RayG said:
No, I don't know. I regret I didn't save the email exchange between us. After I queried him about any close scientific examination of the cast being written up in scientific journals, he never replied.
Yes I'm unconvinced. It will take more than speculation about squatch butts to convince me too. Squatch was never witnessed sitting in the mud, nor were any clear tracks found. No visualization took place, the fruit was never proven to have been chewed by bigfoot, and I've not heard of any definitive identification of sasquatch hairs found embedded in the cast.
Since there's no indisputable sample of hair known without a doubt to have come from a Sasquatch for comparison, the best that could be done was "unknown primate", and yes, that's how hairs found embedded were identified.
If MM and co. had watched it sit down, do you think they would have been believed?
I never mentioned Piltdown Man. I was actually thinking of many other instances in which scientists have been proven wrong. Rene Blondlot for example, and the fiasco concerning N-Rays.
From: http://www.rexresearch.com/blondlot/nrays.htm
I was on Creationism vs. Evolution boards too long, I guess. First it's "If man evolved from apes, why are there still apes?" then the Lady Hope Hoax, then Piltdown Man and Nebraska Man..............ARGHHHHHHHHGGGGGGRGH.
The part I DID see did not paint Meldrum as gullible or a loon or anything. The show was presenting unexplained mysteries, and seemed to be doing so in a 'factual' manner.
Good. I'd like to see it. Let me know if you remember more.
She may have an opinion on bigfoot, but I'm not aware of ANY research conducted by Goodall into the bigfoot phenomenon. If she has, I'm not aware of it and will gladly remove my foot from mouth to eat crow if proven wrong. Her opinion carries no more weight than the next person who has never investigated the evidence for or against bigfoot.
She's read every book she could find on it over thirty years and been photographed with Dr. Bindernagle at a conference. That puts her a conference up on me, anyway.
Yes, I have. I've been following the bigfoot mystery for over 20 years, and though I can't profess to be aware of ALL that's been written concerning bigfoot, I have read that particular article.
RayG
Green said AP wouldn't pick it up; it never got farther than Denver. A Waynesville preacher made national news for getting 9 members of East Baptist ousted for voting for Kerry. Go figure.
"BIP: How about hoaxers in general. Do they do any damage to the public's perception of bigfoot?
JG: Well, the media reaction certainly does. We've gone over the years through a phase where anything about this was news to where anyone who was doing something about it was news to where the only news nowadays is when people claim to have proven it's all a hoax.
BIP: Yes, I was going to ask you about that -
JG: Oh, I missed one phase. There was a phase there when any scientist who showed an interest was news. We've now reached the extreme where some of the world's very top people in the relevant fields are very interested and are saying publicly that there should be proper investigation and this is not news. The only thing that's news is that the whole thing has proved to be a fake. The demonstration of that is very clear when this absolute nonsense story about Ray Wallace faking all the foot prints went all around the world in exactly the same time period the Denver Post ran a major article and sidebars on these key scientists who were saying it should be investigated, the Associated Press wouldn't even carry the story. It never went anywhere beyond Denver. To me as a newspaper man, this is absolutely shocking. I tried to contact some of those at Columbia University's long-established graduate school of journalism who keep a tab on the press and the response was, "Nobody here is interested in taking this up." In other words, for 40 years we've been butting our heads against a barrier manned by the scientists saying there can't be any such thing. Now they're stepping away from the ramparts and the media is stepping up to take their place. Absolutely fascinating. The media is seeing to it that this heresy does not get to the public.
BIP: It seems to be the case when you can bet that someone who has bigfoot living up in that attic would get more press than something like the Skookum cast would.
JG: Well...
BIP: They seem to want to relegate this to the tabloids and that's where the story stays.
JG: For example, right now, we have the proof - absolute and indisputable - that the Patterson film is genuine. The newspapers refuse to carry anything of that. It can't be sold so therefore they're not going to be taken in therefore they're not going to run the story. As a result of this silly book where people are claiming that they were involved in making the film we've gone back to looking at the film and realize that, although you can't establish beyond dispute the size of anything, you can establish the relative size of things that are right there in the same film frame. This creature has an intermembral index - the comparison of the length of the arms to the length of the legs - that is totally outside the human range so it cannot be a human in a suit, but it is also totally outside the range of any other known primate of any size at all. Therefore, it has to be an unknown primate. This can only be ignored, it cannot be argued against. All you can do is say, "Well, you can't measure properly on the film." Well, you can't measure precisely, but the different is so slight that it doesn't matter. The human intermembral index is around 70, all of the great apes are over 100, this thing is in the high 80's. The question of the angle of this segment of the arm to the camera and so on, if you look at enough frames, you've got to be able to get to it. And on top of that, we have a forensic animator who worked on the "Legend Meets Science" DVD. He says that they established beyond any question the relative length of where the joints were as the thing was moving and the intermembral index was pretty close to 90. This is a man who says when he was hired to work on the film he took it for granted it was a man in a suit. "
http://www.bigfootproject.org/interviews/john_green.html