Gorillagator
Student
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2005
- Messages
- 29
aggle-rithm said:Not if the expert is sufficiently credulous.
Isn't that an oxymoronic phrase? <g>
aggle-rithm said:Not if the expert is sufficiently credulous.
Not necessarily - you could be an expert in self delusion and believing anything exciting just for the sake of it.Gorillagator said:Isn't that an oxymoronic phrase? <g>
Do you mean Ray Wallace or Bob Heironimus?
Neither originated any hoax and both have been thoroughly debunked.
I find it amusing there are still people who know so little about this they can make statements like yours above.
LAL said:It's being worked on. One researcher has been monitoring a particular area for years. He has something inconclusive on film, with, perhaps, something better to come. He has a great deal of experience and expertise.
Considering there has never been a full scale scientific investigation, the effort has pretty much been up to amateurs working on their own time and money. The creatures are largely nocturnal, elusive and potentially very dangerous. They don't seem to follow any set pattern in their foraging and roam over a huge territory. Bryne estimated they can cover 25 miles in a night. Where would you set up the camera traps?
I don't know that anyone's been inept or incompetant (and much evidence has been gathered). "Unlucky" might be a better word.
Dr. Meldrum applied for a grant for field work on them in the Southern Rockies last year. Suppose he got it?
He was suspended (again), last I heard. They're debating whether or not to upgrade that to banning.I'll_buy_that said:first, let me state that I love reading this thread. I find it really really amusing. I hate to see it end; where is Erik lately?
I'll_buy_that said:Oh, that would be disappointing. I like good fodder
by the way, how could I have been so skeptical when there are good clear photos of yeti....
![]()
Clearly she's quite small. Otherwise, she'd be easy to photograph and wouldn't show up as rods or orbs.aggle-rithm said:Wow... can they whip up a "life-size" statue of the Tooth Fairy?
I always wondered if she was normal sized, or like Tinkerbell.
RayG said:I wasn't trying to imply otherwise, just pointing out that claims of dermal ridges in casts might not actually BE dermal ridges. The original poster himself stated:
" Very few Sasquatch footprint casts contain features that are considered to be dermal ridges."
To already start with a small number of casts, and then to point out the possibility of contamination (for lack of a better word) depending on the methods and materials used, does not bode well for the authenticity of casts with dermal ridges.
No, but investigators should be aware that a possible problem exists.
I don't deny that, however, he started out by calling the footage "compelling".
Does that mean I'm suggesting the Skookum cast is a hoax? Not at all, but Meldrum is only human, and humans have been known to make mistakes. Is it possible that the print was made by a sasquatch? I guess so, but I don't see any convincing evidence to confirm that hypothesis.
The TV show I just recently watched had Meldrum himself looking at the footage and calling it "compelling". He has used the same word to describe the Skookum cast.
Which again, seems to be 'name-dropping', or at the very least an appeal to authority.
RayG
aggle-rithm said:Wow... can they whip up a "life-size" statue of the Tooth Fairy?
I'll_buy_that said:first, let me state that I love reading this thread. I find it really really amusing. I hate to see it end; where is Erik lately?
LAL, I thought you were one voice of reason here until your post
on page 5...
then the one on page 6...
do you know why people haven't heard the debunking of Wallace? it is because most reasonable people do not beieve in bigfoot, yeti, sasquatch, yoda, or the Easter Bunny. They wouldn't spend time finding out about Wallace's claim or his debunking.
Keep up the good work LAL and Erik, I like a good read
![]()
LAL said:
Somehow, I think Chilcutt would have been alert to this possibility. He went in as a sceptic.
He tried to duplicate ridges and failed. He was very thorough.
[/B]
Meldrum is, and it said on the conference thread they were going to inform Chilcutt.
[/B]
I didn't see the show. Was it the one NG did? I suspect he's more careful now. Note my sig line. I e-mailed him about being shown in front of a Snow Walker still, and, modest guy that he is, he didn't even mention who exposed the hoax in his reply.
[/B]
One way that conclusion was reached was by ruling out other possibilities, including imprints of several animals combining to appear to be an imprint of a hominid. Did you see LMS? Swindler and Sarmiento were quite clearly convinced.
[/B]
What show was that on? Did they also say he exposed the hoax or were they trying to insinuate it's all a hoax and paint Meldrum as a gullible fool?
Check the other thread. I even posted information on what qualifies as appeal to authority.
I named several people, including Dr. Swindler, who is a giant in his field, with good credentials in primatology who are taking this seriously.
"2003 International Bigfoot Symposium Keynote Address
By John Green
Most of you will have noticed that I am not Jane Goodall, and you may well be wondering why I have been asked to fill her spot at this symposium. Well, you are missing the obvious. We have the same initials.
That Dr. Goodall has been unable to keep her commitment to speak here is most unfortunate. Her presence might well have focused the attention of the media on the fact, which they have so far largely succeeded in ignoring, that scientists of world-wide reputation are starting to take a serious look at the evidence that humans are not the only bipedal primates on Earth.
That, in my opinion, is the current development that holds the greatest promise for the future of Bigfoot/sasquatch investigation...
It is by no means just Jane Goodall.
In recent years I have had considerable contact with:
George Schaller, director of science for the Wildlife Conservation Society
Esteban Sarmiento, primate specialist at the American Museum of Natural History
Russel Mittermeier, president of Conservation International and chairman of the world-wide Primate Specialist Group
Daris Swindler, author of the atlas of comparative anatomy of man and chimpanzee.
All but Dr. Mittermeier have spent time examining the Skookum cast.
All of them are on our side.
They have all stated, all but one of them publicly, that the evidence already accumulated establishes the case for full scientific participation in getting to the bottom of this matter. Dr. Mittermeier told me that he has long considered taking up the hunt himself--and he told Jeff Meldrum that he would not fear being criticized for doing so, because he and his team have already discovered several other unknown primates.
Dr. Swindler, whom I have known for more than 30 years, has appeared in documentaries on this subject in the past as the obligatory skeptical scientist. Now, after careful examination of the best heel print in the Skookum cast, he has expressed the conviction that it is the heel print of a large unknown primate - and he would be here with us today if his health permitted.
With this high-profile support, and with the increasing number of less eminent but fully-qualified zoologists and physical anthropologists who are already participating at their own expense, the time may well be near when scientific institutions with resources and funding will join us in our search."
http://www.bigfootproject.org/articles/green_keynote.html
One of the posters on the Bigfoot Follies thread seemed to be claiming that scientists taking this seriously have lost all credibility and are "woos" . Another seemed more interested in accusing me of "name dropping" than in checking out what they actually had to say. [/B]
LAL said:..................................
One of the posters on the Bigfoot Follies thread seemed to be claiming that scientists taking this seriously have lost all credibility and are "woos" . Another seemed more interested in accusing me of "name dropping" than in checking out what they actually had to say.
Diogenes said:I did check out what they had to say..
I find nothing more than ( paraphrase )
" It should be looked into .. ( Just not by me .. ) "
If you can point to a line of inquiry by one of your eminent primatologists, that has more substance to it than this, I will gladly acknowledge it.
It is a fallacious appeal to authority, to drop the names of experts, who while well credentialed in related fields, have not done ( nor appear interested in doing ) any research into the topic at hand
The other thread has been put out of it's misery.
This one is even more deserving of the same fate.
bruto said:So what we have here, it seems, are five (or maybe four if you discount the one who won't make a statement publicly),
who think it would be worthwhile to find out if there actually is a bigfoot - not that they actually think there is from the evidence, but that they think someone ought to find out for sure. Well, it's a start, but not exactly a running start.
I still contend that given the quality of evidence after all this time, a reasonable skeptic has two things to be skeptical of - choose either or both: neither the existence of bigfoot nor the competence of the researchers has been established to my satisfaction.
Diogenes said:An ' opinion ' of someone else's work is not research .
Still, no research by the respected scientists ( Goodall, Sarmiente, etc.. ) you like to name, in connection with your Bigfoot folklore...
Nothing to see here, move along..
Nope.. Bye.LAL said:Swindler and Sarmiento examined the Skookum Cast themselves. How is that an "opinion of someone else's work"?
And I may review the papers they submitted based on that examination, where ?
Word is Sarmiento wants to look into it when he's finished the Bili Ape project. Goodall's back in Africa. She had to miss the Willow Creek Symposium because of an important meeting with officials. Chimpanzees come first. With no grant money forthcoming, it's asking a bit much to expect a working scientist to drop everything and go into full-time Sasquatch research.
Then it might not be too much to ask that you don't bring up her name to support your position..
Folklore does not leave footprints.
Nothing you're willing to look at..........
I told you who's been doing research. They just don't happen to be world-famous. I'm glad they've persisted despite baseless ridicule.
Again, then you might restrict your references to those actually doing research.
I just checked the other thread and posted on it, in fact. Erik's been suspended again and the kids seem to have taken their baseball gloves and gone home.
It is not dead, it's just away.
You missed the point. The thread died, because no one was interested any longer..
I was interested to find you engaging UFO'ers , so I thought I'd drop in and see if there was anything new. There wasn't...
Now, do you have anything better to do than nitpick over what you perceive as a logical fallacy?

Hitch said:What do you think listing a bunch of names for Bigfoot proves?
With a few minutes effort i could produce a really long list of names for Santa Claus. Does that make him real?
LAL said:I was surprised by how many there are. I'm not trying to prove anything, but it's a pretty interesting article. Perhaps I can induce someone to read it.
For those who think Ray Wallace started the "legend" in 1958, the the lore of the Native Americans might be enlightening.
My favorite comment by one was, "Oh, is the White Man just getting around to that?"