Bigfoot - serious, not follies

That story is so full of fallacious reasoning, I don't know where to start, but I'll add to what I've presented so far, later..


I'll start by repeating what I pointed out earlier.

In spite of what the rest of the ' conclusions ' paragraph says, the final sentence is clear..

" Stories and paintings of how the creature looked and behaved are only present in these Native cultures because of direct observation of a flesh and blood creature."

How could the author possibly know this about a 700 - 1200 year old pictograph.

It is an absurd statement, and typical of Bigfoot rationalization..
 
LAL said:
I didn't ask him about that. Does he have plans to publish on it, do you know?

No, I don't know. I regret I didn't save the email exchange between us. After I queried him about any close scientific examination of the cast being written up in scientific journals, he never replied.

I know you're unconvinced. What other explanation do you have to offer?

Yes I'm unconvinced. It will take more than speculation about squatch butts to convince me too. Squatch was never witnessed sitting in the mud, nor were any clear tracks found. No visualization took place, the fruit was never proven to have been chewed by bigfoot, and I've not heard of any definitive identification of sasquatch hairs found embedded in the cast.

Don't drag in Piltdown Man, please.

I never mentioned Piltdown Man. I was actually thinking of many other instances in which scientists have been proven wrong. Rene Blondlot for example, and the fiasco concerning N-Rays.

From: http://www.rexresearch.com/blondlot/nrays.htm
Some 120 scientists published almost 300 articles on the topic during the years 1903-1906, and the original discoverer himself published 26 articles and a book (Ref. 1) before halting, while one of his colleagues published no fewer than 38 reports in the same three-year period -- all on "rays" which have never since been observed.

If you only saw part of it, how do you know what the overall tone was?

The part I DID see did not paint Meldrum as gullible or a loon or anything. The show was presenting unexplained mysteries, and seemed to be doing so in a 'factual' manner.

Read the other thread, please. I even mentioned she hasn't done the research.

It's rather difficult to find an expert in "Bigfootology" when there's no such field. Primatology is close enough for me.

I mentioned Goodall among others and posted a link to her introduction to the Willow Creek Symposium. I've never presented her as an authority on Sasquatches, only as someone with standing who has looked into it to some extent for thirty years who believes they exist. Posters kind of latched on to her, presumably because they'd never heard of any of the others.

She may have an opinion on bigfoot, but I'm not aware of ANY research conducted by Goodall into the bigfoot phenomenon. If she has, I'm not aware of it and will gladly remove my foot from mouth to eat crow if proven wrong. Her opinion carries no more weight than the next person who has never investigated the evidence for or against bigfoot.

You've seen this?

"Sunday, January 05, 2003

Bigfoot Believers: Legitimate scientific study of legend gains backing of top primate experts

By Theo Stein
Denver Post

Yes, I have. I've been following the bigfoot mystery for over 20 years, and though I can't profess to be aware of ALL that's been written concerning bigfoot, I have read that particular article.

RayG
 
bruto said:
If pictographs and folklore constitute viable evidence of a creature's existence, I suggest that we abandon the search for Bigfoot, whose representations are so few and so poor, and fund more research into centaurs and crocodile-headed gods, because there are so many consistent accounts and pictures of them that they MUST be real.

So far what I've seen is an admission by some reputable sounding scientists that the possibility of a bigfoot is not outright preposterous, and deserves a serious look. This is a far cry from saying they think it exists, and it also presupposes that there has not yet been what they would consider a serious look. I still assert that this is means one or both of two things. Either there isn't really a bigfoot or the people doing the looking aren't doing a very good job of it.

Are you aware of how much physical evidence there is? No one's relying on pictographs as evidence, but since Sasquatches seem to be a wide-ranging species, it's quite possible that legends from the Native people may be based on a real animal just as stories of Raven and Coyote are. Note the descriptions of the behavior and compare with contempory accounts from B.C.

"The Sasquatch is part of the Coastal Salish people’s beliefs—the term is actually derived from the Salish “se’sxac,” which means “wild men.” This makes sense since the Salish would never have been exposed to a monkey or any other primate to better associate a humanoid animal with hands, human-like footprints, and the ability to walk on two feet. Otherwise, the closest primates are the small new world monkeys of Central America. To the coastal First Nations people, the Sasquatch was considered an animal—like a cougar, bear or wolverine."

http://www.martlet.ca/archives/040916/feature.html


There hasn't been a full-scale scientific investigation yet.

John Green has spent about 40 years trying to get scientists to take a serious look. Some have. Napier reached the conclusion they exist and so stated. Krantz was as certain as he was of sunrises and sunsets. Meldrum does field work and has examined tracks in situ five times. Swindler reversed thirty years of scepticism. Don't take the cautious language of science as uncertainty.

"“Because of the sort of taboo nature of this animal, most sightings do not become reports, and most people don’t know where to report them anyway,” he explained. “This is just the tip of the iceberg.”
Bindernagle said that it won’t be long before indisputable evidence is found.

“What we’re going to need is a road kill or the actual carcass,” he said. “In the meantime, we have so much evidence—tracks and eyewitness accounts—the problem is to get other scientists to look at this evidence, but they won’t even address it.”

Most scientists, he said, refuse to engage the evidence found thus far, instead relying on mainstream media and tabloid reports that are done without scientific consultation.

“We have a real problem with a non-human primate existing anywhere in North America. It’s too bizarre for us; it’s too bizarre for scientists,” he said. “This is what keeps me going. [People who report sightings] are not idiots, but they’re being treated as idiots.”

http://www.martlet.ca/archives/040916/feature.html


There are really very few people actually out looking. Most encounters are quite accidental. Nevertheless, the BFRO receives several reports a day.
 
RayG said:
You mean like the Windigo (Wendigo, Windego, Wetiko, Windago, Windikouk)? ;)

RayG
They eat Indians. What the heck, Coyote ate the moon.

I'm not finding the rest of Walker's letter but I seem to remember it mentioned child-stealing. The mountain may have been St. Helens.

There was competition with them on the Coast over the clams, so perhaps the Coast tribes had more direct contact with them and more reason to fear them.

I remember being, um, startled, when Cannibal Woman burst into Don Smith's longhouse north of Portland and swiped his granddaughter. The kids were screaming. I always wondered why he didn't have a Kwakiutl name.
 
RayG said:
No, I don't know. I regret I didn't save the email exchange between us. After I queried him about any close scientific examination of the cast being written up in scientific journals, he never replied.



Yes I'm unconvinced. It will take more than speculation about squatch butts to convince me too. Squatch was never witnessed sitting in the mud, nor were any clear tracks found. No visualization took place, the fruit was never proven to have been chewed by bigfoot, and I've not heard of any definitive identification of sasquatch hairs found embedded in the cast.



Since there's no indisputable sample of hair known without a doubt to have come from a Sasquatch for comparison, the best that could be done was "unknown primate", and yes, that's how hairs found embedded were identified.

If MM and co. had watched it sit down, do you think they would have been believed?



I never mentioned Piltdown Man. I was actually thinking of many other instances in which scientists have been proven wrong. Rene Blondlot for example, and the fiasco concerning N-Rays.

From: http://www.rexresearch.com/blondlot/nrays.htm



I was on Creationism vs. Evolution boards too long, I guess. First it's "If man evolved from apes, why are there still apes?" then the Lady Hope Hoax, then Piltdown Man and Nebraska Man..............ARGHHHHHHHHGGGGGGRGH.



The part I DID see did not paint Meldrum as gullible or a loon or anything. The show was presenting unexplained mysteries, and seemed to be doing so in a 'factual' manner.



Good. I'd like to see it. Let me know if you remember more.


She may have an opinion on bigfoot, but I'm not aware of ANY research conducted by Goodall into the bigfoot phenomenon. If she has, I'm not aware of it and will gladly remove my foot from mouth to eat crow if proven wrong. Her opinion carries no more weight than the next person who has never investigated the evidence for or against bigfoot.




She's read every book she could find on it over thirty years and been photographed with Dr. Bindernagle at a conference. That puts her a conference up on me, anyway. ;)



Yes, I have. I've been following the bigfoot mystery for over 20 years, and though I can't profess to be aware of ALL that's been written concerning bigfoot, I have read that particular article.

RayG
;)

Green said AP wouldn't pick it up; it never got farther than Denver. A Waynesville preacher made national news for getting 9 members of East Baptist ousted for voting for Kerry. Go figure.

"BIP: How about hoaxers in general. Do they do any damage to the public's perception of bigfoot?

JG: Well, the media reaction certainly does. We've gone over the years through a phase where anything about this was news to where anyone who was doing something about it was news to where the only news nowadays is when people claim to have proven it's all a hoax.

BIP: Yes, I was going to ask you about that -


JG: Oh, I missed one phase. There was a phase there when any scientist who showed an interest was news. We've now reached the extreme where some of the world's very top people in the relevant fields are very interested and are saying publicly that there should be proper investigation and this is not news. The only thing that's news is that the whole thing has proved to be a fake. The demonstration of that is very clear when this absolute nonsense story about Ray Wallace faking all the foot prints went all around the world in exactly the same time period the Denver Post ran a major article and sidebars on these key scientists who were saying it should be investigated, the Associated Press wouldn't even carry the story. It never went anywhere beyond Denver. To me as a newspaper man, this is absolutely shocking. I tried to contact some of those at Columbia University's long-established graduate school of journalism who keep a tab on the press and the response was, "Nobody here is interested in taking this up." In other words, for 40 years we've been butting our heads against a barrier manned by the scientists saying there can't be any such thing. Now they're stepping away from the ramparts and the media is stepping up to take their place. Absolutely fascinating. The media is seeing to it that this heresy does not get to the public.

BIP: It seems to be the case when you can bet that someone who has bigfoot living up in that attic would get more press than something like the Skookum cast would.

JG: Well...

BIP: They seem to want to relegate this to the tabloids and that's where the story stays.

JG: For example, right now, we have the proof - absolute and indisputable - that the Patterson film is genuine. The newspapers refuse to carry anything of that. It can't be sold so therefore they're not going to be taken in therefore they're not going to run the story. As a result of this silly book where people are claiming that they were involved in making the film we've gone back to looking at the film and realize that, although you can't establish beyond dispute the size of anything, you can establish the relative size of things that are right there in the same film frame. This creature has an intermembral index - the comparison of the length of the arms to the length of the legs - that is totally outside the human range so it cannot be a human in a suit, but it is also totally outside the range of any other known primate of any size at all. Therefore, it has to be an unknown primate. This can only be ignored, it cannot be argued against. All you can do is say, "Well, you can't measure properly on the film." Well, you can't measure precisely, but the different is so slight that it doesn't matter. The human intermembral index is around 70, all of the great apes are over 100, this thing is in the high 80's. The question of the angle of this segment of the arm to the camera and so on, if you look at enough frames, you've got to be able to get to it. And on top of that, we have a forensic animator who worked on the "Legend Meets Science" DVD. He says that they established beyond any question the relative length of where the joints were as the thing was moving and the intermembral index was pretty close to 90. This is a man who says when he was hired to work on the film he took it for granted it was a man in a suit. "

http://www.bigfootproject.org/interviews/john_green.html
 
Diogenes said:
That story is so full of fallacious reasoning, I don't know where to start, but I'll add to what I've presented so far, later..


I'll start by repeating what I pointed out earlier.

In spite of what the rest of the ' conclusions ' paragraph says, the final sentence is clear..

" Stories and paintings of how the creature looked and behaved are only present in these Native cultures because of direct observation of a flesh and blood creature."

How could the author possibly know this about a 700 - 1200 year old pictograph.

It is an absurd statement, and typical of Bigfoot rationalization..

Explain how the descriptions could be so similar between B.C. and California. Why the match between ancient stories and contemporary accounts? How could a tribe possibly know about giant hairy hominids 700-1200 ago?

So, we have US Forest Service Archeologist saying, in effect, the creatures are real, and you think her reasoning is fallacious because she doesn't share your forgone conclusions.

Oh.
 
Well, all I can say is that the sasquatches seem to be smarter than the people out looking for them. No resources, no technology, but they just seem to slip away. If they ever do catch one I hope they hire it as a cryptozoologist, and maybe it can help us bag a lake monster or two. We're not having much luck on that front either.

So if they used to fight the indians over clams, what are they doing for clams these days. Maybe it's time to buy a decent camera and a sack of clams and hunker down.

You know, if you ever did get a really good picture of one, you'd be rich and famous. It's a great opportunity, and from the sound of it, all the woo-woos are asleep at the switch!
 
bruto said:
Well, all I can say is that the sasquatches seem to be smarter than the people out looking for them. No resources, no technology, but they just seem to slip away. If they ever do catch one I hope they hire it as a cryptozoologist, and maybe it can help us bag a lake monster or two. We're not having much luck on that front either.

So if they used to fight the indians over clams, what are they doing for clams these days. Maybe it's time to buy a decent camera and a sack of clams and hunker down.




No one said they fought the Indians over clams. There was an account of two villages moving because of them going after the clams.
A report from Canada had something lobbing rocks at people on a wild beach (bears don't do that). They may do what they've always done for clams........gone after them. NW cost beaches aren't like Florida. Been to the Olympic Peninsula? The cliffs drop straight to the sand and there's plenty of virgin forest for cover. An army of Sasquatches could go for the razorbacks at night and never be seen.

You know, if you ever did get a really good picture of one, you'd be rich and famous. It's a great opportunity, and from the sound of it, all the woo-woos are asleep at the switch!

Drop the derogatory term, please. You really have no right to categorize people whose efforts you know nothing about. For an idea of the perils, please read this thread:

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?act=ST&f=21&t=1913

Note what happened to the trees.
 
LAL said:
Explain how the descriptions could be so similar between B.C. and California. Why the match between ancient stories and contemporary accounts? How could a tribe possibly know about giant hairy hominids 700-1200 ago?

Explain how the description of dragons could be so similar between China and Great Britain. The pictures are certainly a lot better.. They must be real..


So, we have US Forest Service Archeologist saying, in effect, the creatures are real, and you think her reasoning is fallacious because she doesn't share your forgone conclusions.

Oh.
With no tangable evidence, why is her reasoning any more valid than anyone else's. Her saying it's real, under the circumstances, is enough reason to dismiss her opinion entirely.. Just another UFO'er.. ( Unidentified Furry Object )

Those pictographs don't prove anything. In case you didn't notice, they are very vague..

They are only a Sasquatch in the eyes of someone who wants them to be.
 
Diogenes said:
Explain how the description of dragons could be so similar between China and Great Britain. The pictures are certainly a lot better.. They must be real..

Dragons and other mythical beasts such as the Cyclops may have been inspired by fossils. China's a treasure trove of dinosaur fossils. I'd have to do some reseach on dragons to find out when they showed up in England and whether they were inspired by Chinese depictions. Or do you have this information?

With no tangable evidence, why is her reasoning any more valid than anyone else's. Her saying it's real, under the circumstances, is enough reason to dismiss her opinion entirely.. Just another UFO'er.. ( Unidentified Furry Object )

It's much easier to dismiss your opinion entirely, for the reasons you give.
All theories start with conjecture. It's an interesting article. Hopefully some unseen lurker will appreciate it more than you do.

Those pictographs don't prove anything. In case you didn't notice, they are very vague..

And very damaged. Pictographs are stylized. What other animal would they represent? How realistic are these?

http://www.petroglyphs.us/photographs_pictographs_petroglyphs_baja_norte_california_BC.htm

They are only a Sasquatch in the eyes of someone who wants them to be.

They are of Hairy Man and his family.
 
Is this supposed to be a joke, LAL?

I have to ask why anyone would attach a camera to a tree that obviously fell a while ago, let alone why they would do it twice.

Why didn't anyone seriously question the story?

Those trees have been on the ground for a long time, imo. So, I will have to dismiss yet another case as an attempted hoax.

For those who did not follow the link posted by LAL referencing trees, a poster claimed that these trees had been pushed over because he had mounted cameras on them.

This is not true, imo. These trees fell many years before, imo.

One other possibility comes to mind. The trees have obviously been dead for a while. It's possible the cameraman himself pushed over the rotten trunks, but I am sticking with my original thoughts, that the trees fell a while ago.

Of course we'd also have to ask why any serious person would attach his cameras to two obviously dead & rotting tree trunks???

post-2-1068358761.jpg


post-2-1068358828.jpg
 
damndirtyape Posted: Nov 9 2003, 10:08 AM


Resident Photography Guru


Group: Members
Posts: 1,899
Joined: 14-July 03
Location: Washington
BF Encounter: Not sure



The trees were about 10" in diameter and 50 to 80 feet tall Alders. They were broken from their base below ground about 12". No other trees fell.

When I first got to the site I thought "Oh, Great! Someone stole the cameras." I set them up so I could see the other one from each position, but they were both pointed into the woods along a game trail this time instead of out towards the sand bar. Looking around I discovered them under the two fallen trees. It looked like someone had stolen the whole tree at first until I found the trees and the hole in the ground.

At the site I just thought that the storm had did it but when I got home I started thinking. Why just those two trees that had cameras on them?
 
Re: Is this supposed to be a joke, LAL?

LTC8K6 said:
I have to ask why anyone would attach a camera to a tree that obviously fell a while ago, let alone why they would do it twice.

Why didn't anyone seriously question the story?

Those trees have been on the ground for a long time, imo. So, I will have to dismiss yet another case as an attempted hoax.

For those who did not follow the link posted by LAL referencing trees, a poster claimed that these trees had been pushed over because he had mounted cameras on them.

This is not true, imo. These trees fell many years before, imo.

One other possibility comes to mind. The trees have obviously been dead for a while. It's possible the cameraman himself pushed over the rotten trunks, but I am sticking with my original thoughts, that the trees fell a while ago.

Of course we'd also have to ask why any serious person would attach his cameras to two obviously dead & rotting tree trunks???

post-2-1068358761.jpg


post-2-1068358828.jpg

What makes you think they were on the ground for a long time? They're very long and heavy. It would it be difficult to get the cameras tied on. One of the posters on the thread mentioned the possibility of rot at the base as a cause of them going over. One has lost bark, but it doesn't look at all rotted in the bare patches. It looks like Red Alder, which gets to 85',with a high crown.

"Wood stain and decay proceed rapidly in cut trees, and logs should be processed soon after harvest unless they are stored in fresh water (43). During intermediate cuts, care must be taken to avoid injuring residual trees; once trees are injured, decay organisms can invade rapidly."


http://forestry.about.com/library/silvics/blsilalrub.htm

Those weren't down long. If they had been, they'd be covered in ground- growing club moss. See that in the pictures, and the leaves. Pretty hard to find tracks in stuff like that.
On my place in Washington I had dead trees standing for many years. There was a spar tree up the hill that had been standing dead at least since logging in the fifties. Saplings would go over part way and then hang caught in the branches of a nearby tree and stay there.

Do you know who set the cameras (that should be easy to figure out - no coaching from the audience)? Why would you leap to a conclusion of a hoax, especially from a false premise? He did not claim something pushed them over; he wondered if that was a possibility. They were broken off 12" below the ground.

He's not only a researcher, he's a very careful and wary one.

Aside from falling trees there's the possibility of someone stealing the cameras.
 
Okay, no mystery on dragons.

"Some Celtic / Gaelic / Scottish dragons are linked to the Chinese version by way of the first Byzantine Empire. It also shows Aegean influences."

http://www.theserenedragon.net/Tales/England.html

An elephant skull eroding from a cliff is thought to be the basis for the Cyclops. The huge nostril hole was taken for an eye socket, evidently.
 
Re: Is this supposed to be a joke, LAL?



Of course we'd also have to ask why any serious person would attach his cameras to two obviously dead & rotting tree trunks???

Because they're there. And they do not appear to be rotting. The diameter on alder is a good size and there are no branches in the way. Doug Firs getting enough sun are well-clothed all the way down. When mature they often have dead branches almost to the ground. Dead trees can be quite sturdy (only one looks dead to me) and I would suspect those just happened to be in a good position for getting shots across the sandbar.

Here's a researcher, who has already been in on a major event, continuing his investigations and attempting to get those clear shots you've all been clammering for, and you apply your usual "distain" and accuse him of pulling a hoax. On whom? People on a message board? Many of them are researchers too.
I'd like to see you join the board and tell that to his face....er, post.

Get real.
 
So maybe it's just bad luck again - those researchers seem to be plagued by the worst luck on earth - but it looks to me as if both trees are dead. Alders are trash trees and whether they were up or down, dead or alive, they fall down pretty easily. Anyway, from the little information in those photos it looks as if there weren't any other trees available right nearby. This explains the choice, but also suggests that whatever it was that knocked or blew them down was not selecting camera-bearing trees, but just blowing down whatever punky alders were there.

If it's true that sasquatches are smart and wily and observant enough to attack trees that hold cameras (all the while remaining unobserved by those cameras while they do the job), then they are pretty smart indeed, and require a less blundering strategy than has so far been applied. A sasquatch with this much vested interest in foiling investigators might be expected to repeat this behavior. If the researcher obtained three cameras, and left two of them strapped to obvious trees, and concealed the third within a well-designed blind or hole, aimed at the other two cameras, then next time the sasquatch came out on a camera-bashing foray, the hidden camera ought to catch him in the act. If a clear picture of this event were to be obtained, I am willing to bet that many skeptics would be better persuaded both of the existence of the sasquatch and of the competency of the researcher.

Pile up all the fuzzy pictures and near misses and botched opportunities you want, but I continue to maintain that if there's a sasquatch out there, part of the problem of credibility rests on the quality of investigation.
 
LAL said:


They are of Hairy Man and his family.

The dad..

fig5.gif



O.K. We'll conclude the straignt lines indicate long hair.. Couldn't possibly be anything else.. Certainly not, if we are going reach the conclusion we have set out to reach..


The Mom..

fig7.gif


Not being a trained Bigfootologist, I don't know how we know this is a female, but it looks like she is a rare hairless female Bigfoot, because we have proven that long shaggy hair is always depicted with several straight lines in the shoulder area.


The kid..


fig9.gif



It looks like baby Bigfoots might be adopted badgers.. But we can never really know unless we find the diary of the artist..
 
bruto said:
So maybe it's just bad luck again - those researchers seem to be plagued by the worst luck on earth - but it looks to me as if both trees are dead. Alders are trash trees and whether they were up or down, dead or alive, they fall down pretty easily. Anyway, from the little information in those photos it looks as if there weren't any other trees available right nearby. This explains the choice, but also suggests that whatever it was that knocked or blew them down was not selecting camera-bearing trees, but just blowing down whatever punky alders were there.

If it's true that sasquatches are smart and wily and observant enough to attack trees that hold cameras (all the while remaining unobserved by those cameras while they do the job), then they are pretty smart indeed, and require a less blundering strategy than has so far been applied. A sasquatch with this much vested interest in foiling investigators might be expected to repeat this behavior. If the researcher obtained three cameras, and left two of them strapped to obvious trees, and concealed the third within a well-designed blind or hole, aimed at the other two cameras, then next time the sasquatch came out on a camera-bashing foray, the hidden camera ought to catch him in the act. If a clear picture of this event were to be obtained, I am willing to bet that many skeptics would be better persuaded both of the existence of the sasquatch and of the competency of the researcher.

Pile up all the fuzzy pictures and near misses and botched opportunities you want, but I continue to maintain that if there's a sasquatch out there, part of the problem of credibility rests on the quality of investigation.

No one's claiming a Sasquatch knocked the trees down. It seems odd the storm would only blow over the trees with the cameras.

Alders fix nitrogen in the soil and are extremely valuable in a well-managed forest. They're not "trash". They're fast-growing and short-lived, but I don't know how easy they are to blow down. I had a grove of alder that was sturdy as all get-out, but they were in a rather protected spot.

I don't know that anyone on this board is qualified to judge the quality of the investigation. I do know the level of cynicism is such that if an inverstigator makes a typo, it proves Sasquatches don't exist.
 
Diogenes said:
The dad..

fig5.gif



O.K. We'll conclude the straignt lines indicate long hair.. Couldn't possibly be anything else.. Certainly not, if we are going reach the conclusion we have set out to reach..


The Mom..

fig7.gif


Not being a trained Bigfootologist, I don't know how we know this is a female, but it looks like she is a rare hairless female Bigfoot, because we have proven that long shaggy hair is always depicted with several straight lines in the shoulder area.


The kid..


fig9.gif



It looks like baby Bigfoots might be adopted badgers.. But we can never really know unless we find the diary of the artist..

My point, in case you've forgotten, to another poster was that not all Native legends depict them as scary monsters, so the idea that they might just be tales to keep the kids around the campfire doesn't explain it all.

Native people I know accept them as real without question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom