Bentham Editor In Chief Quits after Jones article

That's interesting, none of her recent published journal articles are in Bentham's Open Journals.

Interesting? Why? What is your line of thought on this?

My thoughts are that she is a serious, well respected researcher, and that she became editor in chief for the publication (A) before she knew anything about it, and (B) because she believes in the Open Access concept as a means to allow publishing of papers that might have merit, but might not get into more established journals.

I do not think she would want to have her own work published in a journal she is editor and chief of...conflict of interest.

TAM:)
 
Only at Bentham. It is my understanding editors normally read papers before submiting them to the reviewers, reviewers they, not the commercial publisher have chosen



That's part of the problem:

"I can not accept that the issue is put in my journal. The article is not about physical chemistry or chemical physics, and I could well believe that there is a political point of view behind the publication. If anyone had asked me, I would say that the article should never have been published in this journal. "

She is however a leading expert in nanometerials. Saying she isn't qualified may be a polite way of avoiding saying it's crap.



Truthers talent for unintentional irony nver ceases to amaze me.

But doesn't the article suggest that her decision was based on her lack of qualifications? Clearly, she is qualified, so I'm curious why the article suggests otherwise.

"Marie-Paule Pileni points out that because the topic lies outside her field of expertise, she cannot judge whether the article in itself is good or bad."
 
Interesting? Why? What is your line of thought on this?

My thoughts are that she is a serious, well respected researcher, and that she became editor in chief for the publication (A) before she knew anything about it, and (B) because she believes in the Open Access concept as a means to allow publishing of papers that might have merit, but might not get into more established journals.

I do not think she would want to have her own work published in a journal she is editor and chief of...conflict of interest.

TAM:)

I'd just like to add here that I'm corresponding with another of the listed scientists on the Editorial Advisory Board of The Open Chemical Physics Journal. He too is a serious researcher and apparently it was the idea of Open Publishing that drew him there - something that seems to be common among those who signed up. He too has his doubts. I'm going to send him links to texts about the recent development.
 
Last edited:
That so-called paper has already been debunked. No legitimate scientific journal will print it.

Galileo, could you explain your words, please?
Thanks.


I wrote a little update in my article:

"According to Danish science news site Videnskab.dk, a controversial article claiming that World Trade Center dust samples contained "active thermitic material" was published in the "Open Chemical Physics Journal" without the knowledge or approval of the editor in chief, Marie-Paule Pileni.
The editor in chief has resigned over the incident.
Says Pileni:
“I cannot accept that this topic is published in my journal. The article has nothing to do with physical chemistry or chemical physics, and I could well believe that there is a political viewpoint behind its publication. If anyone had asked me, I would say that the article should never have been published in this journal. Period.”


http://11-settembre.blogspot.com/2009/04/active-thermitic-material-claimed-in.html


Best wishes,
Henry :)
 
The editor in chief in question, is an expert in "nanocrystals", so she is obviously qualified, over all, in the area of Physical Chemistry dealing with small things, but specialists/experts at this level can be very specific in terms of what they consider to be their "area of expertise", so perhaps the chemical compound/reaction "thermite" was what she was referring to as being out of her area of expertise...

Just a thought.

TAM:)
 
But doesn't the article suggest that her decision was based on her lack of qualifications? Clearly, she is qualified, so I'm curious why the article suggests otherwise.

"Marie-Paule Pileni points out that because the topic lies outside her field of expertise, she cannot judge whether the article in itself is good or bad."

No, to me it suggests that the paper was:

A) Published without the knowledge of the editor
B) Outside the scope of the journal it was published in
 
911 Blogger spins the news

Here's the spin on the resignation from a 911 Blogger contributor

http://www.911blogger.com/node/19963

One legitimate point is made her claim that the paper was outside her area of expertise seems disingenuous:

One particularly notable comment attributed to Ms. Pileni is this one: "Marie-Paule Pileni points out that because the topic lies outside her field of expertise, she cannot judge whether the article in itself is good or bad.".

Strangely, her areas of research seem to contradict that. I'll quote you an excerpt of her resume:

OTHER ACTIVITIES
1990-1992: Chairperson on workshops related to the French Defense research.
1989-1992: Consultant at the Minister of Recherche concerning the National Defense 1989: Member of the “Institut des Hautes Etudes de Défense Européenne”.
1987-1988: Member of the ’“Institut des Hautes Etudes de Défense Nationale” (IHEDN)1984-1986: Member of National exam in Chemistry

EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERSHIP
2006: Accounts of Chemical Research, American Chemical Society.
Journal of experimental nanosciences, Publisher Taylor&Francis.
2002: Journal of Physical Chemistry, Board member, American Chemical Society.

CONSULTING EXPERIENCE
1990-1994: Société Nationale des Poudres et Explosifs, SNPE, France (Literally translated: National Society of Powders and Explosives)

LABORATORY MANAGEMENT
2001: Laboratoire des matériaux mésoscopiques et nanomètriques, LM2N.
1992-2000: Structure et réactivité des systèmes interfaciaux, SRI. (Literally translated: Structure and reactivity of interfacial systems)

Then again presumably she meant dust analysis and analytic chemistry is "outside her field of expertise". But her complaint the paper was published without her approval also was a bit disingenuous.
 
"I was really unsure about them in advance because I had repeatedly asked for information about the magazine without hearing from them. It does not appear in the list of international journals and is a bad sign. Now I see that it is because it is a bad magazine, "says Marie-Paule Pileni and continues:

That is ridiculous. These things have not stopped her, to become editior in chief at Bentham. :confused:
 
Originally Posted by Fjolle
"I was really unsure about them in advance because I had repeatedly asked for information about the magazine without hearing from them. It does not appear in the list of international journals and is a bad sign. Now I see that it is because it is a bad magazine, "says Marie-Paule Pileni and continues:
That is ridiculous. These things have not stopped her, to become editior in chief at Bentham. :confused:

The more accurate translation is "“I was in fact in doubt about them before" I.E. Before this incident not before it existed obviously it wouldn't "appear on the list of international journals" before it went to business.

She also said “There are no references to the Open Chemical Physics Journal in other articles. I have two colleagues who contributed to publishing an article which was not cited anyplace either. If no one reads it, it is a bad journal, and there is not use for it” so her doubts came after she joined the journal.
 
Here's the spin on the resignation from a 911 Blogger contributor

http://www.911blogger.com/node/19963

One legitimate point is made her claim that the paper was outside her area of expertise seems disingenuous:



Then again presumably she meant dust analysis and analytic chemistry is "outside her field of expertise". But her complaint the paper was published without her approval also was a bit disingenuous.

She meant the paper was biased political claptrap; outside her expertise. She was slamming the paper! A polite slam. It is an intellectual slam for an anti-intellectual paper.

I bet they had the paper rejected until the bulk of veil political crap was removed and the publisher wanted the money.
 
Galileo, could you explain your words, please?
Thanks.


I wrote a little update in my article:

"According to Danish science news site Videnskab.dk, a controversial article claiming that World Trade Center dust samples contained "active thermitic material" was published in the "Open Chemical Physics Journal" without the knowledge or approval of the editor in chief, Marie-Paule Pileni.
The editor in chief has resigned over the incident.
Says Pileni:
“I cannot accept that this topic is published in my journal. The article has nothing to do with physical chemistry or chemical physics, and I could well believe that there is a political viewpoint behind its publication. If anyone had asked me, I would say that the article should never have been published in this journal. Period.”


http://11-settembre.blogspot.com/2009/04/active-thermitic-material-claimed-in.html


Best wishes,
Henry :)

Pileni is a disgruntled former employee. Her statements have nothing to do with the science of the thermite paper.

She should have spoke up lat year.
 
Pileni is a disgruntled former employee. Her statements have nothing to do with the science of the thermite paper.

She should have spoke up lat year.

You have made a direct accusation here (that Pileni is a disgruntled employee). If this is your theory with regard to her resignation, please provide proof of (A) her status as an EMPLOYEE of Bentham, and (B) that she was "disgruntled".

Thank you.

TAM:)
 
Pileni is a disgruntled former employee. Her statements have nothing to do with the science of the thermite paper.

She should have spoke up lat year.

We have already pointed out two things:

1. she was not an employee.

2. how could she have spoken up last year when she said she did not even know of the paper until last week??
 
Pileni is a disgruntled former employee. Her statements have nothing to do with the science of the thermite paper.

She should have spoke up lat year.

Ermm... How could she if she only just became aware of it?
 
But doesn't the article suggest that her decision was based on her lack of qualifications? Clearly, she is qualified, so I'm curious why the article suggests otherwise.

"Marie-Paule Pileni points out that because the topic lies outside her field of expertise, she cannot judge whether the article in itself is good or bad."

A more likely interpretation: In academic circles it's generally considered ... let's go with the word "impolite" ... to refer to another scientist's paper in print using the F-word(*), so Pileni is leaving the authors an out even as the resignation sends a pretty clear message as to her professional opinion of both the paper and the journal.





(*) Fraud - what did you think I meant?
 
A more likely interpretation: In academic circles it's generally considered ... let's go with the word "impolite" ... to refer to another scientist's paper in print using the F-word(*), so Pileni is leaving the authors an out even as the resignation sends a pretty clear message as to her professional opinion of both the paper and the journal.





(*) Fraud - what did you think I meant?

I think there could be other reasons. Quite clearly the paper is driven by agenda, not science, which should be left out of any scientific journal, so that on its own is a good reason to walk out in disgust. But more than that, she is probably trying to avoid getting dragged into any kind of scientific debate about the content. Besides the fact that I imagine she had much better things to do anyway, she would in all probability become a target for the kook armchair science brigade. Because they are much more adept at character assassination than scientific debate, they would quickly adopt her as the new figurehead of the heretical voices opposing their creed, much in the same way as happened to the Popular Mechanics folks. Maybe some of them have already, I don't know...
 
The debate over whether or not Bentham and Steven Jones' "peer-review" are credible is a pointless one.

It doesn't matter one bit whether truthers like Swing or Galileo think Bentham is legit, because NO ONE ELSE DOES! In the scientific/academic community, Bentham is irrelevant.

Jones' latest attempt to by-pass the peer-review process has failed miserably - just as it did when he was passing off his own journal as being a peer-review publication.

So the question now becomes: what are Jones and his followers gonna do about it? I would suggest submitting their work to a journal that isn't a complete joke, but we all know what the result of that would be, don't we? (hint: it involves a lot of red ink).

Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for topic
 
Last edited:
So the question now becomes: what are Jones and his followers gonna do about it? I would suggest submitting their work to a journal that isn't a complete joke, but we all know what the result of that would be, don't we? (hint: it involves a lot of red ink).

Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for topic

as demonstrated on Coast to Coast last night, they are doing nothing and are still using the publication in that fraud of a journal as means to say "hey we got published!" ... and of course the coast to coast crowd wont go as far as checking the credibility of said journal.
 
I'd just like to add here that I'm corresponding with another of the listed scientists on the Editorial Advisory Board of The Open Chemical Physics Journal. He too is a serious researcher and apparently it was the idea of Open Publishing that drew him there - something that seems to be common among those who signed up. He too has his doubts. I'm going to send him links to texts about the recent development.

Sorry, make that ex member. He also resigned when he read the article and the background on how it came to be published.
 
Sorry, make that ex member. He also resigned when he read the article and the background on how it came to be published.

I think this is a trend you will see. We often hear from the truth movement that most scientists say nothing, not because they disagree, but because they are in the dark about "the truth". These two recent resignations, however, prove that this is not the case, and that most legitimate scientists will quickly distance themselves from any connection to biased, poorly produced pseudoscience such as the Jones' paper.

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom