptance of the Sasquatch on the grounds that the film would be difficult to fake, to one of irrational rejection based on an emotional response to the possibility that the Sasquatch actually exists. "

http://home.nycap.rr.com/wwilliams/BigfootFAQ.html#Is the 1967 "Patterson Film" shot in Bluff Creek, CA a hoax?

And:

"THE FIRST RUSSIAN REPORT ON THE 1967 BIGFOOT FILM FOOTAGE,
BY DMITRI BAYANOV AND IGOR BOURTSEV OF THE DARWIN MUSEUM, MOSCOW

GENERAL REMARKS ON THE FILM - Roger Patterson's filmstrip shows a hairy man-like creature, walking erect, having well-developed breasts and buttocks. The last three points, if we accept for a time the authenticity of the creature, indicate its belonging in the Hominid, not the Pongid (anthropoid), line of evolution of higher primates.


Proof?


Morphology of the head shows a very outstanding brow ridge, a low bridge of the nose, very pronounced prognatism, a cone-shaped back of the head.

Judging by the well-developed breasts the creature is female. However, the muscles of the back, arms and legs are so much in relief that they call for comparison with those of a heavy weightlifter.

The creature "has no neck," or at least the neck is not to be detected at first sight. Looking back the creature turns its upper torso along with the head to a much greater extent than would normally a human being. This might indicate a somewhat different attachment of the skull to the spine than in man, and a strong development of the neck muscles which conceal a short, sort of simian, neck.

LOCOMOTION AS SEEN IN THE FILM - It seems smooth and resilient like that of a big quadrupedal animal. One gets the impression that the creature steps on slightly bent legs. If that is the case the impact on the heels should be less manifest than in man's walk, and the hominoid tracks, usually rather even in depth, seem to corroborate this conclusion. While walking the creature swings its arms intensely using them as walking beams as it were.

COMPARISON TO SUPPOSED GAIT OF NEANDERTHALER - Prof. Boris Porshnev, who put forward the Neanderthal hypothesis ot the relict hominoid origin, in his monograph (1963), page 288, refers to the opinions of Russian anthropologists V.P. Yakimov, G.A. Bonch-Osmolovsky and V.V. Bounak concerning the walk of Neanderthalers as construed by analysts of fossil material. We find it very significant that the two characteristics mentioned above-i.e. less impact on the heels and arms swinging-are listed by anthropologists as supposed traits of Neanderthal locomotion, while slightly bent legs are ascribed to Neanderthalers even in a standing position.

THE HOMINOID FOOT - The main features standing out in both the American and Soviet (Russian) material: 1. Tracks show flat feet (without an arch). 2. The width of the foot in proportion to the length is much greater than in man's foot. 3. The hominoid foot is generally much bigger than man's.


Bourtsev, Krantz, and Bayanov


Besides, as has been often noted by late Pyotr Smolin, chairman of the Hominoid Problem Seminar at the Darwin Museum in Moscow, the hominoid foot is distinguished by a great mobility of its toes which can bend very much or fully extend or spread very widely.

One more peculiarity: the so-called double ball at the back of the big toe as evidenced in many North American tracks (Green, 1968; Krantz, 1972). We find Grover Krantz's explanation of this feature very interesting, and we especially value at this stage the conclusion drawn by him concerning the size of the creature's calcaneus (heel bone). In some frames the creature's foot seems to have an unnaturally protruding heel. To a casual observer this may look like a sticking out edge of an artificial sole, but to those who know better this is an omen of the creature's reality.

As for the double ball itself we would like to make here the following remark. The double ball is made up not only of two bulges of tissue but also of a furrow between them, which is like a kind of fold on the sole. Hence the question can also be put this way. Why is a fold formed at this spot on the hominoid sole?

The answer, probably, can be like this: because the hominoid foot is not so rigid as man's foot, it still retains a certain measure of mobility inherited from the hand-like foot of the ape, and therefore has a furrow somewhat analogous to lines on man's palm.


Bourtsev, Krantz, and Bayanov


Grover Krantz finds the correlation between the great weight of the creatures in question (as evidence, among other things, by the depth of footprints) and the anatomy of the foot, as it is revealed in the very same footprints, so natural and binding that he makes the following conclusion: "Even if none of the hundreds of sightings had ever occurred, we would still be forced to conclude that a giant bipedal primate does indeed inhabit the forests of the Pacific Northwest."

It's the first time such an unambiguous statement is made by a professional anthropologist regarding the problem of relict hominoids, a statement made even more welcome by the fact that it came about as a result of study of material evidence which is the plastercasts and photographs of footprints.

COMPARISON TO THE NEANDERTHAL FOOT - As far as we know, none of the American researchers has compared the hominoid foot, as revealed in footprints, to the Neanderthal foot, reconstructed on the basis of fossil material.

In the Soviet Union this job has been done by Prof. B.F. Porshnev who noted a similarity in such features as lack of an arch, the width to length ratio, great mobility of toes (Porshnev, 1963).


Statue


It seems that a new and very important development in this direction of research is a comparison made by us between the calcaneus (heel bone) of the Neanderthal foot and that of North American Hominoids as shown in the materials of American hominologists. Grover Krantz, on his part, concludes that the Bigfoot has "enlarged heels", "the heel section must be correspondingly longer." He also writes that the creature's "ankle joint must be set relatively farther forward along the length of the foot", its length is expected to be "set relatively farther forward on the foot than in man."

Thus, this is also true of the Neanderthal foot, dramatically illustrating the above point.

To make things even more fascinating, the very same features show on the foot of the creature in Roger Patterson's filmstrip. To our knowledge, this fact has not been mentioned before by analysts of the film.

It follows that analysing a possible anatomy of the hominoid foot we find agreement in three, apparently, independent sources: 1. Roger Patterson's film; 2. Photographs and plaster casts of footprints obtained by Rene Dahinden and others, and analyzed by Grover Krantz; 3. Morphology of the Neanderthal foot.

As for the giant size of North American Hominoids, we think this cannot be a sufficient argument against Porshnev's standpoint since big variations in size are also true of the species Homo sapiens.

In our analysis we did not refer to Gigantopithecus because virtually nothing is known about that form of primates except their giant size. As for what is known of the foot of Australopithecus and "Homo habilis", it does not seem to fit the pattern of the hominoid foot we are dealing with.

NOT MAN-MADE - So our conclusion at this stage is the following: though it is not yet clear in what relation North American hominoids stand to the making of man, it is pretty clear now they themselves are not man-made.

Moscow , October, 1972. Dmitri Bayanov , Igor Bourtsev

References:
Porshnev, Boris,1963. Sovremennoe sostoyanie voprosa ? relictovykh gominoidakh (Present state of the problem of relict hominoids), Moscow, V.I.N.I.T.I.
Porshnev, Boris,1969. Troglodytidy i gominidy v sistematike i evolutsii vysshikh primatov (The Troglodytidae and the Hominidae in the Taxonomy and evolution of higher primates) in Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR, volume 188, issue 1.
Krantz, Grover, 1972. Anatomy of the Sasquatch Foot, Northwest Anthropological Research Notes, Vol. 6, No. 1.
Urisson, Mikhail, 1966. Pithecanthropus, Sinanthropus and the related hominid forms, in the Collection of articles Iskopaemye Gominidy i Proiskhozhdenie Cheloveka (Fossil Hominids and Man's Origin), Moscow, Nauka publishing house.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


THE SECOND RUSSIAN REPORT ON THE 1967 BIGFOOT FILM FOOTAGE,
BY DR. DMITRI D. DONSKOY, CHIEF OF THE CHAIR OF BIOMECHANICS AT
THE USSR CENTRAL INSTITUTE OF PHYSICAL CULTURE IN MOSCOW, USSR


Dr. Dmitri Donskoy

As a result of repeated viewings of the walk of a two-footed creature in the 1967 "Bigfoot" footage and detailed examination of the successive stills from the footage one is given the impression of a fully spontaneous and highly efficient pattern of locomotion shown therein, with all of the particular movements combined in an integral whole, suggesting a smoothly operating and coherent system.

In all of the strides the movements of the arms, or upper limbs, and of the legs, or lower limbs, are well coordinated. A forward swing of the right arm, for example, is accompanied by a movement of the left leg. This is called cross-limb coordination and is essential for man as well as being quite natural for many patterns of locomotion in quadrupeds, such as in walking or trotting movements.

The strides are energetic and strong, with the leg swinging far forward. When a man extends his leg in this manner he walks at a rapid pace and overcomes by momentum the breaking effect of the angled hurdle provided by the outstretched leg. Momentum is proportional to mass and speed so the more massive the biped the less speed is needed to overcome the breaking effect of an outthrust striding leg.

The arms have swinging motion, which suggests that the muscles are exerted at the commencement of each cycle, after which they relax, allowing the movements to continue by momentum. The character of the arm movements indicates that the arms are massive and the muscles strong. After each heel strike the leg of the creature bends, absorbing the full weight of the body and smoothing over the harmony is the result of synergy, i.e., the combined operation of a whole group of muscles.

Since the creature is manlike in appearance as well as bipedal, its gait resembles in principle the gait of modern man. But all of its movements indicate a much greater weight than is normally found in modern man. Its muscles appear to be much stronger and the walk swifter than that of the normal walk of a man.

There are certain characteristics of the creature's walk, which are difficult to explain in words. They might be called "expressiveness of movement." In modern man this is sometimes seen in a sporting or labour activity where economy and accuracy of movement is vital and essential to the activity. In study this particular characteristic can be seen by an experienced observer. In "expressiveness of movement" the motor systems upon which the particular quality is dependent are perfectly adapted to the tasks which they are called upon to perform. In other words, in the case of this creature, the movements have a neat perfection which through regular use have become habitual and automatic.

On the whole the most important thing in the study is the consistency of all of the above-mentioned characteristics. They not only complement each other but also interact in many ways.

All of these factors together allow us to evaluate the gait of the creature of the footage as a natural movement without any sign of the artfulness that one would see in an imitation. At the same time, with all of the diversity of human gaits, such a walk as demonstrated by the creature in the film is absolutely non-typical of man.

Dmitri Donskoy, 1973."
 
aggle-rithm said:
ZUH?!?

Did I read that correctly? Let me try again...



Must...keep...head...from....exploding....



Apparently, this guy has a different definition of the word "looks" than I do.

Weren't you aware that scientists who take this seriously are way past debating whether they exist or not?
 
LAL said:
Weren't you aware that scientists who take this seriously are way past debating whether they exist or not?

I wasn't aware that any scientists took this seriously. No real scientists, anyway.
 
LAL said:
Weren't you aware that scientists who take this seriously are way past debating whether they exist or not?

I know D&D players who can tell you all about the social, dietary, and mating habits of Kobolds.
 
Correa Neto said:
But they exist, indeed, providing evidence that allows to inferr their geographical distribution. That did not encompass North America.


That we know of.........the two species of Gigantopithecus have left us four lower mandibles altogether. Where are the rest of the remains of this wide ranging and successful species (and subspecies) that endured for half a million years?

I will repeat what I have already wrote, and also what other posters are pointing. Fossil evidence should have surfaced somewhere else, since PNW is not the only place where these animals are supposed to exist. There are other fossil sites in North America of the same age, located at other places. Absence of fossils is more likely to be expected in cases of species with very restricted areal distributions. And even then one can fid them!! Now, you are talking about a species whose habitat expanded from Asia to North America. That´s a huge area, with several fossil sites, representing several different paleoecosystems. Or they have evolved at the PNW and never left the place? If so, reports from other areas are unreliable.


It's not known if they're the same species or not.

What's all this "should". The US isn't the Karoo.

And left remains at caves despite having a very restricted habitat. Where are the bigfoot remains? All along their alleged past and present habitats (a bit bigger than a couple of islands), not a single piece of bone.


That has been found and identified so far.

Who's been looking?

How long did the Leaky's labor before they found a single hominid fossil at Olduvai? Did no hominid fossils exist or were they just not discovered?

Oh, and do you really think the reports on the giant armadillo and the mammoths could not have been misidentifications and/or be the product of some "colorful tones"?


I have no idea. That wasn't why I posted it.

I saw an article in Archaeology, I think, about a search for living Giant Sloths in South America. Can't think of the scientist's name, but he got his funding.

Including the fossil ones? Are bigfoot remains more prone to vanish than those of other animals?


Haven't I already mentioned bones of anything are rare in the wet part of the PNW? Ten or twenty times?

Note that, even with your alleged extraordinarily efficient scavenging activity across the whole PNW, they are not supposed to live just there...


Yep. No fossils of much of anything in these parts either, but there have been sightings in WNC and Tennessee near the border with NC.

Again, you are talking about one (or more) species whose geographic distribution must have been huge. The animals itself are huge. The whole point on bipedalism, under the present focus is not important. A skull, or parts of it, teeth, whatever remains that points to such a big primate within its alleged habitat would be enough. If its found in North America or Northeastern Asia.


I don't know of any fossil beds in the PNW where forest-dwelling Pleistocene (or even more modern) animals are preserved. It's just not fossil country.

Wich of them? Why are the more illogical than a bigfoot? Couldn´t a primate have evolved to, at least on ocasion, feed on blood? What about the vampire bats? And what about the reports of sightings of th headless mule that breathe fire from its nostrils? How woud you know the difference betwee the foot prints of ordinary mules, horses, donkeis and the fabulous beast?

Why? On what basis? What these cryptos lack that bigfoot has? Note that many of them would not leave tracks, since they can fly or swim...
If I recall corrctly, one of the witnesses of the Jersy Devil draw what looked quite like a gray-type alien walking on all fours...


????????? Maybe I'm thinking of the Legend of Boggy Creek. Sorry. I really have little interest in other "cryptos".

Posting an article on fossilization is one thing. Understanding how to work with the fossil record is a completely different thing.
The point was that ape fossils of any kind are exceedingly rare.


Yep.

"Life

By life I mean that the life strategy of the organism, which will have a profound impact into its fossilization potential (FP - the likelihood of being found as a fossil). For an organism even to begin considering a career as a fossil it must be buried, any life strategy which enhances the likelihood of burial will increase its FP. Consequently, organisms which live on land have a much lower FP than organisms which live in shallow, near-shore marine environments. For example, the FP of your average marine Lesser Spotted Leaping Clam has a higher FP than your average Lesser Spotted Leaping Mountain Goat, due to the periodic, rapid sedimentation events experienced in near-shore environments. Also, organisms which do not possess hard parts or whose hard parts are fragile will have a low FP since they are unlikely to survive the burial process intact.

The position of the organism in the food chain is important since those lower down tend (for excellent ecological reasons) to be more abundant than those towards the top, so that organisms which occur in large populations, due to their sheer numbers, have a higher FP than those that occur in smaller populations. Having a lifestyle which incorporates living within the sediment provides added bonus points to the organisms FP since it is already buried. So:

High chance of burial + low in the food chain = high FP (with bonuses for already buried).
Low chance of burial + high in the food chain = low FP (it can be argued that the Lesser Spotted Leaping Mountain Goat has a good chance of being buried by the occasional landslide, living as it does in the mountains, but see Survival below.)

Death
How an organism dies also affects its FP. Shuffling off this mortal coil out in the open is not good since there tends to be a large number of organisms around to take advantage of such events to reduce your remains and FP quite rapidly. Even if you are already buried, something higher in the food chain digging you out and crushing you into a thousand small bits has something of a disastrous effect on your FP. Similarly your FP can be badly affected if you are rolled around by storms. Rapid smothering is still the best way of increasing your FP. This cuts down the possibility of further contributing to the food chain and in certain instances provides an environment suitable for preservation. So we have:

smothering by storm or flood sedimentation = high FP
being eaten or rolled around = low FP
Preservation
This covers the survival of the organism's remains after death and its transition into a fossil. Burial is the premier method of ensuring passage into the preservation stage. Rapid burial is a common process which occurs on a regular basis. Floods, storms, landslides, and volcanic ash eruptions lay down sediments over a period of hours to days. In some cases several meters of sediment can be dumped in near-shore environments by severe storms. Sedimentation does not have to occur on a slow, steady, incremental basis. Rapid sedimentation is part and parcel of current geological theories and is an important causal constituent of the rock record. However, not all environments are preserved equally in the rock record, leading to a heavy bias towards shallow, near-shore marine environments. Also, all periods of geological history are not preserved equally. Far more is preserved of recent Earth history than of more ancient times.

Burial protects the organism from higher food chain organisms with bad intentions and from the general environment - against mechanical (abrasion and break-up) and chemical processes (decay and disintegration). In the vast majority of cases decay is inevitable. Therefore organisms which possess some robust hard parts (shell, bone) have a much higher FP than soft-bodied organisms which have no hard parts, or possess fragile hard parts. Only under exceptional circumstances are soft-bodied organisms, or non-mineralized tissues, preserved. This usually occurs when the environment surrounding the organism either is low or is lacking in oxygen. Such environments are not needed to produce all fossils. The vast, vast, vast majority of organisms were fossilized in environments with normal oxygen levels, although these organisms are only represented by their hard parts with no soft parts remaining. Fossils containing preserved soft parts are therefore exceedingly rare compared with fossils composed of hard parts.

There are a number of possible preservation pathways once burial is complete. Some result in chemical alteration of the remains. Most result in the continued destruction of soft tissues. So:

Rapid burial = High FP
Hard parts = High FP
Slow burial = Low FP
No hard parts = Low FP

Survival
Once an organism has been successfully buried and preserved the fossil must survive. If the sediments containing the fossil erode away the fossil will be lost. If the sediments are buried too deeply the resultant increase in temperature can destroy the fossil.

Loss by erosion is especially likely if the organism was buried above sea level. Sediments above sea level are far more likely to be eroded than sediments buried in basins which are sinking. Sinking basins can accommodate more sediments (e.g. in the near-shore marine environment) allowing more sediment to be deposited, protecting the sediments beneath. Our Lesser Spotted Leaping Mountain Goat (or any other non-marine animal) may well have become a fossil but its fossil is much more likely to be eroded and destroyed than that of a fossilized clam which is buried below sea level. So:

High FP burial below sea level
burial in sinking basin
shallow burial
Low FP burial above sea level
deep burial

Discovery
This encompasses the chance of the fossil being discovered. A fossil cannot be discovered unless the sedimentary rock containing it is exposed at the Earth's surface. At any one time only a tiny fraction of the fossil bearing sedimentary rocks are exposed and available for being searched. Of all the time that current fossil-bearing rocks have been exposed at the Earth's surface only for the last few hundred years have they been searched. Of all the fossil-bearing rocks that have ever been exposed at the Earth's surface only the ones exposed now have been searched. Rocks in past times have been eroded away leaving little, if any, trace of their fossil content. Thus the fossil-bearing rocks we have searched are only a tiny fraction of the total fossil-bearing rocks.

The fossil record we have reflects these influences on fossilization. The vast majority of fossils are of organisms with hard parts which lived in environments conducive to rapid burial, i.e., in basins that were below sea level and were sinking. In other words the vast (up to 90%) majority of all fossils are of near-shore marine organisms with hard parts. Organisms which lived on land represent a tiny fraction of the fossils record............"

http://home.tiac.net/~cri/1998/taphonomy.html

See my initial comments on the spatial distribution of fossil sites. Even small bits can be used to delineate the temporal and spatial ranges of a species.

And before and after the time gap? Why not a single fossil of a bigfoot or a bigfoot-related species?


Or all the hominid and ape species that must have lived during those several million years?

Haven't we been over this before?

The Bering Strait was evidently open until 10,500, 11,000 years ago. Where are all the fossil people, horses and rock rabbits that must have come down the coast..............?

"The research went back in time far beyond the final submergence of the land bridge. Elias says that fossil samples fell into three age classes--more than 40,000 years old, 20,000-14,000 years old, and 14,000-11,000 years old. Generally, the oldest period represented an environment of birch-heath-grass tundra with a few shrubs, while the middle period was tundra with fewer heaths. The latest period again was dominated by birch-heath-grass tundra--moderately moist--and there were small ponds choked with aquatic plants. By 12,000 years B.P. summer temperatures were as warm as they are now and by 11,000 B.P. summers were warmer than Alaska's north slope now experiences.

Elias and paleobotanist Susan K. Short (INSTARR) and Hilary H. Birks (University of Bergen Norway) found no evidence for steppe-tundra vegetation at any period. R. Dale Guthrie of the University of Alaska's Institute of Arctic Biology has hypothesized that Beringia was a vast steppe covered with grasses and sagebrush. Dr. Guthrie, an authority on large Pleistocene mammals, argues that Alaska's plentiful fossil record means that Beringia must have offered highly productive grazing to have allowed bison, mammoths, and other grazers to reach such giant size. Elias and his colleagues, however, have not found evidence of extensive expanses of that steppe habitat, nor had earlier work by palynologists. Is Guthrie wrong?

"I think that we could easily both be right," said Elias. "The land bridge may have been a narrow waist of mesic tundra surrounded by steppe-tundra landscapes on either side." He notes that the land bridge probably could not have sustained many big grass eaters. "I don't think that there was much for megafaunal mammals to graze on out there on the land bridge, but they may have migrated across the narrowest part of the Bering Strait region in just a few days."

"Based on our evidence, grazing animals and their human hunters probably spent little time on the land bridge. Shrub tundra offers too few food resources for the animals." "

http://www.cabrillo.edu/~crsmith/bering.html

How far was he from the fogbank? Was the one he crossed the only one nearby? What were the relative positions of Cox, bigfoot and the fogbank? What light sources were avaliable, and where they came from in repect to the fog, car and alleged bigfoot? You know, driving at 3:30 AM trough fog can induce some changes in visual perception. Specially if the person is a bit sleepy, even if they don´t acknoweledge the fact.

He had driven through the fogbank. I don't know if there were other patches. I hit one en route to Washougal on the same highway that was so dense I couldn't see the end of the hood ( I had to open the door and shine a flashlight on the road to see the center line), but once I was through it it was totally clear.
The animal was on the south side of the road ahead of him. It crossed the highway and leapt up a bank. The only light was from his headlights. He was heading toward Hamilton Island to go fishing. He hadn't been driving all night. He stopped at Jerry's all-night café (no longer there) in North Bonneville, where the Sheriff's Office was phoned. Smeared toe marks were found 8' up the bank and a full print by the river. There was crushed fern and a small tree at the top, according to Deputy Rod Bevins. Rod said it was about a half mile east of Beacon Rock.

The snow pack was the heaviest in 85 years; many animals were coming down from higher elevations in search of food.

There's a full recounting of the incident in Hunter/Dahinden's Sasquatch/Bigfoot and a report on the BFRO website. I saw the story on the front page of the Vancouver Columbian in March, 1969, and talked with some of the people involved about a year or two later. My land was only a few miles from Beacon Rock.
Bigfeet are supposed to live in forests, don´t they? If so, how they expanded their habitats from Asia to North America? Vast extents of grass plains and tundra had to be crossed to reach what are nowdays USA´s northwestern areas from Asia. Habitat expansion, not migration was the proccess, since the species made the cross actually by gradually expanding their habitats´ range across the bridge. So, any species that came from Asia to North America must have been able to live in grassy plains and tundra. So, bigfeet, folowing this line of reason, could not have reached North America by this path unless it is a species that live in such habitats. And even if it (or some antecessor species) were, this would just result in more chances of fossils being found, given the larger habitat area.

There have been sightings in drier areas, such as in eastern Oregon, Colorado, New Mexico........ While forest seems to be the preferred habitat, they may be able to range outside it. See excerpt on the Bering Strait above.

Black Bear prefer forest too. How did they get here? (Note, both are omnivores.)

If a close relative of Homo habilis lived in Russia, why couldn't a species of robust Australopithecine (or something on that order) have made it that far as well? The Russian's have their "crypto" hominids and one report from Russia regarding the hand position (the thumb was practically unopposed) while one fed on "rock rabbits" (aka Pikas, also found in the Northwest) is virtually identical to what Glen Thomas saw on Mt. Hood.

If there's a living Asian relative, who needs fossils?
Is this particular red clay a sedimentary rock or the product of its weathering?

It's clay and it's all over. It's not rock and it doesn't look much like the rock in the area.

I'm in the Appalachians. They're the oldest chain in the world.

Clay soils in the Piedmont yield skeletons of reptiles dating back more than 200 million years, but I'm not in the Piedmont. There are coastal fossil beds, but I know of none in the mountains in this area.
 
RayG said:
I'm not entirely familiar with evolutionary evidence, or bipedal history, but there were competing hypotheses on the development of bipedalism:

http://www.jqjacobs.net/anthro/paleo/bipedalism.html

Is it now a general scientific consensus that bipedalism developed in forested areas?


Yes, I believe so, since the discovery of Ardipithecus ramidus. Hunt's ideas seem to be favored now. Bipedalism conferred a number of advantages.

After the split? How did they get about prior to the split?


Bipedally, arboreally.

You seemed to be claiming that bipedalism preceeded knuckle-walking in the Great Apes. You even indicated you had sources to support that claim.

RayG

That's the consensus according to Chris Stringer in the article I haven't found yet. I'm thinking it may have been around the time "Kadabba" was elevated to full species status. Still looking.

This is from Discover:

"WHY DO WE WALK UPRIGHT?

For millions of years, the earliest hominids were a lot like other apes. They were short, had tiny brains compared with modern humans, and could not speak or fashion a spear. But there was a profound difference that set them apart: They could stand up and walk. Bipedalism was the first great transformation of our ancestors, coming long before the evolution of all the other things that make us uniquely human.
The answer to the question of how our ancestors evolved into bipeds seemed pretty clear for decades. "The long-standing idea was that we became bipedal because we moved out of the forest and onto the savanna, either because we had to look over tall grass or get to isolated stands of trees," says Craig Stanford, a primatologist at the University of Southern California's Jane Goodall Research Center.
But in recent years new evidence has thrown that scenario into doubt. "The time-honored idea that a weakling hominid left the safety of the forest for the dangerous savanna and had to live by its wits and stood upright is a nice story, but it's probably fiction," says Stanford. As researchers have looked closer at the older hominid sites, many have concluded that the areas were not savannas at all but a variety of lightly to densely wooded landscapes. Hominids may not have lived in savannas until 2 million to 2.5 million years ago—2.5 million to 3 million years after the earliest known hominids walked on two legs.
Now scientists are trying to figure out what evolutionary pressure led hominids to become bipedal in the forest. To answer that question, they have to figure out what upright walking evolved from. Fossils offer some clues, but opinion is divided over what the clues mean. Some paleoanthropologists studying Lucy's skeleton say she walked much as we do, for example, while others say she moved awkwardly on the ground and spent a lot of time in trees. Paleoanthropologists can say even less about the oldest hominids, because they've found hardly anything below the skull.
The best clues to our upright origins may come from living apes, although no one knows for sure how much chimpanzees have evolved from the last common ancestor they shared with us. Some primatologists are conducting lab studies of how modern apes knuckle-walk and clamber through trees to see which movements are most like human walking. Other researchers, like Craig Stanford, watch apes in the wild. "Chimpanzees may stand upright on a big limb of a fig tree and pluck figs just overhead," Stanford says. "And when they're on the ground, they'll stand up to pull down branches." He backs a hypothesis originally devised by Kevin Hunt of Indiana University: The earliest hominids may have become specialists in getting food by standing up for short spells, both in the trees or on the ground. It may not seem as heroic as striding out into the savanna, but then again, many great chapters in the book of evolution have been built from such modest changes."

http://www.discover.com/issues/sep-03/cover/
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom