Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Plaster casts which we made from these tracks provide the only tangible evidence I have for the existence of the sasquatch. But wildlife biologists regularly depend on tracks and other wildlife sign as evidence for the presence of bears, deer, wolves, and other mammals. We recognize that tracks constitute more reliable and persistent evidence of a mammal species than a fleeting glimpse of the animal itself. Although I now have no doubt regarding the existence of the sasquatch, this was not always the case. However now that I am satisfied that the sasquatch is a real animal, subject to study and examination like any other large mammal.
What a total bunch of crap.

I'm not going to waste my time picking this apart but I will suggest that anyone who is in doubt, look up the definitions of ' existence ' and ' presence ' ..

This person is no scientist..
 

Gigantopithecus fossils were never found in the Americas. Neither have any fossil ape in USA and Canada dating from the Pleistocene.



Two or three jaws have been found in China. Finds of Gigantipithecus giganteus (India) are even rarer.

Nor are there any fossil beds in the PNW, to my knowlege, preserving any Pleistocene mammals west of the Cascades or in the Cascades, a single find under Sea-Tac Airport nothwithstanding.

And the pattern of habitat expansion -and retreat- of the habitats of these creatures is well registered by the fossil record.

Noting above serves as an explanation for the absence of bigfoot or bigfoot-related species fossils.



Without the La Brea Tar Pits, what would we know of life in the Pleistocene in what is now California?

Oh, but weren´t they a dwarf subspecies, evolved to adapt to the restricted space of an island? How come the reports are from large animals? Again, thesame problem. Reports, nothing else. No solid evidence. Could just as well be "hunter tales". You can not deny the possibility. "You should have seen the one that escaped"...


Interesting article, wasn't it?

Homo floriensis, another dwarf species, persisted at least until 18,000 years ago.


Not all megafauna animals lived in cold areas. No one actually knows why they reached that size. Competition for food favoring larger sizes is just one possibility. What would by fored bigfeet to decrese their size...
Not to mention that Wrangel Island mammoths left remains. And where are the bigfeet remains?



Eaten by bears and bacteria. There may be several species of unknown bipedal primates worldwide. Some aren't all that large.
And there may be bones and fossils not yet found.

Who suspected the Ardipiths before their (fragmentary) fossils were found or that they would turn out to be bipeds?

And you belive that? There are stories of people seeing dinosaurs in the Amazon forest, as well. Do you belive that? Giant armadillos probably were so slow that one could easilly approach and target their unprotected necks with spears. Saber-toothed cats could crack their skulls with their teeth, so a bullet would do the same. Not to mention that there are some armadillos in South America that can be over 1m long, so, confusion with an ordinary animal plus some added colorful tones can generate the report... "You should have sees the one that escaped"...

One can not also trust in reports based on local myths. An example- In northern Brazil (Amapa State), an area covered by Amzon jungle not subject to extensive flooding at the wet season, there is the legend of the mapinguari. It was "interpreted" by a number of people as a giant sloth or the equivalent of bigfoot. Yeah, right... But the original mapinguari has just one eye, among many other features that do not fit with either "interpretations". Ask the local if they ever saw one. The usual answer is "no, but my [add relative or friend-of-a-friend here] has". On occasion, you will find someone who claims to have seen one. And he/she will turn out to be one of those persons that love to tell stories, quite often not true ones.

If these myths and stories were true, in Amazonia there would be, among many others, vampire monkeys and a poisonous beetle that can saw the upper part of a palm tree. Why these are not credited by cryptozoologists, as well as headless mules that breath fire by their nostrils and giant fire snakes? There are reports of sightings and myths about them...


Perhaps because there's no physical evidence for them and they're "illogical".

Just out of curiosity, do you think Charcarodon megalodon is still around? That Ogopogo and Nessie may be real? That all tales of strange man or ape-like creatures report actual creatures? That mokelembembe exists and is some species sauropod still living in Congo? Mothman? Bid bird? Phantom cats? Jersey Devil? Sea serpents? Where, how and why the line is drawn?


No, with the possible exeception of the "Jersey Devil", which may be an eastern variety of Sasquatch.

You seem not no have a good understanding of fossil research.
Excuse me? Didn't I post an article on it?

Forest animals are fossilized also. Their fossils are found in deposits from lakes, rivers and caves that existed within the forest area. And if, the register of a given time is scarce at one area, it may be abundant at another. And animals with a broad geographical distribution are most likely to leave fossilized remains. Specially if you are taliking about a creature that lived in Asia, North America and perhaps Africa. Note that Australopitecine fossils do not come just from Olduvai Gorge, and Homo erectus and related forms have its fossils scatered over Africa, Europe and Asia. What about bigfoot and its relatives? Not a single bone. Maybe you have a shoebox from area A, but you must remember that area A is not the single place with deposits of that age.


The point was that ape fossils of any kind are exceedingly rare. There's a two million year span with just a handful of ape/hominid fossils. That's why "Toumai" is so important. And central Africa was not thought to be a good place to be looking for hominid origins, especially with so many finds in East Africa.

And the last common ancestor, or close relative to it, was found in Spain, not Africa!

The textbooks will need major overhauling.

Point me to finds of fossil deer, bear, wolverine or even beaver west of the Cascades.

BTW, Cox had driven out of the fogbank when he saw the creature cross the road at 3:30 A.M.. It wasn't obscured by the fog.
 
LAL said:
I suppose it's possible for a biped to evolve from a knuckle-walker that evolved from a biped... but I don't know where this has happened.

Wasn't that your claim from the beginning...that bipedalism preceeded knuckle-walking in a specific species?

Originally posted by LAL
But, bipedalism came first, according to the consensus with knuckle-walking a later adaptation in the Great Apes.

I pointed out a number of times that was what appeared to be what you were suggesting, and Diogenes specifically asked: "Can you point to a paper that suggests bipedalism predated walking on all fours by any animal?".

One link you used to support your claim http://www.eurekalert.org/features/doe/2001-08/danl-rfh060602.php starts out:

Hominid refers to the family of primates that includes all species on the “human ” side of the evolutionary tree after the split from chimpanzees..

You then gave us http://www.anatomy.usyd.edu.au/dann...pology.paleo/archive/september-1996/0363.html which stated:

According to all the evidence, the Gorilla/Bonobo/Chimpanzee and their ancestors only evolved knuckle walking after their collective split from the hominids.

These two statements are quite contradictory. The former asserting that humans came after the split, the latter asserting they came before. It can't be both. Clouding the issue, the second quote is attributed to one 'John Waters', who may or may not have any expertise in the area in question.

Tossing this in is even more confusing:

Originally posted by LAL
Maybe the problem is with the word "species". The knuckle-walkers would have evolved from a prior bipedal species, IOW, they'd be a new species, not the same species developing a new trait.

You're back to claiming bipedalism preceeded knuckle-walking. Unless I'm reading it incorrectly, I haven't seen any evidence to support that.

RayG
 
Perhaps because there's no physical evidences for them and they're "illogical".

Both of which also apply to bigfoot.

You would have to prove a track is from a bigfoot for it to be physical evidence of bigfoot. As you would with hairs, scat, bones, etc.

There is too much illogic in the descriptions of bigfoot to go into here, and much of it was covered in this and the other thread(s).
 
How can you possibly argue with someone who answers the assertion that no gigantopithecus have been found in the USA with the observation that they've found a couple in China?

About time to quit and go do something less futile, like nailing Jello to the wall and loading mercury with a pitchfork.
 
Point me to finds of fossil deer, bear, wolverine or even beaver west of the Cascades.
Your point? You are not suggesting that Sasquatch is only found west of the Cascades, are you?

How many animals do Paleontologists believe exist for which they have found NO fossils, remains or living specimens ?
 
bruto said:
How can you possibly argue with someone who answers the assertion that no gigantopithecus have been found in the USA with the observation that they've found a couple in China?

About time to quit and go do something less futile, like nailing Jello to the wall and loading mercury with a pitchfork.

That would certainly be more productive.

The point, in case you missed it, is that even where Giganto are known to have existed in China the fossils are exceedingly rare. The finds of the subspecies in India are even rarer.

Giganto was identified from a single tooth found in an apothecary shop. It could have been missed entirely (and was, until 1935).

And Gigantopithecus may not have been the species that migrated over the Bering Strait in the first place.

If fossils are so darn common, why don't I unearth one every time I plant something in my red clay?
 
Diogenes said:
Your point? You are not suggesting that Sasquatch is only found west of the Cascades, are you?

No they're found in the Cascades, mostly on the west slope, and formerly seem to have ranged near the coast. The largest population seems to be in the PNW, and except for some Missippian formation on top of table mountain that probably has some fossils, I know of no beds in that area. It's all volcanic.

The beds mentioned are east of the Cascades.

How many animals do Paleontologists believe exist for which they have found NO fossils, remains or living specimens ?

Wow. There are several million years that are barely represented just in our line.

A poster on another board who seems to be a paleontologist says there are a thousand living species with no fossil record in answer to a similar question regarding no fossil record for Chimpanzees and Gorillas.

I'll see if I can find something on that in my copious free time.
 
Diogenes said:
Oh, for a start, just the stuff we found from Lake Manix, Rogers Lake Beds and Tecopa Lake Beds .

Pliocene and Holocene, Plio-pleistocene Tecopa?

Doesn't seem like any of it is from deep forests in Pleistocene times, does it? Or did I miss something?
 
RayG said:
Who is John Waters? Your link leads to what appears to be newsgroup postings, and anyone can post to a newsgroup, regardless of their expertise in a particular subject.

john0.jpg
 
misawafan said:

Wrong JW, though both are in the UK.

The John Waters who posted on the newsgroup (and it's a very good one with strict guidelines) is the author of "Helpless as a Baby", which is a book on general and human evolution.
 
LAL said:

"....I am much more concerned with addressing ecological questions such as how it overwinters in the colder regions of North America, than with dwelling on the controversy of whether it does or does not exist...."
ZUH?!?

Did I read that correctly? Let me try again...

LAL said:

"....I am much more concerned with addressing ecological questions such as how it overwinters in the colder regions of North America, than with dwelling on the controversy of whether it does or does not exist...."

Must...keep...head...from....exploding....

LAL said:

".....NORTH AMERICA'S GREAT APE: the SASQUATCH
A wildlife biologist looks at the continent's most misunderstood large mammal."


Apparently, this guy has a different definition of the word "looks" than I do.
 
LAL said:


Wow. There are several million years that are barely represented just in our line.



I'll see if I can find something on that in my copious free time.
I see that I need to be more precise.. ( I realized right after I posted this, but I decided to let it ride and see what you would come up with. )

My question was in the context of the search for Sasquatch.

Do you have any examples of living animals that Paleontologists ( besides Sasquatch officiandos ) believe exist today, for which they have found NO fossils, remains or living specimens ?
 
LAL said:
Two or three jaws have been found in China. Finds of Gigantipithecus giganteus (India) are even rarer.

But they exist, indeed, providing evidence that allows to inferr their geographical distribution. That did not encompass North America.

LAL said:
Nor are there any fossil beds in the PNW, to my knowlege, preserving any Pleistocene mammals west of the Cascades or in the Cascades, a single find under Sea-Tac Airport nothwithstanding.
Without the La Brea Tar Pits, what would we know of life in the Pleistocene in what is now California?

I will repeat what I have already wrote, and also what other posters are pointing. Fossil evidence should have surfaced somewhere else, since PNW is not the only place where these animals are supposed to exist. There are other fossil sites in North America of the same age, located at other places. Absence of fossils is more likely to be expected in cases of species with very restricted areal distributions. And even then one can fid them!! Now, you are talking about a species whose habitat expanded from Asia to North America. That´s a huge area, with several fossil sites, representing several different paleoecosystems. Or they have evolved at the PNW and never left the place? If so, reports from other areas are unreliable.

LAL said:
Interesting article, wasn't it?

Homo floriensis, another dwarf species, persisted at least until 18,000 years ago.

And left remains at caves despite having a very restricted habitat. Where are the bigfoot remains? All along their alleged past and present habitats (a bit bigger than a couple of islands), not a single piece of bone.

Oh, and do you really think the reports on the giant armadillo and the mammoths could not have been misidentifications and/or be the product of some "colorful tones"?

LAL said:
Eaten by bears and bacteria. There may be several species of unknown bipedal primates worldwide. Some aren't all that large.
And there may be bones and fossils not yet found.

Who suspected the Ardipiths before their (fragmentary) fossils were found or that they would turn out to be bipeds?

Including the fossil ones? Are bigfoot remains more prone to vanish than those of other animals? Note that, even with your alleged extraordinarily efficient scavenging activity across the whole PNW, they are not supposed to live just there...
Again, you are talking about one (or more) species whose geographic distribution must have been huge. The animals itself are huge. The whole point on bipedalism, under the present focus is not important. A skull, or parts of it, teeth, whatever remains that points to such a big primate within its alleged habitat would be enough. If its found in North America or Northeastern Asia.

LAL said:
Perhaps because there's no physical evidence for them and they're "illogical".

Wich of them? Why are the more illogical than a bigfoot? Couldn´t a primate have evolved to, at least on ocasion, feed on blood? What about the vampire bats? And what about the reports of sightings of th headless mule that breathe fire from its nostrils? How woud you know the difference betwee the foot prints of ordinary mules, horses, donkeis and the fabulous beast?

LAL said:
No, with the possible exeception of the "Jersey Devil", which may be an eastern variety of Sasquatch.

Why? On what basis? What these cryptos lack that bigfoot has? Note that many of them would not leave tracks, since they can fly or swim...
If I recall corrctly, one of the witnesses of the Jersy Devil draw what looked quite like a gray-type alien walking on all fours...

LAL said:
Excuse me? Didn't I post an article on it?

Posting an article on fossilization is one thing. Understanding how to work with the fossil record is a completely different thing.
The point was that ape fossils of any kind are exceedingly rare.

LAL said:
There's a two million year span with just a handful of ape/hominid fossils. That's why "Toumai" is so important. And central Africa was not thought to be a good place to be looking for hominid origins, especially with so many finds in East Africa.
And the last common ancestor, or close relative to it, was found in Spain, not Africa!

The textbooks will need major overhauling.

Point me to finds of fossil deer, bear, wolverine or even beaver west of the Cascades.

See my initial comments on the spatial distribution of fossil sites. Even small bits can be used to delineate the temporal and spatial ranges of a species.

And before and after the time gap? Why not a single fossil of a bigfoot or a bigfoot-related species?

LAL said:
BTW, Cox had driven out of the fogbank when he saw the creature cross the road at 3:30 A.M.. It wasn't obscured by the fog.

How far was he from the fogbank? Was the one he crossed the only one nearby? What were the relative positions of Cox, bigfoot and the fogbank? What light sources were avaliable, and where they came from in repect to the fog, car and alleged bigfoot? You know, driving at 3:30 AM trough fog can induce some changes in visual perception. Specially if the person is a bit sleepy, even if they don´t acknoweledge the fact.

LAL said:
And Gigantopithecus may not have been the species that migrated over the Bering Strait in the first place.
Bigfeet are supposed to live in forests, don´t they? If so, how they expanded their habitats from Asia to North America? Vast extents of grass plains and tundra had to be crossed to reach what are nowdays USA´s northwestern areas from Asia. Habitat expansion, not migration was the proccess, since the species made the cross actually by gradually expanding their habitats´ range across the bridge. So, any species that came from Asia to North America must have been able to live in grassy plains and tundra. So, bigfeet, folowing this line of reason, could not have reached North America by this path unless it is a species that live in such habitats. And even if it (or some antecessor species) were, this would just result in more chances of fossils being found, given the larger habitat area.

LAL said:
If fossils are so darn common, why don't I unearth one every time I plant something in my red clay?]


Is this particular red clay a sedimentary rock or the product of its weathering?
 
LAL said:
That would certainly be more productive.

The point, in case you missed it, is that even where Giganto are known to have existed in China the fossils are exceedingly rare. The finds of the subspecies in India are even rarer.

Giganto was identified from a single tooth found in an apothecary shop. It could have been missed entirely (and was, until 1935).

And Gigantopithecus may not have been the species that migrated over the Bering Strait in the first place.

If fossils are so darn common, why don't I unearth one every time I plant something in my red clay?

I still maintain that there is no real connection between the fact that very FEW gigantopithecus have been found in one place and that NONE have been found in another. It does not disprove the surmise that there might have been gigantopithecus in places they haven't yet been found, but it constitutes absolutely zero evidence in favor of the hypothesis. It is simply irrelevant as an argument for either side.
 
LAL said:
Pliocene and Holocene, Plio-pleistocene Tecopa?

Doesn't seem like any of it is from deep forests in Pleistocene times, does it? Or did I miss something?

You must have missed your own post...

You said:
Without the La Brea Tar Pits, what would we know of life in the Pleistocene in what is now California?
Where did you say anything about deep forests ( in California ) in Pleistocene times ?
 
LTC8K6 said:
Both of which also apply to bigfoot.

You would have to prove a track is from a bigfoot for it to be physical evidence of bigfoot. As you would with hairs, scat, bones, etc.

There is too much illogic in the descriptions of bigfoot to go into here, and much of it was covered in this and the other thread(s).

You mean like the Skookum Cast which was pronounced to be the imprint of an unknown hominid primate by the top primate anatomist (Dr. Daris Swindler, Professor Emeritus, U of W), in the country, but which you decided must be an elk?
How did the elk get up without leaving hoof prints in the middle of the body print, pray tell? They fold their legs under them.

Or did you mean the thousands of tracks found in remote areas which have been photographed, cast and examined by professors of anatomy, fingerprint experts and other people who know what they're doing and found to be compelling, but which you think must have been hoaxed?

A female was seen by two witnesses, filmed, tracks cast and photographed and the film pronounced authentic by primatologists at Yerkes in 1967. Tracks of at least three individuals were found in the area prior to the filming.

Why wasn't that enough?

If Cox, for example, had been a qualified scientist seeing one cross a road and then, with the aid of trained deputy sherriffs, finding a partial track 8' up a bank, would that have qualified that particular track to have come from a "Bigfoot"?

With 400 credible reports a year of people seeing Sasquatches but none of people seeing people planting evidence of Sasquatches, why is it reasonable to assume it must all be myth, hoax &/or mistaken identity?

What's illogical about a large, mostly nocturnal unknown hominid primate species inhabiting sparsely populated areas of North America?

Is it because we think we know it all that we think that's implausible?

Einstein thought the Milky Way Galaxy was the entire Universe. We now know it's one of about 150 billion.

"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy." (Hamlet: Act 1. Scene V)
 
Gorillagator said:

Bold type won't quote, dammit.

The Redwoods Park had no buffer and logging right up to the border caused erosion in the Park itself.

My opinion of the timber industry could get me suspended, so I'll just ask Bill, again, why mention of the Sierra Club caused him to ROFLMAO.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom