bruto said:
"I wouldn't suspect poor technique from one who has been investigating for thirty years and who helped devise a means to bring one into an area and get some of the best evidence yet. He is extremely intelligent and dedicated and evidently is doing this on his own time and his own dime."
You see, that's just where we differ. Thirty years is a long time to be doing this research, and if he still hasn't come up with more than he apparently has, something is not going well for him. Several obvious choices suggest themselves: incompetence, fraud, the nonexistence of the quarry, or very very bad luck. There is also, of course, the possibility that the quarry is so clever and wary that it has evaded scientific detection for many years, but this would seem to be contradicted by the large quantity of casual and non-scientific sightings, if such sightings are real.
Why don't you check him out before you go jumping to a lot of conclusions? He's not hard to Google.
It's been pretty easy for the quarry to evade scientific detection since not even the National Geographic has seen fit to send an expedition. Dr. Krantz went out with a graduate student and Meldrum may have too, but that's about the extent of the scientific inquiry.
Primatologists at Yerkes pronounced the Patterson Film authentic, but when the Smithsonian backed off, that was the end of that.
Of course I'm no more qualified to judge than anyone else, but this is an internet forum, not a scientific panel. We're each entitled to our opinion. Yours appears to be that long experience and a reputation for dedication excuse scanty results. Mine is that scanty results trump the reputation and experience.
I don't think the results are scanty. There's nothing to excuse.
We see what we want or expect, I guess. That photograph of the fallen tree looks to me, even in the poor compressed version we see here, to be so dead that the bark is falling off, and it is covered with a growth of moss that I would have been surprised to see on any standing tree. It is also pretty well sunk into the ground, more so than I would expect from a freshly fallen tree, especially from a tree that had any kind of top left on it. Judging by that picture alone, I would have said that tree was at least long dead, if not long fallen, and actually to suggest that the choice of that tree for a camera was merely bad judgment is cutting the guy some slack on the basis of his reputation as an honest researcher, because based on that photograph alone I'd have guessed fraud.
NW ground is spongy where it isn't rock. There'd be some detrius under the club moss and leaves. There are few trees in the western slope of the Cascades that do
not have moss growing on them. Tree-climbing club moss grows on living trees, or didn't you know that? It appears to me the moss is pointing away from the camera (could be a trick of the pixels), meaning it was reaching up as it does when the tree was standing. If that's the case the tree was very recently down. Storms uproot living trees as well. Would you have said he used poor judgement in attaching a camera to a living tree and it had been a victim of blow-down? Both trees were living. See below.
Your guess of fraud would be absolutely incorrect.
Here's what happened to another camera:
"The camera used had a fixed focus, plastic lens. The resolution just isn't there. The scan was at 200 dpi. Blowing it up any further except by way of the negative would be very suspect. This camera has since been washed away in a winter storm on the river. Another $150 down the rapids."
Another poster examined the trees:
"I closely examined one of the red alders in question not too long after the photos were taken. There was the beginnings of some rot in the heartwood (as would be found in almost all red alder that age), but it wasn't extensive. About 80-90 % of the wood was solid. I also noticed that the tree had some insect damage just under the bark. Both trees were live and flourishing before their fall.
Looking around the base of the tree (before falling) there were no obvious deep depressions such as a person would have made while setting feet and pushing. Then again maybe I wasn't looking far enough from the base? The ground at the site was/ alternately hard and soft with lots of fern rhizomes and underlaying cobbles, sand, and roots covered by dead leaves. A nearby gametrail network is used by ungulates as well as soft-footed mammals.
I still am puzzled why the trees went down. Could have been the wind... could have be something else. An interesting point that is bothersome is that each tree went down in the direction the camera pointed - but they were different directions on each tree.
Not enough info either way to spend any more time thinking about it."
In fact, if you'd read the thread you'd have found this from the investigator:
"No tracks but there is definately a game trail where the trees fell. Maybe the bear did it to both the trees, smelling them from behind?
Big bear! This is one of my answer's to why I carry in the field, not that a 9mm would help too much here."
He's not only not trying to defraud, he's offering bear as an explanation. Do I hear any apologies?
Also from colobus:
I checked one of the trees carefully over for sign. The portions of the tree exposed were free from sign. Just to clarify... this tree was not rotten structurally. The bark damage extended only a ways below the bark (1/4" or so), and I tested the tree with my Ontario knife in many places. It was sound.
Of course you can say that picture is not enough to base a judgment on, which may well be true, but that would be because it's worthless as evidence of anything, pro or con.
Yep, and it wasn't offered as such either. It was an example of difficulties with camera traps.
Another poster offered this:
"We have found that our camtrakkers were ripped of the trees and scattered through out the forest.The straps and locks broken and torn like they were grabbed and torn off the tree's.The strap that we used are the type that you use on cargo to hold down cars .They were two inches wide and nylon.The straps were just torn and not cut with a knife.One piece of the strap was found down the trail and the other part was found on a branch that was about eight feet off the ground.Foot prints all over the trail and all the same size.Our foot prints look more like they had hair on the soles of the feet but no claws.Your foot prints look more human.Ours were wide with an arch and what look like they had alot of patting to them.No clear toe's but a some what clear print that resembled human except very wide and deep."
I think you can't have it both ways. The longer a researcher goes at it without good results, the more we are reasonably entitled to question either his competence or the exixtence of what he is seeking; the more casual sightings of an unexplained phenomenon, the more damning the lack of hard evidence becomes.
Did I say he's been doing field research for over thirty years? He has a full-time career and investigates in his free time. He's done interviews, some with other researchers, and collected articles for years. He was part of the team that brought in the Skookum Cast and had found tracks in the area some time earlier. He was one of three who identified the imprint. He's is an experienced tracker and photographer, and an expert in the use of various casting materials.
He presents what he has and allows others to draw their own conclusions. That's how it's done........or should be.
Maybe you should try to convince people that sasquatch has feathers. It took less than a year after a single putative sighting of an ivory billed woodpecker before someone came up with a clear video of the critter.
There had been reports for many years. Seven people, including an ornithologist, saw it and the video is three seconds long.
There were several witnesses on the Memorial Day incident and the footage is conderably longer.
There are stuffed specimens of Ivory Bills in museums, so no one questions their existance. That's the difference.