Bigfoot - serious, not follies

Gorillagator said:
Not only that LAL, but fake prints are easily differentiated from a real animals tracks by an expert ichnologist, because fake tracks generally are stomped into the snow and leave an uplifted ridge around the track's perimeter, whereas normal walking or even running do not. Besides how is this dude going to make steps five feet apart unless he is more than seven to eight feet tall?

Yep. They're 10' apart running.

Oh, stilts of course. Never mind no marks where the hoaxer fell down and went "boom".
 
Re: Re: Re: Okay, this is getting silly again.

FFed said:
In my part of the world we have the legendary lake monter Ogopogo. The native elders from the local indian bands talk about how their parents used to tell them about the lake monster when they were children to keep them from going into the lake by themselves. Scare them so they don't go swimming without an adult around.
It seems reasonable to me how a bush monster story could be created in the same way to keep children from wondering off by themselves. Like the boogeyman.

Sure, except that they're seldom portrayed as dangerous, Cannibal Woman notwithstanding.

" How People Were Made

All the birds and animals of the mountains went to Hocheu to make People. Eagle, chief of all the animals, asked each animal how they wanted People to be. Each animal took a turn and said what they had to say.

Fish said, "People should know how to swim, like me, so let them be able to hold their breath and swim very deep."

Hummingbird said, "People should be fast, like me, so let them have good feet and endurance."

Eagle said, "People should be wise, wiser than me, so People will help animals and take care of the Earth."

Turtle said, "People should be able to protect themselves, like me, so lets give them courage and strength."

Lizard said, "People should have fingers, like me, so that People can make baskets, bows and arrows."

Owl said, "People should be good hunters, like me, so give them knowledge and cunning."

Condor said, "People should be different from us, so give them hair, not feathers or fur to keep warm."

Then Coyote said, "People should be just like me, because I am smart and tricky, so have them walk on all fours."

Hairy Man, who had not said anything yet, shook his head and said, "No, People should walk on two legs, like me."

All the other animals agreed with Hairy Man, and Coyote became very angry. He challenged Hairy Man to a race, and they agreed who ever won could decide how People should walk.

They gathered at the waterfall, below Hocheu, to begin the race. Coyote started and took a shortcut. Hairy Man was wiser than Coyote and knew that Coyote would cheat to win and People would have to walk on all fours, so Hairy Man stayed behind and helped Eagle, Condor, and the others to make People. They went back to the rock and drew People, on two legs, on the ground. The animals breathed on them, and People came out of the ground. Hairy Man was very pleased and went to People, but when they saw Hairy Man, they were scared and ran away. That made Hairy Man sad. When Coyote came back and saw what they had done, he was very angry and drew himself on the rock eating the moon (he is called Su! Su! Na). All the other animals drew their pictures on the rock as well, so People would remember them. Hairy Man was sad because People were afraid of him, so he drew himself sad. That is why Hairy Man's picture is crying to this day. That is how people were made.

http://www.bigfootproject.org/articles/mayak_datat.html
 
1 In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. 2The earth was without form, and void; and darkness was[a] on the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God was hovering over the face of the waters.
3Then God said, "Let there be light"; and there was light. 4And God saw the light, that it was good; and God divided the light from the darkness. 5God called the light Day, and the darkness He called Night. So the evening and the morning were the first day.

6Then God said, "Let there be a firmament in the midst of the waters, and let it divide the waters from the waters." 7Thus God made the firmament, and divided the waters which were under the firmament from the waters which were above the firmament; and it was so. 8And God called the firmament Heaven. So the evening and the morning were the second day.

9Then God said, "Let the waters under the heavens be gathered together into one place, and let the dry land appear"; and it was so. 10And God called the dry land Earth, and the gathering together of the waters He called Seas. And God saw that it was good.

11Then God said, "Let the earth bring forth grass, the herb that yields seed, and the fruit tree that yields fruit according to its kind, whose seed is in itself, on the earth"; and it was so. 12And the earth brought forth grass, the herb that yields seed according to its kind, and the tree that yields fruit, whose seed is in itself according to its kind. And God saw that it was good. 13So the evening and the morning were the third day.

14Then God said, "Let there be lights in the firmament of the heavens to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs and seasons, and for days and years; 15and let them be for lights in the firmament of the heavens to give light on the earth"; and it was so. 16Then God made two great lights: the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night. He made the stars also. 17God set them in the firmament of the heavens to give light on the earth, 18and to rule over the day and over the night, and to divide the light from the darkness. And God saw that it was good. 19So the evening and the morning were the fourth day.

20Then God said, "Let the waters abound with an abundance of living creatures, and let birds fly above the earth across the face of the firmament of the heavens." 21So God created great sea creatures and every living thing that moves, with which the waters abounded, according to their kind, and every winged bird according to its kind. And God saw that it was good. 22And God blessed them, saying, "Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the waters in the seas, and let birds multiply on the earth." 23So the evening and the morning were the fifth day.

24Then God said, "Let the earth bring forth the living creature according to its kind: cattle and creeping thing and beast of the earth, each according to its kind"; and it was so. 25And God made the beast of the earth according to its kind, cattle according to its kind, and everything that creeps on the earth according to its kind. And God saw that it was good.

26Then God said, "Let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness; let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over the cattle, over all the earth and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth." 27So God created man in His own image; in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them. 28Then God blessed them, and God said to them, "Be fruitful and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it; have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves on the earth."



Hmmm, my myth disagrees with your myth.

Maybe there's some form of innate problem with quoting myths as evidence for something.
 
Re: Re: Re: Okay, this is getting silly again.

FFed said:
In my part of the world we have the legendary lake monter Ogopogo. The native elders from the local indian bands talk about how their parents used to tell them about the lake monster when they were children to keep them from going into the lake by themselves. Scare them so they don't go swimming without an adult around.
It seems reasonable to me how a bush monster story could be created in the same way to keep children from wondering off by themselves. Like the boogeyman.

There's a fundamental difference, though. I mean, everyone knows lake monsters are real, right? Right? Aw, come on, it would be so neat if they were real that it must be so! It's just bad luck that nobody with anything better than an instamatic has managed to bag one. Probably a conspiracy of some kind. Same with the extensive underwater research. Some doubter probably fiddled with the side-scan sonar to make it less sensitive.

When I go sailing on Lake Champlain I always take at least a halfway decent camera. If Champ appears, I'll get something that can't be reasonably dismissed as a cormorant! I'll be rich and famous. Unless it turns out that Champ is a shape-shifting alien like sasquatch, of course. If it comes out blurry, that will be a reasonable conclusion, much more plausible than forgetting to focus or something.
 

Hmmm, my myth disagrees with your myth.

Maybe there's some form of innate problem with quoting myths as evidence for something.

My point was that the legends don't necessarily protray them as monsters to scare children. I feel sorry for Hairy Man.
The pictograph may represent an actual animal.

Notice how kind of mundane the modern "stories" from your area are:

http://www.bfro.net/GDB/show_county_reports.asp?state=ca-bc


If I were trying to frighten a child, I'd add some menacing gesturing and a gruesome detail or two, such as child-eating.


Parent: "Sasquatches cross the road."
Child: "Big deal."
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Okay, this is getting silly again.

bruto said:
Unless it turns out that Champ is a shape-shifting alien like sasquatch, of course. If it comes out blurry, that will be a reasonable conclusion, much more plausible than forgetting to focus or something.

No one in their right mind thinks Sasquatches are shape-shifting aliens.
 
BronzeDog said:
He was suspended (again), last I heard. They're debating whether or not to upgrade that to banning.

I see some of his posts have been removed on Bigfoot Follies. He was getting overboard on his insulting remarks about me. Maybe that's what did it. He can't say he wasn't warned.
 
Diogenes said:
Hi ! I'm Back ! :w2:

( you keep feeding me )


And how would you make that point with the story you chose?

He didn't do anything to them to make them run away. The story doesn't give his height, but the sight of an 8' hairy hominid seems upsetting to some people even today, strangely.......He seems a gentle beast who cried. Why would such a story be invented to frighten kids? Did you read the article or am I posting all these links in vain?

"Puget Sound tribes shared a knowledge of a race of hairy giants that came down from the mountains to steal salmon from their nets and drying racks. They called these creatures tse-at-ko.

The Indians of the Blue Mountain region of southeastern Washington told of the frightening stiya-hama-tall, smelly, manlike monsters that lurked deep in the mountain forests. The very word Sasquatch is an anglicization of sas-kets, the term used by the Salish-speaking tribes of southwestern British Columbia's lower Fraser River Valley to describe the hairy, manlike giants they believed lived nearby and communicated among themselves with shrill screams and whistles.

Perhaps the earliest recorded mention of Sasquatch can be found in a letter written in April 1840 by the Reverend Elkanah Walker, a Protestant missionary to the Spokane Indians. Preserved today in the archives of the Holland Library on the WSU campus, Walker's letter offers a skeptical but detailed interpretation of the Indians' lore:

...I suppose you will bear with me if I trouble you with a little of their superstition, which has recently come to my knowledge. They believe in the existence of a race of giants which inhabit a certain mountain off to the west of us .... The account that they give of these Giants will in some measure correspond with the Bible account of this race of beings.

They say their track is about a foot and a half long. They will carry two or three beams upon their back at once. They frequently come in the night and steal salmon from their nets and eat them raw. If the people are awake they always know when they are coming
very near, by their strong smell, which is most intolerable. It is not uncommon for them to come in the night and give three whistles and then the stones will begin to hit their houses. The people believe that they are still troubled with their nocturnal visits. We need the prayers of the church at home ..."

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/bigfootlives.htm
 
LAL said:
Somehow, I think Chilcutt would have been alert to this possibility.

What is Chilcutt's response to the investigation results as reported here:
http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=11363&st=0&hl=

Was he aware that dermal ridges could be artificially created so easily? This recent investigation seems to point out that dermal ridge appearances may be deceiving.

He [Chilcutt] tried to duplicate ridges and failed

Did he use the same methods, materials and procedures as described in the link above? How many casts has Chilcutt examined after that investigator's findings?

Meldrum is [aware a possible problem exists], and it said on the conference thread they were going to inform Chilcutt.

In other words, Chilcutt was NOT aware of the techniques that can produce 'fake' dermal ridges.

I e-mailed him [Meldrum]...

I too have e-mailed Meldrum concerning his statements and findings on the Skookum cast, and I remain unconvinced it's the butt print of a bigfoot.

One way that conclusion was reached was by ruling out other possibilities, including imprints of several animals combining to appear to be an imprint of a hominid.

I wasn't aware they used other animals in their testing of the imprint. Which animals did they rule out, and how?

Did you see LMS? Swindler and Sarmiento were quite clearly convinced.

No, I have not viewed Legend Meets Science. I am aware that scientists worldwide have been previously convinced of something that later turned out to be untrue, however.

What show was that on? Did they also say he exposed the hoax or were they trying to insinuate it's all a hoax and paint Meldrum as a gullible fool?

Don't honestly remember the name of the show, I caught it only by channel-surfing, so I missed the beginning, and didn't watch it through to the end. They showed the footage and then cut to Meldrum commenting on the footage. He called it "compelling", and I don't believe the show was presenting it as a hoax or that Meldrum was gullible.

I even posted information on what qualifies as appeal to authority.

Then you must understand that using Goodall to support your argument is an appeal to authority.

From: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_authority

An appeal to authority is a type of argument in logic also known as argument from authority, argumentum ad verecundiam (Latin: argument to respect) or ipse dixit (Latin: he himself said it, where an unsupported assertion depends on the asserter's credibility). It is one method of obtaining propositional knowledge and is often a logical fallacy...Sometimes, an appeal to authority is a logical fallacy. This is the case when a person[LAL] presenting a position on a subject[Bigfoot] mentions some authority who also holds that position[Goodall], but who is not an authority in that area.

They have all stated, all but one of them publicly, that the evidence already accumulated establishes the case for full scientific participation in getting to the bottom of this matter.

That's quite different from claiming that the Skookum cast is evidential proof of bigfoot. If the Skookum cast leads to further investigation into the phenomenon, that's well and good, but believing the cast is the Holy Grail of bigfootdom is not warranted.

Another seemed more interested in accusing me of "name dropping" than in checking out what they actually had to say.

I only commented on the 'name-dropping' after you used Goodall in what appeared to be an attempt to defend name-dropping. I was not referring to any of the other scientists you had named. (Though I fail to see how ANY of them could be classified as 'authorities' on bigfoot.)

RayG
 
LAL said:
Is she known from several jawbones and a thousand teeth?

What bigfoot jawbones and teeth do you mean? Some have speculated that bigfoot is a living example of the Gigantopithecus, or at least a living relative. There's no conclusive evidence to support that speculation however.

RayG
 
LAL said:
.

May I drop some Indian names for the creatures?

Not sure how that shows evidential proof of bigfoot. If you visit http://www.godchecker.com/ you'll see their "encyclopedia currently features over 2,100 deities", but that doesn't prove they exist.

http://www.royalforum.com/article.php?id=46

You might want to read the article (World's Top Experts Conclude Sasquatch Exists;The Royal Forum Investigates)while you're at it.

Experts at what? Another bigfoot article on that same website was authored by:

Sharon Eby is a single mother of three children, with a genetic background of Anglo-Saxon-Celtic/Native American (1/5 Cherokee/Choctaw). She is the West Regional Leader for the Texas Bigfoot Research Center (TBRC) and also does independent research on Bigfoot, UFO’s (also as a Saber “Dream Team” Member with Derrel Sims), alleged alien abductions, the paranormal, esoteric, and human spirituality. Her website is www.unifiedworlds.com and she more recently has returned to college to take courses in geology and anthropology to study our earth and human origins, and volunteers at SaveTheChimps.org. She owns her own solar energy business; implements contracted work in Office Management, and writes and speaks publicly on all topics ranging from her personal experiences, abductions and UFO’s, Bigfoot, Earth Lights (Marfa Lights), and more.

Sounds like she has a lot more on her plate than just bigfoot.

RayG
 
LAL said:


Read Krantz.

I have. His book is sitting less than 10' from my computer.

Green is referring to some who took an interest after the Skookum Cast. There have been many more over the years.

If you mean scientists, I don't believe there have been many more, there've been a few more, but not many. That's unfortunate, I say the more scientists that have an opportunity to examine the cast, the better.

Science wants a body, or a big hunk of one. All evidence short of that gets dismissed as "inconclusive".

Exactly. What YOU accept as evidence for an undiscovered species differs from what science will accept.

RayG
 
LAL said:
He didn't do anything to them to make them run away. The story doesn't give his height, but the sight of an 8' hairy hominid seems upsetting to some people even today,


Uhhh, what 8' hairy hominid would that be ?

Or did you mean " the thought of an 8' hairy hominid " ?



strangely.......He seems a gentle beast who cried.


If he " seems a gentle beast who cried ", then why were they " .... scared and ran away..... " ?

Besides, if one reads further into your source, it really contradicts the point you were trying to make in refuting FFed 's ' boogey man ' analogy ...
Children are cautioned not to make fun of his picture on the painted rock or play around that place because he would hear you and come after you.

Parents warned their children, "You are going to meet him on the road if you stay out too late at night." The children have learned always to come home early.
Thanks for the snack..
 
RayG said:
What is Chilcutt's response to the investigation results as reported here:
http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=11363&st=0&hl=

Was he aware that dermal ridges could be artificially created so easily? This recent investigation seems to point out that dermal ridge appearances may be deceiving.

Did he use the same methods, materials and procedures as described in the link above? How many casts has Chilcutt examined after that investigator's findings?

In other words, Chilcutt was NOT aware of the techniques that can produce 'fake' dermal ridges.


Anyone familiar with casting should be aware of the possibility of artifacts. I'm not certain which casts Chilcutt found compelling, but at least one was not that one. I don't know if he knew about the conditions on that particular cast. Perhaps more information will be forthcoming on BFF.

Napier thought the bunionettes on the right Bossburg track cast were an artifact. He may not have seen photos of the prints at the time.

I too have e-mailed Meldrum concerning his statements and findings on the Skookum cast, and I remain unconvinced it's the butt print of a bigfoot.

I didn't ask him about that. Does he have plans to publish on it, do you know?
I know you're unconvinced. What other explanation do you have to offer?

I wasn't aware they used other animals in their testing of the imprint. Which animals did they rule out, and how?

Elk, bear, coyote......there were traces of them but the print was altogether different. I don't know the exact methods used, but I'll see what I can find. There's a mention of elk below and why that doesn't work.


No, I have not viewed Legend Meets Science. I am aware that scientists worldwide have been previously convinced of something that later turned out to be untrue, however.

I suggest you do. The close-up of the heel print Swindler examines clearly shows the tendon of Achilles.

Don't drag in Piltdown Man, please.

Don't honestly remember the name of the show, I caught it only by channel-surfing, so I missed the beginning, and didn't watch it through to the end. They showed the footage and then cut to Meldrum commenting on the footage. He called it "compelling", and I don't believe the show was presenting it as a hoax or that Meldrum was gullible.

If you only saw part of it, how do you know what the overall tone was?

NG did one recently. They had a woman on who claimed to have been raised by Bigfeet. I suppose that was some kind of balanced reporting. I haven't seen it, but a cyber-friend's wife, who has a degree in anthropology, changed her tune after seeing BH in the Morris suit. She's now more inclined to accept the film as authentic.

Then you must understand that using Goodall to support your argument is an appeal to authority.

From: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_authority

Read the other thread, please. I even mentioned she hasn't done the research.

It's rather difficult to find an expert in "Bigfootology" when there's no such field. Primatology is close enough for me.

I mentioned Goodall among others and posted a link to her introduction to the Willow Creek Symposium. I've never presented her as an authority on Sasquatches, only as someone with standing who has looked into it to some extent for thirty years who believes they exist. Posters kind of latched on to her, presumably because they'd never heard of any of the others.

You've seen this?

"Sunday, January 05, 2003

Bigfoot Believers: Legitimate scientific study of legend gains backing of top primate experts

By Theo Stein
Denver Post



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sunday, January 05, 2003 - EDMONDS, Wash. - After enduring decades of ridicule, Bigfoot researchers are enjoying support from some of the world's most respected scientists in their efforts to prove the hulking creatures of legend are no myth.

The persistence of reported sightings of Bigfoot-type creatures in North America and elsewhere has convinced leading researchers on primates - including Jane Goodall, made famous by her studies of chimpanzees in Tanzania - to call for something never seriously considered before: a legitimate scientific study to determine whether the greatest apes that ever lived persist in the world's moist mountainous regions.

Skeptics, who include those in the scientific mainstream, scoff at such ideas. They say reported Bigfoot encounters, tracks and other evidence are either hoaxes or mistakes, and that people who believe such nonsense are soft-headed.

But dedicated amateurs and a smattering of professionals are trying to change that attitude. Using accepted scientific methods, they believe they can show at least some of the claimed evidence for Bigfoot - footprints, hair, voice recordings and a 400-pound block of plaster known as the Skookum Cast - are authentic traces of a rare giant primate.

Recently they have received support from a handful of the field's top experts.

Daris Swindler, for example, is not the typical Bigfoot believer.

When he retired in 1991 after more than 30 years at the University of Washington, Swindler was an acclaimed expert in the arcane study of fossilized primate teeth.

His book, "An Atlas of Primate Gross Anatomy," went through several printings and was among the standard references in the field.

So it comes as a surprise to some of his peers that Swindler believes that the Skookum Cast, discovered by amateur Bigfoot researchers in 2000, is a genuine record of a hairy giant that sat down by a mudhole to eat some fruit.

"Daris said that?" asked Russell Ciochon, a prominent paleoanthropologist and professor at the University of Iowa. "He's an important figure. But I still don't think Bigfoot exists in any form."

Mythical giant apes lurk in the traditions of nearly every Native American linguistic group and in legends handed down through the ages from Europe and Asia. Each year, Bigfoot or similar creatures are reported by hundreds of hunters, hikers, motorists and others from central Asia to the central Rockies. But no one has provided the minimum proof required by science: a type specimen or remains that researchers can pick up, measure and argue over.

Nevertheless, Goodall is intrigued.

"People from very different backgrounds and different parts of the world have described very similar creatures behaving in similar ways and uttering some strikingly similar sounds," she said. "As far as I am concerned, the existence of hominids of this sort is a very real probability."

George Schaller, director of science at the Wildlife Conservation Society, has spent 40 years studying rare animals in remote places, including pioneering studies of Central Africa's mountain gorilla, which Western scientists first discovered in 1903.

THE SCIENTISTS:

JANE GOODALL

A world-famous primate researcher and author, she revealed, in studies of chimpanzees in Tanzania's Gombe National Park, surprising behaviors in humanity's closest living relative. Goodall has won numerous international awards for her contributions to conservation, anthropology and animal welfare. Currently affiliated with Cornell University, she serves as the National Geographic Society's explorer-in-residence.

GEORGE SCHALLER

International science director for the Wildlife ConservationSociety. His pioneering field studies of mountain gorillas setthe research standard later adopted by Goodall and gorillaresearcher Dian Fosse. Schaller's 1963 book, "The Year of theGorilla," debunked popular perceptions of the great ape andreintroduced "King Kong" as a shy, social vegetarian.

Schaller's studies of tigers, lions, snow leopards and pandasalso advanced the knowledge of those endangered mammals.

In 1973, he won the National Book Award for "The SerengetiLion: A Study of Predator-Prey Relations," and in 1980 wasawarded the World Wildlife Fund Gold Medal for his contributionsto the understanding and conservation of endangered species.During the past decade, he has focused on the little-knownwildlife of Mongolia, Laos and the Tibetan Plateau.

RUSSELL MITTERMEIER

A trained primatologist, herpetologist and biologicalanthropologist, he has discovered five new species of monkey,including two last year. Mittermeier has conducted fieldwork inmore than 20 countries around the tropical world, with specialemphasis on Brazil, Guyana and Madagascar.

Since 1989, Mittermeier has served as president ofConservation International, which has become one of the mostaggressive and effective conservation organizations in the worldduring the last decade. His publications include 10 books andmore than 300 scientific papers and popular articles.

DARIS SWINDLER

Emeritus professor of anthropology at the University ofWashington, Swindler is a leading expert on living and fossilprimate teeth and one of the top primate anatomists in general.His book, "An Atlas of Primate Gross Anatomy," has become astandard reference in the field. A forensic anthropologist,Swindler worked on the Ted Bundy and Green River murder casesalong with hundreds of others.

ESTEBAN SARMIENTO

A functional anatomist affiliated with the American Museum ofNatural History, Sarmiento focuses on the skeletons of hominids.In 2001, he participated with George Schaller in a search forCongo's Bili ape, a possible species super-chimp reported bynatives but unknown to Western science. Sarmiento has alsostudied the Cross River gorilla, a critically endangeredsubspecies on the Nigeria-Cameroon border whose population isthought to be numbered in the hundreds. He has taught in theU.S., South Africa and Uganda.


Schaller remains troubled by the fact no Bigfoot remains have been produced, nor have any samples of feces whose DNA can be chemically poked and prodded to unlock the identity of their maker. And he is mindful of hoaxing.

But he, too, considers Bigfoot an open question.

"There have been so many sightings over the years," he said. "Even if you throw out 95 percent of them, there ought to be some explanation for the rest. The same goes for some of these tracks."

"I think a hard-eyed look is absolutely essential," he concludes.

The most common evidence allegedly left by these animals are the footprints: big prints in remote locations, some deeply pressed in sand or gravel firm enough for a grown man to pass without leaving a trace. Some footprints, like those Ray Wallace's family claim he left near Bluff Creek, Calif., in the late 1950s, are hoaxed. Many more are too vague to be conclusive. But a few are so detailed and anatomically accurate that they baffle the experts.

"Either the forgers are spending an awful lot of time on this, or there is reason to give this evidence another look," said primate researcher Esteban Sarmiento of the American Museum of Natural History. "I think a serious scientific inquiry is definitely warranted."

Skeptics argue that large mammals, particularly great apes, simply aren't discovered anymore. Not true, says Russell Mittermeier, vice president of Conservation International, who has co-authored scientific papers describing five new primates.

Since the 1990s there have been several spectacular finds, he said, including the antelope-like spindlehorn from Vietnam and a South American peccary thought to have gone extinct thousands of years ago.

"I'm not one to pooh-pooh the potential that these large apes may exist," Mittermeier said. "I guess you could say I'm mildly skeptical but guardedly optimistic. Whoever does find it will have the discovery of the century."

Words of encouragement like these are music to Bigfoot researchers' ears.

"My whole motivation has not been to convince anybody of the existence of the animal, but to convince them that there's a body of evidence begging for further consideration," said Idaho State University professor Jeff Meldrum, whose expertise in primate locomotion led him to become one of the few academics openly researching Bigfoot tracks.

"This is immense," said author John Green, who has tracked Bigfoot reports for almost half a century from British Columbia and investigated some of the most famous sightings and track finds. "The possibility that there could be a real animal behind it just didn't occur to scientists 20 years ago."

The flap over recent claims of Bigfoot hoaxing has not deterred Swindler. But the lack of a body plus the acknowledgment of at least some hoaxing adds up to too many questions for Ciochon.

Like that of Swindler, Ciochon's work focuses on fossilized primate teeth, but of a very special species: Gigantopithecus blacki, the giant Asian ape of the Miocene epoch, which lasted from about 24 million to 5 million years ago.

Most Bigfoot supporters advance Gigantopithecus, or Giganto for short, as the likely ancestor of Bigfoot, if not the hairy beast itself. It's a tantalizing but entirely unproven link that drives Ciochon to distraction.

Ciochon thinks his study subject, which co-existed with the human ancestor Homo erectus for hundreds of thousands of years, may well be the archetypal inspiration for the "boogeyman" and other nocturnal monsters that populate the traditions of aboriginal cultures from Nepal to North America.

But he vigorously rejects any suggestion that Giganto, which he thinks was a specialized, bamboo-eating vegetarian, could persist today.

And he worries that the hotly contested grants that fund his work overseas may go elsewhere if the stigma of the shambling sasquatch of Native American lore attaches to his study subject.

"My biggest problem is there's no evidence, other than conjectural hair and these footprints, some of which we know are faked," Ciochon said.

"If someone finds a skeleton, I'll be there in a nanosecond," he said. "But that's what it's going to take to get me to change my mind."

"There are so many problems," agrees Swindler, who six years ago told a USA Today reporter to count him among the skeptics.

But as he examines the Skookum Cast on a rainy December afternoon in this Seattle suburb, Swindler points out landmarks in the lumpy landscape: a hairy forearm the size of a small ham, an enormous hairy thigh, an outsized buttock, and a striking impression he feels confident was made by the Achilles tendon and heel of a creature that is not supposed to exist.

"Whatever made this was very well adapted to walking on two feet," he said. "It's not conclusive, but it's consistent with what you'd expect to see if a giant biped sat down in the mud."

Swindler hopes that his assessment of the Skookum Cast, and a Discovery Channel documentary set to air Thursday, will generate support for further research.

The key, Schaller said, will be finding dedicated amateurs willing to spend months or years in the field with cameras. "So far, no one has done that," he said.

It was a group of dedicated amateurs that discovered the Skookum Cast. A team of volunteers from the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization had spent two days in Washington state's Gifford Pinchot National Forest, putting out pheromone-basted plastic chips during the day and blasting sasquatch calls at night in an attempt to attract an animal.

On the second night, researchers heard a powerful reply to their broadcasts, said Richard Noll, an aerospace toolmaker who has spent 30 years researching the mystery. The next morning, Noll was stunned to realize that an unusual impression of a large animal on the edge of a mudhole near their camp could have been left by their elusive quarry.

"An elk will gather their feet under them when they get up," he said. "But there are no elk hoofprints in the center of the cast."

Meldrum and Swindler concur there are only two logical explanations for the cast: Bigfoot and elk. And they have also ruled out elk.

John Mionczynski, a wildlife researcher who has spent 30 summers studying bighorn herds in Wyoming's Wind River Mountains, has his own reasons for believing in Bigfoot.

On a moonlit summer night in 1972, he backhanded an animal he thought was a bear as it sniffed at a bacon stain in his tent, then watched as the silhouette of a giant, shaggy arm with a broad hand at the end swept toward his tent, collapsing it on him.

"That hand was three times as wide as mine and had an opposed thumb that stuck out as plain as day," Mionczynski said.

He spent the rest of the night huddled by the fire with a revolver in his hand as the creature lobbed pine cones at him from the dark woods behind his tent.

"That pretty much eliminated bears," Mionczynski said.

Mionczynski is working on a contraption of tiny hooks and barbed wire that he intends to place near seasonal foods he thinks sasquatch depend on. He hopes the snare will let him get a DNA sample.

North of Seattle, Noll is collaborating with Owen Caddy, a former Ugandan park ranger who studied chimpanzees in the mid-1990s.

For the last 18 months, they've scoured certain sandbars on a north Cascades river, documenting more than 30 suspected sasquatch footprints they believe were made by a mother and two young. They hope to identify the animals' food sources and travel corridors, then set out a picket line of infrared camera traps.

"I feel the animal is out there, and I don't hedge on that," Caddy said. "I've found physical evidence myself, and I'm confident in my analysis of it.

"Something is making these tracks, and it's not people."




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bibliographical Information:
Front Page of the Sunday Edition of the Denver Post.
By Theo Stein, Denver Post Environment Writer
 
RayG said:
What bigfoot jawbones and teeth do you mean? Some have speculated that bigfoot is a living example of the Gigantopithecus, or at least a living relative. There's no conclusive evidence to support that speculation however.

RayG

I was referring to Gigantopithecus blacki fossils. It was a joke, son.

Krantz thought Giganto was bipedal due to the width of the jawbone. Napier thought A. robustus could have been the ancsestor. The size is a fit for Giganto and it was an Asian species, but there's nothing below the jaw to establish its mode of locomotion. If it was bipedal, it would certainly be a strong candidate for an ancestor, but many bipedal primate fossils have been discovered since Napier's time.

The ancestry is pretty much up for grabs until there are bones for comparison.
 
I'm still reading your source on indian legends..

http://www.bigfootproject.org/articles/mayak_datat.html

They contradict any notion that Bigfoot is a gentle creature who prefers fruit.

I'ts a scary beast that eats animals and people..


It's hilarious how the source ignores this and comes to the conclusion..:


...Stories and paintings of how the creature looked and behaved are only present in these Native cultures because of direct observation of a flesh and blood creature.


Huh? Stories and paintings of creatures, are proof that they exist/ed ???


:dl:



This is so easy lu, bring us some more.
 
Diogenes said:
I'm still reading your source on indian legends..

http://www.bigfootproject.org/articles/mayak_datat.html

They contradict any notion that Bigfoot is a gentle creature who prefers fruit.



Whoever said that? No one's even made a case for them being vegetarians. They don't seem to be aggressive though. There are very few reports of them actually attacking.

I'ts a scary beast that eats animals and people..



Nope. There was a fear among some they might eat people. They seem to eat everything, actually. There are contemporary accounts of them going for fish.

"This story clearly illustrates that Bigfoot was thought to be nocturnal and mainly stayed in Giant Sequoia groves or forests. His intent was not to come into contact with humans and would only go outside when they were asleep. Since Gayton (1976) already stated that Yokuts stories about animals involved real observed behaviors, and all the behaviors attributed to the other animals in this story are consistent with what we know about those animals, it is logical to assume that Yokuts directly observed Bigfoot behavior and incorporated that behavior into this story."

The stone-throwing is noted in contemporary reports, too.

Many Native people consider them a semi-spiritual being and a sighting is considered a good omen for the tribe.

"........it involved Hairy Man coming to a house, throwing off his hair, becoming a man, and offering a healing power to the Shaman. Hairy Man insisted that the power he gave the Shaman could only be used to cure and not to kill."

The article then goes on to the "evil" aspect and a story where children are warned to stay in at night.
A friend of mine was warned about that, too, in Washington State by a white man a few years ago, because the Sasquatches come out at night. She thought he was nuts, of course.

It's hilarious how the source ignores this and comes to the conclusion..:

Conclusion
To summarize, the following are important points presented in this article:

Hairy Man helped create man and has various other associated stories;
This belief is exemplified by the creation of a pictograph representing Hairy Man, which closely resembles descriptions of Bigfoot (8.5 feet tall; long shaggy hair; sagittal crest; walks on two feet; and large, powerful, human-like body type);
The Hairy Man pictograph was noted and called "Hairy Man" by non-Indians in 1889. It is well documented that the painting has been referred to as Hairy Man since 1889 and continuously to modern times;
Bigfoot behavior is represented in traditional Yokuts stories, including nocturnal hunting, association with Forest environments, wood knocking, whistling, and being an omnivore (animals and plants); and
Bigfoot is in both Yokuts culture and the Penutian language stock, suggesting a very old source story.
The presence of a Bigfoot pictograph and numerous stories in the Yokuts culture is not only unique, but also significant to North American Great Ape research. By analyzing traditional Native knowledge and stories of Bigfoot, it helps establish that this creature was not created by "white culture", but instead is a long-time occupant in these people's lives. Stories and paintings of how the creature looked and behaved are only present in these Native cultures because of direct observation of a flesh and blood creature."

Huh? Stories and paintings of creatures, are proof that they exist/ed ???

Read the last paragraph above.

This is so easy lu, bring us some more.

What's easy? You've already shown you have an ability to quote-mine and misconstrue. You don't really need to go on demonsrating it.

Have you considered a career with the ICR?
 
If pictographs and folklore constitute viable evidence of a creature's existence, I suggest that we abandon the search for Bigfoot, whose representations are so few and so poor, and fund more research into centaurs and crocodile-headed gods, because there are so many consistent accounts and pictures of them that they MUST be real.

So far what I've seen is an admission by some reputable sounding scientists that the possibility of a bigfoot is not outright preposterous, and deserves a serious look. This is a far cry from saying they think it exists, and it also presupposes that there has not yet been what they would consider a serious look. I still assert that this is means one or both of two things. Either there isn't really a bigfoot or the people doing the looking aren't doing a very good job of it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom