Bigfoot - serious, not follies

LAL said:
No one's claiming a Sasquatch knocked the trees down. It seems odd the storm would only blow over the trees with the cameras.

Alders fix nitrogen in the soil and are extremely valuable in a well-managed forest. They're not "trash". They're fast-growing and short-lived, but I don't know how easy they are to blow down. I had a grove of alder that was sturdy as all get-out, but they were in a rather protected spot.

I don't know that anyone on this board is qualified to judge the quality of the investigation. I do know the level of cynicism is such that if an inverstigator makes a typo, it proves Sasquatches don't exist.

So if a sasquatch didn't knock down the trees, either there is something really unlikely weird going on or the choice of trees was poor. Are you, after all your attempt to avoid the silliness of far-out explanations, appealing to the supernatural?

I wouldn't ever say alders are ecologically unimportant or worthy of extinction, but they are, as you say, fast growing and short lived, like aspens and box elders, and probably a poor bet for stability especially if they're already looking as punky as the ones in those pictures. Of course if they were the only trees available then the choice is obvious, but then if they were the only trees available, then what is selective about their falling? How much bad luck is it reasonable to expect before you begin to suspect bad technique?

If nobody on this board is qualified to judge the quality of the investigation, then you must count yourself among us. If you were to be consistent you'd withdraw from the thread, since it's obvious you're no more qualified to promote the evidence than I am to question it.

I really hope there is a sasquatch, and would very much like to see serious researchers do a good job of finding out, as I also hope (vainly, I suspect) that there really are lake monsters and that someday someone will get a clear shot at one. Believe me, next time I'm sailing up around Bulwagga Bay, I'm going to have a good fat telephoto lens at the ready! But I think that hope and expectation and denial have led many people to accept a quality of evidence for unknown phenomena that they would never accept in normal life. Seekers of the unexplained seem willing to accept excuses and overlook mistakes, blundering and even occasional frauds, to such an extent that it is hard to take even the more convincing evidence seriously. Could you get a conviction on the forensic quality of those footprints? Would you accept photographic evidence of that quality from a detective or a philandering spouse? Would you even accept some of those hard-luck stories from a student who forgot his homework? I suspect not.
 
LAL said:
Since there's no indisputable sample of hair known without a doubt to have come from a Sasquatch for comparison, the best that could be done was "unknown primate", and yes, that's how hairs found embedded were identified.

Which independent investigator came up with "unknown primate"? Fahrenbach maybe? What is his specific area of scientific expertise? Is he qualified to do hair analysis? Has he samples of ALL North American animals for comparison purposes? (wolverine, moose, etc. etc.) Is Henner considered a hair identification expert outside the field of bigfoot?

The conclusion here:
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m2843/is_6_27/ai_110575770
seems to cast some doubt on the 'unknown primate' conclusion.

Aside from the mud imprint, three samples were subjected to DNA analysis: unidentified hair, saliva from an apple core, and bits of scat. Expert Craig Newton gave the results: the scat turned up nothing usable; "we couldn't conclude anything" from the saliva sample; and the Bigfoot hair sequences were "so human-like as to most likely be contaminants."

There are some claims that microscopic hair analysis is nothing more than junk science. For example,

http://www.law-forensic.com/cfr_hair_10.htm
http://www.law-forensic.com/cfr_hair_15.htm

From http://www.truthinjustice.org/where-justice.htm
Junk science plays a large role in the conviction of innocents. Microscopic hair-comparison evidence has sent many an innocent person to jail. The weakness of hair analysis is well established. For example, it is a known fact that hairs from the same head often do not match. A test of 240 crime labs found error rates in hair analysis of 50 percent, 54 percent, 68 percent and 56 percent. Yet prosecutors desperate for convictions continue to use the junk science of hair comparison to send innocent people to prison.

If MM and co. had watched it sit down, do you think they would have been believed?

If they had dragged back a dead body they would certainly be believed. Supportive evidence, a sighting, tracks, etc. would certainly be better than nothing, which is ultimately what they obtained.

She's read every book she could find on it over thirty years and been photographed with Dr. Bindernagle at a conference. That puts her a conference up on me, anyway. ;)

I too have read just about anything I could find on the subject over the course of about 30+ years. John Bindernagel even sent me a copy of his book about 5 years ago. I admit I've never been to a conference, but I doubt attendance would make me more or less of an authority on bigfoot.

Green said AP wouldn't pick it up; it never got farther than Denver. A Waynesville preacher made national news for getting 9 members of East Baptist ousted for voting for Kerry. Go figure.

No mystery. Preachers and Kerry have actually been proven to exist. I'd be willing to bet the dead body of a bigfoot would make front page news on a national level.

JG: For example, right now, we have the proof - absolute and indisputable - that the Patterson film is genuine.

Absolute and indisputable proof from a subject that stood only 1.66mm tall inside an area measuring 10 mm wide by 7.5 mm tall?

RayG
 
With regards to rotting trees....

A few years ago, when we still lived in the city of Kingston, a single tree stood at the foot of our lawn. It was pretty thick, but it was obvious it was dead. Because of concern that it might fall over upon my neighbor's car during a bad windstorm, I went out to examine the tree closely. I had some of the kids watching me, my own and neigborhood kids as well. I'm a pretty husky guy, and had always told my own kids that I was the strongest man they would ever meet in their entire lives. So, I placed myself between the tree and my neighbor's driveway, and with a lot of showmanship, and a few moans and groans, proceeded to knock that tree clean over. The look on the kids faces was priceless, and I asked a couple neighborhood kids if THEIR dads could knock over a friggin tree!!

This tree

post-2-1068358828.jpg


looks a lot more decayed than did the one I pushed over. Much thinner too.

RayG
 
LAL said:
They eat Indians. What the heck, Coyote ate the moon.

Yup, and coyote also created humans and the Milky Way, and a raven plucked the moon from the sky. That's exactly why I don't accept cave drawings, campfire stories, or totem poles as evidence.

RayG
 
LAL said:
My point, in case you've forgotten, to another poster was that not all Native legends depict them as scary monsters, so the idea that they might just be tales to keep the kids around the campfire doesn't explain it all.

.
And my point, that you ignored, was that the same source you used DID depict them as scary monsters, to make the kids come home early...


Finding the stuff that agrees with your foregone conclusion is called " data mining "..

I have shown that I can use that technigue also, and to use your sources to refute your claims.

That's why scientists use what we call the ' scientific method ' , to eliminate conflicting data..

I'ts a lot different than counting the hits and ignoring the misses.. Which is what some call ' woo ' behavior ..

Sorry if you feel that is a derogatory term, but if the shoe fits...

If I really cared what people who don't know me, think about me, I might be upset by being called a cynic or a sceptic..



Oh.. and as for :
Native people I know accept them as real without question.
And the fact that you don't have a problem with that, tells us a lot about where you are coming from..:)
 
bruto said:
So if a sasquatch didn't knock down the trees, either there is something really unlikely weird going on or the choice of trees was poor. Are you, after all your attempt to avoid the silliness of far-out explanations, appealing to the supernatural?



I believe in absolutely nothing supernatural.

The area is being monitored because there are signs of Sasquatch activity, so it's not out of the question the trees were pushed over, but I'd want some kind of confirmation, such as footprints where one stood to push them.

It was odd the storm only knocked over the ones with cameras.


I wouldn't ever say alders are ecologically unimportant or worthy of extinction, but they are, as you say, fast growing and short lived, like aspens and box elders, and probably a poor bet for stability especially if they're already looking as punky as the ones in those pictures. Of course if they were the only trees available then the choice is obvious, but then if they were the only trees available, then what is selective about their falling? How much bad luck is it reasonable to expect before you begin to suspect bad technique?



They don't look punky. If they were rotted they'd be black. I can't see a crown, but the one doesn't look dead. I may bring this up on the thread when I have time.

I wouldn't suspect poor technique from one who has been investigating for thirty years and who helped devise a means to bring one into an area and get some of the best evidence yet. He is extremely intelligent and dedicated and evidently is doing this on his own time and his own dime.

If nobody on this board is qualified to judge the quality of the investigation, then you must count yourself among us. If you were to be consistent you'd withdraw from the thread, since it's obvious you're no more qualified to promote the evidence than I am to question it.



I do count myself among the people not qualified to judge it. Did you see "except me" anywhere? I'm not on the scene and don't know from first-hand examination the condition of those trees, e.g.. I do know western Washington well, though, and from reading, among other things, over 50 pages of the poster's posts and seeing him on film I have a good sense of what kind of person he is. He has my respect.

I'm certainly as qualified to present the evidence as anyone who's been interested in this for over thirty years and who has taken the time to read on it and talk with people who have had experiences. I won't comment on your qualifications.

I don't know how many people view this board, but I was surprised on looking for one of my posts on BFF that some had had a couple of thousand views (there were about 400 members at the time). It would seem there's a fair number of unseen lurkers.
If I can correct some of the misconceptions many people have and counter some of the tabloid view, I'll consider my time on this well spent.


I really hope there is a sasquatch, and would very much like to see serious researchers do a good job of finding out, as I also hope (vainly, I suspect) that there really are lake monsters and that someday someone will get a clear shot at one. Believe me, next time I'm sailing up around Bulwagga Bay, I'm going to have a good fat telephoto lens at the ready! But I think that hope and expectation and denial have led many people to accept a quality of evidence for unknown phenomena that they would never accept in normal life. Seekers of the unexplained seem willing to accept excuses and overlook mistakes, blundering and even occasional frauds, to such an extent that it is hard to take even the more convincing evidence seriously. Could you get a conviction on the forensic quality of those footprints? Would you accept photographic evidence of that quality from a detective or a philandering spouse? Would you even accept some of those hard-luck stories from a student who forgot his homework? I suspect not.

I would like to see funding made available for research and more cooperation from the scientific community.
Which footprints are you referring to? Meldrum has about 150 casts in his collection. I'd hate to see a conviction of hoaxing on the conjecture that evidence was faked with absolutely nothing to support it.

You seem to be generalizing about "seekers of the unexplained". Are you referring to Coleman? Green? Kratz? Ivan T. Sanderson?

As for excuses mistakes, blundering and even occasional frauds, what specifically are you referring to? Let's look at some examples.

To my mind, Ray Wallace's carved feet in no way affect this (and even though every hair can't be seen, is it really that fuzzy?):
 
Diogenes said:
And my point, that you ignored, was that the same source you used DID depict them as scary monsters, to make the kids come home early...


Finding the stuff that agrees with your foregone conclusion is called " data mining "..

I have shown that I can use that technigue also, and to use your sources to refute your claims.

That's why scientists use what we call the ' scientific method ' , to eliminate conflicting data..

I'ts a lot different than counting the hits and ignoring the misses.. Which is what some call ' woo ' behavior ..

Sorry if you feel that is a derogatory term, but if the shoe fits...



It might if I'd quoted only the part that favored my view and didn't give the link so people could read the whole article. The Hairy Man story is a cool story and I like sharing it. The important thing is that invention of a "boogey man" isn't sufficient to explain it, especially since not all First Nations saw them this way. And there's no evidence the tribes that did view them as scary made up these tales to scare kids. There may have been reasons to fear them if there was competition over a food source or there'd been some aggressive behavior on their part.

Myths don't leave footprints.

If I really cared what people who don't know me, think about me, I might be upset by being called a cynic or a sceptic....



I don't see any need to slap labels and derogatory terms on anyone.


Oh.. and as for :
And the fact that you don't have a problem with that, tells us a lot about where you are coming from..:)

Okay, you've lost me. Elaborate. And who's this "us' you speak for?

I was interested in their view and wanted to know how members of eastern tribes tend to view this. I had opportunity to bring it up at a campout soon after the Nelson Creek sighting and was interested in the opinions, especially since there were Ojibway from Canada there. One fellow went into some detail about his reasons and no one told me any legends or fanciful stories. I wanted to know the Cherokee name for them if any. I wasn't able to find that out. Of course, I haven't questioned all my Cherokee acquaintances about this. I was just at a powwow and the subject never came up.

So tell me, what assumptions have you made about where I'm coming from?
 
RayG said:
Yup, and coyote also created humans and the Milky Way, and a raven plucked the moon from the sky. That's exactly why I don't accept cave drawings, campfire stories, or totem poles as evidence.

RayG

Nor do I, but I find them interesting. We accept that ravens and coyotes are real animals, but if a tale seems to be about Sasquatch or some other large hairy hominid are we to dismiss it out of hand just because it's about a "wildman"?
 
RayG said:
With regards to rotting trees....

RayG

Great! I heard a similar story (involving a chainsaw) from a Cherokee storyteller. He obeyed his dad after that. I liked his retelling of questions he's been asked, such as, "How long have you been an Indian?"

I believe the diameter was given. It doesn't look decayed, it looks dried as though the tree had been standing dead for a long time. Surface rot would be dark brown or black. Dried wood can be quite hard. (Alder's a hardwood. ;) )One of the posters on the thread suggested rot below soilline; I don't know if this was checked out. Wood tends to rot at soilline because of contact with microrganisms in the soil, but these trees were broken off 12" below soilline and found a distance away. Is it possible they were lifted and then heaved?

I was more interested in the blobquatch and the footprint than the trees, actually. I used the the falling trees as an example of perils that can befall cameras, not as evidence of Sasquatch strength and dislike of cameras, but now I'm intrigued. I'll have to follow that thread.
 
"I wouldn't suspect poor technique from one who has been investigating for thirty years and who helped devise a means to bring one into an area and get some of the best evidence yet. He is extremely intelligent and dedicated and evidently is doing this on his own time and his own dime."

You see, that's just where we differ. Thirty years is a long time to be doing this research, and if he still hasn't come up with more than he apparently has, something is not going well for him. Several obvious choices suggest themselves: incompetence, fraud, the nonexistence of the quarry, or very very bad luck. There is also, of course, the possibility that the quarry is so clever and wary that it has evaded scientific detection for many years, but this would seem to be contradicted by the large quantity of casual and non-scientific sightings, if such sightings are real.

Of course I'm no more qualified to judge than anyone else, but this is an internet forum, not a scientific panel. We're each entitled to our opinion. Yours appears to be that long experience and a reputation for dedication excuse scanty results. Mine is that scanty results trump the reputation and experience.

We see what we want or expect, I guess. That photograph of the fallen tree looks to me, even in the poor compressed version we see here, to be so dead that the bark is falling off, and it is covered with a growth of moss that I would have been surprised to see on any standing tree. It is also pretty well sunk into the ground, more so than I would expect from a freshly fallen tree, especially from a tree that had any kind of top left on it. Judging by that picture alone, I would have said that tree was at least long dead, if not long fallen, and actually to suggest that the choice of that tree for a camera was merely bad judgment is cutting the guy some slack on the basis of his reputation as an honest researcher, because based on that photograph alone I'd have guessed fraud.

Of course you can say that picture is not enough to base a judgment on, which may well be true, but that would be because it's worthless as evidence of anything, pro or con.

I think you can't have it both ways. The longer a researcher goes at it without good results, the more we are reasonably entitled to question either his competence or the exixtence of what he is seeking; the more casual sightings of an unexplained phenomenon, the more damning the lack of hard evidence becomes.

Maybe you should try to convince people that sasquatch has feathers. It took less than a year after a single putative sighting of an ivory billed woodpecker before someone came up with a clear video of the critter.
 
Bigfoot/sasquatch have the same problems that nessie has:

*A minimum number of specimens is needed to obtain a viable population;
*This would require that at least some pretty good evidence would already have been found (dead specimens - natural causes, hunters, roadkills; good quality pictures - many hunters use remote cams, pictures by pro and amateur nature photographers).

Note also that we are not talking about small-sized animals, like rodents or small deers, neither of uncatalogued species that are morphologically similar to known ones.
 
bruto said:
"I wouldn't suspect poor technique from one who has been investigating for thirty years and who helped devise a means to bring one into an area and get some of the best evidence yet. He is extremely intelligent and dedicated and evidently is doing this on his own time and his own dime."

You see, that's just where we differ. Thirty years is a long time to be doing this research, and if he still hasn't come up with more than he apparently has, something is not going well for him. Several obvious choices suggest themselves: incompetence, fraud, the nonexistence of the quarry, or very very bad luck. There is also, of course, the possibility that the quarry is so clever and wary that it has evaded scientific detection for many years, but this would seem to be contradicted by the large quantity of casual and non-scientific sightings, if such sightings are real.

Why don't you check him out before you go jumping to a lot of conclusions? He's not hard to Google.

It's been pretty easy for the quarry to evade scientific detection since not even the National Geographic has seen fit to send an expedition. Dr. Krantz went out with a graduate student and Meldrum may have too, but that's about the extent of the scientific inquiry.

Primatologists at Yerkes pronounced the Patterson Film authentic, but when the Smithsonian backed off, that was the end of that.

Of course I'm no more qualified to judge than anyone else, but this is an internet forum, not a scientific panel. We're each entitled to our opinion. Yours appears to be that long experience and a reputation for dedication excuse scanty results. Mine is that scanty results trump the reputation and experience.

I don't think the results are scanty. There's nothing to excuse.

We see what we want or expect, I guess. That photograph of the fallen tree looks to me, even in the poor compressed version we see here, to be so dead that the bark is falling off, and it is covered with a growth of moss that I would have been surprised to see on any standing tree. It is also pretty well sunk into the ground, more so than I would expect from a freshly fallen tree, especially from a tree that had any kind of top left on it. Judging by that picture alone, I would have said that tree was at least long dead, if not long fallen, and actually to suggest that the choice of that tree for a camera was merely bad judgment is cutting the guy some slack on the basis of his reputation as an honest researcher, because based on that photograph alone I'd have guessed fraud.


NW ground is spongy where it isn't rock. There'd be some detrius under the club moss and leaves. There are few trees in the western slope of the Cascades that do not have moss growing on them. Tree-climbing club moss grows on living trees, or didn't you know that? It appears to me the moss is pointing away from the camera (could be a trick of the pixels), meaning it was reaching up as it does when the tree was standing. If that's the case the tree was very recently down. Storms uproot living trees as well. Would you have said he used poor judgement in attaching a camera to a living tree and it had been a victim of blow-down? Both trees were living. See below.

Your guess of fraud would be absolutely incorrect.

Here's what happened to another camera:

"The camera used had a fixed focus, plastic lens. The resolution just isn't there. The scan was at 200 dpi. Blowing it up any further except by way of the negative would be very suspect. This camera has since been washed away in a winter storm on the river. Another $150 down the rapids."

Another poster examined the trees:

"I closely examined one of the red alders in question not too long after the photos were taken. There was the beginnings of some rot in the heartwood (as would be found in almost all red alder that age), but it wasn't extensive. About 80-90 % of the wood was solid. I also noticed that the tree had some insect damage just under the bark. Both trees were live and flourishing before their fall.

Looking around the base of the tree (before falling) there were no obvious deep depressions such as a person would have made while setting feet and pushing. Then again maybe I wasn't looking far enough from the base? The ground at the site was/ alternately hard and soft with lots of fern rhizomes and underlaying cobbles, sand, and roots covered by dead leaves. A nearby gametrail network is used by ungulates as well as soft-footed mammals.

I still am puzzled why the trees went down. Could have been the wind... could have be something else. An interesting point that is bothersome is that each tree went down in the direction the camera pointed - but they were different directions on each tree.

Not enough info either way to spend any more time thinking about it."

In fact, if you'd read the thread you'd have found this from the investigator:

"No tracks but there is definately a game trail where the trees fell. Maybe the bear did it to both the trees, smelling them from behind?

Big bear! This is one of my answer's to why I carry in the field, not that a 9mm would help too much here."

He's not only not trying to defraud, he's offering bear as an explanation. Do I hear any apologies?

Also from colobus:

I checked one of the trees carefully over for sign. The portions of the tree exposed were free from sign. Just to clarify... this tree was not rotten structurally. The bark damage extended only a ways below the bark (1/4" or so), and I tested the tree with my Ontario knife in many places. It was sound.


Of course you can say that picture is not enough to base a judgment on, which may well be true, but that would be because it's worthless as evidence of anything, pro or con.

Yep, and it wasn't offered as such either. It was an example of difficulties with camera traps.

Another poster offered this:

"We have found that our camtrakkers were ripped of the trees and scattered through out the forest.The straps and locks broken and torn like they were grabbed and torn off the tree's.The strap that we used are the type that you use on cargo to hold down cars .They were two inches wide and nylon.The straps were just torn and not cut with a knife.One piece of the strap was found down the trail and the other part was found on a branch that was about eight feet off the ground.Foot prints all over the trail and all the same size.Our foot prints look more like they had hair on the soles of the feet but no claws.Your foot prints look more human.Ours were wide with an arch and what look like they had alot of patting to them.No clear toe's but a some what clear print that resembled human except very wide and deep."
I think you can't have it both ways. The longer a researcher goes at it without good results, the more we are reasonably entitled to question either his competence or the exixtence of what he is seeking; the more casual sightings of an unexplained phenomenon, the more damning the lack of hard evidence becomes.

Did I say he's been doing field research for over thirty years? He has a full-time career and investigates in his free time. He's done interviews, some with other researchers, and collected articles for years. He was part of the team that brought in the Skookum Cast and had found tracks in the area some time earlier. He was one of three who identified the imprint. He's is an experienced tracker and photographer, and an expert in the use of various casting materials.

He presents what he has and allows others to draw their own conclusions. That's how it's done........or should be.

Maybe you should try to convince people that sasquatch has feathers. It took less than a year after a single putative sighting of an ivory billed woodpecker before someone came up with a clear video of the critter.

There had been reports for many years. Seven people, including an ornithologist, saw it and the video is three seconds long.

There were several witnesses on the Memorial Day incident and the footage is conderably longer.

There are stuffed specimens of Ivory Bills in museums, so no one questions their existance. That's the difference.
 
Correa Neto said:
Bigfoot/sasquatch have the same problems that nessie has:

*A minimum number of specimens is needed to obtain a viable population;
*This would require that at least some pretty good evidence would already have been found (dead specimens - natural causes, hunters, roadkills; good quality pictures - many hunters use remote cams, pictures by pro and amateur nature photographers).

Note also that we are not talking about small-sized animals, like rodents or small deers, neither of uncatalogued species that are morphologically similar to known ones.

Green has five reports of them being killed. Since they tend to inhabit remote areas with few roads and little traffic, roadkill isn't very likely. They tend to be nocturnal and hunters aren't. A poster on another board calculated about one dead one per 720 square miles, based on a population of 4000 in 10% of the U.S.

Based on reports there are 2-6000, more than enough for a viable breeding population.

Morphologically, they seem to be close to Australopithecines, or possibly Gigantopithecus blacki. And us.
 
Ok, I think this is going nowhere, so I think it's time to give it a rest. I hope you're right and I'm wrong. Let's hope there are a whole bunch of sasquatches out there, seemingly willing to reveal themselves to unequipped strangers but too wily to fall into the expertly set traps of experienced researchers. Well, they say a crow can see the glint of a gun barrel at a quarter mile too, so maybe...If there's a sasquatch at all, it must be a pretty clever beast to have held out this long.

One of these days the run of bad luck, bad press and bad trees will end, and one of those obstinate searchers will get the last laugh. I don't think it will be done with a fixed-focus plastic lens strapped to a dead tree, but what do I know? I applaud their tenacity anyway.

Good luck.
 
LAL said:
Green has five reports of them being killed. Since they tend to inhabit remote areas with few roads and little traffic, roadkill isn't very likely. They tend to be nocturnal and hunters aren't.

If so, where are the bodies? Now, I´ve worked all my life in areas that are very isolated (Amazon forest is isolated enough?), and I can tell you that:

(a) Nocturnal animals are more prone to become a roadkill. The lights blinds them, they freeze, not able to judge the speed and bang!

(b) Roads in isolated areas, even with little traffic, have a lot of roadkills. More than in non-isolated areas, since there are more wildlife.

(c) Here in South America there are a lot of people who hunt at night, to catch nocturnal animals. I also happen to know three guys from North America who hunt, and they do hunt at night. It depends on the prey you want to catch. And nowdays, with IR visors...


LAL said:

A poster on another board calculated about one dead one per 720 square miles, based on a population of 4000 in 10% of the U.S.

Based on reports there are 2-6000, more than enough for a viable breeding population.

Morphologically, they seem to be close to Australopithecines, or possibly Gigantopithecus blacki. And us.

So, 6000 specimens. Note that they need to be relatively close to each other, even if they do not live in packs. Individuals should stay in contact with each other in order to breed. So, they can not be spread across 10% of USA and still be a viable population... The animals must live within a smaller, more densely populated area.

Note that even animals that have smaller populations are routinely filmed, tracked, their dead bodies found, etc. Some nice footage must hev been made by now, even if by people who were actually trying to film wolves.
 
Correa Neto said:
If so, where are the bodies? Now, I´ve worked all my life in areas that are very isolated (Amazon forest is isolated enough?), and I can tell you that:

(a) Nocturnal animals are more prone to become a roadkill. The lights blinds them, they freeze, not able to judge the speed and bang!


Well, except that their eyes can be 7' off the ground. Peter Bryne told me about a sighting by two women in a car near Estacada, Oregon, where the animal stopped and turned and seemed to be gesturing to others to stay back. This was backed up by the marks in the middle of the road. They may be aware of the danger, but there are many reports of them crossing roads. Drivers may be more inclined to slow down for an 8' hairy hominid than for a raccoon. I mean, what insurance company would believe it?

I read recently about an Amazon tribe that's been undetected for fifteen years coming into conflict with loggers.

(b) Roads in isolated areas, even with little traffic, have a lot of roadkills. More than in non-isolated areas, since there are more wildlife.

(c) Here in South America there are a lot of people who hunt at night, to catch nocturnal animals. I also happen to know three guys from North America who hunt, and they do hunt at night. It depends on the prey you want to catch. And nowdays, with IR visors...



In the area where I lived in Washington State, the only night hunting I know of was for racoon with dogs. Deer and elk hunters were out during the day and the local people were down at the sheriff's reporting them for trespassing. The kind we had wanted to be near the vehicle in case they actually shot something - they were usually from the city. Who wants to drag a deer twenty miles over rugged terrain where much of the ground cover is Poison Oak? Bear hunters were usually poaching and probably wouldn't have reported shooting a Sasquatch if they could. Skamania County would have happily fined the one I'm thinking of.

"Skamania County Ordinance

Tuesday, April 01, 1969

Ordinance No. 69-01


Be it hereby ordained by the Board of County Commissioners of Skamania County:

Whereas, there is evidence to indicate the possible existence in Skamania County of a nocturnal primate mammal variously described as an ape-like creature or a sub-species of Homo Sapiens; and

Whereas, both legend and purported recent sightings and spoor support this possibility, and

Whereas, this creature is generally and commonly known as a "Sasquatch", "Yeti", "Bigfoot", or "Giant Hairy ape", and has resulted in an influx of scientific investigators as well as casual hunters, many armed with lethal weapons, and

Whereas, the absence of specific laws covering the taking of specimens encourages laxity in the use of firearms and other deadly devices and poses a clear and present threat to the safety and well-being of persons living or traveling within the boundaries of Skamania County as well as to the creatures themselves,

Therefore be it resolved that any premeditated, willful and wanton slaying of such creature shall be deemed a felony punishable by a fine not to exceed Ten Thousand Dollars ($10,000) and/or imprisonment in the county jail for a period not to exceed Five (5) years.

Be it further resolved that the situation existing constitutes an emergency and as such this ordinance is effective immediately.

Board of Commissioners of Skamania County"

http://www.inthegorge.com/bigfoot_ordinance.htm

About the only roads in the mountains were gravel or skid roads, and they were few and far between. It was impossible to get much speed on them. Hwy 14 is along the Columbia and there's a highway to Hemlock, and one to Cougar..............and that's about it.

So, 6000 specimens. Note that they need to be relatively close to each other, even if they do not live in packs. Individuals should stay in contact with each other in order to breed. So, they can not be spread across 10% of USA and still be a viable population... The animals must live within a smaller, more densely populated area.



Bindernagle thinks the sightings are just the tip of the iceberg. Krantz estimated 15,000. There may be a small eastern population (some think the occasional three-toed tracks are a sign of defects due to inbreeding), but in the Pacific Northwest, which extends into Canada, there's plenty of suitable habitat and no lack of sightings. There seems to be a colony on Mt. St. Helens.

They've been observed in small family groups, although they seem to range singly much of the time. The high pitched howls may be an adaptation for communication over long distances. Bryne thought they could cover 25 miles in a night. He said it's like looking for a moving needle in a haystack.


Note that even animals that have smaller populations are routinely filmed, tracked, their dead bodies found, etc. Some nice footage must hev been made by now, even if by people who were actually trying to film wolves.

There've been sightings all over the country, but the area I knew best (Skamania County) has dense forest, acid soils, caves, canyons, hollow logs, is extremely rugged and has a population of about 10,000, mostly along the river. It's 86% National Forest and contains Mt. St. Helens with ample room to spare. Dying animals tend to hole up. The scavenger system is extremely efficient and even bodies of common animals are seldom found.

There is some nice footage, by people who were trying to film one and at least one by people who weren't.
 
bruto said:
I forgot to mention above that if there are sasquatches, I suspect they possess one other quality which sets them apart from their pursuers: a sense of humor.

Chimpanzees seem to have a sense of humor. So does Rick Noll.
Maybe that's something we share in that 98% identical DNA. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom