Bentham Editor In Chief Quits after Jones article

No she isn't.

Yes, she is. She is a former employee who wrote a irrelevant rant. She is very disgruntled.

That makes her a disgruntled former employee.

The Bentham Journal has higher standards.

Maybe she can get hired by NIST for their next project on UFOs?
 
She is a disgruntled former employee, with sour grapes added.

Cripes, you know the guy is trolling.

She wasn't an employee.

Bentham Open Publishing has one guy on the payroll. His job is to cash Jones' freaking checks.
 
I've moved a great big chunk of this thread to AAH because of bickering and off-topic posts (especially about thermite). Please stick to the subject and eschew personal attacks. This applies even if you are responding to what you consider to be a personal attack.

I'm not handing out infractions at this time, but consider this a stern warning.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
Just so I'm sure I got my facts straight.

This thread is about an "article" that was published in a "pay to publish" journal that came out last year that has had no impact in the scientific world. Now the editor and Chief has resigned, more or less confirming what has been said about this article (and the journal) all along (By us, the only people that paid attention).

Now my only question is, Why should we care?
 
One of our commenters has provided a more easily digested translation of the article:

It created a great attention, surprise and suspicion when the Open Chemical Physics Journal in April published a scientific article on remains of nanothermite which were found in great amounts in the dust from the WTC.

One those most surprised is apparently the editor in chief of the journal. Professor Marie-Paule Pileni first heard about he article when videnskab.dk wrote to her to ask for her professional assessment of the article’s content. The e-mail got her to immediately close the door to the journal.

“I resign as the editor in chief”, was the abrupt answer in an email to videnskab.dk
 
So, can anyone summarize exactly what happened here? Apparently this editor quit because she found out that some crappy chemistry paper was published in the journal she's in charge of without her knowledege or consent? Do I have that right? If thats the case, that's one well oiled machine of a journal they've got there at Benthem!
 

No wonder she resigned, the guy is an idiot in that video! He can't say if it was 10 tons or 100 tons of thermite. How pathetic; just an insane person ranting about thermite. He and 8 other failed researchers had to pay to publish poppycock.

The experts of the paper have different ways it was applied! Ceiling tiles, paint, and pallets trucked in secretly past WTC security and all the independent security of the tenants at the WTC. The paper is easily seen as a fraud to rational people.
 
Last edited:
can you site a real scientific source for this claim, or did you just make it up as usual?

:id:

Galileo, speaking as someone who's dealt with the peer-review process from both sides, your description of it doesn't seem based in reality. Every time I've been asked to review a paper, it's been by an editor of the magazine, and I've never dealt directly with an author. And the peer reviewer never needs to forward the paper to the editors, because the editors have already got it.

Dave
 
Last edited:
Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for topic (thread moderated)


Back to the topic, I find parts of the translation linked by Brainster quite interesting.

It is Niels Harrit’s coauthor Steven Jones who was in charge of contact to Bentham, and therefore the Danish researcher is presently not aware which responsible assistant editor the group has been communicating with.
[Niels Harrit:] "It surprises me, of course, and it is regrettable, if it discredits our work. But her departure doesn’t change our conclusions, for it is a purely personnel related thing she his angry about. [...]"
Purely personal? Let's see:

[Marie-Paule Pileni:] "I cannot accept that this topic is published in my journal. The article has nothing to do with physical chemistry or chemical physics, and I could well believe that there is a political viewpoint behind its publication. If anyone had asked me, I would say that the article should never have been published in this journal. Period."
That does not look as a "purely personal" point of view. To me it reflects one of the earlier criticisms to the paper that I read: that the conclusions are hushed in one single direction, not justified by the findings.

Now that there's a more accurate translation I have to insist in this part:

Niels Harrit’s superior at the University of Copenhagen, Nils O. Andersen has himself participated in the pool of researchers who could be selected as editor, on an article which should be published in The Open Chemical Physics Journal. He has recently chosen to resign from the journals Editorial Advisory Board.
It'd be interesting to find out when Nils (Niels?) O. Andersen joined the editorial board. To me his presence looks like a suspicious intervention in the process. The fact that it might result suspicious was admitted by the paper's authors as I already quoted.

May Andersen be one of the 'in principle anonymous' referees? Did Jones know him? Did Jones know about his presence in the journal?

Too many unanswered questions.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So, can anyone summarize exactly what happened here? Apparently this editor quit because she found out that some crappy chemistry paper was published in the journal she's in charge of without her knowledege or consent? Do I have that right? If thats the case, that's one well oiled machine of a journal they've got there at Benthem!

In any normal journal, the buck is supposed to stop at the editor for the scientific content of a paper, but Benthem Open seem to operate a curious policy of putting the publication team (whoever they are) in charge and simply using the position of editor as a figurehead. Given that it tarnishes your reputation if a bad paper goes out goes out on your watch as an editor, I'm not surprised she wanted out. I'm also not surprised she didn't comment on the quality of the paper; that would have made her a target for the WAC-jobs, if she isn't already.

This should serve as a warning to scientists everywhere: Under no circumstances have anything to do with Benthem Open. Open access may be the way of the future, but it'll be a non-starter if you don't have scientific quality and integrity.
 
Last edited:
I'm puzzled by Niels O. Andersen's role.



Now he announces he's quitting. Strange.

His explanation were:

Men fagligt lå tidsskriftets i kanten af min ekspertise, og da jeg havde takket nej til at være editor på to artikler, besluttede jeg mig for, at jeg hellere ville bruge min tid på noget andet,« fortæller fysiker Nils O. Andersen, dekan på Det Naturvidenskabelige Fakultet og editor på The European Physical Journal D.

My amateuristic translation:

"The paper was at the fringe of the area of my expertise, and since I've declined editing two articles, I decided that I'd rather spend my time doing other things, says Nils O Andersen (...)

The paragraf just prior to that one also have him saying that he likes the idea of Open Access, since he dislikes that commercial companies makes money of the work of scientists:

Open access er en spændende udvikling, og som princip skal man prøve ideen af, for der er ingen grund til, at de kommercielle forlag tjener penge på vores arbejde.

Translation:

Open access is an exciting development and as a princip you should test the idea that commercial publishers make money on our work. Because there is no reason they should.
 
Thread has been placed on moderated status. I may be moving out some posts, and issuing infractions. Please review Tricky's mod box above, and stop ignoring it.

Post on topic to this thread - that means the situation with Bentham and the Editor in Chief as regards this paper. It does not mean thermite theories, and it does not mean you can bicker.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
Yes, I looked her up - ://xxxxxxxxxxxPileni You would expect someone in that position to be able to see what an absolute crock of crap the paper is.


That's interesting, none of her recent published journal articles are in Bentham's Open Journals.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom