Bigfoot - serious, not follies

RayG said:
Has Erik even considered the amount of energy required for a creature of the supposed size of bigfoot to be able to change its entire cell structure at the molecular level?

I'm guessing after a single shape-shifting episode, his shape-shifting days would be over, permanently.

RayG
I asked him about that, but he essentially just laughed at me.
 
Dredred said:
This pic probably doesn't show the best bigfootfeet ever made. But these are the ones that started the whole myth, according to http://skepdic.com/bigfoot.html.

This?


"Ray had a friend carve him 16-inch-long feet that he could strap on and make prints with. Wallace owned a construction company that built logging roads at the time and he set the prints around one of his bulldozers in Humboldt County. Jerry Crew, a bulldozer operator, reported the prints and The Humboldt Times ran a front-page story about “Bigfoot.” The legend was born."

There were incidents long before Wallace, who couldn't be questioned about the exact location of the 1958 tracks (which he wouldn't have known) for the rather good reason he was dead when his family came out with this remarkable information. He was usually off getting new contracts for the company; that was his job.

Later, he had a lively souvenier business going with photos of his wife in a gorilla suit.

http://www.bigfootresearch.org/Bigfoot_ray wallace.htm

Tracks are still being found, of course.

http://www.bfro.net/news/wallace.asp#commentary

John Green was on to him for years:

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/wallace.html

Funny how the media made a big deal out of the Wallace family but somehow failed to report the rebuttals.

You've got pics of bigfoot footprints showing sweat pores, healed scars etc.? Interesting. Please share. However, don't you think even that could be faked?

Nope. Dr. White (the Dr. Tim White of Berkeley) thought the pores could be air bubbles, but experimentation showed they're circular while sweat pores are irregular in shape.

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/dermal.html

Thousands of tracks have been found in remote areas. Who would bother to fake sweat pores on prints that stand almost no chance of ever being seen?

There's a good arial view of the Powder Mountain tracks in Sasquatch/Bigfoot: The Search For North America's Incredible Creature by Don Hunter with René Dahinden. It gives a good idea of how remote and how many. They were at 4800' and ran for five miles. The snow looks absolutely pristine except for the tracks.


"Now, Bigfoot advocates are increasingly turning to forensic evidence to prove the existence of the giant creature.

Investigator Jimmy Chilcutt of the Conroe Police Department in Texas, who specializes in finger- and footprints, has analyzed the more than 150 casts of Bigfoot prints that Meldrum, the Idaho State professor, keeps in a laboratory.

Chilcutt says one footprint found in 1987 in Walla Walla in Washington State has convinced him that Bigfoot is real.

"The ridge flow pattern and the texture was completely different from anything I've ever seen," he said. "It certainly wasn't human, and of no known primate that I've examined. The print ridges flowed lengthwise along the foot, unlike human prints, which flow across. The texture of the ridges was about twice the thickness of a human, which indicated that this animal has a real thick skin."

Meldrum, meanwhile, says a 400-pound (180-kilogram) block of plaster known as the Skookum Cast provides further evidence of Bigfoot's existence. The cast was made in September 2000 from an impression of a large animal that had apparently lain down on its side to retrieve some fruit next to a mud hole in the Gifford Pinchot National Forest in Washington State.

Meldrum says the cast contains recognizable impressions of a forearm, a thigh, buttocks, an Achilles tendon and heel. "It's 40 to 50 percent bigger than a normal human," he said. "The anatomy doesn't jive with any known animal."

A few academics believe Meldrum could be right.

Renowned chimpanzee researcher Jane Goodall last year surprised an interviewer from National Public Radio when she said she was sure that large, undiscovered primates, such as the Yeti or Sasquatch, exist."

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/10/1023_031023_bigfoot_2.html

Chilcutt points out what he looks for on the scars on Sasquatch: Legend Meets Science, which was shown on the Discovery Channel and is available on tape and DVD.

He stakes his reputation on these animals being real, on camera.

You might want to check out the thread "Bigfoot Follies" on this forum. I posted myself silly over there.
 
LAL said:
Cute pic. Did you notice the carved feet don't match any known trackway and the toes don't move? No midtarsal bend, either. Dermal ridges? Sweat pores? Healed scars? Forget it.

BTW, Lal, this was your reaction to my suggestion to Beckjord that he shares his video of bigfoot tracks in the snow, so that we can provide more probable explanations. Do you really think sweat pores or healed scars should be visible in tracks in the snow?
 
LAL said:
Thousands of tracks have been found in remote areas. Who would bother to fake sweat pores on prints that stand almost no chance of ever being seen?

I agree that sounds a little far fetched. I'm not going to read a lot about this so i am not and will not be informed enough to agree or disagree with you. I can understand your fascination, but i don't share it. I think, if bigfeet are real, somebody will find (a dead) one one day, i'll just wait it out. I've only involved myself in this discussion because i AM fascinated by this Beckjord fellow. I've never encountered anyone so delusional, trying to convert others to his delusional world view. A few weeks ago i had an idea to write a story about a paranoid delusional bigfoot hunter, and now i've discovered Beckjord, who is exactly the kind of lunatic i had in mind. But his website provided me with insanity i could have never come up with myself.
 
Dredred said:
BTW, Lal, this was your reaction to my suggestion to Beckjord that he shares his video of bigfoot tracks in the snow, so that we can provide more probable explanations. Do you really think sweat pores or healed scars should be visible in tracks in the snow?

I caught the sarcasm, but the tracks Wallace was supposed to have faked weren't in snow. I don't consider Wallace's fake feet a more probable explanation for much of anything.

The Bossburg tracks were in snow. Want a video of those? How about a still of some from California this year?

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/images/JimKarl.htm

Somewhere there should be film of a double trackway from Skamania County, Washington, from 1969. Those tracks went for 7 miles and were followed by people I knew and a camera crew from the Columbian. I saw this in a theater in Portland and about fell out of my seat when I realized I was looking at Ed McClarny explaining the find in the movie. I asked him about it years later. He was a county commissioner by then.

There's a report in the BFRO database of five DNR workers seeing a pair of Sasquatches cross a meadow in Skamania County. I've often wondered if it could have been the same ones.

And Skookum Meadows (guess what a "Skookum" is) is in the Gifford Pinchot in Skamania County. The Skookum Cast came from there.

Caves on Mt. St. Helens, also in Skamania County, are known as Ape Caves. There's an Ape Canyon as well.

Skamania County passed the first legislation in this country regarding their protection (in an attempt to protect the hunters from each other).

Almost everyone I knew in Stevenson (who would talk about it) knew someone who'd seen one. I met someone from Stevenson at a conference in W.V. this year who told me the pharmacist, who was a bit sceptical of his uncle's sighting, saw one near Rock Creek with his daughter in the car. Rock Creek came quite near to where I lived on 80 forested acres northwest of town.

This has been exciting stuff to me for a very long time.
 
Dredred said:
I agree that sounds a little far fetched. I'm not going to read a lot about this so i am not and will not be informed enough to agree or disagree with you. I can understand your fascination, but i don't share it. I think, if bigfeet are real, somebody will find (a dead) one one day, i'll just wait it out. I've only involved myself in this discussion because i AM fascinated by this Beckjord fellow. I've never encountered anyone so delusional, trying to convert others to his delusional world view. A few weeks ago i had an idea to write a story about a paranoid delusional bigfoot hunter, and now i've discovered Beckjord, who is exactly the kind of lunatic i had in mind. But his website provided me with insanity i could have never come up with myself.


Just do a bio on Beckjord. There's no need to get fictional.
 
RayG said:
Has Erik even considered the amount of energy required for a creature of the supposed size of bigfoot to be able to change its entire cell structure at the molecular level?

I'm guessing after a single shape-shifting episode, his shape-shifting days would be over, permanently.

RayG

This shapeshifter will self-destruct in five minutes.
 
LAL said:

This pic from your link:
Jims_track1.jpg


I don't find it very convincing. How do you know the footseps aren't that big beacause the surrounding snow melted? The snow was already melting, as the website states, and snow surrounding a footstep will melt faster because it's surrounded by less snow to keep it cool than snow not surrounding a footstep.
Also, 'Jim's boot imprints', were clearly more recent thus less melted, and you can see he took tiny baby steps, probably to make the steps in the other track appear bigger.

The tracks in Beckjord's video supposedly started and ended at places in the middle of nowhere, which is supposed to indicate that the bigfoot shifted in and out of this dimension. I'd like to see his video of this because it seems highly unlikely and there's probably a more logical explanation.

Thanks for your idea of writing Beckjard's bio. It's a great idea. I might just do that. But ofcourse, the advantage of fiction is you don't have to do that much research.
 
LAL said:
"The ridge flow pattern and the texture was completely different from anything I've ever seen," he said. "It certainly wasn't human, and of no known primate that I've examined. The print ridges flowed lengthwise along the foot, unlike human prints, which flow across. The texture of the ridges was about twice the thickness of a human, which indicated that this animal has a real thick skin."

Keep in mind dermal evidence http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=11363&st=0&hl= isn't as strong as once thought.

Meldrum, meanwhile, says a 400-pound (180-kilogram) block of plaster known as the Skookum Cast provides further evidence of Bigfoot's existence.

This is Meldrum's actual statement from the BFRO website:

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/BODYCAST/ISU_press_rel_cast.asp

“While not definitively proving the existence of a species of North American ape, the cast constitutes significant and compelling new evidence that will hopefully stimulate further serious research and investigation into the presence of these primates in the Northwest mountains and elsewhere,”

A few academics believe Meldrum could be right.

He might also be wrong, as he was when he claimed the snow walker video ( http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/films/snowwalker.htm ), now generally regarded as a hoax, was compelling evidence.

Renowned chimpanzee researcher Jane Goodall last year surprised an interviewer from National Public Radio when she said she was sure that large, undiscovered primates, such as the Yeti or Sasquatch, exist."

But her wishes, desires, or beliefs do not make it so, that will require definitive evidence.

RayG
 
Dredred said:
Thanks for your idea of writing Beckjard's bio. It's a great idea. I might just do that.

Make sure you send Beckjord your name, address, and phone number. Be prepared for lots of crank calls and harassment at home and work. The occasional threatening letter too. :D

RayG
 
RayG said:
Keep in mind dermal evidence http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=11363&st=0&hl= isn't as strong as once thought.


You noticed I posted on that thread, didn't you? I wanted clarification and got it.
The original Onion Mountain cast findings are on the Bellingham conference thread. Meldrum commended the work.

It's quite clear this refers to one cast and a copy at that. The artifact had to do with the substrate; it doesn't happen on all of them.

"I have found that under certain conditions cement casts can spontainously develop surface ridges that have a strong resemblance to what are being claimed as dermal ridges, at least on one cast known as the "Onion Mountain" cast made by John Green in August of 1967. Numerous pieces of evidence come together to suggest that the ridges seen on Green's Onion Mountain cast are ridge artifacts and not an accurate representation of dermal ridges pressed into the soil by a primate foot."

This does not mean all dermal ridges are casting artifacts.




This is Meldrum's actual statement from the BFRO website:

http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/BODYCAST/ISU_press_rel_cast.asp

“While not definitively proving the existence of a species of North American ape, the cast constitutes significant and compelling new evidence that will hopefully stimulate further serious research and investigation into the presence of these primates in the Northwest mountains and elsewhere,”


The language of science is cautious. New evidence could show it was Erik Beckjord in an ape butt.


He might also be wrong, as he was when he claimed the snow walker video ( http://www.n2.net/prey/bigfoot/films/snowwalker.htm ), now generally regarded as a hoax, was compelling evidence.


Meldrum exposed that hoax.

" "The Snow Walker Footage
AVI clip (2.97MB)
Perhaps the most elaborate hoax footage ever produced, it was created by an independent production company developing a TV program called "Paranormal Borderline" for UPN (Paramount).

The footage was greatly debated after its release, but was eventually debunked by the BFRO's Dr. Jeff Meldrum.

There are some interesting aspects to this footage. It was too expensive to create a convincing, intricate costume, so the hoaxers compensated in two ways, both of which provided clues that eventually unravelled the hoax.

The shots are brief, blurry, and distant, thus precluding any detailed images of the figure and eliminating the need for an intricate costume. The lack of image quality is cleverly distracted by the context of the footage.
The hoaxers went to extraordinary lengths to make the footage appear to be part of a vacation video of a European couple mountaineering in the Himalayas. In reality it was staged somewhere near Mammoth Mountain, California.
These compensations led to some obvious questions. With the figure crossing an open snow field likely in view for at least a minute, even the most amateur videographer would have shot more tape, and likely would have zoomed in all the way for the better part of the tape. Why then were there only a few seconds of shakey wide-angle shots when the figure was at it closest point?

The context of the footage raised immediate questions about the identify of the European couple. UPN would only say that an American man provided the footage, that he wanted people to see it, but that he wouldn't speak to any investigators or answer any questions about the European couple. This was suspiciously similar to the "alien autopsy" video scenario, where the shadowy source of the footage refused to come forward to authenticate it in any way. In the case of the Snow Walker footage, the producers of Paranormal Borderline acted suspiciously by steering the investigation away from the source.

Dr. Meldrum, who at first tentatively suggested the footage might be authentic, became increasingly suspicious of the dodgey behavior of the show's producers as he tried to investigate the matter further. He pursued it with UPN for over a year. Eventually, after Paranormal Borderline was cancelled, the producers finally outright admitted the hoax, and explained how it was done.

In spite of all this, they did manage to eek out one more profitable use out of the footage when it was used in the Fox TV special "World's Greatest Hoaxes"."

http://www.bfro.net/REF/bfmedia.asp

But her wishes, desires, or beliefs do not make it so, that will require definitive evidence.

RayG
Since I was accused of "name-dropping" and unsubstantiated quotes so many times on the other thread, I thought I would take the opportunity to show that even a national pop-sci mag said Jane Goodall said exactly what she said.

I'm sure everyone considers NG credible and has forgotten the "archaeoraptor" incident.
 
LAL said:
It's being worked on. One researcher has been monitoring a particular area for years. He has something inconclusive on film, with, perhaps, something better to come. He has a great deal of experience and expertise.

Considering there has never been a full scale scientific investigation, the effort has pretty much been up to amateurs working on their own time and money. The creatures are largely nocturnal, elusive and potentially very dangerous. They don't seem to follow any set pattern in their foraging and roam over a huge territory. Bryne estimated they can cover 25 miles in a night. Where would you set up the camera traps?

I don't know that anyone's been inept or incompetant (and much evidence has been gathered). "Unlucky" might be a better word.

Dr. Meldrum applied for a grant for field work on them in the Southern Rockies last year. Suppose he got it?

Sorry, I still think that if there are sasquatches out there and nobody has managed to get a decent picture, a clear footprint cast that a real scientist won't laugh at, a body, a bone, a piece of fur that can be forensically examined, etc. etc. then they're not doing a very good job. We all know that if a really decent piece of evidence were to appear, scientists, skeptics, and everyone else would welcome it. If I were a serious seeker of sasquatches and the people doing the hunting couldn't do any better than they have so far, and kept coming up with dog-ate-my-homework level excuses and quack theories about shapeshifting aliens to explain why they went out in the woods with a crappy camera and didn't use it right, I wouldn't give them a grant either!

I'd really like to find out that these guys are real, but given the level of the evidence there aren't a lot of reasonable choices left: either they aren't there or they aren't being well sought.
 
bruto said:
Sorry, I still think that if there are sasquatches out there and nobody has managed to get a decent picture, a clear footprint cast that a real scientist won't laugh at, a body, a bone, a piece of fur that can be forensically examined, etc. etc. then they're not doing a very good job. We all know that if a really decent piece of evidence were to appear, scientists, skeptics, and everyone else would welcome it. If I were a serious seeker of sasquatches and the people doing the hunting couldn't do any better than they have so far, and kept coming up with dog-ate-my-homework level excuses and quack theories about shapeshifting aliens to explain why they went out in the woods with a crappy camera and didn't use it right, I wouldn't give them a grant either!

I'd really like to find out that these guys are real, but given the level of the evidence there aren't a lot of reasonable choices left: either they aren't there or they aren't being well sought.

I think you might want to do a little research on just how much work has been done on this. There are many "clear" casts and some "real" scientists have not laughed at them. 25 hair samples have been identified as "unknown animal" or "unknown primate". I wouldn't be so opinionated prior to checking it out, if I were you.
Dahinden lost his marriage and family in his efforts on this. Others have been ridiculed and had their pretty darn conclusive evidence dismissed, sometimes by other researchers.

Some recommended reading and viewing (except for the part of Thom Powell's book Erik Beckjord endorses):

http://www.bfro.net/merch/catalog3.asp

Especially read Dr. Krantz, who was a "real" scientist. Remember him from the fight over Kennewick Man?
Here's a sample:

"Increasing body size has an interesting effect on the strength of anatomical structures. The pulling power of muscles and the breaking strength of tendons and ligaments are directly proportional to their cross-sectional areas. Yet their weight, like that of the whole body, increases with volume. Cross-sectional areas increase with the square of a linear dimension, while weight increases with the cube. Thus if a man were doubled in height, keeping all proportions the same, his muscles and supporting tissues would be four times as strong, but his weight would become eight times greater. In relation to the weight he would have to maneuver, his strength would be cut in half. Some changes in body design, especially in lever lengths, would be desirable for such an enlarged man to move about like other people. The large size indicated for sasquatch poses the same kind of problem.

The first peculiarity in these giant footprints is that they are quite flat. The instep or longitudinal arch of the foot is not there. In man this arch is maintained by ligaments and by the muscular pull on tendons. Given 500 pounds or more of body weight, these structures would not have sufficient increased strength and the arch would have to flatten. While adult sasquatch prints are flat, a number of supposed young ones show some arching. It is an interesting question whether the feet flatten with maturity just because of the weight, or if there are genetic mechanisms which would lead to a flat foot regardless of usage. If a number of people were making fake bigfoot prints, it might be expected that many of them would not have thought about this characteristic and would have included arches comparable to their own. None of the evidence I have examined shows a normal human arch."

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/anatomy.html

Beckjord does not qualify as a reseacher except in his own deluded mind. No respectable researcher will have anything to do with him. He's permanently banned from BFF. All he does is disrupt the board.
 
RayG said:
Make sure you send Beckjord your name, address, and phone number. Be prepared for lots of crank calls and harassment at home and work. The occasional threatening letter too. :D

RayG

Is that all?
 
LAL said:
It's quite clear this refers to one cast and a copy at that. The artifact had to do with the substrate; it doesn't happen on all of them.

I wasn't trying to imply otherwise, just pointing out that claims of dermal ridges in casts might not actually BE dermal ridges. The original poster himself stated:

" Very few Sasquatch footprint casts contain features that are considered to be dermal ridges."

To already start with a small number of casts, and then to point out the possibility of contamination (for lack of a better word) depending on the methods and materials used, does not bode well for the authenticity of casts with dermal ridges.

This does not mean all dermal ridges are casting artifacts.

No, but investigators should be aware that a possible problem exists.

Meldrum exposed that hoax.

I don't deny that, however, he started out by calling the footage "compelling". Does that mean I'm suggesting the Skookum cast is a hoax? Not at all, but Meldrum is only human, and humans have been known to make mistakes. Is it possible that the print was made by a sasquatch? I guess so, but I don't see any convincing evidence to confirm that hypothesis.

Dr. Meldrum, who at first tentatively suggested the footage might be authentic...

The TV show I just recently watched had Meldrum himself looking at the footage and calling it "compelling". He has used the same word to describe the Skookum cast.

Since I was accused of "name-dropping" and unsubstantiated quotes so many times on the other thread, I thought I would take the opportunity to show that even a national pop-sci mag said Jane Goodall said exactly what she said.

Which again, seems to be 'name-dropping', or at the very least an appeal to authority.

RayG
 
LAL said:
Ah! That would explain why he's tried to sneak into BFF under different screennames. Invasion of the message-board snatchers!



Or perhaps he is writing a prequel to the series if movies about "Predator" Not exactly a shape-shifter per se, but a creature who can vanish and rematerialize before one's very eyes. This procedure is also relevant to his posts.
 
LAL said:
Cute pic. Did you notice the carved feet don't match any known trackway and the toes don't move? No midtarsal bend, either. Dermal ridges? Sweat pores? Healed scars? Forget it.


Not only that LAL, but fake prints are easily differentiated from a real animals tracks by an expert ichnologist, because fake tracks generally are stomped into the snow and leave an uplifted ridge around the track's perimeter, whereas normal walking or even running do not. Besides how is this dude going to make steps five feet apart unless he is more than seven to eight feet tall?
 
Gorillagator said:
Not only that LAL, but fake prints are easily differentiated from a real animals tracks by an expert ichnologist, because fake tracks generally are stomped into the snow and leave an uplifted ridge around the track's perimeter, whereas normal walking or even running do not. Besides how is this dude going to make steps five feet apart unless he is more than seven to eight feet tall?


Also the man needs to carry a couple of hundred pounds on his back to fool an expert in foot prints no matter the substrate they might be left in. Tracks of a seven or eight hundred pound critter are tough to fake by a two hundred pound man
 
Gorillagator said:
Also the man needs to carry a couple of hundred pounds on his back to fool an expert in foot prints no matter the substrate they might be left in.

Not if the expert is sufficiently credulous.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom