Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Psiload said:
Time for a little dinner theatre:

LAL arrives at BFRO headquarters one bright, sunny morning and notices that a co-worker's cubicle has been cleaned out.

LAL (to boss): Hey, what happened to Ralph?

Boss: He was terminated for drug use. The results of his urinalysis came back negative. The lab could not identify any known contraband substances in his system.

LAL (shaking head): Tsk tsk. He was obviously hopped up on some exotic new designer scag they couldn't identify.

Boss: Yeah, obviously. A real shame. You think you know a person.
:roll:
 
LAL said:
There's a report of a near collision in Don Hunter's book (with Dahinden). The animal calmly inspected the vehicle afterward. There's a similar report from Minnesota. There are probably many more. I was looking for something else when I found those.

Pumas, jaguars, wolves and deer are hit by cars. Unfortunately, even when their populations are small, as pointed by UrsulaV. I should also add the case of "nomadic" jaguars in Southeastern Brazil. These animals live close to large cites at Minas Gerais state. The area, that I´ve been working in since the early 90s, is composed by a mixture of grazing fields, tropical rainforests and three or two types of bush vegetation. There are intense mining activities, several small rural properties as well as several trekking, mountaineering, biking and caving sites in state parks and environmental reserves.The jaguars forage on armadillos, agouti and the occasional cow. To avoid being hunted (what is no longer allowed), the animals developed a nomadic lifestyle. Instead having a fixed territory, they are constantly moving, never staying for too long at a single place. They are a realtively frequent sight. I´ve lost count of the jaguar tracks I found. Some years ago a young couple entered a hotel room, on a very funny incident. Unfortunately, sometimes one becomes roadkills. Population estimates are between 30 to 100 individuals. This figure, as well as the description of their habits, were provided some years ago by a friend who works in a government environmental preservation organization. Now, compare this with the evidence left by bigfoot, specially when it comes to their inferred density population...

LAL said:
If one is lucky enough to hit it. The standard reaction seems to be panic and slamming on the brakes.

To panic and slam the brakes at a gravel road is not a good idea. Assuming you do not completely loose control of the car, it´s wheels will lock -unless its ABS- and the car will slide towards the animal, hitting it. Even if the car has ABS system, the smaller attriction coeficient from unpaved roads will increase the breaking distance. A roadkill bigfoot should have come out so far.

LAL said:
Ishi's people were undetected in California as well, also for fifteen years.

Of course, our government isn't looking for Sasquatches. They range singly and in small family groups. There was a kind of "feeding lot" found near Nelson Creek after the sighting April 16th. They do leave sign.

But there are plenty of people who work in the field -many hired by the government, other by private companies, even in remote areas. Wildlife photographers, biologists, botanics, zoologists, surveyors, geologists, etc. And plenty of people who go to remote areas to have fun: hunters, amateur photographers, mountaineers, climbers, etc. All these people carry equipment that could be used to obtain good records of their existence. Not just some blurry pictures of fuzzy things.

LAL said:
Peter Bryne gave up on trying to track them for reasons I've already gone over on this board. Some dogs freeze, but some seem sensitive to the smell. They could be useful. They could also give advance warning.

There's been better success with luring:

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/pnw_newsle...alExpedMain.htm

People hunt jaguars with dogs. Acting as a group, the dogs surround the cat. Dogs can guide a herd of cattle and face bulls. Don´t you think its a bit weird to say they freeze when facing a big ape? Are you sure the reports of such diferent behavior are not due to incidents involving dogs of different races and/or creation? A pincher raised inside an apartment would be more likely to freeze when seeing a wild animal, even if its a deer... "My dog just froze" is nothing really extraordinary in this case.

So, why not just set baits with motion-activated remote cameras nearby? Some hunters set them to know what sort of game they can count on. Why none of them managed to catch a snapshot of bigfoot walking around? Note that some of these are IR cams. No flash needed. Do you really belive the bigfeet are so smart that they can evade or destroy them all? Humans, as far as I´m concerned, quite often are caught by these cameras...

LAL said:
See the notes. The Pacific Northwest has so much water it would be hard to know where to start. There are lakes, streams, rivers, no water holes that I remember. Mud wallow in Skookum Meadow, yes.

Find a place where animals gather to drink (tracks will tell you where they are). Animals -specially those who walk in packs- tend to drink water at selected spots, where the river banks make access to the water easier and/or allow the whole pack to drink at once for example. Predators quite often also go to these places, either to drink or to feed on those who are drinking. Find a well-used trail. Place remote cameras at these places or stay there awaiting. If nothing shows up, accept that there´s nothing there.

LAL said:
Skamania County had the first ordinance ever in this country. It made us kind of famous for a while. Not many people know about it. There's one in B.C., as I recall.

The mayor of a city here in Brazil once built a "saucerport" to receive our friendly alien neighbours back in the 80s. He got some publicity and turists, but no landings so far. Maybe because there are no aliens around.

LAL said:
You might want to ask Bob Gimlin about getting rich and famous. (He sold his rights to the film for $26.) Or Bobby Clarke. Seems no one but the Cree in Norway House is following up.

Maybe because there are no bigfeet around.

LAL said:
There's a report of a decaying body being found by two little girls who decided they'd better not say anything. One reported it when she grew up.

Wouldn´t they be relative to those girls who took pictures if faires? Memories change with time, so it´s not exactly a good piece of evidence. They could have seen the carcass of anything -if indeed they saw something.

LAL said:
Gorillas were once thought to be a Native myth. There seems to be a new and very large Chimpanzee species in the Congo. Native tales of "Lioncrushers" were dismissed there, too.

And gorillas were found and described. An expedition went to their habitat, hired some local guides and shoot a couple of gorillas. Now, compare the resources and the technology avaliable to those who found the gorillas to what´s at today´s biologists and hunters reach. Some equipments nowdays at use were not even dreamt a few decades ago. And still, no bigfoot was captured, alive or dead.

Regarding the new chimp species, the reports are not confirmed. But, even if a new species is found, it will actually do no good for the big foot cause. Why? Scientists can find a new large ape species in Congo - a logistical nightmare (name a problem: access, equipment maintenance, endemic diseases, politics, etc. and you´ll find it there). However, a species of 2+meter high apes manages to elude scientists, hunters, (both pro and amateur) wildlife photographers and trucks in USA... And something between 2000 to 14000 of them are supposed to exist.

LAL said:
I'm not saying no bodies of anything are ever found. It's possible Sasquatch bodies have been seen but mistaken for bear from a distance, which are seldom if ever found dead either, in the PNW, even by Rangers.

And no one ever comes close enough to notice the difference? Rangers surely might want to know why the bears died (disease, poacher activity, etc.).

LAL said:
It has, by all of the above. Depends on what you regard as "solid", I guess.

The definitive one: a body (or part of one); but good quality footage would be a start.

LAL said:
I lived near a national forest. There was one patrol car to cover the north end of the county (Mt. St. Helens is in it). The Sheriff's department opposed the national monument because they didn't want to have to outfit another officer to keep track of tourists. Rangers stuck to their stations unless they were doing a timber cruise, tourists (there weren't many until the Scenic Act was passed over the citizens' screaming objections) stuck to campgrounds and trails. Berry pickers stuck to the Huckleberry fieds, and mushroom hunters looked for Chantrelles by day, not Sasquatches at night. Even so, Skamania County has the highest number of documented sightings in the "lower 48".

I liked the story of the ranger (in California, I think) who said if there was anything like that around, he'd have seen it, and then drove right by a trackway covered in plastic awaiting casting.

But still, people see, take pictures, find tracks and bodies of bears, pumas, deer, wolves, etc. Why wildlife photographers have not yet produced nice images of these animals? These guys spend months in the field, tracking animals during the day and the night .

And ever considered the possibility that, assuming the ranger story is true, he drove over the track because he realised they were not out of the ordinary?

LAL said:
A mushroom hunter was separated from his friends and lost in the Gifford Pinchot on talus not long before I left the state. They knew where to look, approximately, but his remains weren't found until the following spring. A young hunter was lost in Oregon around the same time, also with companions, in comparatively open woodland. Despite extensive searching, even after the official search was called off, his body was discovered accidently the next year. These people wanted to be found. A couple of dozen aircraft have vanished in the PNW. Why aren't all these hikers and berry pickers and hunters bringing back pieces of planes?

Oh, but the bodies were found, weren´t they? Even if by accident, a long time ago. And note that you can´t say "they wanted to be found". Dead people don´t want anything. Not all lost people know how to act if they get lost, many manage to bring themselves in to greater problems. People are accidented in places that are very hard to spot, heavy rain and river currents may carry a body, snow may cover it. An important point is that the bodies were found a long time later, they were not found during the extensive organised search. What shows us scavenger activity was not enough to terminate the remains. And that bigfeet corpses should be found, even if their numbers are small, and found even by people who were not looking for them...

LAL said:
They are at least good enough to indicate they're probably not of something else. The PGF remains the best and it's held up to scrutiny for close to forty years.

Here are some more questions to help you out

Not really. There are plenty of much better amateur pictures and films from real animals. Specially nowdays, with the proliferation of digital cameras.
 
RayG said:
Regarding hair analysis by Dr. Fahrenbach:

Hair analysis seems to be going nowhere.

RayG


Yep. Tissue is needed.

How many humans do you know, blonde or otherwise, shed hair of the length described that has never been cut?

Fahrenbach has also said he has a dozen he's willing to identify as Sasquatch. At least they know what it isn't.

I would expect hair of a close relative to resemble human hair. It isn't fur. How many other primates are there in North America besides us?

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair of the particular structure (great variability is available among the latter). DNA extracted from both hair shaft or roots (hair demonstrably fresh) was too fragmented to permit gene sequencing. That characteristic is also sometimes found in human hair that lacks the medulla (as does sasquatch hair - at least what I am willing to identify as such)."

http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/WHF/dnatests.htm
 
Correa Neto said:


>snip<

This figure, as well as the description of their habits, were provided some years ago by a friend who works in a government environmental preservation organization. Now, compare this with the evidence left by bigfoot, specially when it comes to their inferred density population...



It would be great if any US government agency would fund someone like that.


To panic and slam the brakes at a gravel road is not a good idea. Assuming you do not completely loose control of the car, it´s wheels will lock -unless its ABS- and the car will slide towards the animal, hitting it. Even if the car has ABS system, the smaller attriction coeficient from unpaved roads will increase the breaking distance. A roadkill bigfoot should have come out so far.



Should? Read some of the reports. A sighting that got me interested in this was by a man named Cox who drove out of a fog bank on Hwy 14 (paved) east of Beacon Rock about 3:30 AM.
The creature stepped 8' up a bank, confirmed by the tracks. ( I knew one of the deputies involved and recently found the story in Sasquatch/Bigfoot; The Search For North America's Incredible Creature, by Don Hunter with René Dahinden.)

How long would it take one to get across a road with a stride like that?


But there are plenty of people who work in the field -many hired by the government, other by private companies, even in remote areas. Wildlife photographers, biologists, botanics, zoologists, surveyors, geologists, etc. And plenty of people who go to remote areas to have fun: hunters, amateur photographers, mountaineers, climbers, etc. All these people carry equipment that could be used to obtain good records of their existence. Not just some blurry pictures of fuzzy things.


The chances of a night sighting are 1500 times greater than for a daytime sighting. Let's hope all these folks have there wits about them and their flashes screwed in.


People hunt jaguars with dogs. Acting as a group, the dogs surround the cat. Dogs can guide a herd of cattle and face bulls. Don´t you think its a bit weird to say they freeze when facing a big ape? Are you sure the reports of such diferent behavior are not due to incidents involving dogs of different races and/or creation? A pincher raised inside an apartment would be more likely to freeze when seeing a wild animal, even if its a deer... "My dog just froze" is nothing really extraordinary in this case.



One first hand account of dog behavior soon after the Cox sighting concerned a part Mastiff who was afraid of nothing, until he froze and bristled and refused to go out. He lived in the woods. This is mentioned in the book as well, but I don't know if it was the same dog.


So, why not just set baits with motion-activated remote cameras nearby?



Been done. Read the field notes yet?

Some hunters set them to know what sort of game they can count on. Why none of them managed to catch a snapshot of bigfoot walking around? Note that some of these are IR cams. No flash needed. Do you really belive the bigfeet are so smart that they can evade or destroy them all? Humans, as far as I´m concerned, quite often are caught by these cameras....



Stay tuned..............



Find a place where animals gather to drink (tracks will tell you where they are). Animals -specially those who walk in packs- tend to drink water at selected spots, where the river banks make access to the water easier and/or allow the whole pack to drink at once for example. Predators quite often also go to these places, either to drink or to feed on those who are drinking. Find a well-used trail. Place remote cameras at these places or stay there awaiting. If nothing shows up, accept that there´s nothing there.



You've never been to the Pacific Northwest, have you? It doesn't work that way.

Read the field notes.

Wouldn´t they be relative to those girls who took pictures if faires? Memories change with time, so it´s not exactly a good piece of evidence. They could have seen the carcass of anything -if indeed they saw something. [/QUOTE]
[/B]

The girls you refer to made the fairies.
One as an adult remembered nails, not claws. The carcass was pretty decayed. Green suggested a search of the area to see if some bones might have survived, but I don't know if this was ever done.


And gorillas were found and described. An expedition went to their habitat, hired some local guides and shoot a couple of gorillas. Now, compare the resources and the technology avaliable to those who found the gorillas to what´s at today´s biologists and hunters reach. Some equipments nowdays at use were not even dreamt a few decades ago. And still, no bigfoot was captured, alive or dead.



No full-scale scientific expedition has been sent to date.


Regarding the new chimp species, the reports are not confirmed.



And Dr. Williams is in disgrace.

"Comments on the DNA Tests

Here are some comments received so far with the DNA results:
They are based on the hypervariable segment of the Mitochondrial Genome.
An alternative to sampling the same few animals over and over again is that we are dealing with a very inbred and marginal population in which even a large number of animals could share identical or or near identical haplotypes.
The chimpanzees we have so far sampled and sequenced from East of the Ubangui seem to consistently lack this large amount of genetic diversity characteristic for all other chimpanzee populations.
It means that the chimps of Central and Eastern Africa really do belong to a common cluster (subspecies). But within that cluster no clear partitioning of schweinfurthii versus troglodytes.
Several samples of the last batch group with no other sequences they come out of the root of the Ptt Pts cluster and form their own branch.

and from a morphologist:

There is a general misunderstanding about genetics including by those that are working with it. Genetic analysis is not presently a very accurate method for determining relationships of populations. Moreover it is long, labrious and costly and necessitates a large sample to make any sense of it."

http://www.karlammann.com/bondo.html


But, even if a new species is found, it will actually do no good for the big foot cause. Why? Scientists can find a new large ape species in Congo - a logistical nightmare (name a problem: access, equipment maintenance, endemic diseases, politics, etc. and you´ll find it there). However, a species of 2+meter high apes manages to elude scientists, hunters, (both pro and amateur) wildlife photographers and trucks in USA... And something between 2000 to 14000 of them are supposed to exist.



On the continent.
Science is waiting for someone to bring in a body. Once someone brings in a body, funding may be available to bring in a body. ;)


And no one ever comes close enough to notice the difference? Rangers surely might want to know why the bears died (disease, poacher activity, etc.).


I've mentioned bears aren't found either. How close would you want to come to some big rotting, maggotty hunk of something, especially if you were a hunter hot on the trail of a deer? Much of the land is privately owned. No rangers.

I lived in the forest. I seldom saw anyone unless I went to town.


And ever considered the possibility that, assuming the ranger story is true, he drove over the track because he realised they were not out of the ordinary?



He drove beside them, not over them, and didn't even notice the plastic. They were covered because they were huge, hominid tracks. That's out of the ordinary. He had just been talking to the investigators.


Oh, but the bodies were found, weren´t they? Even if by accident, a long time ago. And note that you can´t say "they wanted to be found". Dead people don´t want anything.



I obviously meant they wanted to be found when they were alive. It was known where they were last seen, but even professional rescue teams couldn't find them. The remains were discovered accidently much too late.


An important point is that the bodies were found a long time later, they were not found during the extensive organised search. What shows us scavenger activity was not enough to terminate the remains. And that bigfeet corpses should be found, even if their numbers are small, and found even by people who were not looking for them...



I found almost nothing of the corpse of a nearly 16 hand mare after a year and I knew exactly where to look.

I don't know what condition the human remains were in. Both had gone through the winter. One was found on talus, in the open, not deep forest, the other in relatively open woodland.

Peter Bryne said that trying to track a Sasquatch was like looking for a moving needle in a haystack. He also said the forests of the PNW are denser than any he'd ever hunted in, and that includes the jungles of Sumatra.


Not really. There are plenty of much better amateur pictures and films from real animals. Specially nowdays, with the proliferation of digital cameras.

Bobby Clarke had his on autofocus and it focused on tree branches instead of the figure. The branches are nice and clear.
 
LAL said:

Under the microscope (Fig. 2), the average diameter of hair is 65 µm (40-90 µm), these values derived from 15 separately collected samples in four States.

Is there some significance to the diameter of the hair? Doesn't human hair fall between 50-100 microns in diameter?

RayG
 
LAL said:

How many humans do you know, blonde or otherwise, shed hair of the length described that has never been cut?

You left out an important bit: "...and was indistinguishable from human hair by any criterion."

Fahrenbach has also said he has a dozen he's willing to identify as Sasquatch.

Speculation at best. This is what he has actually said:

"All purported sasquatch hairs in my possession (11 regional samples) show a reddish tinge under the microscope, lack a medulla and are indistinguishable from human hair. Efforts at DNA analysis were unsuccessful." -- Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach, Ph.D., Beaverton, Oregon - October 2, 1998

and again,

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair of the particular structure (great variability is available among the latter)." -- Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach, Ph.D., November 3, 1999

He may claim they're sasquatch hairs, but he can't prove it.

At least they know what it isn't.

I have my doubts. Can you answer these earlier questions about Fahrenbach?:
  • What is his specific area of scientific expertise?
  • Is he qualified to do hair analysis?
  • Has he samples of ALL North American animals for comparison purposes? (wolverine, moose, etc. etc.)
  • Is Henner considered a hair identification expert outside the field of bigfoot?

Did you check out those links I gave in an earlier post about microscopic hair analysis being nothing more than junk science?

If microscopic hair identification is so unreliable, why do you place so much importance on it?

It's interesting that according to the FBI's Handbook on Forensic Services:
http://www.fbi.gov/hq/lab/handbook/intro8.htm#hairs
"Hair examinations can determine whether hairs are animal or human." Yet according to Fahrenbach, the hairs he thinks belong to sasquatch are "indistinguishable from human hair."

I would expect hair of a close relative to resemble human hair. It isn't fur. How many other primates are there in North America besides us?

This doesn't just resemble human hair, it is "indistinguishable from human hair."

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair of the particular structure (great variability is available among the latter). DNA extracted from both hair shaft or roots (hair demonstrably fresh) was too fragmented to permit gene sequencing. That characteristic is also sometimes found in human hair that lacks the medulla (as does sasquatch hair - at least what I am willing to identify as such)."

I've already used that quote myself. It's the November, 1999 update, and notice how he says "purported sasquatch hair", and that they were all "indistinguishable from a human hair". His very next sentence after the portion you quoted is this:

"I am concentrating now on blood or tissue, as the hair holds no promise."

I gather by that he means identification is not possible. Do we agree on that?

RayG
 
I think I will compile anecdotes where people did not see signs of bigfoot in the woods, since Lu likes to present anecdotes where people claim to have seen such signs. I will start with a few of my own, and then ask some relatives for woodsy stories.

I invite others at this forum to share their woodsy stories as well. Bigfoot or non.

**********
I went out into the woods yesterday and I didn't see a bigfoot, or any big footprints.

I was driving along a wooded road a few days ago, stopped and got out to observe the scenery, and noticed a 6' high muddy bank had been disturbed. I saw no bigfoot sign at all.

About a month ago, I noticed a large pine tree had fallen in my neighbor's wooded back yard. I went over to see what happened. I saw no sign of bigfoot whatsoever. There were no footprints save my own.

I stayed in the woods several times for Uncle Sam, including a few memorable weeks in the deep, dark, Mark Twain National Forest. I never saw any bigfoot footprints, hairs, or butt prints. This included a lot of 0 dark thirty time.

Last Thursday, I was in the deep woods of Virginia for several hours. I saw no Sasquatch prints, or any other sign of large primates save my own species. This included driving down a couple of isolated trails.

**********
 
If they were broken off 12" below the soilline, it seems they might have been lifted and thrown.

Good lord! You should be embarrassed.

Too bad the researcher just couldn't be bothered for a couple more pics, huh? I'd hate to see the effort of a researcher who wasn't quite as interested in bigfoot as DDA. They probably wouldn't get off the couch in their frenzy to find out about a possible new large primate living in NA.

Let's see:
I am smart enough to avoid humans most of the time, including avoiding leaving tracks when I choose, and thwarting attempts to photograph me, and avoiding bait.

I am however, too dumb to just remove the cameras I don't like, and throw them into the next county, which I can apparently easily do.

Instead, I knock down valuable wildlife habitat. I leave the cameras I hate alone to be posted again on a different tree. Not only that, I knock down the trees in such a way as to advertise my presence, while avoiding leaving tracks to hide my presence, rather than just pushing the trees over, which would look natural.

I am also apparently unable to break in a door, despite my Herculean tree removing abilities.

Do I have that about right?

Can the BFRO spot Dynel? :D
 
Bobby Clarke had his on autofocus and it focused on tree branches instead of the figure. The branches are nice and clear.

That video is not helping your case at all, imo.

Here again we have the possible find of the century, and the finder knows jack about operating his camera.

A later sighting by a child in the area was accompanied by footprints. Unfortunately, the human footprints sank in much deeper and were much clearer than the supposedly super heavy bigfoot's track. I guess this one forgot to conceal his prints when he conveniently stepped in this spot clear of grass.

footprint_4.gif


footprint_5.gif
 
RayG said:
You left out an important bit: "...and was indistinguishable from human hair by any criterion."


Why repost what you already posted? I've posted that site at least half a dozen times on several boards. People tend to seize on that phrase and ignore the rest.



Speculation at best. This is what he has actually said:

"All purported sasquatch hairs in my possession (11 regional samples) show a reddish tinge under the microscope, lack a medulla and are indistinguishable from human hair. Efforts at DNA analysis were unsuccessful." -- Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach, Ph.D., Beaverton, Oregon - October 2, 1998

and again,

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair of the particular structure (great variability is available among the latter)." -- Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach, Ph.D., November 3, 1999

He may claim they're sasquatch hairs, but he can't prove it.



I have my doubts. Can you answer these earlier questions about Fahrenbach?:
  • What is his specific area of scientific expertise?
  • Is he qualified to do hair analysis?
  • Has he samples of ALL North American animals for comparison purposes? (wolverine, moose, etc. etc.)
  • Is Henner considered a hair identification expert outside the field of bigfoot?



He's an expert in microscopy and was a research scientist with the Oregon Regional Primate Center in Beaverton, Oregon. Evidently he became interested after hair was brought to him. Have you read some of his other stuff?

http://www.invertebrate.ws/seaspider/start.htm

The DNA testing on those was done at OSU. The Skookum Cast hair was tested at a lab in BC. There've been 25 hais found to be "unknown animal" or "unknown primate", according to Roger Knights. I don't know his sources yet.

I'll see what else I can dig up on him.

Did you check out those links I gave in an earlier post about microscopic hair analysis being nothing more than junk science? ]


I skimmed them. I'll read them more thoroughly when I have more time.

If microscopic hair identification is so unreliable, why do you place so much importance on it?



I don't. I was asking another poster. I could have said, "What about trees twisted off 8' above the ground?"
It's a part of the evidence, though not a very big part.

I'm trying to dispell the notion that there's nothing but anecdotal evidence.


It's interesting that according to the FBI's Handbook on Forensic Services:
http://www.fbi.gov/hq/lab/handbook/intro8.htm#hairs
"Hair examinations can determine whether hairs are animal or human." Yet according to Fahrenbach, the hairs he thinks belong to sasquatch are "indistinguishable from human hair."


This doesn't just resemble human hair, it is "indistinguishable from human hair."



But he doesn't say it is human hair and there's quite a difference between hair and fur.


I've already used that quote myself. It's the November, 1999 update, and notice how he says "purported sasquatch hair", and that they were all "indistinguishable from a human hair". His very next sentence after the portion you quoted is this:



Then you should know his credentials.



I gather by that he means identification is not possible. Do we agree on that?]




Uh, no.

Funny, I thought reinforcements had arrived when you popped in from BFF. Instead I have another sceptic to deal with, it seems.
:D :p
What do you think the Skookum imprint is if not what it seems to be?
 
I'm trying to dispell the notion that there's nothing but anecdotal evidence.
Trying?

Think a minute.. How would one go about dispelling the notion that there is more than anecdotal evidence?

Hint: It is not by telling another anecdote.



This doesn't just resemble human hair, it is "indistinguishable from human hair."
--------------------------------------------------------------

LAL:

But he doesn't say it is human hair and there's quite a difference between hair and fur.
What part of "indistinguishable from human hair ", Is confusing you ?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Okay, this is getting silly again.

Sorry for such a late response. My time is limited and I don't get the chance to visit JREF much these days. :(


LAL said:
Sure, except that they're seldom portrayed as dangerous, Cannibal Woman notwithstanding.


Neverthethess, they do portray some as dangerous, such as Ogopogo.

I'm not saying no bodies of anything are ever found. It's possible Sasquatch bodies have been seen but mistaken for bear from a distance, which are seldom if ever found dead either, in the PNW, even by Rangers

Until recently, I was a BC Park Ranger. I have found several dead black bears on my patrols among other numerous dead critters. The myth of black bear bodies not being, or rarely, found is simply not true.
It was actually my job as a Ranger which taught me never to rely on what an eye witness has seen. Part of my job involved dealing with bear complaints from hikers and monitoring bear activity. Many times I have had a group of hikers argue over the size of the bear they saw an hour earlier. Some say it was huge, others say it was small. Some groups couldn't even agree on how many bears they saw, what kind of bear, or even if it was a bear at all. I can't tell you how many times I have checked out bear complaints to learn it was just a friggin dog.

One quick story. One morning I encountered two teen age girls hiding in a pit toilet. They told me a bear was chasing them the previous night and they had to hide in the pit toilet and they spent the night there because they were scared to come out. They were really freaked out and very scared. So after investigating it further, checking on tracks etc, the story didn't add up. So I questioned them further and after awhile the real story came out. The bear was down the beach, probably never even saw them, yet they freaked out and ran to the pit toilets to safety.
 
LAL said:
It would be great if any US government agency would fund someone like that.

Surely the US government has people hired in conservation agencies or organization of some sort. A state park, for example, must have people who study wildlife for various purposes. These professionals study the number of specimens, their territories, migration patterns, check for diseases, introduced foreign species, etc. This is needed, for example for management during hunting seasons, stabilishing the conservation areas´ protection zones, planning of touristic trails, campsites etc. And not only animals are studyed, but also plants. That´s just one more reason why a population of large unknown mammals in USA is highly unlikely to exist. There are plenty of qualified people working out there.

LAL said:
Should? Read some of the reports. A sighting that got me interested in this was by a man named Cox who drove out of a fog bank on Hwy 14 (paved) east of Beacon Rock about 3:30 AM.
The creature stepped 8' up a bank, confirmed by the tracks. ( I knew one of the deputies involved and recently found the story in Sasquatch/Bigfoot; The Search For North America's Incredible Creature, by Don Hunter with René Dahinden.)

How long would it take one to get across a road with a stride like that?

So, horses, deer and great felines should never become roadkills, since they can move very fast an jum great distances. However, they do get killed by trucks.

Oh, someone has ever mentioned that fog can cause weird illusions?

LAL said:
The chances of a night sighting are 1500 times greater than for a daytime sighting. Let's hope all these folks have there wits about them and their flashes screwed in.

Wildlife photographers working at night without the proper equipment?

How were the chances calculated? And please note that at night, common things may look quite different. Can´t some bias have been introduced? What sor of filter is used regarding these anedoctal informations? All sighting reports are accepted?

LAL said:
One first hand account of dog behavior soon after the Cox sighting concerned a part Mastiff who was afraid of nothing, until he froze and bristled and refused to go out. He lived in the woods. This is mentioned in the book as well, but I don't know if it was the same dog.

See? Sketchy reports, doubts, uncertain information...

LAL said:
Been done. Read the field notes yet?
Stay tuned..............



Best wishes. But I will not hold my breath.

LAL said:
You've never been to the Pacific Northwest, have you? It doesn't work that way.

Read the field notes.


No, I have not been to Pacific Northwest, but I happen to know people who worked there - in the field, for a long time, and others who live there. And regarding the field notes, don´t you think its a bit weird that hunting tactics that work everywhere else would do not work there?

LAL said:
The girls you refer to made the fairies.
One as an adult remembered nails, not claws. The carcass was pretty decayed. Green suggested a search of the area to see if some bones might have survived, but I don't know if this was ever done.

Memories change with time. Missing parts are quite often "filled in". And if the carcass was pretty decayed, don´t you think the girls could not -assuming they really saw something- misidentified it? Once again, uncertain and unreliable information.

LAL said:
No full-scale scientific expedition has been sent to date.

But there´s no need for that! There are already lots of people working there! Why a biologist working say with, bear population
has not yet by chance found evidence of bigfoot?

LAL said:
On the continent.
Science is waiting for someone to bring in a body. Once someone brings in a body, funding may be available to bring in a body. ;)

But my point (as well as other posters) is - a body should have been found already!

LAL said:
I've mentioned bears aren't found either. How close would you want to come to some big rotting, maggotty hunk of something, especially if you were a hunter hot on the trail of a deer? Much of the land is privately owned. No rangers.

I lived in the forest. I seldom saw anyone unless I went to town.

All people who walk in the are hunters? And no hunter is curious? And why did the girls that supposedly saw a bigfoot corpse would have came close to a "big rotting, maggotty hunk of something"?

And as far as I know, the claim that bear carcasses are not found is not very solid. Animal carcasses are found in the wild, even in areas plenty of scavengers.

I worked in tropical rainforests, among other types of areas. I worked in conservation areas, in private-owned areas, far or close to cities. I have found corpses of animals on several ocasions, big and small, not to mention roadkills. Humans have the habit of wandering around. Note that many - if not most- bifoot sightings are in camp areas and roads. And these are not exactly desert places.

LAL said:
He drove beside them, not over them, and didn't even notice the plastic. They were covered because they were huge, hominid tracks. That's out of the ordinary. He had just been talking to the investigators.

Alleged hominid tracks.

LAL said:
I obviously meant they wanted to be found when they were alive. It was known where they were last seen, but even professional rescue teams couldn't find them. The remains were discovered accidently much too late.

I found almost nothing of the corpse of a nearly 16 hand mare after a year and I knew exactly where to look.

I don't know what condition the human remains were in. Both had gone through the winter. One was found on talus, in the open, not deep forest, the other in relatively open woodland.

But they were found!!! Why no bigfoot remain so far?

LAL said:
Peter Bryne said that trying to track a Sasquatch was like looking for a moving needle in a haystack. He also said the forests of the PNW are denser than any he'd ever hunted in, and that includes the jungles of Sumatra.

Now, if the forest is so dense at ground level, then the existence of large animals are not favored. Dense vegetation at the ground level renders the movment of large animals quite difficult. This is one of the main reasons why there are few large mammals in South America Tropical Rainforests. Tapirs, that may be above 250kg, are semi-aquatic.

There are indeed elephants, gorillas and rhinos living in tropical rainforests such as those from Africa and Sumatra. However, these animals create trails for their movments (not to mention that elephants and rhinos that live inside these forests are smaller than those living at opne fields). And a detail that is forgotten by many people: The tropical rainforests inhabited by these animals are relatively open at ground level.

Sumatra is a special case. It is inhabited by lizzards and other animals that can glide from a tree to another. These adaptations werer developed because the spacing between the trees is larger than in other tropical rainforests. What makes easier for elephants and rhinos to move among them - but still across preterminated paths.

Now, all of this adds another element of implausibility for the existence of a population of unknown large mammals in North America.

And if the forest bigfeet are supposed to live are not that dense... Then someone used a poor excuse.

People can track felines (big and small), deer, gorillas, racoons, wolverines, bear, wolves, moose, etc. But they can´t track a 2+ meter-high ape? Don´t you think its a bit weird and implausible?

LAL said:
Bobby Clarke had his on autofocus and it focused on tree branches instead of the figure. The branches are nice and clear.

He could not use manual focus?
 
LAL said:

Peter Bryne said that trying to track a Sasquatch was like looking for a moving needle in a haystack. He also said the forests of the PNW are denser than any he'd ever hunted in, and that includes the jungles of Sumatra.

I'm no tracker, and my opinion can easily be dismissed as a non-expert, but that strikes me as a load. I've lived in the Pacific Northwest, in the Cascades and in other places, and it was an infinitely easier forest to move in than anything I encountered in the Midwest or down here in North Carolina. I used to wander around all the time, and while there were plenty of spots to conceal a large mammal--I had a few thrilling encounters with elk that way--it wasn't particularly dense, and visibility went surprisingly far. You could hunt with a bow and arrow, and some of my relatives did. The old clearcuts were much worse, because there weren't any tall trees to choke out the undergrowth, so you were smashing your way through shoulder high brush without trails. There were the usual thick patches in the woods, of course, but for the most part, not so bad, presumably because tall pines kept the sunlight down to the point where the undergrowth was low. It wasn't until you got into stuff that had been heavily logged years before, that didn't have the light competition to keep things in check, that it got bad.

Whereas a lot of other wooded areas I've encountered in other parts of the country were like walking into a solid wall. You'd need a machete to get five feet. There's a BIG difference, and the Oregon woods were like gauze by comparison.

My point here is that the Pacific Northwest is obviously not uniform in density--logging and development wreaked an enormous toll. Undoubtedly there are areas that are denser than any jungle and hard to press through. I wouldn't question that, although I'd like to know which specific tract he was talking about. However, saying that the forests of the whole Pacific Northwest are denser than Sumatran jungle is just patently untrue--some of 'em might be, but a lot of 'em aren't even close. What CHUNK of the Pacific Northwest is denser than Sumatra?

If you wish to qualify that Bigfoot only lives in the really dense woods, I'm fine with that, mind you, but I had to point out that this bit does not at all square with my own firsthand experience.
 
"Bobby Clarke had his on autofocus and it focused on tree branches instead of the figure. The branches are nice and clear."

But perish the thought that this might imply a lack of skill or competence. Just rotten luck as usual.
 
And as others have pointed out ( and I wish to focus on ), if this forest is too dense for trackers to easily move in, why are we supposed to believe an 8 foot, 800 + lb. biped ( and it's family ) is moving quickly and stealthfully through the same environment ?
 
LAL said:
Why repost what you already posted? I've posted that site at least half a dozen times on several boards. People tend to seize on that phrase and ignore the rest.

Maybe because it's a very significant phrase.

He's an expert in microscopy and was a research scientist with the Oregon Regional Primate Center in Beaverton, Oregon. Evidently he became interested after hair was brought to him. Have you read some of his other stuff?

http://www.invertebrate.ws/seaspider/start.htm

As Shania Twain sang, "That don't impress me much." He seems to have many interests, but it's important to ask -- Is Henner considered a hair identification expert outside the field of bigfoot?

The DNA testing on those was done at OSU. The Skookum Cast hair was tested at a lab in BC.

Gene sequencing wasn't possible in the OSU testing, and the hair sequences from the Skookum cast were "so human-like as to most likely be contaminants."

There've been 25 hairs found to be "unknown animal" or "unknown primate", according to Roger Knights. I don't know his sources yet.

But none of those 25 hairs have been proven to come from a sasquatch.

I don't. I was asking another poster. I could have said, "What about trees twisted off 8' above the ground?"
It's a part of the evidence, though not a very big part.

I'm not aware of a single report of sasquatch being observed twisting a tree.

I'm trying to dispell the notion that there's nothing but anecdotal evidence.

Twisted trees, unidentified hairs/poop, and unwitnessed vocalizations isn't going to dispell that notion.

But he doesn't say it is human hair and there's quite a difference between hair and fur.

There doesn't seem to be anything that distinguishes it from human hair. If there was such a marked difference, wouldn't he be able to positively identify the hair as non-human?

Then you should know his credentials.

Afraid not. Being a 'research scientist' isn't much in the way of credentials. I have never found a definitive answer to my question -- Is Henner considered a hair identification expert outside the field of bigfoot?


So, even though Dr. Fahrenbach himself has stated:

"All purported sasquatch hairs in my possession (11 regional samples) show a reddish tinge under the microscope, lack a medulla and are indistinguishable from human hair. Efforts at DNA analysis were unsuccessful." -- Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach, Ph.D., Beaverton, Oregon - October 2, 1998

and,

"I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair of the particular structure (great variability is available among the latter)." -- Dr. W. Henner Fahrenbach, Ph.D., November 3, 1999


you believe those hairs to be sasquatch hairs?

Funny, I thought reinforcements had arrived when you popped in from BFF. Instead I have another sceptic to deal with, it seems.

It's no secret that I'm very skeptical of a great many claims, whether it's here or at the BFF. If you've noticed, I have NEVER claimed sasquatch is impossible, or CANNOT exist. I have asked that claims be supported by evidence. In the case of hair analysis, you seem to be seeing evidence where none exists.

What do you think the Skookum imprint is if not what it seems to be?

An artifact. If a group of scientists had witnessed a squatch plunking its butt in the mud, I'd be more willing to suspend my disbelief.

RayG
 
I have copious photographic evidence of alien spacecraft flying in Earth's skies.

Photographic analysts were unable to identify these craft, but they reported that they were indistinguishable from late model Boeing 747-400 series aircraft.

Since they are not B744's, but alien spacecraft, the mystery deepens. :D
 

Last Thursday, I was in the deep woods of Virginia for several hours. I saw no Sasquatch prints, or any other sign of large primates save my own species. This included driving down a couple of isolated trails.

**********

Do you have any idea what a PNW forest looks like? Have you ever been west of the Mississippi?
 
LTC8K6 said:
That video is not helping your case at all, imo.



Nothing helps my case at all, in your opinion.


Here again we have the possible find of the century, and the finder knows jack about operating his camera.



Right. He just got it for Christmas. He's a ferry boat operator.



A later sighting by a child in the area was accompanied by footprints. Unfortunately, the human footprints sank in much deeper and were much clearer than the supposedly super heavy bigfoot's track.



Weren't you tjhe one who was arguing The prints should be shallower because of the distribution of weight?


I guess this one forgot to conceal his prints when he conveniently stepped in this spot clear of grass.



Some have conjectured they may try to conceal tracks at times, but if that were the case Dr. Meldrum would have 0 track casts in his collection rather than 150 (available for inspection). I don't think there's much to support that.

There were a number of tracks found. Some were excavated whole instead of cast.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom