Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Re: Re: Is this supposed to be a joke, LAL?

LAL said:
What makes you think they were on the ground for a long time? They're very long and heavy. It would it be difficult to get the cameras tied on. One of the posters on the thread mentioned the possibility of rot at the base as a cause of them going over. One has lost bark, but it doesn't look at all rotted in the bare patches. It looks like Red Alder, which gets to 85',with a high crown.

"Wood stain and decay proceed rapidly in cut trees, and logs should be processed soon after harvest unless they are stored in fresh water (43). During intermediate cuts, care must be taken to avoid injuring residual trees; once trees are injured, decay organisms can invade rapidly."


http://forestry.about.com/library/silvics/blsilalrub.htm

Those weren't down long. If they had been, they'd be covered in ground- growing club moss. See that in the pictures, and the leaves. Pretty hard to find tracks in stuff like that.
On my place in Washington I had dead trees standing for many years. There was a spar tree up the hill that had been standing dead at least since logging in the fifties. Saplings would go over part way and then hang caught in the branches of a nearby tree and stay there.

Do you know who set the cameras (that should be easy to figure out - no coaching from the audience)? Why would you leap to a conclusion of a hoax, especially from a false premise? He did not claim something pushed them over; he wondered if that was a possibility. They were broken off 12" below the ground.

He's not only a researcher, he's a very careful and wary one.

Aside from falling trees there's the possibility of someone stealing the cameras.




After seeing the pictures of the trees, it seems quite simple to conclude that they had been felled or had fallen quite recently.
The certainly showsigns of not having been on the ground very long, though it looks as if they were dead, standing wood, prior to falling over or being pushed down.

As a sidenote I would lke to point out that in1978 , the Univ. of British Columbia Museum of Anthropology held a seminar entitled Proceedings of the conference of "Sasquatch and other Phenomenon", which was later published as a book called 'Manlike Monsters on Trial: Early Sasquatch and Modern Evidence"[ edited by Marjorie Halpin and Michael M. Ames] Vancouver: Univ. Of British Columbia Press, 1980
Grover Krantz, a professor of anthropology at Washington State Univ., has personally analyzed many purported tracks and has declared that some are genuine.
One last word of advice from noted ecologist , Robert Michael Pyle, as related to Bigfoot: " To dismiss the unknown out of hand is more foolish than accepting it unquestioned..."
 
LAL said:

That's what everybody says, even the the scientists who are convinced. "Inconclusive" doesn't mean "pure bunk", however. ;) [/B]

Helo Lu. I've come across info which declares that it was Grover Krantz, { possibly among others}the Columbia University anthropolgist who has hypothesiszed that Biigfoot represents a living population of Gigantopithecus[from "Where Bigfoot Walks: Crossing the Dark Divide" , by Robert Michael Pyle- a Yale PHD of ecology.]
 
Gorillagator said:
Helo Lu. I've come across info which declares that it was Grover Krantz, { possibly among others}the Columbia University anthropolgist who has hypothesiszed that Biigfoot represents a living population of Gigantopithecus[from "Where Bigfoot Walks: Crossing the Dark Divide" , by Robert Michael Pyle- a Yale PHD of ecology.]

Yep. The size is a match and the mode of locomotion is unknown.
Small correction: Krantz was at Washington State. He's written a book and numerous papers. He led the fight to obtain Kennewick Man for study.
 
Neither Hall nor Parker were members of the BFRO. The frustration was noted at having to call it off because many had a long drive home. It was a combined effort of the TBRO and the BFRO.

That is already noted in the link provided.

It's no wonder they will never find bigfoot. Every time they get within hours or even minutes of a live one, they quit the game. :D

It's too bad there is nothing to connect Bigfoot to GB, and it's also too bad that GB most likely was not bipedal.

It's a shame that Krantz was allowed to pull this out of thin air without much criticism.
 
Why isn't there a large population of bigfoot?

It has virtually no competition at all. It is under no hunting pressure from humans or other animals. It has a huge range available and an ample food supply available. It has ample area for shelter.

It is at the top of the food chain. Possibly a large grizzly could kill one, but I doubt that.

It is supposedly intelligent. Intelligent enough to almost totally avoid conflict with the only other animal that could possibly harm it. In any case, it is physically superior in every way to that species even if it were regularly coming into conflict with it.

It is not being killed off rapidly by disease or we'd find a body or three.

There is no control at all on the population of bigfoot that I can see. The population should be increasing at a decent rate.

It should really be exploding.
 
LTC8K6 said:
That is already noted in the link provided.

It's no wonder they will never find bigfoot. Every time they get within hours or even minutes of a live one, they quit the game. :D

It's too bad there is nothing to connect Bigfoot to GB, and it's also too bad that GB most likely was not bipedal.

It's a shame that Krantz was allowed to pull this out of thin air without much criticism.

Dinner theatre- Act 2

Operation Primate Web 2: Electric Bugaloo

Early evening, on the last day of the expedition. Daryl Coyler, Expedition Leader, calls the team together.

Daryl: "OK, gang... listen up! We've done some amazing work over these last few days. We've got recordings of Bigfoot howling, and we've actually spotted the beast! Bigfoot is in the area, we've got the whole team assembled, and we've got all the gear and gadgetry we need to make a positive identification. We're this close to the greatest zoological discovey of the century!"

Guy in the blaze orange vest: "Yeah... that's great and all, but it's really cold out here."

Camo guy: "My feet are sore, and this backpack is giving me a rash."

Unidentified voice in the crowd: "My plumbing supply shop isn't going to run itself."

Another chimes in: "It'll be dark soon."

Girl sitting on a cooler: "I've got a long drive and there'll probably be traffic."

Daryl: "Yeah, you're right. I gotta go to work tomorrow, and I'm useless if I don't get my eight hours. Let's pack it up!"
 
http://www.bfro.net/gdb/show_FAQ.asp?id=584

I had no idea they knew so much about bigfoot.

Links for anatomy, physiology, and behavior with very complete information.

All that from some footprints and some unknown primate hairs?

Amazing. Fahrenbach is incredible.

They knew all of this in 2002 as well.

And yet they still abandon searches within inches of the goal, even though they believe so strongly and proof would be one of the biggest events ever.

Anyone finding proof wouldn't need to go back to work, or worry about the long drive home, or worry about money for research or for themselves ever again.

Still they go home when they know their quarry was in their presence just minutes or hours ago.
 
LTC8K6 said:
http://www.bfro.net/gdb/show_FAQ.asp?id=584

I had no idea they knew so much about bigfoot.

Links for anatomy, physiology, and behavior with very complete information.

All that from some footprints and some unknown primate hairs?

Amazing. Fahrenbach is incredible.

They knew all of this in 2002 as well.

And yet they still abandon searches within inches of the goal, even though they believe so strongly and proof would be one of the biggest events ever.

Anyone finding proof wouldn't need to go back to work, or worry about the long drive home, or worry about money for research or for themselves ever again.

Still they go home when they know their quarry was in their presence just minutes or hours ago.



Reminds me of the Mysterious Encounters TV show where they were sitting around at night when a "bigfoot" started banging on their parked truck.
Now they drive around the continent looking for bigfoot, so you would think this would make then happy. But instead of sticking around with the object of their search about 20 feet away, and using some of the fancy night vision equipment they are always bragging about, they get in their truck and drive away screaming.
 
All that being said, if our enormous hypothetical Bigfoot exists after all, when they locate it, it'll probably turn out to be four feet tall and weigh sixty pounds.

"Foot Length

Foot prints are the standard stock in trade of sasquatch research, and their sometimes inhuman length assures almost immediate measurement, even by first time witnesses. In all cases, the flat sasquatch foot print corresponds to a human foot outline rather than a human walking print, in which the arch may not touch a hard surface. Comparison of prints in a sasquatch trackway show a common tendency of the toes to be curled, thereby shortening the measured foot somewhat.

A collection of 706 footprints yielded an average length of 15.6" and a range of 4" to 27" (Fig. 1). The statistical treatment implies that more than 99% of the foot prints of this population are going to fall between 6" and 25". The graphic representation of the distribution is a bell-shaped curve, slightly more peaked than a normal distribution. This shape argues compellingly that the data originated from a single species rather than a multitude of overlapping species of different characteristics. It also means that they were not produced fictitiously over 40 years by hundreds of people independently of each other, a process that would have generated a distribution with many peaks.

The slightly peaked nature of the curve suggests that the difference between mature male and female does not exceed 2" in foot length, or about a foot in height, on the average. The largest prints are most probably from males, also supported by eyewitness reports of such animals being more facially hirsute and devoid of breasts. The slight asymmetry of the curve to the left might be attributable to the contribution of juveniles smaller than the population mean and their attrition before adulthood.

As a telling comparison, the published set of data by Napier has been compared to this set (prior to its inclusion). The average length of its 59 foot prints is 15.5" and, thus, deviates by merely 0.1" from the larger population average.

Many of the data points represent a single measurement out of a trackway that might have extended over many yards or in some cases over several miles, where the ground and expertise of the investigator allowed uninterrupted tracking.

Undoubtedly, only a small fraction of the population of any species is ever represented by recorded foot prints, especially in forested terrain. With a life expectancy of around 40 years (see below), this collection of 706 prints over 40 years speaks of a substantial population, probably in the "low thousands", as speculated by Krantz."

And:

"Chest Dimensions

There is, however, a scaling formula for primates that relates chest circumference to weight. This relationship, derived from data from marmosets to gorillas, can be applied to the sasquatch provided its chest circumference is known (Fig. 6). For the Patterson sasquatch, chest circumference can be extracted from enlarged prints of film images, which contain the 14.5" foot as a scale reference. From these, a chest width of 22" and a depth of 16" results, which corresponds to a weight of about 540 lbs. This weight is subject to considerable error, but clearly eliminates many of the high and low estimates from consideration.

Other Dimensions

For the sake of completeness, some other dimensions of the Patterson sasquatch that can be extracted from selected film frames, are cited here: Shoulder width: 33"; hip width: 24"; upper arm circumference: 22"; upper thigh circumference: 31"; knee circumference: 27"; [and from other sources] hand width at palm (with 16" footprint): 6"; wrist to base of fingers: 7"; wrist to end of middle finger: 11".

Weight Extrapolation

On the assumption that chest circumference scales linearly with height of the animal, I have scaled the Patterson values (slightly below the mean as a female) to the calculated mean heights and generated a foot print / height / weight table (rounded values). The mean is represented by the 15.6" foot print.

Foot Height Chest Weight (lbs)

12" 7’ 0" 58" 490
14" 7’ 6" 62" 580
15.6" 7’ 10" 65" 660
16" 7’ 11" 65" 670
18" 8’ 4" 69" 770
20" 8’ 8" 72" 850
22" 9’ 1" 75" 950
24" 9’ 5" 77" 1,040"

http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/WHF/sasq_traits.htm
 
LTC8K6 said:
That is already noted in the link provided.

It's no wonder they will never find bigfoot. Every time they get within hours or even minutes of a live one, they quit the game. :D

It's too bad there is nothing to connect Bigfoot to GB, and it's also too bad that GB most likely was not bipedal.

It's a shame that Krantz was allowed to pull this out of thin air without much criticism.

He based his conclusions on the width of the jaw; a wide jaw would allow passage of a verticle spinal column. Giganto is only known from a few jaws and a thousand teeth. No foramen magnum, no femur. No way to definitely establish the mode of locomotion at this time.

But, bipedalism came first, according to the consensus with knuckle-walking a later adaptation in the Great Apes (there's no fossil record for Gorillas or Chimpanzees, incidently). There are over a dozen species of bipedal primates in the fossil record not including Homo. Bipedalism was the "rule", not the exception.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Why isn't there a large population of bigfoot?

It has virtually no competition at all. It is under no hunting pressure from humans or other animals. It has a huge range available and an ample food supply available. It has ample area for shelter.

It is at the top of the food chain. Possibly a large grizzly could kill one, but I doubt that.

It is supposedly intelligent. Intelligent enough to almost totally avoid conflict with the only other animal that could possibly harm it. In any case, it is physically superior in every way to that species even if it were regularly coming into conflict with it.

It is not being killed off rapidly by disease or we'd find a body or three.

There is no control at all on the population of bigfoot that I can see. The population should be increasing at a decent rate.

It should really be exploding.

BIP: So it's just guesswork to say these creatures are on the verge extinction?

JG: Oh, that's ridiculous. They're not under any pressure at all. They obviously have never been numerous. It's certainly a possibility that the population was knocked down by the same diseases that wiped out so many of the Indians. They would presumably be susceptible to them just as the great apes are. But as to anything that's happening today causing them to become extinct, you can't make any case for that at all."

http://www.bigfootproject.org/interviews/john_green.html
 
LAL said:


But, bipedalism came first, according to the consensus with knuckle-walking a later adaptation in the Great Apes (there's no fossil record for Gorillas or Chimpanzees, incidently). There are over a dozen species of bipedal primates in the fossil record not including Homo. Bipedalism was the "rule", not the exception.
What consensus are you talking about? Sources ?
 
LTC8K6 said:
The wide jaw was likely to support the big molars and powerful jaw necessary for GB to get enough to eat. It may not indicate a very large body at all.

And it may not have been a specialized bamboo eater:

"Ciochon et al., (1990) then go on to compare this morphology with that of the giant panda, another bamboo eater, and infers a diet of bamboo for Gigantopithecus.

While bamboo is a grass, the phytolith analysis does not technically either confirm or deny this theory, since it is not capable of defining the type of grass the phytolith came from. What was surprising to Ciochon was the suggestion of fruit in the diet of Gigantopithecus. Ciochon et al (2) (1990) have identified the fruit as belonging to a species in the family Moraceae or a closely related family and state "Judging from the present frequency of dental phytoliths in Gigantopithecus, fruits may have constituted a significant portion of the diet," and go on to note that the high sugar content of this type of fruit may be responsible for the high incidence of cavities in Gigantopithecus teeth (11%).

The results of this study are reported in less complete and less technical terms in the book Other Origins (Ciochon et al, 1990), and in a review of that book Jeffrey H. Schwartz (1991) notes that a great deal is being drawn from the analysis of four teeth, upon only two of which were found phytoliths, with the greatest concentration on only one. Clearly a larger sample of teeth need to be similarly analyzed, but reading the report it is difficult not to share Ciochon's (et al. (2) 1990) excitement at the findings and for the employment of this technique in paleoanthropology in general."


And:


"Appearance

According to Ciochon et al. (1990), Gigantopithecus blacki was 10 feet tall and weighed 1,200 pounds. This is speculative, since it is with some uncertainty that one reconstructs such a massive creature from a few jaw bones and teeth, however many. The way they arrived at this picture was first to estimate the size of the head from the jaw, and then to use a head/body ratio of 1:6.5 in order to determine the body size. For comparison they cite a head/body ratio of 1:8 for the Australopithecus afarensis specimen known as 'Lucy'. The more conservative ratio for Gigantopithecus was arrived at out of consideration of the massive jaw as an adaptation to the mastication of fibrous plant matter (probably bamboo). Gigantopithecus was probably proportionally a markedly big jawed creature. For the head shape they based their assumptions on the orangutan, since evolutionarily they place Gigantopithecus on the same line as the orangutan, finding a common ancestor for them both in Sivapithecus. However, the orangutan could not serve as a model for the body, since it is unlikely that a 1,200 pound ape would be as arboreal. Therefore they chose the largest primates known, the gorilla and the extinct giant baboon Theropithecus oswaldi, as their models for the body. They gave Gigantopithecus an intermembral index 108 (gorilla at 120 + Theropithecus at 95 divide by 2 = 108 rounded up - very scientific!) (Ciochon et al., 1990)."

http://www.wynja.com/arch/gigantopithecus.html

Giganto seems a likely candidate due to location and size (even if reduced somewhat) if it was bipedal.
 
LTC8K6 said:
No it doesn't, it's just that little is known about it and this allows you to make it fit.

I'm not solidily on the side of Gigantopithecus (haven't we been through this before?). Napier thought Sasquatches could be descended from A. robustus. At least there's more known about the Australopiths, and there's the matter of the midtarsal bend.
 
LTC8K6 said:
Is this really a possibility? I don't think so. I doubt that there were the same sort of contacts involved.

Whole villages that had never seen a white man died of the white man's diseases.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom