Bigfoot - serious, not follies

RayG said:
Shouldn't be that hard if it's the common consensus. :D



Nope, it's news to me. I've not yet found an article where scientists speculate that a species walked upright and then became a knuckle-walker.




In the first chapter of a book entitled "Hominid Culture From A Primate Perspective" {which is a compilation of articles on different aspects of this topic written by about a dozen authors} , Sue Savage-R umbaugh does speculate that the common ancestor of humans and the African primates was bipedal and that both gorillas and the two species of chimpanzees each adopted knuckle-walking afterwards.{ I do not have the bok in front of me as it was a library book so I cannot cite the publishers or date of same}. Orangutans are not knuckle walkers but gibbons and siamangs are bipedal under many circumstances, so Rumbaugh speculates that humans gained bipedalism thru a suspensory habit while arboreal. She even cites fossils which seem to indicate bipedalism which date older than the supposed split between humans and the chimps.








Maybe it's not such common knowledge after all.



Uh, what's the difference?


Big difference. You're putting the cart before the horse, so to speak. For example, at six months age all of my children were able to crawl, but one of them started walking bipedally at the age of 9 months. It took most of the rest of them around 12 months to learn to walk upright. Just because we know the one child walked at 9 months (earlier time-line), it doesn't mean he was able to walk prior to learning to crawl.



You tossed out the statement that bipedalism preceeded knuckle-walking. ;)

RayG
[/QUOTE]
 
LTC8K6 said:
Little to hide in huh? :D



I see that my statement has caused you to lose control of any logical processing of new info. Your outrageous statements are not the logical results of my statements. Perhaps I should have said less to hide in, in their original haunts.






Little to feed on? :D


Yes, in their original territories where clearcutting has moved them out and where dams have damaged the salmon fisheries.



Sightings/photos/videos are way up then, right? Clashes with humans and other animals are way up as well as they are forced into new areas to obtain food.


Not a logical conclusion. This did not happen with other species such as the spotted owl. Instead species were seen les and thrived less, with reduced populations. The same applies to the salmon. Sightings and catches have declined dramatically as the loss of habitat increased. As a simple matter of fact the sixth extinction in which we are now embedded is partially a result of our destruction and alteration of habitats. Your conclusions are exactly opposite to logical reality.


















Bait is working very well to lure them in then, right? Incidents of stolen food are way up too, right? Campers are reporting more and more conflicts, right?



Doubtful. You are working backwards and not thinking critically. It seems that emotions have taken over your posts. Less habitat means less of the animal in question unless they are generalists and can survive as a pest species amongst humans like rats and mice.





Fights between bears and bigfoot over salmon and other scarce resources are getting more common..... bears killed by 8' tall 900 pound bigfoot are commonly found these days, aren't they?







No, not that I am aware of, but since this is irrational and illogical, I wouldn't expect such to occur.High infant mortality and cannibalism are one more logical consequence as is migation .








Maybe the bears are killing bigfoot instead? No, we'd know about that for sure, wouldn't we? Even though Bigfoot can apparently throw your average bear quite a distance, or uproot a tree and cave a bear's skull in with it.



Your bizarre speculations have little or no merit, nor do they folow from what I wrote about clear cuts of forest in the American northwest
 
LTC8K6 said:
There are plenty of fossil beds in the area.

For example, during the construction of Sea-Tac airport, a 12,000 year old giant ground sloth skeleton was found.

You also have nat'l parks, such as the John Day Fossil Beds in Oregon, and the Hagerman in Idaho.



John Day spans 40 of the 65 million years of the Cenozoic Era
They are both National Monuments, BTW, not Parks.

"Here scientists have unearthed countless fossils of land plants and animals dating back 6 to 54 million years as well as evidence of the dramatic climatic changes that have occurred."

Too old.

Hagerman:

"The environment was much different than the sagebrush landscape we see today and has been classified as savanna-like, with higher annual rainfall, isolated patches of pine woodland and abundant hardwood trees growing along the bodies of water including willow, alder, birch and elm."

http://imnh.isu.edu/digitalatlas/geog/parks/hagerman/text/mural.htm

Not forest.

Mastodon skeletons have been found in the PNW, including one with a bone projectile point in it near Sequim, WA.

American Lion bones have been found in Idaho, about 10K years old.

"Therefore, the cave lion stock that gave rise to American lions, probably entered Alaska from Siberia during the second-last (Illinoian) glaciation. Lions had penetrated the North American plains by late Illinoian or early last (Sangamonian) interglacial time. As ice of the last (Wisconsinan) glaciation (about 80,000 to 10,000 years ago) spread, American lions were isolated in unglaciated parts of the northwest (Eastern Beringia) and south. Toward the end of the last glaciation, lions ranged southeast to Florida and as far south as Mexico and Peru. Perhaps rather dense forests prevented their entering eastern Canada and the northeastern United States."

http://www.beringia.com/02/02maina5.html


Thanks. Mastodons and Giant Sloths didn't live in dense forest either, did they?

"During the Pleistocene Epoch, from about 1.5 million to 10,000 years ago, the world grew cold. Great sheets of ice, sometimes a thousand feet thick, moved down from the north gouging out the land. These harsh conditions seemed to encourage the development of giant mammals (Probably because larger animals are better at competing for scare resources like food). Among them were the Mastodon, and the Mammoth."
>snip<
Other Pleistocene creatures include the Gigantopithecus, a huge ape larger that current gorillas. Glyptodon, a giant armadillo-like animal, that had a shell some five feet in length, not including the animal's head or war club-like spiked tail it used for defense. Camelops, as the name implies, was an oversized camel that lived in North America. The Irish Elk, Megaloceros, was larger than any existing deer and had antlers that spread 13 feet across. There was also a rhinoceros, or Elasmotherium, that had a six foot long spear for its central horn.

Predators of the Pleistoncene included the Dire Wolf, Canis dirus, which was larger than current wolves, but the most famous predators were the Saber-toothed cats. Some were capable of hunting and killing even the largest Pleistoncene games like the mammoth.

One of the strangest creatures of the Pleistocene was the Megatherium, or Giant Sloth. They were huge relatives of today's tree sloth. Tree sloths are small, sleep creatures that seem to move in slow motion. They spend much of there life hanging upside down from a branch. Megatherium, in contrast, spent his life on the ground and used his size to reach up to eat in the trees.
>snip<
We know that the dwarf branch of mammoths survived on Wrangel Island in the Arctic Sea north of Siberia until just 4,000 years ago. About the same time the pyramids were being raised in Egypt, the last mammoth died.


Or did it? Thirty-six hundred years later Cossack Ermak Timofeyevich was traveling among tribes on the Eastern side of the Ural mountains and heard stories about large hairy elephants. The natives used these for food referring to them by the name 'mountain of meat.'

More recently, in 1918, a story was told to the French Consul in Vladivostok, Russia, by an elderly hunter about how he tracked a huge animal for several days. When he caught up with it he found it was "a huge elephant with big white tusks, very curved. It was a dark chestnut color. It had fairly long hair on the hind quarters, but it seemed shorter on the front. I must say I had no idea that there were such big elephants."

Are there other giant creatures from the pleistoncene hiding somewhere? There are stories of early European explorers seeing elephant-like creatures in North America, but there is apparently no proof. Ramon Lista, an explorer, geographer and adventurer of Argentina in the late 1800's, was convinced that South American jungles hid surviving giant sloths. He even claimed to have seen a gigantic armadillo, but was unable to kill it and bring it back to display it to civilization because his bullets just bounced off the monster's armored body. "

http://www.unmuseum.org/mastodon.htm

As of 1997:

"GAP: There are no known fossil hominids or apes from Africa between 14 and 4 Ma. Frustratingly, molecular data shows that this is when the African great apes (chimps, gorillas) diverged from hominids, probably 5-7 Ma. The gap may be another case of poor fossilization of forest animals. At the end of the gap we start finding some very ape-like bipedal hominids:

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-transitional/part2a.html

There have been a couple found since, but as Henry Gee put it when "Toumai" was discovered, the number of fossils from that era would fit in a shoebox.

Evidently forest animals have poor fossilization in general.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Little to hide in huh? :D



Currently, the National Wilderness Preservation System contains 106,498,016 acres, mostly in Alaska.

Logged over land is hardly overrun by people once the planting crews have gone. Deer and Elk hunters are confined to a few weeks a year and they hunt by day, staying fairly near the roads and the vehicles.

Logging in the PNW is done in a checkerboard sort of way leaving Large patches standing. There's also some selective logging. Better forest practices encourage narrow clear-cuts for erosion control. And quite a bit is preserved.

Little to feed on? :D


There's plenty to feed on, from Carpenter Ants to Deer.

Sightings/photos/videos are way up then, right? Clashes with humans and other animals are way up as well as they are forced into new areas to obtain food.


Compared to the 1920's, I'd say yes. All the videos are since then for obvious reasons. Reports are up anyway. Humans are encroaching on their territory and they may be expanding into new territory, or they could just be being seen and reported more often.

Bait is working very well to lure them in then, right?


What organizations that have even attempted that, other than the BFRO on the Skookum Meadow expedition?

There's a problem in broadcasting calls in that it's not known what they mean. They could mean something like,"Don't go there, those stupid humans are back." ;)

Incidents of stolen food are way up too, right?


I haven't read any reports of that.

Campers are reporting more and more conflicts, right?


Not conflicts, but there have been a few sightings by campers, and one where a huge hairy hand reached into the tent.

Fights between bears and bigfoot over salmon and other scarce resources are getting more common..... bears killed by 8' tall 900 pound bigfoot are commonly found these days, aren't they?


I mentioned the nocturnal lifestyle may have evolved as a means of avoiding competition with bears, didn't I?

Maybe the bears are killing bigfoot instead? No, we'd know about that for sure, wouldn't we? Even though Bigfoot can apparently throw your average bear quite a distance, or uproot a tree and cave a bear's skull in with it.

I vaguely recall one report of a fight between a bear and a Sasquatch, but then I haven't read all 8000+ reports. They probably practice mutual avoidance. Black Bear aren't aggressive except where a sow is defending cubs, e.g..
 
Gorillagator said:
Your bizarre speculations have little or no merit, nor do they folow from what I wrote about clear cuts of forest in the American northwest

:biggrin:

I've seen plenty of clears-cuts. Too many, in fact.
Weyerhauser overcut their own lands and wanted to move into the Southeast where they had land with maturing timber so they backed the Scenic Act in the Gorge with intent to sell their lands there to the Government for top dollar. The intent of the Act was to keep development where development is. The timber industry got a lot of concessions, but even so a lot of land was set aside in National Heritage.

The Gifford Pinot was the worst-managed National Forest in the country, according to Sierra Cubbers, but even it had plenty of areas set aside for recreation and timber sales were no longer a priority, according to a ranger friend.

I'm not sure a trip to the wilds of Virginia would qualify a person to judge conditions in the PNW, would you? ;)
 
RayG said:
Shouldn't be that hard if it's the common consensus. :D

I'm trying to find the article where Stringer said it was. That's what I was challenged on. Having used it at least twice on AOL's Creationism-Evolution boards, I know I've got it. I just don't know where. Some articles only have the URL for a title, so that doesn't help much. I'm trying to remember what it was in regards to; that would help narrow it down.

I only get asked to produce a source when I can't find the darn thing. :book:

Nope, it's news to me. I've not yet found an article where scientists speculate that a species walked upright and then became a knuckle-walker.

Maybe it's not such common knowledge after all.


It's been kind of big news since the "family tree" got uprooted by the discovery of new fossil bipeds, which confirmed the speculation.
Uh, what's the difference?

Big difference. You're putting the cart before the horse, so to speak. For example, at six months age all of my children were able to crawl, but one of them started walking bipedally at the age of 9 months. It took most of the rest of them around 12 months to learn to walk upright. Just because we know the one child walked at 9 months (earlier time-line), it doesn't mean he was able to walk prior to learning to crawl.


Excuse me for being exceptionally dense, but what does that have to do with the Great Apes developing knuckle walking as a later adaptation, i.e. after the split, rather than hominids developing bipedalism after evolving from a knuckle-walking ancestor?

You tossed out the statement that bipedalism preceeded knuckle-walking. ;)

RayG

It did.

I seem to have been hugely misunderstood, somehow.
 
LTC8K6 said:
It seems bigfoot is not as smart as an elephant, who knows that it's low frequencies that are good for that. :D

Animals don't develop adaptations through intelligence; adaptations come about from mutations.

High pitch is not unusual in primates.

Ever hear a hog-caller? Or a Chimpanzee screeching? Or Leontyne Price?
 
The Gifford Pinot was the worst-managed National Forest in the country, according to Sierra Cubbers

Pinchot

Clubbers

Unnecessary hyphen

:D

Are you sure it was me who couldn't get out of high school, Lu? :D

The Sierra Club? ROTFLMAO

Gorillagator, since you seem to have completely missed my point, I won't bother to respond. Lu got it, though. Thank goodness.

Lu, why is it that you only hear the bass when one of those idiots with the 2,000 watt stereo system drives by?

What about a trip to Ft. Lewis, Lu? :D
 
http://www.nps.gov/joda/paleonews1.htm

Evidence of the last known primate to inhabit North America prior to humans has recently surfaced among the field collections from the 1997 fossil prospecting season at John Day Fossil Beds National Monument.

That's a pretty cool find, actually.

I actually still have a few of the fossils my father collected as a hobby many years ago. I may go and look through them again for the memories.
 
LAL said:

High pitch is not unusual in primates.

Ever hear a hog-caller? Or a Chimpanzee screeching? Or Leontyne Price?

You're either comparing Leontyne Price to a chimpanzee (which is racist) or saying that Bigfoot has a beautiful singing voice (which is ludicrous). ;)

Seriously, I have sat in on a master class by Leontyne Price, back when I was a music major. I can tell you with a fair amount of authority that her ability to be heard over great distance has nothing to do with a high-pitched voice, but the same careful training that all opera singers receive, which allows them to be heard over an orchestra.
 
That's an odd coincidence, aggle-rithm. I am following a discussion on another board where amplitude and frequency seem to be being mixed up......

Bill quips:
It seems bigfoot is not as smart as an elephant, who knows that it's low frequencies that are good for that. :D

Lu responds:
Animals don't develop adaptations through intelligence; adaptations come about from mutations.

There I was being a smart-aleck, and Lu completely missed it...

Oh well.

At any rate, it's certainly possible that elephants adapted their ability to make LF sound into a form of communication. They would have done so through their intelligence.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Pinchot

Clubbers

Unnecessary hyphen

:D

Typos I missed because I was in a hurry (I really can't type) and why is the hyphen unnecessary?

Are you sure it was me who couldn't get out of high school, Lu? :D

No, I just recall misspelling "sophomoric" as in "humor". I didn't say anyone couldn't get out of high school. On the boards I'm used to, criticizing spelling and grammar is against Community Standards.
The Sierra Club? ROTFLMAO

What's funny about the Sierra Club? My ranger friend, who was in charge of checking out reproduction that was only there on paper pretty much confirmed that.......before he shot himself. They were allowing 3% over the allowable cut annually.
Gorillagator, since you seem to have completely missed my point, I won't bother to respond. Lu got it, though. Thank goodness.

Lu, why is it that you only hear the bass when one of those idiots with the 2,000 watt stereo system drives by?

That's a lot lower than an elephant's trumpet, isn't it? Seems I've read elephants may communicate with sounds that are below the range of human hearing. Got anything on that?
What about a trip to Ft. Lewis, Lu? :D

Ft. Lewis? A friend of mine used to date the sargeant who ran the floating crap game there...........probably before your time. Ft. Lewis is on the "corridor" that has most of Washington's population.
 
LTC8K6 said:
That's an odd coincidence, aggle-rithm. I am following a discussion on another board where amplitude and frequency seem to be being mixed up......

Exactly! I think the confusion comes from the fact that greater frequency tends to make greater amplitude easier to achieve.
 
aggle-rithm said:
You're either comparing Leontyne Price to a chimpanzee (which is racist) or saying that Bigfoot has a beautiful singing voice (which is ludicrous). ;)

None of the above. I was giving examples of primates who can deliver high pitched sounds. I would have said Beverly Sills if I'd known you'd make something out of that, but I couldn't think of her name at the time.
Seriously, I have sat in on a master class by Leontyne Price, back when I was a music major. I can tell you with a fair amount of authority that her ability to be heard over great distance has nothing to do with a high-pitched voice, but the same careful training that all opera singers receive, which allows them to be heard over an orchestra.

Mahalia Jackson received no training at all, seldom sang with an orchestra, had a four octave range and could practically (or actually) shatter glass on the high end. (My dad produced her TV show, and, as I recall, the engineers had a workout when she sang.) She said the Bible said, "Make a loud noise unto the Lord", so she did.

(Note I left out all hyphens. I was taught to use them.)
 
LTC8K6 said:

Lu responds:


There I was being a smart-aleck, and Lu completely missed it...

Oh well.



Miss you being a smart-aleck? Never.
 
LTC8K6 said:
There is also Kennewick man, of course.

We'd all love to know what he witnessed in his lifetime.

I'd like to know his origins. He was found to be unrelated to any modern tribe.

"Maybe the bones were not those of a European, but belonged to a long-dead American Indian whose ancestors migrated to America as early as 10,000 years ago. But, another anthropologist, Grover Krantz of Washington State University, confirmed that the bones did not match any existing tribe in the area or any western Native American type."

http://www.crf-usa.org/bria/bria14_1.html

Same Dr. Krantz.
 
LAL said:
It's been kind of big news since the "family tree" got uprooted by the discovery of new fossil bipeds, which confirmed the speculation.

Was the tree uprooted or merely pruned a bit?

Excuse me for being exceptionally dense, but what does that have to do with the Great Apes developing knuckle walking as a later adaptation, i.e. after the split, rather than hominids developing bipedalism after evolving from a knuckle-walking ancestor?

Because they aren't the same thing. You earlier suggested that a species went from bipedalism to knuckle-walking, back to bipedalism. You've provided no sources that support that suggestion.

I seem to have been hugely misunderstood, somehow.

That's why I asked for sources and clarification.

RayG
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom