Bigfoot - serious, not follies

LTC8K6 said:
I think I will compile anecdotes where people did not see signs of bigfoot in the woods, since Lu likes to present anecdotes where people claim to have seen such signs. I will start with a few of my own, and then ask some relatives for woodsy stories.

I invite others at this forum to share their woodsy stories as well. Bigfoot or non.

**********

What is intriguing about this, is that a calculated search for bigfoot yields nothing, while the actual sightings seem to occur by accident and with no planning.

Based on this, we should have thousands more sightings than are actually reported.

I can't begin to calculate how many times I haven't seen one, and now that I am on the lookout, it's doubtfull that I ever will..:(
 
Correa Neto said:
Surely the US government has people hired in conservation agencies or organization of some sort. A state park, for example, must have people who study wildlife for various purposes. These professionals study the number of specimens, their territories, migration patterns, check for diseases, introduced foreign species, etc. This is needed, for example for management during hunting seasons, stabilishing the conservation areas´ protection zones, planning of touristic trails, campsites etc. And not only animals are studyed, but also plants. That´s just one more reason why a population of large unknown mammals in USA is highly unlikely to exist. There are plenty of qualified people working out there.




Yep. And some have had sightings. Again, there has never been a proper scientific investigation, because mainstream science doesn't take it seriously.



So, horses, deer and great felines should never become roadkills, since they can move very fast an jum great distances. However, they do get killed by trucks.



There are a lot more of them. I've never seen a truck on some of those Washington backroads.

Oh, someone has ever mentioned that fog can cause weird illusions?



And tracks? This sighting was thoroughly investigated. It convinced the sherriff. I heard the waitress' story from her and knew the people who followed the double trackway for seven miles. They were quite sane.


Wildlife photographers working at night without the proper equipment?


???????????

How were the chances calculated?



"Nocturnality

The nocturnality of the sasquatch has been questioned on occasion. This trait can be considered from a statistical standpoint. Take a hypothetical area randomly seeded with sasquatches, evenly distributed during day and night. Their apparent temporal distribution will depend on them being seen by human observers. Assume a very conservative ratio of such alert observers during daylight as compared to the hours of total darkness in the mountains to be 20:1. A daylight observer will have a circular observational area with a radius of, say, 500’, over which recognition of the subject will be unambiguous, roughly 800,000 square feet. A nighttime observer has at best the expanding cone of headlights in one direction with recognition of a grey object at 300’ and an expanding width of illumination to 100’, a sector with an area of about 15,000 square feet. Factoring in the number of observers produces a ratio of 800,000 X 20 : 15,000 X 1, or better than 1,000 : 1. This 99.9% : 0.1% ratio describes how sightings should be distributed between day and night, a number that will get more extreme if flashlights or moonlight is the alternative illumination.

An actual ratio cited by Green consists of 735 daytime sightings (58%) and 540 during the night (42%), or a ratio of 1.38 to 1. If only sightings on roads are considered, the ratio shifts to 58% in favor of night sightings. This discrepancy can be interpreted as activity by the sasquatch that exposes it to being seen about 1,500 times more often at night than an even distribution would predict."


And please note that at night, common things may look quite different. Can´t some bias have been introduced? What sor of filter is used regarding these anedoctal informations? All sighting reports are accepted?


There is now at least one place to report sightings and many are followed up. Some turn out to be mistaken identity, but many check out. I've experienced "buck fever" myself, but I saw a doe, not a Sasquatch, an the illusion only lasted for an instant.

People are often reluctant to report what they've seen because of the scoffing and ridicule they receive. Read this board if you don't think that's true.


See? Sketchy reports, doubts, uncertain information...


What's sketchy about trackways that go for miles, multiple witness sightings backed up by film............

Best wishes. But I will not hold my breath.



"Nobody asked you sir, she said....."

No, I have not been to Pacific Northwest, but I happen to know people who worked there - in the field, for a long time, and others who live there. And regarding the field notes, don´t you think its a bit weird that hunting tactics that work everywhere else would do not work there?


No. And your idea of waiting at waterholes would probably work quite well in the Serengeti.

Memories change with time. Missing parts are quite often "filled in". And if the carcass was pretty decayed, don´t you think the girls could not -assuming they really saw something- misidentified it? Once again, uncertain and unreliable information.


It's unfortunate it wasn't reported at the time. But for those who think it's all illusion or paranormal nonsense or that no body has ever been seen, there's at least this one report. There's another of two burying a third, but since it was from students on a hike, who would believe them?

But there´s no need for that! There are already lots of people working there! Why a biologist working say with, bear population
has not yet by chance found evidence of bigfoot?



Tell me what biologist is working with bear in, say, Washington State?

I've already posted a link to an article by a USFS wildlife biologist who bothered to investigate.


But my point (as well as other posters) is - a body should have been found already!



Should have? Is there a timetable on this? If a team went looking for a body in a 750 sq. mi. area, rugged, riddled with lava tubes, full of rotten snags and hollow logs, an no clue about where one would be except there's a statistical possibility one is there, where would be a good place to start?


All people who walk in the are hunters? And no hunter is curious? And why did the girls that supposedly saw a bigfoot corpse would have came close to a "big rotting, maggotty hunk of something"?



As I recall, it was on a trail.

The mistaken identity is only a possibility as is the speculation there may be bones, misidentified, in a collection somewhere.

Why would a hunter (or anyone else) want to approach a stinking corpse that he'd be sure is a bear if he's one who believes Sasquatches are a myth? AS I've mentioned, bodies of anything are extremely rare in the PNW.

And as far as I know, the claim that bear carcasses are not found is not very solid. Animal carcasses are found in the wild, even in areas plenty of scavengers.


They're seldom found, not not found. Piles of elk bones are found in eastern Washington, but not in western Washington.

I worked in tropical rainforests, among other types of areas. I worked in conservation areas, in private-owned areas, far or close to cities. I have found corpses of animals on several ocasions, big and small, not to mention roadkills. Humans have the habit of wandering around. Note that many - if not most- bifoot sightings are in camp areas and roads.


Because that's where the people are.

And these are not exactly desert places.


I was referring to the border.


Alleged hominid tracks.

The language of science is cautious.

But they were found!!! Why no bigfoot remain so far?


Because they haven't been found yet? (Just a guess........)

Now, if the forest is so dense at ground level, then the existence of large animals are not favored. Dense vegetation at the ground level renders the movment of large animals quite difficult. This is one of the main reasons why there are few large mammals in South America Tropical Rainforests. Tapirs, that may be above 250kg, are semi-aquatic.


Skamania County had bear, cougar, Roosevelt elk.........Dense vegetation at ground level is Salal, Oregon grape, Devil's Club, then Vine Maple and more Vine Maple. It's quite springy and easy to get through, actually, even by bipedal hominids such as us. It's almost impossible to see through, though.


There are indeed elephants, gorillas and rhinos living in tropical rainforests such as those from Africa and Sumatra. However, these animals create trails for their movments (not to mention that elephants and rhinos that live inside these forests are smaller than those living at opne fields). And a detail that is forgotten by many people: The tropical rainforests inhabited by these animals are relatively open at ground level.


Interesting, but what does this have to do with temperate rainforests? Other than an old skid road that was being used as a game trail by a small herd of deer, I can't say I ever saw a game trail where I lived.

Sumatra is a special case. It is inhabited by lizzards and other animals that can glide from a tree to another. These adaptations werer developed because the spacing between the trees is larger than in other tropical rainforests. What makes easier for elephants and rhinos to move among them - but still across preterminated paths.


That works for them. Sasquatches don't roam in herds.

Now, all of this adds another element of implausibility for the existence of a population of unknown large mammals in North America.


Mn, no, it's apples and oranges. Good attempt at trying to prove a negative, though. I commend you.

And if the forest bigfeet are supposed to live are not that dense... Then someone used a poor excuse.


They're extremely dense where the loggers haven't got 'em. Google up some pictures.

People can track felines (big and small), deer, gorillas, racoons, wolverines, bear, wolves, moose, etc. But they can´t track a 2+ meter-high ape? Don´t you think its a bit weird and implausible?


No, because I talked to one who had spent years trying to track them. He and his team were feeding all data into computers trying to determine some kind of pattern. There was none that they could find.

He could not use manual focus?

Evidently he was a bit rattled. He apparently dropped the camera when the figure turned toward him.
 
Psiload said:
Time for a little dinner theatre:

LAL arrives at BFRO headquarters one bright, sunny morning and notices that a co-worker's cubicle has been cleaned out.

LAL (to boss): Hey, what happened to Ralph?

Boss: He was terminated for drug use. The results of his urinalysis came back negative. The lab could not identify any known contraband substances in his system.

LAL (shaking head): Tsk tsk. He was obviously hopped up on some exotic new designer scag they couldn't identify.

Boss: Yeah, obviously. A real shame. You think you know a person.

Y'know, that wouldn't even make a good skit, let alone a documentary. As for dinner, I'll cancel my order.

For starters, I have no idea where "BFRO headquarters" is. For seconders, I resent the implication that people who are willing to investigate are into drugs.

So what does any of this have to do with Dr. Meldrum?
 
Diogenes said:
Trying?

Think a minute.. How would one go about dispelling the notion that there is more than anecdotal evidence?

Hint: It is not by telling another anecdote.

It's by pointing out there is physical evidence.

What part of "indistinguishable from human hair ", Is confusing you ?

Read the whole paragraph, will you, or even the whole sentence?

And this:

"After lengthy deliberation, we (W. H. Fahrenbach, J. A. Poe, and P. Fuerst), co-authors of the intended article on the Eastern Washington hair found in August, 1995, have decided to withhold submission of the manuscript of the analysis until more DNA from tissue, preferably with attached hair, is obtained. Our studies have not yielded a sequenced mitochondrial gene fragment to determine the phylogenetic affiliation of the creature. The ambiguous results at the present time can, on the one hand, generate misplaced enthusiasm and be quoted as "proof", or, on the other hand, can be used by the opposite camp to criticize and denigrate the results unfairly."
 
LAL said:
There are a lot more of them [horses and deer]. I've never seen a truck on some of those Washington backroads.
It's estimated that there are only around 20 mountain lions in the region between LA and San Diego; they still manage to go and get themselves hit by cars every now and then. It's hard to believe that a Bigfoot has yet to lose a game of chicken with a vehicle.

This sighting was thoroughly investigated. It convinced the sherriff. I heard the waitress' story from her and knew the people who followed the double trackway for seven miles. They were quite sane.

I convinced the sheriff,
but I did not convince no deputy,
Oh, no, oh


(Sorry, couldn't help myself. My apologies to Bob Marley.) They may have been "quite sane," but could still have been delusional/mistaken/etc. Going back to So Cal mountain lions; rangers in the local parks are required to post mtn. lion siting warnings whenever they are reported; however, in talking with the rangers privately, they frequently comment that the "siter" had most likely mistaken a bobcat, coyote, or golden retriever for a lion. There have actually been very few confirmed sitings of the big cats. I know, it's a bigger stretch to go from "I saw a Bigfoot" to "it was actually a chipmunk," but the mind can play tricks on you. I SWEAR that on a recent mountain biking trip I saw a gigantic tarantula; I'm talking about 12 inches across with a leg the size of a baby's arm. Scared the crap out of me, and I still can't be sure of what it was (although it was most likely two squirrels humping.)

edited for stuff.
 
LAL said:
Read the whole paragraph, will you, or even the whole sentence?

And this:

"After lengthy deliberation, we (W. H. Fahrenbach, J. A. Poe, and P. Fuerst), co-authors of the intended article on the Eastern Washington hair found in August, 1995, have decided to withhold submission of the manuscript of the analysis until more DNA from tissue, preferably with attached hair, is obtained. Our studies have not yielded a sequenced mitochondrial gene fragment to determine the phylogenetic affiliation of the creature. The ambiguous results at the present time can, on the one hand, generate misplaced enthusiasm and be quoted as "proof", or, on the other hand, can be used by the opposite camp to criticize and denigrate the results unfairly."

That quote is an 'update', published March 20, 1998 at
http://www.bfro.net/REF/THEORIES/WHF/dnatests.htm

If you read the whole page, you'll see a further 'update', published November 3, 1999, more than a year and a half AFTER the update you've quoted, where Dr. Fahrenbach states:

I have by now a dozen purported sasquatch hair samples, all morphologically congruent (which rules out hoaxing) and all effectively indistinguishable from a human hair of the particular structure (great variability is available among the latter). DNA extracted from both hair shaft or roots (hair demonstrably fresh) was too fragmented to permit gene sequencing. That characteristic is also sometimes found in human hair that lacks the medulla (as does sasquatch hair - at least what I am willing to identify as such).

I am concentrating now on blood or tissue, as the hair holds no promise. Feces do so even less, since the DNA collecting has to be done while they are practically steaming fresh, and it is improbable in the extreme that anybody with fecal DNA expertize would stumble onto fresh sasquatch droppings.

Contrary to popular belief, I have not encountered any deliberate effort to produce a hoax with hair samples, even in the much decried case of the fiber sample gathered by Paul Freeman. The same man-made fibers have been found elsewhere in the mountains by others and may be an environmental contaminant. People like Paul Freeman submit these samples for analysis precisely because they are not sure what they are at the time of collection.

In short, Dr. Fahrenbach is saying he can't positively identify the hair samples, cannot even distinguish them from human hair, and that following the hair trail will not lead to positive results. You seem to be reading someting else into his statements, that he has positively identified sasquatch hair, for example. At least that's how it appears from my point of view.

RayG
 
Blackwell said:
It's estimated that there are only around 20 mountain lions in the region between LA and San Diego; they still manage to go and get themselves hit by cars every now and then. It's hard to believe that a Bigfoot has yet to lose a game of chicken with a vehicle.



There's considerably more traffic between LA and San Diego than there is between Vancouver, Washington, and White Salmon, e.g.

I convinced the sheriff,
but I did not convince no deputy,
Oh, no, oh



Cute, but the deputies were convinced as well.

They may have been "quite sane," but could still have been delusional/mistaken/etc.



Sheriff Closner kept a cast on his desk for years. Columbian film crews filmed the trackway. Was the camera delusional?


Going back to So Cal mountain lions; rangers in the local parks are required to post mtn. lion siting warnings whenever they are reported; however, in talking with the rangers privately, they frequently comment that the "siter" had most likely mistaken a bobcat, coyote, or golden retriever for a lion. There have actually been very few confirmed sitings of the big cats. I know, it's a bigger stretch to go from "I saw a Bigfoot" to "it was actually a chipmunk," but the mind can play tricks on you. I SWEAR that on a recent mountain biking trip I saw a gigantic tarantula; I'm talking about 12 inches across with a leg the size of a baby's arm. Scared the crap out of me, and I still can't be sure of what it was (although it was most likely two squirrels humping.)

There have been cases of mistaken identity and some height estimates seem to be exaggerated, but there are, according to Green, over 8000 reports in the BFRO's database. It's not hard to find photos of tracks on the Internet.

People who've lived with bears all their lives are not likely to confuse a bear with an apelike creature walking bipedally.
 
LAL said:
Y'know, that wouldn't even make a good skit, let alone a documentary. As for dinner, I'll cancel my order.

For starters, I have no idea where "BFRO headquarters" is. For seconders, I resent the implication that people who are willing to investigate are into drugs.

So what does any of this have to do with Dr. Meldrum?
Wooooosh!

Right over your head.
 
RayG said:

In short, Dr. Fahrenbach is saying he can't positively identify the hair samples, cannot even distinguish them from human hair, and that following the hair trail will not lead to positive results. You seem to be reading someting else into his statements, that he has positively identified sasquatch hair, for example. At least that's how it appears from my point of view.

RayG

I've read the whole thing several times and have been looking for other reports. He even tells the proper way to collect it. He says he has a dozen samples he's willing to identify as Sasquatch hair, but without a sample of known Sasquatch hair, of course, it's inconclusive.

"Bigfoot hair has been subjected to intense attempts at DNA analysis. All the extracted DNA, though ample, was too fragmented to permit mitochondrial DNA gene sequencing. Since the same problem exists for a significant percentage of human hairs, we attribute this problem to the absence of a medulla (always in sasquatch hair, often in human hair). We no longer consider hair a promising subject for further attempts at DNA sequencing, but must wait for
tissue or blood samples.

There is no absolutely identified sasquatch hair. I have 12 samples from 4 states, all collected under suggestive or excellent circumstances. They measure from 3 to 15 inches in length, are all under 90 microns in diameter, all have a reddish tinge under the microscope, and all are lacking a medulla. You can find human hair like that, but a dozen samples like that, collected
independently, are not suggestive of hoaxing."

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/biology/hair.htm

There are close to twenty extinct "human" species. Might they not all have had hair indestinguishable from human hair by any criteria?
Chimpanzee DNA and human DNA differ by a per cent or two.

I recently read a report of one seen doing some tree-twisting. I'll try to remember where.
Bindernagle discusses this in his book.
 
Psiload said:
Wooooosh!

Right over your head.

Not really. I used to be in Harness Racing and was well aware the tests weren't adequate to detect everything a trainer could slide under the Lasix.

I'm just not into attempted ridicule as a proper form of debate.
 
Blackwell said:
rangers in the local parks are required to post mtn. lion siting warnings whenever they are reported; however, in talking with the rangers privately, they frequently comment that the "siter" had most likely mistaken a bobcat, coyote, or golden retriever for a lion.

Semi-related, my parents once saw a mountain lion out in the woods--again in Oregon--and thought it was a dog. It wasn't until they'd watched it for a minute that it occurred to them that dogs just don't move like that and that tail wasn't right at all. Because they didn't expect to see mountain lions, knowing that, well, you hardly EVER see mountain lions, it took awhile to realize just what it was, and if they hadn't had a few minutes to observe it, would probably have gone away thinking at most that it was a coyote.

The funny thing about the sizes is that, while cougars of course seem huge when they're alive, the dead ones are often not very large at all--they're all leg and feet and there's next to no meat on their bones, and they don't seem any bigger than a dog. Likewise, the elk in the area reportedly weighed between six and eight hundred pounds--maybe a thousand for the biggest bulls. I would swear up, down, and sideways that one I practically stepped on was a monster the size of a moose, a megaceros, a bull elephant, possibly a land whale. It was gigantic. It blotted out the sun. I'm sure when the elk tells the story, it says I was nine feet tall, weighed half a ton, and breathed fire.

All that being said, if our enormous hypothetical Bigfoot exists after all, when they locate it, it'll probably turn out to be four feet tall and weigh sixty pounds.
 
LAL said:
I've read the whole thing several times and have been looking for other reports. He even tells the proper way to collect it. He says he has a dozen samples he's willing to identify as Sasquatch hair, but without a sample of known Sasquatch hair, of course, it's inconclusive.

Exactly.

"Bigfoot hair has been subjected to intense attempts at DNA analysis. All the extracted DNA, though ample, was too fragmented to permit mitochondrial DNA gene sequencing. Since the same problem exists for a significant percentage of human hairs, we attribute this problem to the absence of a medulla (always in sasquatch hair, often in human hair). We no longer consider hair a promising subject for further attempts at DNA sequencing, but must wait for tissue or blood samples.

Can't disput that.

There is no absolutely identified sasquatch hair. I have 12 samples from 4 states, all collected under suggestive or excellent circumstances. They measure from 3 to 15 inches in length, are all under 90 microns in diameter, all have a reddish tinge under the microscope, and all are lacking a medulla. You can find human hair like that, but a dozen samples like that, collected
independently, are not suggestive of hoaxing."

Can't argue with that either.


That quote/page is from an article written by Dr. Fahrenbach in 1997. His more recent statements (1998 and 1999) were just as inconclusive. Pointing out even older information does little to support your case.

There are close to twenty extinct "human" species. Might they not all have had hair indestinguishable from human hair by any criteria?

Not sure what you're trying to argue here. Are you suggesting that sasquatch is a formerly extinct 'human' species that now wanders the woods of the world?

What I'm suggesting is that, if the sasquatch hair can't be clearly identified as non-human, maybe it IS human hair and not from a sasquatch at all.

Chimpanzee DNA and human DNA differ by a per cent or two.

Irrelevant. Approximately 150,000,000 gene sequences DON'T match. That's a significant difference. Besides, the FBI claims it can differentiate between human and animal hair, Dr. Fahrenbach apparently cannot.

RayG
 
RayG said:
Exactly.

That quote/page is from an article written by Dr. Fahrenbach in1997. His more recent statements (1998 and 1999) were just as inconclusive. Pointing out even older information does little to support your case.

It explains the problem with the medulla or lack thereof, which is why I posted it. What does the date matter? There's still no tissue is there? The B.C. lab essentially said the same thing in 2003.

The most recent hair I know of is from 2005, but I can't find a report on the Net.

It's all "inconclusive" until a body's brought in.


Not sure what you're trying to argue here. Are you suggesting that sasquatch is a formerly extinct 'human' species that now wanders the woods of the world?



No, just a close relative of Homo. Tattersal and Schwartz include Australopiths with "extinct humans".

What I'm suggesting is that, if the sasquatch hair can't be clearly identified as non-human, maybe it IS human hair and not from a sasquatch at all.


I know that's what you're suggesting, but it has characteristitics that make it unlikely to be human. I kind of think someone with the smarts to earn a PhD might have considered that possibility before he became willing to identify them as Sasquatch and risk being laughed out of the research center.

Irrelevant. Approximately 150,000,000 gene sequences DON'T match. That's a significant difference.



Why is it irrelevant? There are far more similarities than differences.
Here's what's in the 1%:

http://www.news.cornell.edu/Chronicle/04/2.12.04/human_chimp_DNA.html

Wouldn't a closer relative have even more similarities, such as in the mode of locomotion and the hair?

Besides, the FBI claims it can differentiate between human and animal hair, Dr. Fahrenbach apparently cannot.



We're animals. :p
Does the FBI have unidentified hominid hair for comparison? It isn't fur, it's hair, and others have identified it as "unknown primate".
 
Weren't you tjhe one who was arguing The prints should be shallower because of the distribution of weight?

I believe my point was that they should not be any deeper. A much bigger "human" with a much bigger foot should come out about even, I thought.

Of course, if he was carrying a recently twisted off redwood tree.....
 
others have identified it as "unknown primate".

So they know for sure it's hair from an unknown primate?

Have they published this extraordinary finding in any peer reviewed journals?

I had no idea that the existence of an unknown primate in the area had been proven.

You apparently have all you need then to interest mainstream science in this primate.
 
http://www.texasbigfoot.com/016_905.html

Operaton Primate Web 2 is reported on here.

If you scroll down to Sunday, 9 January 2005, you'll see that once again the BFRO appears to be very hot on the trail of bigfoot.

Two team members appear to have actually seen bigfoot early that morning, and evidence in the area of the sighting supports them.

The search is abandoned the same day.....
 
RayG said:
I thought that's what I had been saying. ;)


That's what everybody says, even the the scientists who are convinced. "Inconclusive" doesn't mean "pure bunk", however. ;)
 
LTC8K6 said:
http://www.texasbigfoot.com/016_905.html

Operaton Primate Web 2 is reported on here.

If you scroll down to Sunday, 9 January 2005, you'll see that once again the BFRO appears to be very hot on the trail of bigfoot.

Two team members appear to have actually seen bigfoot early that morning, and evidence in the area of the sighting supports them.

The search is abandoned the same day.....

Neither Hall nor Parker were members of the BFRO. The frustration was noted at having to call it off because many had a long drive home. It was a combined effort of the TBRO and the BFRO.

Evidently there haven't been enough T-shirts sold to fund a couple of full-time researchers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom