Bigfoot - serious, not follies

RayG said:
I found it by typing 'Christopher Stringer bipedalism' into Google. The very first link contained his wading hypothesis.

RayG

This?

"Well known names who are open to the Wading Origins idea.
Chris Stringer (British Natural History Museum) is open to the idea of a Wading Origin for Bipedalism

Professor Chris Stringer is famous all over the world for his insightful work into the so called "Out of Africa II" theory - which argues that fully modern Homo sapiens emerged from Africa very recently (less than 200,000 years ago) and replaced all other hominines that already lived in Europe, Asia and Australasia as they did.

Less well known is Chris Stringer's tacit support of (or at least openness to) the wading origins theory of bipedalism. He co-authored a student text book on Human Origins. In which a sidebar about the aquatic ape hypothesis was written in an unusually open (as opposed to the more common dismissive) way.

Stringer, Christopher. B. (1976).
Before Adam; The First True Men; Man's Migrations. In F. Clapham (ed.) The Rise of Man. Sampson Low: London, pp. 52-79

In another publication ...

Stringer, Christopher. B. (1997).
Discussion. RSA Journal. November/December. p 115.

...he wrote “If our ancestors did go into the water, that would force them to walk upright.”

At Birkbeck College (London) at the end of 2000 I went to hear Chris speak about his Out of Africa Theory. At the end end of a very interesting talk, which considered the possibility of a coastal route for the exodus of modern Homo sapiens out of Africa around 150,000 years ago he stopped and responded to general questions from the audience.

I asked him "I have a question about your proposed coastal route out of Africa. Considering the fact that we swim so much better than chimpanzees, do you think that this swimming ability is derived and that if so do you think this ability evolved during this African exodus?"

Chris seem to twig straight away where I was coming from and delivered the expected cautious but unambiguous refutation of the AAH that anyone would do in his position today. Then, to my astonishment and elation he added words to the effect "... but if you are looking for something that might have resulted from an exposure to water how about the way we move around? How about wading?" "

http://www.riverapes.com/AAH/AATheories/Wading/HowAboutWading.htm

I doubt he's developed these comments to the point of hypothesis.

Here's the site:

http://www.riverapes.com/

Note the kid's stories. Weird, huh?
 
LAL said:
...the species did not use the knuckle-walking technique of gorillas and chimps or the branch-swinging technique of orangutans for locomotion.

From what I gather, that only shows that bipedalism developed earlier than thought, not that it predated knuckle-walking.

RayG
 
Note the figure in the Clarke film is wading.........in water that was measured at 3-4' deep.

(desperately tries to tie all this to the topic................)
 
LAL said:

I doubt he's developed these comments to the point of hypothesis.

Since the wading idea isn't yet widely accepted as a theory, and is only a tentative explanation presented by Stringer and others, that's why I referred to it as a hypothesis.

:D

RayG
 
RayG said:
From what I gather, that only shows that bipedalism developed earlier than thought, not that it predated knuckle-walking.

RayG

The article I'm looking for was published before this, and Stringer clearly stated that. It may have been archived and that's why I can't get it to come up on the exact phrase, "The consensus, according to Chris Stringer.........".

Note that the upright Pierolapithecus catalaunicus lived a few million years before there were any Great Apes.

"the species did not use the knuckle-walking technique of gorillas and chimps or the branch-swinging technique of orangutans for locomotion. The body was designed for waking upright and would have made a good tree climber. The bipedal locomotion of the new discovery is intriguing because it was once thought that our upright posture evolved later and was a significant change that led to the development of both advanced brains and our skill with our hands."
 
RayG said:
Since the wading idea isn't yet widely accepted as a theory, and is only a tentative explanation presented by Stringer and others, that's why I referred to it as a hypothesis.

:D

RayG

I'd refer to it as a "sidebar". Didn't "Toumai" kind of blow the "Aquatic Ape" stuff out of the water (so to speak)? It was found in Chad.
 
LAL said:
The bipedal locomotion of the new discovery is intriguing because it was once thought that our upright posture evolved later and was a significant change that led to the development of both advanced brains and our skill with our hands."

As I said,

Originally posted by RayG
...that only shows that bipedalism developed earlier than thought, not that it predated knuckle-walking.

Are you suggesting that they walked bipedally, then became knuckle-draggers, then walked bipedally again? I'm not sure I understand what you're attempting to say.

RayG
 
RayG said:
As I said,



Are you suggesting that they walked bipedally, then became knuckle-draggers, then walked bipedally again? I'm not sure I understand what you're attempting to say.

RayG


Who did?

The line split several times, but the common ancestor seems to have been a biped. It's now thought knuckle-walking was a later adaptation in the Great Apes while the Ardepiths, Australopiths, Orrorin, Kenyanthropus, Homo (which developed a locking arch)and who knows what else retained the bipedalism.

IOW, there were more bipedal primates than there were knuckle-walkers.
 
LAL said:
It's now thought knuckle-walking was a later adaptation in the Great Apes...

In other words, they walked upright first and then became knucklers? Where are they saying that?


IOW, there were more bipedal primates than there were knuckle-walkers.

That's a whole different issue, and not what I was addressing.

RayG
 
Late in the game to comment, but evidence of the entire group being out of whack is in the site itself. Any organization that has been around longer than the existence of the internet could put forth the effort to make a clear and well designed site. This is necessary to be seen as a serious organization in today's world.

Also, selling a copy of the bigfoot tape for a MILLION DOLLARS? Would you be willing to be talked down to 900 grand?

EDIT: Assuming that the bigfoot is not immortal, how can you explain the lack of hundreds if not thousands of remains littering the archaeological record?
 
RayG said:
As I said,



Are you suggesting that they walked bipedally, then became knuckle-draggers, then walked bipedally again? I'm not sure I understand what you're attempting to say.

RayG

I'm not sure I understand the question.

Think "bush" instead of "line".
 
SmooveK said:
Late in the game to comment, but evidence of the entire group being out of whack is in the site itself. Any organization that has been around longer than the existence of the internet could put forth the effort to make a clear and well designed site. This is necessary to be seen as a serious organization in today's world.

Also, selling a copy of the bigfoot tape for a MILLION DOLLARS? Would you be willing to be talked down to 900 grand?

EDIT: Assuming that the bigfoot is not immortal, how can you explain the lack of hundreds if not thousands of remains littering the archaeological record?

What site are you referring to? Beckjord's? Beckjord is out of whack, not "the entire group".

There are very few ape fossils of any kind, due to the habitat they prefer. Fossilization is extremely rare in general and it's possible millions of species have come and gone leaving no trace.

Bones of any kind don't last long in the PNW (the region I'm most familiar with). The scavenger system makes short work of them.
 
RayG said:
In other words, they walked upright first and then became knucklers? Where are they saying that?


Knuckle-walking was a later adaptation in the Great Apes. The common ancestor wasn't a knuckle-walker as was previously thought.

That's a whole different issue, and not what I was addressing.

RayG

I don't see why. Why?
 
RayG said:
No idea. I only looked up info on Stringer because you mentioned him.

RayG
Elaine Morgan stated the Aquatic Ape stuff; she wrote a book on it. There's never been anything in the fossil record to support it.

Algis Kulikas seems to be the originator of this modification. It doesn't look like Stringer did anything other than say something to the effect of "Yeah, that's a possibility. Gotta go."

http://www.riverapes.com/Me/index.htm
 
This recent disdussion of bipedal vs knuckle-dragging seems to be stayed from Bigfoot. Except, if I was a Believer in BF, I'd say "Yup, he is a wading ape, thats why we find no skeletons- they usually die in the water." But then the Skeptic me would say "but don't we have fossils of otters?"


And on the "anthropometrics of hominoids" concept that seems to say that BF weighs 800 pounds: I know of a subspecies of nearly 8 feet tall hominids that only weigh 350 pounds. They seem to be proportioned about like the BFs in the films. including 16 inch feet. They are in the subspecies "Lakers/Celts"
 
Originally posted by LAL When did I attack mainstrean science? Efforts have been made over forty years to interest mainstream science.
I was labled a "woo" the minute I hit the board. What can I possibly do to make it worse?
I have seen no evidence that you were labeled a woo by defending your claim that bigfoot is real. People are just challenging your claims. Some posts had a humorous tones, but I really see no problem with that. So far you presented no evidence that you are a woo like erickbjord, antigray et al. Keep up the good work. However, I still don´t think the presented evidence is solid. And you seem not to trust those you call "mainstream scientists". This position deserves a change.
Originally posted by LAL It's implausible we may have living bipedal relatives on earth? Why is that so implausible?
The implausibility lies on the lack of favorable evidence.

Originally posted by LAL There have been several encounters involving screeching brakes and terrified motorists. A friend's daughter and her friends saw one en route home from the Prom on Hwy 14. If you knew how deserted that highway was at night, you'd wonder how they happened to be lucky enough to even see it.
And why not s single roadkill? I´m used to desert roads, and animals get killed in them. Even the rare ones. Unfortunately, I admit.
Originally posted by LAL There was physical evidence.
That could have been misinterpretated.
Originally posted by LAL I suggest you read some reports and the comments by investigators.
I had. That´s why I am still questioning.
Originally posted by LAL Never mind that the Patterson film has been analysed to pieces over 38 years, and it still holds up. Try reading some of the analyses instead of dismissing it as "fuzzy". It's pretty clear, and there are some very good reasons it cannot be a man in a suit, despite the wishful thinking of sceptics.
Oh, but I have read them. As well as the critics, that seem quite plausible. Don´t get me wrong, but the expression "despite the wishful thinking of sceptics" was very badly used. I don´t think anyone here would not like to have a solid evidence for such a wonderfull thing as the existence of bigfeet. We have wishfull thinking that evidence better than fuzzy pictures, questionable tracks and questionable reports will surface. We just don´t think that the avaliable evidence supports the notion that exists a population of unknown large apes living in North America.
Originally posted by LAL It's just possible a homidid primate is more intelligent than the average bear.
Fruit bait was taken on the Skookum expedition. I'm impressed by what they did get, not tearing my hair out because they didn't come back with a body.
Even humans can be ambushed, tracked, etc... Still waiting for good pieces of evidence, good quality footage would be nice start.
Originally posted by LAL I don't know. Could be because the report was from years before and the students weren't sure of the spot. Many people do not report for fear of ridicule and it's only been in recent years that people could report to an organization rather than just to law enforcement.
But if they were walking across a trail and that´s not exactly the thing that you would forgot the location... There was no real reason for not getting the corpse. With the corpse, no one would fear ridicule. Or its just one of those reports that one does not know the exact origin and are repeated ad nauseaum in several books, sites etc, but was never really checked? People nowdays can find humans remains from the 60s and 50s in airplane crash sites, decades-old burial sites can be found by GPR, and so on. Even on acid soil, at least teeth would be preserved.
Sidenote- I remember reading not just about the reported sighting of bigfeet burying the bodies of their relatives but also as an hipothesis for the absence of bodies in cryptozoology texts back in the 70s. So, chances are its another report of unknown and unreliable source.
Originally posted by LAL On Sasquatches? Here's a graduate student:

http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/sbs/somer87.htm
Who said it has to be with bigfoot? It can be accidental! Someone is studying say, woodpecker population, hears a noise at the nearby bush, sees bigfoot lingering, grabs camera, click click, there you are!
Originally posted by LAL Remember the famous case of the hominid clavical Dr. Tim White determined was a fossil dolphin bone?
Right. An unfossilized dolphin bone in the midlle of North America would not raise any eyebrows...
Originally posted by LAL I read it. I've also seen a statement from a ranger that he's never seen a bear carcass.
There are sightings and tracks from other areas, but most of the data seems to be from the Northwest.
I know there are reported sightings from other areas. Why there are no corpses from these areas? Bones are also rare in Texas, Florida and Canada? No roadkills either... No one managed to shoot one. Weird, don´t you think?
I
Originally posted by LAL Why, when so few mainstream scientists accept it? Where's the grant money? It's mostly been left to amateurs and they're scoffed at for being amateurs. Geez.
Please note that what I am saying is that, with people making field research, even if focusing in other species, for so long and with all the attention that these works require, evidence would have been found. Its would be like seing jaguars when you are looking for tapirs, or a grizzly bear while studying moose. It happens all the time. That´s why "mainstream scientists" find hard to accept it. Not only "mainstream scientists" but also other people such as myself.
Originally posted by LAL All of which are answerable, whether you accept the answers or not.
The same is valid if the answers point to the non-existence of bigfoot.
Originally posted by LAL If they don't exist, what's leaving all that "inconclusive" evidence?
A number of things, such as common animals misidentified.
Originally posted by LAL A full-time team is needed.
No, it is not.
Originally posted by LAL There are no Moose in the area I'm talking about.
And what would be the maximum size of the animals that live there? About the same, smaller of larger than a bigfoot?
Originally posted by LAL I lived in it. It's dense. The ground cover is one of the reasons it's difficult to track anything. There are a couple of layers of understory. These animals, deer included, are adapted to it.
Dense enough to difficult the locomotion of a 2+m tall ape? It has enough food for it?
Originally posted by LAL Skeletons of Homo florensis should have been discovered much sooner than they were, the Ivory Billed Woodpecker should have been photographed much sooner than it was, Coelacanths should have been discovered much sooner than they were, Eric Rudolf should have been apprehended much sooner than he was, four new mammalian species in Viet Nam should have been discovered much sooner than they were............
Someone reaserched a cave and found H. florensis. Someone noticed a weird fish in a market and coelacanthus was found. The mamalian species in Vietnam are not exactly as large as bigfoot, neither so different from other common animals that live there, Vietnam´s logistics and political situation are, if I am not wrong, a bit worse than in USA. And still, not a single carcass of a bigfoot was found, neither it was captured in nice shap footage, pictures, etc.
Originally posted by LAL There are no Moose in Skamania County, Washington. No pine where I lived either. Too wet. I lived in mature second growth timber, mostly Douglas Fir. The canopy was open enough for plenty of sun to get to the Broadleaf Maple and Alder, Blackberries, Wild Raspberries.............Skamania County has the most reported sightings in the country.

No solid evidence was found by whom?
Mature second growth and open canopy are the key words.
No solid evidence was found by anyone.
Originally posted by LAL Perhaps because they don't have migration routes and tend to roam randomly when feeding. The Powder Mountain tracks (in snow), went from Balsam stand to Balsam stand. The animal was apparently feeding on the Balsam berries. They were spotted and photographed from a helicopter. There is no sign of other activity in the snow.......it looks absolutely pristine.
Remember the nomadic jaguars I mentioned some posts above? They can be tracked, are seen people take pictures, sometimes the become roadkills, sometimes they even get in to trouble entering in hotels...
Originally posted by LAL They mostly "appear" to people who don't happen to be carrying cameras at the time.
Choosy creatures...
Originally posted by LAL Because they are not being monitored or hunted, except by a few "weekend warriors".

Gorillas travel in troops and leave considerable sign, including nest-making. Chimpanzees travel in troops as well.
Not all gorillas are monitored. Still, locals know where and how to find them.
Gorillas and chimps are not always in groups. Animals that become isolated from the group by some reasons (fight, disease, predation, etc.) quite often wander close to human settlements. And are caught.
Originally posted by LAL It does. The tracks near Bluff Creek were seen when new roads were going in. That's near a 17,500 sq.mi. area in Northern California that had only been mapped from the air.
Only mapped by air by who? With what objectives? Topographic surveys? Or bigfoot search? No one works there? What´s it? Gwangi´s valley?

Originally posted by LAL There may be a living relative in Russia.
Ah, yeah. As well as the yeti, the wildment from Southern Asia, woodwoose from Britain, mapinguari here in Brazil...
Originally posted by LAL "Protopithecus brasiliensis Lund, 1838
Caipora bambuiorum Cartelle and Hartwig, 1996

'There is no smoke without fire' says the proverb. There really have been some larger primates in South America. The evidence consists of the fossil remains of two species of extinct giant primates in South America, which keeps paleo-primatologists and evolutionary primatologists extremely busy and excited today.
...snip...

Now one's claiming Sasquatches evolved in NA. They evidently came over the Bering Strait. Our species did too.
I happened to meet Cartelle some yeras ago. I also happen to know a lot of people who worked with him at Toca da Boa Vista (Caipora bambuiorum´s "birthplace"), helped him for years with its fossils, mapped the cave, as well as Lagoa Santa, among many others. Are you aware of it´s name origin? The caipora is a Native Brazilian myth, a small hairy person, with feet turned backward. Black fur, white at its belly, according to some versions. A protector of the animals that live in the woods, sometimes mounts a wild pig. There is an anedoctal story that Cartelle thinks there´s a slim chance that the myth could have started by memories retained by the natives from the megafauna animals. Why they would not remember saber-toothed cats, much more impressive beasts- is something I don´t know. Oh, then you would say, same can be valid for bigfoot!
And yes it could, but... There´s no fossil register in the Americas suggesting the existence of such a creature! Not to mention the exting South American apes were not that big. Roughly the size of a small child. And were tree-dwellers. And were not related to great apes neither to hominids...

Besides, there´s no fossil remains of anything similar to bigfoot along the proposed migration routes. Note also that big apes seem to be restricted to tropical to subtropical climates.

Originally posted by LAL No fossils of Chimpanzees and Gorillas have been found at all. There are around a thousand living species with no fossil record.
Fossilization is a rare event. Here's my favorite article on it:

http://home.tiac.net/~cri/1998/taphonomy.html

It's not likely they'd "devolve" from Great Apes. They may be another species of Great Ape. We're a medium-sized ape.
Elephants are tropical too, but they had relatives that lived in the tundra.
Hominid fossils have been found in Russia. They are practically Homo habilis
We're an ape and we live everywhere.

I really don´t want to brag about this, neither use argument from authority, so please don´t get me wrong. I am a geologist, I know a lot of paleontologists. There are also other geologists here in this board. If I miss the mark here, they will surelly twist my ears. What goes now, is a bit of personal experience. Sometimes people use the argument that fossil register is incomplete to defend a number of points, some valid, some not valid. The fact is that fossil register is not so incomplete as some people think or say. Take Brazillian big fossil apes as an example. They were tree-dwellers from tropical rainforests. The type of animal that you would never expect to find a fossil from. However, they were found...
So, you have Africa, Asia and North America as possible places where these animals inhabited. Note that when one says a species migrated from Asia to the Americas, it is implied that actually its habitat expanded from Asia to the Americas, its not just the passage of a pack. Sure, only a small portion of these continents have the correct continions for fossilization. Still, chances are that in some of these places, the remains of something like bigfoot would have been found. Specially when you take in to account the climate changes at the end of the Ice Ages. Sinkholes attracted all sort of animals due to the shortage of water, that´s why caves have such a great fossil register. But so far no large primate fossil was found in sinkholes in North America. Neither in lake beds, etc.
Note also that we are tool-making "naked apes", the species from the Homo genus were the ones who managed to spread across a variety of climates. Great apes are still restricted to warm climates. This is backed by the fossil register.
Regarding elephants... Actually there are different genus as well as species adpated to different climates and form different eras. With fossil register. Same thing when it comes to rhinos. But great apes and other animals are more demanding when it comes to environmental conditions.

Originally posted by LAL No. I lived in Sasquatch country and practically everything I've read and seen on it since, except for UFO/paranormal silliness, has only strengthened my conviction.

Read Krantz.
Pratically everything I read about bigfoot only strenghtened my position that its an implausible idea. I know people who lived and worked in areas where bigfoot is supposed to live and they think its nothing but a myth.
And why do you think I have not read Krantz? What would be your reaction if I say that still, I am not convinced? Don´t underestimate the people you´ll find here. Most of us, before declaring that are we not convinced of something, make our homework.
 
casebro said:
This recent disdussion of bipedal vs knuckle-dragging seems to be stayed from Bigfoot. Except, if I was a Believer in BF, I'd say "Yup, he is a wading ape, thats why we find no skeletons- they usually die in the water." But then the Skeptic me would say "but don't we have fossils of otters?"

In fact, most fossilization does occur in water. I don't know how wading got into this, but it can get right out again.

It's not straying far. It came up in regard to whether Gigantopithecus was bipedal or not. There were over a dozen species of bipedal "apes" found so far, so there's no lack of possible ancestors. I would not expect a large bipedal hominid to have evolved from a large knuckle-walking ape, but there's just not enough of Giganto to know what the mode of locomotion was. There was a smaller subspecies in India. It is known they were wide ranging and survived for some 500,000 years, which is about 300,000 years longer than anatomically modern humans have been around. Arguments that there hasn't been time for Sasquatches to have evolved from them wouldn't seem to carry much weight, IMO.

And on the "anthropometrics of hominoids" concept that seems to say that BF weighs 800 pounds: I know of a subspecies of nearly 8 feet tall hominids that only weigh 350 pounds. They seem to be proportioned about like the BFs in the films. including 16 inch feet. They are in the subspecies "Lakers/Celts"

There's a thread on Bigfoot Forums comparing photos of the Patterson creature with photos of NFL players.

You'll have to get bigger and bulkier than that.

Do Lakers/Celts have a midtarsal bend?
 
LAL said:


Do Lakers/Celts have a midtarsal bend?


Here's a link to "meldrums best pic of a midtarsel bend" (from a BF forum) http://www.isu.edu/~meldd/jpg/018.jpg

If that creature has a midtarsel bend, so do I. My tracks on the beach sure look like that, a pile of sand pushed up as my forefoot thrusts me forward. Whats that you say? Sand is piled in the wrong direction? Try wearing "big foot sandals" and walking backwards, that's why an inexperienced tracker will find "tracks that disappear" where the hoaxer started. If I were to put on some BF sandals backwards, and run down a hill, my footprints would be 8 feet apart, and appear to be going up hill, dug in deeper at the toes where I landed with each step,wouldn't they? But anybody who has ever ween a set od day old tracks in the melting snow knows that the ttracks get bigger as the snow melts. The warm air in the tracks melt the snow faster than the surround snow, and the compressed snow in the tracks lacks the insulatory effect of the air trapped in fluffy snow.

Speaking of tracks, how come none of the tracks in Texas or PNW have been examined by a US Border Patrol expert? They track more 'hominids' than anybody....hmmm... they ought to have found tracks near the border too, since BF knows no political boundaries......perhaps the illegals use 'big foot sandals' to evade the cops? Patrolman 1 to Patrolman 2 " Nope not a Guatamalan immigrant, just another Sasquatch heading for Dicken's apple orchard . Even Bigfoot wants to have a Dickins Cider. Forgetaboutit."
 
LAL said:

Knuckle-walking was a later adaptation in the Great Apes. The common ancestor wasn't a knuckle-walker as was previously thought.

Where specifically are they saying that? You have yet to provide any links to support the statement you've made. You previously posted this:

Originally posted by LAL
But, bipedalism came first, according to the consensus with knuckle-walking a later adaptation in the Great Apes.

When pressed for sources, you threw out Christopher Stringer et al, but no specific link. You did add this:

According to Chris Stringer (you do know who he is, I hope), the consensus is that bipedalism was first.

Again, with no link or specific source to support your statement.

Diogenes then asked: "Can you point to a paper that suggests bipedalism predated walking on all fours by any animal?"

To which you submitted this:

"Dating the beginnings of bipedalism is very important in the human story because, for many experts, it would mark a clear divergence from the ancestral/ape pattern and show that the human lineage had really begun," said Chris Stringer, director of the Human Origins Program at the Natural History Museum in London.

Although this finding puts the development of bipedalism back by another two million years, it is not necessarily a surprise. The chimpanzee-human divergence has been estimated to have occurred between five and seven million years ago, based on genetic data.

"Now, for the first time, we have solid evidence dated to six million years ago of an intermediate creature between humans and the apes that demonstrated upright posture and bipedalism," said Robert Eckhardt, a developmental-genetics and evolutionary-morphology researcher at Pennsylvania State University. "And the dating of this fossil is unusually secure."

Which indicates bipedalism developed earlier in the time-line, not that bipedalism preceeded knuckle-walking.

If you are referring to this quote:

The bipedal locomotion of the new discovery is intriguing because it was once thought that our upright posture evolved later...

Again, it refers to the bipedalsim time-line, and I see nothing there about bipedalism preceeding knuckle-walking.

If knuckle-walking came later for a particular species, in your opinion, what mode of transportation preceeded knuckle-walking for that particular species?

RayG
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom