Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Diogenes said:
A consensus of one ?

According to Chris Stringer (you do know who he is, I hope), the consensus is that bipedalism was first. I didn't think it was necessary to spell that out.

Adv. 1. et al. - used as an abbreviation of `et alii' (masculine plural) or `et aliae' (feminine plural) or `et alia' (neutral plural) when referring to a number of people
 
LAL said:
According to Chris Stringer (you do know who he is, I hope), the consensus is that bipedalism was first.

Do you have some links to specific info on this? From what little I've read about his bipedalism approach, it appears to apply to wading, not knuckle-walking. I've not yet stumbled across any confirmation that bipedalism came first, though I might not be looking in the right place.

RayG
 
LAL said:
According to Chris Stringer (you do know who he is, I hope),


How does knowing who he is, support your position? ( appeal to authority )


the consensus is that bipedalism was first. I didn't think it was necessary to spell that out.

Adv. 1. et al. - used as an abbreviation of `et alii' (masculine plural) or `et aliae' (feminine plural) or `et alia' (neutral plural) when referring to a number of people
I find no such concensus.

Can you point to a paper that suggests bipedalism predated walking on all fours by any animal?
 
Whole villages that had never seen a white man died of the white man's diseases.

Contact in reference to spreading disease does not equal "seen" or even touched.

Did those blankets, etc., indirectly reach bigfoot too?

Did whole villages of Bigfoot die out as well?

Dead bear:
CableCanyonDeadBearDec2003S.JPG
 
big feet and carvings

While I'm not an expert on Big feet- mine are only size 13- I am a professional wood carver. Can anybody here point me to a photo of a BF footprint that shows the 'dermal ridges' ? I think lengthwise ridges may be an artifact of the carving process, and I may be able to identify the tool used....If I was carving a foot 16" long, I would use lengthwise strokes.

I also wonder about the depth of these'footprints'. Seems to me an elephant wouldn't sink in so far as Bigfoot did, but a man stomping on a molded rubber foot might.... and/or a deer running will place his hoofs in a tight cluster, rears into the same place the fronts had left just previously, making 'footprints in the snow' at lengths equal to BF's supposed stride. Most of the BF track photo's Ive pulled up have been in the snow, melted beyond any recognition. I'm sure someone here will educate me...
 
Originally posted by LAL
Yep. And some have had sightings. Again, there has never been a proper scientific investigation, because mainstream science doesn't take it seriously.

You should understand that attacks to "mainstream science" do not help. They will only level you down with woos.

Anyway, why the notion of large unknown primates living in North America is not taken seriously? Simple. Because its highly implausible. There´s very little support. Would I gather support if I claimed that there is a dinosaur living somewhere in Brazil?

Originally posted by LAL There are a lot more of them. I've never seen a truck on some of those Washington backroads.

Uh... Bigfeet population estimates according to the figures you provided a few posts ago are bigger than many endangered species - or populations - that quite often become roadkills. And are all bigfeet living in this area of Washington? According to your posts, and the data at the sites you linked, no. There are reported sightings in touristic areas in national parks as well as forests with logging activity, and there are plenty of trucks and roads in these areas. And note that even you wrote " I've never seen a truck on some of those Washington backroads". There are others, with trucks, I suppose.

Originally posted by LAL And tracks? This sighting was thoroughly investigated. It convinced the sherriff. I heard the waitress' story from her and knew the people who followed the double trackway for seven miles. They were quite sane.

Who said they were not sane? They could just have been mistaken.

Originally posted by LAL
There is now at least one place to report sightings and many are followed up. Some turn out to be mistaken identity, but many check out. I've experienced "buck fever" myself, but I saw a doe, not a Sasquatch, an the illusion only lasted for an instant.

What is considered a reliable report? A person claiming to have seen a big ape in the woods? What criteria are used to check out? What about the reports linking bigfeet to UFOs?

Why do you think your experience with an illusion is the rule?

Originally posted by LAL People are often reluctant to report what they've seen because of the scoffing and ridicule they receive. Read this board if you don't think that's true.

Who´s scoffing and ridiculing you here? You claimed that bigfoot is real. We are just questioning your claim because we don´t think the evidences backing the claim are enough. If I were writing at a bigfoot forum defending the point that bigfoot is a myth, what sort of reaction would I obtain?

And if any biologist working in the woods ever manages to see a bigfoot, I´m pretty sure he/she would not hesitate and would do his/her best to raise funds to find out more about it. Same is valid for a good quality footage obtained by any wildlife photographer. But bigfeet just do not appear to this sort of people... Could this be the skeptic influence reported by those who belive in the paranormal?

Originally posted by LAL
What's sketchy about trackways that go for miles, multiple witness sightings backed up by film.............

Wait a minute... Trackways that go for miles, eh? So they should not be so impossible to track as bigfoot researchers claim. Another weird problem noted.

The footage, please, are far from convincing. And the reports are anedoctal evidence, and many -if not most- are really sketchy. If these are sound evidence, UFOs, Nessie, Ogopogo and ghosts must also be true...

Originally posted by LAL No. And your idea of waiting at waterholes would probably work quite well in the Serengeti.

Ambushing a large mammal does not work at these forests where bigfeet live... So, hunters have no succes on tracking their prey? No hunter or wildlife photographer sets a shelter near a track, a tree ripe with fruits, a carcass, a drinking place and is successful? This is weird...

Originally posted by LAL It's unfortunate it wasn't reported at the time. But for those who think it's all illusion or paranormal nonsense or that no body has ever been seen, there's at least this one report. There's another of two burying a third, but since it was from students on a hike, who would believe them?

The problem is that these are just reports. But, OK, lets suppose the reports are credible and bigfeet do bury their dead. How deep are their graves? Deep enough to avoid scavengers such as wolves, coyotes and bears to dig them out? Oh, and if someone saw two burying their dead mate, please answer me why no bigfeet researcher has ever just went to the grave to recover the body? Why people have not followed the students to recover what could be a spetacular find?

Originally posted by LAL Tell me what biologist is working with bear in, say, Washington State?

Tell me, no biologists do field work in Washington? Not even undergratuate students? Weird...

Originally posted by LAL Should have? Is there a timetable on this? If a team went looking for a body in a 750 sq. mi. area, rugged, riddled with lava tubes, full of rotten snags and hollow logs, an no clue about where one would be except there's a statistical possibility one is there, where would be a good place to start?

The timetable started when the first naturalist arrived to North America. Since then, there were chances that a carcass of such an animal would have been found - or one would have been shot. As population increased and more roads were constructed, the chances also increased.

Originally posted by LAL As I recall, it was on a trail.
The mistaken identity is only a possibility as is the speculation there may be bones, misidentified, in a collection somewhere.

Why would a hunter (or anyone else) want to approach a stinking corpse that he'd be sure is a bear if he's one who believes Sasquatches are a myth? AS I've mentioned, bodies of anything are extremely rare in the PNW.

They're seldom found, not not found. Piles of elk bones are found in eastern Washington, but not in western Washington.

You truly think a naturalist or a biologist would not find the femur of a large ape very different from the usual findings from bear, deer, elk, etc.?

There´s a post by a ranger a few posts above. Perhaps you would like to know what he has to say about carcasses in the woods. Anyway, even if scavenging is exeptionally efficeint at PNW, why a corpse of a bigfoot has never been found somewhere else? They are not restricted to that area area they?

And in a national park, at a private reserve, or at any area where someanimal population study is going on, some people wold have to "approach a stinking corpse that he'd be sure is a bear". It would be his/hers work to know why it died and exactly what individual was that. Heck, my wive had to collect and study dung from monkeys when she was studying them (she´s a biologist). And she spent day after day observing them in the woods. A friend of ours did similar thing with wolves - and they were much harder to spot (the wolves, not the dung). Another one spent days watching birds and recording their sounds. Two or three others made surveys of animal population in conservation areas - months in the field, collecting and/or examining all sort of dung or rotten carcasses, setting traps, scanning the area with binoculars, etc. All this mean a lot of time in the wilderness, with attention completely turned to animals. Now, we are talking about Brazil, a third world country where money for research is scarce at best and there are relatively few people doing this sirt of work. Don´t you think its at least a bit improbable that these animals would have been identified by now in USA?

Originally posted by LAL Because that's where the people are.

Not just people, but also bigfeet, otherwise ther would be no reports of sighting... What raises the questions I and other posters have been asking.

Originally posted by LAL Because they haven't been found yet? (Just a guess........)

Or because they don´t exist?

Originally posted by LAL
Skamania County had bear, cougar, Roosevelt elk.........Dense vegetation at ground level is Salal, Oregon grape, Devil's Club, then Vine Maple and more Vine Maple. It's quite springy and easy to get through, actually, even by bipedal hominids such as us. It's almost impossible to see through, though.

But then, again, tracking bigfeet is not that impossible... Also, searching for their corpses, hiding places, etc.

Originally posted by LAL They're extremely dense where the loggers haven't got 'em. Google up some pictures.

Extremely dense? Then there should be no big ground animals, since walking across it would be very difficult. But there are bear, moose, deer, etc., as you stated. Thus they must not be so dense at ground level. And so, bigfeet could be tracked, their corpses become easier to find, wildlife photographers should have been able to take good shots of it, scientists and rangers should have been able to see and study them, etc.

If I what I have read is correct, temperate forests, the sort of habitat bigfeet are supposed to live, are truly dense at ground level only at its borders and where trees are young. The canopy of tall trees block sunlight, so the growth of smaller plants becomes difficult. When a tree falls, its like the start of a race - plants start using the opportunity to grow. And while the canopy is not yet well developed, smaller (as well as younger) plants can grow, creating entangled vegetation. As soon as the canopy block sunlight, the entangled vegetation dies. And depending on the type of temperate forest (some varieties of pinus, for example), periodic forest fires clear the low-level vegetation, but leaves the tall trees unharmed - they are adapted to this. These forests are composed by tall trees, but with enough open space at ground level to allow a moose to walk with ease. And many sighting reports come from such areas. And yet no solid evidence was found.

Originally posted by LAL
No, because I talked to one who had spent years trying to track them. He and his team were feeding all data into computers trying to determine some kind of pattern. There was none that they could find.

Perhaps because things that do not exist have no pattern.

Originally posted by LAL Evidently he was a bit rattled. He apparently dropped the camera when the figure turned toward him.

So, bigfeet appears just to people who will take fuzzy pictures?

A comparsion with gorilla population density helps to highlight some of the problems with the existence of a population of large primates in North America:

IUCN status and population figures for gorilla:
Mountain gorilla: Critically Endangered (650)
Cross River gorilla: Critically Endangered (200)

And yet, they are constantly tracked, filmed and unfortunately, hunted. See the numbers? Compare with those you provided for bigfoot population estimates. Why bigfeet can evade while gorillas can´t?

Gorilla population is being endangered by growing human population. Contacts became more frequent. And compare the distribution of human population in Africa with that from USA. Why this does not affects bigfeet?

Sources:
www.wwf.org.uk/researcher/ issues/rarespecies/0000000152.asp
http://www.berggorilla.de/english/gjournal/texte/18takam.html
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...ve&db=PubMed&list_uids=14586801&dopt=Abstract
Some more problems for bigfoot...
The fossil record does not provides any support for the existence of an unknown species of large apes both in South and North America. Specially if you consider bigfeet as some sort of hominid species.
Hominid fossils are restricted to Africa, Asia and Europe. The earliest known ones are from Africa and date from 22 to 18 My. Gigantopithecus, bigfoot´s most common identification, is from China´s Pleistocene (11Ky ago), and no fossils of it -or any similar species- have yet been found in any of the Americas. The largest fossil primates (also the largest known primates from the Americas) are Caipora bambuiorum and Protopithecus, both from South America. They are New World monkeys, what means they are quite different from hominids and Old World apes. And they weighted between 20 and 40kg.
Similar problems are faced by any ideas relating bigfoot to great apes such as chimpanzees and gorillas. No fossils of great apes heve ever been found in the Americas.
North America, despite though having quite old primate fossil remains, does not seem to be a pleasant habitats for apes. Actually, they seem to be restricted to tropical areas. Fossil ape populations have prosperated in tropical areas in Africa, Asia and Europe.
Some usefull links:
http://www.pnas.org/cgi/content/abstract/93/13/6405
http://www.leeds.ac.uk/chb/lectures/anthl_09.html
http://highered.mcgraw-hill.com/sites/0072485949/student_view0/chapter12/

So, do you really think that, taking in to account all the pro and cons, one can say its absolutely certain that there is a population of unknown large primates in North America?

Or it would not be better to say something like "It is possible that there is a population of unknown large primates in North America, but its highly improbable".
 
RayG said:
Do you have some links to specific info on this? From what little I've read about his bipedalism approach, it appears to apply to wading, not knuckle-walking. I've not yet stumbled across any confirmation that bipedalism came first, though I might not be looking in the right place.

RayG

I did. Give me a little time to wade through over 300 saved sites and articles on human evolution.
 
LAL said:
Whole villages that had never seen a white man died of the white man's diseases.

Whole villages indeed - those Indians had a pretty sophisticated social structure with villages, plantations, organized trading, alliances, etc., and this is one of the reasons such pandemics were possible. What evidence do we have that sasquatches are organized into such communities? Are we missing not only the squatches themselves, but their villages and their trade routes?
 
LAL said:
Originally posted by RayG

Do you have some links to specific info on this? From what little I've read about his bipedalism approach, it appears to apply to wading, not knuckle-walking. I've not yet stumbled across any confirmation that bipedalism came first, though I might not be looking in the right place.

I did. Give me a little time to wade through over 300 saved sites and articles on human evolution.

Nice pun. :D

RayG
 
Correa Neto said:
You should understand that attacks to "mainstream science" do not help. They will only level you down with woos.


When did I attack mainstrean science? Efforts have been made over forty years to interest mainstream science.

I was labled a "woo" the minute I hit the board. What can I possibly do to make it worse?

Anyway, why the notion of large unknown primates living in North America is not taken seriously? Simple. Because its highly implausible. There´s very little support. Would I gather support if I claimed that there is a dinosaur living somewhere in Brazil?


It's implausible we may have living bipedal relatives on earth? Why is that so implausible?

Uh... Bigfeet population estimates according to the figures you provided a few posts ago are bigger than many endangered species - or populations - that quite often become roadkills. And are all bigfeet living in this area of Washington? According to your posts, and the data at the sites you linked, no. There are reported sightings in touristic areas in national parks as well as forests with logging activity, and there are plenty of trucks and roads in these areas. And note that even you wrote " I've never seen a truck on some of those Washington backroads". There are others, with trucks, I suppose.


There have been several encounters involving screeching brakes and terrified motorists. A friend's daughter and her friends saw one en route home from the Prom on Hwy 14. If you knew how deserted that highway was at night, you'd wonder how they happened to be lucky enough to even see it.


Who said they were not sane? They could just have been mistaken.



There was physical evidence.


What is considered a reliable report? A person claiming to have seen a big ape in the woods? What criteria are used to check out?



I suggest you read some reports and the comments by investigators.


What about the reports linking bigfeet to UFOs?


Who cares?

Why do you think your experience with an illusion is the rule?


Huh? Bipedalism was common in the ancient ape world. There was even a bipedal ape in Italy. The recently found "last common ancestor" seems to have been upright most of the time.

Who´s scoffing and ridiculing you here? You claimed that bigfoot is real. We are just questioning your claim because we don´t think the evidences backing the claim are enough. If I were writing at a bigfoot forum defending the point that bigfoot is a myth, what sort of reaction would I obtain?


You'd be scoffed at and ridiculed by a few, but seriously debated by most. Try it and see.

And if any biologist working in the woods ever manages to see a bigfoot, I´m pretty sure he/she would not hesitate and would do his/her best to raise funds to find out more about it. Same is valid for a good quality footage obtained by any wildlife photographer. But bigfeet just do not appear to this sort of people... Could this be the skeptic influence reported by those who belive in the paranormal?


Forget the paranormal, please.

Dr. John Bindernagle has written a book and papers for presentation and all he found was a trackway.

Wait a minute... Trackways that go for miles, eh? So they should not be so impossible to track as bigfoot researchers claim. Another weird problem noted.


The people I knew who followed the seven miles of double trackway lost it in forest. The tracks were in snow and several days old when they were found. The animals were long gone.

The footage, please, are far from convincing. And the reports are anedoctal evidence, and many -if not most- are really sketchy. If these are sound evidence, UFOs, Nessie, Ogopogo and ghosts must also be true...


Non sequitur.

Never mind that the Patterson film has been analysed to pieces over 38 years, and it still holds up. Try reading some of the analyses instead of dismissing it as "fuzzy". It's pretty clear, and there are some very good reasons it cannot be a man in a suit, despite the wishful thinking of sceptics.

Ambushing a large mammal does not work at these forests where bigfeet live... So, hunters have no succes on tracking their prey? No hunter or wildlife photographer sets a shelter near a track, a tree ripe with fruits, a carcass, a drinking place and is successful? This is weird.


It's just possible a homidid primate is more intelligent than the average bear.
Fruit bait was taken on the Skookum expedition. I'm impressed by what they did get, not tearing my hair out because they didn't come back with a body.

The problem is that these are just reports. But, OK, lets suppose the reports are credible and bigfeet do bury their dead. How deep are their graves? Deep enough to avoid scavengers such as wolves, coyotes and bears to dig them out? Oh, and if someone saw two burying their dead mate, please answer me why no bigfeet researcher has ever just went to the grave to recover the body? Why people have not followed the students to recover what could be a spetacular find?


I don't know. Could be because the report was from years before and the students weren't sure of the spot. Many people do not report for fear of ridicule and it's only been in recent years that people could report to an organization rather than just to law enforcement.

Tell me, no biologists do field work in Washington? Not even undergratuate students? Weird...


On Sasquatches? Here's a graduate student:

http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/sbs/somer87.htm


The timetable started when the first naturalist arrived to North America. Since then, there were chances that a carcass of such an animal would have been found - or one would have been shot. As population increased and more roads were constructed, the chances also increased.


And still do.

You truly think a naturalist or a biologist would not find the femur of a large ape very different from the usual findings from bear, deer, elk, etc.?


Remember the famous case of the hominid clavical Dr. Tim White determined was a fossil dolphin bone?

There´s a post by a ranger a few posts above. Perhaps you would like to know what he has to say about carcasses in the woods. Anyway, even if scavenging is exeptionally efficeint at PNW, why a corpse of a bigfoot has never been found somewhere else? They are not restricted to that area area they?


I read it. I've also seen a statement from a ranger that he's never seen a bear carcass.
There are sightings and tracks from other areas, but most of the data seems to be from the Northwest.

And in a national park, at a private reserve, or at any area where someanimal population study is going on, some people wold have to "approach a stinking corpse that he'd be sure is a bear". It would be his/hers work to know why it died and exactly what individual was that. Heck, my wive had to collect and study dung from monkeys when she was studying them (she´s a biologist). And she spent day after day observing them in the woods. A friend of ours did similar thing with wolves - and they were much harder to spot (the wolves, not the dung). Another one spent days watching birds and recording their sounds. Two or three others made surveys of animal population in conservation areas - months in the field, collecting and/or examining all sort of dung or rotten carcasses, setting traps, scanning the area with binoculars, etc. All this mean a lot of time in the wilderness, with attention completely turned to animals. Now, we are talking about Brazil, a third world country where money for research is scarce at best and there are relatively few people doing this sirt of work. Don´t you think its at least a bit improbable that these animals would have been identified by now in USA?


Why, when so few mainstream scientists accept it? Where's the grant money? It's mostly been left to amateurs and they're scoffed at for being amateurs. Geez.

Not just people, but also bigfeet, otherwise ther would be no reports of sighting... What raises the questions I and other posters have been asking.


All of which are answerable, whether you accept the answers or not.

Or because they don´t exist?


If they don't exist, what's leaving all that "inconclusive" evidence?

But then, again, tracking bigfeet is not that impossible... Also, searching for their corpses, hiding places, etc.


A full-time team is needed.

Extremely dense? Then there should be no big ground animals, since walking across it would be very difficult. But there are bear, moose,


There are no Moose in the area I'm talking about.

deer, etc., as you stated. Thus they must not be so dense at ground level.


I lived in it. It's dense. The ground cover is one of the reasons it's difficult to track anything. There are a couple of layers of understory. These animals, deer included, are adapted to it.

And so, bigfeet could be tracked, their corpses become easier to find, wildlife photographers should have been able to take good shots of it, scientists and rangers should have been able to see and study them, etc.


Skeletons of Homo florensis should have been discovered much sooner than they were, the Ivory Billed Woodpecker should have been photographed much sooner than it was, Coelacanths should have been discovered much sooner than they were, Eric Rudolf should have been apprehended much sooner than he was, four new mammalian species in Viet Nam should have been discovered much sooner than they were............

If I what I have read is correct, temperate forests, the sort of habitat bigfeet are supposed to live, are truly dense at ground level only at its borders and where trees are young. The canopy of tall trees block sunlight, so the growth of smaller plants becomes difficult. When a tree falls, its like the start of a race - plants start using the opportunity to grow. And while the canopy is not yet well developed, smaller (as well as younger) plants can grow, creating entangled vegetation. As soon as the canopy block sunlight, the entangled vegetation dies. And depending on the type of temperate forest (some varieties of pinus, for example), periodic forest fires clear the low-level vegetation, but leaves the tall trees unharmed - they are adapted to this. These forests are composed by tall trees, but with enough open space at ground level to allow a moose to walk with ease. And many sighting reports come from such areas. And yet no solid evidence was found.



There are no Moose in Skamania County, Washington. No pine where I lived either. Too wet. I lived in mature second growth timber, mostly Douglas Fir. The canopy was open enough for plenty of sun to get to the Broadleaf Maple and Alder, Blackberries, Wild Raspberries.............Skamania County has the most reported sightings in the country.

No solid evidence was found by whom?

Perhaps because things that do not exist have no pattern.


Perhaps because they don't have migration routes and tend to roam randomly when feeding. The Powder Mountain tracks (in snow), went from Balsam stand to Balsam stand. The animal was apparently feeding on the Balsam berries. They were spotted and photographed from a helicopter. There is no sign of other activity in the snow.......it looks absolutely pristine.

So, bigfeet appears just to people who will take fuzzy pictures?


They mostly "appear" to people who don't happen to be carrying cameras at the time.

A comparsion with gorilla population density helps to highlight some of the problems with the existence of a population of large primates in North America:

IUCN status and population figures for gorilla:
Mountain gorilla: Critically Endangered (650)
Cross River gorilla: Critically Endangered (200)

And yet, they are constantly tracked, filmed and unfortunately, hunted. See the numbers? Compare with those you provided for bigfoot population estimates. Why bigfeet can evade while gorillas can´t?



Because they are not being monitored or hunted, except by a few "weekend warriors".

Gorillas travel in troops and leave considerable sign, including nest-making. Chimpanzees travel in troops as well.


Gorilla population is being endangered by growing human population. Contacts became more frequent. And compare the distribution of human population in Africa with that from USA. Why this does not affects bigfeet?




It does. The tracks near Bluff Creek were seen when new roads were going in. That's near a 17,500 sq.mi. area in Northern California that had only been mapped from the air.

Some more problems for bigfoot..

The fossil record does not provides any support for the existence of an unknown species of large apes both in South and North America. Specially if you consider bigfeet as some sort of hominid species.


There may be a living relative in Russia.

It was thought Homo couldn't get out of Africa until there was a sophisticated toolkit until Homo georgicus was discovered in Georgia in Russia a few years ago.

Hominid fossils are restricted to Africa, Asia and Europe. The earliest known ones are from Africa and date from 22 to 18 My......


The earliest known hominid fossil is "Toumai", Sahelanthropus tchadensis, circa 7-9 mya. The last common ancestor may be Pierolapithecus catalaunicus found near Barcelona, Spain. It's about 13 million years old.

Gigantopithecus, bigfoot´s most common identification, is from China´s Pleistocene (11Ky ago), and no fossils of it -or any similar species- have yet been found in any of the Americas.


Hardly any have been found in China.

The largest fossil primates (also the largest known primates from the Americas) are Caipora bambuiorum and Protopithecus, both from South America. They are New World monkeys, what means they are quite different from hominids and Old World apes. And they weighted between 20 and 40kg.



"Protopithecus brasiliensis Lund, 1838
Caipora bambuiorum Cartelle and Hartwig, 1996

'There is no smoke without fire' says the proverb. There really have been some larger primates in South America. The evidence consists of the fossil remains of two species of extinct giant primates in South America, which keeps paleo-primatologists and evolutionary primatologists extremely busy and excited today.

These fossil remains, however, other than the size of their bones indicating that they possibly belong to either a large howler (Alouatta), woolly (Brachyteles) or spider (Ateles) monkey (Hartwig and Cartelle, 1996; Cartelle and Hartwig, 1996) have nothing to do with the way these were discovered. In fact, they were found far from the region of Sierra de Perija, where Dr. de Loys originally encountered and then shot his spider monkey, more than 2800 miles southeast in the state of Bahia in Brazil.

A limestone cave system near the town of Lagoa Santa ('holy pond') about 20 miles north of Belo Horizonte ('beautiful horizon') (Simpson, 1984). This cave system has been a Mecca for anthropologists and paleontologists, where numerous mammal remains, such as ground-sloth, giant armadillo, bear, capybara and human remains have been found (Walter, 1948).

The Protopithecus brasiliensis remains (part of a femur and a humerus) were originally discovered by the Danish naturalist, Peter W. Lund in 1836 (Lund, 1836), but was largely misrepresented and ignored for more than 150 years (Hartwig, 1995). A complete skeleton of the same species has been found in another cave, Toca da Boa Vista near Campo Formosa in Bahia, Brazil in 1992. The remains indicate an animal of approximately 25 kg (about 50 pounds) mass of body size, which is twice the weight of the largest spider monkey live in South America today (Hartwig & Cartelle, 1996). The Caipora bambuiorum skeleton, which was also found in the same cave estimated to weight 20,5 kg (roughly 45 pounds) (Cartelle & Hartwig, 1996), but still considerably heavier than the biggest living spider monkey recorded so far (Peres, 1994).

These new findings indicate that these monkeys were substantially larger than their descendants today; certainly giants among the New World monkeys, but they fall far behind the mass weight of the chimpanzee, orangutan and gorilla, and they are not Apes."

Now one's claiming Sasquatches evolved in NA. They evidently came over the Bering Strait. Our species did too.

Similar problems are faced by any ideas relating bigfoot to great apes such as chimpanzees and gorillas. No fossils of great apes heve ever been found in the Americas.


No fossils of Chimpanzees and Gorillas have been found at all. There are around a thousand living species with no fossil record.
Fossilization is a rare event. Here's my favorite article on it:

http://home.tiac.net/~cri/1998/taphonomy.html

It's not likely they'd "devolve" from Great Apes. They may be another species of Great Ape. We're a medium-sized ape.

North America, despite though having quite old primate fossil remains, does not seem to be a pleasant habitats for apes. Actually, they seem to be restricted to tropical areas. Fossil ape populations have prosperated in tropical areas in Africa, Asia and Europe.



Elephants are tropical too, but they had relatives that lived in the tundra.
Hominid fossils have been found in Russia. They are practically Homo habilis
We're an ape and we live everywhere.

>snip<

So, do you really think that, taking in to account all the pro and cons, one can say its absolutely certain that there is a population of unknown large primates in North America?


Yes.

Or it would not be better to say something like "It is possible that there is a population of unknown large primates in North America, but its highly improbable".

No. I lived in Sasquatch country and practically everything I've read and seen on it since, except for UFO/paranormal silliness, has only strengthened my conviction.

Read Krantz.
 
Diogenes said:
I find no such concensus.

Can you point to a paper that suggests bipedalism predated walking on all fours by any animal?

Oh, for Pete's sake.

I was referring to bipedalism coming before knuckle-walking in the hominid/ape line, and it's no appeal to authority to refer to Chris Stringer on the evolution of bipedalism.

I have no idea where he stands on the unknown hominid primate issue.


I haven't found the article I'm looking for yet, but here's this:

""Dating the beginnings of bipedalism is very important in the human story because, for many experts, it would mark a clear divergence from the ancestral/ape pattern and show that the human lineage had really begun," said Chris Stringer, director of the Human Origins Program at the Natural History Museum in London.

Although this finding puts the development of bipedalism back by another two million years, it is not necessarily a surprise. The chimpanzee-human divergence has been estimated to have occurred between five and seven million years ago, based on genetic data.

"Now, for the first time, we have solid evidence dated to six million years ago of an intermediate creature between humans and the apes that demonstrated upright posture and bipedalism," said Robert Eckhardt, a developmental-genetics and evolutionary-morphology researcher at Pennsylvania State University. "And the dating of this fossil is unusually secure." "

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2004/09/0902_040902_upright_hominid.html
 
LAL said:
Oh, for Pete's sake.

I was referring to bipedalism coming before knuckle-walking in the hominid/ape line, and it's no appeal to authority to refer to Chris Stringer on the evolution of bipedalism.



What was your point?

Your appeal to authority was that I should know who he was...

What does knuckle walking have to do with Sasquatch?
 
Diogenes said:

What does knuckle walking have to do with Sasquatch?

I'm still trying to see where bipedalism predated knuckle-walking. That's what I thought was being presented, anyway.

Originally posted by LAL
But, bipedalism came first, according to the consensus with knuckle-walking a later adaptation in the Great Apes....I was referring to bipedalism coming before knuckle-walking in the hominid/ape line...

I see where Christopher Stringer thinks that wading may have preceeded bipedalism, and, as a result, bipedalism may have evolved earier than thought, but I still don't see where bipedalism came prior to knuckle-walking.

RayG
 
Diogenes said:
What was your point?

I don't know; I forgot. I've been busy trying to straighten out the quotes in the long post above.

Your appeal to authority was that I should know who he was...

Your inference. I asked if you know who he is. Of course, if you've looked into human evolution much you might have run across his name................If you'd said you didn't know I'd have told you.

It seems you've taken a course in logic. Did you pass?

What does knuckle walking have to do with Sasquatch?

It has to do with ancestry. There's no lack of bipedal primates in the fossil record.

If Giganto was a knuckle-walker, then it's probably not an ancestor or even a very close relative. If it was bipedal, then it's very possibly an ancestor, or even the same species.

Have Gigantopithecus fangs been found?
 
RayG said:

Nice pun. :D


Totally unintentional. I had no idea he had an opinion on wading, even though I found the remarkable RiverApes site a couple of years ago. I kind of skimmed it and then stuck it somewhere between Elaine Morgan and Rudyard Kipling's Just-So Stories.

Last I heard, the going hypothesis is that bipedalism was favored for food gathering while standing on branches in trees (Hunt, I think, and Tattersal, et al). Chimpanzees tend to do this at times.

I really liked the idea of gathering high protein foods and bringing them back to hidden mates and young, though........

Bipedalism had a lot of advantages, such as enabling early hominids to wave and throw and look threatening while short.
 
RayG said:
I'm still trying to see where bipedalism predated knuckle-walking. That's what I thought was being presented, anyway.



I see where Christopher Stringer thinks that wading may have preceeded bipedalism, and, as a result, bipedalism may have evolved earier than thought, but I still don't see where bipedalism came prior to knuckle-walking.

RayG

It would help if I could remember the name of the article. I've used it a few times in debates on Creationism vs. Evolution boards, and I'm not getting anything Googling the phrase except for RiverApes and Reasons to Believe.

Nuts. I'll work on it. With almost 2500 sites in My Favorites, I'm bound to forget a few. :(
 
This isn't what I was looking for, but try this:

"The newly-found Pierolapithecus catalaunicus has fingers like a chimp, a body like an ape and the upright posture of humans. According to Salvador Moya-Sola, one of the husband and wife team of paleontologists who discovered the fossils, the species did not use the knuckle-walking technique of gorillas and chimps or the branch-swinging technique of orangutans for locomotion. The body was designed for waking upright and would have made a good tree climber. The bipedal locomotion of the new discovery is intriguing because it was once thought that our upright posture evolved later and was a significant change that led to the development of both advanced brains and our skill with our hands. Early theories about human evolution thought upright walking was a late development but since then, many significant discoveries about human evolution pushed back its appearance."

http://www.thecurrentonline.com/med....Family.Tree.Has.Expanded-816957.shtml?page=2
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom