Bigfoot - serious, not follies

LTC8K6 said:
Yeah, I just told you that they did, and that they were smart for using it for long distance commo.

You didn't mention the sounds were below the range of human hearing and I had forgotten about that. It's a fairly recent discovery.

Elephants trumpet as well. That can be high-pitched and we can hear it just fine.

"high-pitched (hī'pğcht')
adj.
High in pitch, as a voice or musical tone.
Steeply sloped, as a roof.
Marked by or indicating intense emotion: a high-pitched debate."

http://www.answers.com/topic/high-pitched

Again, adaptations come about from mutations. If they confer a benefit, they tend to spread through the population. Intelligence itself came about this way.

Elephants roam in herds. Why would they need long distance communication anyway, even if they could use their intelligence to use the low sounds that way?

Tap,tap, tap.....Is this thing on....??? Hello?

S-o-p-h-o-m-o-r-i-c. I'll never misspell that one again
 
LAL said:
:biggrin:

I've seen plenty of clears-cuts. Too many, in fact.
Weyerhauser overcut their own lands and wanted to move into the Southeast where they had land with maturing timber so they backed the Scenic Act in the Gorge with intent to sell their lands there to the Government for top dollar. The intent of the Act was to keep development where development is. The timber industry got a lot of concessions, but even so a lot of land was set aside in National Heritage.

The Gifford Pinot was the worst-managed National Forest in the country, according to Sierra Cubbers, but even it had plenty of areas set aside for recreation and timber sales were no longer a priority, according to a ranger friend.



You're right about the Gifford Pinchot being heavily overcut and also the Forest Service has allowed motorcycles{recreation} to screw up the built in trails. Roads for the cutting crew are quite numerous as well. Much of the cut areas were done on steep embanjments were erosion has been problematical, to say the least.
In the area of Bluff Creek in Calif., where the Patterson/Gimlin film was shot, the redwoods have been reduced bt 98% leaving 2% of their original {at time of European discovery} area size.Georgia Pacific and later Louisiana Pacific commited this act of violence.

I'm not sure a trip to the wilds of Virginia would qualify a person to judge conditions in the PNW, would you? ;)
 
LAL said:
You didn't mention the sounds were below the range of human hearing and I had forgotten about that. It's a fairly recent discovery.

Elephants trumpet as well. That can be high-pitched and we can hear it just fine.

"high-pitched (hī'pğcht')
adj.
High in pitch, as a voice or musical tone.
Steeply sloped, as a roof.
Marked by or indicating intense emotion: a high-pitched debate."

http://www.answers.com/topic/high-pitched

Again, adaptations come about from mutations. If they confer a benefit, they tend to spread through the population. Intelligence itself came about this way.

Elephants roam in herds. Why would they need long distance communication anyway, even if they could use their intelligence to use the low sounds that way?

Am merely guessing here: perhaps the long distance calls of elephants came about for the adaptive reason of finding mates in an outgroup; finding waterholes, or yelling "Fire!". Then again perhaps these lond distance calls developed as a way to avoid expensive roaming charges?
<g>


S-o-p-h-o-m-o-r-i-c. I'll never misspell that one again
 
LAL said:
Found one of the "et als", anyway (from John Waters clear back in 1996):

"However, all available evidence
shows that hominids never used knuckle walking. Their fossils
never show the strengthened digits which are typical of knuckle
walkers.


This raises the question of how they moved on the ground. If
they did not knuckle walk, what did they do? Did they turn
somersaults? Do backflips? Cartwheels?


Sometimes orang utans do use somersaults ro progress quickly while agound.


If the Gibbon analogy has any value, then it is most probable
that they were bipedal on the ground. Not good bipedalists
perhaps, but bipedalists nevertheless.


According to all the evidence, the Gorilla/Bonobo/Chimpanzee and
their ancestors only evolved knuckle walking after their
collective split from the hominids. This raises the question of
why did they evolve knuckle walking. Why did they not become
bipedal?"
According to what I remember of the Sue Savage-Rumbaugh article, the hairier chimps and gorillas could allow infants to cling to them while traveling on all fours while on the other hand hominids ere required to hold the infant with one free hand due to lack of fur This put a burden on homonids while releasing some selection against chimps and gorillas. Our system must have had some sort of adaptive benefit in a particular context not found in the habitats of the other great apes.
http://www.anatomy.usyd.edu.au/dann...pology.paleo/archive/september-1996/0363.html
 
RayG said:
Was the tree uprooted or merely pruned a bit?



Rearranged and more deeply rooted and root pruned with question marks in our lineage instead of solid lines. The discovery of the Ardipiths shot down the idea that bipedalism evolved because the African forests retreated. Bipedalism evolved in a forested environment. A. afarensis is no longer thought to be an ancestor; they may have been a kind of cousin. The Ardipiths are now thought to be ancestors of humans, but a minority opinion had them ancestral to the pongids. Orrorin may be an ancestor to the Ardipiths and the jury seems to still be out on Kenyanthropus.

Because they aren't the same thing. You earlier suggested that a species went from bipedalism to knuckle-walking, back to bipedalism. You've provided no sources that support that suggestion.


That wasn't my suggestion. You asked if that's what I meant.

The common ancestor(s) of the Great Apes and humans were bipedal. The hominid line stayed bipedal. The Great Apes developed knuckle-walking after the split.

No one's saying a Great Ape "devolved" to bipedalism. I said I didn't think that was likely.

If Gigantopithecus was a knuckle-walker or even a fist-walker, I think that might rule it out as a Sasquatch ancestor, but the mode of locomotion can't be established for certain without more bones. Since there seems to be no lack of bipedal primates from 13 mya even to the present (counting us), there's no reason they couldn't have evolved from another species exhibiting the midtarsal bend, such as an Australopith or even something as yet undiscovered.

That's why I asked for sources and clarification.
Still looking for Stringer's comment. I remember finding that during or after a debate with an IDer/Creationist on "Lucy" after Richmond and Strait published. I deduced bipedalism was first (I'd been taught "up from the apes", of course) and was glad to see it confirmed, though a little disappointed to find out I wasn't the first to think of that. ;)

I'm hoping it wasn't in the Nature article. That's for sure been archived by now and I don't have a subsciption.
 
LAL said:
:biggrin:

I've seen plenty of clears-cuts. Too many, in fact.
Weyerhauser overcut their own lands and wanted to move into the Southeast where they had land with maturing timber so they backed the Scenic Act in the Gorge with intent to sell their lands there to the Government for top dollar. The intent of the Act was to keep development where development is. The timber industry got a lot of concessions, but even so a lot of land was set aside in National Heritage.




One other item, that I forgot to mention earlier is the forest "management' practice of spraying the clearcut land with herbicides before replanting of a monocultural tree farm.
It would seem plausible that Sasquatch may be omnivorous and even practice coprophagy as do gorillas. Food and proper nutrition may not be available for some time in these clearcuts so then some migration into Canada and Alaska might be beneficial.







The Gifford Pinot was the worst-managed National Forest in the country, according to Sierra Cubbers, but even it had plenty of areas set aside for recreation and timber sales were no longer a priority, according to a ranger friend.

I'm not sure a trip to the wilds of Virginia would qualify a person to judge conditions in the PNW, would you? ;)
 
Elephants trumpet as well. That can be high-pitched and we can hear it just fine.

Wow! I didn't know that. I thought people followed them around and played trumpets. They actually make that sound themselves?

"high-pitched (hī'pğcht')
adj.
High in pitch, as a voice or musical tone.
Steeply sloped, as a roof.
Marked by or indicating intense emotion: a high-pitched debate."

Yeah, I thought you might have been talking about roofs when you mentioned high pitch. I'm glad you cleared that up. I was wondering what bigfoot was doing up on roofs all the time. That could be dangerous.

Could you look up low pitch for me now?

Elephants roam in herds.

Oh! I thought they just didn't know where they were going and were milling around in confused family groups. Again, thanks for clearing that up.

Why would they need long distance communication anyway

To communicate over long distances regarding mating, food, water, etc.?
 
LAL said:


Mahalia Jackson received no training at all, seldom sang with an orchestra, had a four octave range and could practically (or actually) shatter glass on the high end. (My dad produced her TV show, and, as I recall, the engineers had a workout when she sang.) She said the Bible said, "Make a loud noise unto the Lord", so she did.

(Note I left out all hyphens. I was taught to use them.)

There are those lucky few who have an instinctive ability to sing with proper vocal control, and thus need no training. I believe Charlotte Church falls in this category. Still, high pitch is not the same thing as being loud. Although this further raises the question of how Bigfeet can remain so elusive, when they are shrieking to each other across great distances...?

(BTW, shattering glass is just a matter of hitting the exact frequency at which the glass resonates. )
 
LAL said:
Thanks. Mastodons and Giant Sloths didn't live in dense forest either, did they?
"During the Pleistocene Epoch, from about 1.5 million to 10,000 years ago, the world grew cold. Great sheets of ice, sometimes a thousand feet thick, moved down from the north gouging out the land. These harsh conditions seemed to encourage the development of giant mammals (Probably because larger animals are better at competing for scare resources like food). Among them were the Mastodon, and the Mammoth."
>snip<
Other Pleistocene creatures include the Gigantopithecus, a huge ape larger that current gorillas. ...snip...
One of the strangest creatures of the Pleistocene was the Megatherium, or Giant Sloth. They were huge relatives of today's tree sloth. Tree sloths are small, sleep creatures that seem to move in slow motion. They spend much of there life hanging upside down from a branch. Megatherium, in contrast, spent his life on the ground and used his size to reach up to eat in the trees.

Depends on the giant sloth species you are talking about. Some were not really that gigantic and lived in forests. Many species were about the size of a bear, or even smaller. Megatherium was among the largest. Nowdays it is belived that Megatherium used its long claws to dig for roots and tubercules. Some even consider it may occasionally have acted as a scavenger.

Gigantopithecus fossils were never found in the Americas. Neither have any fossil ape in USA and Canada dating from the Pleistocene.

And the pattern of habitat expansion -and retreat- of the habitats of these creatures is well registered by the fossil record.

Noting above serves as an explanation for the absence of bigfoot or bigfoot-related species fossils.

LAL said:
>snip<
We know that the dwarf branch of mammoths survived on Wrangel Island in the Arctic Sea north of Siberia until just 4,000 years ago. About the same time the pyramids were being raised in Egypt, the last mammoth died.

Or did it? Thirty-six hundred years later Cossack Ermak Timofeyevich was traveling among tribes on the Eastern side of the Ural mountains and heard stories about large hairy elephants. The natives used these for food referring to them by the name 'mountain of meat.'

More recently, in 1918, a story was told to the French Consul in Vladivostok, Russia, by an elderly hunter about how he tracked a huge animal for several days. When he caught up with it he found it was "a huge elephant with big white tusks, very curved. It was a dark chestnut color. It had fairly long hair on the hind quarters, but it seemed shorter on the front. I must say I had no idea that there were such big elephants."

Oh, but weren´t they a dwarf subspecies, evolved to adapt to the restricted space of an island? How come the reports are from large animals? Again, thesame problem. Reports, nothing else. No solid evidence. Could just as well be "hunter tales". You can not deny the possibility. "You should have seen the one that escaped"...

Not all megafauna animals lived in cold areas. No one actually knows why they reached that size. Competition for food favoring larger sizes is just one possibility. What would by fored bigfeet to decrese their size...
Not to mention that Wrangel Island mammoths left remains. And where are the bigfeet remains?

LAL said:
Are there other giant creatures from the pleistoncene hiding somewhere? There are stories of early European explorers seeing elephant-like creatures in North America, but there is apparently no proof. Ramon Lista, an explorer, geographer and adventurer of Argentina in the late 1800's, was convinced that South American jungles hid surviving giant sloths. He even claimed to have seen a gigantic armadillo, but was unable to kill it and bring it back to display it to civilization because his bullets just bounced off the monster's armored body. "

And you belive that? There are stories of people seeing dinosaurs in the Amazon forest, as well. Do you belive that? Giant armadillos probably were so slow that one could easilly approach and target their unprotected necks with spears. Saber-toothed cats could crack their skulls with their teeth, so a bullet would do the same. Not to mention that there are some armadillos in South America that can be over 1m long, so, confusion with an ordinary animal plus some added colorful tones can generate the report... "You should have sees the one that escaped"...

One can not also trust in reports based on local myths. An example- In northern Brazil (Amapa State), an area covered by Amzon jungle not subject to extensive flooding at the wet season, there is the legend of the mapinguari. It was "interpreted" by a number of people as a giant sloth or the equivalent of bigfoot. Yeah, right... But the original mapinguari has just one eye, among many other features that do not fit with either "interpretations". Ask the local if they ever saw one. The usual answer is "no, but my [add relative or friend-of-a-friend here] has". On occasion, you will find someone who claims to have seen one. And he/she will turn out to be one of those persons that love to tell stories, quite often not true ones.

If these myths and stories were true, in Amazonia there would be, among many others, vampire monkeys and a poisonous beetle that can saw the upper part of a palm tree. Why these are not credited by cryptozoologists, as well as headless mules that breath fire by their nostrils and giant fire snakes? There are reports of sightings and myths about them...

Just out of curiosity, do you think Charcarodon megalodon is still around? That Ogopogo and Nessie may be real? That all tales of strange man or ape-like creatures report actual creatures? That mokelembembe exists and is some species sauropod still living in Congo? Mothman? Bid bird? Phantom cats? Jersey Devil? Sea serpents? Where, how and why the line is drawn?

LAL said:
As of 1997:

"GAP: There are no known fossil hominids or apes from Africa between 14 and 4 Ma. Frustratingly, molecular data shows that this is when the African great apes (chimps, gorillas) diverged from hominids, probably 5-7 Ma. The gap may be another case of poor fossilization of forest animals. At the end of the gap we start finding some very ape-like bipedal hominids:

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq...nal/part2a.html

There have been a couple found since, but as Henry Gee put it when "Toumai" was discovered, the number of fossils from that era would fit in a shoebox.

Evidently forest animals have poor fossilization in general.

You seem not no have a good understanding of fossil research. Forest animals are fossilized also. Their fossils are found in deposits from lakes, rivers and caves that existed within the forest area. And if, the register of a given time is scarce at one area, it may be abundant at another. And animals with a broad geographical distribution are most likely to leave fossilized remains. Specially if you are taliking about a creature that lived in Asia, North America and perhaps Africa. Note that Australopitecine fossils do not come just from Olduvai Gorge, and Homo erectus and related forms have its fossils scatered over Africa, Europe and Asia. What about bigfoot and its relatives? Not a single bone. Maybe you have a shoebox from area A, but you must remember that area A is not the single place with deposits of that age.
 
Gorillagator said:




One other item, that I forgot to mention earlier is the forest "management' practice of spraying the clearcut land with herbicides before replanting of a monocultural tree farm.
It would seem plausible that Sasquatch may be omnivorous and even practice coprophagy as do gorillas. Food and proper nutrition may not be available for some time in these clearcuts so then some migration into Canada and Alaska might be beneficial.



Whoa, hang on there, Hoss! How about we establish the existence of Bigfoot, before we begin speculating about its eating habits and migration patterns?
 
LAL said:
Found one of the "et als", anyway (from John Waters clear back in 1996):

Who is John Waters? Your link leads to what appears to be newsgroup postings, and anyone can post to a newsgroup, regardless of their expertise in a particular subject.

"However, all available evidence
shows that hominids never used knuckle walking. Their fossils never show the strengthened digits which are typical of knuckle walkers.

That only seems to support my assertion that no species walked bipedally first, then evolved to knuckle-walking. Or the further assertion that they then evolved back to biped.

RayG
 
aggle-rithm said:
Whoa, hang on there, Hoss! How about we establish the existence of Bigfoot, before we begin speculating about its eating habits and migration patterns?

What? You haven't read the Sasquatch FAQ ?


http://www.bfro.net/gdb/show_FAQ.asp?id=587



Unlike the past, where we established existence and then behaviour details, we have the behaviour details all worked out and ready to apply to the aminal, once it is located..
 
LAL said:
Bipedalism evolved in a forested environment.

I'm not entirely familiar with evolutionary evidence, or bipedal history, but there were competing hypotheses on the development of bipedalism:

http://www.jqjacobs.net/anthro/paleo/bipedalism.html

Hunt, Kevin D., 1996. The postural feeding hypothesis: an ecological model for the evolution of bipedalism. South African Journal of Science 92:77-90. [The postural feeding hypothesis]

Lovejoy, C. Owen, 1981. The Origins of Man. Science 211:341-348. [The behavioral model]

Wheeler, P. E., 1991. The thermoregulatory advantages of hominid bipedalism in open equatorial environments: the contribution of increased convective heat loss and cutaneous evaporative cooling. Journal of Human Evolution 21:107-115. [The thermoregulatory model]

Is it now a general scientific consensus that bipedalism developed in forested areas?

The Great Apes developed knuckle-walking after the split.

After the split? How did they get about prior to the split?

No one's saying a Great Ape "devolved" to bipedalism. I said I didn't think that was likely.

You seemed to be claiming that bipedalism preceeded knuckle-walking in the Great Apes. You even indicated you had sources to support that claim.

RayG
 
RayG said:
....


You seemed to be claiming that bipedalism preceeded knuckle-walking in the Great Apes. You even indicated you had sources to support that claim.

RayG
I suspect that there is the suggestion that the knuckle walking post dated bipedalism but not ' walking on all fours '... i.e.. primate evolution included bipedalism, even though many primates continue to walk on all fours; some more than others.

Those that knuckle-walk , developed this after they went from walking on all fours ( fingers extended ) to the limited bipedalism that we see today.

Does that make sense?

Of course if LAL has evidence that suggests otherwise, I stand to be corrected.


P.S. Of course brachiation, wading, etc. all fits in there somewhere also..
 
Diogenes said:
What? You haven't read the Sasquatch FAQ ?


http://www.bfro.net/gdb/show_FAQ.asp?id=587



Unlike the past, where we established existence and then behaviour details, we have the behaviour details all worked out and ready to apply to the aminal, once it is located..

Wow...what a timesaver! I feel silly now.

Edited to add:

I don't suppose, when they DO find Bigfoot, and the behavior patterns turn out to be completely wrong, they would consider adapting their belief system...?

Nah. Silly thought.
 
aggle-rithm said:
Wow...what a timesaver! I feel silly now.

Edited to add:

I don't suppose, when they DO find Bigfoot, and the behavior patterns turn out to be completely wrong, they would consider adapting their belief system...?

Nah. Silly thought.

You haven't been paying attention. They don't have to adapt. They'll just say "I didn't say that." They're never wrong. You are. Get used to it.
 
RayG said:

That only seems to support my assertion that no species walked bipedally first, then evolved to knuckle-walking. Or the further assertion that they then evolved back to biped.

RayG

How does it support that?

Maybe the problem is with the word "species". The knuckle-walkers would have evolved from a prior bipedal species, IOW, they'd be a new species, not the same species developing a new trait.

I suppose it's possible for a biped to evolve from a knuckle-walker that evolved from a biped; the genes would still be there and could be expressed again, but I don't know where this has happened. Richmond and Strait thought they found evidence gracile Australopithecines evolved from a knuckle-walking ancestor because of the locking mechanism in the wrist, but that may have been an arboreal adaptation. The gracile types apparently used three kinds of locomotion, but they seem to have been primarily bipedal and arboreal much of the time.

Robust Australopiths didn't have it.
 
aggle-rithm said:
Wow...what a timesaver! I feel silly now.

Edited to add:

I don't suppose, when they DO find Bigfoot, and the behavior patterns turn out to be completely wrong, they would consider adapting their belief system...?

Nah. Silly thought.

Much can be deduced from reports and physical evidence. Even when they're finally "discovered" they'll be tough to properly observe.

Bindernagle wrote a book from the perspective of a wildlife biologist. It's a good read (I got it from the library).

"I am a wildlife biologist who is seriously studying the sasquatch (bigfoot) in North America. My interest in this animal began in 1963 when I was a third year student in wildlife management at the University of Guelph in Ontario, Canada. My field work began in 1975 when our family moved to British Columbia, partly in order for me to begin field work on this species. In 1988, my wife and I found several sasquatch tracks in good condition in the mountains not far from our home on Vancouver Island. Plaster casts which we made from these tracks provide the only tangible evidence I have for the existence of the sasquatch. But wildlife biologists regularly depend on tracks and other wildlife sign as evidence for the presence of bears, deer, wolves, and other mammals. We recognize that tracks constitute more reliable and persistent evidence of a mammal species than a fleeting glimpse of the animal itself. Although I now have no doubt regarding the existence of the sasquatch, this was not always the case. However now that I am satisfied that the sasquatch is a real animal, subject to study and examination like any other large mammal, I am much more concerned with addressing ecological questions such as how it overwinters in the colder regions of North America, than with dwelling on the controversy of whether it does or does not exist. I remain aware, however, that many people are not aware of the large volume of information that exists about this species and I understand why others are less ready than I am to treat it as a real animal. For this reason I began writing a book on the sasquatch in 1996. The book is entitled:

NORTH AMERICA'S GREAT APE: the SASQUATCH
A wildlife biologist looks at the continent's most misunderstood large mammal."

http://www.island.net/~johnb/
 
Diogenes said:
I suspect that there is the suggestion that the knuckle walking post dated bipedalism but not ' walking on all fours '... i.e.. primate evolution included bipedalism, even though many primates continue to walk on all fours; some more than others.

Those that knuckle-walk , developed this after they went from walking on all fours ( fingers extended ) to the limited bipedalism that we see today.

Does that make sense?

Of course if LAL has evidence that suggests otherwise, I stand to be corrected.


P.S. Of course brachiation, wading, etc. all fits in there somewhere also..

Primates have weird ways of getting around. Early bipeds may have spent some time on all fours and some would have brachiated, but bipedalism was a primary means of getting around as early as 13 mya in at least one species thought to be the last common ancestor.

Ardepiths, Australopiths and Orrorin were all bipeds. Knuckle- walking evidently developed after the split in the line that led to the modern Great Apes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom